Charlotte
Proges
a,
Kevin
Lindenau
a,
Julia
Rothe
ab,
Anke
Spannenberg
a,
Wolfgang
Baumann
a,
Fabian
Reiß
*a,
Axel
Schulz
ab and
Torsten
Beweries
*a
aLeibniz Institute for Catalysis, Albert-Einstein-Str. 29a, 18059 Rostock, Germany. E-mail: fabian.reiss@catalysis.de; torsten.beweries@catalysis.de
bInstitute of Chemistry, University of Rostock, Albert-Einstein-Str. 3a, 18059 Rostock, Germany
First published on 12th December 2024
Starting from the alkyne complex Cp2Zr(py)(η2-Me3SiC2SiMe3) (Cp = η5-cyclopentadienyl, py = pyridine), the synthesis and complete characterisation of a zirconocene(IV) triazenido hydride complex and its use in the activation of small molecules is reported. The reaction with CO2 led to the formation of a zirconocene(IV) triazenido-formate complex, which was further investigated for its stability towards different bases with respect to the formation of formic acid. The experimentally observed reaction pathway was investigated computationally using DFT methods, revealing the favourable role of pyridine coordination in the hydrogen transfer from the triazene to the alkyne unit of the zirconocene reagent.
In group 4 coordination chemistry, several documented routes have been established for the introduction of these types of ligands. One of the first reported examples is the use of 1,3-tolyltriazene and hafnocene hydrides, which forms a triazenide hydride complex (Fig. 1a).5 Furthermore, insertion of organic azides into M–C bonds allows the synthesis of unsymmetrical triazenido complexes (Fig. 1b).6 A rather unusual protocol includes the insertion of alkynes into an N–N bond in zirconium tetraazadienediyl complexes (Fig. 1c).7
The use of free triazenes as starting materials was investigated using various sources of reactive group 4 metal fragments. Both, the prior basic treatment of free triazenes8 with subsequent transmetallation to the group 4 metal,9 as well as direct treatment with basic group 4 metal amido complexes, form products of the type [M(RNNNR)n(X)m] (M = Ti, Zr or Hf, X = e.g. NMe2, Cl, Cp).10 It was claimed that alkyl triazenido complexes can be used to form Zr and Hf monolayers by CVD,10c whereas aryl-substituted analogues can serve as pre-catalysts for olefin polymerisation.10d The use of aryl triazene and Ti(II) sources or Ti(IV) precursors has also been investigated by the Beckhaus group and by us before. Beckhaus’ Ti(IV) bis(pentafulvene) complexes, formally Brønsted basic, lead to Ti(IV) triazenido complexes where the proton is transferred to one of the pentafulvene units.11 Conversely Ti(II) sources such the alkyne complex [Cp2Ti(η2-Me3SiC2SiMe3)] (Cp = η5-cyclopentadienyl) lead to rare Ti(III) triazenido complexes under evolution of hydrogen (Fig. 1d).9,11
Considering the divergent coordination behaviour that can be observed with the related triatomic allenediide ligand [Me3SiCCCSiMe3]2−, giving either four-membered 1-metalla-cyclobuta-2,3-dienes (similar to structure AFig. 1 bottom) when using ansa-metallocenes,12 or dinuclear dizirconacyclooctatetraenes with smaller metallocenes (like structure BFig. 1 bottom),13,12b the question arises whether similar, hitherto unknown triazenido-bridged dinuclear zirconocene complex B can be prepared using Rosenthal's reagent [Cp2Zr(py)(η2-Me3SiC2SiMe3)] (1, py = pyridine) as the Zr(II) precursor14 (Fig. 1, bottom). Herein we present an investigation of this reactivity and the study of the obtained first zirconocene triazenido hydride complex towards CO2.
Proton transfer reactions, in particular from acidic groups to the alkyne Me3SiC2SiMe3, are well known.17 However, reactions in which the hydrogen atom of the resulting alkenyl/vinyl group undergoes a subsequent shift along with elimination of the alkyne, are much rarer.18 The reactivity described here is reminiscent of that of the chemically related N,N‘-diphenylformamidine with 1, in which a complex similar to 2 was identified. Upon heating this species formed the Zr hydrido complex [Cp2Zr(H)PhNC(H)NPh], suggesting the formation of an analogous complex in our case.18b With this in mind, we then focused on the more stable follow-up reaction product identified in our NMR monitoring experiments. To bypass the long reaction time observed, a 1:
1 mixture of 1 and 1,3-diphenyltriazene was reacted in C6H6 for 18 hours at 50 °C, giving a clear dark red solution. Single crystals suitable for single crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) analysis of the follow-up product 3 (Fig. 3, left) could be obtained after addition of pentane to the concentrated reaction solution at −78 °C. The molecular structure reveals the formation of a zirconocene triazenido hydrido species, similar to Bercaw's hafnocene hydrido complex (Fig. 1a), which explains the lack of hydrogen evolution and again shows the preferential chelating coordination of the NNN unit. A comparison of 1H NMR resonances of redissolved (C6D6) isolated crystals of 3 and those observed in the above monitoring experiment (Fig. 2b and c) shows excellent agreement. Due to the moderate solubility of 3 in C6D6, further NMR analysis was performed in THF-d8, where the Cp signal shifts to δ 6.05 ppm and the Zr–H resonates at δ 5.17 ppm. The presence of a hydride in 3 is substantiated by the 1H–15N HMBC correlation between the Zr–H signal and the terminal α-nitrogen atoms (δ −122.5/−109.6 ppm) as well as a minor correlation with the central β-nitrogen atom at δ 126.6 ppm (Fig. S15†). The large relative shift between α- and β-nitrogen signals of Δδ = 249 and 236 ppm reflects their contrasting electronic situations, ruling out a partial Zr–Nβ interaction (see ESI section 2.5†). The ATR-IR spectrum of 3 shows a strong νas.(NNN) vibration at 1271 cm−1 and ν(Zr–H) stretching mode at 1591 cm−1 in good agreement with Bercaw's heavier hafnocene congener (Fig. 1a) (νas.(NNN) = 1301, ν(Hf–H) = 1630 cm−1).19
In an initial attempt to crystallise complex 3, a colour change of the solution from orange to yellow was observed after storing the flask in a Dewar barrel cooled with dry ice. Surprisingly, 1H NMR analysis of this solution showed a different set of characteristic signals in THF-d8 for Cp ligands (δ 6.38 ppm) and a further singlet at δ 8.28 ppm. The latter shows 13C satellites with a remarkably large coupling constant (1JC,H = 205 Hz). After clarifying the formation of 3, we focused on this secondary finding as we had reason to assume that CO2 accidently entered the flask, resulting in serendipitous, yet selective follow-up reaction of complex 3 with the former. Reproducing this transformation by treatment of isolated crystals of 3 with CO2 in THF shows a colour change of the solution from orange to yellow (Scheme 1). The 1H NMR spectrum of the yellow solid obtained after workup was identical to that observed earlier, thus confirming our assumption. The 1H–15N HMBC spectrum neither shows correlation between the new resonance at δ 8.28 ppm and the α-nitrogen atoms (−113.3/−97.7 ppm) nor with the β-nitrogen atom (Fig. S20†),20 indicating CO2 insertion into the Zr–H bond. This assumption could be confirmed by SC-XRD analysis, which revealed the formation of a zirconocene triazenido formate complex 4 (Fig. 3, right). Based on this finding, the new 1H NMR resonance at low field can be assigned to the formate ligand. The insertion of CO2 into metal hydride bonds is a well-documented reaction, particularly in late transition metal chemistry, where the catalytic reduction of CO2 with hydrogen to formic acid has been studied in detail.21 Of note, there are comparably few examples of such insertion reactions in group 4 metal chemistry. These studies were carried out in the context of frustrated Lewis pair chemistry, showing the same behaviour.22 To our knowledge, only one comparable isolated zirconocene formate complex was reported before, showing a formate 1H NMR resonance at δ 8.87 ppm (C6D6) that agrees well with the value of 4.22a Formation of such species was observed as an intermediate in the reaction of the related Schwartz reagent Cp2Zr(H)Cl with CO2 which furnishes formaldehyde and the dinuclear complex μ-O-[Cp2ZrCl]2.23 This onward reactivity contrasts with the herein reported formation of a stable, mononuclear formate complex 4, likely due to the presence of the sterically demanding triazene ligand. In previous studies, hydrogenation of the formate with bulky Lewis acids as a further activating agent was attempted, however, formation of formic acid was not found.
To deepen our understanding of the observed reactivity, a two-step computational analysis was carried out. First, the observed reaction pathway and its possible transition states were investigated using the semi-empirical GFN2-xTB method,24 followed by a DFT re-optimisation and verification at the B3LYP25-D326/def2-TZVP27 level. The rapid formation of 2 from 1 suggests that in the first step the pyridine ligand is exchanged by the coordination of one nitrogen of the triazene unit. To our surprise, the subsequent hydrogen transfer from the triazene NH to the alkyne unit in this structure shows an activation barrier of ΔG‡ = 138.5 kJ mol−1, which is not compatible with the experimentally observed fast formation of 2 under ambient conditions. Therefore, the influence of the pyridine ligand on this transformation was further evaluated and coordination of the 1,3-diphenyltriazene unit in between the pyridine and alkyne ligand was found to be preferred (Fig. 4, Int1). Starting from this structure, four different reaction pathways were explored at the GFN2-xTB level of theory (Fig. S37†), revealing that a hydrogen shift to the pyridine and pyridine de-coordination is rather unlikely. Interestingly, the hydrogen shift to the alkyne unit shows the lowest estimated energy barrier and the second highest energy gain, which agrees with the experiment and therefore this pathway was investigated further on a higher level of theory. The consideration of pyridine in Int1 leads to a remarkable decrease of the activation barrier for the hydrogen shift (TS1, ΔG‡ = 81.4 kJ mol−1) followed by strongly favoured pyridine de-coordination viaInt2 and Int3 leading to complex 2 (Fig. 4, Int4, ΔRGθ = −66.3 kJ mol−1). It was not possible to locate a transition state structure between Int2 and Int3 probably due to the flat energy surface connecting these species. The subsequent hydrogen shift from the vinyl group of 2 to the Zr centre in 3 (Int6), shows the highest-lying transition state of the entire reaction sequence (TS2, ΔG‡ = 117.6 kJ mol−1), which explains the rather slow reaction at ambient temperature or the need for thermal activation. The rapid formation of highly exergonic complex 4 (Int8, ΔRGθ = −123.6 kJ mol−1) at ambient conditions is well explained by the low-lying transition state (TS3, ΔG‡ = 76.0 kJ mol−1). Although transition states could not be localised for all reaction steps, in particular for substrate coordination and de-coordination, presumably due to flat potential energy surfaces, the calculations show very good agreement with the observed experimental behaviour and shed light on a likely reaction pathway. Particularly noteworthy are the lowered activation barrier for the NH shift to the alkyne unit due to additional pyridine coordination at Zr and the activation barrier of 117.6 kJ mol−1 for the rate-determining step of the H transfer to the Zr centre. Next, the possibility of catalytic use of complex 3 for the reduction of CO2 with H2 was studied. While the formation of 4 from 3 and CO2 is exergonic (ΔRGθ = −54.3 kJ mol−1), the regeneration of 3 with H2 and elimination of formic acid is strongly endergonic (ΔRGθ = 105.8 kJ mol−1) and lies at the upper limit of a reaction possible at ambient conditions (Fig. S40†). Nevertheless, this motivated us to conduct a series of NMR experiments to shed more light on this transformation. Heating complex 4 at 80 °C in hydrogen atmosphere did not lead to any reaction (Fig. S25†). The hydrogenation of CO2 is endergonic; however, the reaction can be influenced by the addition of a base, producing formate salts, which can lead to an exergonic reaction.28 For example, Leitner and co-workers used methyldiethanolamine to facilitate the iridium-catalysed hydrogenation of CO2.29 The impact of the addition of different bases was investigated by a series of stability tests on the NMR scale (see ESI Fig. S28–33†). Complexes 3 and 4 were dissolved in THF-d8 and approx. 10 equiv. of the bases triethyl amine (NEt3), pyridine and 1,8-diazabicyclo(5.4.0)undec-7-ene (DBU) were added. From the resulting samples a series of 1H NMR spectra were recorded, revealing that virtually no reaction takes place when adding NEt3 or pyridine to 3 or 4, even after a reaction time of several days at room temperature. The same was observed with 3 and DBU. However, when the Ar atmosphere was replaced by CO2 in this case, the 1H NMR spectra showed formation of unknown Cp resonances. Decomposition into an ill-defined mixture was also observed when DBU was added to independently synthesised 4. In turn, the addition of hydrogen to samples containing 4 and pyridine or NEt3 shows practically no changes in the 1H NMR spectra. No hydrogen consumption or decrease in the signals for 4 was detected, even after three days at 60 °C (Fig. S34 and 35†). Another possibility to facilitate the reaction of 4 back to 3 may be the addition of a hydride source. This was investigated using a 1:
1 ratio of Et2SiH2 and 4 in THF-d8, however, the 1H NMR spectra remain unchanged at ambient conditions or after heating to 50 °C for three days (Fig. S36†). Additionally, the stability of complexes 3 and 4 in the presence of formic acid itself was tested in THF-d8 solutions. Both complexes were not stable under these conditions with 3 reacting to 4 and molecular hydrogen and complex 4 further reacting to an unidentified species (Fig. S26 and 27†). Broadening of the excess formic acid signal could suggest an exchange of the formate ligand.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental, spectroscopic, crystallographic, and computational details. CCDC 2342475 and 2342476. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4dt03155e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |