Bethuel Daurai and
Manashjit Gogoi*
Department of Biomedical Engineering, North-Eastern Hill University, Shillong, Meghalaya, India. E-mail: bethueldaurai@gmail.com; manash.aec@gmail.com
First published on 5th August 2024
Pancreatitis is a life-threatening inflammatory disease of the pancreas. In 2019, 34.8 out of 100000 people suffered from acute pancreatitis globally. In humans, the level of α-amylase increases three times the normal value during pancreatitis. α-Amylase is an enzyme that hydrolyses α-1,4 glycosidic bonds of starch. In this study, we investigated a novel distance-based sensing method. We exploited the existing starch triiodide method, where the blue colour of starch-triiodide fades away and becomes colourless when α-amylase breaks the starch chain at the α-1-4 glycosidic bond. A hydrophilic channel was made on paper using a simple laser printer to create hydrophobic barriers. This channel was impregnated with starch triiodide, where α-amylase can turn it colourless. This distance covered by the change in colour is directly proportional to the concentration of α-amylase in a sample. Simulated samples with different concentrations of porcine α-amylase and pancreatin were used for testing using the developed paper-based chemometer device. The paper-based chemometer device was also tested with artificial blood serum with different concentrations of α-amylase. The R2 of this device was found to be 0.9905, and the accuracy of the device when compared with a 2-chloro-4-nitrophenyl-α-D-maltotrioside method was found to be 95.54% with a sensitivity of 0.131 U L−1 mm−1. Correlation test also showed that the paper-based chemometer device for α-amylase can be used as a testing device for artificial blood serum. This is a preliminary investigation that shows promising results. The chemometer devices stored in air-tight packets at 4–8 °C in a refrigerator did not lose the colour intensity until day 90 and retained an accuracy of 94.5%. However, the device needs to be evaluated in clinical settings prior to using it for measuring α-amylase in patients.
Paper-based devices can be easily transported and stored, making them ideal for field testing in remote and rural areas where laboratory facilities are hardly available.17,18 The devices do not require any specialised training or equipment, and the results can be easily interpreted without the need for complex data analysis.19 They have also demonstrated excellent performance in various chemical analyses, including the detection of glucose, cholesterol, and protein biomarkers in biological fluids.20–22 These devices have also been used for environmental monitoring, such as the detection of heavy metal ions in water samples, and food safety testing, such as the detection of pathogens in food products.23–25 There is ongoing research focused on improving the sensitivity and selectivity of distance-based paper-based microfluidic devices using new materials and technologies, such as nanoparticles and biosensors, to enhance the detection capabilities of these devices.26–29
α-Amylase measurement contributes to the timely identification of pancreatitis. Pancreatitis is an inflammation of the glandular organ pancreas situated posterior to the stomach.30 The global burden of acute pancreatitis depends on the prevalence of the disease. In 2019, 34.8 persons out of 100000 suffered from acute pancreatitis globally.31 In North America, 52 persons suffered from pancreatitis out of 100000, whereas the highest incidence was recorded in Eastern Europe, which stood at 79.6 in 100000 people and was also prevalent in low-income regions, such as South-East Asian countries as well as South and Central American nations. As per the revised Atlanta classification, α-amylase serves as the principal biomarker for pancreatitis detection.32
In this study, a paper-based chemometer device (PCD) developed using a laser printer is investigated for measuring α-amylase, a biomarker for pancreatitis. Hydrophilic channel saturated with starch triiodide exhibits a profound blue colour due to the triiodide forming bonds with the alpha-1,4 linkages of large polysaccharides.33,34 The channel undergoes a colour change from blue to colourless upon the introduction of α-amylase from one end.35 The measurement of the distance at which the colour transitions from deep blue to colourless across the channel is utilised to determine the concentration of α-amylase. The developed PCD was used to determine α-amylase for both simulated samples and artificial blood serum. All the results in this study are shown for the artificial blood serum.
Existing studies suggest the use of the same principle of starch triiodide and other techniques for the detection of α-amylase in various biological fluids.36–40 Some devices use colourimetric, fluorometric, liquid crystal, surface plasmon resonance, mechanic, and electrochemical probes.37,41–43 The main distinction lies in the fact that these earlier studies required a supporting electronic device, while the PCD we developed is standalone, and α-amylase estimation can be performed with naked-eye visualisation. This PCD device will not replace the existing methods of detection but will supplement them by aiding in ruling out pancreatitis in rural areas with community healthcare centres and can also aid in ruling out clinics and emergency medicine.
α-Amylase stock solutions were prepared from both porcine α-amylase and pancreatin by dissolving their lyophilised powders in a phosphate buffer solution of pH 6.8 and ABS. Stock solutions of both materials were prepared, with concentrations ranging from 70–420 U L−1. Amylase (pancreatin) was added to the ABS and PBS to prepare different solutions with amylase concentrations ranging from 70–420 U L−1. The viscosity of both PBS and ABS (containing α-amylase) solutions was measured using an Ostwald's viscometer to evaluate the impact of viscosity on the flow of the fluid in the PCD. The test was performed on the PCD channels by dropping 100 μL each of α-amylase solution.
The stability of a PCD depends on uniformity in the pore sizes and quality of the paper used. Uniformity in pore sizes ensures the fluid retention capacity of the device and the flow rate of the fluid.48,49 Whatman filter papers were used to ensure the quality of paper, fluid retention capacity and constant flow rate of fluid. Both Grade 1 (pore size approximately 11 μm) and Grade 4 (pore size approximately 20–25 μm) Whatman filter papers were investigated for the development of the chemometer. However, Grade 4 Whatman filter paper was found to be suitable for our device due to the higher retention capacity of reagents, higher flow rate of fluid and hence less reaction time. Moreover, printing hydrophobic material on Grade 4 filter paper is easier because of its larger pore size.
UV-visible spectroscopy (Inkarp Sican 2000) was used for the spectrum scan. The scan was done to determine the peak absorbance of starch triiodide and to observe if the peak reduced with the action of α-amylase. The estimation of α-amylase is well established using the starch triiodide method with the UV-visible spectroscopic method. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) characterisation was done for starch triiodide, α-amylase, and the reaction. The scan was taken from the paper surface of the PCD channels. This was done to determine the presence of the functional group in the reaction. The concentration of α-amylase was taken at 420 U L−1 for the characterisation of both UV-visible spectroscopy and FTIR.
The CNPG3 method adopted by Euro Synergy Bio was used as the standard method for the validation and comparison of the PCD. The CNPG3 method is a good assessment for microanalysis system.50 This CNPG3 method works with UV-visible spectroscopy, which has linearity up to 2000 U L−1. The accuracy of the PCD was determined by estimating the concentrations, i.e., 70, 140, 210, 280, 350, and 420 U L−1 of α-amylase in ABS. All the concentrations were tested with both PCD and CNPG3 for accuracy using the following equation. The accuracy was calculated by subtracting the percentage error from 100%.
(1) |
To determine the storage stability of the device, the fabricated PCDs were stored in the following conditions: (i) room temperature open; (ii) room temperature sealed in an airtight packet; (iii) 4–8 °C refrigerated open, and (iv) 4–8 °C refrigerated sealed airtight packet and used to determine α-amylase in simulated samples after 90 days.
To test the reproducibility of our device, the correlation of the 3 sets of tests shown in Fig. 5 was performed to determine the linear response of the three sets of tests. ANOVA single factor was also done on the 3 sets of PCD data. The null hypothesis is as follows: the 3 sets of data are similar or follow the same pattern. The alternate hypothesis is as follows: there is no similarity among the 3 sets of data.
A test of correlation and a t-test (two samples assuming equal variance) were performed between the PCD and the CNPG3 method to determine the linear response test and determine the usability of the PCD in place of the CNPG3 method. The data were normalised before running the test because both had the X-axis as an arbitrary value. In the paired t-test, the null hypothesis was that the PCD and CNPG3 methods were similar and could be interchanged in the determination of the two methods. The alternative hypothesis was that the two methods were completely different and could not be used interchangeably in the estimation of α-amylase.
A case was developed to maintain the hydrophilic part of the PCD strips elevated. This case prevents unwanted fluid leakage from the PCD. Fig. 1(a) shows the 3D design and the printed case for the PCD. Creality Ender 3 S1 (3D Printer) was used to print the case, and the material used for printing was polylactic acid. The case is reusable and biodegradable if chosen for disposal.
In Fig. 2(a), photographs of the channels are shown from both the top and bottom of the channels to show that the channel was formed without leakage. The toner ink, although not visible on the bottom, seeps to the bottom, forming a hydrophobic barrier. Another optional layer could be printed on the opposite surface of the paper with a mirror image. This step is optional because the uniform printing may be compromised because of human error, which leads to the narrowing of the channels. Starch triiodide was used as a coloured solution to show that the channels were intact and to check for any leakage along the channel. A slight overspread of the hydrophobic material was observed along the border of the channel and the hydrophobic barrier. This can be avoided by reducing the heating time by about half an hour of the mentioned time. However, in this application, the heating time was not reduced.
In Fig. 2(b), a microscopic image was captured using a field emission scanning electron microscope (FE SEM Zeiss Sigma) to observe whether the pores of the channels had been clogged and had gained hydrophobicity with the toner ink. Similar results have also been observed in previous studies.13,47 This shows that the pores were all filled with the melted toner material. Magnification was taken 100 times with a 100 μm size of the view, and the size of the pores was approximately 23.5 μm when measured with Image J software (Grade 4 Whatman filter paper usually has a pore size of 20–25 μm). A slight overspread of hydrophobic material can also be observed at the edge of the barriers, as shown in the photograph in Fig. 2(a).
I2 + KI → KI3 | (2) |
I2 + I− → I3− | (3) |
As long as iodine molecules and iodide ions are present, triiodide ions are continuously produced.51 The triiodide ions are responsible for the brown hue of the solution, which is caused by the complex triiodide ions. The triiodide ions react with starch to form starch triiodide, which is blue in colour.52 This reaction is represented in the following equation:
Starch + I3− → starch triiodide. | (4) |
This range was chosen to cover at least 3 times the normal range from the biological reference value. Now, this starch triiodide is coated to the channel, as shown in Fig. 1(d). The drying is performed at room temperature because, with heat, the blue colour dissipates into colourless by itself because of the breaking of the α-1,4 glycosidic bond. The final channel looked bright and light blue, which was easily distinguishable from the naked eye.
The volume of the starch triiodide was calculated based on the volume of fluid retained in the channel. Considering the channel as a cuboid structure, the amount of fluid retained is length × breadth × height. The thickness of the paper is 210 μm which is considered as the height. Therefore, the volume is 37.8 mm3, which is equivalent to 37.8 μL.
A UV-vis spectrophotometric analysis of starch triiodide and the reaction of starch triiodide with α-amylase are shown in Fig. 3. Starch triiodide of the same concentration deposited in the PCD was used, and it showed peak absorbance at 600 nm. A concentration of 70–420 U L−1 of α-amylase was taken and mixed with starch triiodide at the ratio of 1:10, and the reading was taken, as shown in Fig. 3. The mixture was incubated at 37 °C for 15 minutes. This shows that a serial dissemination of the peak occurs. This shows that the activity of α-amylase hydrolyses the α-1,4 glycosidic bond, and the intense blue turns colourless.
Fig. 4(a) illustrates the FTIR spectra of α-amylase, starch triiodide, and the reaction, which were in the PCD channel. The FTIR reading was taken directly from the paper channel. A molecular structure of starch is also given to show various bonds and their presence in the FTIR spectra. The stretched peak pattern around 3000–3600 cm−1 in wave number shows the presence of an OH bond in all the three samples. This shows that the bond vibrates at that specific wavenumber, and all the three compounds had –OH (hydroxyl group) as their functional group. Starch usually contains an acetal group. The bending vibration at 1078 cm−1 is present in α-amylase, which is also observed in the reaction solution with starch triiodide. This bend signifies the presence of α-amylase in the reaction. The other smaller bending peaks are also visible at the 1640 cm−1 and 2359 cm−1 wavenumbers. Fig. 1 (ESI)† shows the FTIR of the serial dilution of α-amylase from 70–420 U L−1. The FTIR of these concentrations was taken from the solutions used in the absorbance spectrum and not directly in the PCD, as depicted in Fig. 4. As the amylase concentration decreases, there are observable shifts and changes in the intensity of the peaks, indicating alterations in the chemical environment and interactions between the molecules.
(5) |
Fig. 5 shows a scanned photograph of the tests performed. All the dried test strips were attached to a sheet of paper ISO A4. A scale of 10 mm was printed on a sheet of paper for reference. As enzyme α-amylase starts its action, the α-1,4 glycosidic bond in the starch starts breaking, losing its blue colour. This leads to the channels turning from blue to white. The discolouration because of the breaking of the α-1,4 glycosidic bond spreads according to the concentration of the enzyme. All the data derived from Fig. 5 are tabulated in Table 1.
Conc. (U L−1) | D1 (mm) | D2 (mm) | D3 (mm) | Average (mm) | SD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
70 | 5.882 | 7.061 | 10.084 | 7.68 | 2.17 |
140 | 17.984 | 17.482 | 18.151 | 17.87 | 0.35 |
210 | 26.219 | 33.284 | 36.302 | 31.94 | 5.18 |
280 | 36.472 | 34.034 | 37.311 | 35.94 | 1.70 |
350 | 46.386 | 43.868 | 45.883 | 45.38 | 1.33 |
420 | 54.79 | 54.453 | 55.127 | 54.79 | 0.337 |
However, ascorbic acid present in the blood serum is known to interfere with the starch triiodide complex. It readily oxidises the iodine in the starch triiodide complex. Dutta et al. described neutralizing ascorbic acid in the sample before it could be tested using the starch triiodide method.36 Potassium iodate was used to pretreat this blood serum to neutralise the effect of ascorbic acid on the starch triiodide complex.54–56 Potassium iodate was made from potassium iodide and iodine, and the pH was adjusted with sodium hydroxide. Potassium iodate is mixed with the blood before it can be introduced to the PCD.
The calibration curve obtained showed that the R2 value obtained was 0.9905 with a sensitivity of 0.131 U L−1 mm−1 (shown in Fig. 6). The determination of the accuracy of the PCD was compared with that of the standard CNPG3 method. The obtained accuracy was 95.54%. This shows that PCD as a POC device for the determination of α-amylase concentration is possible.
Fig. 6 Calibration curve concentration against distance derived from Fig. 5. |
In the stability test, it was observed that the PCDs stored at room temperature without the seal lost their colour after 3 days, and the sealed packet PCDs stored at room temperature also lost their colours after 30 days. Both the PCDs stored at room temperature were not tested because they lost the intense blue colour, which shows that the α-1,4 bond has already been broken because of temperature fluctuations. The PCDs stored at 4–8 °C in refrigerated but not sealed packets also lost colour because of moisture. The PCDs stored at 4–8 °C refrigerated sealed airtight packets did not lose the colour intensity after 90 days. Once more, an accuracy test was conducted in comparison to the CNPG3 method, which produced a result of 94.5%.
The Pearson's correlation value of 0.982 for the three repeated tests with the PCD suggests that they have a strong positive linear relationship. Table 1 (ESI)† shows the standard deviation (SD) with the precision level of the PCD at various data points. Fig. 7 shows the scattered plot of the three sets of data and the regression line of the average values corresponding to Fig. 6. This high correlation value also suggests the PCD's high reproducibility in quantifying the α-amylase in the ABS. An ANOVA single factor for the same three sets of data was performed with a significance level of 0.05. The F value was 0.0233, indicating no significant difference between the groups, and the P value was 0.976, indicating that there was no rejection of the null hypothesis (all three sets of data were similar).
Fig. 7 Scatter plot of the data. The trend line is taken for the average of the three sets of tests. |
A t-test (two samples assuming equal variance) was performed with α 0.05 significance value. The values were first normalised, and the P value found was 0.89, showing that there was no significant difference between PCD and the CNPG3 method and that there was no significant difference in the mean. Hence, we failed to reject the null hypothesis.
The Pearson correlation for the normalised data for both methods was 0.985, showing a very strong positive linear relation between the two methods. The p-value for the Pearson correlation between the normalised PCD data and the normalised standard data is approximately 5.11 × 10−5. The very small p-value indicates that the observed correlation is not due to random chance but because of the high accuracy of the PCD.
The 95% confidence interval for the Pearson correlation coefficient between the normalised PCD data and the normalised standard data is approximately [0.899, 0.998]. The interval further reinforces the strong positive correlation observed between the PCD's measurements and the standard, indicating that the developed PCD is likely to provide consistent and reliable results comparable to the standard.
For the test performed with the ABS, the PCD determined the concentration of the enzyme α-amylase with an accuracy of 95.54%. The R2 value achieved was 0.9905. Colour change by dissipation of blue colour to colourless was observed in all the concentrations of the enzyme with different distances in mm. The paired t-test and Pearson correlation also suggest the usability of this PCD as a method to determine α-amylase. This device is applicable in testing applications as a POC device.
One of the future aspects of this device is to replace this starch triiodide with other reagents based on colourimetry. Some of the reagents that can be used are based on nanotechnologies, such as copper/gold nanocluster peroxidase and chitosan-tripolyphosphate core coated with a starch–iodine shell.57,58
Although the elevation of the enzyme α-amylase in serum during pancreatitis is of a shorter duration (three days), it can still be utilised to diagnose the condition at the onset of symptoms. The developed PCD device is working effectively in determining α-amylase in ABS. The PCD developed is a working prototype and will be useful for testing α-amylase in the low-income region of the world where the incidents of acute pancreatitis.31 This PCD can be used in rural areas as a first-line test for screening pancreatitis, which can even be helpful in emergency medicine (provided the community healthcare centre is equipped with refrigerators). However, the PCD was tested using only ABS. The results of this PCD need to be validated with real samples prior to its clinical application.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ra03804e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |