Open Access Article
Kazuya
Tanimura
a,
Kento
Tanaka
a,
Masayuki
Gon
ab and
Kazuo
Tanaka
*ab
aDepartment of Polymer Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Kyoto University, Katsura, Nishikyo-ku, Kyoto 615-8510, Japan. E-mail: tanaka@poly.synchem.kyoto-u.ac.jp
bDepartment of Technology and Ecology, Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Katsura, Nishikyo-ku, Kyoto 615-8510, Japan
First published on 10th October 2024
Since π-conjugated molecules are commonly used as a scaffold for constructing optoelectronic and functional materials, much effort has been devoted to exploring novel molecular scaffolds for obtaining superior properties. This study focuses on dinuclear hypervalent tin(IV) compounds prepared by the ladderization of Schiff bases using hypervalent tin units. The optical measurements found that introducing hypervalent tin atoms can reinforce the D–π–A system. We synthesized two types of dinuclear hypervalent compounds by simple condensation reactions and observed near-infrared (NIR) emission. Also, depending on the direction of the imine bonds, these molecules had different quadrupolar orientations with D–π–A–π–D and A–π–D–π–A systems followed by negative solvatochromism, which is the unique behavior of quadrupolar-derived absorption. Furthermore, the π-conjugated polymers involving dinuclear compounds showed NIR emission in the wavelength range over 800 nm owing to the distinct expansion of π-conjugation. Our findings could be useful not only for constructing electronic structures with narrow energy gaps but also for designing molecules with unique electronic states and environmental responsiveness.
We have been studying the “hypervalent state”11 created by main-group elements for constructing a ladder skeleton based on heteroatoms. The hypervalent states are regarded as multi-coordinate species that formally have electrons exceeding the octet rule, and many researchers have focused on their synthesis, geometry, and reactivity.12–15 Our previous reports have looked at the unique electronic states of the hypervalent state to modify the electronic structure of π-conjugated scaffolds.16 Main group elements like tin,17–21 germanium22,23 and bismuth24 in the hypervalent state are suggested to create coordination position-specific electronic effects on π-conjugated molecules through the intermolecular Lewis D–A interaction at the equatorial position and the polarized bond known as three-center/four-electron (3c–4e) bonds at the apical position. Based on these site-specific electronic properties, we obtained NIR materials without significantly increasing the molecular size and finally obtained polymers that can exhibit NIR absorption and/or emission properties.16,18,22,25 This strategy offers a new way to control the electronic properties of π-conjugated scaffolds by creating unique inductive effects related to the hypervalent state.
In this study, we created a series of hypervalent tin compounds by the ladderization of Schiff bases (also known as azomethines) using hypervalent tin units. Specifically, we observed both negative solvatochromic behaviors and NIR emission with small π-conjugated structures through the process of dinucleation (see Fig. 1). Firstly, as previously reported with mononuclear hypervalent tin derivatives, we also evaluated the electronic effect of the introduction of hypervalent tin into the π-conjugated system by comparing the electronic states of the standard Schiff base Azm and the hypervalent compound TPh. Secondly, as mentioned above, we confirmed that hypervalent tin was able to perturb the electronic state of the π-conjugated scaffolds through different site-specific electronic interactions at the equatorial and axial positions. Furthermore, we also found that the hypervalent tin enhanced the electron-withdrawing ability of the imine moiety, and consequently, charge separation followed by the D–π–A structure was efficiently formed. Next, we synthesized two dinuclear compounds, TPhCN and TPhCN, where the direction of the imine bond is opposite, and evaluated their optical properties. Interestingly, we discovered unique optical properties such as negative solvatochromism originating from “symmetry-breaking”26 in the ground state on the electronic structures of D–π–A–π–D or A–π–D–π–A, depending on the different quadrupolar orientation of the imine bond. We were also able to introduce each dinuclear compound into a π-conjugated polymer and obtain NIR-emitting materials having emission wavelengths over 800 nm by extending the π-conjugation and electronic interactions with the copolymer. Our findings demonstrate that hypervalent tin compounds, π-conjugated molecules bridged by hypervalent atoms, can be a new platform for developing D–A materials.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Chemical structures of the Schiff base Azm, the mononuclear hypervalent tin compound TPh, and the dinuclear hypervalent tin compounds TPhCN and TPhNC. | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Synthesis of mononuclear (TPhBr) and dinuclear (TPhCN, TPhCNBr, TPhNC, and TPhNCBr) hypervalent tin compounds. A chemical structure of the mononuclear compound TPh was also shown. | ||
Next, we synthesized π-conjugated polymers from mononuclear and dinuclear hypervalent tin compounds by the Migita–Kosugi–Stille cross-coupling reaction (Scheme 2). TPhBr, TPhCNBr, and TPhNCBr were polymerized with bithiophene comonomers, and insoluble high molecular weight polymers and low molecular weight oligomers were removed by Soxhlet extraction. Regarding relative molecular weights measured by gel permeation chromatography (GPC) with polystyrene standards, the number of molecular weights (Mn) was estimated to be 4.1 × 103 for P-TPh, 1.8 × 104 for P-TPhCN, and 1.3 × 104 for P-TPhNC. The characterization was carried out by 1H, 13C{1H}, 119Sn NMR spectroscopy, and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time of flight (MALDI-TOF) MS (see the ESI† for more details). The observed changes in absorption spectra over time for each compound did not show any noticeable changes (Fig. S2†). This indicates that each compound is sufficiently stable under the measurement conditions.
N–C were assessed as 179.7(6)° for TPh, 179(1)° for TPhCN, and 178.3(9)° (178.0(9)°) for TPhNC, indicating that this dinucleation hardly affects the planarity of the molecule. On the contrary, the structural optimization of each compound in quantum chemical calculations with density functional theory (DFT) showed that all the molecules adopted trigonal bipyramidal geometries (τ5 value of TPh: 0.58, TPhCN: 0.57, TPhNC: 0.57) and exhibited highly planar structures (the torsion angles of C–C
N–C in TPh: 177.64°, TPhCN: 178.09°, TPhNC: 177.94°) (Fig. 2). From the viewpoint of the packing, the interplane distances of the nearest-neighbor aromatic rings were 4.216 Å for TPhCN and 4.016 Å for TPhNC. These results propose that weak intermolecular interactions could be formed in the crystalline packing (Fig. S3 and S4†). In addition, these data suggest that the structures around the hypervalent tin are flexible and distorted in the crystal due to the dense packing.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) ORTEP drawings of the hypervalent tin compounds, TPhCN and TPhNC (50% probability for thermal ellipsoids). Hydrogens and disordered atoms were omitted to clarify. All crystallographic data are shown in ESI.† (b) Geometrical optimized structures of TPhCN and TPhNC (gray carbon atoms; red oxygen atoms; blue atom nitrogen; pale green tin atoms; hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity) (B3LYP/6-31G(d) for C, H, N, O and LanL2DZ for Sn). | ||
To assess the electronic effects of the formation of the hypervalent state, UV-vis absorption spectra of TPh and the model compound Azm were measured in toluene (1.0 × 10−5 M), as shown in Fig. 3a. The absorption band of TPh was bathochromically shifted compared to that of Azm. The DFT calculations were performed to gain deep insight into the origin of the electronic states in the hypervalent tin derivatives (Fig. 3b and Tables S3–S6†). We evaluated the electronic effects of the hypervalent state on the π-conjugated scaffolds by comparing model compounds Azm and AzmOMe. According to the MOs of Azm, AzmOMe, and TPh, the LUMO energy levels were significantly stabilized by the tin coordination compared with the HOMO energy levels (Azm: HOMO = −5.90 eV, LUMO = −1.55 eV, AzmOMe: HOMO = −5.22 eV, LUMO = −1.17 eV, TPh: HOMO = −5.40 eV, LUMO = −2.21 eV). This result suggests that the MO is stabilized by electron-accepting nitrogen–tin (N–Sn) coordination at the equatorial position. Moreover, the stabilization of the HOMO energy level is relatively suppressed by the electron-donating 3c–4e bond, as described in our previous report (Fig. 3c).17 The hypervalent states can exhibit electronic effects specific to their coordination positions, irrespective of ligand structures.
The distributions of electric charges and dipole moments before and after introducing the hypervalent tin were also examined using DFT calculations. From Fig. S7,† it was found that the unsymmetrical distribution of electric charges was observed from the surface of molecular electrostatic potential (MEP) of TPh compared with Azm and AzmOMe, and a larger degree of negative charge was observed from the benzene ring of the N-side than that of the C-side, like D–π–A molecules. These results represent that the introduction of the hypervalent tin atom should induce charge separation and reinforce the inductive effect of the imine bond. This is because of the enhanced electron-withdrawing ability by the coordination of the tin atom, which works as the Lewis acid. In addition, the dipole moment of Azm was 1.431 debye along the direction of the imine bond, while that of TPh was 2.778 debye, indicating that the asymmetric electronic state should be realized (Fig. S7†). These data suggest that the different electronic states should be realized in both dinuclear compounds where only the nitrogen position is different.
The electronic states of π-conjugated molecules can be influenced by the direction of imine bonds and the positions of nitrogen atoms in forming the hypervalent state. We explored the electronic states and the impact of dinucleation by comparing the mononuclear and dinuclear hypervalent tin compounds (Fig. 4c, S9 and Tables S7, S8†). As depicted in Fig. 4c, TPhCN and TPhNC exhibited narrower energy gaps than TPh because of the extension of their π-conjugated scaffolds. Focusing on the range of changes in the MO levels compared to TPh, the HOMO of TPhCN is destabilized more significantly than that of TPhNC (TPhCN: −4.87 eV, TPhNC: −5.25 eV), and the LUMO of TPhNC is stabilized more dramatically than that of TPhCN (TPhCN: −2.54 eV, TPhNC: −2.97 eV). We considered that these are derived from the direction of the imine bonds. In TPhCN, the electron-donating effect of the two imine bonds contributed to the central benzene ring, which is expected to destabilize the HOMO by increasing the electron density. In TPhNC, on the other hand, the electron-withdrawing effect of the two imine bonds should stabilize the LUMO by promoting electron deficiency of the central benzene ring. Moreover, we assessed the MO energy levels using cyclic voltammetry (CV), as illustrated in Fig. S10.† The HOMO and LUMO energy levels of TPh, TPhCN, and TPhNC determined from the cyclic voltammograms closely mirrored the trends observed in the results from the DFT calculations. Notably, it was concluded that the positions of dinucleation in the ladder structure strongly affected the optical and electronic properties.
The photoluminescence spectra of TPh derivatives in the solid state were observed and compared with those in the solution state (Fig. S11†). Focusing on the emission wavelengths, the change was hardly observed in TPh (λmaxFL,solid = 576 nm, ΦFL,solid = 18.4%). This slight wavelength change should be due to the weak intermolecular interactions. On the other hand, the emission bands of both dinuclear compounds TPhCN and TPhNC were shifted to the longer wavelength regions, leading to their solid-state NIR luminescence (TPhCN: λmaxFL,solid = 836 nm, ΦFL = 0.5%, TPhNC: λmaxFL,solid = 796 nm, ΦFL,solid = 2.4%). Considering these results and the optimized structures in the ground and excited states, their symmetric structures should restrict structural relaxation. Consequently, we speculate that the observed emission in the longer wavelength region can be attributed to intermolecular interactions. The dinuclear compounds also exhibited aggregation-caused quenching properties that reduced the quantum yield.31 These results suggest that the construction of symmetric structures affects not only the electronic state of the molecules but also their mobility.
We draw the MEP surface to examine the charge distribution of these hypervalent compounds (Fig. 5). TPh showed the unsymmetrical charge distribution, and the benzene ring of the N-side had a larger negative charge than that of the C-side, as described previously (Fig. 5a). In addition, reflecting the charge distribution of TPh, TPhCN had a large negative charge in the center benzene ring (Fig. 5b), while TPhNC had that in the side benzene rings (Fig. 5c). Therefore, this molecular design of dinucleation provided charge separation and quadrupolar molecules in the ground state, and TPhCN and TPhNC constituted the ring-fused A–π–D–π–A and the D–π–A–π–D systems, respectively.
The absorption spectra were measured in dichloromethane (CH2Cl2), chloroform (CHCl3), toluene, and cyclohexane (c-hex) to gain insights into the solvent effects on these compounds. Surprisingly, both TPhCN and TPhNC exhibited negative solvatochromism in the only absorption property regardless of their neutral and symmetric structures. Meanwhile, the emission wavelengths hardly changed depending on those solvents (Fig. 5). In general, negative solvatochromism is caused by photoexcitation changes in the dipole moment.32 However, the DFT calculations suggested that the dipole moments in TPhCN and TPhNC are almost identical (Fig. S12†). On the other hand, there are few examples of negative solvatochromism in the only absorption property because of “Symmetry breaking” in the ground state. Terenziani et al. predicted the existence of molecules with negative solvatochromism only in the absorption spectrum (referred to as “Class III” in the literature).26,33,34 They proved that polymethine derivatives fall into this category.33 These reports showed that large quadrupolar dyes caused negative solvatochromism in the only absorption property because the ground state was bistable (D–π–A−–π–D+ or D+–π–A−–π–D) and the excited state was stable as nonpolar. Therefore, we estimated the dinuclear compounds TPhCN and TPhNC have a large quadrupolar in the only ground state owing to the electronic effects unique to the hypervalent state and their imine moiety. We further observed the solvent effects in the DFT calculations. We reproduced the results, that is, the same as the tendency of optical measurements (Fig. S13,† the calculation was performed against CH2Cl2, CHCl3, toluene, and c-hex). These findings propose that the electronic effects of hypervalent states can be exploited to create a novel D–A system in small molecules beyond the conventional D–A linking method.
The DFT calculations were performed to assess the extension of conjugation in mononuclear and dinuclear compounds with two and three units (Fig. 6b and S16–S21†). In the mononuclear compound, the HOMO and LUMO expanded as the number of units increased, whereas expansion of π-conjugation in the entire molecule was hardly observed, which might be attributed to the twisted bithiophene unit. In the A–π–D–π–A dinuclear compound TPhCN, as the number of units increased, the LUMO was expanded because of its high planarity, while the HOMO was localized in the dinuclear compound owing to the electron-rich moiety of the center benzene ring. On the other hand, in the D–π–A–π–D dinuclear compound TPhNC, the HOMO was extended throughout the main chain, and the LUMO was localized on the dinuclear compound unit because of the centered electron-deficient benzene ring. These results suggest that the charge distribution induced by each direction of dinucleation (TPhCN or TPhNC) leads to different orbitals in the extended MOs, altering the energy level of each MO. As described above, polymerization of polarized D–π–A–π–D or A–π–D–π–A type molecules is suggested to induce specific orbital extensions, and the polarized state in π-conjugated scaffolds can be featured by constructing conjugated polymers.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details “bisTPh_SI.pdf”. CCDC 2373875 and 2373876. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc05006a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |