Taishi
Oka
a,
Takeshi
Maeda
*a,
Daisuke
Sakamaki
b,
Hideki
Fujiwara
*b,
Naoya
Suzuki
a,
Shintaro
Kodama
a,
Shigeyuki
Yagi
a,
Luca
Mauri
cd and
Kenji
Kamada
*c
aDepartment of Applied Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka Metropolitan University, Naka-ku, Sakai, Osaka 599-8531, Japan. E-mail: tmaeda@omu.ac.jp
bDepartment of Chemistry, Graduate School of Science, Osaka Metropolitan University, Sumiyoshi-ku, Osaka 558-8585, Japan. E-mail: hfuji@omu.ac.jp
cNanomaterials Research Institute (NMRI), National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST) Ikeda, Osaka 563-8577, Japan. E-mail: k.kamada@aist.go.jp
dChemistry Department, Università degli Studi di Milano, UdR dell’INSTM, Via Golgi 19, Milano 20133, Italy
First published on 7th May 2025
Chalcogenopyrylium-based croconaine dyes with intermediate diradical character exhibit intense one-photon absorption (OPA) and two-photon absorption (TPA) in the short-wavelength infrared (SWIR) region. These properties arise from the synergistic effects of enhanced diradical character via substitution with heavier chalcogen atoms (O, S, Se) and π-conjugation extension through sphenyl group incorporation. Chalcogenopyrylium-based croconaine dyes with intermediate diradical character exhibit intense one-photon absorption (OPA) and two-photon absorption (TPA) in the short-wavelength infrared (SWIR) region. These properties arise from the synergistic effects of enhanced diradical character through substitution with heavier chalcogen atoms (O, S, Se) and π-conjugation extension via phenyl substitution. X-Ray crystal structure analysis, temperature-dependent 1H-NMR, and ESR spectra revealed the intermediate diradical character of the croconaine dyes, with the contribution of the diradical form increasing in the order O < S < Se as the atomic number of the chalcogen element increases. Correspondingly, the OPA band shifts to lower energy regions. Notably, dyes incorporating sulfur and selenium exhibit strong OPA in the SWIR region, with absorption maxima at 1046 nm and 1096 nm, respectively. Furthermore, TPA spectra measured using the Z-scan technique reveal that dyes containing O, S, and Se exhibit large TPA cross sections of 1008 GM at 1255 nm, 1011 GM at 1395 nm, and 1177 GM at 1445 nm, respectively. The absorption bands shift to lower energy regions, similar to the OPA bands, with the cross section increasing with the atomic number of the chalcogen element. These findings demonstrate that chalcogen atoms not only play a crucial role in modulating the intermediate diradical character of croconaine dyes but also significantly influence their OPA and TPA properties.
Organic materials offer a promising alternative for SWIR absorption, as their structural diversity enables precise tuning of the orbital energy levels involved in electronic transitions.9–11 SWIR-absorbing organic molecules typically feature an extended π-electron system that links strong electron donors and acceptors.12–14 This arrangement promotes resonance, where electron push–pull effects between donors and acceptors reduce bond alternation and suppress Peierls distortion, also known as the pseudo Jahn–Teller effect.15,16 Molecules with intermediate diradical character, referred to as diradicaloids, serve as effective SWIR absorbers, with closed-shell and open-shell resonance structures that reflect their degree of open-shell character (Fig. 1A).17–20 This property is quantified by the diradical character (y0), where a value of 1 indicates a fully open-shell state, and 0 indicates a fully closed-shell state and 1–y0 means its bond order.21 Following the pioneering work of Chichibabin22 and Müller,23 researchers have developed a diverse range of diradicaloids with both Kekulé and non-Kekulé structures.24–29 Recently, compounds such as diketopyrrolopyrroles30,31 and certain polymers32,33—previously considered closed-shell—have exhibited intermediate diradical character, broadening the potential of organic materials for SWIR absorption.
In diradicaloids, the π bonds can be considered partially dissociated due to the contribution of the diradical forms, making the electron density along the π-conjugated system more susceptible to distortion under electromagnetic fields induced by high-intensity laser irradiation. As a result, they exhibit intense two-photon absorption (TPA), which is a third-order nonlinear optical (NLO) process involving the simultaneous absorption of two photons through a virtual state in response to laser irradiation (Fig. 1B).34–36 As an illustration of the substantial influence of intermediate diradical character on TPA properties, Kamada et al. demonstrated that the TPA cross-section of a bis(acridine) dimer, which exhibits intermediate diradical character in its oxidized state, is over two orders of magnitude higher than that of the corresponding dimer in its lower oxidation state, which possesses a closed-shell electronic configuration (Fig. 1C).37 Similarly, bisphenalenyl and benzo-thia-fused [n]thienoacenequinodimethane derivatives, which also exhibit intermediate diradical character, show large TPA cross-sections (Fig. 1D).38,39
For closed-shell molecules, it is well-established both extending π-conjugated systems and incorporating donor–acceptor structures can enhance the TPA cross section.36,40 In addition to these two axes of molecular design, which form a 2D-plane containing closed-shell molecules, the diradical character can be the third axis of the degrees of freedom, which expanded the dimensionality of the molecular design (Fig. 2A). With this third axis, further enhancement of TPA can be expected. This strategy is expected to promote the development of TPA materials for applications such as three-dimensional laser microfabrication,41–44 3D fluorescent imaging,44,45 and photodynamic therapy.45–49
We previously demonstrated that croconaine dyes, featuring a five-membered oxocarbon ring and a (thio)pyrylium skeleton (CR1a and CR1b) exhibited intermediate diradical character (y0 = 0.63, 0.70 respectively) and showed strong TPA in the SWIR region (σ(2) = 750 GM at 1290 nm as the maximum of CR1b) (Fig. 2B).50 This is the first report on the intermediate diradical character and TPA properties of croconaine dyes to our best knowledge. This report suggests that croconaine dyes have potential as excellent TPA materials, similar to polymethine dyes such as cyanine dyes, which exhibit relatively intense TPA.51–53 In contrast to polymethine dyes, croconaine dyes exhibit an additional axis of diradical character, in addition to the extension of the π-conjugated system and the modulation of the donor and acceptor strengths in the chromophore. These properties can be fine-tuned by replacing the oxygen atom in the pyrylium skeleton with a heavier heteroatom, such as sulfur in a thiopyrylium skeleton.50,54–56 As illustrated in Fig. 2A with blue/red arrows, tuning of the degree of intermediate diradical character by replacing heavy atom and expansion of the π-conjugation have possibility of further enhancement of the TPA properties. These factors also enable the fine-tuning of the transition energy associated with TPA.
In this study, we synthesized croconaine dyes by replacing chalcogen atom in the chalcogenopyrylium ring from O to S, to Se for wider tuning diradical charter, enhancing both one-photon absorption (OPA) and TPA in the SWIR region (Fig. 2C). Additionally, we functionalized the chalcogenopyrylium core by introducing phenyl groups at the 2,5-positions to extend the π-conjugation, aiming to achieve a further red shift in both OPA and TPA. We investigated the effects of both the substitutions of chalcogen elements and phenyl groups on the intermediate diradical character, as well as the combined impact of the intermediate diradical character and the extended π-conjugated system on the OPA and TPA behaviors.
As mentioned earlier, molecules with intermediate diradical character exhibit both closed-shell and open-shell contributions, and the relative contribution of each resonance structure, with its distinct electron configuration, influences the bond lengths.37CR2c is expected to have multiple resonance structures due to its extended π-electron system (Fig. S4, ESI†). These structures can be classified into two zwitterionic forms, α and β, in closed-shell configurations, and two diradical forms, where unpaired electrons are delocalized over the central five-membered ring (γ) or the selenopyrylium ring (δ, Fig. 3C). Now, we focus on the outer bonds (a, d) and the inner bonds (b, c) connecting the central five-membered ring and the selenopyrylium ring, and quantify the bond length difference, ΔD = ave. (a, d) − ave. (b, c) (Fig. 3A and Table 1).
Closed-shell singletb/Å | X-ray | Open-shell singletc/Å | Open-shell tripletc/Å | |
---|---|---|---|---|
a ave. (a, b) represents the average bond length of bonds a and b. b Calculated at CAM-RB3LYP/6-31G(d,p) levels. c Calculated at CAM-UB3LYP/6-31G(d,p) levels. | ||||
ave. (a, d) | 1.403 | 1.412 | 1.415 | 1.421 |
ave. (b, c) | 1.390 | 1.396 | 1.380 | 1.374 |
ΔD | +0.013 | +0.016 | +0.035 | +0.047 |
In the two closed-shell zwitterionic forms (α, β), bonds a and d (or b and c) are assigned as a pair of a double bond and a single bond, resulting in ΔD being zero. The diradical form γ, however, exhibits a negative ΔD value, as the inner bonds (b, c) are single bond and the outer bonds (a, d) are double bond. In the δ form, a positive ΔD value is observed in this bond length analysis. Actually, the X-ray structure of CR2c confirms a positive ΔD value, suggesting that the δ form, where the unpaired electron is delocalized on the selenopyrylium ring, has a greater contribution among the four resonance forms. Additionally, we compared the ΔD values of the DFT-optimized structures of the closed-shell singlet and open-shell triplet states with those obtained from the X-ray data. The value from the X-ray structure (+0.016) was found to lie between those of the closed-shell singlet (+0.013) and open-shell triplet states (+0.047), further supporting the intermediate diradical character of CR2c.
The spin density distributions of the croconaine dyes were calculated at the unrestricted CAM-B3LYP/6-31G level to investigate their spin delocalization (Fig. 4). The calculations revealed that spins are delocalized over the entire molecule, including the phenyl groups attached to the pyrylium moieties. Moreover, NICS(1)zz values were calculated to evaluate the aromaticity of each ring.58 The peripheral phenyl rings showed NICS(1)zz values below −10, confirming that they are aromatic, while the central cyclopentenetrione and chalcogenopyrylium rings exhibited values between −1.9 and −1.6, indicating reduced aromaticity (as shown in Fig. 4C).
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Variable temperature 1H-NMR spectra (CDCl3, 213–313 K) of CR2c along with a diagram illustrating thermal excitation from singlet to triplet states. |
Furthermore, the electron spin resonance (ESR) spectra of each dye were recorded to confirm the presence of unpaired electrons arising from thermally populated triplet states (Fig. 6A). In 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane at 303 K, CR2c displayed a broad ESR signal at g = 2.003. Unlike the behavior observed in the 1H NMR spectra, the ESR signal intensified with increasing temperature, indicating the presence of unpaired electrons from a thermally populated triplet state. In the solid state, CR2c exhibited a more complex ESR signal than in solution (Fig. 6B). X-Ray crystal structure analysis revealed intermolecular interactions in the crystalline state for CR2c. These interactions are thought to influence electron spin coupling in the solid state, leading to the observed changes in the ESR signal.
A similar trend was observed for the solutions of CR2a and CR2b, which also exhibited the increase in the ESR intensities upon heating (Fig. S8, ESI†). The plots of ESR signal intensity (IESR) multiplied by temperature (T) as a function of temperature are shown in Fig. 6C. For all three dyes, IESRT increased with an increase in temperature. To estimate the energy difference between the singlet and thermally accessible triplet states (ΔES–T), the data were fitted to the Bleaney–Bowers equation (see ESI†).59 The curve-fitting analysis yielded ΔES–T values of 0.169, 0.164, and 0.148 eV for CR2a, CR2b, and CR2c, respectively. These results show a trend where the ΔES–T decreases as the atomic number of the chalcogens increases. The relatively small ΔES–T values suggest weak electron–electron interactions within the molecule, accompanied by a substantial contribution from the diradical form. Thus, the contribution of diradical forms increases in the order of CR2a, CR2b, and CR2c, which is consistent with the trend observed in the diradical character y0 obtained from quantum chemical calculations.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Normalized electronic absorption spectra (solid line) and emission spectra (dot line) (CHCl3, r.t., conc. 5 × 10−6 M) of CR2a (red), CR2b (green), and CR2c (blue). |
Dye | λ OPA /nm | ε /105 M−1 cm−1 | λ PL /nm | Stokes shift/cm−1 | λ TPA /nm | σ (2) /GM |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a OPA maxima in CHCl3 (conc. 5 × 10−6 M). b Molar absorption coefficient. c Emission maxima in CHCl3 (conc. 5 × 10−6 M, excitation at 430 nm). d TPA maxima in CHCl3 (conc. 0.44 mM for CR2a, 0.49 mM for CR2b, and 0.47 mM for CR2c) obtained by Z-scan technique. e TPA cross section (σ(2)) was expressed in the Göppert-Mayer (GM) unit defined as 1 GM = 10−50 cm4 s molecule−1 photon−1. | ||||||
CR2a | 955 | 3.30 | 989 | 360 | 1255 | 1008 ± 136 |
CR2b | 1047 | 1.83 | 1102 | 477 | 1395 | 1011 ± 202 |
CR2c | 1096 | 1.64 | N.D. | N.D. | 1445 | 1177 ± 193 |
These results demonstrate that the extension of π-conjugation through the phenyl substitution, coupled with the orbital expansion by the heavy chalcogen elements, contributes to the observed red-shift and enables SWIR absorption in these dyes. Fabian et al. predicted a correlation between diradical character and transition energy, describing that an increase in diradical contribution leads to a decrease in transition energy. Consistent with this prediction, the diradical character increases in the order CR2a < CR2b < CR2c, while their transition energies decrease in the reverse order CR2a > CR2b > CR2c. According to the energy band gap law, organic compounds with transition energies in the SWIR region are expected to show weak fluorescence.60 As anticipated, CR2c, which has the lowest transition energy, exhibited negligible fluorescence at r.t.
In contrast, CR2a and CR2b exhibited fluorescence in the SWIR region with maxima (λem) at 989 nm and 1102 nm, respectively, although their quantum yields were too low to evaluate. Thus, it remains difficult to achieve substantial SWIR emission in this class of dyes.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Open-aperture Z-scan traces, the normalized transmittance TN curves against the sample position z, of (a) CR2a, (b) CR2b, and (c) CR2c in CHCl3 (0.44, 0.49, and 0.47 mM) at 1255, 1395, and 1454 nm (red square) with theoretical fits (grey curves, see ESI†) and blank solvent (green cross) at different excitation intensity I0 of 190, 153, and 158 GW cm−2, respectively. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 TPA spectra in the cross section σ(2) (symbols, left and bottom axes) of CR2a (A), CR2b (B) and CR2c (C) in CHCl3 together with the corresponding OPA spectra (black dashed line, right and top axes). λTPA comes at the same horizontal position of 2 × λOPA, resulting in the same transition energies for TPA and OPA comes at the same horizontal position. Open symbols and the filled symbols with error bars mean that the σ(2) data were obtained by the different measurement procedures (wavelength scan and power scan, respectively; see the ESI† for details.). |
The OPA and TPA spectra of CR2a–c were simulated by DFT calculations at the CAM-B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level (see ESI†). Although the transition energies were slightly overestimated for OPA and significantly overestimated for TPA, the relative spectral positions of OPA and TPA bands matched well with experimental values (Fig. S12, ESI†). The simulations suggest that the OPA and TPA transitions correspond to the S1 ← S0 and S4 ← S0 states, respectively, which supports observed fact that the transition energies of the TPA maxima differed from those of the OPA maxima. In the simulation, the relatively weak second OPA band appears on the shorter wavelength side of the TPA band assigned to the S4 ← S0 transition. In the experimental spectrum of each dye, the substantial TPA is also observed on the shorter wavelength side of the strong S4 ← S0 TPA band, likely due to resonant enhancement by the OPA.61,62
The peak σ(2) of CR2a, CR2b, and CR2c of the band were determined to be 1008 ± 136, 1011 ± 202, and 1177 ± 193 GM, respectively (where 1 GM = 10−50 cm4 s molecule−1 photon−1). These are significant values in the SWIR region as this size of molecule. To compare with the benchmarks, Fig. 10 shows the reported σ(2) scaled by molecular weight (M.w.) for structurally similar oxocarbon analogues (squaraine dyes SQ1b and a previously repored croconaine dye with shorter conjugation CR1b, see Fig. S14 for their structures, ESI†) is plotted against the TPA peak wavelength. Clearly, it is shown that CR2a–c have the highest class values of σ(2)/M.w. in the SWIR region, compared to the closed-shell squaraine dye. This finding suggests that these croconaine dyes possess unusually large σ(2), likely due to their extended conjugation and strong donor–acceptor interactions. Furthermore, the intermediate diradical character of these dyes contribute to the observed enhancement of σ(2).
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 Plot of the maximum TPA wavelength versus TPA cross section for each dye divided by molecular weight for squaraine and croconaine dyes (detail showed in Fig. S14 and Table S5, ESI†). |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic procedures, experimental details. CCDC 2407572 (CR2c). For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5tc00973a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |