Yaru
Wei‡
abc,
Baocheng
Yang‡
b,
Shouren
Zhang
b and
Houyang
Chen
*ac
aChongqing Institute of Green and Intelligent Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Chongqing 400714, P. R. China. E-mail: chenhouyang@cigit.ac.cn
bHenan Provincial Key Laboratory of Nanocomposites and Applications, Institute of Nanostructured Functional Materials, Huanghe Science and Technology College, P. R. China
cChongqing School, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Chongqing 400714, P. R. China
First published on 14th April 2025
The depletion of fossil fuels and increasing greenhouse gas emissions underscore the urgent need for sustainable energy technologies. Herein, we present rC14, a novel two-dimensional (2D) carbon allotrope engineered by reconfiguring graphene through carbon–carbon bond rotation and defect introduction, which exhibits remarkable multifunctionality for energy storage and conversion applications under conventional and micro-strain conditions. Theoretical calculations indicate that rC14 exhibits excellent dynamical, thermal and mechanical stability. Its high porosity facilitates a theoretical Na-ion storage capacity of 1115 m Ah g−1, approximately three times higher than that of conventional graphite, and this high capacity is retained under small compressive strains. It possesses a low ion diffusion barrier (0.22–0.54 eV) that promises rapid charge/discharge kinetics. Furthermore, the non-uniform charge distribution across rC14, particularly at C1 and C2 sites, renders it an effective metal-free catalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). The application of small biaxial compressive strains further refines the electronic structure and adsorption properties of the metal-free catalyst, yielding near-optimal ΔGH* values (|ΔGH*| around 0.05 eV) that surpass the values of conventional catalysts such as the Pt(111) surface (−0.09 eV). This work establishes rC14 as a promising dual-function metal-free material for next-generation energy storage and conversion systems under conventional and micro-strain conditions and demonstrates the effectiveness of the designed strategies in advancing material performance.
Recently, two-dimensional (2D) anode materials with large surface areas have attracted great interest, which can provide abundant active sites for electrocatalytic reactions.9,10 Pristine graphene, however, is not an ideal choice for these energy-related applications because the high delocalization of its π electrons renders the structure chemically inert despite its stability. This limitation has driven the scientific community to explore new carbon allotropes and develop innovative synthesis methods.11 Notably, carbon structures containing non-six-membered ring units have demonstrated excellent physicochemical and electronic properties, making them promising candidates for electrodes in energy conversion and storage.12 For instance, in 2021, biphenylene was synthesized on the surface of Au(111) single crystals under ultra-high vacuum conditions and then applied it as a metal-free catalyst for water splitting in OERs.13,14 Li et al. identified monolayer biphenylene as a promising high-performance anode for sodium-ion batteries (SIBs).15 Wang et al. has demonstrated a new 2D carbon allotrope (net-τ) as a new high-performance metallic carbon anode material for lithium-ion batteries.16 Wu et al. investigated graphdiyne (GDY) and graphyne (an allotrope of GDY) as high activity catalysts for CO oxidation and the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR),17,18 owing to the positively charged sites within their frameworks, although the HER performance of pristine GDY remained suboptimal.19 More research has focused on two-dimensional carbon materials as single energy storage or catalytic electrodes, while little research has focused on multifunctional materials. In 2022, Yang et al. proposed graphene composed of four- and seven-membered rings as an efficient bifunctional electrocatalyst for both the HER and OER, as well as a promising anode material for potassium-ion batteries.20 These studies underscore the growing interest in multifunctional materials that can serve dual or more purposes while reducing overall costs.
In this work, based on first-principles calculations, we have constructed this novel 2D carbon allotrope, which consists of three-, five-, six- and fourteen-membered rings, and named it rC14. rC14 could be constructed by rotation of the carbon–carbon bond and introduction of defects (Fig. S1†), and these methods have experimental feasibility.21–23 The energy calculations reveal that while rC14 is metastable compared to graphene, it is energetically more favorable than graphdiyne24 (Table S1†). Moreover, our results showed that rC14 is a promising anode material for Na-ion batteries (SIBs), as evidenced by its high Na-ion storage capacity, low diffusion energy barrier and modest average open circuit voltage. Meanwhile, the fully exposed active sites in rC14 enhance its catalytic activity for the HER, with applied strain playing a critical role in modulating the performance. We further analyzed its electronic characteristics and composition that underpin both its energy storage capacity and catalytic activity. The computational strategies and methods used in this study provide a reference for future search of new 2D materials with dual-function applications.
Furthermore, the structural stability of the proposed structure is confirmed. The total energy of rC14 is −8.59 eV per atom, underscoring its energetic stability. The detailed structural information of rC14 and other 2D carbon allotropes is given in Table S1 and Section S1 of the ESI.† The phonon spectrum (Fig. S2†) shows no imaginary phonon mode throughout the entire Brillouin zone, indicating that rC14 is dynamically stable. To evaluate the thermal stability of rC14, AIMD simulations were performed at 300 K and 1200 K. Each simulation was conducted for 5 ps with a time step of 1 fs to ensure accuracy and reliability. The total energy of rC14 possesses slight fluctuations in total energy without any structural changes (Fig. 1b and S3†), signifying outstanding thermal stability even at high temperatures around 1200 K. The elastic constants are C11 = 182 GPa, C22 = 228 GPa, C12 = 51 GPa and C44 = 36 GPa. The elastic constants Cij satisfy the Born–Huang criteria,36 C11C22– C122 > 0 and C44 > 0, implying the mechanical stability of rC14. Furthermore, Young's modulus C and Poisson's ratio ѵ estimated the in-plane stiffness from the linear elastic constants. The polar diagrams of C(θ) and ѵ(θ) in Fig. 1c and d show that the Young's modulus and Poisson's ratios are almost isotropic. Specifically, the plane Young's modulus is 224 GPa nm along the a-axis (Ca) and 178 GPa nm along the b-axis (Cb), implying high in-plane stiffness. The corresponding Poisson's ratios in the a-axis and b-axis directions are 0.22 and 0.28, respectively, which indicate that rC14 is malleable in the axial direction.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) Band structures by PBE and HSE06 functionals. (b) Projected density of states of rC14 obtained by the PBE functional. The Fermi level is set to zero. (c) The ELF map of rC14. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a) The possible Na adsorption sites on rC14. (b) The adsorption energies of the Na-adsorbed rC14 monolayer at different sites by the atom pair adsorption approach. |
Subsequently, a series of Na ions of increasing concentration were adopted to test the storage capacity of the rC14 anode. Their energetically favorable configurations are provided in Fig. S5a–e,† and the computed adsorption energies for Na4C56, Na8C56, Na12C56, Na20C56 and Na28C56 are −0.80, −0.36, −0.16, −0.12 and −0.18 eV, respectively, and our AIMD result shows that Na32C56 is not thermally stable (Fig. S5f†). It implies the maximum stoichiometric ratio is NaC2. Our AIMD result shows that Na28C56 is thermally stable (Fig. S6†), and the corresponding theoretical maximum specific capacity of 1115.78 mA h g−1, which is much higher than those of 2D anode materials such as graphite (237 mA h g−1),40,41 phosphene (433 mA h g−1),42 Ti3C2 (352 mA h g−1),43 phagraphene (557.87 mA h g−1)44 and net-C18 (403 mA h g−1).45 To further assess the performance of the anode for the stretchable SIBs, the mechanochemical approach was employed to check their specific capacities under biaxial strains, as shown in Fig. S7a–d.† At a compressive strain of 0.5–2%, rC14 undergoes a reversible phase transition while maintaining a capacity of approximately 1115 mA h g−1. Moreover, after the metal ions are removed, rC14 fully recovers to its original configuration (Fig. S7e†). This indicates that small compressive strains retain the high capacity of the anode.
To understand the microscale mechanism of the adsorption in-depth, we calculated the charge density differences of most stable adsorption structures at various Na concentrations. The electrons mainly accumulated primarily around the C atoms, and the Na atoms lost a significant portion of their electrons (Fig. S8†), which demonstrates that the charges are transferred from metal atoms to the rC14 monolayer. Bader charge population analysis shows that at low Na concentrations (Na4C56), the average electron loss for each Na atom is 0.90 e, indicating that Na atoms are near-complete ionization. While at high concentrations ((Na28C56)), the average electron transfer per Na atom decreases to 0.51e. Furthermore, electron localization function (ELF) results provide further insight. At lower ionic concentrations (x = 2), only a sparse electron cloud surrounds the Na atoms (ELF values close to 0), indicating the highly delocalized electron density and the formation of strong ionic bonds with neighboring carbon atoms. With the adsorption of two layers of Na atoms on both sides of rC14, the electron-deficient region at the center of rC14 gradually decreases. Partial ionization of Na atoms occurs, while others contribute to delocalized electron density, which accumulates between Na ions to neutralize the repulsion among the Na+ cations and stabilize the adsorbed layer. For the maximum capacity of Na atom adsorption (Fig. S9e†), the electron cloud mainly filled the interstices between the two Na layers, implying the formation of conductive channels that facilitate efficient electron transfer.
To assess the kinetics of the transport of Na ions, we further investigated the charge/discharge rate, which is one of the key indicators for rechargeable batteries and depends on the electronic conductivity and diffusion barrier. The charging/discharging rate is affected by the electronic properties of anodes. To better understand the electronic properties of rC14 with Na ion loading, the density of states (DOS) of the most stable configurations is computed (Fig. 4). With the loading of Na ions, the electron states of the Na atom gradually near the Fermi level, and the total DOS shifts towards the low energy level. Projected density of states (PDOS) shows that there is a clear overlap between the Na s orbital and the carbon p orbital at the Fermi level, indicating significant s-p hybridization and strong interactions between Na atoms and the rC14 monolayer. In addition, the rC14 monolayer retains its metallic character with outstanding electronic conductivity during the Na insertion and extraction processes, which is essential for fast charge/discharge kinetics.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Density of states for the rC14 monolayer with Na atom adsorption. The Fermi level was set as 0 eV and indicated by the black vertical dashed lines. |
Next, the mobility of Na atoms on the rC14 monolayer was performed by the climbing-image nudged elastic band (CI-NEB) method. We first investigated the diffusion of one of the metal ions on the rC14 monolayer by considering three possible migration pathways from one energetically favorable H1 site to another along different directions (Fig. S4b†). From Fig. S4c,† the diffusion energy barrier of Path1 is 4.55 eV, indicating that Na-ions are not likely to diffuse along this route. In contrast, both Path2 and Path3 exhibit a migration barrier of 0.51 eV (Fig. S4d and e†), making these pathways more feasible for ion migration. To further understand Na-ion diffusion at low concentrations, we studied the diffusion behavior of Na-ions by adopting a “particle (atom) pair diffusion” model.35 We selected three possible diffusion pathways between the two most stable adsorption sites (H2 sites), which were found in the atom pair adsorption model, marked as Path1, Path2 and Path3 in Fig. 5a. The diffusion energy barrier profiles for these pathways were calculated (Fig. 5b). The corresponding diffusion barriers are 0.31, 0.54 and 0.22 eV for Paths1–3, respectively, which are much lower than that the mobility of single Na atoms. The migration barriers of Na atoms in rC14 are smaller than those observed for the commercial graphite anode (∼0.6 eV).41,46,47 The low-energy migration barrier of Na diffusion indicates its potential for achieving high charge–discharge rates as an anode material.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) The three possible migration paths and (b) the migration barrier of low concentration Na atom diffusion on rC14. |
Finally, the average open-circuit voltage (OCV) was computed by using the following equation:
OCV = (EM + xENa − EM+Na)/xe | (1) |
ΔGH = ΔEH + ΔEZPE + TΔSH | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) The computed free energy profiles for the HER. (b) The p-band center (εp) of the active C sites of rC14. |
To further understand the origin of the enhanced catalytic activity, we performed the charge density and Bader charge population analysis. The electrons are redistributed on the surface of the 2D rC14 monolayer, compared to graphene (Fig. S10†). Although rC14 is entirely composed of carbon atoms, subtle charge transfers occur among the different carbon sites. For example, the net charges are approximately −0.04|e| for the C1 atom and +0.13 |e| for the C2 atom, with similar variations observed for the other carbon atoms. The coexistence of unpaired electrons and empty states is believed to be beneficial for the HER. Additionally, the DOS of various C sites in rC14 is presented in Fig. S11.† The projected DOS reveals that pz orbitals of the carbon atoms play a decisive role in the formation of C–H bonds, as evidenced by the significant overlap with the s orbital of hydrogen. To elucidate the remarkable difference between the adsorption strength of the H* species on different C atoms, we explored the electronic properties of the p-orbital in the C sites based on the amendatory p band-center (εp) model proposed by Wang's group.56–58 Our results (Fig. 6b) indicate that the positions of εp of C1 (−3.71 eV) and C2 (−3.48 eV) are closer to the Fermi level than those of other carbon atoms, implying that C1 and C2 atoms can interact more strongly with reaction intermediates compared to other C atoms of rC14. This strong interaction further supports the role of these sites as the primary active centers for the HER on the rC14 monolayer.
In fact, graphene is not perfectly flat, and the adsorption on the flat surface leads to deformation and an associated increase in energy. However, if the flat surface is properly curved, this energy penalty can be mitigated, thereby enhancing the catalytic activity. To systematically investigate the effect of strain on the HER performance, we applied a series of small external biaxial compressive strains ranging from 0.5% to 2% with intervals of 0.5%. One can see that compression strains would regulate the Gibbs free energy and thus affect the performance of the HER (Fig. 7a). Under 1% and 2% strains of the rC14 system, the C1 and C3 sites exhibit considerable catalytic activity for the HER, and the ΔGH* values are −0.049 and 0.053 eV, respectively. These values are close to the optimal HER catalyst (ΔGH* = 0 eV) and are even lower than those of the well-established Pt(111) surface (−0.09 eV)59 and non-noble metal-based catalysts anchored on GDY.60,61 Although there is no clear trend in the curvature effect on the C–H bond distance, probably due to out-of-plane deformation induced by hydrogen adsorption, the overall adsorption ability increases with increasing rC14 curvature. This observation suggests that the curvature, introduced by strain, can effectively influence the adsorption of reaction intermediates (Table S2†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) The HER free energy of the active C sites of rC14 with compression ratios of 0 to 2%. (b) The relation between ICOHP and HER free energy. |
Furthermore, we analyzed the bonding relationship between the C site of rC14 under strain and adsorbed H* by implementing COHP, as shown in Fig. 7b. The curvature has a significant impact on the bonding strength between C atoms and H atoms. In COHP analysis, a more negative integrated COHP (ICOHP) value corresponds to a stronger bonding interaction. The bonding strength between the active C atoms and H increase with the increase of curvature. For the originally active C1 and C2 atoms, applying a slight strain (0.5–1%) yields an optimal balance interaction between C and H atoms, resulting in adsorption that is neither too strong nor too weak and thus enhances the catalyst activity. However, if the strain is increased further, the adsorption becomes too strong, which hinders the desorption of the hydrogen atom. In summary, the excellent catalytic performance of the C1 and C2 sites can be attributed to the moderate ICOHP values achieved under compressive strains of 1% and 0.5%, respectively. For the less active C3, C4, and C5 atoms, increasing the strain enhances the adsorption interaction between carbon and hydrogen, thereby tuning their HER activity. Notably, for the C3 and C5 atoms, applying strains of 2% and 1.5% results in ΔGH* values of 0.054 and 0.115 eV, respectively, values close to the ideal near-zero condition for optimal HER performance.
To further elucidate the origin of the enhanced catalytic activity in strained rC14, we analyzed the PDOS for rC14 under biaxial compressive strains ranging from 0.5% to 2% (Fig. 8a). The total DOS around the Fermi level (−2 to 5 eV) is primarily contributed by electrons of pz orbitals. With increasing strain, a noticeable downward shift of the Fermi level is observed. Additionally, small but noticeable changes near the Fermi level caused by the out of plane deformation are evident (Fig. 8b). For a compression strain of 0.5%, the total DOS closely resembles that of the flat rC14, indicating that slight out-of-plane deformation has a minimal impact on the electron states around the Fermi level. In contrast, for strains exceeding 1% (where the deformation is more pronounced), the electron states near the Fermi level decrease with increasing deformation. At 1% strain, the electronic state at the Fermi level falls between the values observed at lower and higher strains. Therefore, one could conclude that slight out-of-plane deformation induced by compressive strain regulates the electron states near the Fermi level in rC14 and changes its chemical activity. This modulation may enhance the adsorption and dissociation of hydrogen molecules, thereby improving the overall catalytic performance of rC14 for the hydrogen evolution reaction.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) Calculated electronic density of rC14 at compression ratios of 0 to 2%. (b) The total DOS around the Fermi level. |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ta00955c |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |