Open Access Article
Yuwei
Shen
a,
Soraya
Bouras
a,
Latévi Max
Lawson Daku
b,
Christian
Serre
a and
Antoine
Tissot
*ac
aInstitut des Matériaux Poreux de Paris, UMR 8004 CNRS, Ecole Normale Supérieure, ESPCI Paris, PSL University, 75005 Paris, France. E-mail: antoine.tissot@ens.psl.eu
bDepartment of Physical Chemistry, University of Geneva, 1211 Geneva, Switzerland
cInstitut de Chimie Moléculaire et des Matériaux d'Orsay, CNRS, Université Paris-Saclay, 91400 Orsay, France
First published on 20th October 2025
The design of new colorimetric sensors for the detection of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) is of high interest due to the health issues they can induce. In this study, we report the fabrication of a film composed of the spin crossover complex [Fe(Sal2trien)]NO3 embedded within metal–organic framework nanocrystals. This composite material demonstrates a selective and reversible colorimetric response to dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) vapor exposure at room temperature, which is attributed to a spin state switching from high-spin (HS) to low-spin (LS) of the Fe(III) centers upon DMSO adsorption (down to 15 ppmV). This work highlights the potential of integrating spin crossover complexes into MOFs to develop colorimetric and reusable VOC vapor sensors.
Ordered porous solids are particularly appealing for the design of optical VOC sensors, as they may combine optically switchable sites with selective sorption of target analytes.5,6 Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are a class of crystalline micro- or meso-porous hybrid crystalline solids that present appealing features for sensing applications such as a large scope of structural features and possible functionalization combined with sensitive and selective vapor sorption features.7 For example, luminescent MOFs based on optically active cations (mainly lanthanides) or organic linkers have been widely explored for the sensing of ions or organic molecules.8,9 Several MOFs can also undergo a color change upon guest sorption, based on the coordination of the analyte to an accessible metal site or on supramolecular interactions between the analyte and the MOF backbone. However, most of the existing studies have been performed in the liquid phase and the investigation of their switching in the presence of vapors remains scarce.10,11
As an alternative strategy for the design of colorimetric sensors, researchers are beginning to explore the development of switchable porous solids based on the assembly of diamagnetic large pore MOFs with spin crossover complexes.12,13 Indeed, spin crossover compounds are known to switch between the low spin (LS) and high spin (HS) states under several external stimuli such as temperature, light and pressure.14 Moreover, a slight modification of their supramolecular environment can also induce a spin state change, for example, in the presence of vapors.15 This spin state switching is accompanied by a modification of most physical properties of the compound, particularly its color. Based on this concept, we recently evidenced that loading spin crossover complexes in preformed chemically stable MOFs can lead to chemoswitchable solids that are sensitive to vapors of water, alcohols, formaldehyde and formic acid, even if the hybrid solids do not undergo noticeable thermal spin crossover.16,17 On the other hand, some of us reported the design of a porous switchable compound based on the loading of the model FeIII(sal2trien)+ spin crossover complex in MOF-808(Zr), a benchmark Zr tricarboxylate MOF exhibiting 18 Å large pores.18 The compound presents an abrupt thermal spin transition close to room temperature with a 15 K wide thermal hysteresis, regardless of the MOF particle size and the amount of complex loaded. It is therefore very promising for the design of a chemosensor, as both LS and HS states are close in energy at room temperature and therefore, a small stimulus might induce a spin state switching. Here, we present the shaping of the Fe(Sal2trien)NO3⊂MOF-808 compound into films of optical quality and the investigation of their switching properties in the presence of VOC vapors.
With a 3-layer deposition, a transparent film presenting limited light scattering was obtained (Fig. S4a), which allowed investigation of its optical properties in the visible range using an optical absorption spectrometer. Although few cracks were observed due to the absence of a binder to increase the mechanical strength of the films after drying, the films presented satisfactory mechanical stability to be handled and used as a colorimetric sensor. Fig. S4c shows a SEM image of the cross-section of the film deposited on a Si wafer, evidencing that the film is homogeneous on the mm scale with an average thickness of 1 ± 0.2 μm. Higher resolution SEM indicated that the nanoparticles are tightly packed (Fig. S4d), which may explain the mechanical properties of the films. With a 5-layer deposition process, a thicker film (around 1.5 ± 0.3 μm) with similar mechanical and optical properties was obtained (Fig. 1 and Fig. S5).
Similar to that for the MOF-808 powder,18 the films were then loaded with FeIII(Sal2trien)NO3 by impregnation of the film in a solution of the complex in dichloromethane, followed by a washing step using the same solvent. UV-visible spectroscopy evidenced that the films exhibit an identical red-brown color to the powdered sample, associated with the LMCT transition of the HS complex at 520 nm (see Fig. 1 and Fig. S6, S7). The Fe
:
Zr ratio in the film was investigated by SEM-EDX analysis (Fig. S6) and the results are consistent with those obtained for the powdered sample. A slight decrease in the loading was observed for the thicker film, which may be related to the dense packing of MOF nanocrystals within the film, which hinders the diffusion of the complex into it.
As previously reported, Fe(Sal2trien)+ complexes present a solvatochromic behavior in solution at room temperature associated with a spin state switching.20 This solvent dependence is attributed to the interactions through H-bonding between the solvating molecules and protons on the secondary amine of the trien backbone that are prone to stabilize the LS state. Consequently, Fe(Sal2trien)+ complexes are mainly HS in most organic solvents (HS fraction >0.7), while the LS state is more stabilized in DMSO (HS fraction of 0.5; see Fig. S8, S9 and Table S1 for characterization of the solutions by UV-visible spectroscopy and Evans 1H NMR).
In order to explore the sensing response of Fe(Sal2trien)NO3⊂MOF-808 films towards different VOC vapors, a film was exposed to saturated vapors in a sealed container without any activation treatment (e.g. heat or vacuum). Before exposure, the pristine film presented a predominant HS (500 nm) absorption band, with a shoulder at 630 nm corresponding to LS species, in line with an almost exclusive population of the HS state (Fig. S10). Vapors of methanol, acetonitrile and toluene, which represent model vapors of polar protic, polar aprotic and nonpolar VOCs, did not induce any major changes in the optical spectra. In contrast, after exposure to DMSO, the color of the film turned dark purple with a significant reduction in absorbance at 500 nm and a corresponding increase in absorption at 630 nm. This evolution of the absorbance spectrum indicates stabilization of the LS state in the presence of DMSO vapors, in agreement with both the behavior of the complex in solution and the magnetic measurements performed on Fe(Sal2trien)NO3⊂MOF-808 powder loaded with vapors. Indeed, these measurements evidenced that at RT, the dry compound is predominantly HS, the hydrated compound presents an intermediate spin state, and the DMSO-loaded sample is mainly LS (Fig. S11).
In order to probe the interactions between the SCO complex, the DMSO adsorbed molecules and the MOF-808 backbone, well-tempered metadynamics (WT-MTD) and Born–Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) simulations were performed with the tight-binding GFN-xTB method on a model system based on one complex loaded in the MOF-808 large pore. At first, the WT-MTD simulation was applied to determine the most favorable locations of GaIII(sal2trien)+ in MOF-808 in the presence of DMSO molecules at T = 320 K, using as collective variables the Cartesian coordinates of GaIII (see the SI for computational details; note that GaIII was used instead of FeIII at this stage (i) to allow faster calculations using a diamagnetic cation (closed-shell system) and (ii) also because of the similar ionic radii of HS FeIII and GaIII). Fig. S12 shows the reconstructed free energy surface (FES) F(T = 320 K; xGa, yGa, zGa), evidencing that the complex is preferentially located close to the walls of the cavities of MOF-808, as previously reported when the complex is encapsulated in the absence of solvent.18
The (BOMD) simulations were then performed at T = 320 K with the FeIII(sal2trien)+ complex in both LS and HS states (see the SI for computational details). Fig. 2 presents the spatial distribution functions of the O, S and C atoms of the DMSO molecules located in the close vicinity of the complex. They evidence that these molecules are engaged in the N–H⋯O hydrogen bonds with the amine groups of the ligand. The radial distribution functions g(r) of the O, S and C atoms of DMSO with respect to the Namine atoms of the complex (Fig. 2) further evidence that each amine group is engaged in a strong N–H⋯O hydrogen bond with one DMSO molecule. Therefore, the simulations strongly support the existence of a strong interaction between DMSO and the complex through H-bonding, which likely enhances the ligand field strength and therefore induces the stabilization of the LS state in the presence of DMSO.
Owing to the selective spin state switching of the Fe(Sal2trien)+ complexes in Fe(Sal2trien)NO3⊂MOF-808 in the presence of DMSO vapors, we then investigated the colorimetric switching of the films using a home-made in situ measurement chamber. Indeed, given that DMSO is considered potentially toxic, its monitoring in air could be of high relevance.21,22 A 1.5 μm thick film was thus placed in the in situ measurement chamber to get an insight into the kinetics of its response when exposed to VOC vapors (see the SI for details of the setup). Prior to the measurements, the film was activated at 100 °C to remove absorbed water and traces of the loading solvent (DCM) from the pores. The absorbance of the activated film in the visible region mainly presents an absorption band at 500 nm, indicating that the complexes are in the HS state (Fig. 3). Afterwards, the film was exposed to a relatively high concentration (68 ppmv) of DMSO vapor (N2 carrier gas flow: 1.2 L min−1, bubbler temperature: 30 °C) for 1 h at room temperature. Fig. 3 illustrates the evolution of the film absorbance during the exposure. A gradual increase in the bands at 630 nm, correlated to a decrease in the absorption at 500 nm, indicated a DMSO-induced HS-LS spin transition. The evolution of the absorbance at 630 nm, corrected from baseline fluctuation, is presented in Fig. 3. It evidences that the HS–LS transition follows single exponential kinetics with a half-time of 970 s. The same film was also investigated at a lower concentration of DMSO vapor (15 ppmv) in order to investigate its sensitivity. Prior to the exposure to the lower concentration, the film was heated to 100 °C to remove the absorbed DMSO molecules. A similar HS–LS transformation was observed, although it was slower and less complete compared to that obtained in the experiment performed with 68 ppmv of DMSO (see Table 1 and Fig. S13).
| Film thickness | DMSO vapor concentration | Water vapor | t 1/2/s | Relative absorbance variation at 635 nm/% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 μm | 68 ppmv | No | 970 | 42 |
| 15 ppmv | No | 2000 | 25 | |
| 15 ppmv | Yes | 710 | 25 | |
| — | Yes | 273 | 22 | |
| 1.0 μm | 68 ppmv | No | 320 | 58 |
The desorption process of DMSO was investigated to assess the reversibility of the sensing process. The chamber was flushed with solely N2 at 400 mL min−1 at room temperature overnight to remove absorbed DMSO. A progressive recovery of the HS fraction was observed, suggesting a LS-to-HS transition (Fig. S14). However, the desorption process is not complete at room temperature, as the band at 630 nm (LS) remains visible after 9 h of N2 flushing. This can be attributed to the inefficient removal of DMSO vapors from the chamber under N2 flux at room temperature. We then subjected the film to a 100 °C heat treatment and showed that it led to a complete desorption of DMSO. Therefore, the same piece of the film was used for several consecutive measurements without any alteration of their switching properties. This reversibility indicates that the DMSO sensing mechanism is based on physisorption and that the thermal treatment effectively removes adsorbed DMSO and restores the switching state of the film, which highlights its potential for practical applicability as a reusable colorimetric sensor.
In order to explain the sensing potential of our films under environmental conditions, we then explored the influence of humidity on DMSO sensing. For such purposes, we first recorded the evolution of the film absorption in the presence of water vapor (>1000 ppmV). A fast but partial HS–LS conversion was observed, which is consistent with magnetic measurements performed on powder (see Fig. S15). Therefore, the HS-LS conversion is by far more quantitative in the presence of 68 ppmv of DMSO than with a large excess of water vapor (concentration >1000 ppmv), which evidences the potential of the films for DMSO sensing in humid environments.
To investigate the competition between DMSO and water sorption, an experiment with a 15 ppmv DMSO vapor concentration generated with a wet N2 gas flux was performed. In this case, the HS–LS conversion was close to that observed in the presence of water vapor only, but slight differences appear after 1500 s of exposure (Fig. 3). Over this long exposure period, an additional slow HS–LS switching was observed, which is attributed to the slow kinetics of DMSO sorption into MOF-808 pores compared to water. This measurement evidenced that DMSO sensing can be performed even in the presence of water vapor down to 15 ppmv, which is a prerequisite for the design of a colorimetric chemosensor.
Finally, we investigated the influence of film thickness on the spin state switching. With a thinner film (around 1.0 μm), the spin state switching occurred faster (320 s vs. 970 s) and with a higher relative amplitude (58% of relative variation of the optical density at 635 nm vs. 42%) compared to the 1.5 μm film. This observation was consistent with faster vapor diffusion kinetics in the thinner film. However, the absolute optical density variation at 635 nm is lower for the thinner film (see Fig. S13), which highlights the need to balance switching kinetics with the intensity of the color change when designing a colorimetric sensor. Overall, the sensitivity of these films compares well with that of previously reported spin crossover based porous solids.17
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |