Open Access Article
C isomers†
Simin
Cheng‡
a,
Chenxi
Cao‡
b,
Yao
Qian
b,
Huan
Yao
c,
Xiaoyun
Gong
a,
Xinhua
Dai
*a,
Zheng
Ouyang
*b and
Xiaoxiao
Ma
*b
aTechnology Innovation Center of Mass Spectrometry for State Market Regulation, Center for Advanced Measurement Science, National Institute of Metrology, Bejing, 100029, China. E-mail: daixh@nim.ac.cn
bState Key Laboratory of Precision Measurement Technology and Instruments, Department of Precision Instrument, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China. E-mail: ouyang@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn; maxx@tsinghua.edu.cn
cDivision of Chemical Metrology and Analytical Science, National Institute of Metrology, Beijing, 100029, China
First published on 4th April 2024
Single-cell mass spectrometry (MS) is an essential technology for sensitive and multiplexed analysis of metabolites and lipids for cell phenotyping and pathway studies. However, the structural elucidation of lipids from single cells remains a challenge, especially in the high-throughput scenario. Technically, there is a contradiction between the inadequate sample amount (i.e. a single cell, 0.5–20 pL) for replicate or multiple analysis, on the one hand, and the high metabolite coverage and multidimensional structure analysis that needs to be performed for each single cell, on the other hand. Here, we have developed a high-throughput single-cell MS platform that can perform both lipid profiling and lipid carbon–carbon double bond (C
C) location isomer resolution analysis, aided by C
C activation in unsaturated lipids by the Paternò–Büchi (PB) reaction and tandem MS, termed single-cell structural lipidomics analysis. The method can achieve a single-cell analysis throughput of 51 cells per minute. A total of 145 lipids were structurally characterized at the subclass level, of which the relative abundance of 17 isomeric lipids differing in the location of C
C from 5 lipid precursors was determined. While cell-to-cell variations in MS1-based lipid profiling can be large, an advantage of quantifying lipid C
C location isomers is the significantly improved quantitation accuracy. For example, the relative standard deviations (RSDs) of the relative amounts of PC 34:1 C
C position isomers in MDA-MB-468 cells are half smaller than those measured for PC 34:1 as a whole by MS1 abundance profiling. Taken together, the developed method can be effectively used for in-depth structural lipid metabolism network analysis by high-throughput analysis of 142 MDA-MB-468 human breast cancer cells.
Lipids, as major components of cell membranes, play essential roles in energy storage, signal transduction, and the regulation of membrane protein functions.26–29 Previous studies have shown that lipid alterations are closely related to type-II diabetes (T2D), cancers, and cytotoxicity of NK cells.30–33 Besides, a great number of isomers exist in the lipidome, including C
C location isomers and C
C geometry isomers, and in glycerolipids, fatty acyl sn-positional isomers, etc. The relative amounts of lipid isomers have been demonstrated to be correlated with various diseases including cancer, at the cell, animal model, and human levels.34–36 Over the past 20 years, innovative methods have emerged to tackle the structural diversity and complexity of lipids at the omics level towards structural lipidomics. Of note, novel ion activation methods or chemical reactions coupled with MS or MS/MS have become routine methods for detailed lipid structure analysis, e.g., ozone-induced dissociation (OzID), electron impact excitation of ions from organics (EIEIO), and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD).37–40 Since 2014, the PB reaction coupled with tandem MS has been reported and has now become an effective method for lipid analysis with C
C specificity.41–45 The PB-MSn method allows comprehensive analysis of lipids at the omics level in plasma, blood, tissues, and organs, in a shotgun approach or coupled with liquid chromatography (LC) for separation prior to MS analysis. Based on PB reactions, to our knowledge, we developed a single cell lipid analysis method with C
C specificity in 2021, by combining cell fixation, lipid derivatization, droplet-assisted electrospray ionization (DAESI), and MS/MS, capable of revealing new metabolic features of human breast cancer at the C
C level.35 However, similar to other static extraction methods, this approach suffers from a relatively low throughput for single-cell analysis, making it labor-intensive and difficult to accumulate a sufficient number of single cells for biological applications.
In this work, we aim to develop a high-throughput single-cell in-depth lipidomics workflow capable of detailed lipid structure elucidation and quantitative lipid isomer analysis with high accuracy, as depicted in Fig. 1 and S1.† In brief, freshly prepared single cells can be analyzed directly by MS/MS through a cell introduction device consisting of a three-layered capillary tubing (i). In addition, prior to cell introduction and MS analysis, we can also conduct batch cell fixation and PB photochemical derivatization that allow parallel C
C activation of a large number of single cells. The derivatized cells were then introduced into the MS for rapid sequential analysis (PB-MS/MS), at 51 cells per minute (ii). We used this single cell MS analysis system to analyze the in-depth lipidome of human breast cancer cells, revealing clear cellular heterogeneity and lipid composition differences with a particular dimension of detailed lipid structures, e.g., lipid C
C locations. We can simultaneously analyze six distinct lipid isomers from a single cancer cell through multiple MS2 analysis. With multiplexed lipid structure elucidation and quantitative analysis, an increased number of dimensions of lipid information can be acquired to enable more accurate cell phenotyping, reveal new metabolic features, and characterize cellular heterogeneity. Moreover, the in-depth structural lipid metabolic network can be mapped with unprecedented details to validate the co-regulation of distinct lipid species.
C specificity. Experimental parameters of the cell introduction device were optimized using MDA-MB-468 cells, including carrier gas pressure and sheath fluid flow rate, along with MS instrument parameters. Specifically, we found that (1) applying an appropriate high voltage (3 kV) and carrier gas pressure (6 bar) enhanced the ionization efficiency of single cell analysis (Fig. S2a–c†); (2) increasing the sheath fluid flow rate and adjusting the distance between the outlet of the middle and inner capillary initially led to an increase in signal intensity, followed by a subsequent decrease, which may be related to the extraction efficiency and dilution effect of metabolites (Fig. S2d and e†); (3) the cell concentration and the cell injection pressure were positively correlated with single cell analytical throughput (Fig. S3†). The number of single cell MS signals per minute matched well with the number of cells analyzed at different cell concentrations, indicating that most cells were detected as a single cell. A camera was used to record this process (Videos S1 and S2†). However, as the cell concentration was increased to >5 × 104 cells per mL, cell adhesion occurred and cell aggregates were observed as evidenced by the occurrence of increased proportion of consecutive MS peaks for cells (Fig. S4†). In addition, we conducted solvent evaluation for the sheath liquid for lipid extraction of single cells. Methanol yielded the highest signal intensity when used as the sheath liquid, while the addition of 1% formic acid suppressed lipid [M + Na]+ ions, thereby favoring [M + H]+ ions and yielding cleaner spectra (Fig. S5†). Consequently, methanol containing 1% formic acid was utilized as the sheath fluid.
Following method optimization, we set to evaluate the performance of the developed method for single cell analysis with lipid C
C specificity, at a cell analysis rate of 51 cells per minute (Fig. 2a). Representative mass spectra of MDA-MB-468 cells collected in positive ion mode using the developed method are shown in Fig. 2b. To improve lipid derivatization and MS detection by avoiding inter-cellular contamination, single cell fixation was performed in batch using glutaraldehyde. Fixed cells were then subjected to PB derivatization with 2-acetylpyridine (2-AP), resulting in a 121 Da mass shift (2-AP molecular weight, 121 Da) in derivatized lipids with 47.5% reaction yield (Fig. 2b and S6†). 2-AP is a versatile reagent for C
C modification in unsaturated lipids, with no reaction selectivity towards C
Cs at different locations in polyunsaturated lipids.43 Without the PB reaction, we utilized tandem MS to analyze 61 lipid precursors, leading to 145 lipids being identified, including 32 phosphatidylcholines (PCs), 35 phosphatidylethanolamines (PEs), 16 phosphatidylserines (PSs), 3 lysophosphatidylcholines (LPCs), 3 sphingomyelin (SM), and 56 triacylglycerols (TAGs) (Fig. 2c, S7 and Table S1†). With the PB reaction, we additionally identified 17 lipid C
C location isomers from 5 PC precursors in single cells (Fig. 2d and Table S2†). Of note, the fixation of glutaraldehyde on cells is based on cross-linking of amino residues in proteins. However, fixation also leads to the loss of amino lipids such as PEs and PSs, therefore no such lipid isomers were analyzed after fixation (Fig. S8†). By using PC 26:0 as the internal standard, it is estimated that the recovery rate of PCs after fixation is >95%, and after derivatization the recovery rate is >90% (Fig. S9†).
C location isomers) levels in analyzing MDA-MB-468 cells. Compared with the relatively large variations in MS1 lipid profiling (adding PC 26:0 to the sheath fluid as the internal standard), the relative amounts of lipid C
C location isomers offered increased quantitative stability in terms of the relative standard deviation (RSD). For PC 34:1, the precursor ions at m/z 760 among 100 single cells showed a wide distribution with a large RSD of ∼57.8% in intensity (Fig. 3a). By contrast, the variations in the relative amounts of PC 34:1 C
C location isomers were much smaller, i.e., RSDs of 48.7% for the n-10 isomers, 2.2% for the n-9 isomers and 13.8% for the n-7 isomer, with a 2.7-fold improvement compared with MS1 lipid profiling (Fig. 3a). The larger RSD for the n-10 isomers compared with the n-9 and n-7 counterparts was due to the low amount of the former. Similar results were observed for PC 34:2, where the RSD based on MS1 analysis compared to the internal standard was 62.4%, while the RSDs for the n-10, n-9, n-7, and n-6,9 isomers were 58.7%, 23.4%, 22.2%, and 10%, respectively, with an average of 2.2-fold improvement in RSD (Fig. 3b). The significantly lower variation in the quantification of lipid C
C positional isomers using the developed method can be rationalized by the tightly regulated lipid C
C positional isomer homeostasis in the biological system.34 This advantage of single cell structural lipidomics analysis with C
C specificity offers a new dimension for obtaining cellular information with added quantitative accuracy, avoiding the major difficulties of introducing lipid standards into a single cell.
C position isomers of PC 18:1_18:1 were structurally characterized and relatively quantified at the single-cell level. Interestingly, we observed that MCF-10A cells (n = 52) consistently showed higher amounts of n-9 isomers than MDA-MB-468 cancer cells (n = 385), as shown in Fig. 4a. Bivariate joint kernel density estimation showed significant differences in PC 18:1_18:1 isomer composition in MDA-MB-468 and MCF-10A cells. As shown in Fig. 4a, the two cell populations showed non-overlapping distributions, strongly suggesting PC 18:1_18:1 isomer composition to be a useful marker for discriminating breast cancer cells from normal ones. We also conducted an unsupervised t-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding (t-SNE) calculation for successful classification of these two cell lines based on the lipid isomer ratio (Fig. S12†). The corresponding chemical structures and MS/MS spectra of PC 18:1_18:1 isomers are shown in Fig. 4b and c. As expected, two-dimensional joint kernel density estimation of lipid isomer distribution has larger differences than one-dimensional composition distribution, highlighting the advantage of multidimensional cell classification enhanced with lipid structure information.
In another abundant phospholipid PC 18:0_18:1, the relative proportions of n-9 and n-7 C
C location isomers differ significantly between MDA-MB-468 and MCF-10A cells, yet these distinct isomer amounts still show some overlap (Fig. 4d–f, n = 46 and 343 for MCF-10A cells and MDA-MB-468 cells, respectively). Nonetheless, the trend in lipid C
C isomer composition remains similar to that of PC 18:1_18:1, and for both lipids the relative amounts of n-7 isomers are higher in cancer cells.
Next, we conducted lipid C
C location isomer analysis besides n-7 and n-9 isomer analysis. As has been reported, lipid desaturation can be achieved via two biological pathways in humans, including the generation of C18:1 n-7 and n-9 isomers via stearoyl-CoA desaturase 1 (SCD1) or the generation of the C18:1 n-10 isomer through fatty acid desaturase 2 (FADS2).46 We detected elevated amounts of the C18:1 n-10 isomer in cancer cells compared to normal epithelial cells for both PC 18:1_18:1 and PC 18:0_18:1 (Fig. S11a and b†). This observation is consistent with the recently reported metabolic plasticity of lipid desaturation in cancer, where the otherwise less active FADS2 pathway in normal cells is activated in the corresponding cancer cells, leading to increased levels of phospholipid n-10 C
C isomers.46 Besides phospholipids containing only monounsaturated fatty acyls, we also analyzed the C
C isomer composition of polyunsaturated lipids. For instance, in PC 18:0_18:2, normal epithelial cells exhibited increased amounts of n-6,9 C
C location isomers (Fig. S11c†), while in PC 16:0_18:2, decreased amounts of n-6,9 C
C location isomers were detected with large isomer composition variations among the cell population analyzed (Fig. S11d†). The large variations of the amounts of n-6,9 isomers in polyunsaturated lipids are intriguing, as these lipids are exogenous and cannot be synthesized de novo in cells.
C specificity enabling in-depth structural lipid metabolic network analysis
C location isomers in MDA-MB-468 cells to study their roles in lipid metabolic pathways. A metabolic network involving C18:1-containing lipids is shown in Fig. S13a,† where PC 18:1_18:1 containing two C18:1 fatty acyls was used as an example (Fig. S10a†). The composition of lipid isomers including n-7, n-9, and n-10 isomers in single cells was analyzed and used to evaluate their metabolic correlations. A strong negative correlation between the n-7 and n-9 isomers was observed (Fig. S13b†), which can be well explained by the fact that C18:1 n-7 and n-9 isomers are generated from the same SCD1 pathway, and more importantly the amounts of these two isomers may be more dominant than other possible isomers, e.g., the less abundant C18:1 n-10 isomer from the independent FADS2 pathway (Fig. S13a†).
We attempted to apply this method to more complex lipid pathways, which requires characterization and quantitation of more structurally distinct lipids from single cells. Such analysis requires the collection of multiple MS/MS spectra from a single cell for structural elucidation of lipids. In the shotgun analysis mode, we set up an MS1 full scan followed by multiple targeted MS/MS scans (Fig. S14†). To extend the cell analysis time without compromising detection sensitivity, we adjusted the distance between the middle/inner capillary outlets from 2 mm to 4 mm. MS/MS analysis of derivatized PC 16:0_18:1 (m/z 881) and PC 16:0_16:1 (m/z 853) was performed for structural elucidation and quantitation of their C
C isomers (Fig. S15†). The biosynthesis pathways of common lipid C
C isomers are illustrated in Fig. 5a. MS/MS analysis revealed 6 PC C
C location isomers and enabled their metabolic correlations. While the majority of lipid C
C isomers exhibited negative correlations, a few instances (3 out of 15 correlation analysis results) showed positive correlations (Fig. 5b and Table S3†). Specifically, positive correlations were observed between the n-7 location isomers of PC 16:0_16:1 and PC 16:0_18:1, as well as between their corresponding n-9 and n-10 location isomers. This finding is consistent with the generation of n-10, n-7, and n-9 fatty acyl-CoA species, which are then utilized for further synthesis of more complex phospholipids, such as PC 16:0_16:1 and PC 16:0_18:1. Within PC 16:0_16:1 or PC 16:0_18:1 (Fig. 5b), a strong negative correlation between their n-7 and n-9 isomers was also observed, as has been pointed out previously. These experimental results highlight the usefulness of lipid structural elucidation and quantitative analysis in lipid metabolic pathway analysis.
C position isomers. As a result, 17 lipid C
C location isomers from 5 PC precursors can be identified at the single cell level using PB derivatization. This breakthrough in high-throughput single-cell lipidomics analysis allowed us to observe distinct distributions of lipid C
C location isomer composition between the breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-468 and the mammary epithelial cell line MCF-10A. Furthermore, correlation analysis of different lipid C
C position isomers showed a compelling agreement with metabolic pathways observed in living organisms. The good agreement with known pathways confirms the reliability and accuracy of our single-cell analysis approach, demonstrating its potential to provide deeper insights into cellular processes and offer new perspectives on cellular heterogeneity and the complex interactions within cellular systems. This innovative approach has the potential to revolutionize lipidomics research and contribute to a better understanding of cellular heterogeneity, disease mechanisms, and potential therapeutic targets.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc06573a |
| ‡ Equal contributions. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |