Nisal
Wanasingha
a,
Rajkamal
Balu
a,
Agata
Rekas
b,
Jitendra P.
Mata
cd,
Naba K.
Dutta
a and
Namita Roy
Choudhury
*a
aChemical and Environmental Engineering, School of Engineering, STEM College, RMIT University, Melbourne, VIC 3000, Australia. E-mail: naba.dutta@rmit.edu.au; namita.choudhury@rmit.edu.au
bNational Deuteration Facility, Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation (ANSTO), Lucas Heights, NSW 2234, Australia
cAustralian Centre for Neutron Scattering, Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation (ANSTO), Lucas Heights, NSW 2234, Australia
dSchool of Chemistry, University of New South Wales, Sydney 2052, Australia
First published on 21st November 2024
The controlled co-assembly of biomacromolecules through tuneable interactions offers a simple and fascinating opportunity to assemble multiple molecules into a single entity with enhanced complexity and unique properties. Herein, our study presents a dynamic co-assembled system using the multistimuli responsive intrinsically disordered protein Rec1-resilin and the adhesive hydrophilic protein silk sericin (SS). We utilized advanced characterization techniques including circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering (DLS), small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and small/ultra-small angle neutron scattering (SANS/USANS) to elucidate the detailed co-assembly behavior of the system and its evolution over time and temperature. To achieve sufficient neutron contrast, we successfully biosynthesised deuterium-labeled Rec1-resilin (D-Rec1). Our research demonstrates that this co-assembly allows the formation of a robust entity with dynamic conformational assembly and disassembly, exhibiting both the upper critical solution temperature (UCST) and lower critical solution temperature (LCST) with reversibility. The assembly and disassembly dynamics of the co-assembled entity at UCST are very fast, while the process is kinetically controlled at LCST. This study provides significant new insights into the interplay of a hydrophilic, multi-responsive IDP and a highly hydrophilic protein, shaping the thermoresponsive and stable properties of the co-assembled entity.
The co-assembly of two different proteins forms a new frontier in material properties, where ‘protein A’ would co-assemble with ‘protein B’ to form a supramolecular architecture and conformation or dynamic conformational ensemble with enhanced complexity, dynamic properties and functionality.4,9–14 Controlled co-assembly is a powerful technique and has been successfully employed to create new biotechnologies for a variety of uses, such as drug delivery, sensors, and assisted charge transport.15–19 This multicomponent co-assembly is a spontaneous intermolecular non-covalent interaction (e.g., hydrogen bonding, electrostatic attraction, hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions and van der Waals interactions) derived organization under near thermodynamic equilibrium conditions into stable arrangements. Due to the structural complexity of proteins and the nature of the self-assembly process, it is difficult to control and predict the size and morphology of the self-assembled nanomaterials.20 Surely, some impressive reviews have discussed the effectiveness of the different techniques used for the modelling and prediction of multicomponent assembly.21,22 Thus, to understand these systems completely, it is of paramount importance to co-assemble rationally designed peptides/proteins strategically and simultaneously characterise the multicomponent assemblies across multiple length-scales, from molecular interactions to bulk properties.
Herein, we investigate the co-assembly of two environmentally responsive biomimetic proteins, Rec1-resilin, a multi-stimuli-responsive intrinsically disordered protein (IDP); and silk sericin (SS), a responsive globular glycoprotein that functions as the glue. We investigate in detail how their co-assembly affects the conformational ensembles, aggregation, size, phase behaviour and conformational dynamics; and its impact on thermo-responsiveness using state-of-the-art experimental tools including dynamic light scattering and small/ultrasmall-angle neutron scattering (SANS/USANS). Our goal is to investigate the effect of the co-assembly on the conformational ensemble of the co-assembled system and its impact on the thermo-responsiveness. We biosynthesised deuterium-labelled Rec1-resilin (D-Rec1) to obtain adequate neutron contrast in the two proteins during the small/ultrasmall-angle neutron scattering (SANS/USANS) experiment.
Native resilin is an exoskeletal structural protein found in insects and other arthropods, and is characterized by low stiffness, high extensibility and extraordinary resilience; and professed to be the most efficient elastomeric protein known.23,24 Resilin-mimetic proteins (RMPs), specifically, Rec1-resilin, have attracted great interest due to their unusual structural characteristics, dynamics of conformational ensembles, multi-stimuli responsiveness and outstanding elasticity; and potential for use in a diverse range of applications in nanotechnology, drug delivery and medicine.23 Rec1-resilin, a recombinant version of resilin was first successfully cloned and expressed in 2005 by Chris et al.24 from the first exon of the Drosophila CG15920 gene. The consensus sequence of Rec1-resilin consists of 18 copies of a 15-residue repeat sequence: GGRPSDSYGAPGGGN, exhibiting high content of glycine (Gly) and proline (Pro), transpiring a profoundly hydrophilic IDP with unusual environmental responsiveness;24–26 contrary to conventional wisdom. The structural characteristics of Rec1-resilin at the amino acid sequence level and the resulting unique property attributes have led researchers to investigate diverse RMPs.23 These RMPs stand out as a unique class of IDP, with an unusual structure–function relationship; where they fail to form a stable structure, yet they exhibit unusual environmental responsiveness and biological activities. They are poorly understood and are attractive targets for modern protein research.27,28
Kindred to various extracellular matrix (ECM) environments of tissues, RMPs can also react to diverse parameters due to their multi-stimuli responsive behaviour; demonstrating responsiveness to pH, ion concentration, light and temperature in aqueous solution; including dual-phase behaviour (DPB) – displaying both upper critical temperature (UCST) and lower critical solution temperature (LCST).25,29–31 However, both the UCST (6 °C) and LCST (70 °C) of Rec1-resilin25 falls outside of the physiological temperature range, hindering the possibility of showcasing its stimuli-responsiveness for biological applications. Indeed, using RMPs as a biomaterial for tissue engineering applications would be beneficial where they have shown structural similarity to the ECM of tissues and are responsive to temperature relevant to physiological conditions.32
It has been demonstrated that for self-assembling proteins, the tunability of the LCST can be achieved through modulation of the hydrophobicity of the protein/polypeptide through relevant changes in amino acid residues at the sequence level.33,34 Additionally, the predictive knowledge of the relationship between amino acid residues at the sequence level and protein behaviour provides new avenues for the logical engineering of novel protein activities through the design of amino acid sequences.35 Nevertheless, the process of expressing and purifying a recombinant protein from a designed complementary DNA (cDNA) library is still a grand challenge36 and the potential to design a protein's distinct structure at the sequence level to produce dynamic, hierarchical functional materials is still a distant goal. Conversely, the co-assembly of carefully chosen individual proteins with the appropriate amino acid composition can result in supramolecular complexes whose constituent parts work together harmoniously to perform complicated functions.37 Comparable strategies have been explored for co-assembled protein systems, wherein hydrophobic peptides, proteins and polymers were introduced to modulate LCST.10,38 In a previous work10 we have shown that the recombinant resilin protein Rec1-resilin may be easily co-assembled into a rigid model polypeptide (poly-L-proline) or a hydrophobic rigid protein (Bombyx mori silk fibroin) to adjust its thermo-responsiveness. However, as noted by Liu et al.39 and Wu et al.,40 many variables – both compositional and environmental can dictate the properties and functions of these co-assemblies. Protein co-assembly is still in its infancy, and to regulate protein co-assembly by design and obtain desired functionality, new approaches, cutting-edge instruments, and advanced experimental methodologies must be used.19,41
SS is an abundant polymer, which is widely discarded during the degumming of silk, despite being a biocompatible material with a vast range of biomedical applications such as antioxidant and antibacterial activity.42 SS is structurally a globular protein that possesses β-sheet and random coil structural motifs that can interconvert depending on the environment (responsive to temperature, moisture and mechanical stretching).43–45 In addition to its adhesiveness, SS is chemically and biologically distinctive due to its low immunogenicity, pH responsiveness, antioxidant activity, biocompatibility, and capacity to stimulate cell division, antimicrobial properties, UV resistance, moisturising effect on skin and lowering cholesterol. Due to its unique qualities, such as its good cytocompatibility and ability to promote wound healing, SS films have garnered significant interest from researchers in the biomedical and cosmetic industries. These characteristics make SS valuable in a variety of industries, including food, drug delivery and biomedicine. Additionally, it can be easily transformed into biomaterials by copolymerization, cross-linking, and combining with other polymers.46
000 g for 15 min at 20 °C. The resulting supernatant obtained was identified as electrophoretically pure Rec1-resilin and D-Rec1 with molecular weights of 28.5 and 29.2 kDa respectively, shown in Fig. S1 (ESI†). The protein samples were stored at −20 °C before use.
:
50 volumetric ratio with a total concentration of 0.1 mg mL−1. Pure Rec1-resilin and SS systems were also prepared to a final concentration of 0.1 mg mL−1. All solutions were prepared in 1 mM PBS buffer to reduce the chances of a noisy spectrum and maintain a reliable HT value. All systems were aged over time up until 6 days to observe any structural changes, with incubation at 4 °C, 20 °C and 70 °C, respectively. CD spectra of the proteins were obtained using a JASCO spectropolarimeter (Jasco J-150, Jasco, Japan). Systems were measured at the incubation temperature, where heating and cooling were maintained using the Jasco MCB-100 Mini Circulation Bath. Prior to each scan, 15 min of equilibrium was given for each protein solution at their relevant incubation temperature. The experimental spectra were measured in the range of 190–260 nm. The data pitch was set at 0.2 nm, at a scanning speed of 50 nm min−1, a bandwidth of 1.0 nm, DIT of 1 s, and an accumulation of 10 scans. Dichroweb, an online fitting program, was used to extract the secondary structure information from the CD spectra for fitting.50
:
50 volumetric ratio, followed by stirring and sonication for homogeneous distribution of particles. The system was studied over a period of 0–6 days, incubated at 4 °C, where each temperature increment change was given a 5 min equilibration time. For size determination of temperature cycling measurements, the solution was heated from 4 °C to 70 °C in the same incremental steps as previously described, before being cooled back down to 4 °C in the same manner. The equilibration time was consistent throughout this process. Visual observation of phase transitions was photographed to distinguish the appearance of the system as the transitions occurred. The measured Dh values were averaged from a cumulative analysis of five cycles.
:
SS weight ratios of 1
:
1, 1
:
2 and 2
:
1 were loaded into Hellma cells (20 mm diameter and 1 mm path length). The sample to detector distances of 20, 12 and 1.3 m were used with an incident neutron wavelength of 5.0 Å and 8.1 Å (for lens optics configuration). The SANS data were measured in the scattering vector (q) range of 0.0007 to 0.7 Å, and the obtained scattering data were reduced, combined, and background subtracted using the IgorPro software package.52 Structural parameters of the samples were acquired using the SasView software package.
:
SS (1
:
1) co-assembled system along with pristine Rec1-resilin and SS was investigated (after 1 day and 6 days of equilibration at 4 and 20 °C) using a bench top Xeuss3.0 SAXS instrument (Xenocs Grenoble). The instrument was equipped with a rotating anode Cu Kα radiation source (1.42 Å) and a 2D detector. The samples (0.1 mg mL−1) were loaded in disposable quartz capillaries, and the SAXS data were collected at 20 ± 0.1 °C in the scattering vector (q) range of 0.01 to 0.5 Å−1. The background data were subtracted from the sample data using ATSAS software package for analysis.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Kyte–Doolittle hydropathy plot of (a) Rec1-resilin and (b) B. mori silk sericin. The average hydropathy of a moving segment of a fixed window size of 7 is shown in the figure. | ||
Fig. 1b shows the Kyte–Doolittle hydrophobicity plot of SS, which has an average hydropathy score of −2.16 reflecting hydrophilicity. SS is a globular hydrophilic protein composed of 18 amino acid residues the majority of which have polar side chains that primarily contain polar side chains made of hydroxyl, carboxyl, and amino groups (Fig. S3 and Table S2 in the ESI†).42,54 Collectively, hydroxy amino acid residues make up 45.8% of the SS structure, polar amino acids account for 42.3%, and nonpolar amino acids make up 12.2%. Compositionally, serine is the most abundant amino acid in SS (∼39 mol%), followed by glycine (∼15 mol%), and aspartic acid containing asparagine (∼15 mol%), which makes them hydrophilic. This is to note that native SS is a protein of complex composition. Based on its solubility, the composition of native-SS has been divided into three groups, respectively SS-A, SS-B, and SS-C.43 SS-A, which is insoluble in hot water forms the outer layer of the SS layer enveloping the fibroin core. The amino acid residues serine, threonine, aspartic acid, and glycine are the primary component observed in this layer with 17.2% of nitrogen. SS-B, the middle layer, has 16.8% nitrogen content and contains a set of amino acids resembling those in SS-A but more soluble in hot water. The last internal layer, known as SS-C, located close to the fibroin core contains 16.6% nitrogen sulphur and is strongly bound to the fibroin core. The SS used in this work is a water-soluble component and is essentially composed of SS-B and the amino acid sequence of SS-B is shown in Fig. S3 in the ESI.† The negative hydropathy score for both the polypeptides, Rec1-resilin and SS reflects that they are completely hydrophilic, however, there are significant differences in their amino acid composition, which is reflected in their secondary structures and properties. Conformationally, SS is constituted by a repeated amino acid sequence capable of forming the β-sheet structure, whereas Rec1-resilin is an IDP. Characteristically, Re1-resilin demonstrates temperature dependent dual phase behaviour – exhibiting both UCST and LCST;25 whereas SS displays thermo-responsive sol–gel transition due to the interconversion of random coil into the β-sheet structure.45 Understanding how co-assembly modifies the secondary structure of the co-assembled entity and its consequences on resilin's temperature phase transition is fascinating from a scientific standpoint and has never been attempted before. This knowledge also has significant practical importance in the application in biology, targeted delivery, and nanotechnology. To reveal the hierarchical organisational features of the co-assembled system in different length scales, we employed scattering (both light scattering and neutron scattering) techniques as follows.
:
1 ratio) at the micron level and above. Initially, the hydrodynamic diameter (Dh) of the two individual proteins was measured and shown in Fig. S4 in the ESI.† The Dh distribution plots display Dh values for Rec1-resilin (∼10 nm) and SS (∼10 nm), respectively, that corroborate with the previous literature reported values.25,55Fig. 2a displays the effect of temperature on the variation of Dh of the Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled entity during the full thermal cycling step between 4 and 70 °C. The curve precisely illustrates the dynamics of the co-assembly pathways and occurrences of phase transitions (pH 7.4) as a function of temperature-both during heating and followed by successive cooling. It is evident from the figure that upon heating the co-assembled system from 4 °C (Fig. 2a), there appears to be a minute fluctuation in Dh, followed by a steep inflection point at 10 °C (UCST). Subsequently, the Dh value drastically decreases with a progressive rise in temperature until it reaches about 22 °C, at which point it adopts a steady size that is independent of temperate up to ∼52 °C. Notably, the hydrodynamic diameter (Dh) of the co-assembled entity composed of Rec1-resilin and SS is roughly 55 nm, in contrast to around 10 nm for the size of the native proteins. This observation implies that there are intermolecular interactions taking place between Rec1-resilin and SS. The pattern suggests the formation of a stable co-assembled individual entity occurs within the temperature range of 22 °C to 52 °C. A second transition during the first heating cycle (Fig. 2a) at ∼52 °C is characterised by a sharp increase in Dh with temperature, which is indicative of LCST behaviour.
Subsequently, the reversibility of the co-assembled entity's UCST behaviour was investigated by measuring Dh as a function of temperature covering the UCST (between 4 and 30 °C) zone in multiple cooling and heating cycles (Fig. 2b). In the cooling cycle at the UCST the dissociated chains initiate association and exhibit a sharp change in the Dh with an inflection point at ∼22 °C followed by a peak at ∼10.0 °C due to the formation of a swollen gel. Experiments involving repeated heating and cooling covering the UCST region verify that the transition is robust and fully reversible, with no hysteresis. Conversely, as seen in the behaviour at LCST (Fig. 2a), the pathways during the cooling phase did not align with those from the heating phase, and the Dh value exhibited considerable hysteresis. We further investigated the time-dependent recovery of post-LCST associated entity at room temperature (Fig. 2c). The figure clarifies that the dissociation process from an associated system post-LCST is kinetically controlled, and the co-assembled entity follows an exponential model, similar to that observed in the pristine Rec1-resilin system.25
This observation could additionally be seen visually (Fig. 2d), where the cooling cycle did not attain a uniform singular unit system at expected temperatures. Interestingly, this Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled entity could remarkably retain the reversible dual phase behaviour equivalent to Rec1-resilin at both the UCST and LCST,25 though with some noticeable differences. Firstly, both the UCST and the LCST of the co-assembled entity shifted to ∼15 °C and ∼57 °C, respectively, relative to Rec1-resilin, which was reported to have UCST at ∼6 °C and LCST at ∼70 °C, respectively.25 Secondly, the size of the co-assembled entity post-UCST is much higher than pristine Rec1-resilin (∼10 nm). Thirdly, the aggregate size of the co-assembled entity at UCST is lower (<1000 nm) than Rec1-resilin (≫1000 nm). The kinetics of the dissociation process of the co-assembled entity post-LCST appears to be slower than Rec1-resilin.25
To examine the stability of the co-assembled entity, the Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled systems were aged for a long period (0–6 days). The aliquots would be taken for particle size distribution measurements at a daily interval. The temperature range for the DLS measurement used covered both the UCST and LCST. Fig. S5 in the ESI,† shows the Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled system Dh size measurements over an incubation period of 6 days heating from 4 °C to 70 °C. Overall, the particle size distribution illustrated a similar trend replicating over the incubation period and the temperature range, notably with the distinctive and identical dual phase transition behaviour, suggesting that co-assembled systems are highly stable under the storage conditions. Fig. 3 presents the visual observation of the temperature phase behaviour of the co-assembled Rec1-resilin/SS system at varying temperatures and incubation periods.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Visual observation of the temperature phase behaviour of the co-assembled Rec1-resilin/SS system at varying temperatures and incubation periods. | ||
It was compelling to note the temperatures at which the phase shifts (both LCST and UCST) of the co-assembled system occurred compared to the neat Rec1-resilin. The shift is more pronounced in the highly hydrophilic Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled system than in the previously reported co-assembly of Rec1-resilin with hydrophobic–hydrophilic interactions.10 Intuitively, this is unanticipated, as studies have predominantly suggested that the phase transition behaviour is largely directed by the presence of a hydrophobic block and hydrophobic interaction.56 Although highly hydrophilic proteins have shown phase transition behaviours that undergo self-assembly driven by complex coacervation, these systems follow the principality of polyelectrolytes.57,58 Hence, nullified in the Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled system studied; as both proteins display a net negative surface charge at the experimental pH.25,59 A prior study45 revealed the thermo-reversible characteristics of SS, where the protein showed rapid gelation with increasing concentrations (10–50 mg mL−1) and at higher temperatures (40 °C). The structural composition of SS shows that it is rich in hydrophilic amino acids, including serine, tyrosine, glutamic acid, aspartic acid, and lysine, which bestow SS with favourable water solubility. The amount of charged residues (Glu + Asp = 13% and Lys + Arg = 15%) confers to some regions of SS a higher degree of solvent accessibility and hydrophilicity. Approximately 45 mol% of SS is made up of amino acids having hydroxyl side chains, such as threonine and serine. Part of the consensus sequence of SS is [GSVSSTGSSSNTDSST]60,61 where G, S, T, V, N and D denote glycine, alanine, serine, threonine, valine, asparagine and aspartic acid, respectively. This part of the sequence of SS has the hydroxyl groups regularly on one side of the peptide backbone allowing SS to approach each other to form hydrogen bonds. A polar zipper interactions, driven by hydrogen bonds among various polar amino acids in the Ser-rich repeating motif, likely play a critical role in forming the β-sheet structure.62,63 Additionally, both Rec1-resilin and SS contain a large proportion –OH containing amino acid residues, serine; ∼15 mol% in Rec1-resilin (Table S1 in the ESI†) and ∼35 mol% in SS and (Table S2 in the ESI†) that have the potential to form inter and intramolecular hydrogen bonding. Given that SS's phase transition occurs at a notably lower temperature than that of Rec1-resilin (∼70 °C) the incorporation of SS results in a negative shift in the LCST of the co-assembled systems and the potential molecular level interactions are discussed later.
:
SS weight ratios of 2
:
1, 1
:
1, and 1
:
2 at 5 and 75 °C, respectively, in water. The scattering profile of the co-assembled systems (all three ratios) exhibited three distinct regions at the UCST (Fig. 4a): a high-q Porod region (0.06 < q < 0.1 Å−1), a mid-q Guinier-like region (0.02 < q < 0.06 Å−1), and a low-q Porod-like region (0.0007 < q < 0.02 Å−1). On the other hand, the scattering profile of co-assembled systems (all three ratios) exhibited two distinct regions at the LCST (Fig. 4b): a mid-q to high-q Porod region (0.06 < q < 0.1 Å−1) and a low-q to mid-q Porod-like region (0.0007 < q < 0.02 Å−1). The lack of the Guinier region at low-q (i.e. the observed increase in the scattering intensity with a decrease in the q value) indicates the structures formed at both UCST and LCST are beyond the size range of SANS measurement, which is in good agreement with the DLS results. SANS intensity profiles of D-Rec1 in water and a fit of the data with model function to estimate structural parameters are presented in Fig. S6a (ESI†). The radius of gyration (Rg) of D-Rec1 has been established as 6.2 ± 0.1 nm.48 The Rg of SS was estimated in this work from the respective SANS data measured at 25 °C (Fig. S6b in the ESI†). The scattering profile of SS in water (10 mM PBS) exhibited two distinct regions: a high-q Porod region (0.07 < q < 0.3 Å−1), and a mid-q Guinier-like region (0.006 < q < 0.07 Å−1), and a low-q Porod-like region (0.0007 < q < 0.02 Å−1). Therefore, a shape-independent Poly_Gauss_Coil model function (which describes the scattering from polydisperse polymer chains in theta solvents65) was fitted to the data to obtain the Rg (Fig. S6 in the ESI†). The Poly Gauss_Coil fit returned a Rg of 1.8 ± 0.1 nm, which when compared with the measured (using DLS) hydrodynamic diameter of ∼10 nm indicates that the SS molecules stabilise as a multimer through intermolecular interaction in water. The measured (using DLS) hydrodynamic diameter of ∼55 nm for Rec1-resilin/SS (1
:
1) co-assembly at 25 °C indicates intermolecular interaction between Rec1-resilin and SS to form stable nano-aggregates.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 SANS intensity profile of the D-Rec1 : SS co-assembled system (at 2 : 1, 1 : 1, and 1 : 2 weight ratios) compared at (a) UCST and (b) LCST. | ||
To estimate the structural parameters of the D-Rec1:SS co-assembled system at both UCST and LCST, a shape-independent Guinier–Porod model function (which describes scattering from a generalised Guinier/power law object66) was fitted to the mid-q and high-q data to obtain the Rg, whereas a power law function fit to low-q data to obtain the fractal dimension of aggregates (Fig. 5). The structural parameters estimated from the fits are provided in Table 1. In general, the co-assemblies exhibited Gaussian coil intrinsic structure and relatively smaller Rg at UCST compared to the fully swollen coil intrinsic structure and relatively larger Rg at LCST. Moreover, the co-assemblies exhibited surface fractal dimension (Porod slope between 3 and 4; i.e., relatively packed aggregates) at UCST, whereas mass-fractal dimension (Porod slope between 2 to 3; i.e., relatively loose network aggregates) at the LCST. While the Rg was observed to decrease with an increase in the SS content of co-assemblies, no significant difference in the fractal dimension of aggregates was observed.
| Sample | Temperature (°C) | Low-q (power law fit) | Mid-q & high-q (Guinier–Porod fit) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exponent/slope | R g (nm) | Exponent/slope | ||
D-Rec1 : SS (2 : 1) |
5 | 3.47 ± 0.01 | 3.05 ± 0.03 | 1.99 ± 0.06 |
| 75 | 2.48 ± 0.02 | 4.28 ± 0.14 | 1.70 ± 0.01 | |
D-Rec1 : SS (1 : 1) |
5 | 3.46 ± 0.01 | 2.97 ± 0.04 | 1.99 ± 0.07 |
| 75 | 2.48 ± 0.02 | 4.10 ± 0.16 | 1.70 ± 0.01 | |
D-Rec1 : SS (1 : 2) |
5 | 3.45 ± 0.02 | 2.71 ± 0.06 | 1.98 ± 0.09 |
| 75 | 2.48 ± 0.03 | 3.57 ± 0.15 | 1.70 ± 0.01 | |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 CD spectra of protein systems after 1 day incubation at (a) 4 °C, (b) 20 °C, and (c) 70 °C and 6 day incubation at (d) 4 °C, (e) 20 °C and (f) 70 °C. | ||
To gain a deeper understanding of how the secondary structure transitions with varying incubation periods, we conducted a comprehensive study over a span of 7 days at 20 °C across all protein systems. The observation demonstrated that this change for Rec1-resilin began at day 4 of incubation (Fig. 7a), where it would gradually lose its inherent secondary structure. Unlike Rec1-resilin, the SS solution displayed a stable form (Fig. 7b), which in turn aided the co-assembled system in extending its shelf-life stability to retain its secondary structure (Fig. 7c). Compellingly, at both low temperatures, below UCST (Fig. 6d), and high temperatures, above LCST (Fig. 6f), during the incubation periods, there was no indication of any significant secondary structural changes to any of the proteins and their co-assembled entity. Though, previous reports suggested the sol–gel properties of sericin upon heating, which led the random-coil structure to subsequently become a β-sheet.42,69 Accordingly, we postulate that the proteins can maintain their secondary structures at the extreme temperatures of incubation and analysis, or they may have influenced the resulting structures exhibited due to the presence of aggregated units, reflecting what was found in DLS measurements.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 CD spectra of protein systems (a) Rec1-resilin, (b) SS, and (c) Rec1-resilin and SS co-assembled system at 20 °C, at incubation periods ranging from 0–6 days. | ||
Fig. S7 in the ESI,† shows the SAXS intensity profile of the Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled system with a 1
:
1 ratio compared with pristine Rec1-resilin and SS after 1 and 6 days of equilibration at UCST (4 °C) and room temperature (20 °C). It can be observed that pristine SS and Rec1
:
SS (1
:
1) co-assembled system showed no significant difference in scattering when equilibrated at UCST and room temperature. The pristine Rec1-resilin exhibited no significant difference in scattering when equilibrated at UCST, however, it formed aggregates (increased low-q scattering intensity, Fig. S7d in the ESI†) after 6 days at room temperature. Therefore, the SAXS results are in general agreement with CD spectroscopy results.
Fig. 8 shows the consensus primary amino acid repeat sequence and amino acid fraction in Rec1-resilin and SS. Rec1-resilin is an intrinsically disordered protein and its primary structural composition is mainly dominated by 18 copies of a 15-residue repeat sequence: GGRPSDSYGAPGGGN (Fig. 8a and b). It contains a very high content of Gly (∼34 mol%) and the amino acid residues in this recombinant protein are dominated by polar residues including both uncharged, ∼23% (Ser ∼14.2%, Thr-1.6%, Asn-6.45%, Gln-3.87%) and charged polar, ∼11.5% (with Asp ∼4% and Arg ∼5%) hydrophilic residues punctuated with aromatic amino acid residue Tyr (∼6.5%) (Fig. 8c). Due to this unique primary structure of Rec1-resilin liquid/liquid demixing and aggregation at UCST is driven by the electrostatic interactions between positively and negatively charged amino acid repeats. These interactions are amplified by localized alterations in protein dynamics influenced by the water dynamics in the first hydration shell. A reduction in temperature facilitates the ordering of the hydration water molecules, ultimately resulting in protein aggregation through phase separation at ∼6 °C. In a manner similar to Rec1-resilin, the SS sequence contains a high proportion of charged and polar residues (Fig. 8d–f) that impart certain regions of SS with greater solvent accessibility and hydrophilicity. As noted from SANS (Fig. S6 in ESI†) and DLS, in solution SS stabilizes as a multimeric protein. When Rec1-resilin and SS are uniformly mixed in a solution (LCST〈T〉UCST) they form a stable, co-assembled nano-aggregate ∼55 nm in size (Fig. 2a) due to intermolecular interactions without major secondary structural change (Fig. 6a). This co-assembled structure shows a marginal increase in the UCST to ∼15 °C due to the rise in the fraction of overall charged polar amino acids.
The LCST behaviour exhibited by Rec1-resilin at ∼70 °C is attributed to the reduction in the hydration layer around the hydrophilic segment and the intermolecular hydrophobic interaction of the exposed hydrophobic amino acid segments.25 Due to the low fraction of hydrophobic segments present, at LCST, Rec1-resilin forms micro-gel particles rather than a dense gel network.25 The observed decrease in the LCST of the co-assembled nano-aggregate entity of Rec1-resilin/SS from 70 °C to ∼57 °C (Fig. 2a) is counterintuitive. Nonetheless, as elaborated in Fig. 8, both Rec1-resilin and SS comprise a significant percentage of amino acid residues with –OH groups (Ser, Thr), which are predominantly placed on one side of the peptide backbone. Therefore, in Rec1-resilin/SS co-assembled system it is postulated that, while LCST is seeded by hydrophobic interactions, the hydrogen bonds formed by several polar amino acids in the Ser-rich repeating sequence (polar zipper interactions), contribute to the negative shift in LCST. This intermolecular interaction could potentially alter the molecular dynamics of the co-assembled structure from being independently exclusive to mutually cooperative, thus reducing LCST, although there are no notable changes in secondary structure observed.
Our investigation revealed that, despite the inherent challenges associated with a hydrophilic-hydrophilic co-assembled system, the Rec1-resilin/SS system exhibited promising results that enhanced the tunability of the Rec1-resilin protein. This study illustrated that the engineering of stimuli responses can be achieved through the co-assembly of proteins, enabling the straightforward design of materials of interest for various biological and non-biological applications. This innovative possibility also presents several challenges in comprehensively gaining molecular insights into alterations in the local molecular environment and long-range order during the transitions of LCST and UCST. Molecular dynamics simulations at both the atomistic and mesoscale levels can be instrumental in gaining a deeper level understanding of the structural and dynamic characteristics of these conjugates within a temperature range associated with their UCST/LCST-like phase behavior; though this aspect falls outside the focus of this work.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tb01737d |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |