Hiroaki
Shimomoto
*,
Takaya
Izumoto
,
Kazuki
Yamashita
,
Tomomichi
Itoh
and
Eiji
Ihara
*
Department of Applied Chemistry, Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Ehime University, 3 Bunkyo-cho, Matsuyama 790-8577, Japan. E-mail: shimomoto.hiroaki.mx@ehime-u.ac.jp; ihara@ehime-u.ac.jp; Fax: +81-89-927-9949; Fax: +81-89-927-8547; Tel: +81-89-927-9949 Tel: +81-89-927-8547
First published on 8th February 2024
Salicylaldiminate (SalAld)-ligated Pd complexes were generated by the reaction of SalAld with Pd(tfa)2 in THF, and their initiating ability for C1 polymerization of diazoacetate was investigated. When a mixture of a series of SalAlds and Pd(tfa)2 ([SalAld]/[Pd(tfa)2] = 2:
1–4
:
1) was employed for the polymerization of ethyl diazoacetate (EDA), polyEDA’ with a high number-average molar mass (Mn,SEC = 20000–35
000) was obtained in moderate yield; the polymer yield became highest (50%) when the polymerization was conducted with a [SalAld]/[Pd(tfa)2] ratio of 4
:
1 at 50 °C for 13 h. NMR analyses indicated that polyEDA’ had a syndiotactic-rich main chain stereo-structure. These results demonstrate that the SalAld/Pd(tfa)2 system is a new effective initiating system for the C1 polymerization of diazoacetate, which can be generated from a combination of ordinary reagents with facile procedures.
For the C1 polymerization of diazoacetate, transition metal initiators based on Rh and Pd have been demonstrated to be effective for preparing high molar mass polymers, even in a highly stereoselective manner in some cases.30–42 For example, Rh(diene)-based initiators can afford high number-average molar mass (Mn) polymers (Mn up to 200000) with high syndioselectivity,30–32 whereas some Pd-based initiating systems can afford atactic high Mn polymers (Mn of several tens of thousands) with a variety of ester substituents. In particular, we have succeeded in developing a series of initiating systems consisting of a combination of well-defined Pd complexes and NaBPh4: (NHC)Pd(nq)/NaBPh4 (NHC: N-heterocyclic carbene, nq: 1,4-naphthoquinone),33 π-allylPdCl/NaBPh4,34,39 and (nq)2Pd/NaBPh4.37 Although these Pd-based systems are indeed effective initiators for diazoacetate polymerization, in most cases, the active initiator should be generated at −78 °C under a strictly controlled N2 atmosphere with careful handling of the Pd precursor and NaBPh4. Therefore, initiating systems that can be generated from more ordinary reagents with more facile procedures are desired.
In that context, apart from the Pd-precursor complexes used for the reported polymerization, in this study we turned our attention to salicylaldiminate (SalAld)-ligated Pd complexes which can be generated in situ, because some SalAld-ligated transition metal complexes have been demonstrated to be extremely effective as highly active initiators for olefin polymerization.43–48 As described in this paper, while investigating the initiating behavior of a mixture of SalAld and some Pd precursors for diazoacetate polymerization, we have found that a certain mixture of the combination can indeed exhibit activity for the polymerization, yielding high Mn polymers in moderate yield. Although the identity of the actual active species of this system is not clear at present, it is advantageous that the active species can be generated by just mixing SalAld formed using NaH as a base and commercially available Pd(trifluoroacetate)2 [Pd(tfa)2] as a Pd precursor.
While we and other research groups have established that the presence of an η3-type anionic ligand on a Pd center is essential for the Pd-based system to have high initiating ability (Chart 1),34,36–40 the results in this study demonstrate that SalAld-ligated Pd complexes can be another type of platform for initiator generation. The results reported here show the promising potential of SalAld-ligated Pd complexes as highly active initiators for diazoacetate polymerization. The details of this SalAld/Pd(tfa)2 initiating system will be described in this paper.
The results using a variety of salicylaldimine, 1–7 and a related phenol 8 (Chart 2) are summarized in Table 1, where the neutral ligand precursor was first reacted with NaH in THF for 1 h at room temperature, and then the resulting SalAld was reacted with a Pd precursor for 3 h at room temperature, followed by the addition of 100 equiv. of EDA (CH2Cl2 solution, ca. 1–2 M) and polymerization for 13 h at room temperature. In this table, the [SalAld]/[Pd] ratio was fixed to 2:
1, because no polymerization occurred with the ratio of 1
:
1.
Run | Ligand precursor/base | Pd | Complexation | Polymerization | Yieldb (%) | M n,SECc | Đ | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Temp. | Time | Temp. | Time | ||||||
a Conditions: solvent = THF, [salicylaldimine]/[NaH]/[Pd(tfa)2] = 2.0![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|||||||||
1 | 1/NaH | Pd(OAc)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | Trace | ||
2 | 1/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 15 | 35![]() |
1.98 |
3 | 2/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 14 | 36![]() |
1.73 |
4 | 3/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 10 | 24![]() |
1.61 |
5 | 4/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 30 | 34![]() |
1.89 |
6 | 4/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 16 | 33![]() |
1.88 |
7 | 5/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 27 | 35![]() |
2.16 |
8 | 6/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 2.7 | 20![]() |
1.72 |
9 | 7/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 9.5 | 32![]() |
2.12 |
10 | 8/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 2.3 | 36![]() |
1.47 |
11 | None/none | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | No polymerization | ||
12 | 4/NaH | None | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | No polymerization | ||
13 | None/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | No polymerization | ||
14 | 4/none | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 3 h | RT | 13 h | No polymerization | ||
15 | (SalAld)2Pd (SalAld of 4) | — | — | RT | 13 h | No polymerization | |||
16 | 4/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | RT | 9 h | RT | 13 h | 35 | 31![]() |
1.75 |
17 | 4/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | −10 °C | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 6.6 | 22![]() |
2.72 |
18 | 4/NaH | Pd(tfa)2 | 50 °C | 3 h | RT | 13 h | 15 | 18![]() |
2.64 |
With the use of salicylaldimine 1 without any substituent on the two phenyl rings, the attempt for polymerization using Pd(OAc)2 as a Pd precursor afforded a trace of a polymeric product (run 1). On the other hand, the use of Pd(tfa)2 in place of Pd(OAc)2 under the same conditions yielded a high Mn polymer (SEC-estimated Mn,SEC = 35000) in a low yield of 15% (run 2). The results suggest that SalAld ligation on Pd(tfa)2 is more efficient than on Pd(OAc)2. Under the same conditions as that in run 2, a series of salicylaldimines 2–5 with different substitution modes on the two phenyl rings on the salicylaldimine framework were employed (runs 3–7); as a result, SalAld derived from 4 with 2,6-diisopropyl substitution on the aniline-derived ring afforded polyEDA’ in the highest yield of 30% (run 5), while the Mn,SECs of polyEDA's obtained with these SalAlds were in the range of 24
000–36
000, which is relatively high for polyEDA’ obtained with Pd-initiated polymerization (as described later, Mn determined with MALS (Mn,MALS) is 1.8 times higher than the Mn,SEC; thus, the number-average-degree of polymerization of polyEDA's typically obtained here exceeds 500). When the monomer concentration was increased from the standard value of 0.5 M to 1.3 M, the polymer yield decreased to 16% (run 6). The use of other solvents than THF, such as 1,4-dioxane, Et2O, and DMF failed to give polymers.
When 2,6-difluoroaniline derived salicylaldimines 6 and 7 were used, the polymer yield significantly decreased (runs 8 and 9), suggesting that electron donation from the aniline derived moiety is important for the high initiating ability. The use of an anion derived from sterically demanding phenol 8 in place of salicylaldimine with Pd(tfa)2 yielded polyEDA’ in a very low yield (run 10), indicating that the chelating coordination of O and N to Pd is essential for the initiating ability. We also confirmed that the reaction of EDA either with Pd(tfa)2 alone (run 11), SalAld 4 alone (run 12), or NaH/Pd(tfa)2 without salicylaldimine (run 13) did not afford a polymeric product. In addition, the reaction of EDA with a mixture of salicylaldimine 4 with Pd(tfa)2 in the absence of NaH (run 14) did not afford a polymeric product, indicating that SalAld is required for the generation of the active initiator. Furthermore, we newly prepared and isolated (SalAld)2Pd (SalAld: 4) by the reaction of salicylaldimine with Pd(OAc)2 in MeOH, following the reported procedures for the preparation of analogous complexes (see the ESI†),52,53 and examined the reactivity of this complex with EDA. As a result, no polymerization occurred as shown in run 15, indicating that the outcome of the reaction of the Na salt of salicylaldimine with Pd(tfa)2 in THF [the SalAld/Pd(tfa)2 system] is totally different from that of the reaction of salicylaldimine with Pd(OAc)2 in MeOH; in the former case, the presence of THF as a solvent and Na-tfa could play a crucial role in the generation of the active species for the EDA polymerization.
The above-described results suggest that even though the active species producing high Mn polymers was actually generated, the relative amount of the active species with respect to the Pd(tfa)2 employed was not enough to give polyEDA’ in a higher yield. Therefore, in order to improve the efficiency of initiator generation, the effect of the reaction conditions of SalAld with Pd(tfa)2 on the polymerization behavior was examined. When the reaction period was extended from 3 h to 9 h, the polymer yield slightly increased to 35% (run 16). The reactions at −10 °C and 50 °C were found to result in lower polymer yields of 6.6% (run 17) and 15% (run 18), respectively. These results indicate that the ligand substitution on Pd occurred at room temperature and the reaction for 3 h is almost enough for the generation of the initiator.
Run | [SalAld]/[Pd] | [EDA]/[Pd] | Polymerization | Yieldb (%) | M n,SECc | M n,MALSd | Đ | IEe (%) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Temp. | Period | ||||||||
a Conditions: solvent = THF, salicylaldimine = 4, [EDA]0 = 0.5 M; EDA was used as a CH2Cl2 solution with a concentration of 1.3–3.2 M. b After purification with preparative SEC to remove oligomers. c Determined by SEC using PMMA standards. d Determined by SEC-MALS. e Calculated based on the polymer yield and Mn,SEC. f The same data as those in run 6. | |||||||||
1 | 2 | 100 | RT | 13 h | 30 | 34![]() |
1.89 | 7.6 | |
2 | 3 | 100 | RT | 13 h | 30 | 36![]() |
1.69 | 7.2 | |
3 | 4 | 100 | RT | 13 h | 25 | 29![]() |
1.93 | 7.4 | |
4 | 2 | 100 | 50 °C | 13 h | 22 | 25![]() |
1.91 | 7.6 | |
5 | 3 | 100 | 50 °C | 13 h | 39 | 31![]() |
2.01 | 11 | |
6 | 4 | 100 | 50 °C | 13 h | 50 | 25![]() |
45![]() |
1.85 | 17 |
7 | 4 | 50 | 50 °C | 13 h | 44 | 22![]() |
2.02 | 8.6 | |
8f | 4 | 100 | 50 °C | 13 h | 50 | 25![]() |
45![]() |
1.85 | 17 |
9 | 4 | 200 | 50 °C | 13 h | 25 | 27![]() |
2.45 | 15 | |
10 | 4 | 300 | 50 °C | 13 h | 27 | 28![]() |
2.50 | 26 | |
11 | 4 | 100 | 50 °C | 1 h | 18 | 30![]() |
1.47 | 5.2 | |
12 | 4 | 100 | 50 °C | 3 h | 32 | 26![]() |
1.92 | 11 | |
13f | 4 | 100 | 50 °C | 13 h | 50 | 25![]() |
45![]() |
1.85 | 17 |
Then, using the optimized conditions of [SalAld]/[Pd(tfa)2] = 4:
1 at 50 °C, the polymerization of EDA was conducted with a series of feed ratios of [EDA]/[Pd] from 50 to 300 as listed in runs 7–10. Regardless of the feed ratio, the Mn,SEC of the product remains in a certain range of 20
000–30
000, and the apparent initiation efficiency (IE) of Pd(tfa)2 based on the polymer yield and Mn,SEC has an increasing trend with the feed ratio. In addition, when the polymerization was intentionally terminated after 1 and 3 h, it was found that regardless of the reaction period, Mn,SEC reached the range of 20
000–30
000, and a gradual increase in the polymer yield and IE was observed. These results suggest that the initiating species were gradually and continuously generated for a period of several hours, and once the initiation started, the propagation rapidly ensued until completion as typically observed in the conventional radical polymerization of vinyl monomers.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 1H and 13C NMR spectra of the polyEDA's obtained with SalAld/Pd(tfa)2, (cod)PdCl(Cl-naphthoquinonyl)/NaBPh4, and (nq)2Pd/NaBPh4 systems. |
Run | Monomer | Yieldb, % | M n,SECc | Đ |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Conditions: solvent = THF, salicylaldimine = 4, [monomer]0 = 0.5 M, [monomer]0/[Pd] = 100; MDA was used as a CH2Cl2 solution with a concentration of 1.86 M. b After purification with preparative SEC to remove oligomers. c Determined by SEC using PMMA standards. | ||||
1 | MDA | 27 | 23![]() |
1.56 |
2 | BDA | 2.7 | 9300 | 2.1 |
3 | cHDA | 4.6 | 21![]() |
4.6 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental section and supplementary figures. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3py01426f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |