Open Access Article
Guo-Ao
Li‡
a,
Min
Deng‡
a,
Wei
Guo
a,
Shuang
Yin
a,
Yan-E
Liu
a,
Ai-Xin
Zhu
*a and
Michael J.
Zaworotko
*b
aKey Laboratory of Modern Separation Analysis and Substance Transformation, Faculty of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Yunnan Normal University, Kunming 650500, China. E-mail: zaxchem@126.com
bDepartment of Chemical Sciences, Bernal Institute, University of Limerick, Limerick V94T9PX, Ireland. E-mail: xtal@ul.ie
First published on 10th March 2025
We report the synthesis of a 2-fold interpenetrated primitive cubic (pcu) topology network, X-pcu-11-Zn, formulated as [Zn2(DMTDC)2(dpb)] (H2DMTDC = 3,4-dimethylthieno[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid; dpb = 1,4-di(pyridin-4-yl)benzene). Upon removal of solvent molecules from the as-synthesised form, X-pcu-11-Zn-α, transformation from a large-pore “open” phase to a narrow pore phase, X-pcu-11-Zn-β, occurred. The β-phase subsequently exhibited guest-induced switching as evidenced by a 2-step type F-IV2 adsorption isotherm for N2 at 77 K and a 3-step profile with two gate-opening pressures for CO2 at 195 K. Dynamic vapour sorption studies revealed selective sorption of methanol, ethanol, and CH3CN over H2O at 298 K. Furthermore, X-pcu-11-Zn-β selectively adsorbed benzene over cyclohexane concomitant with a gate-opening effect driven by structural transformations. Importantly, the transformations between the guest-free and guest-loaded structures were found to be reversible over six adsorption/desorption cycles. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis of the benzene-loaded phase indicates that selective benzene binding can be attributed to π–π and C–H⋯π aromatic packing interactions.
Separation of benzene (Bz) and cyclohexane (Cy) is a challenge for the chemical and petrochemical industries. Cy is primarily obtained through the catalytic hydrogenation of Bz and unreacted Bz must be removed from the reactor's effluent stream to generate high-purity Cy. However, this separation is challenging due to their similar boiling points (Bz, 80.1 °C; Cy, 80.7 °C), molecular geometries (Bz, 3.3 × 6.6 × 7.3 Å3; Cy, 5.0 × 6.6 × 7.2 Å3), and Lennard–Jones collision diameters.17,18 The similar boiling points and the formation of azeotropes render distillation processes poorly effective. Currently, the predominant industrial methods for separating Bz/Cy mixtures are extractive distillation and azeotropic distillation, both of which have high energy footprints and are accompanied by process complexity and high operating costs.19–21 It is therefore desirable to develop separation methods that are easier and more energy-efficient for the separation of Bz and Cy. A similar challenge exists for alcohol/water separations.
To enable selective separation between sorbates with similar physicochemical properties, the development of physisorbents with tight binding sites has proven to be fruitful as exemplified by CO2 and C2H2 selective adsorbents.22,23 For Bz/Cy, π–π, H-π, and H-bonding interactions are likely to drive selective Bz binding and could also induce structural transformations.24–29 FMOFs comprised of aromatic linker ligands would be expected to offer suitable pore chemistry for Bz binding and, because of inherent flexibility, offer the possibility of induced-fit binding for Bz that is reminiscent of enzyme–substrate binding.26–29 This principle was demonstrated by Kitagawa's group in an FMOF featuring a flexible undulating channel that exhibited selective adsorption of Bz over Cy via gate-opening triggered by CH-π interactions.26 Chen et al. reported a flexible MOF with a similar mechanism for selective adsorption of Bz,27 whereas Ghosh et al. reported an FMOF with a π-electron deficient ligand that exhibited Bz/Cy recognition and structural transformation induced by Bz.28
In this study, we report a new 2-fold interpenetrated FMOF, [Zn2(DMTDC)2(dpb)] (X-pcu-11-Zn), comprising two aromatic π-conjugated ligands (Scheme 1): 3,4-dimethylthieno[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (H2DMTDC) and 1,4-di(pyridin-4-yl)benzene (dpb). X-pcu-11-Zn was found to undergo reversible structural transformations between its as-synthesized large pore “open” phase, X-pcu-11-Zn-α, and its activated narrow pore phase, X-pcu-11-Zn-β. These transformations were characterised by single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) as well as gas and vapor adsorption to provide insight into the Bz binding mechanism.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 X-pcu-11-Zn-α is composed of H2DMTDC and dpb ligands and exhibits a primitive cubic (pcu) topology with 2-fold interpenetration. | ||
. The resulting coordination network comprises dinuclear Zn(II) tetracarboxylate paddlewheels (Fig. 1a) linked via DMTDC ligands to form a square lattice (sql) network (Fig. 1b). The sql nets are pillared by dpb linkers to generate a pcu topology (Fig. 1c). X-pcu-11-Zn-α is a member of the DMOF-1 family which already has several members with extended (X-) ligands, X-pcu-n-Zn (e.g. n = 5, 6, 7, 8), that exhibit 2-fold offset interpenetration (Fig. 1d).30–32X-pcu-11-Zn-α features ultramicroporous 3D channels with effective pore diameters of ca. 2.3 × 2.5, 3.3 × 5.4, and 4.5 × 6.8 Å2 along the a-, b-, and c-axes, respectively (Fig. S1–S3†). The calculated guest-accessible volume is 49.8%. TGA revealed that as-synthesized X-pcu-11-Zn-α loses guest molecules (observed: 30.02%; calculated: 30.05%) on reaching 150 °C and is thermally stable below 320 °C (Fig. S8†).
X-pcu-11-Zn-α underwent single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) transformation after heating at 120 °C for 12 h to form X-pcu-11-Zn-β (Fig. S11†). SCXRD revealed that the β-form is a contorted version of the α-form with the same connectivity (Fig. 1e and f) but with centred rather than offset interpenetration (Fig. 1g). X-pcu-11-Zn-β crystallized in the orthorhombic space group Ibca with a 32.0% shrinkage in unit-cell volume relative to the α-form (Table S1†). X-pcu-11-Zn-β exhibits 1D channels with an effective pore diameter of ca. 2.1 × 2.6 Å2 along the a-axis (Fig. S4†). TGA and IR studies indicated that guest molecules had indeed been removed (Fig. S8 and S10†) and PLATON calculations revealed that the β-phase has only 4.9% solvent-accessible space. TGA of X-pcu-11-Zn-β showed no weight loss until decomposition at 320 °C (Fig. S8†). The structural transformation associated with guest release is reversible, with PXRD data revealing that the β-form had reverted to the α-form when soaked in DMF at room temperature for one day (Fig. S11†).
Analysis of the crystal structures reveals that the transformation between the large pore and narrow pore phases involves distortion of the sql nets and a sliding motion of the two interpenetrated nets (Fig. 1 and Fig. S7, Table S2†). In the α-phase, the metal–carboxylate junction Zn2
O2 > C approaches linearity with dihedral angles (Table S2 and Fig. S5†) between the Zn2
O2 plane and the carboxylate group O2 > C ranging from 1.0° to 8.4° for X-pcu-11-Zn-α. Conversely, in the β-phase, the metal–carboxylate junctions bend with dihedral angles ranging from 18.1° to 30.1° for X-pcu-11-Zn-β. There are no π–π interactions (centroid–centroid distance <4.0 Å) or C–H-π interactions in either structure, but C–H⋯O hydrogen bonding exists in both phases (Table S3†).
36) or even a five-step type F-IV5 isotherm (Co(bpe)) with an uptake >300 cm3 g−1.37
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Gas sorption isotherms of X-pcu-11-Zn-β. Solid and open symbols represent adsorption and desorption branches, respectively. | ||
Unlike N2 adsorption at 77 K, the adsorption isotherm of CO2 for X-pcu-11-Zn-β at 195 K consists of three adsorption/desorption steps. The initial uptake of CO2 reached a saturated uptake of 33 cm3 g−1. The Langmuir surface area calculated for the first CO2 sorption step is 200 m2 g−1. The next step, which we attribute to gate-opening, occurred at P/P0 = 0.10 with saturated uptake reaching 125 cm3 g−1. The Langmuir surface area calculated from the second-step of CO2 sorption is 754 m2 g−1. At the second gate-opening pressure (P/P0 = 0.70), the CO2 uptake further increased to 267 cm3 g−1 at P/P0 = 1.0. The Langmuir surface area was calculated to be 1677 m2 g−1 (see section 10†).38X-pcu-11-Zn-β represents a rare example of 3-step CO2 adsorption with high capacity (>250 cm3 g−1) (Table S8†). After N2 and CO2 desorption, X-pcu-11-Zn-β retained its original structure (Fig. S12†).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 H2O, MeOH, EtOH, and MeCN sorption isotherms measured at 298 K. Solid and open symbols represent adsorption and desorption branches, respectively. | ||
To investigate the adsorption behaviour of larger organic molecules on X-pcu-11-Zn-β, single-component adsorption isotherms for benzene (Bz) and cyclohexane (Cy) were collected at 298 K. As shown in Fig. 4, X-pcu-11-Zn-β adsorbed Bz (92 cm3 g−1) but exhibited minimal adsorption for Cy (5 cm3 g−1) at P/P0 = 0.99. This uptake amount corresponds to 3.56 Bz molecules per formula unit. Although Bz is larger than MeOH, EtOH, and MeCN, its gate-opening adsorption pressure starts at a lower relative pressure (P/P0 = 0.10), which may be attributed to host–guest interactions arising from the π system and the more acidic C(sp2)–H moieties in Bz compared to C(sp3)–H bonds. PXRD patterns of X-pcu-11-Zn-β exposed to Bz for 12 h reveal distinct changes compared to the patterns of unexposed X-pcu-11-Zn-β, whereas the PXRD patterns remained unchanged under Cy vapour for the same duration (Fig. 5). PXRD data suggest that the structure of X-pcu-11-Zn-β after exposure to Bz for 12 h matches well with that of X-pcu-11-Zn-α calculated from SCXRD data, indicating that Bz had induced structural transformation from the β to the α phase, while Cy did not induce such a change (Fig. 5). This makes X-pcu-11-Zn-β a candidate for selective adsorption of Bz over Cy.
To gain insight into this adsorption behaviour, single crystals of Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn were obtained by soaking X-pcu-11-Zn-α in benzene (Bz). PXRD analyses indicate that Bz-loaded X-pcu-11-Zn is indeed isostructural with X-pcu-11-Zn-α as calculated from SCXRD data (Fig. 5). The single crystal structure of Bz-loaded X-pcu-11-Zn reveals the presence of 3.5 Bz molecules per molecular unit, consistent with the uptake from the Bz adsorption isotherm. In the crystal structure of Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn, the framework resembles that of X-pcu-11-Zn-α with similar unit cell parameters (Table S1†). As shown in Fig. 6 and Tables S4, S5,† multiple π–π and C–H⋯π aromatic interactions exist between the benzene molecules and the X-pcu-11-Zn framework, which likely drive the phase transformation of X-pcu-11-Zn-β. The selectivity of X-pcu-11-Zn-β for Bz can be attributed to this host–guest binding. Furthermore, the PXRD pattern of X-pcu-11-Zn-β after Bz capture also matches well with the calculated pattern from the crystal structure of Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn- (Fig. 5), indicating that the crystal structure transforms from X-pcu-11-Zn-β to Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn upon Bz adsorption. The 1H NMR spectra of X-pcu-11-Zn-β exposed to Bz and Cy vapours for 12 h showed that X-pcu-11-Zn-β adsorbs 3.48 Bz and 0.04 Cy molecules per molecular unit (Fig. S19 and S20†), respectively. Additionally, TGA data were collected for Bz and Cy vapour adsorption by X-pcu-11-Zn-β. As shown in Fig. S9,† the TGA curves for X-pcu-11-Zn-β that had been exposed to Bz for 12 h reveal a weight loss of 22.61% below 115 °C, corresponding to 3.26 Bz molecules per molecular unit, again consistent with the SCXRD analysis results. In contrast, there is negligible weight loss (2.61%) for X-pcu-11-Zn-β after exposure to Cy vapor for 12 h before reaching 300 °C. This pronounced adsorption difference suggested to us that X-pcu-11-Zn-β can be utilised for the separation of Bz and Cy.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 The π⋯π and C–H⋯π interactions between benzene molecules and the framework in Bz@X-pcu-11-α viewed along the crystallographic b-axis. | ||
To evaluate the adsorption kinetics of X-pcu-11-Zn-β for benzene (Bz) and cyclohexane (Cy) vapours, 1H NMR spectroscopy was employed (details are available in the ESI†). Samples that had been exposed to Bz and Cy vapours were soaked in CDCl3 to extract adsorbed Bz and Cy, respectively. As depicted in Fig. 7a, the amount of Bz adsorbed by X-pcu-11-Zn-β increased over time, reaching saturation after approximately 1 h at room temperature. At saturation, X-pcu-11-Zn-β adsorbed about 3.48 Bz molecules per unit, while the uptake of Cy was negligible. The adsorption kinetics for Bz were analysed by using pseudo-first-order and pseudo-second-order kinetic models (see section 15 of the ESI†). As shown in Fig. S23, S24 and Table S6,† the adsorption kinetics can be best described by the pseudo-first-order model for X-pcu-11-Zn-β. This suggests that the adsorption process may be governed by physisorption rather than chemisorption. The structural changes induced by Bz adsorption were found to be reversible; adsorbed Bz was removed by heating Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn at 120 °C under vacuum (Fig. S14†). So-formed X-pcu-11-Zn-β retained its ability to adsorb Bz with no loss of performance after six cycles (Fig. 7b) and PXRD data revealed that X-pcu-11-Zn-β maintained phase stability (Fig. S14†).
To explore the potential of X-pcu-11-Zn-β for separating Bz and Cy mixtures, a time-dependent binary-component sorption experiment was conducted with X-pcu-11-Zn-β exposed to an equimolar Bz/Cy vapor mixture (details are available in the ESI†). In contrast to single-component adsorption, binary-component Bz/Cy adsorption resulted in co-adsorption, 2.10 Bz and 0.97 Cy molecules per formula unit, respectively, after 12 h of exposure to equimolar Bz/Cy (Fig. 7c). The separation ratio of the Bz/Cy mixture was calculated to be 2.16. Although the Bz/Cy selectivity is smaller than other flexible MOFs (Table S9†) such as [Zn(TCNQ-TCNQ)bpy]n
26 and CID-23,39 this value is comparable or better than several rigid MOFs such as MOF-5,40 HKUST-1,41 and CUB-30.42 Binary-component Bz/Cy adsorption by gas chromatography revealed that X-pcu-11-Zn-β reached saturation for Bz and Cy within 1 h (Fig. S22†), and had adsorbed 76.52% Bz and 23.48% Cy after 1 h (Fig. 7d). The molar ratio of Bz/Cy (3.2
:
1) from gas chromatography is comparable to that obtained from 1H NMR analyses. As expected, the PXRD pattern of X-pcu-11-Zn-β changed upon exposure to the Bz/Cy mixture, matching the calculated pattern from the SCXRD data of Bz@X-pcu-11-Zn (Fig. S15†). These results indicate that X-pcu-11-Zn-β is a soft crystalline material with moderate selectivity for adsorption of Bz from a 1
:
1 Bz/Cy mixture, the selectivity being ascribed to the structural transformation induced by Bz adsorption.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, single-crystal XRD data, PXRD patterns, IR spectra, TGA curves, etc. CCDC 2372920–2372922. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5qi00261c |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2025 |