Open Access Article
Giovanni
Ricci
*a,
Antonella Caterina
Boccia
a,
Benedetta
Palucci
a,
Anna
Sommazzi
b,
Francesco
Masi
c,
Miriam
Scoti
d,
Fabio
De Stefano
d and
Claudio
De Rosa
d
aCNR-Istituto di Scienze e Tecnologie Chimiche “Giulio Natta” (SCITEC), via A. Corti 12, I-20133 Milano, Italy. E-mail: giovanni.ricci@scitec.cnr.it
bScientific Advisor, Viale Giovanni XXIII 34, I-28100 Novara, NO, Italy
cScientific Advisor, Via Galvani 7, I-26866 Sant'Angelo Lodigiano, LO, Italy
dDipartimento di Scienze Chimiche, Università di Napoli Federico II, Complesso Monte S.Angelo, Via Cintia, I-80126, Napoli, Italy
First published on 21st February 2024
β-Myrcene was polymerized with catalysts based on pyridyl-imino complexes of neodymium, iron and copper. Highly stereoregular polymers were obtained: in particular, the neodymium-based catalyst gave highly cis-1,4 polymers (≥97%), while iron and copper catalysts gave a quite unusual structure in the field of stereospecific polymerization, that is, a predominantly alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 polymer containing cis-1,4 unit (five units) sequences within the polymer chain. Structural, thermal and mechanical characterization of the obtained polymers was carried out.
In this context, on the basis of the experience previously acquired in the field of the polymerization of conjugated dienes with iron-,1–4 copper-5,6 and neodymium-based catalytic systems,3,7 we have now examined the polymerization of β-myrcene with catalysts based on pyridyl-imino complexes of neodymium, iron and copper.
β-Myrcene is a member of the large family of terpenes, which, due to its structural similarity to isoprene (I) and butadiene (B) and large availability, has recently attracted growing attention as a building block for the synthesis of a vast range of polymers, including the elastomer synthesis: polymers having cis-1,4, trans-1,4 and 3,4 structures have already been obtained and characterized (Fig. 1).8–25
Highly stereoregular poly(myrcene)s, exhibiting somewhat unusual structures as regards the field of conjugated diene polymerization, were obtained, and their synthesis and characterization are reported in the present paper.
Details of the characterization of the structure by X-ray diffraction and calorimetry and the analysis of the mechanical properties are reported in the ESI.†
Poly(myrcene) with a rather high molecular weight, narrow polydispersion and extremely high cis-1,4 content (around 97%) was obtained, as shown by their FT-IR (Fig. SI_1†), 1H (Fig. SI_2†) and 13C NMR spectra (Fig. SI_3† and Fig. 4) (Table 1). The glass transition temperature was about −60 °C, quite similar to that of natural rubber. The catalyst activity was rather low, although complete monomer conversions could be achieved.
| Entry | Mt_complex (μmol) | Al_type | Al/Mt | Time (h) | Yield (g) | Conv. % | cis-1,4b (%) | 3,4b (%) |
M
w c (kg mol–1) |
M
w/Mn c |
T
g d (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Polymerization conditions: toluene as solvent (heptane in entry 1), total volume 16 mL; myrcene, 2 mL; 22 °C. b Percentage of cis-1,4, and 3,4 units determined by 1H and 13C NMR. c Average molecular weight (Mw, in kg mol−1) and molecular weight distribution (Mw/Mn) by SEC. d Glass transition temperature (Tg) by DSC. | |||||||||||
| 1 | Nd1 (10) | TIBAO | 1000 | 46 | 1.39 | 87.9 | 97 | 3 | 319 | 2.4 | −65 |
| 2 | Fe1 (10) | MAO | 100 | 1/4 | 1.17 | 74.0 | 68 | 32 | 109.6 | 2.0 | −57 |
| 3 | Cu1 (20) | MAO | 500 | 48 | 0.59 | 37.3 | 67 | 33 | 261.8 | 2.0 | −56 |
:
32) structure (Fig. SI_1, SI_2, and SI_3†) was obtained, with the iron system exhibiting extremely high activity (Table 1), much higher with respect to that exhibited by the neodymium system. The polymer molecular weight was around 110
kg × mol−1 with a polydispersion of 2, and the glass transition temperature (Tg) was about −57 °C. The distribution mode of the cis-1,4 and 3,4 units along the polymeric chain turned out to be quite regular but at the same time rather unusual for the stereospecific polymerization field. The poly(myrcene) obtained with the Fe1-based catalyst was in fact characterized by an alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 structure in which, however, long cis-1,4 unit sequences (five units) can be detected within the polymer chain (Fig. 3), as suggested by the NMR (1H, 13C and 2D) analysis of the polymer reported below in the Polymer characterization section.
000 g × mol−1 with a polydispersion of 2, and the glass transition temperature (Tg) was about −56 °C. The activity of the copper system resulted to be much lower with respect to that of the iron system, and this could be attributed to the different structures of the active centers in the case of iron and copper, as shown below in section 3.7.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Assignment of the peaks in the 13C NMR spectra of Nd-polymyrcenes (in red) and Fe-polymyrcenes (in black). | ||
The polymer microstructure was deeply investigated through two-dimensional 1H–13C HMBC experiments, (heteronuclear multiple bond correlation in Fig. SI_5†) and crucial were the long-term correlations among protons and carbons. In detail, carbon atoms from C7 to C10 have the same chemical shifts for both 3,4- and cis-1,4 myrcene units, independent of the comonomer sequences (see Fig. 4). They were assigned starting from the 1H–13C long-term correlations of methyl groups shown in Fig. SI_5,† as follows: C9 at 15.70 ppm; C10 at 23.54 ppm; C7 at 122.88–122.92 ppm; C8 at 128.98–129.17 ppm. Assignment of the 3,4 unit carbons was done in the same way, but starting from the correlations of the olefinic H1 protons at 4.67 ppm (Fig. 5 and Fig. SI_6†), which are as follows: C1 at 107.05 ppm; C2 at 150.72 ppm; C3 at 42.96 ppm; C5 at 32.15 ppm. It is evident that only one signal was observed for each of the two olefin carbons of a myrcene unit having a 3,4 structure, indicating that the 3,4 unit experiences only one type of environment. Finally, to complete the assignment of the 3,4 myrcene unit, C4 was positioned at 34.28 ppm and C6 at 26.5–26.30 ppm.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Expanded spectral region of 1H–13C HMBC of poly(myrcene) obtained with the Fe-based catalyst, @600 MHz and 330 K, evidencing peculiar correlations. | ||
Apart from this first quite easy assignment, the remaining carbon atoms were assigned step by step due to the complex pattern of almost superimposed signals from Fig. SI_5.† C3 of a cis-1,4 unit (I) involved in an alternating 3,4-(cis-1,4)-3,4 sequence was assigned at 124.40 ppm; C3 of a cis 1,4 unit (IV) at 124.48 ppm; C3 (III) at 124.1 and C3 (II) at 123.3 ppm. The differentiation among the olefinic CH atoms (C3 and all the C7 in the spectral region between 122 and 125 ppm) was made considering the absence of correlations in Fig. SI_6† between C3 and the protons of the methyl groups (C9 and C10). Moving on to the assignment of the cis-1,4 units, C2 (I) was assigned at 135.91 ppm, C2 (III) at 136.16 ppm, C2 (IV) at 137.38 ppm and C2 (II) at 137.59 ppm, while the C5 of all units was positioned between 25.46 and 25.38 ppm. The C1 of cis-1,4 units (II) was assigned at 35.04 ppm; C1 (IV) at 35.21 ppm, and C1 (I) and (III) at 35.26 ppm. Once the chemical shift of C1 and its protons was known, the (cis-1,4)-3,4 sequence was verified by observing the presence of a correlation among the H1 protons of the cis-1,4 unit (at 1.86 ppm) with the C2 of the 3,4-unit at 150.72 ppm and with the C3 at 42.96 ppm (Fig. SI_5†). After all, for the assignment of comonomer sequences, the proton spectral region between 4.9 and 5.1 ppm in the HMBC spectrum (Fig. 5) played a crucial role, even if it was very hard to solve considering that at 0.15 ppm, four protons can be found (H7 for both 3,4- and 1,4-myrcene units and H3 for the 1,4-myrcene units involved in (I), (II), (III), and (IV) sequences, correlating with more than 12 carbons in the F1 dimension).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 X-ray powder diffraction profiles of the as-prepared (A) and compression-molded (B) samples of poly(myrcene)s of entry 1 (a), entry 2 (b) and entry 3 (c) of Table 1 prepared with the catalysts Nd1, Fe1 and Cu1, respectively. | ||
The DSC curves of the amorphous as-prepared samples of poly(myrcene)s recorded during heating of the as-prepared samples up to 120 °C, cooling down to −100 °C and successive second heating are shown in Fig. 7. All curves show only a glass transition temperature at low temperature (lower than −50 °C) and the absence of any endothermic or exothermic signals. The exact values of the glass transition temperature have been evaluated in the DSC cooling and successive heating curves recorded at the same scanning rates to avoid hysteresis phenomena (Fig. 7 and Table 1). The value of glass transition temperature depends on the molecular structure and, in particular, on the concentration of cis-1,4 units, and decreases with increasing concentrations of cis-1,4 units. Samples of entries 2 and 3 with 67–68% of cis-1,4 units and characterized by prevalent alternating cis-1,4/3,4 structures, prepared with iron- and copper-based catalysts, show a glass transition temperature of −56/−57 °C, while the sample of entry 1 with 97% of cis-1,4 units prepared with a neodymium-based catalyst shows the lowest glass transition temperature of about −65 °C.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 Stress–strain curves of compression molded films of samples of poly(myrcene)s of entry 1 (a), entry 2 (b) and entry 3 (c) of Table 1, prepared with the catalysts Nd1, Fe1 and Cu1, respectively. | ||
| Entry | Mt | cis-1,4 (%) | 3,4 (%) | M w (kg mol−1) | M w/Mn |
T
g a (°C) |
E (MPa) | ε b (%) | σ b (MPa) | σ b(max) (MPa) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Glass transition temperature evaluated from the DSC heating curves of Fig. 7C recorded at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1. | ||||||||||
| 1 | Nd | 97 | 3 | 319 | 2.4 | −65 | 0.21 ± 0.02 | 700 ± 150 | 0.02 ± 0.01 | 0.08 ± 0.03 |
| 2 | Fe | 68 | 32 | 109.6 | 2.0 | −57 | 0.42 ± 0.04 | 361 ± 97 | 0.09 ± 0.03 | 0.15 ± 0.02 |
| 3 | Cu | 67 | 33 | 261.8 | 2.0 | −56 | 0.62 ± 0.01 | 240 ± 70 | 0.12 ± 0.03 | 0.21 ± 0.02 |
(a) Fe1/MAO and Cu1/MAO give (i) essentially alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 polymers, in which, however, long cis-1,4 sequences (5 units) are present within the polymer chain, from myrcene; (ii) essentially alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 polymers, in which, however, short cis-1,4 sequences (3 units) are present within the polymer chain, from isoprene;3,4 (iii) predominantly syndiotactic 1,2 polymers from butadiene,3,4 with some cis-1,4 units randomly distributed along the polymer chain. This experimental evidence confirms once more the importance of the monomer structure, and also indeed of the last units of the growing chain, in determining the polymerization selectivity.2,3,26
(b) What is stated above, however, is not always true, since Nd1/TIBAO invariably supplies high cis polymers from butadiene, isoprene and myrcene. This means that the polymer microstructure is always the result of the combination of two main factors, namely the catalytic structure and the monomer structure; sometimes one of the two factors may clearly prevail, making the influence of the other factor practically negligible. In the case of the polymerization of myrcene with the Nd-catalyst, the polymerization mechanism is likely the classical one already reported for other dienes (Fig. 9), with the monomer cis-η4 coordinated to the Nd atom, the growing chain bonded to the Nd-atom through an anti-η3-allyl bond and the insertion of the incoming monomer onto the C3 of the anti η3-allyl unit giving rise to a cis-1,4 unit.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 Scheme of the formation of cis-1,4 units in the polymerization of myrcene with the Nd-based catalyst. | ||
(c) We have said above that a rather unusual polymer structure was obtained from β-myrcene with the iron- and copper-based catalysts. In our previous paper,4 we reported on the polymerization of isoprene with the same iron-based catalyst to give a polymer having a similar structure, that is, an essentially alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 polymer, in which short cis-1,4 sequences (3 units) are present within the polymer chain. We had also proposed a possible mechanism for the formation of such an unusual polymer, and we now believe that such a mechanism (Fig. 10) can be re-proposed to account for the formation of a poly(myrcene) having an essentially alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 structure, in which, however, long cis-1,4 sequences (5 units) are present within the polymer chain. This scheme of mechanism illustrates, in our opinion, in a plausible way, the subsequent coordination and insertion of myrcene that can lead to the formation of the polymer described in the present paper, even if we realize it does not clarify the reason for the formation of these monomeric sequences (10 units) so regular as to constitute the repeating unit of the polymer itself. In this regard, computational studies could perhaps be of great help.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 A possible formation mechanism for the predominantly alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 poly(myrcene) containing long cis-1,4 sequences (five units) within the polymer chain. | ||
(d) The catalytic activity of the iron system is much higher than that of the copper system. A plausible explanation for such a difference could be the following: in the case of the iron-based catalyst, the structure of the active center is likely that shown in Fig. 11(a), with the ligand coordinated to the iron atom, the diene cis-η4 coordinated and the growing chain linked to the metal atom through an allyl bond. Such a structure is not possible in the case of the copper-based system, as we would have three electrons in excess of those allowed according to the 18 electron rule.
As already reported in our previous work, we can hypothesize different structures for the catalytic center in the case of the copper catalyst, as shown in Fig. 11(b) and (c).
Myrcene can coordinate cis-η4 with both double bonds, but, in this case, the ligand must have migrated entirely on methylaluminoxane (Fig. 11c), or it can coordinate with only one double bond (trans-η2), and in this case, the ligand can remain coordinated to the copper atom with only one donor atom (Fig. 11b).
A sort of equilibrium can be hypothesized between form (b), with the monomer trans-η2 coordinated and the ligand coordinated with only one nitrogen atom, and form (c), with the monomer cis-η4 coordinated and the ligand onto MAO, with the formation of 1,2 (3,4) units (form (b), through insertion of the incoming monomer to the C3 of the allyl group) rather than cis-1,4 (form (c), through insertion of the incoming monomer to the C1 of the allyl group) depending on whether the equilibrium is more shifted towards form (b) or form (c), respectively.
The formation of these active centers with different structures and the oscillation between forms (b) and (c) could be responsible for a lower rate of polymerization, such as to justify the considerable difference in the catalytic activity between iron- and copper-based systems. However, the fact that catalytic centers with different structures (in the case of iron- and copper-based catalysts) can supply the same polymer would seem to indicate that in this case the determining factor of the polymerization stereoselectivity is likely the monomer structure.
In particular, highly cis-1,4 polymers have been obtained with neodymium-based systems, while polymers having a rather unusual structure as regards the stereospecific polymerization of conjugated dienes, that is, a mainly alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 structure, but with regular cis-1,4 sequences (5 units) along the polymer chain, were obtained by means of iron and copper catalysts. The polymers have generally high molecular weights and glass transition temperature values of around −60 °C, similar to those of natural rubber, which makes them of potential interest for possible use as elastomers.
The polymers are amorphous, despite the high degree of stereoregularity exhibited, as indicated by NMR analysis. The lack of crystallinity is probably due to the presence of rather long pendants/side chains even in a rather regular molecular structure that prevents crystallization. In fact, either the sample with a prevalent cis-1,4 structure prepared with Nd1 or the samples with prevalent alternating cis-1,4-alt-3,4 structures and long sequences of cis-1,4 units prepared with Fe1 and Cu1 present long pendant chains even in the regular cis-1,4 units that prevent crystallization.
As a consequence, the samples show the mechanical behavior of soft materials with uniform deformation without evident yielding up to achieve maximum values of stress at deformations in the range 200–400%. At higher deformations, the samples experience viscous flow without breaking up to 600–800% strain.
Finally, the different behaviors exhibited by the Fe1/MAO and Cu1/MAO systems towards butadiene, isoprene and myrcene represent a further confirmation of the remarkable influence of the monomer structure on the polymerization selectivity.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3py01309j |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |