Ruiqi
Zhao
a,
Xushuai
Chen
a,
Xi
Chen
*a,
Panpan
Zhang
a,
Chunjia
Luo
a,
Pengfei
Zhang
*b,
Min
Chao
a and
Luke
Yan
*a
aSchool of Materials Science & Engineering, Chang'an University, Xi'an, 710064, China. E-mail: yanlk_79@hotmail.com
bSchool of Textile Science and Engineering, Xi'an Polytechnic University, Xi'an, 710048, China. E-mail: fengyunjian1981@126.com
First published on 16th January 2025
Solar-driven interfacial evaporation (SDIE) is an eco-friendly and sustainable technology for desalinating water. Hydrogel-based composite evaporators are effective in resisting salt, but often suffer from reduced shape stability and diminished water transport capability during dehydration and rehydration cycles, which undermines their long-term performance in photo-evaporators. Here, we developed a long-term stable MXene-carrageenan/polyacrylamide (MXene-CA/PAAm) hydrogel evaporator. This device integrates an MXene film for efficient photothermal conversion with a double-crosslinked, high-strength, deformation-resistant, self-healing hydrogel for water supply. A dehydration/rehydration cycling test was developed to evaluate the shape stability and water absorption capacity of hydrogel-based evaporators. The MXene-CA/PAAm hydrogel evaporator operated continuously for 360 hours without performance decrease, achieving an average evaporation rate of 1.78 kg m2 h−1 under 1 sun illumination. This study presents a novel approach to creating double-network hydrogel evaporators, enhancing stability and durability, and advancing desalination technology.
Titanium carbide (Ti3C2Tx, T = –F, –O, and –OH), a two-dimensional (2D) MXene material, has attracted considerable attention due to its extensive light absorption, excellent photothermal effect, and hydrophilic two-dimensional lamellar-structure facilitating water molecule transport.14–19 With a photothermal conversion efficiency as high as 99%, MXene membranes demonstrate potential as photothermal conversion materials for solar desalination.20 Hydrogels are functional soft materials characterized by a three-dimensional network structure formed by chemical covalent bonds or physical forces between polymer chains.21–24 Traditional polymer hydrogels, however, are brittle due to their pure elastic behaviour (lacking energy dissipation mechanisms) and heterogeneous network structures.25 To enhance the mechanical properties of hydrogels, researchers have proposed various synthesis methods such as amphiphilic polymer hydrogels,26,27 polymer microsphere composite hydrogels,28 nanocomposite hydrogels,29 and double network (DN) hydrogels.30
In recent years, DN hydrogels have attracted attention for their unique network structures and excellent mechanical strength and toughness.31–33 Indriyati et al. introduces an approach using a hydrogel film based on poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) integrated with carbon dots (CDs) to leverage their photothermal effect, which demonstrates remarkable stability, maintaining consistent evaporation rates over several cycles, thus indicating its long-term durability and potential for reuse.34 Zhang et al. synthesized ferric tannate (TA–Fe3+)/sodium alginate (SA–Fe3+)/polyacrylamide (TFSFP) hydrogels and constructed a solar water evaporator (SWE). Along with a ion cross-linked SA–Fe3+ network, a porous hydrogel with a hydrophilic water transportation network maintained continuous water supply to an evaporation interface.35 Although hydrogel-based composite evaporators are effective for SDIE, they often crack and bend during dehydration and rehydration cycles, compromising long-term stability. Moreover, their shape retention and water transport efficiency during photothermal evaporation have yet to be thoroughly investigated.36
Here, we report a MXene-carrageenan/polyacrylamide hydrogel (MXene-CA/PAAm) solar-driven interface evaporator for desalination, employing MXene membranes as the photothermal layer and carrageenan/polyacrylamide (CA/PAAm) double-network (DN) hydrogels with self-healing as the water supply layer. The Ti3C2Tx photothermal layer achieves 99% photothermal conversion efficiency, guaranteeing efficient water evaporation. The DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel demonstrates exceptional deformation resilience, crack resistance, and self-healing capabilities, enabling sustained photothermal evaporation. It features strong mechanical properties, with a tensile strain of 718% and compressive strength of 478 kPa, while maintaining its shape and water transport capacity after 10 dehydration/rehydration cycles. The MXene-CA/PAAm hydrogel (MCPH) evaporator demonstrated continuous operation for 360 hours without bending or cracking, achieving an average evaporation rate of 1.78 kg m−2 h−1 under 1 sun illumination, sustaining high steam generation rates even after prolonged simulated seawater desalination. This work focuses on the structural integrity and water transport stability of hydrogel-based photothermal evaporators, providing a durable and reliable solution for solar-driven interfacial desalination.
The contact angles of the hydrogel and MXene film were determined using a contact angle measuring device (JC2000D1, Powereach). A rotational rheometer (DHR, TA Instruments, USA) was employed to record the storage modulus (G′) and loss modulus (G′′) to evaluate the viscoelasticity of the DN hydrogel. The mechanical properties of the hydrogel were characterized using an electronic universal testing machine (T-30, CAFMAN) equipped with a 100 N load sensor, conducted at room temperature.
Evaporation rate (v, kg m−2 h−1) and solar conversion efficiency (η, %) are calculated by eqn (1) and (2) respectively.
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Preparation of the MXene CA/PAAm double-network hydrogel evaporator for stable and efficient photothermal desalination. | ||
The two-dimensional layered structure of the MXene film allows for the unimpeded entry of sunlight, which is then reflected multiple times between the MXene nanosheets.37 This results in the effective absorption of a broad spectrum of sunlight.46 Furthermore, the PVDF insulation layer impedes the transfer of heat to the substrate, thereby reducing heat loss. As demonstrated by UV-vis-NIR diffuse reflectance spectroscopy, MXene membranes exhibit a solar energy absorption efficiency exceeding 94% within the wavelength range of 250 to 2500 nm (Fig. 1f). The infrared image (Fig. S3†) shows that the MXene membrane temperature increased from 28.4 °C to 49.1 °C after 30 min of one-sun exposure, demonstrating efficient light absorption.47
Fig. 2b illustrates the FTIR spectra of SN-CA, SN-PAAm and DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels. The peaks of the SN-CA hydrogel are located at 3411, 2921, 1069, and 1647 cm−1, attributed to the stretching vibrations of O–H, C–H, C–O and –COO– stretching vibrations, respectively. The symmetric stretching vibration of the O–H group of CA at 3411 cm−1 was observed in the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel, yet no new peaks emerged, indicating that hydrogen bonding was established between the O–H group of the SN-CA chain and the N–H group of the SN-PAAm chain. The FTIR results substantiate the formation of an interpenetrating double network comprising CA and PAAm. The surface elemental composition and chemical bonding states of the hydrogels were evaluated by XPS. As illustrated in Fig. 2c, the XPS spectrum exhibited distinctive peaks for C 1s, N 1s, O 1s, and K 2p3/2. The intensity of the peaks around 290 eV is greater in DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels than in SN-CA and SN-PAAm hydrogels, which provides preliminary evidence of the successful synthesis. In addition, the oxygen-containing groups promote the water-absorption of the hydrogels (Fig. S6†).
Fig. 2d shows the Raman spectra of the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel, with peaks at 3215–3316 cm−1 and 3417–3520 cm−1 corresponding to strong (FW) and weak (IW) hydrogen bonds, respectively (Fig. S7a and b†).48 The degree of DN-CA/PAAm hydrogen bonding in hydrogel samples can be quantified by measuring the peak intensity ratio of I3230/I3420. The reduction in I3230/I3420 in DN hydrogels relative to SN-PAAm hydrogels indicates that DN-CA/PAAm may disrupt the robust hydrogen bonds between water molecules. It can be postulated that the hydration of K+ may promote the conversion of free water to bound water, thus counteracting the freezing effect.48 The increase in I3230/I3420 in DN hydrogels in comparison to SN-CA hydrogels indicates that the incorporation of PAAm may augment the quantity of IW within the hydrogels, thereby providing a greater supply of activated water for evaporation. Consequently, the effective water delivery network of the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel can reliably meet the evaporated bulk water delivery.
Additionally, the water contact angle (WCA) of the DN hydrogel was 10.2°, while that of the MXene membrane was 75.1° (Fig. 2e). The smaller WCA indicates that the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel exhibits excellent hydrophilic properties. Given that the WCA of the top MXene photothermal layer was larger than that of the bottom DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel, and considering the porous structure of the hydrogel (Fig. 2a), the CPDH evaporator was able to efficiently direct the water flow from the bulk water stream to the evaporator surface. Furthermore, the saturated water content of the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel was evaluated (Fig. 2f), which demonstrated a notable capacity for water absorption in simulated seawater relative to the SN hydrogels (Fig. S7c and d†). Consequently, the MCPH evaporator for simulated seawater desalination exhibits the capacity to absorb water rapidly, which facilitates efficient photothermal evaporation and ensures timely water replenishment.
The DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels display remarkable deformability, tensile strength, and mechanical resilience, attributable to their soft and elastic double-network.49 A comparison of the stress–strain curves of hydrogels with different monomer ratios revealed that the hydrogel with CA/PAAm mass ratio of 1
:
8 exhibited the highest tensile and compressive strengths, which align with the requirements of a high-strength hydrogel evaporator (Fig. S8†). Accordingly, the 1
:
8 mass ratio hydrogel was selected for the photothermal evaporation experiment. The stress–strain curves of DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels in the tensile state are illustrated in Fig. 3a. The stress and strain at break for the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel were 132.6 kPa and 718.4%, respectively, whereas those for SN-CA hydrogels were 5.1 kPa and 16.4%, and for SN-PAAm hydrogels were 8.0 kPa and 270.5%. The mechanical properties of DN hydrogels showed a significant improvement over the single network hydrogels. Fig. 3b shows that the stress of the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel reached 478.04 kPa at 80.31% strain, which is four times higher than that of the SN-CA hydrogel and 9.6 times higher than that of the SN-PAAm hydrogel.
Rheological analysis of the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel (Fig. 3c) shows that the storage modulus (G′) exceeds the loss modulus (G′′) at ambient temperature. G′ remains consistently higher than G′′ across the entire frequency range, indicating dominant elasticity over viscosity and suggesting substantial cross-linking within the system. The higher G′ values correlate with stronger mechanical properties, which result from the synergistic interaction between the two networks.50
The self-healing ability of DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels was investigated. As shown in Fig. 3d, the gel strips were cut into five segments and pressed end-to-end for 12 hours, and then the gels showed self-healing behavior. The healed DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels were able to withstand a load of 50 g (Fig. 3e). Fig. 3f shows the tensile strength increased with healing time, reaching a maximum at 30 minutes. After this point, further healing led to increased gel deformation, but no significant increase in strength. These results highlight the excellent self-healing properties of DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels.41
Hydrogels are commonly used as water transport layers in photothermal evaporators, where they absorb and transport water while resisting salinity.37 However, repeated cycles of water absorption and loss can lead to physical degradation and reduced water transport capacity, ultimately causing evaporator failure.21 We designed a dehydration–rehydration cycling test to assess the shape retention and water transport efficiency of hydrogel-based evaporators. The hydrogels were dried at 60 °C for 12 hours, then immersed in water for 12 hours to swell (Fig. 4a). This dehydration/rehydration cycle was repeated multiple times.
Fig. 4b shows that the SN-CA hydrogel deformed after one cycle, and the SN-PAAm hydrogel deformed after three cycles and failed to recover its shape. In contrast, the DN hydrogel withstood three cycles without significant deformation or cracking, demonstrating superior stability. After three cycles, the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel retained 82% of its initial mass, indicating sustained water absorption and transport (Fig. 4c). In comparison, the mass of SN-CA and SN-PAAm hydrogels decreased to 72% and 45%, respectively, reflecting a significant loss in water absorption capacity. In order to visualize the change of the water content of the hydrogels, we define a new concept called relative water content, which is obtained by normalizing the water content (Fig. S9†). The relative water content of SN-CA and SN-PAAm hydrogels decreased to 56% and 44%, respectively, while the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel maintained 80% of its original water content (Fig. 4d). Similar results were observed in simulated seawater (Fig. S10†), where SN hydrogels failed after three cycles, whereas DN-CA/PAAm hydrogels preserved both structure and water content.
We extended the dehydration/rehydration tests to 10 cycles for the DN-CA/PAAm hydrogel. Notably, after 10 cycles, the hydrogel maintained its shape and retained 66% of its water absorption capacity, demonstrating exceptional structural stability and water absorption ability (Fig. 4e and S11†), even in both DI water and simulated seawater, highlighting its potential for practical applications.
The MCPH evaporator can facilitate long-term, continuous desalination of simulated seawater, exhibiting consistent evaporation performance across varying salinity levels (0–20 wt%). Fig. 5b and c illustrate the time-dependent mass and evaporation rates of the MCPH evaporator in salt solutions of varying concentrations over a 60 min period under 1 sun. The evaporation rate of the MCPH evaporator was as high as 1.81 kg m−2 h−1 in deionized water, 1.76 kg m−2 h−1 in simulated seawater (3.5 wt%), and not less than 1.25 kg m−2 h−1 in highly concentrated salt solutions (10–20 wt%), and photothermal evaporation efficiency of up to 91.2% under 1 sun. Compared to the MCH and MPH evaporators, the MCPH showed a significantly higher evaporation rate during the course of the experiment (Fig. 5d).
The MCPH evaporator demonstrated effective evaporation in simulated seawater (3.5 wt%) under varying light intensities (Fig. 5e and f). The evaporation rates were 2.20 kg m−2 h−1 and 2.70 kg m−2 h−1 under 2 and 3 suns, respectively, with corresponding photothermal conversion efficiencies of 72.3% and 79.7%. Moreover, the light-to-heat evaporation efficiency of the MCPH evaporator in 3.5 wt% saltwater is superior to some of the previous studies (Table S1†).
To evaluate the stability of the MCPH evaporator during continuous evaporation, hydrogel evaporators were subjected to 360 hour photothermal tests (Fig. 6 and S15†). As shown in Fig. 6a, the MPH evaporator underwent significant deformation, leading to a reduction in the light-absorbing surface area, while the MCH and MCPH evaporators maintained their structural integrity. Images taken at 72 hour intervals provide clear visual evidence of the sustained functionality and stability of the MCH and MCPH evaporators throughout the test. To quantify the results, we tracked changes in the curving angle of the evaporator to assess gel deformation (Fig. S16†), and monitored changes in mass to evaluate the gel layer's water absorption capacity. As illustrated in Fig. 6b, the MPH evaporator exhibits the poorest structural stability. Furthermore, the mass of the MPH evaporator increases with the duration of the evaporation process, which may be attributed to salt clogging (Fig. S17†). Fig. 6c demonstrates that the MCPH evaporator exhibited long-term stability, with an average evaporation rate of 1.78 kg m−2 h−1, outperforming both the MPH and MCH evaporators. The MPH evaporator suffered from structural bending, which reduced photothermal efficiency. To further assess stability, the SN-CA hydrogels were immersed in 60 °C water for 120 min, with no mass loss observed (Fig. S18†).
Additional seven-day evaporation tests were performed using the MCPH evaporator in seawater from the Bohai Sea. Fig. 7a shows that the average evaporation rate from the MCPH evaporator was 1.53 kg m−2 h−1 under 1 sun (1000 W) for 8 hours per day. Fig. 7b illustrates the outdoor evaporation system. Furthermore, 10 hour outdoor evaporation experiments under natural sunlight were conducted (Fig. 7c), and the average evaporation rate was up to 0.88 kg m−2 h−1. Under real sunlight, the photothermal evaporation rate is lower than under simulated sunlight in the laboratory, due to the difference in light angle and the temperature of surroundings. These results highlight the continuous photothermal performance and robust mechanical properties of the MCPH evaporator, demonstrating its potential for sustained desalination over extended periods.
The MCPH evaporator demonstrates exceptional desalination performance in the Bohai Sea seawater, with Na+ concentration reduced by four orders of magnitude, well below the World Health Organization's drinking water standard (Fig. 7d). Additionally, concentrations of K+, Ca2+, and Mg2+ were also reduced by four orders of magnitude after photothermal evaporation. These results indicate that the MCPH evaporator effectively desalts ions of seawater, meeting drinking water quality standards.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ta08803d |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |