Open Access Article
Elsammani Ali Shokralla
a,
Arslan Ashfaq
*b,
Ubaid Ur Rehman
c,
Hind Albalawid,
Zahra Bayhan
d,
Sarah A. Alsalhid,
Shoug M. Alghamdie and
M. Musa Saad H.-E.
f
aDepartment of Physics, Faculty of Science, Al-Baha University, Alaqiq, 65779-7738, Saudi Arabia
bDepartment of Physics, Emerson University Multan, Multan 60000, Pakistan. E-mail: arslan.ashfaq201@gmail.com; arslan.ashfaq@eum.edu.pk
cSchool of Physics, State Key Laboratory of Crystal Materials, Shandong University, Jinan, Shandong 250100, China
dDepartment of Physics, College of Sciences, Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University (PNU), P. O. Box 84428, Riyadh 11671, Saudi Arabia
eDepartment of Physics, College of Science, Taibah University, Yanbu Governorate, Saudi Arabia
fDepartment of Physics, College of Science, Qassim University, Buridah, 51452, Saudi Arabia
First published on 21st October 2025
In this work, a ZnO:Al/ZnO/ZnS/BaZrSe3/Au heterojunction solar cell was numerically investigated using SCAPS-1D to optimize its structural and electronic parameters for high photovoltaic performance. The effects of absorber thickness (50 nm–6.0 μm), buffer layer thickness (10–100 nm), doping densities, defect states, operating temperature, and back metal contacts were systematically studied. The results revealed that increasing the BaZrSe3 absorber thickness enhanced the short-circuit current density (Jsc) due to improved light absorption, with an optimum thickness of 2.0 μm balancing carrier generation and recombination. The ZnS buffer layer exhibited optimum performance at 20 nm, ensuring efficient charge transfer without increasing resistive losses. The acceptor doping concentration in BaZrSe3 strongly influenced the device properties, with NA = 1018 cm−3 yielding the maximum PCE of 22.77%. Similarly, an optimized donor doping density of 1019 cm−3 in the buffer enhanced carrier extraction. Defect density analysis showed that PCE remained stable up to NT = 1014 cm−3, beyond which recombination dominated, reducing efficiency. Temperature-dependent simulations indicated a decline in PCE from 22.92% at 300 K to 17.87% at 360 K due to enhanced carrier recombination. Finally, the choice of back contact significantly affected performance, with a high work-function metal (5.9 eV) achieving superior results, including PCE = 29.46%, Voc = 0.7528 V, Jsc = 46.38 mA cm−2, and FF = 84.37%. These results highlight the promising potential of BaZrSe3 as a lead free absorber material for next-generation thin film solar cells, where optimization of thickness, doping, and contact engineering play a crucial role in maximizing device efficiency.
Solar technology has developed over time, with each generation introducing distinct challenges and materials. The first generation primarily utilized monocrystalline and multicrystalline silicon (m-Si) architectures. Although silicon-based devices dominated the commercial market, their wider adoption was hampered by high production costs.3 To address these issues, the second generation of cells arose, using thin film technologies derived from materials such as CdTe, CIGS, and amorphous silicon.4,5 These advances aimed to reduce production costs and increase performance, but also created new technological challenges. Despite these hurdles, solar cell research took a new turn, opening the path for the 3rd generation. This generation includes breakthroughs such as organic–inorganic hybrid halide structures, which are prized for their high efficiency, low production costs, and good opto-electronic properties, become the promising candidates for photovoltaic applications. Despite reaching an impressive PCE of 26.10% according to the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) records, their widespread adoption remains limited due to the uncertainty of organic components and concerns over Pb toxicity.6 Lead is a highly toxic element, with its use strictly regulated or banned in many nation states due to its injurious effects on environment and human health.7 The risk increases when lead volatilizes at high temperatures during procedures like sintering and calcination, releasing harmful pollutants into the atmosphere.8 This pollution was led to lead poisoning, causing symptoms such as muscle pain, fatigue, and abdominal discomfort, while posing serious risks to brain and neurological development. As a result, there is a significant effort to create naturally stable, Pb-free materials, including chalcogenide perovskites, as safer, sustainable alternatives.9
The perovskite structure is ABX3, with A is cations with consisting of group II, B is the transition metals consisting of group IV, and X referring to chalcogen anions. These materials are highly promising due to their eco friendly and non toxic properties.10,11 These compounds possess a distorted perovskite framework and exhibit semiconducting properties, with band gaps spanning from 0.3 to 2.3 eV. They possess direct energy bandgaps and maximum absorption spectrum, similar to conventional opto-electronic semiconductors such as GaAs. Furthermore, hafnium (Hf) and zirconium (Zr) compounds exhibit significant band dispersion, indicating high carrier mobility.12 These qualities make them ideal for photovoltaic, like as the SrZrS3, BaZrS3, and BaZrSe3, all of which have bandgaps suitable for solar applications.2
BaZrS3 is unique among chalcogenide perovskites, attracting great research interest because to its exceptional eco-friendly stability, lead free composition, superior absorption, and impressive carrier movement. The absorption co-efficient (α) is higher than that of several standard solar cell absorbers, showing considerable potential for effective photo-generated charge carrier collection. According to research, the ideal bandgap for single junction solar cells is approximately 1.35 eV. However, BaZrS3 typically has a bandgap of 1.70 to 1.90 eV, which is slightly higher than the optimum range. To address this challenge, scientists have shifted their attention to BaZrSe3, which features energy band gap range from 1.0–1.45 eV closer to the ideal range for efficient solar cell performance. Ong et al.'s calculations revealed especially lower band-gap of 1.10 eV for BaZrSe3 highlighting its potential as an effective material for solar cell light absorption.13
In the field of chalcogenide perovskite, extensive research has focused on unraveling the intricate relationships between the various layers of the cell. The performance and reliability of chalcogenide PSCs heavily rely on the seamless integration of these layers, as each plays a crucial role in influencing the device overall functionality and performance. Improving device stability and performance hinges on the heterostructure interface between the absorber layer and the ETL, which plays a vital role in ensuring efficient charge transport and minimizing energy losses.14,15
ZnS emerges as a promising candidate for the buffer layer due to its exceptional properties, making it an attractive option for chalcogenide heterojunction. With its excellent transparency in the high electron mobility, maximum visible range, and wide energy band gap of around 3.68 eV, and robust thermal and electro-chemical stable, ZnS proves to be a highly suitable choice for buffer layer. Its cost-effectiveness, combined with advantageous opto-electronic properties, further highlights ZnS suitability for this critical role.16
In the current work, SCAPS-1D numerical software using to investigate the potential of absorber layer BaZrSe3 in the heterojunction ZnO:Al/ZnO/ZnS/BaZrSe3/Au structure. This study seeks to improve the understanding of selenium-based heterojunction optimization by thoroughly adjusting key parameters like thickness, acceptor and donor doping density, defect density and temperature. The reduction of charge carrier recombination with defect density concentration were also optimized. The study purposes to offer valuable insights to address challenges related to efficiency and stability in heterojunction technology.
A key advantage of SCAPS-1D lies in its user-friendly interface and robust defect modeling framework, which allows researchers to examine the influence of numerous intrinsic and extrinsic parameters. This versatility makes it particularly suitable for studying advanced chalcogenide-based heterojunction devices aimed at sustainable energy applications. The software was simulated essential processes such as band alignment, charge generation, recombination mechanisms, and defect distributions, thereby providing a comprehensive picture of device physics. Furthermore, it numerically solves Poisson's equation together with the electron and hole continuity equations, enabling precise evaluation of critical photovoltaic parameters.
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
The physical constraints are expressed as follows: e is the elementary charge, Ψ denotes the electrostatic potential, ε0 and εr is the vacuum and relative permittivity, respectively. The carrier concentrations are given by n (electrons) and p (holes), while their spatial charge densities are described as ρn and ρp. The terms Jn and Jp indicate the current densities associated with electrons and holes, respectively. Furthermore, R refers to the recombination rate, and G designates the carrier generation rate.
In this configuration, Fig. 1 presents (a) the solar cell structure ZnO:Al/ZnO/ZnS/BaZrSe3/Au (b) the corresponding energy band diagram of the structure. ZnO:Al is employed as the front contact, while ZnO is served as the window layer, which ensuring high optical transmission with maximum protection of the devices. The ZnS layer functions as the buffer, acting as n-type material with high electron mobility. It minimizes interfacial charge accumulation and facilitates charge transport, thereby improving overall device performance. The BaZrSe3 layer is utilized as the primary light absorber, and gold (Au) is applied as the back electrode to complete the cell structure.
The simulation process was initiated using the input parameters summarized in Table 1. These parameters were carefully chosen on the base of previous reports to guarantee accuracy and reliability. For consistency and direct comparability, all numerical simulations were carried out at a fixed room temperature under standard AM 1.5G illumination, corresponding to a light intensity of 1000 W m−2.
| Properties | BaZrSe3 | ZnS | ZnO | ZnO:Al |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thickness (nm) | 1200 | 20 | 50 | 200 |
| Eg (eV) | 1.01 | 3.68 | 3.3 | 3.3 |
| NC (cm−3) | 2.2 ×1018 | 1.5 ×1018 | 4.1 ×1018 | 4.1 ×1018 |
| Nv (cm−3) | 1.8 × 1019 | 1.8 × 1019 | 8.2 × 1018 | 8.2 × 1018 |
| χ (eV) | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4.55 | 4.53 |
| ε (eV) | 4.19 | 8.32 | 8.0 | 8.0 |
| NA (cm−3) | 1016 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| ND (cm−3) | 0 | 1018 | 1010 | 1010 |
| NT (cm−3) | 1014 | 1014 | 1014 | 1014 |
| μp (cm2 V−1 s−1) | 113 | 25 | 20 | 20 |
| μh (cm2 V−1 s−1) | 58 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| References | 18 | 19 | 19 | 19 |
Fig. 1(c) presents the quantum efficiency (QE), while Fig. 1(d) illustrates the current density–voltage (J–V) characteristics of the initial and proposed device structures. For the initial configuration, the simulated performance parameters were obtained as: open-circuit voltage (Voc) = 0.5568 V, short-circuit current density (Jsc) = 43.81 mA cm−2, fill factor (FF) = 79.77%, and power conversion efficiency (PCE) = 19.46%.
Fig. 2(a and b) demonstrates how variations in the BaZrSe3 thickness affect the photovoltaic properties of the ZnO:Al/ZnO/ZnS/BaZrSe3/Au heterostructure. Increasing the perovskite thickness from 50 nm to 6.0 μm leads to a steady enhancement in key performance indicators, including Jsc, Voc, FF, and PCE. At lower thicknesses, the rapid improvement in performance is primarily associated with stronger photon absorption region and more effective carrier generation.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Effect of BaZrSe3 absorber thickness on heterojunction performance (a) Jsc & Voc (b) FF & PCE . | ||
The open-circuit voltage (Voc) rises quickly with thickness up to ∼1000 nm, stabilizing around 0.55 V thereafter. This behavior indicates that charge extraction improves initially as recombination losses are minimized, but beyond this point Voc saturates since the gain in photogenerated carriers is counterbalanced by increased recombination within the bulk of the absorber. This trend was described using the diode model equations,20
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
The Jsc also exhibits a thickness-dependent trend. At very thin layers (50–200 nm), incomplete absorption of longer-wavelength photons reduces carrier generation, keeping Jsc relatively low. The enhance of the thickness are caused to more photons absorber, resulting in higher carrier generation and improved Jsc values. However, once the absorber becomes thicker than the effective diffusion length, carrier recombination increases, causing Jsc to saturate rather than increase indefinitely. This explains why performance growth is more substantial below ∼1.5 μm but less pronounced at higher thicknesses.
The overall device efficiency (PCE) follows a similar pattern: low efficiency at minimal thickness due to poor absorption, significant enhancement at moderate thicknesses owing to balanced light absorption and carrier collection, and eventual saturation at larger thicknesses due to recombination and resistive losses.21 The FF also improves with absorber thickness as recombination at the junction is suppressed, but its growth rate diminishes once the device reaches optimal thickness.
Although simulations show continued improvement up to 6.0 μm, such high thicknesses are not practical in experimental fabrication because of excessive material consumption, long deposition times, and challenges in maintaining high crystallinity. Additionally, carriers generated deep inside a very thick absorber often fail to reach the junction, reducing their contribution to the photocurrent. Considering these trade-offs, a moderate BaZrSe3 thickness of ∼2.0 μm is identified as the most suitable value. This thickness ensures efficient optical absorption, minimizes recombination, and balances device performance with realistic fabrication constraints.
Fig. 3(a and b) shows the effect of ZnS buffer layer thickness on the photovoltaic performance of the device. The thickness of the ZnS layer was varying from 10 nm to 100 nm. It was observed that increasing the buffer thickness from 10 nm to 20 nm leads to noticeable improvements in Voc, Jsc, FF, and PCE. Beyond 20 nm, however, the device performance remains nearly constant, indicating that further increases in ZnS thickness do not provide additional benefits.
The improvement at 20 nm was attributed to the effective role of ZnS in reducing interface recombination between the ZnO window and the BaZrSe3 absorber. At 10 nm, the coverage of the buffer layer is insufficient to fully passivate interface defects, which results in increased carrier recombination and lower performance. By increasing the thickness to 20 nm, the ZnS layer becomes continuous and uniform, effectively blocking recombination pathways and facilitating improved carrier separation. This results in higher Jsc due to better charge collection, as well as improved Voc and FF.
Once the ZnS thickness exceeds 20 nm, the parameters saturate because the layer has already reached its optimal passivation effect. Additional thickness only introduces unnecessary series resistance and does not enhance light absorption, since ZnS is a wide bandgap material (3.68 eV) that does not contribute to photocurrent generation. As a result, PCE does not increase further for thicker ZnS layers.
Based on these observations, a ZnS thickness of 20 nm was selected as the optimum value. This thickness provides sufficient interface passivation and stability while avoiding excess material usage and resistive losses.
As the NA increases, the depletion region becomes narrower, and the built-in potential rises, which improves charge separation and reduces recombination. At NA = 1 × 1018 cm−3, the device reaches a Voc of 0.6304 V and an optimized Jsc of 43.05 mA cm−2. Although Jsc decreases slightly due to the reduced depletion width and higher recombination at elevated doping levels, the gain in Voc and FF compensates for this reduction. The maximum power conversion efficiency (PCE = 22.77%) and FF (82.54%) are obtained at this doping concentration.
This behavior reflects the trade-off between photocurrent and photovoltage as governed by doping density. Lower NA favors current generation but suppresses voltage due to insufficient barrier height, while higher NA strengthens the junction, boosting Voc and FF at the expense of some current. The optimum doping level of 1 × 1018 cm−3 ensures a balanced performance, yielding the highest efficiency by maintaining reasonable Jsc while maximizing Voc and FF. Therefore, NA = 1 × 1018 cm−3 was selected as the optimal doping concentration for the BaZrSe3 absorber in this device structure.
At lower donor concentrations, the ZnS buffer exhibits limited conductivity, which restricts electron transport and increases series resistance, thereby reducing overall device performance. As ND increases, the electrical conductivity of the buffer layer improves, minimizing resistive losses and enhancing carrier collection across the heterojunction. This results in better current extraction, higher Voc, and improved FF.
However, excessively high donor doping was introducing drawbacks such as increased interface recombination, tunneling effects, or potential band misalignment at the ZnS/BaZrSe3 interface. To balance these factors, an optimized doping density of 1 × 1019 cm−3 was selected. At this concentration, the device benefits from reduced resistive losses and efficient carrier transport, while avoiding the detrimental effects that may arise at extremely high doping levels.
Therefore, ND = 1 × 1019 cm−3 for the ZnS buffer is identified as the optimal choice, providing a stable efficiency of ∼22.79% with reliable device operation.
Beyond NT = 1 × 1014 cm−3, all performance parameters begin to decline. The reduction in Voc is linked to enhanced non-radiative recombination at defect sites, which lowers the quasi-Fermi level splitting.22 Similarly, Jsc decreases as more photogenerated carriers are captured by traps before reaching the electrodes. The FF also deteriorates due to increased recombination currents and reduced carrier collection performance. Collectively, these effects result in a marked drop in PCE at higher NT values. This behavior is consistent with the Shockley–Read–Hall (SRH) recombination mechanism, where the recombination rate increases in proportion to defect density.23 At high NT, trap-assisted recombination becomes dominant, shortening carrier lifetimes and diffusion lengths, which suppresses both current output and voltage.
Thus, maintaining a low defect density (≤1 × 1014 cm−3) in the BaZrSe3 absorber is crucial for achieving high device efficiency. Strategies such as post-deposition annealing, interface passivation, and improved material crystallinity are therefore essential to minimize NT and preserve photovoltaic performance.
The combined effect of these mechanisms explains the observed sharp drop in both PCE and FF with rising operating temperature. Thus, BaZrSe3 devices exhibit optimum performance near room temperature, while elevated operating conditions accelerate recombination and resistive losses, limiting efficiency.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 Impact of varying back metal contacts on device characteristics of the heterojunction solar cell. | ||
This enhancement was attributed to the improved energy-level alignment between the BaZrSe3 absorber and the high work function back contact. A higher work function metal reduces the Schottky barrier height at the interface, ensuring better hole collection while minimizing carrier recombination at the back surface.25 Moreover, the formation of an ohmic-like contact enhances charge transport efficiency, leading to higher FF and Voc.
Conversely, low work function contacts create unfavorable band bending, which result in barrier formation, charge accumulation, and higher recombination losses. Thus, the observed improvement at 5.9 eV demonstrates that a proper selection of back contact material is essential for maximizing device efficiency.
The improvement in Jsc is primarily attributed to the enhanced absorption within the BaZrSe3 absorber layer and optimized charge carrier transport at the ZnS buffer/absorber interface. By tailoring the thickness, doping density, and defect concentration, the absorber is able to generate a higher density of photogenerated carriers, while also minimizing recombination losses.26 The increased carrier lifetime and reduced series resistance facilitate more effective charge extraction, leading to a measurable rise in photocurrent density.
The notable increase in Voc from 0.5568 V to 0.7528 V was explained by the improved band alignment and reduction in interface recombination. A higher acceptor concentration in the absorber, together with the optimized donor density in the buffer, establishes a stronger built-in electric field across the junction. This enhances charge separation and suppresses carrier recombination at defect states, thereby allowing a larger splitting of quasi-Fermi levels, which manifests as a higher Voc.
The FF improvement, from 79.77% to 84.37%, arises due to the reduction of resistive losses and suppression of recombination at both the front and back contacts. The introduction of a back contact material with a higher work function (5.9 eV) ensures a favorable ohmic contact with the p-type absorber, which minimizes barrier formation and enhances carrier extraction efficiency. Together, these factors lead to a more ideal diode behavior, reflected in the higher FF.
The PCE enhancement, from 19.46% to 29.46%, results from the cumulative effect of increased Jsc, Voc, and FF. Importantly, the QE spectrum demonstrates stronger absorption and carrier collection across the solar spectrum, which confirms that the optimized device structure effectively utilizes incident photons and mitigates recombination losses.
Overall, the combined improvements in absorber thickness, doping densities, defect management, buffer optimization, and contact engineering contribute synergistically to the superior performance of the final device. This highlights the critical role of interface engineering and defect passivation in realizing high-efficiency BaZrSe3-based solar cells.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |