Xiaolong Guo†
a,
Robert Markowski†a,
Ashley Black†b,
Petru Apostola,
Darsi Rambabua,
Olivera Lužaninc,
Tjaša Pavčnikc,
Damien Montib,
Mengyuan Dua,
Da Tiea,
Xiaodong Lina,
Vasudeva Rao Bakurua,
Raphaël Delognea,
Koen Robeyns
a,
Laura Simonelli
d,
Jean-François Gohy
a,
Jan Bitenc
*c,
Jiande Wang*a,
Alexandre Ponrouch
*be and
Alexandru Vlad
*a
aInstitute of Condensed Matter and Nanosciences, Molecular Chemistry, Materials and Catalysis, Université catholique de Louvain, Louvain-la-Neuve B-1348, Belgium. E-mail: jiande.wang@uclouvain.be; alexandru.vlad@uclouvain.be
bInstitut de Ciència de Materials de Barcelona, ICMAB-CSIC, Campus UAB, Bellaterra, Catalonia 08193, Spain. E-mail: aponrouch@icmab.es
cNational Institute of Chemistry, Hajdrihova 19, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia. E-mail: jan.bitenc@ki.si
dALBA Synchrotron Light Facility, Carrer de la Llum 2-26, Cerdanyola del Vallès, 08290, Spain
eALISTORE-European Research Institute, CNRS FR 3104, Hub de l’Energie, Rue Baudelocque, Amiens 80039, France
First published on 17th September 2025
Divalent metal-ion batteries hold immense promise for electrochemical energy storage applications, offering advantages in terms of volumetric capacity, cost-efficiency, sustainability, and safety. Despite advances, the lack of high-voltage and high-performance positive electrode materials remains a critical obstacle. Here, we disclose a family of amorphous coordination polymers capable of reversibly storing Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+, and Zn2+ cations. For Ca2+ and Mg2+ systems, the highest reported working potentials of >3.2 V vs. Ca2+/Ca and 2.8 V vs. Mg2+/Mg are measured, along with fast, stable, and low-hysteresis storage without solvent or ion pair storage. These characteristics stem from the amorphous structure, delocalized anionic charge, and disordered, long bond-distance coordination, enabling weak binding and fast cation diffusion. Using sustainable elements and demonstrating universal divalent cation storage capacity by achieving the first-ever reversible storage of Sr2+ and Ba2+ ions, this work establishes key design principles for divalent cation storage materials and systems.
Broader contextDeveloping high-energy-density, sustainable battery chemistries is essential for the future of electrochemical energy storage. Divalent metal-ion batteries offer advantages in volumetric capacity, cost-efficiency, sustainability, and safety, yet their progress is constrained by the scarcity of high-voltage, high-performance positive electrode materials. Magnesium (Mg) and calcium (Ca) batteries are among the most promising alternatives to lithium-ion systems, but their development is hindered by strong interactions between divalent cations and rigid inorganic hosts, which limit ion mobility and reversibility. While electrolyte design has advanced, the positive electrode remains a critical bottleneck. Here, we introduce amorphous coordination polymers as positive electrode materials for Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba, and Zn-ion storage, achieving high working potentials, stable cycling, and minimal voltage hysteresis. These electrodes store pure Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+, and Zn2+without solvent or anion co-intercalation. Their favorable electrochemical properties arise from the synergy of delocalized anionic charge, disordered cation coordination, and the structural adaptability of an amorphous framework, which together weaken metal-ion binding and promote rapid diffusion. Composed of non-toxic, earth-abundant elements, these materials provide guiding principles for designing next-generation divalent metal-ion batteries and advancing sustainable, high-performance energy-storage technologies. |
Positive electrode materials generally fall into two compositional classes: inorganic and organic structures. The former are known for their high stability and elevated working redox potential for mono-valent cation storage, but have thus far failed to deliver suitable performances for divalent cation storage due to their compact, rigid framework and high migration barrier for highly polarizing divalent cations.18–25 Conversely, organic materials offer better lattice flexibility during charge and discharge, easy tunability of specific capacity, and reliance on abundant elements. However, they are often plagued by solubility issues, low working potentials, and a tendency to swell in the electrolyte, and thus store cation–anion paired or cation-solvated species, which diminishes their true performance metrics.26–33 Numerous materials from both inorganic and organic classes have been investigated for Ca2+ and Mg2+ storage (Fig. 1), yet none have demonstrated simultaneously low hysteresis, high discharge voltage, high capacity, and good kinetics. Furthermore, most developed materials are synthesized in the oxidized, cation-free state, which is less practical for real-world applications.11,34
Recognizing the strengths of both inorganic and organic materials, we sought to combine these advantages by focusing on solid amorphous coordination polymers (CPs). Similar compositions have already been proven to be efficient for monovalent cation storage,28 yet their compatibility with divalent cation storage has remained uncertain, as the transition to divalent ion storage systems is far from being a straightforward extrapolation, even when using the best-performing phases for Li-ion storage. The family of divalent-cation-containing conjugated CPs studied here were synthesized in their reduced (cation-reservoir) form via an acid–base reaction followed by cation exchange reactions (Fig. 2A), yielding compositions with the general formula DI–M–PTtSA. The CP combinations explored include DI storage cations such as Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+, or Zn2+; M nodal metals such as Zn2+, Co2+, Ni2+, Mn2+, or Fe2+; and the PTtSA4− Wurster-type redox center benzene-1,2,4,5-tetra-methylsulfonamide (Fig. 2B). Among these, the Mg/Ca–Zn–PTtSA compositions exhibited the best performance for Ca2+ and Mg2+ storage (Fig. 2B), achieving working potentials as high as 3.2 V vs. Ca2+/Ca and 2.8 V vs. Mg2+/Mg. Coupled with very low intrinsic hysteresis, these results mark a new milestone for Mg- and Ca-ion electrode chemistries (Fig. 1 and Table S1). Moreover, as the first materials capable of reversibly storing Sr2+ and Ba+ ions (Fig. 2B), these coordination polymers establish DI–Zn–PTtSA as the first and the only reported universal framework for divalent cation storage. These remarkable properties arise from a synergy of factors, including the amorphous solid polymer phase, the highly reversible redox of the sulfonamide unit, and the inductive polarization effect of the nodal metals. Advanced ex situ and operando structural and compositional analyses revealed the charge storage mechanism, emphasizing pure divalent charge storage without coordinated solvents or salt anions. This work not only introduces the first highly efficient divalent-cation-containing materials for broad-spectrum divalent cation storage but also elucidates critical design criteria essential for high-performance next-generation DMBs.
Mononuclear complexes were synthesized and the structure was confirmed through single-crystal X-ray analysis (Scheme S1 and Tables S5–S7). These were subsequently used as model systems to probe the local structure of DI–M–PTtSA via synchrotron-sourced X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) and extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) techniques. The mononuclear DI–M–(o-PDSA)2 complexes, derived from the N,N-(1,2-phenylene)dimethanesulfonamide (H2-o-PDSA) ligand, closely resemble half of the PTtSA ligand (Scheme S1). The excellent overlap of the sulfonamide band positions in the Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) spectra between the polymer and the mononuclear complex (Fig. S3 and S4) suggests highly similar bonding modes, supporting the inference that DI–M–PTtSA shares the same metal coordination environment as the mononuclear complex (Fig. S5, S6 and Tables S5–S7).
Taking Ca–Co–PTtSA as a representative example, an identical XANES signature to that of the crystalline mononuclear Ca–Co–(o-PDSA)2 complex is noted (Fig. 3A), implying an analogous Co2+ local structure. Both exhibit a strong pre-edge peak at 7707 eV, indicative of the 1s → 3d transition. This characteristic peak suggests a deviation from the centrosymmetric geometry and a notable 3d-4p mixing, aligning with a distorted and disordered tetrahedral coordination environment around the Co2+ center. Single crystal analysis confirms a distorted tetrahedral geometry (with a CN = 4) for Ca–Co–(o-PDSA)2, with N1–Co–N2 dihedral angles of 82° and 125° (Fig. S5 and Tables S5, S6). Given the similar XAS spectra, we infer that Ca–Co–PTtSA exhibits the same tetrahedral configuration. Square planar geometry was ruled out by comparison with Co(II) phthalocyanine spectra, while the absence of high-intensity pre-edge peaks, multiple 1s → 3d transitions, edge shifts, and complex post-edge features rules out the rare cubic four-coordinate geometry for Ca–Co–PTtSA (Fig. 3A and Fig. S7). The Co K rising edges' energy positions were found to be compatible with the Co2+ oxidation state in both cases, as compared to the references (CoO and Co2O3). Building upon this, a detailed analysis was performed by modeling the Fourier-transformed (FT) k2-weighted EXAFS data signal in a single scattering approximation (Fig. 3B). The results reveal that the local structure around Co2+ in both the Ca–Co–PTtSA and mononuclear Ca–Co–(o-PDSA)2 complexes is identical within the measurement error (Fig. S8 and Table S8). The model captures the first and second coordination shells, featuring four N atoms at approximately 1.996 Å, four C atoms around 2.92 Å, as well as both, short (around 3.12 Å) and long (around 3.2 Å) Co–O and Co–S distances (around 3.09 and 3.18 Å), depicting a distorted tetrahedral coordination geometry around the Co2+ centers.
Regarding the DI coordination environment, the Ca K-edge XAS analysis indicates two pre-edge features separated by ∼1 eV in the Ca–Co–PTtSA CP, in contrast to only one observed in the CaSO4 reference sample (Fig. S9A). The 1 eV pre-peak splitting is the signature of 6 coordinated species and corresponds to the eg–t2g energy splitting. For 7–8 coordinated complexes, such a shift is not visible within the core–hole lifetime broadening.35 This supports a coordination number of Ca2+ of 7–8 in CaSO4 (Fig. S9B) and on average of 6 in Ca–Co–PTtSA.35 Additionally, the FT k2-weighted EXAFS spectral analysis is compatible with a preference for Ca2+ ions to selectively bind to O atoms of the –SO2– groups (Fig. S9C), in agreement with the HSAB principle. Given the absence of solvents in the Ca–Co–PTtSA phase (Fig. S3), the coordination of Ca2+ ions predominantly involves the oxygen atoms of the mesyl (–SO2–) groups. This aligns with FTIR spectra showing a shift in the –SO2– stretching band to lower wavenumbers in Ca–Co–PTtSA compared to Li2–Co–PTtSA (Fig. S10), indicating that Ca2+ coordination with –SO2– depletes electron density, lowering the SO bond stretching energy. The visibility of only the first shell (Fig. S9C) also implies a relative disorder within the Ca–Co–PTtSA environment, providing further evidence of the disordered nature of these materials.
The Ca–Zn–PTtSA phase shares comparable structural features and binding modes with Ca–Co–PTtSA (Fig. 3C and Fig. S11, S12), revealing that these materials display analogous structural and binding modes (Fig. S13 and Fig. 3C), consistent with the proposed structure for the 1D coordination polymer chain depicted in Fig. 2C. The M metal nodes are tetrahedrally (distorted) coordinated by the nitrogen atoms of the PTtSA4− ligand, forming the polymer chain, with the DI cations required to maintain the charge balance. Essential for transport and storage, this analysis globally reveals a long-range disordered structure, a low coordination number for Ca2+ (6), high average Ca–ligand distances (2.4 Å), and partial negative charge on mesyl oxygen atoms, with Ca2+ (but also Mg2+) thus weakly bound to the framework, resulting in a low diffusion energy barrier for transport and storage (refer next for details and discussion).
The galvanostatic charge–discharge curves of the Ca–Zn–PTtSA notably exhibit a reversible two-electron redox behavior, characterized by two pairs of sloping plateaus averaging at 3.24 V vs. Ca2+/Ca (Fig. S16). For Mg-ion phases, the average redox potential is 2.81 V vs. Mg2+/Mg (Fig. S17). In our previous study, adding a transition metal like Co2+ to form Li2–Co–PTtSA also resulted in a two plateau electrochemical response (compared to a single plateau in the parent Li4–PTtSA), indicating a sequential electron transfer.27,28 This arises from TM-induced electron cloud delocalization, which stabilizes the semi-quinone type radical intermediate and enables stepwise electron transfer. The differential capacity (dQ/dV) plots (Fig. S18) confirm this mechanism, with distinct peaks corresponding to redox events and phase transformations occurring during cation exchange. ICP analysis further supports this two-electron process, showing that precisely 50% of the Ca2+ ions are removed in half-charge and half-discharge states. Similarly, in DI–M–PTtSA, the dual inclined platforms in the galvanostatic charge–discharge response (Fig. 4A) demonstrate a reversible, one-by-one, two electron redox behavior. The variations in the cycling profiles of DI–M–PTtSA CPs (Fig. 4A) result from a combination of factors, including the intrinsic properties of each electrode material, phase transformations during cycling, electrochemical kinetics, and electrolyte composition, influenced by the nature of the divalent cation (i.e. ionic radius and charge density). In addition, the working potential of DI–M–PTtSA ranks among the highest in both Ca-ion and Mg-ion electrode materials (Fig. 1), attributed to the synergistic effect of the intrinsically high redox potential of the sulfonamide functionality and the inductive polarization effect of the nodal metal (Co2+, Zn2+, etc.).28
Notably, compared to state-of-the-art Mg- and Ca-ion electrode materials, both Mg2+ and Ca2+ extraction and uptake in Mg/Ca–Zn–PTtSA occur with remarkably low polarization. Mg–Zn–PTtSA achieves a low voltage hysteresis of only 100 mV for Mg2+ storage, rivaled only by a few materials like Chevrel phases, V2O5, or NASICON (Fig. S19 and Table S10). Ca–Zn–PTtSA attains a hysteresis of just 60 mV upon Ca2+ release and storage—the lowest reported to date—surpassing previously studied NASICON and FePO4 phases (Fig. S19 and Table S11) and establishing these electrode materials as the most energy-efficient developed to date. The exceptionally low hysteresis in Ca/Mg–Zn–PTtSA is attributed to the structural factors: (i) the amorphous nature which creates a flexible framework capable of accommodating large cations and (ii) the weak interaction of the cations with the host framework, facilitated by electron delocalization throughout the organic components (as discussed in the Structural elucidation section). Even with larger cations such as Sr2+ and Ba2+, the hysteresis remains low, around 70 mV (Fig. 4A).
The observed difference between the first cycle and subsequent charge steps is attributed to conformational rearrangements associated with the rotation of the methyl sulfonyl group, which is triggered by the extraction and reinsertion of divalent cations. The first charging cycle can be considered as an activation step, marked by the reorganization of both the polymer and the DI environment. This transformation is influenced by the polymer's solvation structural ‘history’ arising from the synthesis step, which subtly but significantly alters the structure of the pristine material compared to its state after electrochemical cycling. Our data suggest that this activation is an inherent property of the materials, stemming from the peculiar solvation and desolvation processes during the materials synthesis. This process, although not affecting the overall charge storage performances, is discussed in detail in Fig. S20 and S21 and Table S12.
Fig. 4B and C display the rate capability and long-term cycling performances of Ca–Zn–PTtSA and Mg–Zn–PTtSA electrodes. Taking Ca–Zn–PTtSA as an example, at a rate of 5C (with 1C rate being equivalent of 2e−–1Ca2+ exchange in 1 hour, or 97 mA g−1), nearly 70% of the nominal capacity is retained. Mg–Zn–PTtSA exhibits comparable rate performances, attributed to the intrinsic electronic conductivity (Fig. 4E and Fig. S22) and in particular to the divalent cation diffusion kinetics. Indeed, the diffusion coefficients extracted from the galvanostatic intermittent titration technique were found to range between 1.1 × 10−10 and 9.8 × 10−10 cm2 s−1 (Fig. 4D and Fig. S23–S29, Table S13), which, compared to other reported materials,39–42 represent outstanding dynamic properties. The average capacity retention rate per cycle is also excellent, considering the state-of-the-art achievements in divalent cation storage (Tables S10 and 11), with approximately 99.9% for Ca–Zn–PTtSA and 99.7% for Mg–Zn–PTtSA. Even after 2000 cycles, Ca–Zn–PTtSA and Mg–Zn–PTtSA retain 99% and 90% of their initial capacity, respectively (Fig. 4C). Moreover, at a high rate of 10C, no capacity fading is observed over 3000 cycles (Fig. S30). The localization and weak binding of Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions on the periphery of the coordination chain (refer to Fig. 2C and associated structural analysis) enable high mobility during the cycling process without perturbing the integrity of the backbone structure, thereby preserving the framework's stability. In addition, the electrode morphology is well preserved throughout cycling, as no significant differences were observed between the cycled and pristine electrodes in SEM images (Fig. S31), further highlighting the remarkable structural stability and dynamic integrity of these coordination polymers. The developed materials can also be used with a low carbon content (down to 10 wt% tested) and high mass loading (up to 10 mg cm−2 tested), and despite the minor decrease in material utilization, the DI–M–PTtSA CPs remain on top of the best-performing available Mg/Ca-ion storage materials (Fig. S32–S36). Other DI–M–PTtSA compositions (DI = Ca2+ and Mg2+; M = Fe2+, Mn2+, and Ni2+) were also synthesized and characterized (Fig. S37), with, however, the partial oxidation of nodal metals leading now to structure instability and solubility in the electrolyte (Fig. S38 and S39).
Overall, the electrochemical analysis of the disclosed DI–Zn–PTtSA phases highlights the remarkable versatility of these divalent-cation-containing coordination polymers as universal positive electrode materials for DMBs. They exhibit an exceptional balance of stability, energy density, and cyclability, setting a new benchmark in the field. While these coordination polymers may not claim the top position in any single performance metric, their overall cycling performance is outstanding, ranking them among the best across all key categories combined (Table S14).
Fig. 5E displays operando XANES results for Ca–Co–PTtSA. The Co K-edge rising-edge energy position (7714 to 7719 eV) gradually shifts to higher energies during oxidation and exhibits perfect reversibility, shifting to lower energy during reduction. This indicates effective reversibility in electronic and structural environments during Ca2+ extraction and uptake, aligning with electrochemical cycling data (Fig. 4 and Fig. S44A). In contrast to pristine samples (Fig. 5F and G), the fully oxidized state exhibits a minor energy shift in the rising edge position of 0.4 and 0.3 eV for Ca–Co–PTtSA and Ca–Zn–PTtSA, respectively. This indicates the absence of Co2+/Co3+ redox during the oxidation process, supported by the expected energy shift of up to 3.5 eV for the Co2+–Co3+ transition (Fig. 2A).49 These are also confirmed by XPS and molecular electrochemistry of model mononuclear building block analysis, which reveal that the Co2+ to Co3+ oxidation occurs 500 mV above the redox potential of the organic moiety (Fig. S45–S47). Such minor energy shifts are associated with structural variations upon redox of the PTtSA4− ligand, where higher rising edge energies suggest a contracted local structure. Additionally, the pre-edge feature of the Co K-edge XAS spectra, highly sensitive to metal coordination, remains constant during electrochemical cycles (Fig. S44B). This observation further supports no change in the Co oxidation state.
Operando XANES measurements for the Ca–Zn–PTtSA and Mg–[Zn/Co]–PTtSA also confirmed a fully reversible process (Fig. S48–S50). Notably, the Würster-type PTtSA4− ligand serves as the redox-active center, influencing the rising-edge position of the metal nodes during electrochemical cycling, which reflects local structural changes. In the analysis of local structural evolution during Ca2+ extraction and uptake in Ca–Co–PTtSA, the Co K-edge EXAFS spectra were fitted with the previously described mononuclear complex (Fig. S51 and Table S16). Following Ca2+ extraction, the first shell (Co–N bond distance) remains nearly constant, while the second shell exhibits a complex peak shift due to changes in Co single scattering events with C, O, and S atoms. The predominant feature is a shift towards lower distances in Co–C interactions, attributed to C–N bond contraction (single to double C–N bond transition) within the ligand upon oxidation (Scheme S2), following the Wurster-type redox process.26 This finding aligns with the redox process being centered on the ligand within the studied voltage range. In summary, upon oxidation, the PTtSA4− ligand undergoes a two-electron process, reducing its overall charge from −4 to −2. To maintain charge neutrality, one DI2+ cation is released from the coordination polymer. During reduction, the reverse process occurs, involving the reuptake of DI2+ cations into the polymer framework (Scheme S2).
For Mg metal cells, 0.6 M Mg[Al(hfip)4]2 in (bis(2-methoxyethyl)ether)51 was found as the electrolyte formulation with the highest anodic stability (Fig. S52), with nevertheless the onset of anodic decomposition at 2.7 V vs. Mg2+/Mg. However, the high voltage characteristic of Mg–Zn–PTtSA was found to be slightly beyond the thermodynamic anodic stability of this electrolyte, thus requiring a compromise between the active material utilization and cycling stability (Fig. S53). Upon electrode, electrolyte, and cycling condition optimization (Fig. S54), the Mg metal cells achieved 70% of the theoretical capacity with an average working voltage of 2.4 V (Fig. 6A), with, however, higher utilization resulting in lower efficiency due to decomposition of the electrolyte at the upper potential limit. FTIR and ICP analyses of cycled composite electrodes also confirmed that the Mg ions are neither solvated nor ion-paired within the coordination polymer, when cycled in this electrolyte formulation as well, further emphasizing the versatility for pure solid-phase storage of divalent cations (Fig. S55 and Table S17).
Comparing DI–M–PTtSA to the reported positive electrode materials for divalent cation storage, we highlight the superior energy storage metrics in Fig. 6C (the details of the analysis are provided in Tables S18 and S19). In Mg systems, Mg–Zn–PTtSA competes closely with 1,4-polyanthraquinone (14PAQ) in Mg metal cells, offering slightly higher energy density and importantly operating at a significantly higher potential, approximately 1 V above that of 1,4-polyanthraquinone. Polyanthraquinones52 are known to swell in the electrolyte, accommodating partially solvated cations and ion pairs. This process reduces the effective energy storage metrics, whereas in Mg–Zn–PTtSA, Mg2+ storage occurs strictly in the solid state. For Ca systems, Ca–Zn–PTtSA shows high performance in capacitive cells, where it delivers a higher voltage than 3,4,9,10-perylene tetracarboxylic dianhydride (PTCDA), despite the slightly lower energy density. In Ca metal cells, poly(anthraquinonyl) sulfide (PAQs) achieved higher energy density given the higher specific capacity (albeit proceeding as well through partial ion-paired and solvated cations, with thus true metrics being lower) yet operating at a significantly lower potential of about 1 V below that of Ca–Zn–PTtSA.50 This positions Ca–Zn–PTtSA as a superior candidate for large energy storage applications, thanks to its higher energy efficiency driven by its higher operating voltage and low hysteresis.
These materials not only unlock the field of high voltage divalent containing materials but also emphasize now the need to develop higher anodic stability electrolytes compatible with Mg- and Ca-metal interfacial chemistry.51,54,55 While operating at moderate voltages (3–3.6 V vs. Mg/Ca), our materials echo the early stages of Li and Na battery development, where the introduction of high-voltage positive electrode chemistries drove advancements in electrolyte formulations.56,57 Unlike conventional Mg and Ca battery research, which has thus far prioritized compatibility with metal anodes, the DI–M–PTtSA CPs challenge the overlooked aspect of anodic stability by presenting the high-voltage positive electrode chemistries for divalent systems. Rather than a limitation, the current anodic stability gap presents an opportunity to propel transformative developments in high-voltage electrolytes, enabling breakthroughs in Mg and Ca energy storage technologies. As cation-reservoir materials, these coordination polymers represent promising candidates for enabling an anode-free configuration in divalent metal batteries. Although such configurations were not demonstrated in this work, their favorable ion storage behavior suggests potential for future exploration. When combined with high-voltage-stable electrolytes, this approach could contribute to the development of practical, high-energy divalent battery systems.
Supplementary information is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ee02567b.
Footnote |
† These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |