Lyndsey Hendriks
*a,
Matthias Egger
bc and
Denise M. Mitrano
d
aInstitute of Analytical Chemistry, University of Vienna, Währingerstraße 38, 1090 Vienna, Austria. E-mail: lyndsey.hendriks@univie.ac.at
bThe Ocean Cleanup, Coolsingel 6, 3011 AD Rotterdam, The Netherlands
cEmpaqtify, Ullmannstrasse 13a, 9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland
dDepartment of Environmental Systems Science, ETH Zurich, Universitätstrasse 16, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
First published on 8th September 2025
Plastic pollution in marine environments poses ecological risks, in part because plastic debris can release hazardous substances, such as metal-based additives. While microplastics have received considerable attention as vectors of contaminants, less is known about larger macroplastics and their role in the spatial and temporal redistribution of substances. In this study, pristine, store-bought plastic items and macroplastics recovered from the North Pacific Subtropical Gyre (NPSG) were analysed using Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) to identify polymer types, and bulk acid digestion followed by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) for total metal quantification. These techniques were complemented by high resolution elemental mapping by Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICP-TOFMS). Detailed elemental maps revealed native metal distribution in pristine plastics, and evidence of both sorption and intrinsic metal depletion in weathered plastics. In particular, weathered plastics showed surface depletion of intrinsic metals, and enrichment of seawater-derived elements (e.g., Na, Mg, I). Linear regressions were used to quantify spatial distribution trends across cross sections, providing statistical support for directional gradients. Since pristine and weathered plastics were opportunistically collected, variability in product type, polymer chemistry, and weathering time limited direct comparisons. Instead, this study demonstrates the utility of LA-ICP-TOFMS for mapping elemental distribution in plastics, offering a novel analytical approach for investigating spatial metal distribution in plastics and laying the groundwork for future studies on weathering processes in marine environments.
Understanding the interactions between plastics, their additives, and marine environments necessitates advanced and robust analytical tools. While techniques such as Fourier-Transform Infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and Raman spectroscopy provide valuable insights into polymer composition and weathering processes,20 these techniques cannot detect the incorporation, absorption or leaching of inorganic species contained within the plastic. Understanding the spatial distribution of metals within plastic—both in pristine and weathered states—is critical for evaluating metal-plastics dynamics. A variety of techniques are available to detect metals on material surfaces, including Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDX), X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS).21,22 Historically applied in materials sciences for characterizing coatings on metals and in earth sciences for studying isotopic variations and trace element zoning in minerals,23 LA-ICP-MS has recently been adopted for analysing weathered microplastics (MPs).24–26 LA-ICP-MS has successfully been used to generate metal concentration profiles in MPs collected from marine systems by analysing their subsurface layers (∼200 μm).24 Their study provided critical insight into the distinction between sorbed and intrinsic metal distributions, but was limited to near-surface regions. Building on this, a subsequent study advanced this approach by combining LA-ICP-MS and Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) to study biofilm covered MPs in controlled freshwater and wastewater settings.26 Their results confirmed that laser-based techniques can successfully be applied to monitor both leaching and adsorption processes, although the focus remained on smaller MPs and controlled ageing. While MPs have garnered significant attention due to their small size and widespread distribution, macroplastics, offer distinct analytical advantages due to their larger physical dimensions. These include easier handling, and the possibility to obtain cross-sections for internal versus external regions of interest. This makes them particularly suitable for studying spatially resolved metal distributions, including potential leaching of intrinsic additives or sorption of environmental contaminants. Although it remains uncertain how these patterns translate to MPs, macroplastic items provide an important opportunity to examine early-stage weathering processes and the redistribution of metals within the plastic matrix.
Thus, building upon previous work, here we present a novel application of Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICP-TOFMS) to analyse pristine plastics and naturally weathered plastic items collected from the North Pacific Garbage Patch (NPGP).5,27 A focused laser beam is used to raster across the sample surface, ablating material that is then transported to the ICP-TOFMS for analysis. Each shot corresponds to an individual pixel in the resulting map, allowing LA-ICP-TOMFS to generate high-resolution elemental maps of solid samples.28 A key advantage of using a TOFMS-detector lies in its ability to simultaneously detect the full suite of elements across a broad mass range (m/z 14 to 254),29,30 which provides a complete and comprehensive picture of the metals embedded and associated with the plastic samples. Comparing environmental weathered plastic items with new, store-bought, counterparts, provides a deeper understanding of how the metals distribution in the plastic could change due to exposure to sunlight, seawater, and mechanical stress in marine environments. The recorded elemental patterns revealed localized enrichments, depletion zones, and directional gradients—patterns that offer insights into the extent of metal leaching over time. Consequently, this proof-of-concept study takes a step forward in providing high-resolution elemental maps to reveal spatial patterns that emerge after environmental exposure.
Pristine plastics (P1–P8) were purchased from local stores in Switzerland in 2024, and were used to assess the variability and homogeneity of metal distribution as initially produced. This included two toothbrushes, a plastic handle, a plastic dinosaur toy, a vertical bouncer fish as well as common laboratory items such as PTFE tubing.
Ocean-weathered plastics (W1–W8), which were weathered under natural conditions for unknown amounts of time, were collected by The Ocean Cleanup (see Fig. S1 for an overview). These samples were recovered from the NPGP, an open ocean plastic accumulation area located between California and Hawaii, between 2015 and 2018. Plastics afloat in these offshore waters have been shown to often be decades old.31,32 A detail description of the sampling area and procedure can be found elsewhere.27
While the pristine and weathered plastics were opportunistically collected and thus differed in product type and chemistry, our goal was to use the pristine samples as a baseline for native metal distribution, allowing for comparison with the weathered counterparts. Metal content and distributions vary with product manufacturing, thus our results illustrate general patterns rather than absolute concentrations across all plastics.
On each plastic cross section, a lasso-pattern, which allowed to flexibly outline irregularly shaped samples, was set up before being scanned by the laser. The analysis of a greater proportion of the sample is expected to be more representative of the average value of the elemental intensity compared to focusing on individual spots or lines. The specific ablated areas used for analysis are highlighted in blue in Table S1.
Additionally, to evaluate whether the observed elemental profiles reflect meaningful directional trends or random variation, we applied simple linear regression fits to the central portion of each normalized intensity profile, excluding the rise and tail regions to minimize edge-related effects. Three metrics were extracted from each regression: the slope, the coefficient of determination (R2) and the p-value for the slope. The R2-value quantifies the goodness of fit to a linear model; values closer to 1 indicate a stronger correlation. The p-value assesses whether the observed slope differs significantly from zero. A p-value < 0.05 is considered statistically significant, supporting the observation of an actual gradient rather than random variation.
The metal content quantification by bulk ICP-MS revealed the presence of various metals in both pristine and weathered samples, with varying concentrations ranging from μg kg−1 to mg kg−1 (see Fig. S2, and Table S5 for LOQs). Different metals are commonly used as additives or stabilizers in plastic production,11 which explains their presence in these samples. Predominant analytes observed were Na, Mg, Al, Ca, Ti, Fe, Zn, Ba and Pb. Sodium sulfate (NaSO4), magnesium silicates – also known as talk, calcium carbonate (CaCO3), zinc oxides and barium sulfate (BaSO4) are common plastic filler materials and stabilizers while Al, Ti and Pb are used as inorganic pigments, which explains their high abundances.11 While the original plastic manufacturing recipe is unknown for each item, the recorded values are within the same range as reported values from previous studies investigating metal content in plastics.11,35,39 Item P6, a blue plastic handle, exhibited elevated concentrations of Na, Al and Cr in the mg kg−1 range. Given its distinct blue colour, these elements are likely associated with the presence of blue pigments such as ultramarine blue—a sulfur-containing sodium aluminosilicate—and potential chromium-based compounds, which are occasionally used to modify colour tone or arise from recycled pigment mixtures. Interestingly, trace levels of rare earth elements (REE), comprising the fifteen lanthanide elements (La through to Lu, plus Y and Sc) were detected in items P2 and P6, suggesting that these could be recycled plastics.40 Weathered samples generally exhibited a slight increase in the concentration of Se and Cd indicating that the weathering process may lead to the sorption of certain metals from the surrounding environment. However, it should be noted that a clear distinction between sorbed and embedded elements is not possible from this bulk information alone.
For example, item W2, which was identified as an orange buoy, contained a much higher Cd concentration (85.2 mg kg−1) than all other plastics analysed in this survey. This suggests that Cd was likely added during manufacturing, possibly as a pigment (cadmium orange),13,41 which is supported by the co-detection of Mo, also an orange pigment. However, since the original composition of these weathered plastics is unknown, it remains difficult to determine whether Cd was originally incorporated during production, later adsorbed from the environment, or influenced by both processes. This ambiguity illustrates a key limitation of bulk ICP-MS: while it provides total metal concentrations in plastic samples, it does not distinguish whether metals are incorporated within the polymer matrix, sorbed onto the surface, or associated with biofilms. This limitation makes it difficult to interpret the impacts of environmental weathering on the distribution of metals detected or how these metals diffuse through plastic. To address this gap, spatially resolved techniques such as LA-ICP-TOFMS are needed to differentiate between surface-enriched (potentially sorbed) elements and those distributed throughout the polymer matrix (likely intrinsic). Spatially resolved mapping offers insights into metals distribution patterns and potential mobility during environmental weathering.
Furthermore, it should be noted that while the detection of these metals aligns with common plastic manufacturing processes and expected metals from exposure, the varied origins and unknown initial conditions of the samples limit further interpretation. Therefore, any observed differences—or similarities—in elemental concentrations between pristine and weathered samples cannot be directly interpreted as indicative of metal stability within the plastics during weathering. Rather, they should be viewed in the context of the inherent variability in both initial composition and environmental exposure history. Establishing this baseline material characterization is essential for interpreting the results of subsequent LA-ICP-TOFMS analysis.
To assess the presence of directional trends in elemental profiles, linear regressions were applied to the central portions of normalized intensity profiles. A summary of regression results is provided in Table 1. The majority of the elemental profiles were flat (slope ≈ 0, R2 < 0.2, p > 0.5), indicating no directional changes. Overall, minimal or non-significant trends were observed for the pristine samples, supporting the interpretation of an overall homogeneous additive distribution with isolated microscale heterogeneities.
Element | R2-value | p-value | % Change | |
---|---|---|---|---|
P5 | Mg | 0.00 | 0.39 | — |
Al | 0.00 | 0.71 | — | |
Ti | 0.00 | 0.97 | — | |
Ca | 0.00 | 0.12 | — | |
P6 | Mg | 0.01 | 0.02 | — |
Al | 0.00 | 0.92 | — | |
Ti | 0.00 | 0.17 | — | |
Ba | 0.00 | 0.57 | — | |
P8 | Zn | 0.00 | 0.56 | — |
Ag | 0.54 | 2.67 × 10−6 | −27% | |
Sn | 0.00 | 0.89 | — | |
Ba | 0.38 | 6.88 × 10−5 | — |
However, two exceptions were identified among the pristine samples. First, in sample P8 (Tygon® tubing), Ag exhibited a pronounced and statistically significant outward-to-inward gradient (R2 = 0.74, p = 2.7 × 10−6). The Ag concentration was highest at the interior surface and declined toward the outer edge of the tubing, consistent with the intentional incorporation of Ag-based antimicrobials during production. No similar gradients were observed for other elements in P8, supporting their role as bulk fillers rather than surface-active agents. Second, in sample P3, a fishing bouncer, a clear Pb gradient was observed (Fig. 3). During the sample preparation, a jig head embedded in the plastic was identified as the likely source, being coated with lead or a lead-containing component. This direct contact resulted in elevated lead concentrations (60 mg kg−1), likely due to the transfer of Pb from the jig head into the plastic over time. A linear regression was applied on the central portion of the Pb intensity profile (edge regions were excluded) and revealed a strong linear correlation (R2 = 0.83) with a significant p-value (p = 1.3 × 10−13), confirming that the Pb decrease across the profile was statistically significant and is unlikely due to random variation. Based on this fit, a 48% decrease in normalized signal intensity was determined. This change indicates relative metal leaching or redistribution within the material. However, due to the absence of matrix-matched calibration, such changes remain semi-quantitative and should be interpreted as within-sample proportional changes rather than absolute concentration changes. The accumulation of Pb on the side of the plastic in contact with the pristine jig head underscores the inherent ability of plastics to uptake or retain substances from their immediate surroundings.
Together, these results demonstrate that pristine plastic items generally lack progressive elemental gradients. Instead, they display isolated microscale inhomogeneities or surface enrichments that can be attributed to manufacturing processes, such as uneven additive distribution or surface treatments. These pristine samples serve as a baseline for typical metal distribution profiles in plastics which can be used to contrast how environmental weathering may alter metal distribution patterns across the material.
To better understand metal distributions in marine-weathered plastics, we generated a set of elemental maps (Fig. 5) focusing on two groups of elements: (1) those commonly present in seawater, which may sorb onto plastic surfaces, and (2) those likely embedded in the polymer matrix, which may exhibit leaching or internal re-distribution. Item W4, a brown buoy, was selected as an example here, as microscopic examination revealed multiple fractures within the material (Fig. 4), and its brittle nature, noted during sample preparation, both suggested advanced weathering. When comparing elemental maps with structural features, seawater-derived elements (e.g. Na, Mg, Sr, and I) showed a clear enrichment at the surface of the plastic, as well as along cracks and fractures, which often aligned with physical changes, suggesting a strong correlation between physical and chemical weathering processes. While cracks varied in sizes within one plastic item and across materials, the largest crack measured was approximately 1.4 mm in depth. These cracks offer potential pathways for deeper penetration of seawater-derived elements into the plastic matrix. As Na, Mg, Sr, and I are abundant in marine environments, these are likely to sorb onto plastic surfaces through direct adsorption, incorporation into carbonate precipitates, or entrapment within biofilms, which create chemically active microenvironments favouring metal binding.49 Traces of U showed a similar surface enrichment pattern, and its co-localization with other seawater-derived elements suggests that it was sorbed during environmental exposure, potentially through similar mechanisms. In contrast, elements such as Cd and Sb—though also present in the environment—are commonly used as pigments or flame retardants in plastic manufacturing. In several samples, these elements showed internal intensity gradients, with higher levels in the centre and lower towards the exposed edges. A similar gradient was observed in the colour of the plastic, with more intense coloration preserved in the core and faded or bleached zones near the edges. This alignment suggests that weathering processes may be driving the outward migration of these additives.
The elemental patterns may reflect leaching, where elements are lost from the material into the environment, or diffusion, where elements redistribute internally without being fully dissociated from the plastic matrix. Although the precise mechanisms are uncertain, the co-occurrence of discoloration and elemental depletion supports the idea that long-term environmental exposure alters both the physical appearance and chemical composition of the material. Similar surface-depleted profiles were also observed for Ba and Al, elements typically associated with inorganic fillers rather than pigments. Although not linked to colour change, their gradients indicate that other types of additives may also be affected by environmental exposure. These findings point to broader changes in the internal composition of plastics following prolonged weathering. Some elements, however, did not show one distinct pattern but rather a dual behaviour. For example, Zn and Mg, both presented an internal gradient pattern consistent with a re-distribution of embedded additives, and a surface accumulation suggestive of sorption from seawater or biofilms. This duality illustrates how weathered plastics can both release and sorb metals over time. Overall, these elemental maps, combined with visual observations, suggests that W4 had undergone substantial weathering and supports the idea that increased surface roughness enhanced sorption from seawater. However, the absence of matrix-matched standards and full mass balance assessments limits definitive conclusions about the mechanisms driving these gradients.
To further illustrate these complex spatial patterns, a false-colour RGB composite map was created by overlaying individual elemental distributions (Fig. 5c). This composite visualization provides an overview of the metal distribution across the plastic cross section and highlights areas where elements associated with surface sorption (e.g., Na, Zn) and potential additive loss (e.g., Cd, Zn) are spatially concentrated.
Similar to the pristine items, cross-sectional elemental maps and corresponding intensity profiles were generated for selected weathered samples (Fig. 6). Unlike the pristine plastics, where no consistent gradients were observed, weathered items often showed clear spatial patterns—particularly gradients pointing to the leaching of certain elements. These gradients were evident both in the false-colour elemental maps and in the quantitative profiles, where signal intensities decreased from the core toward the surface, or vice versa. Such patterns are indicative of internal migration and release of additives, likely triggered by environmental factors such as UV irradiation, contact with seawater, and mechanical stress. Unlike previous studies focused only on the subsurface,24 here our full cross-sectional mapping spans several millimetres—capturing the entire depth of the plastic item, from the weathered edges through the core and back to the weathered edges. This enabled a more comprehensive evaluation of leaching and sorption processes, revealing internal gradients that would have remained undetected with surface-limited techniques.
To further interpret these spatial trends, we examined the distribution profiles of individual elements commonly present as fillers or additives in plastics (Fig. 6). For example, Al, commonly used as a filler, shows a clear concentration gradient from the interior to the surface, suggesting internal redistribution or partial leaching. Cd also displays such gradients. In item W2, visible decolouration is evident (Fig. 4), and this fading may reflect Cd loss from the material. This interpretation is supported by bulk ICP-MS measurements, which revealed elevated Cd concentrations—levels unlikely to result from environmental sorption alone due to low ng L−1 concentrations in the surface waters of the NPGP,50 and more plausible with Cd being incorporated as a pigment. These findings align with those of Liu et al., who demonstrated that sunlight-mediated Cd release occurs from coloured MPs containing Cd-based pigments in aqueous environments.51 Their study highlights that the photo-dissolution of Cd pigments, leads to Cd2+ leaching, a process driven by polymer matrix degradation under UV light exposure. Sb, another common plastic additive,13,52 exhibited a mix of hotspots, internal gradients and surface-enriched patterns. The observed patterns for Cd and Sb are environmentally relevant due to their known toxicity and potential bioavailability, further accentuating the role of weathered plastics as reservoirs of hazardous trace metals. In all cases, both edges were exposed to seawater. While items W1 and W2 present bidirectional gradients, item W5 displayed a unidirectional gradient suggesting that the object may have been floating mostly upright in the water, resulting in asymmetrical exposure.
To quantitatively assess the bidirectional gradients observed in weathered samples W1 and W2, segmented linear regression fits were applied to the left and right halves of each signal intensity profile. The split point was determined visually, based on where the signal clearly changed direction or flattened out near the middle of the profile. For item W5, the gradient appeared unidirectional and so a single linear regression was fitted to the central region of the signal intensity profile, excluding the edges. The resulting R2-values, p-values, and signal change percentage are summarized in Table 2. These metrics are reported as indicators of relative spatial patterns, rather than absolute chemical changes.
Element | Left segment | Right segment | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
R2 | p | % Change | R2 | p | % Change | ||
W1 | Al | 0.85 | 5.3 × 10−17 | −186 | 0.92 | 1.9 × 10−23 | 168 |
Zn | 0.79 | 2.4 × 10−14 | −151 | 0.91 | 6.6 × 10−23 | 129 | |
Cd | 0.26 | 7.6 × 10−4 | −19 | 0.06 | 1.3 × 10−1 | 39 | |
Sb | 0.81 | 2.3 × 10−15 | −444 | 0.65 | 1.5 × 10−10 | 380 | |
W2 | Cu | 0.01 | 2.2 × 10−1 | 27 | 0.47 | 7.4 × 10−21 | −75 |
Zn | 0.55 | 1.0 × 10−26 | 60 | 0.55 | 7.5 × 10−26 | −92 | |
Cd | 0.53 | 6.0 × 10−25 | 43 | 0.58 | 3.9 × 10−28 | −75 | |
Sb | 0.17 | 3.2 × 10−7 | 37 | 0.06 | 4.8 × 10−3 | −35 |
Element | R2 | p | % Change | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
W5 | Al | 0.48 | 1.05 × 10−39 | 53.3 | |||
Zn | 0.04 | 2.02 × 10−8 | 62 | ||||
Cd | 0.10 | 7.74 × 10−14 | 158 | ||||
Sb | 0.00 | 9.57 × 10−1 | 0 |
In W1, elements such as Al, Zn, and Sb exhibited statistically significant bidirectional gradients, with opposite slopes but comparable magnitude, suggesting relative enrichment or depletion from both surfaces' edges. Al and Zn showed over 150% change in normalized signal intensity from the core to the edges, highlighting substantial spatial elemental redistribution within the sample. Cd in W1 and Cu in W3 showed more variable behaviour, with lower R2-values, reflecting imperfect fits to linear models. This discrepancy suggests that while the overall directional trend is real, the signal is affected by localized heterogeneities, non-uniform additive dispersion or weathering artifacts. Some profiles contained pronounced spikes and irregularities that reduced fit quality without negating the presence of relative directional change.
Although many of the fitted slopes were statistically significant (p < 0.001), linear regressions may oversimplify the processes driving metals redistribution in weathered plastics. Metal leaching in polymers is often governed by diffusion, which follows non-linear kinetics and can produce exponential or sigmoidal concentration profiles, especially in weathered or aged plastics where surface oxidation, micro-cracks and matrix degradation alter diffusion dynamics.53,54 Additionally, mechanisms such as additive migration, photo-oxidative restructuring, or surface contamination could also produce non-linear or spatially variable patterns that are not well captured by linear models. Thus, while the current linear approach provides a useful metric for identifying relative directional trends and comparing spatial patterns across samples, it should not be interpreted as a quantitative measure of leaching or sorption rates.
Similar to the profiles in Fig. 2 and 6, a comparison of Fig. 7 and 8 confirmed that pristine samples generally exhibited uniform elemental distributions without clear concentration gradients. This included additives such as Al, Ti and Zn, which displayed uniform signal intensity profiles across pristine cross-sections in comparison to clear gradients in weathered cross-sections, with higher signal intensity inside the plastics and depletion on surfaces in contact with seawater. In contrast, elements commonly abundant in seawater—such as Na, Mg, Ca, Fe, Zn, and I—were notably enriched at the edges of weathered plastics, reflecting sorption processes during marine weathering absent in pristine samples. Iodine was entirely absent in pristine materials, confirming seawater origin. These surface accumulations likely arise from physical weathering that increases surface roughness and biofilm development, both of which facilitate metal sorption. Sb was detected in both pristine and weathered plastics, consistent with its known use in plastic manufacturing.13,52
While Cd was not detected in the pristine plastic samples purchased in 2024 using LA-ICP-TOFMS, very low levels were reported in the bulk analysis using ICP-QQQ-MS. In contrast, weathered samples W2, W4, W5 and W7 showed distinct signal intensity gradients for Cd, which correlated with colour gradients, suggesting its historical use as pigment, as discussed in previous sections. These observations underscore the impact of analytical sensitivity on trace element detection and indicate that Cd is largely absent or present only at trace levels in contemporary plastics, which aligns with current regulations that have largely phased out its use in plastic production due to its toxicity.13,55
Lastly, regarding asymmetric weathering, W6 does not show clear gradients but exhibited an abrupt transition, indicative of a bi-composite structure (see Fig. S3). Additionally, the cross-sectional analysis showed that the outer edge exhibited a notably higher concentration of seawater constituents. As this sample is part of a pipe, this suggests that the exterior of the pipe had been exposed more to seawater than the interior, leading to a differential accumulation of elements. Similarly, W8, another hollow object, showed a clear difference in intensity across its surface. Here, the left rim had a higher intensity, which is consistent with the exterior side being more in contact with seawater, further supporting the idea of differential exposure. Lastly, W7, with a prominent crack running along its centre, presents an interesting case where the crack likely served as a pathway for seawater to infiltrate the material. This increased exposure resulted in a higher concentration of seawater constituents along the crack, highlighting the effect of structural damage on the materials interaction with its environment.
First, analytical sensitivity differs between the ICP-MS instruments used. ICP-QQQ-MS offers lower detection limits than ICP-TOF-MS (LOQ are presented in Table S5).29 Second, the instruments were tuned differently; the quadrupole system was operated in collision/reaction cell mode with O2 and He to enhance sensitivity for elements affected by spectral interferences. While this is a useful and widely accepted approach for targeting specific analytes, it can also generate additional reaction products.56 In a TOFMS system, which measures the full mass range simultaneously, these unintended species may overlap with analytes of interest, potentially introducing new interferences. To avoid this, the ICP-TOFMS was operated in no-gas mode to preserve full-spectrum clarity and minimize secondary spectral complexity. The impact of these differences in optimization strategies was particularly evident in the case of Se. With ICP-QQQ-MS, the use of O2 reaction gas enabled a mass-shift approach, allowing detection of the 80Se16O+ product ion at m/z 96. This approach took advantage of the high natural abundance of 80Se, resulting in improved sensitivity. In contrast, the ICP-TOF-MS could not use mass-shift technique and was therefore limited in no-gas mode to monitoring 78Se, a less abundant and inherently less sensitive isotope. Similarly for Cd, pristine samples contained only trace amounts detectable by bulk ICP-QQQ-MS, which remained below the limits of detection of LA-ICP-TOFMS. In contrast, weathered samples exhibited Cd signals detectable by both techniques, with LA-ICP-TOFMS maps revealing relative spatial patterns. These observations highlight that trace elements present at sub-ppm levels may be missed in spatially resolved mapping due to instrument sensitivity. Subsequently, differences in sample introduction between the two systems influenced sensitivity. Solution nebulization generally provides more consistent aerosol transport and ionization compared to laser ablation, which is subject to variables such as ablation efficiency, plasma loading, and elemental fractionation. A final consideration is sample representativeness. For bulk ICP-QQQ-MS a few milligrams of material were digested providing an average elemental composition, whereas LA-ICP-TOFMS maps spanned only a few mm2. Consequently, localized variations or trace elements may be missed in small-area mapping, and bulk analyses may be more sensitivite for averaged compositions. These differences underscore the importance of integrating both approaches for a comprehensive assessment of elemental distributions. Overall, these observations emphasize the need for standardized protocols.
Nevertheless, the strength of LA-ICP-TOF-MS lies in its capacity to capture the full mass spectrum at high acquisition rates, enabling simultaneous mapping of numerous elements in a single measurement. This screening capability was particularly useful for detecting seawater-associated elements such as I and Cl, which were not targeted in the ICP-QQQ-MS analysis. Despite its low ionization efficiency, I was consistently detected in the elemental maps, suggesting surface accumulation from the marine environment. Cl was also detected, but it produced high intensity signals and was notched to prevent detector saturation.29
While total elemental concentrations in acid digests could be quantified using common multi-element ICP-MS standard solutions, quantification of the elemental maps remained semi-quantitative due to the lack of matrix-matched standards for plastics. While glass-based standards such as NIST SRM 612 were useful for instrument tuning in this study, their ablation behaviour differs substantially from that of polymer matrices and are therefore not ideal for accurate quantification of metals in polymer matrices. Thus, to advance quantitative capabilities in future studies, the use of matrix-matched polymer certified reference materials (CRMs) is essential. In addition to SRM 2858 from NIST, potential candidates for quantification include two PE-based CRMs (ERM-EC680m and ERM-EC681m), a PVC CRM (NMIJ CRM 8123-a), two PP CRMs (NMIJ CRM 8133-a and a Sigma-Aldrich quality control material), as well as an ABS CRM (BAM-H010). These standards, which span multiple common plastic types, have been characterized for both certified and non-certified elemental content,34 making them ideal for quantification purposes. Incorporating these in future LA-workflows will improve measurement accuracy and help overcome matrix-related biases, especially when assessing metal distribution and leaching potentials in environmentally aged plastics.
Lastly, to gain a deeper insight into the underlying mechanisms governing metal redistribution in weathered plastics, future studies will require well-defined weathering histories. Experimental designs should incorporate matched pristine and weathered samples exposed to controlled and standardised conditions (e.g., UV radiation, mechanical abrasion, biofouling), in order to isolate weathering effects from initial material heterogeneity. Quantitative assessment of elemental loss or uptake will benefit from mass balance approaches. While linear regression offered a useful starting point for identifying trends, more advanced models accounting for diffusion, sorption dynamics, and matrix degradation are needed to better characterize transport mechanisms in aged plastics.
Supplementary information: an overview of the analzyed plastics items – weathered and pristine, operating conditions for ICP-MS and LA-ICP-TOFMS, FTIR characterization results, and bulk digestion results. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ja00223k.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |