Open Access Article
Rowan L.
Pilkington
a,
Rosa
Kössler
b,
Jesse
Molloy
a,
Stefan
Bräse
b and
Daniel L.
Priebbenow
*a
aMedicinal Chemistry Theme, Monash Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Monash University, Parkville, VIC 3052, Australia. E-mail: daniel.priebbenow@monash.edu
bInstitute of Biological and Chemical Systems (IBCS-FMS), Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Kaiserstraße 12, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany
First published on 8th October 2025
Siloxycarbene intermediates induced via the visible light irradiation of acylsilanes undergo highly efficient benzoin-type click reactions with pyruvate derivatives. This process requires no reagents other than visible light, proceeds with high efficiency and is tolerant of a wide range of functional groups. Pyruvate esters, thioesters, amides, nitriles and phosphonates were all identified as suitable electrophiles including those tethered to complex drug or biomolecule scaffolds. The visible-light induced carbon–carbon bond forming process was scalable using both batch and flow methodologies, accompanied by diversification studies on the corresponding addition products. Mechanistic insights into siloxycarbene reactivity were also obtained by DFT analysis.
ThDP-dependent enzymes typically comprise three key structural domains: the N-terminal aminopyrimidine pocket which binds the pyrimidine ring of ThDP, a central domain containing a thiazolium ring and the C-terminal diphosphate pocket.1a An exemplar enzymatic mechanism is outlined in Fig. 1, in which the catalytically active ThDP-carbene (or its ylide resonance form generated via deprotonation at C2 of the thiazolium ring) undergoes nucleophilic addition to the α-carbonyl motif of a pyruvic acid derivative.1a,2 Following nucleophilic addition, a tetrahedral intermediate is formed that upon extrusion of carbon dioxide forms an ‘activated aldehyde’ or enamine (a Breslow-type intermediate).2 This enamine can react as a nucleophile with a secondary acceptor molecule, such as an aldehyde, to generate a carboligation product (Fig. 1).2
A number of ThDP-dependent enzymes have been successfully employed as biocatalysts in asymmetric synthesis.1b,2a,3 Furthermore, N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) catalysts that resemble the thiazolium ylide involved in ThDP enzymatic and related biological processes have become a cornerstone of (asymmetric) organocatalysis.4 This class of highly stabilised singlet nucleophilic carbenes catalyse a diversity of synthetic transformations including the benzoin reaction between aldehydes, ketones and α-ketoester (pyruvate) derivatives.5
Acylsilanes are of increasing utility in synthesis.6 Siloxycarbenes—another class of singlet nucleophilic carbene—can be readily generated from acylsilanes via a 1,2-Brook rearrangement initiated by direct photochemical irradiation or triplet–triplet energy transfer photocatalysis.7 Siloxycarbenes are known to react in transformations including [2 + 1]-cycloadditions,8 1,4-conjugate addition,9 and X–H insertion.7c,10 Siloxycarbenes can also be engaged as nucleophiles in 1,2-carbonyl addition processes (benzoin-type reactions) with carbonyl-derived electrophiles including aldehydes,7d,11 carbon dioxide,12 fluorinated ketones,13 amides,14 and esters.15
Inspired by the carbene promoted reactivity of ThDP-dependent enzymes with α-keto acids, we hypothesised that α-keto esters (pyruvate derivatives) should be sufficiently electrophilic to react with visible-light induced nucleophilic siloxycarbenes. Given that such carbene intermediates can be readily generated using only visible-light irradiation (negating the requirement for photocatalysts and additives), we strategised the development of a novel bioinspired photoinduced click reaction between acylsilanes and pyruvate derivatives enabling the rapid formation of a new carbon–carbon bond with perfect atom economy. The realisation of this strategy is described herein.
| Entry | Deviation from standard conditions | Yield 3a (%) |
|---|---|---|
| a Conducted on 0.1 mmol scale using 1.5 equivalents of 2a Light source is 2 × 40 W 427 nm LEDs. Yields determined by 1H NMR analysis of the reaction mixture relative to an internal standard. Brackets refers to isolated yield. | ||
| 1 | None | 99% (99%) |
| 2 | PhMe | 96% |
| 3 | MTBE | 25% |
| 4 | EtOAc | 15% |
| 5 | DCM | 63% |
| 6 | DCE | 73% |
| 7 | MeCN | 15% |
| 8 | 4A MS | 84% |
| 9 | Under air | 30% |
| 10 | In darkness | 0% |
With optimised conditions in hand, we explored the scope of substrates amenable to this reaction. Initially, diversity in the silyl group on the acylsilane was investigated, with the triethylsilyl and trimethylsilyl derivatives affording quantitative yields of the siloxyketones 3a and 3b in only 1–2-hour reaction time with ethyl pyruvate. The tert-butyldimethylsilyl and dimethylphenylsilyl analogues also performed well to afford 3c and 3d however the inclusion of the bulkier triisopropylsilyl and triphenylsilyl groups led to significantly reduced yields of the α-siloxyketone adducts 3e and 3f, respectively.
Benzoylsilanes containing various aryl substitution patterns were next explored, with the reaction highly tolerant of neutral, electron-donating, and electron-withdrawing substituents to afford a series of α-siloxyketone adducts (3g–v) containing a range of halide, ether, and ester residues. Notably, functional groups such as alkenes were unreactive towards the singlet siloxycarbene. Heterocyclic siloxyketones 3w and 3x were also readily accessible via reaction of the corresponding furanoyl and thiophenoyl silanes.
Alkenyl- and alkyl-substituted acylsilanes also reacted cleanly with ethyl pyruvate to afford the α-siloxyketone adducts 3y–3ab. For the latter examples, the poor absorption profiles of alkyl acylsilanes in the visible light range necessitated the inclusion of 0.5 mol% Ir(dFCF3ppy)2dtbbpy·PF6 as a triplet–triplet energy transfer photosensitiser (with 12-hour reaction times) to obtain the insertion products. Notably, the reaction was also amenable to preparative multigram scales (10.0 mmol) in batch, affording 2.77 g of 3g (94%) with a slightly longer reaction time (3 hours) and without the need for chromatographic purification.
After demonstrating that aryl, alkenyl and alkyl acylsilanes reacted rapidly with ethyl pyruvate, we next explored variation within the pyruvate substrate. Whilst aryl pyruvates failed to react, a range of alkyl pyruvate derivatives bearing alkyl-derived ketones or different ester groups reacted rapidly and cleanly (with reaction times ranging from 5 minutes to 2 hours) to afford a range of α-siloxyketones (Scheme 2). Toluene, or mixtures of cyclohexane and toluene were used as the reaction solvent in some cases where the pyruvate was sparingly soluble in cyclohexane.
Various alkyl pyruvates with cyclic, linear and branched alkyl chains were well tolerated (4a–e), including one example containing an α-bromo ketone (4d) which reacted extremely rapidly (5 min). In the case of phenethyl-substituted compound 4e, desilylation was conducted using 1 M HCl to expedite chromatographic separation from the unreacted pyruvate starting material. A cyclic, sterically hindered α-keto lactone also engaged the siloxycarbene to provide the expected product 4f in high yield.
Trifluoromethyl pyruvate, an excellent electrophile, reacted very quickly to afford 4g (99%). Variation of the ester component within the pyruvates also provided a diverse selection of the crossed benzoin-type adducts: tert-butyl (4h), benzyl (4i), allyl (4j), propargyl (4k), aryl (4t) and ethyl(trimethylsilyl) (4n) esters typically provided the products in quantitative yields, with the potential for orthogonal deprotection strategies.
Further substrates containing alkyl bromide (4l), N-Boc (4r), phthalimide (4o) and sulfonamide (4o), ketones (4p), acetal (4w), and thiophene (4q) functionalities all proved successful. Generally, all were visibly complete with reaction times <1 hour. One exception was the pyruvate substrate bearing a tethered primary carbamate, which upon reaction with excess siloxycarbene afforded the siloxyketone adduct bearing an N,O-acetal generated via N–H insertion of a second siloxycarbene intermediate (detected via1H NMR analysis). Hydrolysis of this unstable N,O-acetal under mildly acidic aqueous conditions provided a means to ultimately afford the desired mono-addition product 4v. Pyruvates derived from more synthetically mature frameworks including oxaprozin, dehydroabietic acid, cholesterol and fenofibrate also reacted well to afford siloxyketones 4x–4aa. Finally, a lithocholic acid derivative bearing two pyruvate functional groups was prepared and irradiated in the presence of 2.2 equivalents of acylsilane which afforded the bis-addition product (4ab) in exceptional yield (93%).
Attempts to achieve the diastereoselective 1,2-addition of siloxycarbenes was investigated utilising pyruvate esters derived from chiral alcohols such as hydroxyproline, menthol, and borneol. Although high yields of the desired siloxyketone products were obtained in each case (4u, 4ac, 4ad), limited diastereoselectivity was achieved. This observation is consistent with a high degree of rotation within the ester group of the chiral pyruvates which obviates chiral influence. Among the adducts, diacetone-D-glucose derived pyruvate provided the greatest diastereomeric ratio (1.4
:
1 d.r., 4ae) upon photoreaction with benzoyl(trimethyl)silane, which was further improved by employing a bulkier benzoyl(triethyl)silyl analogue and conducting the reaction at 0 °C (95%, 2
:
1 d.r., 4af). Unfortunately, the Evans' oxazolidinone derived pyruvyl imide failed to react under the standard conditions (4ag).
Having established the visible-light induced 1,2-addition of siloxycarbenes with both fluorinated ketones13 and α-ketoesters (Schemes 1 and 2) proceeds to afford a variety of α-siloxyketone derivatives, we were intrigued to explore if ketones bearing alternative electron-withdrawing groups were competent electrophiles in the photochemical 1,2-carbonyl addition transformation. To this end, the visible-light irradiation of acylsilanes in the presence of α-ketothioesters was conducted, affording the thioester-containing α-siloxyketones 5a–e in excellent yields (Scheme 3). In line with that described previously, the α-ketothioester derived from cysteine bearing a carbamate tether reacted with two siloxy carbene intermediates to afford the siloxyketone bearing an N,O-acetal generated via carbene N–H insertion, which under mild acidic conditions was hydrolysed to afford 5d as the major product. The pyruvyl thioester derived from captopril, an antihypertensive bioactive, also provided the drug-containing conjugate 5e in good yield. The reaction of α-ketoamides with acylsilanes was also realised (5f, 5g), albeit in reduced yields and requiring longer reaction times due to the reduced electrophilicity of these reactants. Pyruvonitrile and acylphosphonate also reacted cleanly to afford 5h and 5i, in 99% and 64% yield respectively. Finally, the tricarbonyl compound diethyl 2-oxomalonate reacted in only 15 min to afford siloxyketone 5j in an excellent yield of 95%. 2,2,2-Trichloroacetophenone was an unreactive electrophile under the standard conditions and 5k was not detected. 1,2-Diketones, such as 1,2-diacetyl, afforded a complex mixture of products presumably due to competing photodecomposition of this electrophile.
Photochemical reactions with large volumes suffer from attenuated light penetration through solution according to the Beer–Lambert Law, leading to sluggish conversion rates and altered product profiles. In order to effectively scale photochemical reactions, flow chemical processing is often employed. The miniaturised reactor dimensions in a flow chemical reactor effectively nullify light attenuation allowing for more efficient irradiation of the reaction mixture and enabling consistent scale-up using a scale-out approach.16 The novel reaction described herein was thus adapted to flow photochemistry conditions (Fig. 2a) by passaging a solution of the reagents through a transparent 1.0 mL glass chip reactor irradiated by a 427 nm (40 W) LED lamp. The reaction was conducted on 3.0 mmol scale, requiring 8 minutes residence time to produce over 800 mg of the product 3g isolated in excellent yield and purity after concentrating the mixture without chromatographic purification. The space-time-yield (STY) for this process was determined to be 0.10 g min−1 mL−1.
With a quantity of α-siloxyketone 3g in hand, derivatisation was conducted to further demonstrate the synthetic utility of the adducts (Fig. 2b). The ketone group was selectively reduced in the presence of NaBH4 to afford geminal diol 7, while the use of LiAlH4 afforded triol 8 by global reduction. α-Siloxyketone 3g was reactive towards methylphosphonium ylide in a Wittig reaction to provide styryl derivative 9 in exceptional yield. These systems proceeded with concomitant hydrolysis of the siloxy substituent, a reaction which can be otherwise achieved using 1 M HCl to generate the α-hydroxyketone (6) in nearly quantitative yield. When α-siloxyketone was treated with trimethylsulfonium ylide, the homologated compound 10 was the major product. Attempts to hydrolyse the ethyl ester of 3g under basic conditions afforded benzoic acid quantitatively, presumably following a retro-benzoin type fragmentation (see SI for details). Finally, condensation with hydrazine or hydroxylamine afforded in high yield heterocycles 11 and 12, respectively.
The free energy profile of the siloxycarbene insertion was interrogated using Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods (Fig. 2c). The photoinduced formation of siloxycarbenes proposedly proceeds via 1,2-Brook rearrangement from the acylsilane triplet excited state, from which the initially formed triplet carbene (T0) equilibrates via inter-system crossing (ISC) to the singlet siloxycarbene (S0). The carbene stabilisation energy (CSE) for this process, which is exergonic, reflects the predominantly singlet character of siloxycarbenes owing to the stabilising effect of the non-bonding electrons on the adjacent oxygen atom on the vacant 2p orbital at the carbene centre.17 The singlet siloxycarbene thus is significantly nucleophilic and is predisposed to undergo 1,2-addition to ethyl pyruvate viaTS1, approaching the carbonyl group at the Bürgi–Dunitz angle (107°) to form zwitterionic intermediate INT1. This species may traverse a ring-closure, ring-opening mechanism via epoxide INT2,18 or otherwise undergo an energetically spontaneous 1,4-silyl transfer (TS3) to the oxyanion to ultimately form the final silicon-trapped α-siloxyketone (PROD).
It is likely that INT1 is destabilised in non-polar solvent such as cyclohexane, leading rapidly to barrier-less silicon transfer viaTS3.19 Overall the process is calculated to be highly exergonic (−72.1 kcal mol−1) from the singlet siloxycarbene which is congruent with the experimentally observed exceptional reaction efficiency and rapid rate of this visible-light induced protocol. 1,2-Dicarbonyl compounds such as ethyl pyruvate are known to possess low lying triplet energies as well as associated photochemistry.20 Comparison of the calculated triplet energies of the benzoylsilane 1g and ethyl pyruvate 2a suggest that relaxation of the triplet excited state acylsilane by energy transfer to ethyl pyruvate, which would hinder reactivity and lead to photodecomposition of the pyruvate, is disallowed due to the higher triplet energy of the pyruvate. Furthermore, as evidenced by UV-Vis analysis in Fig. 2d-i, direct photodecomposition of ethyl pyruvate is avoided due to its limited absorbance in the visible light region. Of the reactants, only benzoylsilane absorbs visible light (427 nm) energy, whilst pyruvate and the insertion product absorb at wavelengths beyond the visible light spectrum (<400 nm). These spectral differences readily enable the reaction to be tracked visually, or by ex situ UV-Vis analysis (Fig. 2d-ii), in which the characteristic yellow absorption profile of the benzoylsilane (1gλmax ∼ 420 nm) is extinguished over time and the absorbance of 3g develops in the UV-region (3gλmax ∼ 327 nm).
In 2001, Sharpless and co-workers introduced click chemistry as a concept for the modular and rapid synthesis of functional molecules.21 Typically, a set of efficiency criteria must be met for a transformation to be considered a click reaction. For example, the reaction should: (i) be easy to perform and applicable to a diversity of substrates; (ii) be rapid, high yielding, and selective; (iii) generate minimal waste (with any by-products readily removable); and (iv) be carried out under ambient conditions in non-hazardous solvents or neat.22 Many photochemical reactions readily satisfy these criteria, inspiring the development of visible light induced click chemistry reactions, termed photo-click chemistry.23 To date, a number of photo-click chemistry strategies have been developed including the visible-light induced azirine–alkene cycloaddition,24 thiol sulfoxonium ylide reaction,25 acyl fluoride exchange,26 Diels–Alder cycloadditions,27 and the N–H insertion of siloxycarbenes with indole scaffolds.28
To this end, the properties of the novel visible light induced reaction described herein align strongly with that required for a (photo)click reaction: operationally simple, rapid, requires visible-light irradiation, proceeds with 100% atom economy (no-byproducts) and is highly modular.23c Given this set of desirable properties, the application of this visible light induced process as a photo-click reaction beyond chemical synthesis (e.g. in both bioconjugation and materials science applications) is currently under investigation, with the outcomes to be reported in due course.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |