Open Access Article
Irwan Saleh Kurniawan†
ab,
Russel Cruz Sevilla†ab,
Hsiu-Ming Hsu†ab,
Ruth Jeane Soebrotoab,
Chii-Bin Wuab,
Ji-Lin Shen
ab,
Hsiu-Ying Huang*ab,
Wen-Chung Li*abc and
Chi-Tsu Yuan
*ab
aDepartment of Physics, Chung Yuan Christian University, Taoyuan, Taiwan. E-mail: estion53@yahoo.com.tw; ctyuan@cycu.edu.tw
bResearch Center for Semiconductor Materials and Advanced Optics, Chung Yuan Christian University, Taoyuan, Taiwan
cLEAP Semiconductor Corporation, Taoyuan, Taiwan. E-mail: wenchunglee@leap-semi.com
First published on 3rd December 2025
Threading dislocations (TDs) are the most abundant extended defects in highly n-doped SiC (n+-SiC) substrates. Notably, only a small subset, those hosting deep states (DS-TDs), can potentially impact device operation. However, selective detection of such electrically active DS-TDs using conventional photoluminescence (PL) techniques remains challenging due to universal PL quenching across all defects. Here, we develop confocal subsurface defect-PL spectro-microscopy to selectively detect screw-component DS-TDs (DS-STDs) in n+-SiC substrates. By directly photoionizing the occupied deep states, DS-STD-specific emissions can be activated. Such inherent deep-level emissions of dislocation lines, combined with external surface-state emissions at the etch pits, enable the reconstruction of 3D images with high contrast for the partially etched DS-STDs. This approach overcomes the limitations of conventional PL and paves the way for non-destructive, in-line inspection of electrically active dislocations even in highly doped SiC substrates.
Certain TDs have been identified as leakage current paths and charge trapping centers, thus classifying them as device-killing extended defects for power devices.12–14 These electrically active TDs host deep states within the bandgap (hereafter referred to as DS-TDs), spatially distributed along the entire dislocation lines. As a result, charge carriers can be trapped, generated, and recombined through these deep states, contributing to reverse leakage current via mechanisms such as trap-assisted tunneling and the Poole–Frenkel emission effect.15–17
It should be noted that such DS-TDs constitute only a small subset of all TDs but play a critical role in determining device yield, performance, and reliability.12,18,19 For instance, X. Zhang et al. investigated the correlation between the failed dies of Schottky barrier diodes (SBDs) and threading screw dislocations (TSDs) in the substrates. They found that TSDs were observed around the breakdown sites of most failed dies, but not vice versa, as abundant TSDs existed without causing device breakdown.18 In addition, A. Severino et al. investigated the correlation between TDs and failed MOSFET devices after reliability testing and also emphasized the roles of certain TDs in substrates.12 Recently, dislocation-related leakage current paths in 4H-SiC were investigated using a combination of conductive atomic force microscopy and KOH etching.19 The study revealed that both TSDs and TMDs have a greater impact on reverse leakage current compared to TEDs.
Due to their critical roles in power devices, the development of optical techniques for nondestructively detecting TDs, particularly electrically active DS-TDs in SiC substrates, is highly desirable.20–22 Photoluminescence (PL)-based methods are noncontact optical techniques commonly used to nondestructively inspect various defects in semiconductors based on defect-induced band-edge emission quenching.23–25 In general, defects can trap the charge carriers and act as nonradiative recombination centers, thus reducing band-edge emissions and forming a PL-dark region.26 Consequently, the intensity difference in band-edge emissions between the background matrix and the defects can create imaging contrast, providing information about defect locations.
So far, several types of extended defects, such as TDs and stacking faults, have been visualized using PL-quenching imaging techniques in SiC epilayers with low dopant concentrations.26,27 By laboriously mitigating the Z1/2 centers by post-oxidation, etching and passivation, TDs in SiC epilayers can be observed using such PL-dark mode in band-edge PL mapping.28 These additional post-treatments are required for reducing the defect density and increasing the carrier lifetimes, thereby enhancing the imaging contrast.29 Unfortunately, this technique fails in highly n-doped substrates with high defect/impurity density and short carrier lifetimes, where imaging contrast is diminished due to universal band-edge PL quenching caused by abundant background defects/impurities.30,31 More importantly, conventional band-edge PL quenching methods cannot selectively visualize electrically active DS-TDs and provide crucial electronic information about their defect nature.
To address these issues, we developed a confocal subsurface defect-PL spectro-microscopy technique with a PL-active mode, enabling selective detection of electrically active screw-TDs with deep states (DS-STDs) in n+-SiC substrates. By photo-ionizing the occupied deep states, only DS-STDs can be brightened among all STDs, thus generating broadband visible-range deep-state emissions. Such DS-STD-specific emissions enable 2D subsurface imaging with ultrahigh contrast, while facilitating the reconstruction of distortion-free 3D images. Additionally, we investigated the correlation between etch pit morphology and optical features of dislocation lines to further identify the defect nature of DS-STDs. Our work demonstrates a powerful optical technique for nondestructively detecting DS-STDs even in highly n-doped SiC substrates, while providing valuable insights into their optical fingerprints and defect characteristics.
Unlike conventional PL-dark mode imaging, we aim to develop an optical technique that exclusively visualizes the DS-TDs among TDs in a PL-active mode, as schematically illustrated in Fig. 1(a). Such electrically active DS-TDs can also become optically active by direct photoionization of their occupied deep states. Fig. 1(b) illustrates the physical concept underlying our approach based on a configuration coordinate diagram for describing direct defect photoionization and defect emission processes, which has been applied for the explanation of electronic–vibronic transitions of deep-level defects in wide-bandgap semiconductors.32,33
To elucidate the defect photoionization and following emission processes, we assume that the DS-TDs involve negatively charged acceptor-type deep states, which serves as an illustrative example.34,35 By direct photoionization, the defect system can form coordinate-displaced excited states, consisting of free electrons in the conduction band and localized bound-holes at acceptor-type deep states (A− + hνSG → A0 + e−). Subsequently, the free electrons can recombine with the bound holes (A0 + e− → A− + hνDPL), producing defect-specific emission (defect-PL), which would be a specific optical feature for defect identification.
To test this hypothesis, defect-selective etching was intentionally employed to delineate dislocation etch pits (DEPs) in n+-SiC substrates, as illustrated in Fig. 1(c). The anisotropic etching process preferentially removes atoms at an enhanced rate in the strained regions surrounding dislocations, thereby making the DEPs visible on the surface while leaving the corresponding dislocation lines beneath.35 Revealing DEPs is beneficial for locating dislocations for subsequent optical probing and provides valuable structural indications; however, detailed structural information cannot be determined solely from their DEP morphology. It should be emphasized that the main advance of this work lies in the optical detection and characterization of electrically active TDs with deep states, as well as in establishing their correlation with etch-pit morphology. In fact, pre-etching the samples is not necessary for TD inspection once the optical fingerprints of electrically active DS-TDs are identified, which is the main objective of this study.
With the assistance of the DEPs, we can apply our developed technique, confocal subsurface defect-PL spectro-microscopy, to probe individual TD lines beneath the DEPs (Fig. 1(c)). Probing deep-subsurface TD lines, away from the DEPs, is crucial to capture the inherent deep-state emissions specific to the dislocation lines of DS-TDs. This approach helps eliminate interference from extrinsic surface-state emissions on the hexagonal facets of the DEPs, which can be unavoidably introduced during the chemical etching process.
Here, we focus primarily on STDs owing to their significant influence on device performance and reliability, serving as leakage current paths and potential nucleation sites for other extended defects within epitaxial layers.12,18,19 After selecting specific STDs, confocal dual-mode mapping was conducted, including both laser backscattering mode and defect-PL mode, to simultaneously examine the surface DEPs and subsurface TD lines, as well as perform cross-sectional mapping (without depth correction) for the partially etched TD configuration. Fig. 2(b) and (c) present laser backscattering images of the surface and cross-sectional planes for a selected STD. This direct depth-profile mapping has been used for distinguishing the types of TDs, but it unfortunately suffers from significant imaging distortion due to spherical aberration caused by the large refractive index mismatch between the sample and the environment.36,37 Therefore, obtaining calibrated depth profiles is essential for accurate analysis, as will be demonstrated later.
The corresponding defect-PL images are shown in Fig. 2(d) and (e), revealing numerous bright defects on the hexagonal facets of the DEPs, which were externally introduced by the defect-selective etching process. Notably, such foreign defects are absent during nondestructive TD inspection (without chemical etching) and are therefore irrelevant to this study. However, they can brighten the DEP region in the partially etched TD configuration. Remarkably, bright emissions spatially distributed along the TD lines beneath the DEPs are clearly visible in the cross-sectional defect-PL mapping. It should be noted that these emissions originate specifically from the dislocation lines rather than from the etch pits, owing to spatial filtering through the confocal pinhole. Moreover, such unique emissions appear only in a small subset of STDs and can be attributed to those possessing inherent deep states, herein referred to as DS-STD-specific emissions.
Fig. 3(a) and (b) present representative 2D subsurface defect-PL images for two STD lines with similar DEP morphologies (additional data available in Fig. S2). In Fig. 3(a), a bright emission spot attributed to DS-STD-specific emissions is clearly visible, exhibiting ultrahigh imaging contrast and spatial resolution even in highly n-doped SiC substrates, referred to as bright DS-STDs. In contrast, Fig. 3(b) shows no such emission, and these are thus classified as dark STDs. Notably, dark STDs can still exhibit bright DEPs due to externally created defect emissions, but appear dark along the dislocation lines due to the absence of inherent deep states. This finding demonstrates that structurally similar STDs (reflected in comparable DEPs) exhibit distinct electronic transitions. The pronounced disparity indicates that the occurrence of deep-state emissions is not solely determined by the TD types. Instead, additional, unidentified factors play a crucial role in synergistically influencing the formation of deep electronic states.
To quantify the imaging contrast, we used the contrast ratio metric, defined as
, where ISTD and IB denote the mean of defect-PL intensity of DS-STD-specific emissions and the background intensity, respectively. A larger CR value indicates better imaging contrast and higher visibility for defect inspection. Fig. 3(c) presents the intensity profile of the bright spots along the dotted lines (inset in Fig. 3(c)). The full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the intensity profile is ∼1.3 µm, and an ultrahigh CR value of ∼700 was achieved. This performance is particularly challenging for TD inspection based on conventional nondestructive techniques, such as band-edge PL quenching and X-ray topography.20,28,38
It is observed that the spot sizes of DS-STD-specific emissions in defect-PL imaging, even when probing deep subsurface regions in SiC substrates with high refractive index mismatch, are approximately ∼1.3 µm, primarily constrained by optical diffraction. In contrast, spatial resolution in conventional PL quenching and X-ray topography is often largely degraded by the convolution of carrier diffusion lengths or strain fields. The underlying detection mechanism of our technique, PL-active mode via deep-state emission, ensures immunity to these limitations. Therefore, we refer to this as optical diffraction-limited spatial resolution, in contrast to carrier diffusion-limited spatial resolution. Consequently, our approach is applicable across all regions of SiC materials and devices. As a result, our unique technique can be applied for probing individual DS-TDs within defect clusters, which may critically impact device performance.18
Fig. 4(a) and (b) show the 3D images of bright DS-STDs and dark STDs, reconstructed from 2D-stack mapping with depth correction. For bright DS-STDs, both DEPs and tilted dislocation lines are clearly visible, whereas only the DEPs are observed for dark STDs. To investigate potential correlations between the DEP morphology (related to TD structures) and DS-STD-specific emissions, lateral-slicing images at various depths (0, 40, 80 µm) were extracted from 3D images for DS-STDs and STDs, as shown in Fig. 5(a) and (b). Additionally, cross-sectional images were also generated by orthogonal slicing, as depicted in Fig. 5(c) and (d). Using our technique, we can reconstruct depth-corrected 3D images and extract 2D images of the partially etched TD configuration for two structurally similar but electronically distinct STDs, providing deeper insights into electrically active DS-STDs. It should be noted that our optical technique cannot unequivocally distinguish TSDs from TMDs based solely on etch-pit morphology and inclination angles, but it does provide optical access to structural information for both defect types.
By carefully examining lateral and cross-sectional images, we found that the DEPs of both STDs exhibited similar combined features, that is, an end tip beneath the hexagonal stage, which is the characteristic of the TMDs.39,40 In this case, two inclination angles relative to the surface plane, denoted as α and β, were defined for the analysis of depth profiles (Fig. 5(c)). A detailed comparison of the depth profiles revealed that bright DS-STDs typically exhibited a larger difference between α and β (here β − α ∼ 15°).
We have applied our technique to probe over 300 individual STDs, aiming to gather statistical data and quantify the prevalence of electrically active DS-STDs among STDs. Interestingly, the majority of STDs (∼93%) exhibited no deep-state emissions from their dislocation lines, indicating the absence of deep states for most STDs. It should be noted that this prevalence is specific to the substrate type, doping concentration, and measurement conditions and should not be generalized as a universal value. This finding is consistent with the previous reports based on electrical measurements in SiC power devices, which also suggested that only a small subset of STDs adversely impacts device performance and reliability.12,18,19,41
To further investigate their electronic nature, power-dependent deep-state emission measurements were performed, as shown in Fig. 6(b), revealing a slight blue shift in the defect-PL maximum with increasing excitation power, suggesting donor–acceptor-pair (DAP)-type emissions. Notably, these DAP-type emissions are attributed to donor-type and acceptor-type defect states created within the bandgap, rather than impurity-related donors and acceptors, as will be further discussed later.
However, this method was limited by both imaging contrast (∼0.4) and spatial resolution (∼16 µm) for the TSDs. Additionally, the PL-quenching method can differentiate dislocation types only for treated SiC epilayers with low defect density and low impurity concentrations, but it cannot identify whether TDs are killing or benign. The same group also attempted to identify the TDs in n+-SiC substrates using NIR-PL imaging under UV excitation.30 While this approach revealed TDs as dark spots in the NIR-PL images, it again suffered from low contrast, limited spatial resolution, and a lack of selectivity for TDs with deep states.
Commercially available surface inspection tools, such as KLA Candela and Lasertec SICA, which integrate optical inspection techniques with PL channels, are widely used in industry for nondestructive inspection of extended defects in SiC epilayers, such as stacking faults and surface topographic defects.42,43 However, these surface-sensitive tools are ineffective for detecting TDs due to the weak or nonexistent optically detectable surface features and their nanoscale physical size of TDs.24 Consequently, significant discrepancies have been reported even for SiC wafers with similar quality from the same vendors. Furthermore, abundant impurities and subsurface damage can further degrade the performance of these tools by disabling PL channels (PL-dark modes) in SiC bulk substrates.31,44
Despite widespread adoption in both academia and industry, PL-based techniques still face several critical limitations and challenges in the inspection of electrically active TDs. First, all TD types, as well as all dislocations within the same type, can serve as nonradiative recombination centers, universally quenching the band-edge emissions and impeding the selective detection of device-relevant TDs. Second, imaging contrast and spatial resolution are constrained by carrier diffusion lengths, limiting these techniques only to laboriously treated SiC epilayers with long carrier lifetimes, while they fail to work for highly defective n+-SiC substrates. Lastly, the band-edge PL quenching method provides no electronic information about the nature of the defects.
To provide a comprehensive comparison of PL-based techniques, a comparison table focusing on image quality, technique capabilities, and applicability is included (Fig. S5 for more details). This table compares confocal mapping of band-edge emission, PL imaging with a camera, two-photon excitation of band-edge emission, and commercially available inspection tools with our developed technique. Clearly, our technique outperforms existing methods in imaging quality, capability, and applicability.
Recently, conventional 3D laser scanning confocal microscopy with above-bandgap excitation has been employed to study the morphology and defect emissions of the DEPs (rather than the dislocation lines).34,35 It is important to note that these studies primarily focus on the interaction between band-edge emissions and newly created external defects at the etch pits, rather than the inherent deep states of electrically active TDs. In contrast, while we also delineated DEPs to locate the positions of TDs, our primary focus is on the specific emissions originating from the inherent deep states of the dislocation lines. In addition, this partially etched TD configuration—comprising both DEPs and dislocation lines—provides an opportunity to further investigate the correlation between the TD structures (revealed by the DEPs) and the optical features of the dislocation lines.
Such STDs with deep states are electrically active and capable of bridging terminals, thereby forming leakage current paths through continuous deep states. Similarly, these DS-STDs are also optically active and can be selectively excited via the same deep states, producing DS-STD-specific emissions that enable nondestructive defect inspection. This concept is analogous to the light-driven deep-level transient spectroscopy technique, which uses light pulses to excite deep-level defects.
Footnote |
| † Irwan Saleh Kurniawan, Russel Cruz Sevilla and Hsiu-Ming Hsu contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |