Open Access Article
Ryohei
Mizoue
a,
Takashi
Takeda
abc,
Shun
Dekura
ab,
Mikiya
Kato
de,
Tomoya
Fukui
de,
Yoshiaki
Shoji
de,
Takanori
Fukushima
def,
Saya
Yamane
g,
Yasutaka
Suzuki
g,
Jun
Kawamata
g and
Tomoyuki
Akutagawa
*ab
aGraduate School of Engineering, Tohoku University, Sendai 980-8579, Japan
bInstitute of Multidisciplinary Research for Advanced Materials (IMRAM), Tohoku University, 2-1-1 Katahira, Aoba-ku, Sendai 980-8577, Japan. E-mail: akutagawa@tohoku.ac.jp
cFaculty of Science, Shinshu University, 3-1-1 Asahi, Matsumoto 390-8621, Japan
dLaboratory for Chemistry and Life Science, Institute of Innovative Research, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Yokohama 226-8503, Japan
eSchool of Materials and Chemical Technology, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Yokohama 226-8503, Japan
fLiving Systems Materialogy (LiSM) Research Group, International Research Frontiers Initiative (IRFI), Tokyo Institute of Technology, 4259 Nagatsuta, Midori-ku, Yokohama 226-8503, Japan
gGraduate School of Sciences and Technology for Innovation, Yamaguchi University, 1677-1 Yoshida, Yamaguchi, 753-8512, Japan
First published on 19th March 2024
1,8,13-Tris(dodecyloxy)triptycene forms uniform two-dimensional (2D) thin films by self-assembly. We synthesized new 1,8,13- and 1,8-substituted triptycene derivatives in which the alkoxy chains were replaced with alkylamide chains capable of hydrogen-bonding and investigated their phase transition behaviors, molecular assembly structures, and dielectric properties. In the three-chain compounds, the formation of a tightly packed 2D structure dominated by one-dimensional (1D) intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds was observed. In the two-chain compounds, the molecular arrangement and hydrogen bonding patterns were different from those of the three-chain molecules due to the decrease in the occupied volume of the alkyl chains and molecular symmetry, and the disorder in the molecular arrangement increased in the hydrophobic moiety. Both compounds exhibit solid-to-solid and solid-to-liquid phase transitions without forming a liquid-crystalline phase. In the temperature- and frequency-dependent dielectric constants, thermally activated dynamics of the polar amide groups with increasing temperature was observed at low frequencies, accompanied by a hysteresis in the polarization–electric field (P–E) curve above 400 K, which is a characteristic of ferroelectrics.
An interesting π-skeleton capable of forming 2D molecular arrays by self-assembly has been developed using triptycene.17–19 For instance, 1,8,13-tris(dodecyloxy)triptycene, in which three dodecyl ether chains are introduced at the 1, 8, and 13-positions of triptycene, can form 2D thin films on a variety of substrate surfaces.17 The 2D arrangement of the triptycene moieties with three-fold symmetry provides the molecular thin films with excellent stability and flexibility via the aid of multipoint van der Waals interactions between the alkyl chains. Applications of a 2D molecular layered structure to organic transistors and thermoplastic materials have already been reported.20–25 Thus, 1,8,(13)-substituted triptycene represents an interesting molecular motif for the design of organic functional materials featuring 2D structural elements.
The development of functional organic materials based on dynamic molecular assemblies has attracted much attention in recent years.26–32 For example, proton and ion dynamics in molecular assemblies facilitate ferroelectricity and ionic conductivity,33,34 and molecular rotational dynamics causes dielectric phase transitions and ferroelectricity.35,36 Among the structural units that can be used to realize diverse dynamics in solids, alkylamide chains (–CONHCnH2n+1) are the most promising unit, because of their hydrophobic interactions and intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonding, both of which coexist in the molecular assemblies.37–39 The formation of discotic hexagonal columnar (Colh) liquid-crystalline phases has been reported for N,N′,N′′-tri(tetradecyl)-1,3,5-benzenetricrboxamide with three alkylamide chains at the 1, 3, and 5-positions of benzene, and ferroelectricity with reversal of the polarization direction has been reported in the Colh phase when an external electric field is applied.40–44 The inversion of polar intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds along the 1D chains can result in a macroscopic dipole inversion, which is the origin of ferroelectricity. The partial melting of alkyl chains in the molecular assembly plays an important role in the inversion of intermolecular amide hydrogen bonds even in the solid state.45 The π-electron cores at the molecular center have been utilized for pyrene,46,47 tetrabenzoporphyrin,48 and azobenzene,49 in addition to benzene rings, and offer a lot of design freedom. 1D ferroelectrics can be formed by the formation of π-stacks and intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds. The introduction of alkylamide chains into nonplanar π-electron compounds such as helicenes tends to form 2D hydrogen-bonding networks, increasing the values of the physical properties in ferroelectrics, remanent polarization (Pr), and coercive electric field (Ec), compared to materials featuring 1D hydrogen-bonding chains.50 Furthermore, the chiral design of intermolecular amide hydrogen-bonding chains plays an important role in controlling the physical properties of ferroelectrics by utilizing the dynamics of the molecules.51,52
Triptycene is an interesting research target as a π-core to introduce multiple alkylamide chains. In previous studies, introduction of alkylamide chains into disc-shaped π-molecules such as benzene and pyrene resulted in the formation of 1D columnar structures and 1D ferroelectrics. The introduction of alkylamide chains into triptycene has the potential to form molecular assemblies that differ from 1D structures. Since triptycene easily adopts a 2D π-interdigitated layered structure and forms a stable 2D arrangement by self-assembly of alkyl chains through van der Waals interactions, the formation of intermolecular hydrogen bonding through additional amide units is expected to affect the 2D layered structure. In this study, we synthesized N,N′,N′′-tritetradecyl-1,8,13-triptycenetricarboxamide (C14TATP) and N,N′-ditetradecyl-1,8-triptycenedicarboxamide (C14DATP) and investigated their phase transition behaviors, assembly structures, and dielectric properties and succeeded in revealing C14TATP shows a tightly packed 2D structure dominated by one-dimensional (1D) intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds and ferroelectricity by the inversion of the amide group in the solid phase (Scheme 1). The reduction in the number of alkyl chains in C14DATP produced randomness in the packing structure, which affected the dielectric response and ferroelectricity.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Phase-transition behaviors. (a) DSC charts of C14DATP (blue i) and C14TATP (black ii) in the second heating cycle. (b) POM images of C14TATP at 300, 350, and 500 K. | ||
A similar phase transition behavior was observed for the triple-chain compound, C14TATP, displaying S1–S2 and S2-IL phase transitions at 320 (ΔH = 30.9 kJ mol−1) and 532 K (ΔH = 52.5 kJ mol−1), respectively. Compared to C14DATP, the S2-IL phase transition temperature for C14TATP increased by 92 K, which was due to the presence of an additional intermolecular hydrogen bonding site that allows for the stabilization of the ordered phase up to higher temperatures. As expected, ΔH accompanying the S2-IL phase transition for C14TATP is 1.5 times larger than that for C14DATP (ΔH = 34.9 kJ mol−1). Fig. 1b shows the change in the polarized optical microscopy (POM) image of C14TATP with increasing temperature. The S1 phase showed a dark field under a Cross-Nicol arrangement, whereas, upon the phase-transition into S2, the POM image turned bright with the emergence of a birefringent texture. This corresponds to a change in the domain orientation.
Fig. 2a and b show the assembly structures of C6TATP viewed along the a- and c-axis, respectively. C6TATP molecules form a layered structure with a 2D arrangement in the bc plane, where the neighboring molecules are aligned in such a way that the longer molecular axis orientations are opposite to each other. Unlike the 2D lamellar structure observed for 1,8,13-tris(dodecyloxy)triptycene, an interdigitated molecular assembly between the triptycene moieties was not observed. On the other hand, intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonding interactions were observed along the c-axis, where the intramolecular and intermolecular N–O distances (dN–O) were 2.847(2) Å, 2.802(8), and 2.749(7) Å, respectively. The intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds are stronger than intramolecular ones. Given that there are no effective intermolecular interactions along the a-axis that corresponds to the interlayer direction, the hydrogen-bonding interaction is considered to be the most effective intermolecular interaction in determining the packing structure of the molecular assembly.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Crystal structure of C6TATP at 100 K. Unit cell viewed (a) along the a-axis and (b) along the c-axis. | ||
Fig. 3b shows the temperature-dependent PXRD pattern of C14DATP with regular diffraction peaks appearing at 2θ = 4.09, 6.07, 8.11, 10.2, 12.2, 14.2. 16.3, and 18.4°. These can be well-explained by considering a layer periodicity with a d-spacing of 43.1 Å and correspond to correlation lengths of 1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5, 1/6 1/8, and 1/9. Therefore, the molecular assembly of C14DATP has a 2D layered structure. We can now conclude that the dark-field POM images observed for the S1 and S2 phases are due to the formation of a homeotropic alignment perpendicular to the substrate surface, rather than randomly oriented domains. Notably, both C14TATP and C14DATP form 2D molecular assemblies with a layered lamellar structure, whereas the values of the layer periodicity (d = 25.5 and 43.1 Å for C14TATP and C14DATP, respectively) are very different from each other.
The molecular arrangements of C14TATP and C14DATP can be discussed in terms of 2D layered structures with different interlayer spacings. Assuming that the alkyl chains adopt an all-trans conformation, the maximum molecular lengths of C14TATP and C14DATP are estimated to be about 25 Å (Scheme 2a), with a thickness of about 7 Å for the triptycene moiety and an alkylamide chain length of about 18 Å. The molecular arrangement in C14TATP is expected to be dominated by 1D intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds, as observed for single-crystalline C6TATP. The neighboring C14TATP molecules are arranged in upper and lower orientations with respect to each other, allowing the formation of a closest-packed structure even when the alkyl chain length is elongated from hexyl to tetradecyl chains (Scheme 2b). The amide N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds are formed in a direction parallel to the 2D layer. The molecular length of about 25 Å is in good agreement with an interlayer spacing of d = 25.5 Å found in the PXRD pattern.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Possible packing structure of C14TATP. (a) Schematic molecule and (b) its assembly strucuture. | ||
C14DATP having two tetradecylamide chains gives a longer lamellar periodicity of d = 43.1 Å than C14TATP, suggesting that its closest-packing structure is different from that of C14TATP. The size of the triptycene moiety is compatible in volume with the three alkyl chains, and the formation of an interdigitated structure of the triptycene moiety and the closest-packing of the alkyl chains has been reported for a tris(alkoxyl)-substituted triptycene derivative that realizes a 2D sheet-like structure. In the case of double-chain compounds such as C14DATP, a space to be occupied by the alkyl chains remains in contrast with that in C14TATP, and the molecular arrangement is different from that of triple-chain compounds such as C14TATP to maintain the closest-packing structure. Considering the lamellar periodicity of d = 43.1 Å observed in the PXRD pattern of C14DATP as well as the formation of intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds, a possible molecular arrangement can be proposed (Scheme 3). The lamellar periodicity (d = 43.1 Å) cannot be explained without assuming a dimer unit as a basic structure. It is reasonable to consider a dimer unit, in which the triptycene moieties interact in a face-to-face manner (left in Scheme 3a). The bilayer lamellar structure (d = 43.1 Å) can be explained if the alkyl chains are tilted about 54° with respect to the layer plane (Scheme 3b). Even in this case, intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds are possibly formed in the in-plane direction of the bilayer structure. However, when the packing density of the alkyl chains is reduced, it appears difficult to form a closest-packing structure as in the case of three alkyl chains with an all-trans conformation. Therefore, the conformational and packing patterns of the alkyl chains in the C14DATP assembly are expected to be different to the case of C14TATP.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 Possible packing structure of C14DATP. (a) Schematic dimer molecular units and (b) its assembly strucuture. | ||
hydrogen bonding interactions in the C14TATP and C14DATP assemblies, temperature-dependent IR spectra of KBr pellets were measured (Fig. 4). C14TATP and C14DATP exhibit S1–S2 phase transitions at 318 and 291 K, respectively. At 300 K, the asymmetrical stretching vibrational bands (νNH) of the amide unit of C14TATP appear at two different energies of 3258 and 3318 cm−1. The former νNH band is assigned to the intermolecular hydrogen-bonding amide groups, while the latter νNH band is assigned to the intramolecular hydrogen-bonding amide groups. The presence of amide groups in two different environments is consistent with the crystal structure of C6TATP. On the other hand, a broad νNH band is observed at 3299 cm−1 for the double-chain compound C14DATP at 300 K. The absence of νNH bands that are not involved in hydrogen bonding indicates that all the alkylamide chains in C14DATP contribute to intramolecular and intermolecular hydrogen-bonding interactions. The hydrogen-bonding νNH band for C14DATP is observed at higher energies than those for C14TATP, suggesting that a weaker hydrogen-bonding interaction is present in the former assembly.
Upon increasing the temperature from the S1 phase at room temperature to the S2 phase, the energy of the νNH band in each compound shows a blue-shift. For C14TATP, the νNH band at 470 K is observed at 3279 cm−1, which is blue-shifted by approximately 20 cm−1 from that observed at 300 K. In contrast, the νNH band for C14DATP at 460 K is observed at 3279 cm−1, with a blue-shift of 12 cm−1 compared to that at 300 K. The changes in the FWHM of the νNH bands for C14TATP and C14DATP upon increasing the temperature from 300 to 470 K are +14 and 0 cm−1, respectively. The broadening of the νNH band for C14TATP is most likely due to an effect of randomness arising from thermal motion and disordering of hydrogen-bonding interactions. Therefore, the temperature increase results in thermal fluctuations in the N–H⋯O
hydrogen-bonding sites of C14TATP, leading to a change so that they can respond to external electric fields. On the other hand, given the fact that the νNH band of C14DATP remains almost intact with the temperature change and remains broad over a wide range including room temperature, and the N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds with different strengths coexist in the assembly (Fig. S9, ESI†). We presume that in C14DATP having only two alkyl amide chains, a closest-packing of alkyl chains prevails over the formation of a structure with optimal hydrogen bonding between the amide groups, leading to randomness within the 2D structure and in turn the insensitivity of the νNH band to the temperature change.
hydrogen bonding and a closest-packed structure in the 2D plane of the three alkyl-chains in C14TATP induced a rigid crystal lattice and dielectric response only at high temperatures.
The temperature- and frequency-dependent dielectric constants ε1 of C14DATP (Fig. 5b) are different from those of C14TATP. A frequency-dependent broad peak varying from ε1 ∼3 to 3.5 was observed around 290 K, where the S1–S2 phase transition of C14DATP occurs. Upon further heating, the ε1 value at a low frequency of 100 Hz increased from ∼350 K. Compared to C14TATP, the observed frequency- and temperature-dependence of C14DATP is more pronounced, and it can be concluded that the change in the dipole moment of C14DATP is greatly affected by the external field in the assembly. The imaginary part of the dielectric constant (ε2) shows a frequency-dependent broad peak near the S1–S2 phase transition point, which is the characteristic of a single-Debye type relaxation process for the dielectric response. The random 2D arrangement of two alkylamide chains in C14DATP reduced the crystallinity and uniformity of the intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen-bonding network. The loose packing structure of C14DATP induced broad T- and f-dependent dipole responses. These results are consistent with the fact that the νNH band broadens around room temperature in the IR spectra of C14DATP.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Frequency-dependent P–E hysteresis curves of (a) C14TATP and (b) C14DATP. I–E plots of (c) C14TATP and (d) C14DATP at T = 400 K and f = 0.2 Hz. | ||
In C14TATP and C14DATP, ferroelectricity was also observed in the P–E curves in the 2D structure in the solid state. The inversion motion of the hydrogen-bonded alkylamide chains within the 2D structure due to the electric field resulted in the polarization inversion and ferroelectricity. The thermally induced partial melting of the alkyl chains plays an important role in the reversal motion of the polar amide groups in hydrogen-bonding states. The remanent polarization (Pr) and coercive electric field (Ec) of C14TATP at 400 K with f = 0.2 Hz were 0.99 μC cm−2 and 3.88 V μm−1, respectively, while those of C14DATP at 400 K with f = 0.2 Hz were 1.38 μC cm−2 and 5.82 V μm−1. The Pr value of C14DATP is slightly larger than that of C14TATP; however, the magnitude of Pr for both compounds are same to each other accompanying a difference of leakage current. The similarity in Pr between C14TATP and C14DATP can be accounted for a scenario that only two of the three alkylamide chains in the former are involved in hydrogen-bonding interactions, and thus their contribution to the magnitude of Pr is the same as in C14DATP. On the other hand, the Ec value of C14TATP was smaller than that of C14DATP. This is because the formation of regular intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds provides a constant barrier height for the dipole inversion. In the contrary, the disordered N–H⋯O
hydrogen-bonds in the 2D structure of C14DATP generates a random energy barrier for the dipole inversion, which is thought to be the result of the increase in Ec.
hydrogen bonded chains were observed in both compounds, and ferroelectricity due to the inversion dynamics of the polar amide units was observed in the higher-temperature solid S2 phase above 400 K. Different dielectric responses between C14TATP and C14DATP were observed, and the dielectric response of the latter is dominated by the disordered packing of the alkylamide chains. The νNH band of C14DATP in the assembly was broadened compared to that of C14TATP, indicating the presence of disordered N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonding interactions. The P–E hysteresis was observed in the high-temperature S1 phase for both compounds, which is consistent with the presence of polarization inversion dynamics of the polar amide groups in the C14DATP assembly. The Pr values were comparable for both compounds, whereas the Ec values varied depending on the number of alkyl amide chains present. The intermolecular N–H⋯O
hydrogen bonds of C14DATP were more disordered than those of C14TATP, and the presence of structural randomness resulted in an increase in the polarization inversion energy. The design of alkylamide chains allows for the development of diverse ferroelectric molecular assemblies, and further design of π-electronic systems could lead to the creation of diverse multifunctional molecular materials.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2295387. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3tc04752k |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |