Open Access Article
Stefano
Parisotto
*,
Marco
Blangetti
and
Cristina
Prandi
Dipartimento di Chimica, Università di Torino, Via Pietro Giuria 7, 10125 Torino, Italy. E-mail: stefano.parisotto@unito.it
First published on 2nd October 2025
In this paper, we present the first combination of commercially available imine reductases (IREDs) with the photocatalytic hydroimination of alkene-tethered iminyl radicals. Notably, the photochemical step was achieved from simple oxime benzoates lacking additional electron-withdrawing activation. This hybrid cascade enabled the synthesis of diverse 2,5-disubstituted pyrrolidines with good functional group compatibility and tolerance to sterically demanding substrates. Additionally, our methodology was extended to the preparation of a novel all cis analogue of (−)-codonopsinine. Mechanistic studies suggested the generation of the key iminyl radical from the benzoate by triplet–triplet energy transfer (TTEnT).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 (a) Known photobiocatalytic syntheses of chiral amines; (b) selected methodologies to access chiral 2,5-disubstituted pyrrolidines; (c) our designed photobiocatalytic cascade. | ||
In the context of our ongoing interest in using imine reductases under non-conventional conditions,22 we recently focused our attention on their integration with photocatalysis. Since several methodologies involving visible light have been reported for the synthesis of substituted pyrrolines,23 we envisioned that their combination with imine reductases could provide a new route to cyclic amines and in particular to 2,5-disubstituted pyrrolidines (Scheme 1c), commonly found in the core structure of organocatalysts,24 bioactive compounds,25 and natural alkaloids.26 This methodology would complement existing approaches (Scheme 1b) such as the direct C–H functionalisation of pyrrolidines using organolithiums reported by Seidel,27 the rhodium-catalysed nitrene transfer with N-tosyloxycarbamates,28 and the multienzymatic cascades combining transaminases with monoamine oxidases,29 or imine reductases.30 Notably, although Wang and Huang recently demonstrated the use of IREDs in photobiocatalysis for the stereoselective addition of alkyl radicals to enamides,31 no photobiocatalytic cascades involving imine reductases have been hitherto reported. Among the several photochemical transformations leading to cyclic imines, we focused on the hydroimination of alkene-tethered iminyl radicals. These reactive species are typically generated via N–O bond cleavage in oxime esters or ethers, often requiring electron-deficient substrates to enable efficient reduction by the photocatalyst's excited-state. So far, this approach has heavily relied on aromatic rings bearing strong electron-withdrawing groups (e.g., –NO2,32 –CF3,33,34 –F35) to enhance redox activity. In contrast, we were interested in investigating the use of simple oxime benzoates lacking additional electron-withdrawing activation.
| Entry | Photocatalyst | Hydrogen donor (eq.) | Solvent | Yield 3aa (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Yield determined by 1H NMR using 1,3,5-trimethoxybenzene as the internal standard. b Stirring was conducted at 1500 rpm to obtain a dispersion of droplets. c The intensity of the light source (Kessil lamp) was increased from 50% to 75%. d The intensity of the light source (Kessil lamp) was increased from 50% to 100%. e The intensity of the light source (Kessil lamp) was increased from 50% to 100% and the reaction time was reduced to 16 hours. f Under red-light irradiation by a 660 nm LED chip. g 1.0 equivalent of K2CO3 was added. | |||||
| 1 | PC-1 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | 64 |
|
| 2 | PC-1 | HAT-2 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | Traces | |
| 3 | PC-1 | HAT-3 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | Traces | |
| 4 | PC-1 | HAT-4 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | Traces | |
| 5 | PC-1 | HAT-5 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | 60 | |
| 6 | PC-1 | HAT-6 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | 23 (65 2a) | |
| 7 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | DMF [0.1 M] | 61 | |
| 8b | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | H2O [0.1 M] | 56 (23 2a) | |
| 9 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | NaPi pH 8 [0.1 M] | 0 | |
| 10 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | CH3CN [0.1 M] | 24 (73 2a) | |
| 11 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 50 (35 2a) | |
| 12 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 82 | |
| 13d | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 78 | |
| 14e | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 76 | |
| 15 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.2 M] | 79 | |
| 16 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.05 M] | 74 | |
| 17 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | CPME [0.1 M] | 72 | |
| 18 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (1.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 75 (5 2a) | |
| 19 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (1.5 0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 78 | |
| 20 | PC-2 | HAT-1 (4.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 80 | |
| 21 | PC-1 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 67 | |
| 22 | PC-3 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 0 (84 2a) | |
| 23 | PC-4 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 50 (38 2a) | |
| 24f | PC-5 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | Acetone [0.1 M] | 0 (99 2a) | |
| 25g | PC-2 | HAT-1 (2.0 eq.) | acetone [0.1 M] | 85 | |
To probe the role of the aromatisation, we tested cycloheptatriene, which can similarly aromatise to a tropylium ion. This gave low conversion of 2a (65% unreacted 2a) and moderate yield of 3a (entry 6). Triphenylmethane also proved effective (60% yield, entry 5), which we attributed to both the stability of the trityl cation and its comparable hydrogen-donating ability (BDE triphenylmethane = 81 kcal mol−1,37vs. BDE γ-terpinene ≈ 77 kcal mol−1).38 Surprisingly, we later found out that 4CzIPN (PC-2) catalysed the reaction with similar efficiency to the iridium complex (61% yield, entry 7), whereas other catalysts were not effective. Hence, PC-2 was chosen as elective catalyst to carry on with the optimisation of the reaction conditions. The solvent played a crucial role in improving the yield of the hydroimination. Indeed, we got optimal results by replacing DMF with acetone and increasing the intensity of the light source (82% yield, entry 12). CPME also outperformed DMF (72% yield, entry 17) and promising results were obtained even in water (50% yield and 67% conversion, entry 8). Aiming at a one-pot photobiocatalytic cascade we repeated the reaction in phosphate buffer; however, we recovered a complex reaction mixture suggesting complete decomposition of 2a. Finally, although a slight increase in the yield was observed in the presence of K2CO3 (85% yield, entry 25), we chose not to include it to maintain a less complex reaction medium and minimise potential interferences in the subsequent enzyme-catalysed step. No further improvement was observed changing the molarity of the reaction (entries 15–17), nor the loading of the HAT reagent (entries 18–20). Next, we conducted control experiments to confirm the role of each component in the reaction mixture (Table 2). Quantitative recovery of unreacted oxime benzoate 2a after conducting the reaction in the dark or in the absence of 4CzIPN confirmed the photocatalytic nature of the reaction (entries 1 and 2). The role of γ-terpinene as the hydrogen radical source was supported by the reduced efficiency observed in its absence, with imine 3a still forming in 25% yield (entry 3). To assess whether the solvent might participate in the HAT step, we repeated the reaction in deuterated acetone. The reaction proceeded with similar yield, and the product (d-3a) showed 30% deuterium incorporation at the exocyclic methyl group, supporting the participation of the solvent in the process, either through direct hydrogen donation or via hydrogen/deuterium exchange with an intermediate donor species. Moreover, when the model reaction was performed in the presence of radical quenchers, such as TEMPO and BHT, the formation of radical adducts 3a-TEMPO and 3a-BHT confirmed the radical nature of the transformation (entries 5 and 6). Moreover, the reaction was conducted under aerated condition, by saturating the reaction vessel with oxygen prior to irradiation. After 24 hours we recovered a complex reaction mixture containing unreacted oxime benzoate 2a (23%) and imine 3a (31%, entry 7). Removal of the photocatalyst and irradiation using 370 nm LEDs provided the desired product in a low 27% yield (entry 8), thus confirming the beneficial role of 4CzIPN in mediating the photochemical reaction.
| Entry | Deviation | Yield 3aa (%) |
|---|---|---|
| a Yield determined by 1H NMR using 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane as the internal standard unless otherwise specified. b 3a-TEMPO detected by HRMS analysis. c Isolated yield. d 3a-BHT detected by HRMS analysis. | ||
| 1 | Reaction conducted in the dark | 0 (99 2a) |
| 2 | No photocatalyst | 0 (99 2a) |
| 3 | No γ-terpinene | 25 |
| 4 | Reaction carried out in acetone-d6 | 23 (3a : d-3a 7 : 3) |
| 5b | TEMPO (1.0 eq.) added | Traces (>90 2a) |
| 6d | BHT (1.0 eq.) added | 41c (14 2a) |
| 7 | Aerated conditions | 31 (23 2a) |
| 8 | No photocatalyst, 370 nm | 27 |
|
||
Having established the optimal conditions for the photochemical step, we selected imine 3f and screened a set of commercially available imine reductases to identify the most suitable enzyme for the desired transformation. The results are summarised in Scheme 2a. Using our previously optimised conditions,22 a suspension of pyrroline 3f (0.1 M) in a sodium phosphate buffer (pH 8)/glycerol mixture was treated with different IREDs. NADP+ was employed as the cofactor and regenerated in situ using glucose dehydrogenase (GDH-101) and D-glucose. After 48 hours, full conversion was observed only with two variants, IRED-44, and IRED-72, yielding pyrrolidine 4f in 78% and 82% yield, respectively. IRED-69 also showed good catalytic activity (53% yield, 80% conversion), while IRED-17, IRED-18, and IRED-33 gave only low to moderate conversion. The reduction proceeded with excellent (S)-stereoselectivity, consistent with previous reports, yielding 4f as a mixture of diastereomers. At higher conversions, equimolar mixtures of cis and trans isomers were obtained. In contrast, the limited activity of IRED-17, -18, and -33 resulted in partial kinetic resolution, favouring the formation of the cis isomer. Given the optimal performance of IRED-44, we assessed its compatibility with the photocatalytic process by evaluating the effect of individual reagents and major by-products from the hydroimination step (Scheme 2b). No significant inhibition was observed upon the addition of γ-terpinene, p-cymene, or 4CzIPN (entries 2–4). However, the addition of one equivalent of benzoic acid significantly reduced the conversion of pyrroline 3f (entry 5), likely due to a drop of the pH below the optimal range for this enzyme (7.0–8.5 as reported by the supplier). Increasing the volume of the buffer solution mitigated this effect (entry 6), and we therefore optimised the biocatalytic step by conducting the reduction at a final substrate concentration of 75 mM.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Biocatalytic reduction of imine 3f. (a) screening of commercial IREDs; (b) 3f reduction if the presence of potential inhibitors. | ||
Finally, with the aim of producing stereodefined pyrrolidines directly from oxime benzoates, we developed a one-pot cascade process integrating the photochemical and biocatalytic steps. As mentioned before, initial attempts to perform the photochemical reaction on oxime benzoate 2a in phosphate buffer failed to yield the desired pyrroline 3a, ruling out a fully concurrent cascade. However, by conducting the photochemical step in acetone, we enabled a sequential (telescoped) cascade process. Indeed, a rapid solvent switch from volatile acetone to the aqueous phosphate buffer containing all components required for biocatalysis allowed smooth progression to the biocatalytic reduction. The designed cascade was first applied to model substrate benzoate 2a, and we were pleased to observe complete conversion of both the starting material and the intermediate imine, yielding the desired amine 4a in 64% yield with the expected diastereoselectivity (dr 1
:
1) and excellent enantioselectivity in the biocatalytic step (er >99
:
1 for both diastereomers). Furthermore, a ten-fold scale-up of the reaction was successfully carried out, affording product 4a in 49% yield with same selectivity. Notably, the use of a fed-batch strategy in the biocatalytic step (see SI for a detailed procedure) enabled a tenfold increase in the enzyme-to-substrate ratio without a significant drop in the overall yield. To demonstrate the versatility of the developed hybrid process, we applied it to a selection of oxime benzoates 2a–o featuring different substituents, including electron-rich and electron-poor arenes, heteroarenes, and substituted scaffold (Scheme 3).
The desired pyrrolidines 4a–o were isolated with high stereoselectivity (er >99
:
1) and modest to good yields (40–72%). The photobiocatalytic reaction tolerated a moderate range of substituted arenes. Halogenated substrates were all successfully converted into products 4b–d, highlighting the compatibility of the cascade with synthetically versatile and reactive handles. We obtained good yields for fluorinated products 4d (p-F phenyl) and 4e (p-CF3 phenyl), which are especially significant in the context of pharmaceutical chemistry, where fluorine incorporation is widely employed to enhance metabolic stability, membrane permeability, and target binding affinity. Substrates bearing electron-donating groups, such as the methoxy and methyl group, were also well tolerated, providing good yields for products 4f–g (up to 70%), confirming that the electronic nature of the aryl group has minimal impact on the efficiency of the hybrid process. To probe the steric constraints of the enzymatic reduction step, we evaluated the preparation of ortho-substituted arene 4h and the naphthyl derivative 4i. These bulkier substrates led to slightly diminished yields (53% and 48%, respectively), suggesting some sensitivity to steric hindrance near the imine moiety, yet the reaction remained viable, reflecting the remarkable substrate flexibility of the IRED. We further examined heteroaryl-derived substrates, which are prominent in drug and agrochemical discovery. 2-Pyridyl (4m), 2-thienyl (4n), and 2-furyl (4o) analogues were all successfully isolated (34–49% yield), confirming the compatibility of the process with heteroatom-containing substrates, which often present challenges in both photocatalysis and biocatalysis. Finally, to assess the enzyme's tolerance to substitutions on the pyrroline ring, we introduced larger alkyl groups at the 2-position. While ethyl-substituted products (4m, 4n) were obtained in good yields (up to 62%), the more sterically demanding isopropyl derivative afforded a reduced yield for product 4o (42%). Given the good functional group compatibility and the moderate tolerance towards larger substituent on the azacycle, we applied the photobiocatalytic methodology to the preparation of an analogue of codonopsinine. This alkaloid which was first isolated from Codonopsis clematidea by Matkhalikova and co-workers in 1969,39 features a 1,2,3,4,5-pentasubstituted pyrrolidine core bearing a p-anisyl group at the C2-position. This natural product has attracted interest due to its biological properties, including antibiotic and hypotensive effects.40 Its epimer, 4-epi-codonopsinine, exhibits inhibitory activity against α-fucosidase,41 moreover both natural codonopsinine and its synthetic derivatives have shown promising activity against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA).42 In this context, we prepared oxime benzoate 2p from D-ribose (see SI for the full synthetic route) and subjected it to our optimised photobiocatalytic protocol, producing pyrrolidine 4p as a single stereoisomer in 44% yield (Scheme 3). As mentioned before, all previous products were generated as a mixture of enantiopure diastereomers, owing to the inherent non-selective photochemical cyclisation that produced racemic imines. However, employing oxime benzoate 2p, which features two consecutive chiral centers derived from ribose, alongside the rigidity induced by the cyclic ketal moiety, the photocatalytic step becomes stereoselective. This results in the enzymatic reduction yielding a single stereoisomer of the final pyrrolidine. This result highlights the potential of this methodology, which complements recent advances in the biocatalytic preparation of bioactive imino- and aminosugars,43,44 to access a new class of all cis codonopsinine analogues, thereby expanding the accessible chemical space for future biological exploration.
Finally, given the unexpected results observed with simple oxime benzoates despite the mild reducing ability of 4CzIPN, we hypothesised that the photochemical step might be initiated by triplet–triplet energy transfer rather than by single electron transfer. Oxime benzoate 2a exhibits two reduction peaks (Scheme 5b): at −1.70 V and −2.32 V, relatively far from the redox properties of the catalyst (E0(PC*/PC+) = −1.18 V, E0(PC/PC−) = −1.24 V).45 Due to their desirable photophysical properties, carbazolyl benzonitriles have been used also in photochemical transformations involving Dexter triplet–triplet energy transfer (TTEnT).46,47 As the triplet state energy for 4CzIPN is 58.3 kcal mol−1,48 derivatives with a lower energy should undergo photosensitisation. Taking advantage of the machine-leaning platform recently developed by Glorius,49 we calculated a value of 56.08 kcal mol−1 for the energy of the triplet state of 2a. Comparing this value with those of 4CzIPN and the photocatalysts we tested, we observed a good correlation with the results observed during the optimisation (Scheme 5a). In addition, we also tested other organic sensitizers and got stronger evidence of an energy transfer process (Scheme 4). While benzyl (ET = 53.3 kcal mol−1) afforded minimal conversion (entry 6), Michler's ketone (ET = 61.0 kcal mol−1) produced imine 3a with 33% yield and 35% conversion. Notably, both conversion and yield improved (86% and 68% respectively) upon irradiating the reaction mixture at 390 nm to better match the spectroscopic feature of the sensitizer (entries 7 and 8 respectively). Also, thioxanthone (ET = 65.5 kcal mol−1) was tested under blue and purple light. In the former experiment we observed low conversion (22%) and 14% yield (entry 9). Switching to purple light resulted in the complete conversion of oxime benzoate 2a, but no product could be detected in the crude mixture, suggesting a possible degradation of the product (entry 10).
Based on these results and on the experiments summarised in Table 2, we are inclined to propose that following the photoexcitation of 4CzIPN to its singlet state (14CzIPN*) and its successive interconversion into triplet state (34CzIPN*), the reaction is initiated upon sensitisation of oxime benzoate 2a to 32a*via energy transfer (Scheme 5c). Homolysis of the N–O bond produces iminyl radical I and benzyloxy radical II. Exocyclic radical III is then produced upon 5-exo-trig cyclisation, which abstracts a hydrogen atom from γ-terpinene producing imine 3a and bis-allyl radical IV. The latter finally aromatises to p-cymene by a second hydrogen atom transfer, producing benzoic acid from radical II.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |