Victor Vega-Mayoral*ab,
Saül Garcia-Orrita,
Peijiang Wang
c,
Rafael Morales-Márquez
c,
Emma Martín Rodríguez
def,
Beatriz H. Juárez
*c and
Juan Cabanillas-Gonzalez
ab
aIMDEA Nanoscience, Faraday 9, Campus de Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain. E-mail: victor.vega@imdea.org
bUnidad de Nanomateriales Avanzados, IMDEA-Nanociencia, Unidad Asociada al CSIC por el ICMM. C/Faraday 9, 28049, Madrid, Spain
cMaterials Science Institute of Madrid, ICMM, Spanish Research Council, CSIC, C/Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz, 3, 28049, Madrid, Spain. E-mail: bh.juarez@csic.es
dDepartamento de Física Aplicada, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, C/Francisco Tomás y Valiente 7, Madrid, Spain
eInstituto Ramón y Cajal de Investigación Sanitaria (IRYCIS), Ctra. Colmenar Viejo, km. 9100, 28034 Madrid, Spain
fInstitute for Advanced Research in Chemistry (IAdChem), Campus de Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain
First published on 18th March 2025
The optoelectronic properties of Ag2S nanocrystals with different surface passivation treatments have been investigated using femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. Plain Ag2S nanocrystals and improved surface-passivated nanostructures were studied under different pump fluences and photon energies. Surface passivation significantly sharpens excitonic resonances, reducing defect-assisted recombination. Transient absorption spectroscopy reveals that the excited state dynamics are dominated by trapping and exciton recombination at low exciton densities, while fluence dependence studies reveal significant contributions from biexcitons and Auger recombination in all samples at high exciton densities. Notably, surface-passivated nanostructures exhibit faster multi-exciton recombination dynamics, highlighting the impact of effective surface passivation.
In general, many-body processes play an important role in the optoelectronic properties of a material and have significant implications for developing next-generation devices.12,13 In this respect, Ag2S nanocrystals hold great promise, since they integrate unique optical and electronic properties, such as multi-exciton generation (MEG), a pivotal feature for advancing in efficiency and functionality. Ag2S NCs are capable of carrier multiplication via MEG, where photon energies above the band gap can lead to the generation of multiple excitons from a single absorbed photon, which enhances the photon conversion efficiency.14,15 The presence of MEG is not only promising for boosting the photovoltaic efficiency, but also offers insights into exciton dynamics and the interaction of photoexcited carriers within strongly confined nanostructures.12,13 Colloidal Ag2S NCs with sizes beyond the quantum confinement regime (i.e., particle sizes significantly larger than the exciton Bohr radius of ∼2 nm),16 typically above ∼4–6 nm, can also benefit from the MEG phenomenon as the density of excited states increases. Nevertheless, the behaviour of photoexcited states at low and high densities might differ significantly. Above the threshold density of carriers, many-body phenomena dominate relaxation processes and hence the applicability of a given material might get compromised or boosted for a certain application. Colloidal Ag2S NCs have been previously studied with transient absorption spectroscopy (TAS).14,17,18 Furthermore, TAS has been employed to follow the exciton dynamics in cation exchange CdS–Ag2S rods.19
In a recent work, we highlighted the outstanding PLQY improvement of Ag2S NCs covered by a shell that incorporates Se and Zn synthesized by hot-injection.20 The emission improvement was explained as the result of the effect of two passivation layers: an inner one composed of Ag2(S,Se) formed upon treatment with a selenium precursor and an outer one, composed of ZnS, formed after further treatment with a zinc precursor and subsequent Zn diffusion.20 In this work, TAS measurements have been conducted to provide insights into the electronic states and the dynamics of charge carriers of plain and surface-passivated Ag2S NCs to characterize their multiexciton interactions and associated decay pathways. It is found that while thermalization, trapping, and exciton recombination govern relaxation at low fluences, studies at higher fluences reveal that the photophysics is dominated by two many-body processes: biexcitons and Auger recombination.
Furthermore, by comparing the effects of surface passivation across different NCs, we demonstrate how the reduction of surface defects directly impacts on the radiative and non-radiative relaxation channels. Along with the improvement in the PLQY resulting from a decrease in defect-assisted recombination and the sharpening of excitonic resonances,21 surface passivation also lowers the exciton density threshold required for biexciton generation and Auger recombination.22,23 The enhancement of many-body phenomena together with the enhanced PLQY supports an effective passivation of surface defects.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Sketch of the Ag2S C NCs passivated upon two treatments: first with a Se precursor solution and second with a Zn precursor solution. (b) Representative HRTEM images of the Ag2S C, CS and CSS samples. Scale bars correspond to 5 nm. (c) Extinction and normalized PL intensities of Ag2S C (wine), CS (red) and CSS (orange). (d–f) PL intensity spectra of the (d) Ag2S C, (e) CS and (f) CSS NCs fitted to two Gaussian components (see the ESI† for details). The component marked in red (related to surface defects) decreases as the NCs are better passivated. |
The extinction spectra of Ag2S C, CS and CSS NCs are shown in Fig. 1c. All extinction spectra exhibit featureless profiles with strong absorption in the visible region and a long tail spanning across the visible region down to the NIR region. No excitonic resonances are observed, likely due to a combined effect of the low exciton binding energy (0.09 eV, a value obtained by applying effective mass approximation methods16) and the relatively big particle size (∼9 nm) compared to the exciton Bohr radius (2 nm), leading to the absence of confinement effects.16,21 Absorption spectra of Ag2S C ranging from ∼7 to 9 nm can be found in section S2 and Fig. S2, ESI.† The lack of excitonic resonance in the extinction spectra has also been assigned to the presence of intra gap defect states.24 Defect states are distributed along a range of energies below the conduction band (or above the valence band), blurring the excitonic resonances. The photoluminescence (PL) spectra of the three types of NCs (Fig. 1c) were examined and compared to assess the impact of the passivation layers. Starting with Ag2S C, the PL adopts the shape of a broad emission band centered at around ∼1.1 eV, characteristic of excitonic recombination. Previous work relates the broadband emission to the effect of electron–phonon coupling and defects at room temperature.25 The introduction of the first shell upon Se@TOP treatment (CS sample) causes a noticeable enhancement of the PL intensity, indicating a reduction in surface defects and non-radiative recombination channels. This trend is further amplified in the CSS structure, where the formation of the additional zinc chalcogenide layer results in an even stronger PL emission, suggesting that surface passivation is more efficient in reducing non-radiative losses. The PL spectrum of the CSS sample shows a sharper and more intense peak. The PL spectra of the three NCs diverge from a single Gaussian shape as they show two distinct Gaussian contributions centered at 1.02 and 1.09 eV, respectively (Fig. 1d–f). The emission at 1.02 eV is assigned to excitons trapped at defects in surface states while the emission at 1.09 originates from free exciton recombination.26 Free exciton recombination increases its relative weight by more than four-fold as plain Ag2S C are passivated, forming subsequently CS and CSS NCs (Fig. 1d–f). In Fig. S3 (section S3, ESI†), the central positions of peaks assigned to contributions to the PL response from free excitons and trapped excitons, along with the ratio of the intensities of the two peaks are shown. The weight increase of free exciton recombination is accompanied by a mild 9 meV blueshift in the free exciton resonance, which is related to the stoichiometric change originated from the Ag2S/Ag2(S,Se) layer and the concomitant slight change in the electronic band gap.27 The larger contribution of free excitons to the PL signal points towards an efficient surface passivation and explains the increase of PLQY values from less than 1% (for plain Ag2S C) to ca. 10% in CSS NCs.20 It is worth mentioning that the relatively large Ag2S NCs we study in this work exhibit weak electron and hole wavefunction overlap, leading to a small transition dipole moment and limiting the radiative decay. This factor, combined with slow radiative recombination rates and trap-mediated non-radiative recombination processes commonly observed in narrow-bandgap semiconductors, inherently constrains the maximum achievable PLQY for these NCs. Despite these intrinsic limitations, our synthesis and passivation strategies have demonstrated improved performance, achieving a PLQY of ∼10%, which is a reasonable value for large NCs exhibiting weak or no quantum confinement. These values can be achieved by forming a type-I core/shell structure that reduces surface defects,20,28–31 or by post-treatments.32,33 Higher PLQYs can be obtained through strong quantum confinement (i.e., reducing the particle size)34,35 or ligand exchange reactions.36 Considering an effective passivation in CSS NCs where non-radiative emission paths are only due to bulk defects, in our case, it is estimated that for Ag2S plain cores, around 91% of non-radiative paths are due to surface defects, while around 9% is due to bulk defects (see section S4, ESI† for details).
![]() | (1) |
Fig. 2a displays a density plot of ΔT/T across an entire delay window for plain Ag2S C upon pumping with 1.6 eV photons at a 0.16 mJ cm−2 fluence (upper plot) and the TAS spectra at selected delays (bottom plot). The TAS spectrum of Ag2S C is dominated by a broad positive signal centered at 1.2 eV (ground state photobleach, PB) and a negative band originating from the absorption from excited states (ESA) at energies below 1.1 eV. The PB signal accounts for the spectral signature of excitons, whereas the ESA stands for the absorption of photons from photoexcited species. The absence of quantum confinement in plain Ag2S C suggests that the ESA features may arise from intraband transitions or transitions involving defect states, such as surface states. As can be seen in Fig. 2a, the spectral evolution of Ag2S C is as follows: the initial PB (already present within pump pulse duration) is centered at 1.35 eV and undergoes a redshift and broadening in the first picoseconds, shifting the maximum by 10 meV to lower energies. On the other hand, the ESA undergoes an apparent redshift during 1 ps, which in the high energy range overlaps spectrally with the PB resonance. The temporal dynamics of both resonances are biexponential and can be satisfactorily reproduced by applying global fit analysis using a system of two linear differential equations (see sections S5 and S6, ESI†):
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
A high density of defects is expected at the surface of plain Ag2S C, leading to exciton trapping, which creates a distribution of different exciton binding energies, as evidenced by the broader PB contribution in the TAS spectra generated in the first picosecond.25 Brelle et al. proposed a triphasic relaxation dynamics in their study with an intermediate lifetime of 4 ps assigned to the evolution from shallow to deep traps.17 Since we observe a single (sub)ps process, this suggests that one type of defect dominates the photoexcited state dynamics. These defects are distributed closely below the bandgap and contribute to the broadening of the excitonic resonance (see the lower panel in Fig. 2a). Interestingly the broad PB resonance in Ag2S C narrows significantly as the first and second passivation layers are added (CS and CSS samples), as can be seen in Fig. 2b and c (lower panels). The width of the excitonic resonance in CS and CSS NCs remains roughly constant as delay evolves and undergoes a 25 meV redshift in the first picosecond after photoexcitation. When pumping with 1.6 eV photons and 0.16 mJ cm−2, the excited state temporal evolution of CS and CSS NCs is biphasic, as their behavior can be reproduced with the same sequential model, obtaining lifetimes of τ1CS = 240 fs and τ2CS = 649 ps for the CS NCs and τ1CSS = 243 fs and τ2CSS = 1043 ps for the CSS NCs. Interestingly, both τ1CS and τ1CSS decrease significantly with respect to τ1C. This acceleration aligns with the hypothesis of efficient surface defect passivation in CS and CSS NCs. When the defect density is sufficiently reduced, the corresponding process may fall below the detection threshold. Since the ∼240 fs value observed for τ1 in the passivated samples is close to our temporal resolution, a reliable comparison between τ1CS and τ1CSS is challenging. We tentatively assign τ1CS and τ1CSS to a fast thermalization process occurring, approximately, in the first 200 fs in both samples. Note that since we propose a consecutive linear model, any change in the physical interpretation of the process behind τ1 necessarily implies a different initial photoexcited state for the process described by τ2. Similarly, since the shells passivate surface traps and defects on the Ag2S cores, the non-radiative recombination pathways are expected to be reduced, which explains the larger τ2CSS when compared with that of plain Ag2S C. The non-monotonic change in τ2 for C, CS, and CSS reflects the differing nature of the initial photoexcited state in the process described by τ2. In plain Ag2S C, where τ1 is attributed to exciton trapping at defects, τ2 corresponds to the recombination of trapped excitons. In contrast, in Ag2S CS and CSS, after a fast thermalization process described by τ1, the process governed by τ2 corresponds to the recombination of free excitons. The longer τ2 observed in CSS compared to CS suggests a larger exciton diffusion distance prior to recombination, resulting from improved passivation and a lower density of recombination centers.
The passivation layers in the CS and CSS structures reduce defect density, resulting in narrower, more defined, and sharper excitonic resonances, as fewer surface-related states contribute to the ESA signal. The defect states can be due to Ag+ and S2− vacancies, which introduce long-lived states. The improved surface passivation also leads to stronger PL intensities in the CS and CSS samples, as previously evidenced in Fig. 1b. Fig. 2e and f show the temporal traces at 1.2 eV (in black) and 0.9 eV (in red) fitted according to eqn (1) and (2). It is noteworthy that the same relaxation model is able to reproduce the low pump fluence photophysics of the three samples.
Fig. 3a and b summarize the results of Ag2S C and CSS NCs upon pumping with 1.6 eV across a range of fluences from 0.16 to 1.29 mJ cm−2. The PB (1.2 eV, black dots) and ESA signals (0.95 eV, red dots) scale equally following a linear fluence dependence for both Ag2S NCs C (Fig. 3a) and CSS NCs (Fig. 3b), confirming a linear absorption regime and a linear dependence of all studied photoexcited states with pump fluence. This linearity stands as a remarkable finding, confirming that the loss of excited states by many-body effects is negligible when pumping with low energies, a result of interest for NIR imaging or luminescence nanothermometry in the NIR II window.9 In contrast, when pumping with 3.2 eV photons (Fig. 3c and d), the PB and ESA signals of Ag2S C and CSS NCs show different evolutions. The PB band (black dots) exhibits a sublinear deviation at high fluences, indicating saturation of the exciton generation in Ag2S C (Fig. 3c). In parallel, the ESA band (red dots) evolves from a linear to super-linear (quadratic) increase. Similar dependence is observed in CSS (Fig. 3d), observing saturation of the PB intensity and super-linear ESA growth. The PB intensity in CSS inverses the growth tendency and decreases the highest pump fluence. The quadratic growth of the absorption feature suggests that that spectral feature is the signature of a two-body particle. This, in addition to the saturation or decrease of the excitonic signal at higher fluences, is interpreted as the appearance of biexcitons. The ESA band centered between 1.0 and 1.1 eV stands as the biexciton spectral fingerprint. Accordingly, the drop in the PB signal in CSS at the highest fluence (Fig. 3d) is the combined result of the spectral overlap between the biexciton ESA and the exciton PB (centered at 1.2 eV) and the higher growth of the former at high fluences. Time-resolved PL measurements performed previously in C, CS and CSS confirmed multi-exponential decay with intensity-average PL lifetimes of 50 ± 4, 360 ± 3, and 817 ± 4 ns, respectively.20 These increasing values are in good agreement with the expected behavior for a better passivated NC. The different decay components are usually related to defects that can eventually constitute alternative paths for relaxation, especially at high fluences, what can be tentatively related to the sublinear deviation observed at high fluences in Fig. 3c and d. Considering the significant enhancement of photoluminescence, passivation of surface defects, and stronger saturation of exciton generation, we place further emphasis on CSS.
The temporal evolution of TAS pumped with 3.2 eV photon energy also provides further insights into the order of the decay process. |ΔT/T|−1 evolves linearly with time at longer delays (see section S5, ESI †for more details), indicating that the final recombination is also bimolecular and pointing towards Auger recombination as the dominant relaxation process.39 It is interesting to note that the |ΔT/T|−1 linear evolution is present in CSS measurements at pump fluences smaller than in Ag2S C, indicating the presence of Auger recombination also at lower fluences on CSS (Fig. S4, ESI†). The effective competition between Auger recombination and defect trapping is another signature of the efficient defect passivation of the CSS NC sample.
Since the model described in eqn (2) and (3) can no longer reproduce our data for CSS NCs pumped at 3.2 eV, we proceed to modify it by introducing two bimolecular processes, as suggested by the observed spectral and temporal evolutions. A well-established approach for experimentally extracting the dynamics of many-body phenomena is the subtractive procedure.40 However, its accuracy decreases significantly at high photoexcited state densities, leading to potential artifacts.41 Considering these limitations, we instead employed global fit analysis as the preferred fitting method using the following photophysical model.
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
![]() | (7) |
Fig. 3e displays the temporal dynamics of Ag2S C at different fluences together with the fits according to eqn (4)–(7), yielding a 500 fs time component as initial thermalization, a biexciton generation coefficient of γ2 = 1.89 × 10−25 s−1 m−3, an Auger recombination term of γ3 = 1.94 × 10−26 s−1 m−3, and a final exciton recombination with a lifetime of 517 ps. Likewise, a comparison between the temporal traces and fits of CSS NCs is shown in Fig. 3f. In CSS, thermalization of hot excitons occurs in 355 fs lifetime, followed by biexciton formation with a characteristic γ2 = 9.9 × 10−25 s−1 m−3 and recombination through Auger scattering (γ3 = 6.7 × 10−26 s−1 m−3). Finally, the remaining excitons will recombine with a lifetime of 166 ps. It is noteworthy that γ2 (γ3) are more than 5 (3) times larger in CSS, implying larger biexciton generation yields and faster non-radiative Auger recombination rates in better passivated NCs. As mentioned before, the PLQY of plain C Ag2S cores is substantially lower than that of CSS.20 The observed higher γ2 and γ3 rates in CSS compared to those in Ag2S C are not in conflict with the higher PLQY values in the former measured under photoexcitation conditions where biexciton and Auger recombination are unimportant. However, when pumping with 3.2 eV, differences in surface passivation clearly affect the non-radiative recombination pathways. In particular, the better passivated CSS system exhibits reduced defect-mediated non-radiative recombination, which causes the PLQY increase even if Auger recombination is significant. In contrast, the plain Ag2S cores suffer from higher defect-mediated recombination, reducing its efficiency (and therefore the PLQY), despite having lower biexciton and Auger constants. A higher biexciton rate constant indicates a faster radiative recombination, which may include both radiative and non-radiative components. Thus, if the radiative component is relevant, it may contribute to the highest PLQY, even if Auger recombination is present.
Hence, the relaxation pathway followed by photoexcited species at low pump fluences starts with an initial sub-picosecond cooling of photoexcited carriers and band to band recombination with a lifetime ranging from hundreds of ps up to a nanosecond, in good agreement with previous work on plain Ag2S NCs.17 When the pump fluence increases, two many-body phenomena rule the relaxation dynamics of Ag2S NCs and CSS: the generation of biexcitons at small delays and Auger recombination as the main band to band relaxation process. Finally the remaining excitons recombine in hundreds of ps.
Our findings highlight the effectiveness of surface passivation in improving the optical quality of Ag2S-based nanocrystals and underscore the importance of controlling the exciton density for studying many-body interactions in these materials. We have found that the core/shell/shell system shows reduced trap-mediated paths and faster multi-exciton recombination dynamics. These NCs, in particular, demonstrate significant promise for optoelectronic and nanomedicine applications, where enhanced photoluminescence and reduced nonradiative recombination are desirable.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5nr00511f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |