Seo Yeon
Han‡
a,
Jung Jae
Do‡
ab and
Jae Woong
Jung
*ab
aDepartment of Advanced Materials Engineering for Information & Electronics, Kyung Hee University, 1732 Deogyeong-daero, Giheung-gu, Yongin-si, Gyeonggi-do 446-701, Republic of Korea. E-mail: wodndwjd@khu.ac.kr
bIntegrated Education Institute for Frontier Materials (BK21 Four), Kyung Hee University, 1732 Deogyeong-daero, Giheung-gu, Yongin-si, Gyeonggi-do 446-701, Republic of Korea
First published on 30th May 2024
Efforts have focused on ensuring bright and reliable light emission from perovskite thin films to achieve high-performance full-color display technology in perovskite light-emitting diodes (PeLEDs). We herein suggest a multi-ligand engineering approach, incorporating octylammonium iodide (OAI) as an adjunct alkylammonium ligand to enhance the quality of quasi-2D perovskite films designed for red emission in PeLEDs. The strategic use of OAI slows down the crystallization kinetics of perovskite nanocrystallites, leading to reduced defect density and improved crystallinity in the films. Systematic characterizations cover surface morphology, photoluminescence properties, and electrical characteristics, revealing the mechanisms behind the observed enhancements. These OAI-modified perovskite films serve as the high-performance emitting layer in the red PeLEDs, demonstrating notable performance metrics: a maximum electroluminescence (ELMax) of 962 cd m−2, a peak external quantum efficiency (EQE) of 8.62%, and a low turn-on voltage of 1.59 V, as compared to the pristine device (ELMax: 685.08 cd m−2 and EQE: 0.92%). Notably, the operational stability is exceptional, with a half-lifetime of >18 hours, marking a significant advancement in reliable red PeLED technology.
The achievement of full-color light emission from MHPs has been facilitated by introducing quantum confinement effects or manipulating halide composition. However, theoretical investigations of CsPbX3 nanocrystal systems reveal that halide vacancies and dangling bonds at the crystal surface result in local point defects and accumulated charge density, leading to a noticeable reduction in PLQY.7–10 Simultaneously, an increase in halide composition compromises film morphology and crystallinity, yielding non-uniform light emission and unfavorable carrier injection.11–15 Moreover, mixed-halide PeLEDs exhibit severe instability in EL spectra due to phase segregation and ion migration under an electrical field. In the case of CsPbI3 crystals designed for red-emission, a high-temperature thermal post-treatment process is necessary to suppress the formation of δ-phase crystals and promote the development of a stable α-phase.16 However, high-temperature processes, while enhancing crystallinity, result in irregular crystallites with uncontrollable morphology development and numerous surface defects, contributing to a rough surface, shortened exciton diffusion lengths, and poor radiative recombination.17–25 Ion migration within MHP crystals also causes the degradation of PeLEDs, leading to phase segregation in perovskite films and device performance deterioration.26–29
To address these challenges, organic ligands are commonly employed to generate quasi-2D perovskites with less-defect film morphology for high PLQY, resulting in elevated luminance and EQEs in red PeLEDs.30 The energy level matching of perovskite crystallites along stepwise n phases could enhance carrier transport behavior by suppressing non-radiative recombination in quasi-2D perovskite films. However, the presence of variable n phases can contribute to a broadened light emission bandwidth without meticulous design of phase distribution. Aggregated organic ligands may also decompose PLQY and increase the internal resistance of perovskite emitter films, affecting the optoelectronic properties and long-term operative stability of red PeLEDs. Therefore, the exploration of defect-free perovskite nanocrystallites through the optimization of halide ratio, dimensionality, and the incorporation of multiple organic ligands is desirable for preparing red PeLEDs with improved optoelectronic performance and long-term operative stability.31–33
In this study, a multi-ligand engineering approach is proposed for the fabrication of high-quality quasi-2D perovskite films intended for use in PeLEDs with red emission. Octylammonium iodide (OAI) is introduced as an adjunct ligand to decelerate the crystallization kinetics of perovskite nanocrystallites. This strategic integration of a long alkylammonium ligand results in a reduction in defect density and an augmentation of crystallinity within the perovskite films. Systematic characterization of the perovskite films is conducted, encompassing evaluation of surface morphology, photoluminescence (PL) properties, and electrical characteristics, thereby elucidating the mechanisms underlying the observed enhancements. Ultimately, the modified perovskite films serve as the emissive layer (EML) in the realization of the red PeLEDs, achieving noteworthy performance metrics. Specifically, these devices exhibit a maximum EQE of 8.62% and luminance reaching 962.15 cd m−2. Additionally, the operational stability of the red PeLEDs is exceptional, as evidenced by a half-lifetime (LT50) of approximately 18 hours, representing reliable red PeLEDs.
The crystallization kinetics of perovskite films prepared with a multi-ligand system was monitored. As illustrated in Fig. 1a, the film's color transitioned from transparent to dark brown as the multi-ligand CsPbIXBr3−X films solidified and crystallized at 80 °C. The OAI-modified film exhibited a retarded nucleation rate and slower crystallization compared to the pristine film, attributed to the presence of the octylammonium ligand.38 Generally, 3D perovskite lattices rapidly self-assemble and grow in irregular phase distribution and surface defects than the quasi-2D perovskites.39 The delayed crystallization observed in the OAI-modified perovskite films suggested the formation of larger and more regular nanocrystallites in the perovskite films. To further elucidate the crystallization behavior of perovskite films, X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of two perovskite films, with and without OAI (2 mol%), were compared (Fig. 1b). In the pristine perovskite film, two diffraction peaks at 14.32° and 28.92° corresponding to the typical (100) and (200) planes of α-phase CsPbI3 crystals in the cubic phase were observed. Upon the introduction of OAI, the intensity of (100) and (200) diffractions for α-phase CsPbI3 crystals was enhanced, indicating that the incorporation of OAI facilitated more regulated crystal growth. Furthermore, a slight peak shift to 14.34° and 28.98° for the (100) and (200) planes, respectively, along with a narrowing of the peak width, was observed in the presence of OAI. This observation was attributed to well-dispersed mixed halides (I− and Br−) as well as a slight increase in iodide content in the perovskite films due to OAI. It is noted that the narrower diffraction peak of the perovskite film with OAI also implies enlarged nanocrystalline domains, as summarized in the ESI (Table S1†).
The surface morphologies of the perovskite films were systematically examined utilizing atomic force microscopy (AFM). As shown in Fig. 1c, the pristine perovskite film manifests discernible aggregates on a rough surface, characterized by a root-mean-squared roughness of 8.72 nm. Conversely, in the presence of OAI, the film's roughness gradually diminished, measuring 5.92, 5.31, 5.39, and 5.57 nm for films incorporated with 1, 2, 3, and 4 mol% OAI, respectively. Furthermore, the grains of the perovskite exhibited enlargement with increasing OAI content in the perovskite films, which is consistent with the XRD study. This augmentation in grain size within the perovskite crystals is attributed to the growing OAI content, presenting a notable difference in nucleation and crystal growth owing to retarded crystallization kinetics. Larger grain sizes in perovskite crystals contribute to a reduction in defective antisites, thereby elevating the probability of radiative recombination and exciton recombination energy. However, an excessive incorporation of OAI led to aggregation between crystals and the formation of very large domains within the perovskite crystals. Consequently, an optimal concentration of OAI (2 mol%) was determined to optimize the controlled crystallization kinetics of perovskite films, resulting in enlarged crystal sizes, domains, and enhanced crystallinity.
The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images in Fig. 1d reveal a pronounced change in the film surface morphology of the OAI-modified perovskite film: uniform perovskite films with fewer pinholes were obtained by utilizing OAI as an additional ligand in the red-emitting perovskite films (Fig. S1† for lower magnification SEM images). Furthermore, Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM) images were collected to confirm surface potential variations in the perovskite films in Fig. 1e. The pristine perovskite films exhibited surface potential variation of σ ∼ 16.57 μV over the whole film surface, while the OAI-modified perovskite films displayed a smoother and more uniform surface potential variation throughout the film (σ ∼ 9.21 μV) (3D KPFM images and corresponding line profiles in Fig. S2†). Thus, pinhole-free, smooth perovskite films with reduced grain boundaries and defect sites could be obtained by modifying the perovskite film with OAI.40 It is also noted that the OAI-modified perovskite film exhibited increased hydrophobicity of the film surface, which also confirms partial engagement of octylammonium ligands on the lattice surface of perovskite nanocrystals and the grain boundaries of perovskite films (Fig. S3†).
Possible coordination of OAI with PbI2 is further confirmed by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR). The full spectra of FT-IR of three samples are presented in Fig. S4.† In Fig. 2a, the characteristic stretching vibrations of OAI were observed in a multiple peak at ∼2900 cm−1 and a broad absorption at 3040 cm−1 for the alkyl chain (CH2/CH3) and ammonium cation (NH4+), respectively. As OAI was mixed with PbI2, the N–H absorption peak was reduced while no shift or absorption change was found in the region for C–H stretching. In the mixture of perovskite and OAI, the N–H absorption peak re-appears at a higher wavenumber of 3100 cm−1 because of Lewis acid–base chelation between Pb and ammonium ligands in the solid-state. However, multiple peaks for C–H stretching remain without peak shift. This phenomenon could be explained by sufficient coordination of ammonium in OAI with Pb2+ or Pb clusters. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) is then conducted to determine the electronic interaction between the perovskite and OAI (Fig. 2b). Two peaks were observed at 141.7 and 137.0 eV in the pristine perovskite film, corresponding to Pb 4f5/2 and Pb 4f7/2, respectively. Those peaks move to the higher binding energy by 0.2 eV in the OAI-modified perovskite film, implying strong coordination bonding between the perovskite and OAI. Other peaks for I 3d, Br 3d, and N 1s were also shifted to higher binding energy after OAI was incorporated in perovskite films due to enforced hydrogen bonding, which confirms the possible role in passivating the defective antisites by OAI.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) FT-IR characteristics, (b) XPS binding energy spectra for Pb 4f, I 3d, Br 3d, and N 1s of perovskite films with and without OAI incorporation (2 mol%). |
The steady-state photoluminescence (PL) spectra for two perovskite films with varied OAI concentration are compared to examine the impact of multiligand with OAI on the optoelectronic properties of perovskite films (Fig. S5†). The pristine perovskite film, prepared from a multi-ligand system, displayed a fluorescence emission center at 643 nm with an emission width of 53.2 nm. Upon OAI addition, the PL peak exhibited a gradual hypsochromic shift to 640, 639, 637, and 634 nm for 1 to 4 mol% OAI, respectively, with a narrower emission bandwidth toward pure-red emission (Fig. 3b and Table 1). The hypsochromic shift observed in the perovskite films, resulting from the addition of OAI, can be attributed to the multifunctional role of OAI. Firstly, OAI influences the crystallization process of perovskite lattices, leading to the formation of uniform, predominantly large-grained, and defect-free perovskite films. Secondly, OAI promotes a reduction in the large-n phases and an enhancement of the small-n phases. Additionally, OAI serves to passivate defective antisites within the perovskite lattices by acting as an alkylammonium ligand. These characteristics collectively contribute to the hypsochromic shift observed in the PL spectra, indicating that the octylammonium ligand may aid in the passivation of deep- and shallow-level trap sites in perovskite nanocrystals, thereby inhibiting trap-assisted non-radiative recombination. Alongside the peak shift, a significant increase in PL intensity was observed in the OAI-modified perovskite film compared to the pristine film, as confirmed by the photographic image of the films (inset of Fig. 3a). Fig. 3c illustrates the time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) curves of the two perovskite films, and the raw data were fitted using a bi-exponential decay function of I = A1exp(−t/τ1) + A2
exp(−t/τ2), where A1 and A2 are relative amplitudes, and τ1 and τ2 are carrier lifetimes for fast- and slow-decay components, respectively.41 (TRPL decay curves for all samples are provided in Fig. S6† and the fitted parameters are summarized in Table S2.†) The average carrier lifetime (τavg) was calculated using the equation τavg = f1 × τ1 + f2 × τ2, where f1 and f2 are the relative ratio factors for A1 and A2 which are calculated using the equation
. The fast decay component (τ1) is attributed to the defect/interface trapping process, while the slow decay component (τ2) originates from bimolecular recombination inside of the bulk perovskite film.42 The OAI-modified perovskite film exhibited an average lifetime (τavg) of 16.44 ns, which is extended compared to the pristine film (τavg = 5.15 ns). This elongated τavg suggests inhibited non-radiative recombination losses of charge carriers in the perovskite films. In addition, the relative ratio factor of fast recombination (f1) was suppressed in the presence of OAI, as summarized in Table S2.† Consequently, the fluorescence analyses conclude that the octylammonium ligand not only contributes to crystallization kinetics, leading to the formation of large crystals with high crystallinity but also influences charge carrier dynamics, suppressing defect-oriented non-radiative recombination in the red-emitting perovskite films.43
Con. OAI (mol%) | λ EL (nm) | FWHMEL (nm) | V on (V) | ELMax (cd m−2) | EQE (%) | CIE (x, y) | LT50 (min) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N/A | 663 | 47.29 | 1.59 | 685.08 | 0.92 | (0.715, 0.284) | 348 |
2 | 657 | 35.50 | 1.59 | 962.15 | 8.62 | (0.711, 0.288) | 1080 |
Fig. 3d presents the absorption spectra of the two perovskite films with and without OAI. The OAI-modified film exhibited higher absorption band at lower n-phases (λ ∼ 460 and 530 nm) as compared to the pristine film, which could contribute to hypsochromic shift of emission properties. In addition, an enhanced content of 2D layered structure could provide controlled stacked layers with varied n values, which also contribute to improved film morphology.44–46 It is noteworthy that the retarded crystallization rate in the OAI-incorporated perovskite films also contributed to the preparation of improved film quality with dense grains and low defect densities. The evaluation of sub-bandgap states could be achieved by investigating the Urbach energy, reflecting lattice vibrations and defect states in polycrystalline semiconducting films. The sub-bandgap absorption near the band edge is exponentially dependent on photon energy, given by the correlation: , where EU is the Urbach energy α(E) is the absorption coefficient of photon energy (E), and αg is the α value at the band-gap energy (Eg) with and without OAI, and the corresponding Urbach tail spectra are shown in the inset of Fig. 3d. The Urbach energy values for the pristine and OAI-modified films were 204.2 and 131.6 meV, respectively. Higher values of EU reveal substantial sub-gap Urbach tail absorption caused by defects related to halide vacancies, pinholes, or grain boundaries. Therefore, it is expected that the octylammonium ligand effectively mitigates the sub-gap defects in the perovskite films.47
To assess the impact of OAI on the optoelectronic properties of red PeLEDs, the devices with the schematic architecture of ITO-coated glass/PEDOT:PSS/perovskite/PCBM/BCP/Al were fabricated, in which, multi-ligand perovskite films were used as light-emitting layers, PEDOT:PSS and PCBM served as the hole and electron transport layers, respectively, and BCP/Al served as the cathode (Fig. 4a). Each functional layer can be clearly distinguished from the cross-sectional scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image in Fig. 4b, which reveals the clear interface of perovskite and interfacial layers. The current density (J)–voltage (V) curves and luminance (L)–V characteristics of the PeLEDs were investigated by varying the content of OAI (0, 1, 2, 3, 4 mol%) and are displayed in Fig. 4c and d. As compared to the pristine device, the OAI-modified devices exhibited distinctly reduced current level below 2 V. However, the PeLEDs showed comparable current density after the turn-on voltage (Von) (1.59 V) regardless of OAI incorporation, while the EL intensity was increased in the presence of OAI in the perovskite emitting layers. Among the varied concentrations of OAI, 2 mol% OAI exhibited the highest EL intensity, resulting in the highest current efficiency and EQE. Therefore, the optimized device configuration was set to include 2 mol% of OAI for further device analyses. When the pristine device and the target device with 2 mol% OAI are compared, much suppressed leakage current in the OAI-modified device before the turn-on voltage (Von = 1.59 V). The leakage current mainly comes from the defects of the perovskite films such as pin-holes, which reveals remarkably diminished defect density in the perovskite emitters. It is noteworthy that the trap-state density (nt) was determined by the space charge limited current (SCLC) technique from the equation nt = (VTFLεε0)/(eL2), where e is the elementary charge, L is the thickness of the perovskite absorber, ε is the dielectric constant of the perovskite film, and ε0 is the vacuum permittivity. The trap site density determined from VTFL decreased from 5.044 × 1015 cm−3 to 3.887 × 1015 cm−3 as OAI was incorporated in the perovskite films, which thus confirms that the inclusion of OAI as an additional ligand effectively eliminates the trap states and prevents the trapping of injected charge carriers (Fig. S7†).48 In the meantime, the OAI-modified PeLEDs recorded the maximum luminance of 962.15 cd m−2 which is much enhanced brightness than the control device (685.08 cd m−2) (Table 1). Notably, the lower leakage current along with excellent optical output achieved higher current efficiency (CE) and external quantum efficiency (EQE) compared to the pristine device. As a result, the PeLEDs based on pristine perovskite emitters showed relatively lower CE and EQE, while other PeLEDs based on the modified perovskite film with a 2 mol% OAI showed higher efficiency, as displayed in Fig. 4e and f (Table S3, ESI,† for device properties of all samples). The champion device of the PeLEDs with OAI incorporation exhibiting a maximum electroluminescence (ELMax) of 962.15 cd m−2 and a peak EQE of 8.62%, which outperformed the pristine device without OAI incorporation (ELMax: 685.08 cd m−2; EQE: 0.92%). In addition, the devices exhibited a high EQE level in the luminance range for 50 to 900 cd m−2 without significant EQE drop at high luminance, demonstrating the high reliability of the high quantum efficiency of the OAI-modified perovskite films in red PeLEDs.
Fig. 5a shows the EL emission spectra of two devices, one with and one without OAI incorporation. Both devices exhibit intense emission characterized by a red color, with peak wavelength of 663 nm and 657 nm for the pristine and the target devices, respectively. It is noteworthy that the EL emission of the OAI-modified perovskite demonstrates remarkable color stability compared to the pristine device, particularly evident as the operating voltage increases from 2 to 8 V, as depicted in Fig. 5b and c. The EL emission aligns with Commission Internationale de L'Eclairage (CIE) coordinates indicative of a red color for both devices (Fig. 5c). In the pristine device, the EL emission at 663 nm corresponds to CIE coordinates (0.715, 0.284), while the addition of OAI yielded color coordinates of (0.711, 0.288) from the emission at 657 nm with a narrower bandwidth, closer to the Rec. 2020-specified primary red coordinates of (0.708, 0.292). Given that defect sites within perovskite lattices significantly influence halide ion movement under an electric field, the incorporation of OAI effectively suppresses ion migration, thereby stabilizing the band gap of the perovskite emitters. Consequently, this leads to enhanced EL stability in PeLEDs under continuous bias.49
Concerning the operational stability, we further investigated the lifetime performance of PeLEDs with and without OAI. Fig. 5e presents the EL lifetime data, measured at a luminance of 100 cd m−2 based on a 50% lifetime (LT50). Notably, all devices in this study were encapsulated, and measurements were performed under ambient conditions. The pristine device exhibited a lifespan of 5.8 hours, whereas the OAI-modified device demonstrated a significantly extended LT50 of 18 hours. This operational longevity, particularly at a luminance level of 100 cd m−2, is noteworthy as PeLEDs of a red emission typically struggle to attain operational lifetimes exceeding a few hours. As listed in Table S4,† the recorded lifetime in this study stands out as one of the most impressive among solution-processed state-of-the-art red PeLEDs. The observed enhancement is attributed to the reduction of trap sites facilitated by the OAI, resulting in improved film quality characterized by low leakage current and favorable charge carrier recombination. The achievement of balanced carrier transport in perovskite emitter films minimizes non-radiative recombination, thereby facilitating radiative carrier recombination and enhancing brightness.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ta00369a |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |