Qirui Sunab,
Zhongyi Liab,
Jiaqi Yeab,
Yuqi Zhaid,
Xin Ye*ab,
Liqun Zhang*c and
Yongpeng Wang
*d
aState Key Laboratory of Organic–Inorganic Composites, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing, 100029, PR China. E-mail: yexin@buct.edu.cn
bEngineering Research Center of Elastomer Materials on Energy Conservation and Resources, Ministry of Education, Beijing, 100029, PR China
cState Key Laboratory of Fluorine and Nitrogen Chemicals, School of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Xi’ an Jiaotong University, Xi’ an, Shanxi 710049, PR China. E-mail: zhanglq@buct.edu.cn
dCollege of Materials Science and Engineering, Jilin University of Chemical Technology, Jilin, 132022, PR China. E-mail: wyp4889@163.com
First published on 5th September 2025
To contribute to the circular and sustainable economy framework, waste tire rubber reclamation by extracting carbon black through pyrolysis and heat treatment and then ingeniously designing it as an electromagnetic wave absorbing (EWA) material is proposed herein. The results showed that the pyrolysis-recycled carbon black (RCB) was heterogeneous with multiple interfaces, making it suitable for EWA application. The RCB was processed at 500 °C–1000 °C to study the changes in the composite and microstructure as well as the EWA properties. The heterointerfaces, defects and components changed with the pyrolytic temperature, which helped to adjust the conductive loss, polarization loss, impedance matching, and electromagnetic wave (EW) transmission path, thereby obtaining different EWA performances. As a result, RCB500 exhibited a minimum reflection loss (RLmin) of −35.99 dB at a thickness of 2.5 mm with a low filler loading of 40 wt%. Its widest effective absorption bandwidth (EAB) can reach 3.98 GHz at a low thickness of 1.5 mm. For RCB800, the RLmin value can reach −34.47 dB, and the EABmax value can reach 4.14 GHz at a low thickness of only 1.5 mm with a filler loading of only 30 wt%. The absorption mechanism was deeply studied. The results indicated that the carbon black pyrolysed from waste tire rubber with strong, wideband electromagnetic wave absorption can be considered a promising candidate for designing high-efficiency carbon-matrix EWA materials.
Nowadays, with the rapid development of microelectronic technology and instant communication, electromagnetic wave (EW) radiation has become a serious concern for human survival.13,14 Long-term exposure to high electromagnetic pollution can lead to many diseases such as dry eyes, joint pain and even intellectual development problems.15,16 Therefore, it is essential to design and develop new electromagnetic wave absorption (EWA) materials with high efficiency to protect the human body from the hazards of electromagnetic radiation. Since the 1960s, electromagnetic protection fabrics including metal wire fabrics and metal wire chemical fiber-blended fabrics have been designed.17 However, their drawbacks such as high cost, poor flexibility, unsatisfactory electromagnetic protection performance, and processing difficulties limited their development. The desired features of EWA materials include strong absorption over a broad bandwidth, low density, thinness, oxidation resistance, wear resistance, ability to withstand high temperatures and high strength.18 However, this has not been completely accomplished so far. Dielectric loss material is one of the main categories in EWA materials.19 Among various dielectric loss materials, carbonaceous materials such as carbon nanospheres,14 carbon nanotubes,18,20 carbon nanofibers,21,22 and graphenes23,24 are particularly noteworthy for their unique properties of light weight, vast surface area, low density, exceptional dielectric properties, superior conductivity, and remarkable stability.19,25 However, the single loss mechanism, impedance mismatch and narrow absorption band resulting from their single component type and simple structures have hindered their practical EWA applications. The conductivity and permittivity of carbonaceous composites can be modified by hybridization with dielectric materials, thus leading to better impedance matching.26 As a member of the carbon materials, in addition to the aforementioned advantages, RCB exhibits unique advantages for EWA applications. Unlike other materials requiring hybrid processing, RCB inherently contains mixed ash components that can further facilitate energy dissipation. This intrinsic multi-component system enables efficient EW attenuation without additional hybridization reactions, making RCB a promising candidate for EWA. RCB is a composite that contains ash components such as ZnS and SiO2. This has been verified in previous studies. Interestingly, the components were all able to enhance the EWA properties. Although SiO2 is an excellent wave-transparent material, it is a desirable candidate for adjusting the EM parameters and improving impedance matching.27 Yue et al.28 developed a network-like structure formed by silicon-coated carbon nanotubes via a sol–gel process, which showed a minimum reflection loss (RLmin) of −54.1 dB at 14 GHz with a low loading rate of 10 wt% and a low absorber thickness of 1.08 mm, covering an effective absorption bandwidth (EAB) of 2.08 GHz. Their results indicated that the impedance mismatch decreased gradually with the increase in SiO2 content. Multiple relaxation loss conditions were also generated by the introduction of SiO2. Zhicheng Wang et al.29 used SiO2 fillers as a means to mitigate the shrinkage of SiOC ceramics during pyrolysis and to match the impedance matching properties to enhance their EWA capabilities. Finally, the SiOC/SiO2 ceramics achieved an RLmin value of −28.10 dB with a thickness of 1.90 mm, and the widest EAB was 6.38 GHz at a thickness of 2.30 mm. ZnS is a typical type of transition metal sulphide that has been demonstrated to have good responses to EW, which leads to unique EWA properties. It has been applied in the field of EWA in recent years. Yunfei Yang30 et al. prepared ZnS/NiS/C composites, which exhibited RLmin values of −51.45 dB at 4.72 GHz and −56.69 dB at 11.12 GHz. The EAB reached 3.68 GHz at 1.16 mm. The optimal impedance matching and dissipation capability were obtained by adjusting the ratios of NiS and ZnS, in which ZnS played an important role. Jiawei Ding31 et al. fabricated vertical hollow ZnS nanoarrays on a carbon cloth substrate. The composites achieved an RLmin value of −52.5 dB and an EAB of 5.1 GHz when the thickness was only 1.9 mm. The excellent EWA performance was due to the unique hollow ZnS nanoarray structure, which enhanced the interface polarization, multiple reflections, and properties of metamaterials with resonant absorption. Therefore, as RCB is a hybrid material that contains ash, it could have an effective EWA capacity. Moreover, the interfaces between carbon and the ash component can generate additional interface polarization and multi-stage scattering, further enhancing the dissipation ability. It is worth to study the varying graphitization degrees, interfaces and components of the RCB with temperature and their effect on EWA capacity. However, this is rarely reported in the literature.
In this work, recycled carbon black obtained from waste tires were used for the first time as an EWA material. The RCB has the characteristic of extremely low cost, which was conducive to large-scale production. It also provided a green way for a reasonable utilization of waste tires. Different from traditional carbon black, the RCB is a hybrid carbon material without any post-treatment. The RCB has an analogous double-layered structure, with ash dots and crystalline carbon attached on the CB sphere. The structural change in ash with temperature is also studied because it has some influences on the EWA properties. Meanwhile, the extensive interfaces were generated by the hybrid structure, which may lead to the occurrence of interface polarization, charge polarization, and associated relaxation losses in the incident wave, thereby exerting an effect on EWA performance further. The relationship between the change in RCB structure or morphology caused by different temperature treatments and EWA performance was the focus of our research. The results indicated that the RCB series had an outstanding EWA ability.
CaCO3 = CaO + CO2 |
2CaO + C = 2Ca + CO2 |
3Ca + N2 = Ca3N2 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 XRD, TGA, FTIR and Raman spectroscopy results: (a) XRD patterns, (b) TGA curve of RCB, (c) FTIR spectra and (d) Raman spectra of RCB, RCB500, RCB600, RCB800, and RCB1000. |
Due to the changes in composition, the EWA properties of the products may differ.
The thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) curve of RCB from room temperature to 800 °C was obtained to further support the analysis of the XRD pattern. The results are shown in Fig. 2b. There were three stages of weight loss. The first weight loss (0.84%) occurred from room temperature to approximately 125 °C due to the dehydration of the starting material. Previously, the RCB raw material had been treated at 430 °C for a while at the factory to prepare for sale. The results indicated that RCB easily adsorbed water vapour from the air, and this water was held physically in the pores.32 The second stage at 125 °C–600 °C was mainly caused by the escape of volatiles from the carbonized substances and the partial rearrangement of amorphous carbon structures. Although the product had been treated at 430 °C in the factory, this was not sufficient to thoroughly eliminate the volatiles because of the very short retention time. In the range of 600 °C to 800 °C, a third weight loss (2.43%) occurred. It has been reported33 that obvious decomposition of calcium carbonate in N2 occurred above 600 °C and this decomposition intensified at 700 °C. Thus, this weight loss corresponded to the decomposition of CaCO3. The results demonstrated that in the products treated below 600 °C, CaCO3 was present, whereas above 600 °C, CaCO3 had decomposed. This result was in accordance with the XRD analysis.
A Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometer was employed to further confirm the identities of the products. Fig. 2c demonstrates that the five samples exhibited similar spectra with only a few slight differences. The peak at 1450 cm−1, which corresponded to the C–O stretching mode of calcium carbonate,34 disappeared when the temperature was above 600 °C. The tiny band at 679 cm−1 which corresponded to CO32− (ref. 34) also disappeared. Moreover, the band at approximately 873 cm−1, which is due to the bending of C–O,35 became weak with the increasing temperature. All of the results confirmed the presence of CaCO3 in both the RCB and the low-temperature treatment products. Upon reaching a temperature above 600 °C, CaCO3 underwent decomposition. The FTIR data were in good agreement with the XRD and TGA results.
Raman spectroscopy provided a precise method for accurately examining the bonding state and defects of carbon atoms, which had a significant impact on EM parameters. Fig. 2d shows the Raman spectra of the RCB series. Two peaks corresponding to the D band at ∼1350 cm−1 and the G band at ∼1590 cm−1 can be observed. The former peak originated from the vibration modes of six-membered rings, whose activation resonance process involved peculiar electron–phonon interactions mediated by defects such as point, line, plane defects, and dangling bonds.36 The latter peak indicated the sp2 hybridized carbon atoms in graphite.37 Therefore, the value of ID/IG is always viewed as an indicator of the lattice defect density in carbon materials. As depicted in Fig. 2d, the ID/IG values increased from 0.9092 (for RCB) to 1.0411 (for RCB1000) with the increasing treatment temperature. This indicated an increase in the number of lattice defects in the different samples obtained at different temperatures. The increase in lattice defects was mainly due to the removal of the carbon atoms that were previously bound to oxygen-containing functional groups during a redox reaction process, resulting in the creation of vacancies and structural defects. The abundant defects provided more active sites for the other components in the composites, which can effectively improve their EWA performance.
In conclusion, the XRD patterns, TGA curves, FTIR spectra and Raman spectra confirmed that the treatment temperature caused a modification in the structure of the product. The samples treated at low temperatures were composed of amorphous carbon, SiO2, ZnS, and CaCO3, of which amorphous carbon and CaCO3 were not beneficial to the movement of electrons. The samples treated at higher temperatures consisted of crystallographic carbon, amorphous carbon, SiO2, ZnS, and Ca3N2, with crystallographic carbon and Ca3N2 contributing to enhanced conductivity.38 This may lead to a positive effect on conductive loss. Moreover, there are many interfaces between various compounds that can contribute to the occurrence of polarization loss. Thus, it can be speculated that in addition to the great conductive loss, the obtained products may have great polarization loss.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 SEM images of different samples: (a) RCB, (b and c) RCB500, (d and e) RCB600, (f and g) RCB800 and (h and i) RCB1000. |
Sample | Atom % | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
C | O | Si | S | Zn | Ca | N | |
RCB500 | 92.91 | 3.91 | 1.83 | 0.66 | 0.29 | 0.40 | 0 |
RCB800 | 94.08 | 2.84 | 2.29 | 0.21 | 0.11 | 0.06 | 0.41 |
The details of the microstructures were further revealed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM). The acquired images are shown in Fig. 5 and S3–S8. The large particles are indeed composed of multiple tiny particles, which is in agreement with the SEM results. Fig. S3a and S4 show the morphology of RCB and its corresponding elemental mapping images. Most of the carbon black exhibits a spherical structure with some attached particles. The particles attached to the carbon spheres are composed of Si, O, S, Ca and Zn, as indicated by the elemental mapping images. The elemental mapping results of RCB500 and RCB600 are similar to those of RCB (as illustrated in Fig. S5 and S6), demonstrating that they contain identical components. However, their morphologies are different. With the increase in treatment temperature, the carbon spheres exhibit a progressive increase in their sphericity (Fig. S3a–c), while the boundaries of the spheres become progressively more distinct. There are inevitable spaces between the spheres, which can amplify the multiple reflections and scattering of the incident EW. The HRTEM images of RCB500 are given in Fig. 5a–c. It can be seen that numerous black dots are dispersed throughout the sphere. Upon partial magnification (Fig. 5b), the distinct attachment of dots on the sphere demonstrate the inherent analogous double-layered structure that has many interfaces. The HRTEM analysis results revealed the measured lattice spacings of 0.170, 0.332 and 0.306 nm, corresponding to the ZnS (1124) (JCPDS 89-2201), SiO2 (011) (JCPDS 85-0794), CaCO3 (104) (JCPDS 47-1743) crystal planes, respectively (Fig. 5c). This demonstrates that the dots are the composition of ZnS, SiO2 and CaCO3. There are also some areas that lack lattice fringes, which are identified as amorphous carbon. In addition, a lot of defects that can destroy the lattice's periodicity39 are presented in the image. They are composed of point defects, lattice dislocations, discontinuous lattice fringes and lattice distortion. These defects can act as polarization centers to assist in creating dipole polarization,40 which increases dielectric loss. Meanwhile, the combination of defects, the interface phase, and different substances can form multiple heterogeneous interfaces. This results in enhanced interfacial polarization and multiple EW reflections, which improves the EWA capacity of RCB. After treatment at higher temperatures, the components changed. In addition to the initial elements C, Si, O, S, Ca and Zn, the presence of N was detected (Fig. S7). Fig. 5d–f show the HRTEM images of RCB800, in which the ordered lattice fringes can be observed. The interplanar spacings are 0.169, 0.337, 0.286, and 0.240 nm, respectively, corresponding to the ZnS (1124) (JCPDS 89-2201), SiO2 (011) (JCPDS 85-0794), Ca3N2 (601) (JCPDS 21-0153), and Chaoite C (205) (JCPDS 22-1069) crystal planes. The results verified the XRD analysis that new Ca3N2 and crystallographic chaoite C are generated at high temperatures. Introducing them enhances dielectric loss through both the material composition and the additional interfaces they create. The areas that lack lattice fringes are caused by amorphous carbon. In addition, defects with a higher density can be observed due to further pyrolysis. The result coincided with the Raman analysis. The elemental mapping images of RCB1000 are shown in Fig. S8, which display similar elemental mapping results as RCB800. The more defects and the more interfaces would further improve the EWA capacity of RCB.
![]() | (1) |
Zin = Z0Zrtan![]() | (2) |
Zr = Z/Z0 = 1/(εr/μr)1/2 | (3) |
The results are shown in Fig. 7. It is obvious that RCB-40%, RCB500-30%, RCB500-40%, RCB500-50%, RCB600-30%, RCB600-40%, RCB800-30%, RCB800-40%, and RCB1000-30% have effective absorption. When the filler loading was only 30 wt%, the absorption intensity initially increased followed by a subsequent reduction as the treatment temperature increased. The RCB800-30% exhibited the highest absorption intensity and the widest EAB. When the filler loading was 40 wt%, RCB500-40% had the best EWA performance from the perspective of intensity and the EAB. Interestingly, all of the samples exhibited a decreasing trend when the filler loading continuously increased, especially for RCB1000. This could be attributed to the increased conductivity, resulting in an impedance mismatch. Therefore, RCB500, RCB800 and RCB1000 were chosen as representative samples for further study to clearly determine the mechanism of EWA performance, especially for the impact of varying treatment temperatures.
According to the transmission line theory, EM parameters, which are composed of the complex permittivity (εr = ε′ − jε′′) and complex permeability (μr = μ′ − jμ′′), are closely related to EWA properties.42 To explore the impact of modifications in morphology and structure on EWA properties and determine the absorption mechanisms, it is necessary to examine variations in EM parameters. Based on the aforementioned structural analysis, it was found that no magnetic compounds were present in the samples. Thus, the magnetic loss could be ignored. Accordingly, it was crucial to thoroughly investigate the real permittivity (ε′), imaginary permittivity (ε′′), and dielectric loss tangent (tanδε). Among the three parameters, ε′ represents the capacity of the material to store electrical energy or the degree of response to the EM field, and ε′′ represents the ability of the material to lose electrical energy.43 The EM values of RCB-500, RCB-800 and RCB-1000 with different sample loadings were measured over a frequency range of 2–18 GHz. Fig. 8 shows the curves of ε′, ε′′, and tanδε with respect to frequency for different samples.
As shown in Fig. 8a and d, when the filler loading was 30%, RCB800 exhibited the highest average ε′ (11.30) and ε′′ (4.53) values, followed by RCB1000 (10.80 and 3.70) and RCB500 (10.38 and 3.17). Remarkably, RCB800 had the lowest ε′ and ε′′ values below 10.1 GHz, whereas beyond 10.1 GHz, the ε′ and ε′′ values were the highest. This is related to the polarization loss, which is mainly derived from dipole polarization and interfacial polarization in the gigahertz frequency range.31 Therefore, dipole polarization occurs at lower frequencies, while interfacial polarization occurs at higher frequencies.44 Amorphous carbon tends to provide many defects as polarization centres, which leads to the generation of dipole polarization.45,46 XRD analysis reveals that the carbon phase in RCB500 is mainly amorphous, whereas in RCB800 and RCB1000, the carbon phase consists of chaoite and amorphous carbon. The crystallization of carbon is conducive to the ordering of the carbon black atomic structure, which may decrease the number of defects. Therefore, the ε′ and ε′′ values of RCB500 were initially greater than those of RCB800. However, the atomic arrangement at the interfaces between the crystalline phase and the amorphous phase is disordered. Insufficient atoms exist at the interfaces to form a complete lattice sequence and complete valence bonds, resulting in the presence of suspended bonds. When the temperature increased to 1000 °C, the presence of chaoite phase of carbon became more pronounced, meaning that there were more interfaces between the crystalline and the amorphous phases. Consequently, the number of suspended bonds increased, resulting in a higher number of defects being generated from suspended bonds. Moreover, the TGA curve revealed that the weight ratio consistently decreased as the temperature increased, indicating the occurrence of a redox reaction. The redox reaction that occurred resulted in the removal of a large number of oxygen-containing functional groups, leaving some vacancies at the same position on the carbon. Defect dipoles are generated by the unbalanced charge around the vacancies.47 As the temperature increases, the number of defects also increases, which has been proved by Raman and TEM analysis. As a result, RCB1000 exhibited the greatest ε′ and ε′′ values at lower frequencies. Above 10.1 GHz, interfacial polarization was the predominant factor. The SEM images show that the porosity was the highest when the temperature was 800 °C, which means that most of the interfaces and surfaces were affected, thereby leading to the significant interface polarization. The ε′ and ε′′ curves of RCB800 fluctuate many times in the high-frequency band, indicating the occurrence of significant polarization loss during the attenuation of incident EW.48 The components in the high-temperature-treated products may lead to significant polarization loss. Although SiO2 is transparent to EW,29 it is a desirable candidate for adjusting the EM parameters.27 The heterogeneous interfaces (between SiO2 and ZnS and between SiO2 and carbon) greatly promote interface polarization. ZnS and carbon have been reported to respond well to EW, which may lead to unique EWA properties. The combination of ZnS and carbon resulted in a closely integrated heterogeneous interface, resulting in powerful interface polarization. In addition, the high-temperature-treated carbon and the produced Ca3N2 helped to enhance the conductivity, which may have contributed to the loss of conductivity. Notably, as shown in Fig. 8g, RCB800 had a greater average tanδε than that of the other two samples, indicating a greater dielectric loss capability. Although the ε′, ε′′ and tan δε values of RCB500, RCB800 and RCB1000 had some differences, the difference was very small.
Significant differences are evident in Fig. 8b, c, e, f, h, and i when the loading ratio was 40 wt% and 50 wt%. It is obvious that all of the values follow to the order of RCB500 < RCB800 < RCB1000. This is attributed to the improvement in the electrical conductivity of the materials with the increase in temperature, as shown in Fig. 6. With the increase in temperature, partial oxygen-containing functional groups were removed from the RCB series spheres due to the redox reaction. The electrically conductive paths for hopping electrons can be reconstructed.36 Hopping electrons can jump across defects or between RCB series spheres, which greatly enhances the dielectric loss. In addition, this phenomenon can be attributed to the enhanced interfacial polarization and dipole polarization, both of which can enhance the dielectric loss capability of the samples.49,50 The results indicate that a high treatment temperature can effectively enhance the dielectric loss capability of the sample.
The reflection loss (RL) values of the composites were calculated using eqn (1)–(3) to evaluate the EWA properties. The results are shown in Fig. 9 and 10. The highlighted parts indicate the regions that are efficient in absorbing. The RCB500 samples, with varying t mass ratios and thicknesses in the range of 1.5–5.5 mm, all exhibited effective absorption. Specifically, when the filler loading was 40%, the minimum RL value (RLmin) reached −35.99 dB with an effective absorption bandwidth (EAB) of 2.48 GHz at a thickness of 2.5 mm. The widest EAB can reach 3.98 GHz at a thickness of 1.5 mm. Unexpectedly, the RCB800 sample showed efficient absorption only at filler loadings of 30% and 40%. Among these, the sample with 30% filler loading exhibited an RLmin value of −34.47 dB with an EAB value of 4.14 GHz at a thickness of only 1.5 mm. Effective absorption was observed in the 40% filler loading sample only when the thickness was 1.0 mm, with an RLmin value of −12.91 dB and an EAB value of 2.09 GHz. When the filler loading was 50%, no effective absorption was observed. The same trend can be observed for RCB1000. Only when the filler loading was 30%, there was effective absorption. RLmin can reach up to −38.78 dB with an EAB value of 1.43 GHz at a thickness of 4.5 mm. The widest EAB value can reach 3.38 GHz at a thickness of 1.5 mm. Nevertheless, with filler loadings of 40% and 50%, there was no discernible absorption. This phenomenon can be attributed to the rapid increase in electrical conductivity with the increase in temperature for the sample. Conversely, because of the higher filler loading, a connected structure was more readily formed to increase the conductivity. Both of these factors can have a negative effect on impedance matching, which may decrease the EWA properties. To meet the requirements of wide, thin and strong absorption performance, it is necessary to minimize the value of RLmin and maximize the width of EAB, and the thickness should be as thin as possible. Thus, RCB800 exhibited more pronounced advantages.
It has been reported that two pivotal factors, energy attenuation and impedance matching, should be considered when designing superior absorbing materials.51 First, the attenuation factor α was studied using the following equation to determine the degree of attenuation:
![]() | (4) |
The relationship between α and frequency is shown in Fig. S6. It is obvious that the high-temperature-treated products had higher attenuation constant values within the test frequencies. The order was RCB1000-50% > RCB800-50% > RCB1000-40% > RCB800-40% > RCB800-30%. RCB500-30%, RCB500-40%, RCB500-50%, and RCB1000-30% exhibited similar attenuation constant values. The attenuation constant values, which represented the degree of EW attenuation, decreased as the filler loading and treatment temperature decreased. These findings demonstrate that increasing the temperature and loading ratio can effectively improve the attenuation ability. The high attenuation capability was determined relying on the relatively large values of ε′ and ε′′. However, it is essential to note that a high attenuation constant α does not necessarily imply a strong EWA capability.52 This is because the EWA capability also depends on impedance matching, as the EM should penetrate the absorber as much as possible.
In order to characterize the impedance matching property of different samples, the value of impedance characteristic parameter (Z) used to evaluate the penetration ratio of the EWs and the reflection of EWs at the air–absorber interface was calculated using the following equation:
![]() | (5) |
Fig. 11 illustrates the Z values of samples treated at different temperatures and filler loadings. RCB500-40%, RCB800-30%, and RCB1000-30% had Z values of 0.9660 at a thickness of 2.5 mm, 0.9639 at a thickness of 1.5 mm, and 0.9777 at a thickness of 4.5 mm, respectively. This demonstrated that the three products had good impedance matching. Therefore, EM waves can penetrate the inside of the material rather than being reflected at the material–air interface. At the other levels of filler loadings, the samples exhibited impedance mismatch, especially for RCB800-50%, RCB1000-40%, and RCB1000-50%. Their values of the impedance parameter exhibited significant deviation from 1, indicating very poor impedance matching, which indicates a higher level of reflection of the EM waves at the interface between the material and air. The impedance matching is related to the characteristics of components and the filler loading. The primary components of RCB500 were amorphous carbon, SiO2, ZnS, and CaCO3, and CaCO3 was not involved in the regulation of the dielectric constant. Therefore, the adjustment of the impedance should depend on the increase in the filler loading. For RCB800 and RCB1000, crystallographic carbon, amorphous carbon, SiO2, ZnS, and Ca3N2 were the main components, and crystallographic carbon and Ca3N2 can help to adjust the dielectric constant. Thus, only 30 wt% filler loading had good impedance matching. However, when the filler loading was continuously increased, the high conductivity resulted in inadequate impedance matching, causing a higher percentage of EW to be reflected on the surface. Hence, the composites had a high attenuation constant, α, but a low EWA capability.
The investigation shows that RCB500-40%, RCB800-30%, and RCB1000-30% exhibited excellent EWA properties, which can be attributed to their good impedance matching. Therefore, the major focus of the investigation was on RCB500-40%, RCB800-30%, and RCB1000-30%.
In order to further examine the EWA mechanism, simulation thickness-F curves were analysed. When the phase difference between the incident and reflected waves in the absorber was 180°, the reflected waves at the air-absorber interface were completely cancelled,53 and the reflection of EW on the material surface decreased. This phenomenon is called quarter-wavelength attenuation. This will occur if the thickness of the material meets the following equation at a fixed frequency:
![]() | (6) |
where fm and tm are the absorption peak frequency and the thickness of the absorber, respectively.
The results are shown in Fig. 12. It can be seen that the experimental values of all of the three samples of tm are consistent with the simulated values at 1/4 λ, when the thickness was less than or equal to 4.0 mm. However, when the thickness was greater than 4.0 mm, the experimental values deviated from the simulated values. An ideal EW absorbent should be wide, lightweight, thin and strong. Typically, for practical use, the thickness must be less than 4.0 mm. Thus, the deviation that appeared above a thickness of 4.0 mm can be disregarded. The results demonstrate that thin RCB EW absorbers can more easily achieve quarter-wavelength attenuation, hence improving the EWA property. Moreover, it can be concluded from eqn (7) that higher ε′ and ε′′ values are beneficial for achieving lightweight EW absorbers. The thickness decreased as fm, εr, and μr increased. This indicates that a high treatment temperature would result in a lightweight EW absorber.
![]() | ||
Fig. 12 RL-F curves and simulation thickness-F curves of (a) RCB500-40%, (b) RCB800-30%, and (c) RCB1000-30%. |
In order to understand the efficient EWA of the RCB series, it is necessary to investigate the mechanism of dielectric loss. According to the Debye theory, dielectric losses are mainly composed of polarization loss and conductivity loss, in which polarization loss can be categorized as interface polarization or dipolar polarization.54,55 The Cole–Cole semicircle, which was derived from the plot of ε′ versus ε′′, can be used to evaluate the dielectric loss. Based on the Debye relaxation theory, ε′ and ε′′ adhere to the following equation:
![]() | (7) |
The Cole–Cole semicircles of different samples are shown in Fig. 13. Each semicircle represents a relaxation process, and a larger radius represents a greater relaxation loss.56 RCB800-30% exhibited a more pronounced relaxation loss than that of the other two samples. This was mainly caused by the formation of an obviously more porosity structure, which has been discussed in the SEM analysis. In addition, the presence of various heterogeneous interfaces (such as SiO2–ZnS, SiO2–carbon, SiO2–Ca3N2, ZnS–carbon, ZnS–Ca3N2, and Ca3N2–carbon) greatly promoted interface polarization. These substances have different dielectric properties and conductivities. At a heterogeneous interface, accumulated charges caused by the Schottky barrier are formed. Then, they interact with the incident EW to promote dielectric loss.57 Moreover, for carbon-based composites, there are many defects and polar groups, which provide conditions for dipole polarization.58 Furthermore, the porous structure of carbon networks provides sufficient room for the accumulation of space charges. The decomposition of CaCO3 and the formation of Ca3N2 particles also provided dipole polarization of the dangling bonds around the vacancies. The above-mentioned factors work together to obtain the semicircles. RCB500 and RCB1000 exhibited similar processes. At 500 °C and 1000 °C, there were also many heterogeneous interfaces (such as SiO2–ZnS, SiO2–carbon, SiO2–CaCO3, ZnS–carbon, ZnS–CaCO3, and CaCO3–carbon for RCB500; SiO2–ZnS, SiO2–carbon, SiO2–Ca3N2, ZnS–carbon, ZnS–Ca3N2, and Ca3N2–carbon for RCB1000), as well as dipole polarization provided by carbon. Thus, all of the composites exhibited many semicircles. The multipolarization relaxations caused by heterogeneous interfaces help to enhance the EWA property. However, compared with those of RCB800, the porous structures of RCB500 and RCB1000 were not very obvious, which may have a negative effect on the interfacial polarization, thereby influencing the EWA property. Fig. 13 further demonstrates that there were linear tails in the semicircles of all the samples. The slope of the linear part always represents the degree of conductive loss of the materials. The tangent of the linear part for RCB500, RCB800 and RCB1000 was 0.59, 0.62, and 0.66, respectively, indicating that the high-temperature-treated RCB exhibited great conductive loss. The results confirm the coexistence of dual polarization relaxations and conductive loss.
![]() | ||
Fig. 13 Cole–Cole semicircles of different samples: (a) RCB500-40%, (b) RCB800-30%, (c) RCB1000-30%. |
According to the above-mentioned results, the EWA mechanism of the obtained composites can be summarized (Fig. 14). First, the incident EWs experience multiple reflections and scattering inside the porous RCB series significantly extends propagation pathways, thereby intensifying their attenuation.59 The morphological characterization confirmed that RCB800 had the greatest porosity. Therefore, RCB800 may exhibit the most pronounced multiple reflection and scattering effects on EWs. Second, the electrical conductivity of the RCB series increased with the increase in treatment temperature due to the phase change of carbon and the formation of Ca3N2. When an external electric field is applied, the conductivity of the network increases, leading to conductive loss in the composite materials. Moderate high conductivity is usually beneficial to obtain high reflection loss, thus increasing the dielectric loss of the material.60,61 Third, apart from the pre-existing defects in the original RCB, new defects were introduced into the composites during subsequent calcination processes at various temperatures. Consequently, dipole polarization is generated as a function of the electric field, in which the positive and negative charge centres of the molecules form an electric dipole moment.62 Moreover, SiO2 and the newly produced Ca3N2 are polar molecules63 that undergo dipole rearrangement in response to external electromagnetic fields, leading to dipole polarization. Therefore, RCB800 and RCB1000 exhibited an increase in dipole polarization. Fourth, in the RCB series, there were a large number of nonhomogeneous interfaces and heterogeneous junctions, including carbon sphere inner and outer interfaces, pore interfaces, air-different substance interfaces, and SiO2–ZnS, SiO2–carbon, SiO2–CaCO3, ZnS–carbon, ZnS–CaCO3, and CaCO3–carbon interfaces for RCB500 and SiO2–ZnS, SiO2–carbon, SiO2–Ca3N2, ZnS–carbon, ZnS–Ca3N2, and Ca3N2–carbon interfaces for RCB800 and RCB1000. Interfacial polarization is facilitated by these interfaces.64 Fifth, the good impedance matching optimized by the components and the filler loading caused the EWs to dramatically enter the interior of the RCB series rather than reflecting at the air–absorbing material interface. The Z values confirmed that the impedance matchings of RCB500-40%, RCB800-30%, and RCB1000-30% were better than those of the other samples. Ultimately, the EM reflection was further significantly decreased through quarter-wavelength attenuation, particularly for RCB500-40%, RCB800-30%, and RCB1000-30% when the thickness was less than 4.0 mm.
From the perspective of practical production applications, RCB800 can serve as a promising EWA material. This is because compared to RCB500 and RCB1000, RCB800 achieved the widest EAB (4.14 GHz), strongest loss capability (−34.47 dB), smallest thickness (1.5 mm), and lowest filler loading (30 wt%) at a moderate temperature. The EWA properties of typical carbon-based composites reported in the recent literature are shown in Table 2. The RCB800, developed in this study, had superior EWA capabilities compared to conventional C-based materials, as demonstrated by its higher RL, thinner thickness, wider EAB, and lower filler loading values. The results once again indicate that RCB with further heat treatment can serve as a highly efficient EWA material.
Samples | RLmin (dB) | Thickness (mm) | EAB (GHz) | Filler loading (%) | Refs. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Carbon nanofibers | <–25.0 | 4.0 | <2.0 | 100 | 65 |
Fe3O4@C nanofibers/bismaleimide composites | −22 | 6.0 | ≪1 | 100 | 66 |
CuS-biomass carbon | −28.8 | 4.08 | 4.2 | 20 | 67 |
Mn–Zn ferrite/carbon fibre | −28.75 | 10 | 1.46 | 100 | 68 |
Thermosetting polyimide-derived carbon | −36.5 | 1.8 | 4.1 | 30 | 69 |
Reduced graphene oxide | −37.2 | 3.5 | <2.0 | 30 | 36 |
Hollow ZnFe2O4/residual carbon | −38.99 | 4.0 | 3.2 | 45 | 70 |
Carbon-wrapped Y2Si2O7 | −42 | 3.3 | 3.6 | 100 | 71 |
NiS/Ni0.96S@multiwalled carbon nanotube | −35.5 | 2.0 | <3.76 | 30 | 72 |
N, S Co-doped porous carbon | −15.478 | 2.0 | 2.08 | 70 | 73 |
RCB800 | −34.47 | 1.5 | 4.14 | 30 | This work |
Supplementary information: the comparison of the sample with the XRD standard cards for each compound contained in the sample; nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms and pore size distributions of all sample; TEM images of RCB, RCB600, RCB1000; TEM elemental mapping images of RCB, RCB500, RCB600, RCB800, RCB1000; attenuation constants of all samples. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ra05326a.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |