Alexey M.
Romshin
*a,
Nikolay A.
Aseyev
*b,
Olga S.
Idzhilova
b,
Alena A.
Koryagina
b,
Vadim E.
Zeeb
ac,
Igor I.
Vlasov
a and
Pavel M.
Balaban
b
aProkhorov General Physics Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 119991 Moscow, Russia. E-mail: alex_31r@mail.ru
bInstitute of Higher Nervous Activity and Neurophysiology of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 117485 Moscow, Russia
cInstitute of Theoretical and Experimental Biophysics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 142292 Moscow, Russia
First published on 5th November 2024
Precise control of cellular temperature at the microscale is crucial for developing novel neurostimulation techniques. Here, the effect of local heat on the electrophysiological properties of primary neuronal cultures and HEK293 cells at the subcellular level using a cutting-edge micrometer-scale thermal probe, the diamond heater-thermometer (DHT), is studied. A new mode of local heat action on a living cell, thermal-capture mode (TCM), is discovered using the DHT probe. In TCM, the application of a 50 °C temperature step induces a great increase in cellular response, allowing the cell to be thermally captured and depolarized by up to 20 mV. This thermal effect is attributed to local phase changes in the phospholipid membrane, enabling precise and reproducible modulation of cell activity. The TCM is shown to open up new opportunities for thermal cell stimulation. DHT reliably triggers action potentials (APs) in neurons at rates up to 30 Hz, demonstrating the ability to control cell excitability with millisecond and sub-millisecond resolution. AP shape is modulated by local heat as well. The ability to precisely control the AP shape and rate via thermal-capture mode opens new avenues for non-invasive, localized neurostimulation techniques, particularly in controlling neuron excitability.
The mechanisms underlying the dependence of the electrical parameters of the cell on temperature have been extensively studied in recent years. A number of approaches aimed at delivering a precise amount of heat in order to control the electrophysiological state of living cells have been developed. One of the most elaborated and widely used approach is a local pulsed infrared stimulation, exploiting the absorption of water to rapidly increase temperature at the cellular level.6,11 It was shown that even slight local heating triggers changes in membrane potential and overall permeability of the cell membrane. An infrared-induced thermal effect results in reversible changes in the electrical capacitance of the plasma membrane of cells,1 depolarizing the cells and generating action potentials. Subsequently, Beier et al.12 proposed that infrared radiation causes structural changes in the cell membrane, leading to the formation of transient nanopores which increase the non-selective ionic permeability of the membrane, contributing to cell depolarization. This effect was also reversible, allowing the membrane to return to its original state 20 minutes after the cessation of infrared stimulation, indicating a mechanism that could be used repeatedly for therapeutic purposes without permanent damage to the cells. Another family of methodologies employed photoabsorption materials, such as metallic2 and semiconductor4 nanoparticles, as well as biopolymers,13 for effective light-to-heat conversion. It was shown that plasmonic nanoparticles can be conjugated to high-avidity ligands having an affinity for specific proteins on the neuronal membrane in primary culture.2 It was revealed that the efficacy of the neuronal response depends on the target, being higher in the case of TRPV1 and voltage-gated sodium channels, and less when the ligand targets the ATP-gated P2X3 receptor. Nonetheless, changes in membrane capacitance and depolarization currents were observed in the targeted neurons regardless of the type of ion channel. Therefore, the action of local heating on the cell appears to be more dependent on the thermal membrane properties rather than mediated solely by ion channel-dependent temperature perception.
Despite the clarity of previous studies, the mechanism of the membrane potential shift due to the effect of local heat on cellular compartments and the cell as a whole remains incompletely determined. Partly, constraints arise from optical techniques, as both infrared and photothermal materials make it impossible to affect the electrophysiological processes with high spatial resolution and are limited to the scale of the whole cell soma (∼10 μm). Although plasmonics typically employs metallic nanoparticles of several tens of nanometers for thermal stimulation, conjugating a multitude of these nanoparticles can result in the entire cell surface being exposed to heat. Moreover, the aforementioned methods either required preliminary temperature calibration using external thermometers,1,4,12 sometimes giving inaccurate temperatures, especially for nanoscale heat sources,2 or were applied blindly, so that just the relative changes in the optical power applied to the heater were determined.14 Such approaches do not provide an adequate assessment of the amount of heat delivered to the biological system, leading to incorrect interpretation of the conditions, under which cellular processes are initiated.
In this study, the effect of local heat on the electrophysiological properties of cells at the subcellular level was investigated using a state-of-the-art thermal microprobe, known as the diamond heater-thermometer (DHT), which combines the functions of a thermometer and a heater in a single micrometer-scale particle. This major advantage of DHT over reported techniques1,2,4,12,14 eliminates the need for an additional thermal probe in the biological system and minimizes inaccuracies in determining the heating temperature during optical power calibration. Experimentally, DHT was capable of controlling local temperature with an accuracy <0.2 °C in the vicinity of the cell's phospholipid bilayer, occupying less than 3% of its surface and providing unprecedented thermal locality to heat specific cellular compartments. Millisecond local heat pulses induced reversible changes in membrane potential and elicited capacitive currents in cultured neurons and HEK293 cells. At local temperatures close to 50 °C, a rapid increase in cellular response by an order of magnitude was observed, which we attribute to local phase changes in the phospholipid membrane at the point of contact with DHT, allowing the cell to be effectively and reproducibly thermally captured in the so-called thermal capture mode (TCM). Once the transition to TCM occurred, even lower temperatures (<35 °C) elicited depolarization up to 10 mV in neurons sufficient for triggering the action potentials (APs) at rates up to 30 Hz. In addition, the impact of high temperatures far from the physiological range on the electrophysiology of the cell was estimated with focus on the AP generation. Present findings enhance an established understanding of how local heat affects cellular functions and provide valuable insights into thermal modulation of cell activity.
Electrophysiological patch clamp measurements were conducted in the primary culture of neurons or HEK293 cells in the whole-cell configuration. To effectively expose the cell to local heat, the DHT1.4 was positioned as close as possible to the selected cell with minimal mechanical damage. Specifically, the DHT1.4 was placed a few micrometers above the cell, and then brought closer until a slight characteristic bend of the membrane indicated contact. The absence of current through the cell membrane as the DHT1.4 approached ruled out the activation of mechanosensitive channels. At the same time, the DHT1.4 was positioned laterally away from the controlling patch electrode to avoid non-physiological current changes due to thermal alteration of the patch micropipette resistance. Although control measurements did not show significant thermal changes in current through the patch electrode in the absence of a living cell (Fig. S1†), the DHT1.4's position was chosen to be far from the patch electrode (as depicted in Fig. 1e and f) to avoid possible heat-related artifacts. Also, the application of laser pulse alone in the absence of DHT at the focal point did not produce any electrophysiological response (Fig. S2†).
As expected from previous studies with infrared and plasmonic thermal stimulation,1,2 in current clamp mode, the neurons were depolarized from their resting potential with heat pulses produced by the DHT1.4 (Fig. 2a). It can be logically assumed that the DHT1.4 heater, occupying no more than 3% of the cell soma area, could only lead to minor potential changes. However, we revealed two contrasting modes of local temperature impact on neurons, presumably differing in the degree of the DHT1.4's interaction with the cell membrane and the phase state changes of the latter. In the first mode, the DHT1.4 slightly touched the cell membrane without altering its phase properties, operating in probe-mode (P-mode, PM). The depolarization amplitude increased with the rise in peak heating temperature, reaching a maximum of 1.1 mV at remarkably high values of about 70 °C. Surprisingly, even after such thermal exposures, neurons retained their morphology and remained physiologically stable (able to generate action potentials and maintain resting potential) for at least 30 minutes in gap-free protocols (Fig. S3†), indicating probable low thermal toxicity of short-duration temperature pulses at the micro- and nanoscale. The typical depolarization rise time in P-mode was weakly dependent on the heating amplitude and ranged from 0.5 to 1 ms.
For the majority of cells, we revealed a more pronounced mode of potential change in the local temperature field, occurring at an energy threshold of 50–55 °C and heat pulse duration of ∼50 ms (Fig. 2b). Beyond these threshold conditions, the depolarization amplitude elicited by the same temperature stimulus increased 15-fold up to 16 mV, while the time required for saturation of the depolarization voltages increased to 3–4 ms, depending on the cell soma size and contact area. Even with a lower thermal stimulus at 37 °C, the depolarization response was around 10 mV (Fig. 2g). Fig. 2c shows the voltage-clamp time course of the current under a 10 Hz sequence of 50 ms heat pulses (Theat = 55 °C). Initial pulses elicited only slight depolarizing currents; however, by the third pulse, the energy barrier was gradually breached, and from that moment, the peak current values increased dramatically. Subsequent protocols of local heating with varying durations and amplitudes always led to reversible depolarization over hundreds of trials under both current-clamp and voltage-clamp conditions. Presumably, the DHT1.4 could lead to local melting of the membrane and establishment of closer contact with it—transitioning to a thermal-capture mode (TC-mode, TCM). In fact, along with the report in ref. 1 on the infrared light-induced local discoloration of X. laevis oocytes, we also observed a similar effect on the neuronal surface after removing the thermal probe and sometimes stretched filaments of the membrane entrained with the melted membrane part. It should be noted that after the DHT1.4 was completely removed from the extracellular solution, the life cycle of the neurons continued, they fully responded to incoming synaptic signals, and were capable of demonstrating both spontaneous and evoked electrophysiological activity.
The transition from PM to TCM was accompanied by a sharp nonlinear increase of inward currents and, subsequently, a corresponding charge–voltage (Q–V) response to thermal stimuli at a holding voltage of −126 mV and Theat = 55 °C (Fig. 2d). After the TC-mode had been established, the charge increased linearly with voltage, with a slope coefficient of 1.44 ± 0.12 fC mV−1, reaching the reversal at −36 mV for this cell. The average reversal potential across N = 5 neurons was −46 mV, which statistically shows little dependence on local temperature magnitude (Fig. 2e). The observed reversal potential variation of ±15 mV was likely due to the increasing contribution of activated ion channels as the holding current rose along with probable change in surface charge density in the close proximity of the cell membrane.20 In TCM, the charge flowing through the membrane increased with temperature, peaking at ΔT between 35 and 50 °C. Further increases in heating magnitude on the millisecond timescale compromised cell integrity, leading to loss of resting potential and electrophysiological dysfunction (Fig. S4 and 5†).
For a quantitative comparison of P-mode and TC-mode, the maximal depolarizing ΔV at various local temperature amplitudes was measured (Fig. 2f). Saturation behavior with increasing temperature was clearly observed for both modes and was well described by the equation ΔV = ΔV∞·(T − Tsol)/(T − Tsol + ΔTsat), where ΔV∞ is the high-temperature depolarization limit, ΔTsat is the saturation relative temperature corresponding to the curve inflection, Tsol is the temperature of the ambient extracellular solution. Based on the fitting values in TCM, the saturation limit ΔVTCM∞ = 19.7 mV was reached at ΔTTCMsat = 11 °C, while the corresponding parameter in PM was almost 20 times less, with a depolarizing limit ΔVPM∞ = 2.1 mV and a saturation temperature ΔTPMsat = 29.7 °C.
Like the external electrical stimuli, the thermal pulses in TC-mode led to the generation of action potentials in neurons upon reaching the threshold depolarization values. Since in current-clamp mode, the voltage response to local temperature is inert, the depolarization magnitude can be adjusted not only by the amplitude of the thermal pulse but also by its duration. Note that DHT1.4 was capable of inducing depolarization currents with a frequency of at least 2 kHz and a pulse duration of 100 μs (Fig. S6†). Fig. 3a shows a comparison of the voltage time courses, whilst 10 Hz sequences of pulses of different durations were applied, as the DHT1.4 was heated to 40 °C. Starting with 5 ms, thermal depolarization reached the threshold potential with a 20% probability, while pulses with a duration of 10 ms reliably led to action potential generation. The detailed overlay of 10 ms pulses on the voltage time course is shown in Fig. 3b, demonstrating accurate “on-demand” generation of action potentials, at the thermal pulse rate of 10 Hz.
The most suitable frequency for thermal-induced action potential generation in most neurons was found to be 10 Hz. However, some cells were able to respond at frequencies up to 30 Hz (Fig. 3c) and 25 Hz (Fig. 3d), where dense overlapping of action potentials during the repolarization and auto-hyperpolarization phases was observed, as well as a slight (10–15%) decrease in their amplitude. Notably, a similar relative decrease in the AP peak amplitude occurring during heat pulses was also observed in P-mode (Fig. 3f). We measured the action potential durations during electrical stimulation in the absence of thermal impact and found that the action potential duration at 90% repolarization (APD90) in the most cases was 25–30 ms. Therefore, the rate of the thermal stimulation is naturally limited to 30–40 Hz due to the prolonged APD in cultured neurons21 and, in part, due to related factors such as the refractory period of the preceding action potential overlap with the subsequent thermal depolarization. Additionally, the thermal excitability was studied with a smaller size of the heat source (DHT0.5). It was found that application of a 5 Hz train of heat pulses with ΔT = 26 °C also evoked APs in the primary culture of neurons (Fig. S7†).
An observation of the amplitude decrease of APs in both TC-mode and P-mode led us to consider the waveform of APs in detail. In order to understand how the local temperature affects the peak amplitude and duration of APs, an electrical stimulation and thermal exposure were combined. Specifically, a short-term electrical stimulus was necessary for the controlled depolarization of the cell to the threshold potential, while a local thermal pulse of the same duration played a controlling role by altering the shape of the evoked action potential (AP). Fig. 4a and b illustrate the evolution of action potential shape with an increasing temperature in the case of strong coupling between the DHT1.4 and cell membrane (TCM) for both current- and voltage-clamp modes, respectively. As in previous studies on AP property modulation with macroscale temperatures,22 the spike amplitude decreased as the local Theat increased (Fig. 4c). This effect was most clearly manifested in the current-clamp mode, where spike amplitudes dropped by up to 30% (from 60 to 42 mV) at Theat ∼ 57 °C. In contrast, action potentials recorded in the voltage-clamp mode experienced only a slight decrease in amplitude of 2–3%, which can be partly explained by the fact that current is less susceptible to possible changes in cell capacitance than voltage. Similar to the peak amplitude, a trend towards acceleration of the depolarization and repolarization phases of APs was observed (Fig. 4d). The full width at half maximum (FWHM or APD50) decreased in both current-clamp and voltage-clamp modes by 33% and 25%, respectively. As one might expect, action potential rise and decay times followed the trend of the FWHM and decreased with temperature. Yet, the depolarization time reproducibly decreased with the temperature rise, becoming 2–4% faster than the repolarization time.
The above results obtained on cultured neurons demonstrate the reliable capability of thermal control over the potential and current of excitable cells. To determine the possible impact of the local temperature upsurge on non-excitable cells and examine whether the TCM transition is an intrinsic property exclusive to excitable cells, we performed the DHT1.4 stimulation measurements in whole-cell-clamped HEK293 cells. Initially, a 500 ms 42.7 °C thermal pulse was applied to the cell three times (Fig. 5b) to stimulate the TCM transition. While the first pulse elicited a slight inward current of ∼10 pA, the second one enhanced the response up to 40 pA by the end of the thermal exposure. The third pulse did not result in a significant increase in depolarization currents, leading us to conclude that TC-mode had been achieved. Subsequently, the application of a 50 ms temperature pulse at Theat = 55 °C produced the same current response as observed in neurons (Fig. 5a), with an inward direction at high negative holding potentials and outward at positive potentials. In contrast to neurons, the reversal of the current sign for HEKs occurred at a higher holding potential, −26 mV.
The dynamics of heat-induced currents in HEK293 cells were studied at different local temperatures. The amplitude of the current response exhibited linear growth with increasing local temperature, showing no signs of saturation even at ΔT > 35 °C (Fig. 5e). The transition time required to reach the new current level was found to be independent of temperature, and approximately 1 ms. This time constant was used to determine the magnitude of the flowing charge and to construct the corresponding Q–V curves (Fig. 5g). The capacitive charge (−75 pA at −126 mV and ΔT = 37.5 °C) was comparable in magnitude to the corresponding parameter for neurons. Contrary to data obtained in neurons, analysis of 5 HEK cells showed no divergence in reversal potential; at different local temperatures, the current sign change always occurred at −26 mV.
Finally, the response of membrane resistance and capacitance to local heat in TCM for different types of cells was evaluated (Fig. 6). For this, a train of 200 ms 10 mV depolarizing voltage pulses was applied to the cell. By analyzing the renewed level of current and calculating the charge over transient current response, these parameters were estimated. As expected, the capacitance was found to increase by 5–6% under elevation of local temperature to 40 °C, while the resistance synchronously decreased from 10% up to 40%. However, since HEK 293 forms the syncytium of cells and primary neuronal cultures produce the extracellular matrix, a relatively high native capacitance of the cells was observed.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Alteration of membrane resistance (a and c) and capacitance (b and d) of the cultured neurons and HEK cells by 10 s 40 °C DHT1.4 heating (from 10 s to 20 s). |
In previously reported studies, predominantly the entire surface of the cell was exposed to heat, leading to a displacement of the membrane potential by amounts ranging from several millivolts to 30 mV for infrared and plasmonic thermal stimulation, respectively.1,2 Given that the DHT occupies only ∼3% of the cell soma surface, the equivalent depolarization for the entire cell in PM is around 30 mV, which is consistent with previous studies.1,12 Meanwhile, a similar estimation for TCM at a local temperature of 37 °C gives ∼330 mV, significantly exceeding the acceptable physiological limit. Therefore, heating at the cellular scale in earlier experiments would lead to irreversible damage at these temperatures rather than triggering phase changes in the phospholipid membrane bilayer as the DHT does.
Generally, heat affects the properties of the phospholipid bilayer by altering its fluidity and permeability. At higher temperatures, phospholipid molecules gain kinetic energy. The resulting increased fluidity can disrupt the membrane structure producing the ‘melting’ effect, as the phospholipids move further apart. Thus the membrane permeability is increased, potentially allowing normally impenetrant molecules to pass through more easily (local poration). An observed increase in cell capacitance by 5–6% in TCM alters the ionic environment in the vicinity of the phospholipid bilayer, eliciting depolarization currents through the cell membrane. According to the recently proposed MechanoElectrical Thermal Activation (META) theory,20 the total displacement current is contributed by capacitive currents and concurrent changes of the surface charge densities in Stern layers, with a corresponding thermal capacitance increase rate of ∼0.3%/°C. At the same time, the decrease of cell membrane resistance and increase of inward currents potentially refer to either reversible changes in the joint contribution of ion channels, particularly sodium (Na+) and potassium (K+),9,23 or the possible formation of local pores in the lipid bilayer with enhanced fluidity,12,24 facilitating non-selective ion transport. Eventually, local heat above the physiological range may cause denaturation of proteins on the cell membrane,25 leading to the dysfunction of specific cellular receptors. However, since the voltage response to DHT stimuli in TCM is reversible over time, we believe this thermodynamic route is less probable.
The abovementioned factors partly explain changes in excitability and AP shape in neurons at local temperature elevation. First, a faster kinetics of ion channels may lead to a quicker inactivation of Na+ channels and a more rapid activation of K+ channels, reducing the overlap between inward Na+ currents and outward K+ currents.22,23 The rapid inactivation of Na+ channels results in a shorter duration of the action potential, as the period during which Na+ ions enter the neuron is curtailed. Consequently, the action potential peak amplitude diminishes since fewer Na+ ions contribute to the depolarization phase. Second, an increased membrane fluidity may facilitate the inactivation of Na+ channels and the activation of K+ channels, thereby supporting the rapid repolarization of the action potential and contributing to a reduced AP amplitude and duration.
Previous studies have demonstrated that the stimulation of a single neuron in the neocortex can lead to measurable changes in mammalian behavior.26,27 Additionally, theoretical analyses have explored the implications and significance of these conceptually influential neurons within the primate brain.28 These studies indicate that there should be no principled limitations to the application of the DHT method beyond cultured cells under slice or in vivo conditions.
In conclusion, we demonstrate the capability of spatiotemporally confined thermal stimuli to significantly alter the physiological properties of cells. A novel approach based on the interaction between the plasma membrane and local heat sources is promising for controlling cellular electrophysiological states, although temperatures beyond physiological limits pose risks of thermal damage, necessitating careful calibration and control to ensure cell viability and function. The ability to trigger action potentials at sub-physiological temperatures immediately after the thermal-capture transition along with the reduction of APDs, opens uncharted avenues for refined neurostimulation techniques.
HEK293TN cells were grown in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum. One or two days before patching, cells were plated on a 4-well plate (d = 15.4 mm) with an average density of 65 cells per mm2.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4bm01114g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |