Sonja
Storch
ab,
Davide
Campagna
ab,
Simay
Aydonat
abc and
Robert
Göstl
*abc
aDWI – Leibniz Institute for Interactive Materials, Forckenbeckstr. 50, Aachen 52056, Germany. E-mail: goestl@uni-wuppertal.de
bInstitute of Technical and Macromolecular Chemistry, RWTH Aachen University, Worringerweg 2, Aachen 5207, 4, Germany
cDepartment of Chemistry and Biology, University of Wuppertal, Gaußstr. 20, Wuppertal 42119, Germany
First published on 18th December 2024
Force-activated functional groups in polymers may inform the design of future smart materials in which mechanical events trigger productive chemistry. The availability of such mechanochemically active tools (mechanophores) is perpetually increasing, but the limited understanding of mechanochemical reactivity complicates the identification of new molecular motifs that render reactive groups accessible by force. Here, we expand the chemical scope of our previously reported carbamoyloxime mechanophore motif from latent secondary to tertiary amines by harnessing the reactivity of transient nitrogen-centred radicals formed in the mechanochemical reaction pathway. Carbamoyloximes are modified with an N-pentenyl substituent which undergoes a consecutive intramolecular 5-exo-trig ring-closing reaction with an aminyl radical generated upon force-induced homolytic scission of the mechanophore, thereby enabling the hitherto unexplored mechanochemical activation of latent tertiary amines. We therefore show that carbamoyloxime mechanophores are nitrogen-centred mechanoradical generators expanding the chemical space of polymer mechanochemistry.
To date, the activation or release of a variety of chemical functionalities has been reported including acids,15–17 active metal centres,18–22 carbenes,23 and persistent radicals.24,25 However, the discovery of new force-accessible functional groups remains complicated due to a limited understanding of mechanochemical reactivity.26,27 Consecutive cascade reactions of mechanochemically generated transient species are hence a plausible strategy to increase the accessible chemical space using available mechanophores.28 This has been demonstrated for simple moieties, such as azo or disulfide bonds, which undergo homolytic cleavage under force.29,30 For example, the highly reactive radical species resulting from azo bond cleavage have been used for self-amplifying downstream processes, such as polymerization and self-immolation,31,32 or sonopharmacology.33 Disulfide breakage, on the other hand, generates a thiyl radical and subsequently a thiol whose nucleophilic character has been used to induce intramolecular cyclization reactions, for payload release from carbonates and carbamates.34–36
Other concepts have been developed to enable the mechanochemical activation of primary amines through hydrolysis of imine functions generated from aziridines37 or through the release of small molecules from latent carbamates.36,38–41 Moreover, we have recently achieved the activation of a chemically useful secondary amine using carbamoyloxime mechanophores.42 While latent mechanoresponsive primary and secondary amines for the incorporation into polymers are thus available, tertiary amines are still lacking despite their broad use as organic bases or organocatalysts for polymer-related applications, such as the synthesis of epoxy resins,43 polyurethanes,44 or vitrimers.45
The underlying challenge of the mechanochemical activation of latent tertiary amines is the requisite mechanophore bond scission. Therefore, generating tertiary amines by simply using one of the established pathways for mechanochemical amine generation with an adjusted number of N-substituents is either not possible in the case of the aziridine mechanophore given the hydrolysis step that furnishes the amine, or would correspond to a hypothetical carbamate of a quaternary ammonium ion, which does not exist.
Here, we demonstrate the mechanochemical activation of a latent tertiary amine through a reaction pathway of a suitably modified carbamoyloxime mechanophore. Therefore, we exploit the formation of reactive transient nitrogen-centred radicals to enable a consecutive intramolecular ring-closing reaction (Scheme 1). The mechanochemical reaction pathway of carbamoyloximes has been investigated by us previously.42,46 Overstretching induces homolytic N–O bond scission, which on the one side produces an iminyl radical that reacts to an imine function and subsequently hydrolyzes to a ketone if the α-substituent is not H. The transient carbamoyloxyl radical formed on the other side decarboxylates to give an aminyl radical, which can take up an H-atom to afford a secondary amine. Nitrogen-centred radical species are considered versatile synthons for the construction of N-heterocycles due to their reactivity toward sp2-systems, yielding, e.g., lactams, pyridines, quinolines, or pyrrolidines.47,48 One important pathway toward nitrogen-containing cyclic moieties are intramolecular ring-closing reactions yielding the kinetically preferred exo-product.49 The reaction rate hereby depends on the nucleophilicity of the respective nitrogen-centred radical, which in the case of aminyl radicals leads to a significant increase in reaction rate for the protonated aminium radical.47,50 Additionally, hydrogen atom donors (HAD) can be employed to terminate the forming cyclic carbon radical species, shifting the equilibrium to the product side.47,50 Here, we make use of the aminyl radical species formed upon activation of the carbamoyloxime mechanophore for a consecutive intramolecular 5-exo-trig ring-closing reaction,51 thereby demonstrating the unprecedented mechanochemical activation of latent tertiary amines in polymers.
Subsequently, we analyzed the mechanochemical scission kinetics of 6. Despite introducing the N-pentenyl substituent in a location distant to the initial mechanochemical bond scission site, we evaluated potential deviations between the N–O bond of MKO and 6. Therefore, we performed CoGEF26,52 simulations which qualitatively suggested a probable activation of the targeted N–O bond (Fig. S1†).
Furthermore, we successfully verified the accelerated bond scission of 6 subjected to ultrasound (yielding US-6) using an immersion probe sonicator at 20 kHz. We compared the apparent scission rate to pristine PMA (Fig. 1) and determined an average mechanochemical selectivity of bond scission of 40% (Table S4†), which is comparable to our previously reported carbamoyloxime mechanophores.42,46
The molar mass distribution (MMD) of 6 showed a shoulder toward higher M which could possibly arise from bimolecular termination during the polymerization. However, the same shoulder appeared in all MMDs obtained after repeating the polymerization of 6 (Fig. S40†). We therefore suspected the fractional incorporation of the N-pentenyl substituent double bond. This was further supported by the uniform MMD of a control carbamoyloxime mechanophore polymer c6 that featured an aliphatic N-substituent (Fig. S28†). This issue could potentially be resolved by identification of a monomer that would undergo stronger ideal, non-azeotropic copolymerization with the pentenyl moiety. Since, however, the monomer choice was limited to ensure efficient force transmission during ultrasonication53,54 and the loss of the double bond was not within the detectable range of 1H NMR analysis (Fig. S39†), we considered the amount of incorporated double bond to have a negligible impact.
We then investigated the targeted 5-exo-trig cyclization upon activation of 6 by US. As described above, addition of a weak acid enhanced the reactivity by protonating the aminyl radical and a suitable HAD trapped the ring-closed carbon radical 10 (Scheme 3a). Ultrasonication of 6 was therefore carried out in different conditions: without the addition of additives (Table 1, entries 1a–c), in presence of malonic acid (A, Table 1, entries 2a–c), and in presence of A and 1–4 cyclohexadiene (CHD) as HAD (Table 1, entries 3a–c). Each experiment was analyzed by GPC and 1H NMR spectroscopy and the overall fraction of polymer chain scission f, the chain scission selectivity for mechanophore activation S, the fraction of activated mechanophore xact, and the fractional decrease of the N-pentenyl double bond in the formed products xd were determined (Tables 1, S4, and S5†). To exclude any potential uncontrolled chemical transformation or degradation of the mechanophore, specifically, the N-pentenyl double bond, in the presence of A and CHD during ultrasonication, we verified the stability of the small molecule 5 toward acidic environment (Fig. S3†) as well as during ultrasonication of pristine PMA in the presence of A and CHD (Fig. S5†).48,50
Entry | Reactants | f | S , /% | x act | x d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Determined by GPC. b Determined by 1H NMR. c NMR spectra shown in Fig. 3. | |||||
1a | 6 | 1.58 | 29 | 0.46 | 0.45 |
2a | 6 + A | 1.36 | 31 | 0.42 | 0.77 |
3a | 6 + A + HAD | 1.09 | 36 | 0.40 | 0.99 |
1b | 6 | 0.99 | 33 | 0.33 | 0.48 |
2b | 6 + A | 1.04 | 38 | 0.40 | 0.81 |
3b | 6 + A + HAD | 1.14 | 43 | 0.50 | 1.13 |
1cc | 6 | 0.78 | 45 | 0.35 | 0.64 |
2cc | 6 + A | 0.87 | 50 | 0.44 | 0.93 |
3cc | 6 + A + HAD | 0.91 | 49 | 0.45 | 1.10 |
3dc | c6 + A + HAD + olefin | 0.76 | 42 | 0.35 | 0 |
Considering the reaction pathway of the (protonated) aminyl radical 8, two scenarios were possible: (i) cyclization and formation of the tertiary amine 11. (ii) No cyclization yielding the secondary amine 9. Other cyclization modes using aminyl or aminium radicals are kinetically unlikely.47,48 Evaluating the products of this reaction thus posed a challenge as it required the differentiation between a chain-terminal secondary and tertiary amine. We employed Rhodamine B isothiocyanate (RhBITC) as selective labelling agent for secondary amines being unreactive towards tertiary amines55 (Fig. S7†) to treat 6 after US (Scheme 3a). This allowed to compare the fraction of secondary amine formed in different reaction conditions.
Comparing the relative UV absorption by GPC of RhBITC-treated US-6 with and without addition of A and HAD, respectively, elucidated the influence of cyclization-promoting additives on the amount of formed secondary amine 9 during the mechanochemical reaction. US-6 was washed with 1 M aqueous NaOH solution prior to the reaction with RhBITC to receive amines instead of ammonium salts formed due to the presence of A during sonication, and a threefold determination was performed (Fig. 2). Addition of A decreased the degree of functionalization with RhB and even more so when HAD was added, indicating diminished competing formation of secondary amines in reaction conditions favorable for the 5-exo-trig cyclization.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a–c) GPC elugrams in THF with UV-vis detector of 9-RhB after sonication in triplicate with different additives. Annotations in the legends of the graphs are referenced to the entries in Table 1. Absorption was normalized and corrected by the fraction of activated mechanophore xact. |
Direct analysis of 11 by 1H NMR via the 2-methylpyrrolidine moiety that could be distinguished from the signals of 9 was hampered due to overlapping polymer backbone signals. Tertiary amine formation could however be estimated from diagnostic changes in observable signals of carbamoyloxime moieties before and after mechanochemical activation. Fig. 3a shows the included aromatic protons of starting material 6, the iminyl pathway products (imine and ketone function) accounting for the amount of activated 6, and the vinylic proton of the N-pentenyl substituent, for which the chemical shift was the same before (6) and after (9) mechanophore cleavage (Fig. S36†), unless the double bond was consumed during cyclization.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 1H NMR analysis of the mechanochemical reaction of 6. (a) Scheme denoting all measured protons. From top to bottom 1H NMR spectra corresponding to (b) starting material 6, (c) US-6 (Table 1, entry 1c), (d) US-6 + A (Table 1, entry 2c), (e) US-6 + A + HD (Table 1, entry 3c), and (f) control US-c6 (Table 1, entry 3d). |
To ensure that the double bond only reacted during cyclization, a control mechanophore c6 with N-alkyl substituent to prevent intramolecular ring-closing was incorporated into linear PMA (Scheme 3b) and ultrasonicated in cyclization-promoting conditions along with a small molecule vinyl control (Table 1, entry 3d). After sonication, the double bond of the vinyl control was found unaltered, indicating absence of a competing intermolecular reaction (Fig. 3f). Thus, the intramolecular 5-exo-trig cyclization for ultrasonicated 6 could be monitored by the decrease of the vinylic proton signal of the N-pentenyl substituent. Upon ring-closing, the double bond would react to tertiary amine 11 and the corresponding vinylic proton signal therefore would disappear, whereas if no cyclization would take place, secondary amine 9 would form, and the signal would remain unchanged. The decrease of the double bond upon mechanochemical activation was therefore quantified by 1H NMR (Table 1) using the signal integrals of remaining starting material 6 (Fig. 3, Hb), products from the iminyl pathway (Hb′ and Hb′′), and double bond signal (Ha).
The decrease of the double bond followed the expected reactivity trend of the 5-exo-trig cyclization: no additives < A < A + HAD (Table 1), which was in accordance with and reinforced the results of the previous RhBITC-labelling experiment. The measured values xd > 1 were attributed to the limited sensitivity and resolution of NMR measurements toward polymer end groups and suggested a slight general overestimation of the determined values. However, the qualitatively observed overall reactivity trend was validated with the consistent threefold determinations which yielded significantly differing xd depending on the employed reaction conditions. Since the control experiments excluded significant side reactions in which the double bond function was involved, its consumption during irradiation with US was plausibly traced back to mechanochemically induced ring-closing, yielding 11 as tertiary amine.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4mr00099d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |