Anjali
Sugunan
,
Anusree V.
Rethnakumaran
and
Mini Mol
Menamparambath
*
Department of Chemistry, National Institute of Technology Calicut, Calicut-673601, Kerala, India. E-mail: neeharabindu@gmail.com; minimol@nitc.ac.in
First published on 11th October 2024
Reckoning the significance of next-generation biosensors and point-of-care sensors, scientists are interested in developing superior nanomaterials with advantageous characteristics that can serve as electrode modifiers in the development of functional devices. MXenes are a broad class of two-dimensional metal carbides and nitrides characterized by their exceptional hydrophilicity, high specific surface area, and high conductivity. MXenes and their derived nanocomposites are presently gaining importance as electrode materials for the electrochemical detection of various biomarkers. This review assesses and summarises current notable accomplishments in the concepts, fabrication, and diverse applications of MXene-based nanocomposites for electrochemical monitoring of a variety of clinically relevant biomarkers. Furthermore, an outline of the existing impediments linked to technological advancement is included, accompanied by proposals for further investigation into the issues.
Biomarkers are a class of cellular, biochemical, or molecular alterations observable in biological media, offering enormous potential for use in various clinical situations, including early disease detection, risk assessment, prognosis, prediction of patients' response to therapeutic intervention, and disease progression or recurrence monitoring.4 Moreover, biomarkers are ideal molecules to reflect the entire spectrum of disease, from early manifestations to the terminal stages of fatal diseases such as psychological/psychiatric disorders, cancerous growth, and circulatory system disorders.4 Biomarkers can be broadly classified into two categories: exposure biomarkers, which are utilised for risk prediction, and disease biomarkers, which are employed for screening, diagnosis, and monitoring of disease developments.5 Disease biomarkers are valuable for early detection or enable the determination of the desired outcome at a more rudimentary stage of the disease. The tests of blood, urine, and cerebrospinal fluids give essential information for clinical diagnosis. Conventional experimental and data analytical techniques such as mass spectrometry, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), spectrophotometric methods, and chromatography require high-end and costly instruments and an expert technician for operation and result interpretation.6
Highly sensitive and selective electrochemical sensors are low-cost alternatives to these conventional techniques because they eliminate the need for intricate procedures, expensive reagents, and professional expertise. Likewise, electrochemical sensors are appealing due to the possibility of device miniaturisation and the ability to develop disposable, flexible, wearable, or implantable devices.7 Electrochemical sensors, thereby, have the potential to play a crucial role in health monitoring, particularly in POC diagnostics, due to their easy use, low cost, excellent sensitivity and selectivity, portability, and user-friendliness.2,8,9 Over the years, the advancements in microfabrication, nanotechnology, and the need for modern medical diagnosis paved the way for research on sensitive and reliable electrochemical sensors rooted in innovative functional materials.
Various functional materials employed in fabricating electrodes have evolved over the years to optimise the analytical performance of electrochemical sensors to increase sensitivity and selectivity for analysing biomarkers from complex biological fluids.10–12 The susceptibility of the sensor depends on the efficient transport of electrons at the electrode–electrolyte interface and, consequently, the high current density in response to the analyte concentrations. Further, the sensitivity of the electrode is enhanced with the application of potential biological molecules, electrochemically active organic/inorganic materials, and their versatile processing techniques.10 The massive proliferation of potential research in nanomaterials and their composites has opened greater horizons in nanomaterial-based electrochemical sensors. Owing to the high surface area and electrocatalytic activities, the nanostructure-modified electrodes have several advantages over standard macro electrodes, including improved mass transport, lower detection limits, and higher signal-to-noise ratios. Hence, biomarker sensing research encompasses active research on transition metal-based nanostructures, oxides, carbon-based nanomaterials, conductive polymers, metal–organic frameworks (MOFs), etc.13 Two-dimensional nanomaterials (2DNMs) are chosen over 0D and 1D nanomaterials as they have a superior surface-to-volume ratio, which increases their chemical reactivity and ensures impactful interaction between the stimulus and material. On account of the tunable conductivity, band gap, high mechanical flexibility, and excellent electrocatalytic activities, 2DNMs can replace other sensing materials in various electroanalytical devices.14 MXenes are innovative additions to the rapidly expanding family of 2D materials with beneficial and customizable physicochemical properties, such as regular metal atomic layers, high electrical conductivity, hydrophilicity, ease of synthesis and functionalization, excellent mechanical strength, and biocompatibility.15 The above-mentioned fundamental features of MXenes fulfil the requirements for an alternative sensor material; hence, MXene has received much interest in the electrochemical monitoring of biomarkers.
In this review, we focus on numerous Ti3C2Tx MXene-based composites recently reported in the electrochemical sensor domain for monitoring biomarkers of clinical importance that are otherwise difficult to detect at an early stage using conventional techniques. The synthesis methods of MXene-based composites are of great importance since they can directly or indirectly influence their final characteristics and applications. Researchers believe that the synergistic effects of high conductivity, large specific area nanosheet structure, and varied surface chemistry are responsible for the significant performance of MXene nanocomposites. MXene-based nanocomposites have shown intriguing promise and are attracting considerable interest for the electrochemical detection of neurotransmitters, small biomolecules, etc. Furthermore, the future directions and perspectives of these hybrid composites for the possibility of upcoming point-of-care sensor applications, a rapidly growing field in the era of MXene-based composites, are discussed.
Following the discovery of MXene, the first and foremost electrochemical sensor based on Ti3C2, an enzymatic biosensor for detecting H2O2, was developed in 2014.28 The large specific surface area, superior biocompatibility, and hydrophilic surface are promising attributes of an immobilisation matrix in fabricating enzyme-based biosensors, as observed with Ti3C2 MXene. The organ-like structure of MXenes drives enzymes to the interior of the nanolayers, while surface terminations (such as hydroxyl groups) stimulate enzyme adsorption onto the surface, thereby increasing immobilisation. The peculiar MXene structure also fosters enzyme entrapment while increasing the likelihood of successful collisions between the substrate and redox protein; moreover, it minimises the chance of enzyme detachment during substrate reaction.21,29 However, the complexity of the immobilization of enzymes, the stability of the electrodes, and the high cost of fabrication hamper the development of MXene-based enzymatic electrochemical sensors. For this reason, the forefront research area focuses on the fabrication of non-enzymatic electrochemical sensors. To mention a few, F. Shahzad et al. created Ti3C2 MXene-modified GCE electrochemical sensors to achieve great sensitivity with a limit of detection (LOD) of 3 nM for detecting the neurotransmitter dopamine (DA) in real samples.30 Recently, Ti3C2Tx dip coated on an e-waste liquid crystal display was demonstrated to exhibit selective and sensitive detection of DA.31 This approach proclaims the viability of MXene-mediated reuse of e-waste to fabricate sustainable electrochemical devices.
The inherent surface terminations arising from the etching process of MXene render exceptional hydrophilicity indispensable for stable dispersions in aqueous or hydrophilic media.32,33 Drop-casting is the most common method for creating modified electrodes, which necessitates preparing a highly stable and well-dispersed coating solution.34 The excellent solution dispersibility of MXene inks is highly useful in fabricating electrodes for electrochemical sensors by drop-casting techniques. Besides surface terminations, intercalants used for delamination have also been observed to influence the conductivity of MXenes significantly. Fig. 1 summarises some of the critical characteristics of MXenes that make them suitable for fabricating electrochemical sensors with high selectivity and nanomolar scale detection limits. Despite their noteworthy features, pure MXenes have several constraints, such as restacking and poor oxidative stability, that restrict their efficacy in electrochemical sensors. Numerous techniques have been employed to enhance the desirable electrocatalytic characteristics of MXenes, including surface and interlayer engineering, doping, and the development of MXene heterostructures.35,36 In addition, many researchers have also used MXene in conjunction with other materials, notably various nanomaterials, to create composites that reinforce the electrochemical performance of sensors.27 The unique layered structures of Ti3C2 MXene nanosheets have a large surface area, which could offer ample space for functional material intercalation/anchoring, potentially increasing the applicability of MXene nanosheets as promising support materials. Moreover, by means of surface functional groups, MXenes facilitate bonding with other functional materials through van der Waals forces of attraction, covalent bonds, hydrogen bonds, and charge transfer.37,38 Owing to these factors, there has been a surge in research into MXene-based composites for versatile applications, particularly for electrochemical sensors.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of the essential properties of MXenes concerning their use in electrochemical sensing. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The graphical presentation of different categories of MXene-nanocomposites reported as electrode materials for electrochemical sensing of clinically relevant biomarkers. |
The superiority of MXene surface groups in reducing metal ions to metal nanoparticles is reported to be successful in decorating MXene surfaces with active transition metals/metal oxides. Furthermore, one of the major limitations, the instability of MXenes at higher anodic potentials, can be eliminated by incorporating electrochemically active transition metals. The spontaneous reduction of noble metal ions such as platinum (Pt) and palladium (Pd) on MXene exhibited attractive electrochemical sensing of biomolecules.41,42 Similarly, silver (Ag) and gold (Au) nanoparticles with high conductivity and catalytic properties are being added to MXene to create hybrid MXene–metal nanostructures with several advantages such as more active surface sites, larger pore volume, and specific surface area.43 The synergistic influence of transition metal doping on the interlayer separation of MXenes and electrochemical activity has been explored for the detection of biomolecules electrochemically. In addition, metal oxide nanoparticles such as TiO2, Mn3O4, MnO2, Co3O4, etc., are intensively investigated as surface modifiers for MXene.39,44 The synergic effect between MXene and these two materials improves the ionic conductivity and electron transfer rate capabilities of MXene materials for various electrochemical applications.45,46 Recently, a one-pot electrostatic self-assembly of MOF-encased Ti3C2 improved the electronic conductivity of the composites due to the unidirectional charge mobility of Ti3C2.47 Ti3C2Tx-templated in situ growth of a zeolite imidazole framework (cobalt-based MOF, ZIF-67) helped in intertwining the advantages of unique electrocatalytic activity and higher electronic conductivity resulting in excellent electrochemical response towards glucose oxidation.48 Because of the electrostatic attraction of oxygenic groups of Ti3C2Tx, Co2+ ions were bound to the surface of MXene. The highly crystalline ZIF-67 was formed in situ on Ti3C2Txvia the coordination interaction of Co2+ with the nitrogen atom of 2-methylimidazole, resulting in a Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 nanocomposite.48
Similarly, introducing other interlayer spacers, such as carbon nanotubes (CNTs), can preserve the hexagonal stacking of MXene sheets while providing more conductive paths for electron passage with reduced interfacial friction.27 Besides, alternative forms of conductive and carbon-based materials, such as graphene, graphene oxide, and reduced graphene oxides (rGO), are frequently integrated into various MXenes to improve physical, structural, and electrochemical characteristics subjected to the intended application.40,49 For instance, a one-step hydrothermal approach was utilised to successfully generate an MXene/N-rGO composite, which was then used to modify a glassy carbon electrode (GCE) for electrochemical detection of adrenaline.50 Primarily, mild sonication was used to disperse MXene in deionized water, followed by ethylenediamine reduction of graphene oxide. The resultant aqueous dispersion was then transferred to a Teflon-lined autoclave for 24 hours of sustained heating at 180 °C to obtain MXene/N-rGO composites. Polymers endow MXene with specific functions, providing abundant electron–ion channels and interaction sites and thereby improving the performances of the composites.51 Therefore, conducting polymers such as polyaniline, polypyrrole (PPy), polyacetylene, poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT), and polyphenylene can be composited with MXenes by several methods like solvent blending, casting, filtration, in situ polymerization, and melt blending. Moreover, assembling hybrid materials allows for combining beneficial properties unavailable in traditional forms.52 The intricate chemical interactions between the functional molecules and MXene surfaces promote the formation of hybrid structures through self-assembly.53 An electrostatic interaction between positively charged poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (PDDA) and negatively charged Ti3C2Tx resulted in the self-assembly of Ti3C2Tx/PDDA composites with excellent energy storage.54 A simple hydrothermal approach was also employed to fabricate MXene/NiCo-LDH nanocomposites for a non-enzymatic glucose sensor. The precursors were dispersed in a solvent mixture containing methanol and ultrapure water, and the mixture was magnetically stirred at room temperature before being hydrothermally reacted in a Teflon-lined autoclave at 180 °C for 24 hours to obtain the nanocomposite.55 Although hydrothermal treatment has shown to be a simple synthesis process, the aqueous environment may result in O2 and H2O-induced reactions that result in the oxidation of Ti3C2 MXene. As a result, this technique is a poor choice for producing extremely specific MXene-based composites.56 Meanwhile, the solvothermal approach eliminates the oxidation features seen in hydrothermal treatment. This demonstrates the successful synthesis of materials with diverse morphologies, making it an ideal synthesis route for constructing MXene-based composites.53 Detailed discussions on the application of MXene nanocomposites for various electrochemical sensing of potential biomarkers have been presented in the forthcoming sessions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 a) Mechanism of preparation of Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/Ti3C2Tx nanocomposites for detecting 5-HT.(I) Preparation of multilayer Ti3C2 MXene, (II) preparation of Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/MXene, and (III) detection of 5-HT by Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/MXene. b) CV curves for Tri-AgNP/TSC/GCE, Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/GCE, MXene, bare GCE, and Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/MXene/GCE; tests carried out in 0.1 M KCl solutions containing 1.0 mM Fe[(CN)6]3−/4−. c) DPV of 5-HT with changing concentration as 0.5, 7.0, 12, 16, 23, 31, 39, 46, 54, 76, 90, 119, and 150 μM. d) Relationship between peak current (Ipa) and concentration of 5-HT. (a to d) Reproduced with permission from ref. 58. Copyright (2021) American Chemical Society. e) (1 and 2) Schematic diagram of the preparation of AuNPs@Ti3C2 MXene ink, 3) fabrication of the sensor device, and 4) printed AuNPs@Ti3C2 MXene sensor device. f) Current response of AuNPs@Ti3C2 MXene to genomic DNAs without 5hmC (black curve) or with 5hmC (red curve). g) Plot of current response of AuNPs@Ti3C2 MXene sensor incubated with 5hmC-containing DNAs against number of cycles; inset: cyclic voltammogram depicting the sensor stability after multiple runs (up to 50 cycles). (e to g) Reproduced with permission from ref. 59. Copyright (2022) Elsevier. |
S. Elumalai et al. reported the solution-processing-based galvanic deposition of AuNPs on delaminated Ti3C2Tx sheets to obtain a colloidal suspension of AuNP@Ti3C2Tx.60 This synthesis strategy followed the spontaneous reduction of gold nanoparticles onto delaminated Ti3C2Tx nanosheets (AuNP@Ti3C2Tx) devoid of reduction agents or surfactants. The spontaneous reduction of Au3+ ions to Au NPs onto the delaminated Ti3C2Tx flakes was confirmed by ultraviolet-visible-near infrared (UV-vis-NIR) spectroscopy and high-resolution-transmission electron microscopy images (HR-TEM) (Fig. 4a and b). As a result of Au NP adsorption, the AuNP@Ti3C2Tx composite serves as a template for the strong electrocatalytic activity of the analyte (Fig. 4c). The modified GCE electrode demonstrated considerably improved electrocatalytic peak currents at a reduced oxidation potential, indicating that the customized interface had an exceptional electrocatalytic performance against uric acid (UA) and folic acid (FA) with lowered detection limits to nM concentrations (Fig. 4d–f). A novel electrochemical biosensor based on AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene nanocomposite for sensitive miRNA-155 detection by exonuclease III (Exo III)-aided cascade target recycling has been reported (Fig. 4g).61 The distribution of loaded AuNPs onto Ti3C2 MXene nanosheets is shown in Fig. 4h. MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are critical indicators for the early detection and prognosis of genetic disorders such as tumours in humans and neurological diseases. Among the miRNAs, miRNA-155, widely recognised as involved in lymphoma, is also now implicated in advancing breast cancer, and the strategy developed here is employed as a versatile tool for miRNA detection in bioanalysis (Fig. 4i). The AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene 3D nanocomposite has a high surface area for capture DNA (C-DNA) loading and allows for electron transport between the electrochemical species, methylene blue, and the underlying electrode surface. Under some conditions, one miRNA-155 chain releases multiple C-DNAs with the help of Exo III-aided cascade target recycling amplification, resulting in high sensitivity with a detection limit as low as 0.35 fM (Fig. 4j). Pristine Ti3C2Tx fails to show adequate stability in the anodic potential window. An irreversible anodic peak appears at an applied voltage of roughly +430 mV vs. Ag/AgCl, suggesting irreversible oxidation of Ti3C2Tx, which could not be re-reduced.62 Surface modification is an efficient method for stabilising MXenes in the anodic potential window. A GCE modified with Pd@Ti3C2Tx has been reported by Rasheed et al. as a stable and extremely sensitive electrochemical sensor for the detection of L-Cys, which is a potential biomarker for the diagnosis of cancer, Parkinson's and Alzheimer's illnesses, and acquired immune deficiency syndrome.41 The sensor was used to detect L-Cys in an aqueous medium and was made by casting a Nafion-stabilized layer of the Pd@Ti3C2Tx nanocomposite onto a GCE. Pd NPs are used to increase the stability of Ti3C2Tx and the electrocatalytic activity for L-Cys detection. The sensor also showed high selectivity against typical interfering ions such as uric acid, dopamine, ascorbic acid, and glucose.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) UV-visible-NIR spectroscopy analysis on delaminated Ti3C2Tx flakes and spontaneous reduction of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) onto delaminated Ti3C2Tx (AuNP@Ti3C2Tx); inset: magnified UV spectra from 500 nm to 900 nm. The enclosed photographic images (a to f) show the colloidal suspension of AuNP@Ti3C2Tx hybrids synthesized by adding different concentrations of gold ion solution in the colloidal delaminated Ti3C2Tx-MXene solution for the production of AuNPs on Ti3C2Tx flakes. (b) HR-TEM images of the AuNP@Ti3C2Tx hybrid produced by adding 70 μM of gold ion solution; scale bar is 200 nm. (c) CVs of (1) unmodified GCE, (2) AuNP, (3) Ti3C2Tx and (4) AuNP@Ti3C2Tx hybrid at the GCE toward 3 μM UA + 3 μM FA dissolved in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7.0). (d) The increasing concentrations of both UA and FA added and the corresponding CVs recorded using the modified GCE electrode in 0.1 M phosphate buffer, with a scan rate of 50 mV s−1. (e) Amperometric i–t curves of the modified GCE electrode upon each addition of UA into phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) and (f) amperometric response of the modified GCE electrode for FA. (a to f) Reproduced with permission from ref. 60. Copyright (2019) Springer Nature. (g) Schematic representation of the electrochemical miRNA-155 biosensor based on the AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene 3D nanocomposite developed by the Exo III-aided cascade target recycling methodology a) AuE b) AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene/AuE c) C-DNA/AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene/AuE d) BSA/C-DNA/AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene/AuE e) miRNA-155/BSA/C-DNA/AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene/AuE f–h) Exo III/miRNA-155/BSA/C-DNA/AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene/AuE. (h) TEM image of AuNPs/Ti3C2 MXene nanocomposite; scale bar is 50 nm (i) DPV curves in response to different miRNA concentrations from 0.0 to 10 nM (tests were carried out in 0.2 M PBS buffer at a solution pH of 7.4). (j) The linear relationship between the current variation ΔI and the negative logarithm of the miRNA-155 concentration. (g to j) Reproduced with permission from ref. 61. Copyright (2020) Elsevier. |
The presence of numerous functional groups on MXenes, along with its role as a conductive matrix and reducing agent, eliminates lattice mismatching and facilitates the straightforward synthesis of various metal-modified nanostructures.58 Furthermore, the high surface area MXene nanosheets function as a two-dimensional substrate, and the many terminal groups chemically attach the metals with great stability to create encapsulated, loaded, or sandwiched nanostructures with improved properties and stability. Generally, metal nanoparticles are absorbed onto the surface of MXene through electrostatic interaction to generate decorated MXene hybrid structures.41 Optimal metal doping of MXene effectively enhances the electrochemical performance by increasing the interlayer distance, providing more electrochemically active sites and thus rendering them particularly appealing for electrochemical detection of specific analytes with improved selectivity and current response.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 a) Illustration of monitoring ROS in cancer cells using the MXene–Co3O4-nanocomposite designed and integrated onto a screen-printed electrode. b) Cyclic voltammetry studies of the MXene–Co3O4 modified SPE using various concentrations of H2O2 up to 10 mM at a scan rate of 50 mV s−1; inset: calibration curve of peak current value plotted against H2O2 concentrations up to 10 mM. c) LSV of electrochemically activated MXene–Co3O4 modified SPE in 0.1 M KCl with various H2O2 concentrations (up to 75 μM); inset: calibration curve of peak current value plotted against H2O2 concentrations. d) Specificity testing in 0.1 M KCl with 10 μm H2O2 and interferents dopamine, uric acid, acetaminophen, and glucose. e) Electrochemical detection of ROS produced by a) DU145 cell lines, b) MDA-MB-231 cell lines, and in c) DU145 cell lines treated with TGF-β1, d) MDA-MB-231 cell lines + TGF-β1, and e) human immortalized keratinocyte cell line HaCat. Inset i: Measurements with the nanocomposite in the presence of cancer cells (red) and with a non-modified electrochemical platform (black). Inset ii: Voltammetric measurements relative to histograms. Reproduced with permission from ref. 63. Copyright (2023) Wiley-VCH. |
MOFs are recognized as efficient, affordable, and environment friendly solutions for various electrochemical applications, much like metal oxides. Despite the high electrochemical activity of MOFs, their poor electrical conductivity would significantly reduce their sensitivity, which can be overcome by compositing with MXene. Therefore, Xuhui Han et al. reported a Co-based MOF (ZIF-67) on 2D MXene (Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 nanocomposite) with excellent conductivity for the electrochemical analysis of glucose.48 The Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 nanocomposite was synthesised by loading the porous Co-based MOF (ZIF-67) on 2D MXene using a facile in situ method (Fig. 6a). Fig. 6b illustrates the homogeneous distribution of ZIF-67 nanoparticles on the surface of Ti3C2Tx nanosheets. The process started with the oxidation of Co(II) to Co(III), which was followed by the oxidation of glucose molecules to gluconolactone through Co(III), and finally, the reduction of Co(III) to Co(II) (Fig. 6c). This research demonstrated a practical approach for creating high-performance electrochemical sensors, combining good electrocatalytic active MOFs with high conductivity 2D Ti3C2Tx. Chen et al. fabricated a Ce-MOF/Ti3C2Tx composite as an electrode active material for the electrochemical detection of L-tryptophan (L-Trp).66 A three-dimensional straw-sheaf-like Ce-MOF was joined with a few layered Ti3C2Tx nanosheets, as shown in Fig. 6d. The presence of metal active sites and a high surface area of Ce-MOF achieve outstanding electrocatalytic oxidation of L-Trp. The straw-sheaf-like structure can provide good capacity for L-Trp adsorption (Fig. 6e). The modified electrode demonstrated a strong current response even in the co-existence of L-Trp with interferents (ascorbic acid, dopamine, uric acid, L-cysteine, glucose, KCl, and NaCl) (Fig. 6f), which indicates that the common interfering substances did not affect the measurement of L-Trp. Paul and his colleagues used a non-conductive MOF ([Zn4(btec)2(H2O)6]n·3nH2O) and Ti3C2 for the detection of dopamine (DA),47 which is a crucial biomarker for several neurological diseases. The one-pot electrostatic self-assembling method was used to create the MOF–Ti3C2 composite in distilled water (Fig. 6g). Due to the unidirectional charge mobility, the MOF physically bonded around the Ti3C2 sheet improves electrical conductivity. The nanocomposite produced has a high crystallinity with a structure of conjugated orbitals of charge donors and acceptors, which improves electron flow. The major factor driving electrochemical sensing here is space charge transfer (Fig. 6h and i); hence the important goal is to create a highly conjugated, charge-carrying, crystalline, and defect-free MOF–Ti3C2 composite for DA sensing. This technique was utilised to identify DA in PBS that contained ascorbic acid (AA) and 5-amino valeric acid (VA). With a LOD of 110 nM, the material developed identified DA at concentrations between 90 and 130 nM. Based on the above mentioned studies, MXene demonstrates itself to be an optimal material for appropriate hybridization with metal oxides or MOFs. MXene as a conductive substrate facilitates the self-assembly or in situ formation of metal oxide nanostructures, hence improving the electrocatalytic properties and conductivity. Combining MXenes with MOFs in an optimised manner not only addresses the limitations of MOFs (such as low electrical conductivity and poor stability), but also introduces new functionalities by combining MOF's extensive surface area, adjustable porous structure, numerous exposed REDOX active sites, non-toxicity, and MXene's high electrical conductivity and environmental protection.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 a) The synthetic process of the Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 nanocomposites. b) SEM image of the Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 nanocomposite. c) The mechanism of Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67/GCE to detect glucose in NaOH solution. (a to c) Reproduced with permission from ref. 48. Copyright (2022) Royal Society of Chemistry. d) Preparation of the Ce-MOF/Ti3C2Tx MXene composite and modified electrode. e) SEM image of the Ce-MOF/Ti3C2Tx MXene composite; inset: the magnified image of the encircled area. f) Ce-MOF/Ti3C2Tx MXene/GCE 1![]() ![]() |
Unlike 2D graphene nanosheets, 3D porous graphene successfully prevents aggregation and exhibits superior qualities such as increased porosity, improved mechanical stability, and catalytic activity providing an effective framework for detecting small biomolecules.70 A 3D porous rGO/Ti3C2Tx MXene (GMA) was achieved using freeze-drying and heat treatment techniques71 (Fig. 7a). The electrode was then used for the electrochemical detection of epinephrine (EP) (Fig. 7b). The 3D porous structure of GMA makes the entry of small biomolecules easier and increases the electrode–analyte interface (Fig. 7c). The electrode could also detect EP in human urine samples, indicating the employability of the electrodes for POC diagnostics. Similarly, another carbon-based compound, MWCNT, was composited with MXene to fabricate effective electrode materials for various electrochemical devices. The easy functionalisation, exceptional electrocatalytic performance, and strong electron transfer ability of MWCNT identify it as a valuable one-dimensional material for use as an intercalant in the interlayer of MXene. Thus far, MXene/MWCNT nanohybrids have been developed as efficient electrode materials for a range of electrochemical device applications. However, the interface binding of MXene and MWCNTs mostly depends on non-covalent electrostatic attraction and van der Waals forces, which would restrict the mechanical stability and reduce the electrochemical performance. A simple method for in situ cross-linking of amino functionalised multi-walled-carbon nanotubes on polydopamine functionalised MXene (MXene@PDA/NH2-MWCNTs) was created (Fig. 7d) by Chen et al. to address this problem.72 The NH2-MWCNTs can be evenly and firmly distributed on MXene@PDA using the Michael addition reaction. To prevent the MXene stacking phenomenon, NH2-MWCNTs are tightly linked to MXene@PDA and act as an interlayer barrier. The composite was used as an electrochemical sensing platform for detecting acetaminophen (AAP) because of its distinctive structure, abundant active sites, hierarchical mass transfer pathways, and outstanding electrocatalytic capabilities (Fig. 7e and f). As a result, the sensor exhibits wide linear ranges of 0.005 to 60.0 μM, as well as a low LOD of 1.0 nM. Furthermore, the fabricated sensor was effectively used to identify AAP in a urine sample and paracetamol tablet. In addition to demonstrating its potential as an alternative to conventional sensing materials with exceptional applicability towards the selective detection of versatile analytes, the aforementioned studies on developing MXene nanocomposites open up the feasibility of 2D MXenes to incorporate 1D, 2D, and 3D nanostructures to yield hybrid nanostructures.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 a) Schematic of the GMA/ITO electrode preparation and electrochemical detection of epinephrine (EP). b) The DPV curves of the GMA/ITO electrode with various concentrations of EP. c) SEM image of the GMA. Inset: uniform distribution of Ti3C2Tx nanoparticles on the surface of 3D graphene framework. (a to c) Reproduced with permission from ref. 71. Copyright (2021) Elsevier. d) Pictorial representation of the synthesis process of MXene@PDA/NH2-MWCNTs/GCE for AAP determination. e) SEM image of MXene@PDA/NH2-MWCNTs. f) DPV analysis with various AAP concentrations at MXene@PDA/NH2-MWCNTs/GCE in 0.1 M PBS (pH 7.0). (d to f) Reproduced with permission from ref. 72. Copyright (2021) Elsevier. |
The application of MXene in immobilizing enzymes and creating biosensors needs additional research due to its exceptional features and distinctive structure. In line with this, Xia and his co-workers constructed a simple MXene-based enzymatic electrochemical biosensor by utilizing the beneficial properties of MXene and chitosan (Chit).79 Chit and Ti3C2Tx function as a support matrix to immobilise the cholesterol oxidase (ChOx) enzyme and improve electrical conductivity. A continuous self-assembling technique created the hierarchical accordion-like Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx nanocomposite for monitoring cholesterol by selectively oxidizing cholesterol to cholest-4-en-3-one and H2O2 (Fig. 8a). The Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx synthesized was demonstrated to have a porous structure, which helps in improving the effective surface area of the modified electrode (Fig. 8b). The electro-oxidation current was monitored using DPV with the formation of H2O2, the by-product of the ChOx process (Fig. 8c). Moreover, the suggested electrochemical technique has demonstrated outstanding stability and reproducibility for the detection of cholesterol in real samples.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) Schematic illustrations of a) Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx/GCE development and the cholesterol reaction mechanism at the modified GCE. (b) SEM image of Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx/GCE. c) DPV of the Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx/GCE biosensor in different concentrations of cholesterol. (a to c) Reproduced with permission from ref. 79. Copyright (2021) Elsevier. d) MXene/chitosan nanocomposite modified GCE as a support for sarcosine oxidase (SOx) immobilisation and indirect sarcosine detection in urine, based on hydrogen peroxide electrochemical reduction. e) SEM image of the MXene/chitosan nanocomposite. f) Calibration plot of the SOx/MXene–Chi/GCE biosensor. Inset: Current vs. time response of the SOx/MXene–Chi/GCE biosensor. f) Reproduced with permission from ref. 80. Copyright (2020) Processes. |
Another type of enzymatic MXene-based sensor was developed by Hroncekova et al. using Ti3C2Tx MXene and chitosan to detect sarcosine80 (Fig. 8d). The 2D multilayered porous nanostructure of MXene-based layers (Fig. 8e) provides a great surface area for sarcosine oxidase (SOx) immobilization, and this leads to improved performance and sensitivity of the fabricated biosensor. Sarcosine was indirectly detected by amperometric measurement of H2O2 generated during the enzymatic process (Fig. 8f).80 The modified GCE exhibited a linear range of up to 7.8 μM and a low detection limit of 18 nM. As a clinical application, the SOx/MXene–Chi/GCE device was applied to determine sarcosine in artificial urine samples. These two studies on MXene–biopolymer-based composites demonstrate the effectiveness of MXene-based composites in health monitoring by demonstrating their ability to identify by-products produced during intricate biological processes. Similarly, the abundance of active terminations on the surface of MXenes enables the incorporation of a diverse range of polymers through in situ polymerisation or ex situ blending.73,81–83 The exceptionally high dispersibility of MXene in water allows for its easy aqueous phase mixing with any water soluble polymers to fabricate an MXene/polymer nanocomposite sensor. Furthermore, polymers can not only enhance the required electrochemical response but also prevent the oxidation of MXene.84 Optimal blending of polymers results in the creation of a three-dimensional network of conductive nanosheets, which in turn aids in the production of electrochemical sensors.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 a) Schematic representing the fabrication of MXene/NiCo-LDH/GCE. b) Illustration of the mechanism of the oxidation of glucose on the surface of MXene/NiCo-LDH/GCE in an alkaline solution. c) SEM image and (d) TEM image of the MXene/NiCo-LDH composite. e) The chronoamperometry curve of MXene/NiCo-LDH/GCE obtained by successive addition of different concentrations of glucose into the electrolyte every 25 s; inset: magnified image of the marked region in the chronoamperometry curve. (a to e) Reproduced with permission from ref. 55. Copyright (2019) Elsevier. f) Illustration of the synthesis and fabrication of Ti3C2/G-MWCNTs/ZnO/GCE for detection of DA. g) SEM image of Ti3C2/G-MWCNTs/ZnO. h) DPVs of DA quantitative analysis on Ti3C2/G-MWCNTs/ZnO/GCE at various concentrations of DA (a to t: 0, 0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.08, 0.12, 0.2, 0.3, 0.5, 0.8, 1.2, 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 μM); inset: the magnified image of the DPV plot in the concentration range 0, 10, and 20 nM. (f to h) Reproduced with permission from ref. 86. Copyright (2022) Elsevier. |
Owing to their inherent negative charges, MXenes can absorb cations and serve as nucleation sites for the growth of nanostructures.87 Zheng et al. used MXene/DNA/Pd/Pt nanocomposites for the detection of DA, where the negatively charged phosphate backbone of the DNA and the metal ions interact electrostatically to produce MXene/DNA/Pd/Pt nanocomposites.88 The adsorption of DNA on the surface of MXene nanosheets through π–π stacking interaction and successive deposition of Pd/Pt nanoparticles enhances the electrocatalytic activity towards DA. The developed sensor also demonstrated an outstanding response toward DA in human serum samples. Zhao et al. developed a multifunctional 3D carbon fibre paper–MXene–MoS2 (CMM) sensing interface for the highly sensitive detection of several biomolecules (AA, DA, UA, and microRNA).89 The unique array structure of the flexible CMM interface promotes the local enrichment of molecules, which improves the ultra-sensitive detection of biomolecules from complex fluids. Using the DPV technique, the CMM electrode was used for the simultaneous detection of AA, DA, and UA with an LOD of 0.89 μM, 0.23 μM, and 0.35 μM, respectively. Furthermore, the modified sensor also exhibited an ultra-high sensitivity of 3.16 aM towards the detection of miRNA. Dang et al. investigated Prussian blue (PB) nanoparticle intercalated Ti3C2 nanosheets (PB NPs/Ti3C2) for the non-enzymatic electrochemical detection of H2O2 released from living cells.90 The synergistic effect between PB and Ti3C2 on the structure and performance optimization was connected with the outstanding electrochemical determination performance of PB/Ti3C2/GCE. The Ti3C2 layers coated with PB NPs had greater interlayer spacing and prevented PB NP accumulation, increasing the specific surface area and apparent exposure of active sites. Additionally, the two-dimensionally layered Ti3C2 and PB NPs provided shorter diffusion paths for the electrolyte and H2O2, facilitating the migration of electrons and ions and, in turn, increasing the reduction process of H2O2 on the PB/Ti3C2 surface. The human cervical cancer cells (HeLa) injected with N-formylmethionyl-leucyl-phenylalanine (fMLP), a stimulant to destroy cancer cells, were used for real-time analysis to produce H2O2. The current response of PB/Ti3C2/GCE during the successive injection of fMLP in the presence and absence of HeLa cells confirmed that H2O2 was produced from the living tumour cells. Amara et al. designed a composite material of perylene diimide (PDI) and MXene (Ti3C2Tx) for the electrochemical detection of DA.91 The obtained composite was used to modify the graphitic pencil electrode to detect DA in the 100–1000 μM range with an LOD of 240 nM. PDI has been uniformly wrapped around MXene flakes via H bonding and π–π stacking. This powerful interaction creates a stable interface with several active DA adsorption sites, increasing electrochemical activity. The modified sensor also showed good responsiveness in human serum samples. Niamsi et al. fabricated a paper-based screen-printed ionic liquid/graphene electrode (SPIL–GE) modified with Ti3C2Tx, PB, glucose oxidase (GOx), and Nafion for the electrochemical detection of glucose.92 An electrode was created for the first time using ionic liquid and graphene ink on a paper substrate. The performance of the SPIL–GE modified with PB/Ti3C2Tx/GOx/Nafion was examined using CV and chronoamperometry (CA) techniques. The prepared paper-based PB/Ti3C2Tx/GOx/Nafion/SPIL–GE was also used to measure blood glucose concentration for real sample analysis.
By taking advantage of the affordable non-metal doping, Chen et al. developed a structure with co-doped nitrogen (N) and sulphur (S) using thiourea as the doping source on the surface of Ti3C2 nanosheets (NS-Ti3C2) to detect uric acid (UA).93 The composite NS-Ti3C2 was synthesised using a simple one-step synthesis process, which produced more active sites due to the doping of N and S atoms, enhancing electron transport even further. A sensitive colourimetric method was also proposed to detect UA. The sensor achieved a linear range of 2–400 μM with a LOD of 0.19 μM and also detected UA in fresh serum samples. MXene and CNTs with superior electronic conductivity can be further hybridised with Cu-MOF to improve their poor conductivity. As a result, Chen et al. synthesised MXene/CNTs/Cu-MOF composites to imprint them on glassy carbon electrodes and to detect tyrosine.94 Cu-MOF also has a high degree of porosity, which can be used to adsorb analyte molecules and enhance the detection signal in human serum with a high recovery rate. M. Ni et al. used ZnO nanospheres to improve the electrochemical activity of Ti3C2–graphitised multi-walled carbon nanotube composites (Ti3C2/G-MWCNTs) for the detection of DA86 (Fig. 9f). The composite exhibits a decorated structure, which denotes excellent synergy between the three materials (Fig. 9g). Due to the unique features of the as-synthesised nanocomposite, such as fast electron transfer, good electrocatalytic performance, and excellent electrochemical activity, the sensor exhibits high sensitivity and detection performance for DA (Fig. 9h). A wide linear range (0.01–30 μM) with a low detection limit (3.2 nM) was achieved, and the sensor successfully detected DA in human serum samples. Assembly of versatile materials with 2D MXenes enables combinations of properties that no single material can provide and also create a wide range of heterostructures or ordered structures, thereby promoting the emergence of high-performance next generation devices. Table 1 consolidates recent reports on various MXene-based electrocatalytically active nanocomposites for the detection of clinically relevant biomarkers for diagnostic applications in various body fluids.
Nanocomposite category | Working electrode | Analyte | Analytical method | Limit of detection | Linear range | Real sample | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MXene–metal | Tri-AgNP/L-Cys/Ti3C2Tx | 5-HT | DPV | 0.08 μM | 0.5–150 μM | Serum | 58 |
AuNP@Ti3C2 | 5hmC | CV | 6.32 × 10−7 μM | 6.32 × 10−7–6.32 × 10−5 μM | Tumour cells | 59 | |
AuNP@ Ti3C2Tx | UA, FA | Amperometry | 0.0115 μM (UA) and 0.0062 μM (FA) | 0.03–1520 μM (UA) and 0.02–3580 μM (FA) | Serum | 60 | |
AuNPs/Ti3C2 | miRNA-155 | DPV | 3.5 × 10−10 μM | 1 × 10−9–0.01 μM | — | 61 | |
Pd/Ti3C2Tx | L-Cys | Amperometry | 0.14 μM | 0.5–10 μM | Urine | 41 | |
MXene–metal oxide | MXene/Co3O4 | H2O2 | LSV | 0.5 μM | 0–75 μM | Cancer cell | 63 |
SnO2 QD@Ti3C2 | DA | CV | 0.002 μM | 0.004–8.0 μM | Serum and urine | 65 | |
MXene–MOF | Ti3C2Tx/ZIF-67 | Glucose | Amperometry | 3.81 μM | 5–7500 μM | — | 48 |
Ce-MOF/Ti3C2Tx | L-Trp | DPV | 0.19 μM | 0.2–139 μM | Blood serum | 66 | |
MOF–Ti3C2 | DA | DPV | 0.11 μM | 0.09–0.13 μM | Blood serum | 47 | |
MXene–carbon | Ti3C2Tx–rGO | Serotonin | DPV | 0.01 μM | 0.025–147 μM | Blood plasma | 68 |
MXene–graphene | Nicotine | DPV and amperometry | 0.29 μM and 2.8 × 10−4 μM | 1–55 μM and 0.03–0.6 μM | Saliva | 69 | |
Ti3C2Tx/N-rGO | AD | DPV | 0.003 μM | 0.01–90.0 μM | Urine | 50 | |
Ti3C2Tx/rGO | EP | DPV | 0.0035 μM | 1–60 μM | Urine | 71 | |
MXene@ PDA/NH2- MWCNTs | AAP | DPV | 0.001 μM | 0.005–60 μM | Urine | 72 | |
MXene–polymer | Ti3C2Tx/PPy | DA and UA | DPV | 0.37 μM (DA), 0.15 μM (UA) | 12.5–125 μM (DA), 50–500 μM (UA) | — | 76 |
PEDOT:PSS:MXene | DA | DPV | — | 1–100 μM | — | 77 | |
TiO2/MXene–PVA/GO | NE | Amperometry | 0.008 μM | 0.01–60.0 μM | Urine | 78 | |
Chit/ChOx/Ti3C2Tx | Cholesterol | DPV | 1.1 × 10−4 μM | 0.0003–0.0045 μM | Serum | 79 | |
SOx/MXene–Chi | Sarcosine | CA | 0.018 μM | 0.036–7.8 μM | Urine | 80 | |
Other MXene hybrid materials | MXene/NiCo-LDH | Glucose | CA | 0.53 μM | 2–4096 μM | Serum | 55 |
MXene/graphene aerogel/Cu2O | Glucose | CA | 1.1 μM | 100–1.4 × 104 and 1.5 × 104–4 × 104 μM | Serum | 85 | |
Ti3C2/DNA/Pd/Pt | DA | Amperometry | 0.03 μM | 0.2–1000 μM | Serum | 88 | |
Carbon fiber paper–MXene–MoS2 | AA, DA, UA and miRNA | DPV | 0.89 μM (AA), 0.23 μM (DA), and 0.35 μM (UA), miRNA (3.16 × 10−12 μM) | — | Serum and urine | 89 | |
PB NPs/Ti3C2 | H2O2 | Amperometry | 0.20 μM | 0.60–63.6 μM and 63.6–254 μM | HeLa cells | 90 | |
PDI–MXene | DA | Amperometry | 0.24 μM | 100–1000 μM | Serum | 91 | |
PB/Ti3C2Tx/GOx/Nafion | Glucose | CA | 24 μM | 80–1.5 × 104 μM | Blood | 92 | |
NS-Ti3C2 nanosheets | UA | CV | 0.19 μM | 2–400 μM | Serum | 93 | |
MXene/CNT/CuMOF | Tyrosine | DPV | 0.19 μM | 0.53–232.46 μM | Serum | 94 | |
Ti3C2/G-MWCNT/ZnO | DA | DPV | 0.0032 μM | 0.01–30 μM | Serum | 86 |
Plenty of research on the development of various types of electrochemical sensors has been conducted since the discovery of MXene. However, the bulk of studies have remained focused on titanium carbide (Ti3C2Tx materials)95 owing to its excellent metallic conductivity and stability across a wide temperature range. Among all MXenes, Ti3C2 shows prominent conductivity and large active surface area for effective immobilization in view of constructing mediator-free biosensors. Moreover, exceptional hydrophilicity of Ti3C2-MXene confers biocompatibility, making it an excellent material for the development of electrochemical sensors that can detect biomolecules.96 Thus, Ti3C2-MXene has demonstrated potential for use in all fields involving sensitive biomarker detection with a broad linear range and low detection limit. In this review, we mainly focused on Ti3C2Tx, the most researched 2D MXene, and its composites developed for health monitoring. This review initially focused on the hybridization of Ti3C2Tx MXene with electroactive materials such as carbon nanomaterials, metals, metal oxides, and polymers. Successively, the practical viability of the nanocomposites toward the detection of various biomarkers from complex biological fluids has been reviewed. We present a thorough categorisation and analysis of different MXene-based nanocomposites, highlighting their structural–property correlation and underscoring the influence of MXenes on the improved electrochemical performance.
However, the study of electrochemical sensors based on MXenes is still in its early phases, more focus is needed for their development and employment in real-life problems. The conductive structure, sensing mechanism, and sensor performance of MXenes have facilitated their progressive integration into the field of electrochemical sensing. By carefully evaluating the benefits of MXenes and the specific sensing requirements, novel sensing composites can be developed by integrating MXenes with other appropriate materials. This approach aims to optimise the synergistic impact between MXenes and other phase materials, resulting in a high-performance sensor with exceptional sensitivity and a broad response range. Nevertheless, pristine MXenes are susceptible to extreme oxidation under normal environmental conditions, unlike other conductive low-dimensional nanomaterials and have poor stability in air, humidity or water media.19 These constraints of pristine MXenes before compositing can be resolved to an extent by using proper storage conditions like an argon environment and exploiting non-aqueous solvents like ethanol, DMF, etc. Furthermore, a deeper understanding of the terminal groups of MXenes is highly essential as these groups and any related defects will significantly influence the electron transfer rates and hence sensor's operation. The fundamental understanding of the interaction of active molecules on the surface of MXenes is crucial in designing and synthesis of nanocomposites with enhanced electrochemical performance. Although several biocompatible MXene-based composites have been developed, additional research is still required to fully assess their toxicity and biosafety. As the detection of clinically relevant biomolecules is still in its infancy, there are still additional avenues concerning the simultaneous or individual transduction mechanisms of numerous clinically relevant biomarkers that require further investigation. Further investigation into the biofouling of neurotransmitter sensors in complex environments could potentially mitigate the logistical challenges associated with the creation of ubiquitous devices.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |