Alexandra A.
Vidyakina
a,
Sergey A.
Silonov
ab,
Anastasia I.
Govdi
a,
Alexander Yu.
Ivanov
c,
Ekaterina P.
Podolskaya
d,
Irina A.
Balova
a,
Stefan
Bräse
*ef and
Natalia A.
Danilkina
*a
aInstitute of Chemistry, Saint Petersburg State University (SPbU), Saint Petersburg, 199034, Russia. E-mail: n.danilkina@spbu.ru
bLaboratory of Structural Dynamics, Stability and Folding of Proteins, Institute of Cytology, Russian Academy of Sciences, 194064, Russia
cCenter for Magnetic Resonance, Research Park, Saint Petersburg State University (SPbU), Saint Petersburg, 199034, Russia
dInstitute of Analytical Instrumentation RAS, 190103 St. Petersburg, Russia
eInstitute of Organic Chemistry (IOC), Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: stefan.braese@kit.edu
fInstitute of Biological and Chemical Systems – Functional Molecular Systems (IBCS-FMS), Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), 76344 Eggenstein-Leopoldshafen, Germany
First published on 3rd July 2024
Conjugates of benzothiophene-fused azacyclononyne BT9N-NH2 with fluorescent dyes were developed to visualise azidoglycans intracellularly. The significance of the cycloalkyne core was demonstrated by comparing new reagents with DBCO- and BCN-dye conjugates. To reduce non-specificity during intracellular bioconjugation using SPAAC, less reactive BT9N-dye reagents are preferred over highly reactive DBCO- and BCN-dye conjugates.
SPAAC visualisation typically involves two steps. The first step is aimed at incorporating azido groups into the biosystem either through metabolic labelling,26i.e., cell culturing in the presence of unnatural azido monomers, or using organic azides with “directing” groups for specific organelles, such as mitochondria, lysosomes, Golgi apparatus, without metabolic incorporation into biopolymers.27,28 The second step involves the SPAAC reaction between the N3-containing cell compartments and a cycloalkyne reagent conjugated with a fluorescent dye.
Depending on the studied N3-labelled biological target, the cycloalkyne dye reagent should be able to reach the desired cell compartments. When labelling cell surface glycoproteins, it is important to use SPAAC active cycloalkyne reagents that cannot penetrate the cell membrane well to avoid nonspecific intracellular interactions. A dye with polar anionic groups, e.g., from the sulfocyanine family, should be attached to the reactive cycloalkyne core to achieve this property.23,29 To study intracellular N3-labelled biomolecules, the reagent must effectively penetrate the cell membrane.30,31 To achieve this, a lipophilic dye component without any polar anionic groups, commonly different BODIPY derivatives, or other32 should be conjugated with the alkyne. Therefore, nowadays, different companies offer several SPAAC reagents conjugated to dyes of different natures.
Although a wide variety of cycloalkynes with different SPAAC reactivity and other properties have been developed,33–36 the cycloalkyne nature is often overlooked and not taken into account in the case of intracellular biovisualisation. The choice of alkyne moieties in the commercially available cycloalkyne-dye reagents is limited to the most commonly used commercial conjugates with highly SPAAC-reactive DBCO (ADIBO, DIBAC)37 or BCN38 cycloalkyne scaffolds (Fig. 1A), which were originally developed as cell-surface labelling reagents.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Structures of known DBCO- and BCN-based BDP FL reagents and new BT9N-BDP FL dye conjugates studied in this work; k – SPAAC rate constant for BnN3, M−1 s−1. |
However, neglecting the cycloalkane nature, especially when intracellular staining of metabolically labelled compartments is involved, can lead to a high nonspecific fluorescence response due to the known reactivity of BCN and DBCO towards thiols (such as cysteine residues and glutathione)39 and sulfenic acids,40–42 which are common in biosystems.
Therefore, here we study the development of new reagents for efficient intracellular labelling, paying major attention to the cycloalkyne's nature. We synthesized a cycloalkyne-BODIPY-FL conjugate BT9N-BDP FL (Fig. 1B), an analogue of BT9NTs43 (Fig. 1A), and compare its efficiency and specificity for the intracellular labelling with other BODIPY-FL cycloalkyne reagents having more reactive in SPAAC DBCO and BCN alkyne cores (Fig. 1B). We demonstrated that for the visualisation of intracellular N3-glycoconjugates the nature of cycloalkyne is dramatically important. The designed BT9N-BDP FL reagent and its triazole-conjugated analogue BT9N-Tr have an advantage over DBCO-BDP FL and BCN-BDP FL, which showed significantly higher nonspecific affinity towards the intracellular environment.
The prototype of the BT9N-BDP FL conjugate is the BT9NTs cycloalkyne from heterocycle-fused heterocycloalkyne family (Fig. 1), which has been discovered recently43,44 using a combination of the “reagent destabilisation” and the “SPAAC transition state stabilisation” approaches.11BT9NTs possess the highest SPAAC reactivity within this group, but it is unsuitable for conjugation with a dye because the molecule lacks any reactive functionalities. To synthesise the BT9N-BDP FL conjugate, we decide to replace the Ts group with 4-aminobenzenesulfonamide (As) moiety and use the NH2 group of BT9N-NH2 as a site for functionalisation with a BDP FL dye.
The starting material chosen was 4-nitro-N-(pent-4-yn-1-yl)benzenesulfonamide (S1). The synthetic route for BT9N-NH2 is similar to that for BT9NTs43 and consists of three main steps: the Sonogashira cross-coupling, electrophile-promoted cyclisation and the Nicholas cyclisation (Scheme 1). The main question was at what stage the nitro group should be reduced. First, we decided to reduce NO2 at the last stage under conditions that tolerated up to a triple bond45 and obtain the nitroalkyne BT9N-NO2via pathway A (Scheme 1, path A). However, due to its instability, the cycloalkyne BT9N-NO2 without the Co-protecting group was only isolated in a 9% yield. To overcome this problem, we moved the NO2 reduction step to an earlier stage and tried the Nicholas cyclisation for the NH2 derivative 7 (Scheme 1, path B). Although the Nicholas reaction for NH2-containing compounds does not go well,46 to our delight, this reaction for the amino Co-complex 7 gave the desired cyclic product 8 in high yield without forming any by-products. Complex 8 can be obtained even in higher yield using Co-complexation/Nicholas cyclisation in one pot. Cycloalkyne BT9N-NH2 obtained by deprotection of complex 8 showed excellent stability under isolation, storage and heating at 50 °C for 24 hours in CD3CN.
We then turned to the synthesis of the BT9N-BDP FL conjugate. However, 4-aminobenzenesulfonamide moiety was inert towards electrophilic agents, e.g. isothiocyanates, anhydrides and carboxylic acids with coupling reagents (ESI, section 2.3‡). Finally, we found that BT9N-NH2 could be modified by acylation with acetyl chloride (ESI, 2.3.2‡). Therefore, BDP FL acid chloride47 was used to synthesise BT9N-BDP FL under optimised conditions (Scheme 2) (ESI, section 2.2‡).
The synthesis of another example of the BT9N SPAAC reagent, BT9N-Tr (Scheme 2), followed the same procedure. This reagent was examined as an additional BT9N-dye conjugate with a non-commercial lypophilic dye belonging to a pull-push triazole family.48 This would demonstrate the importance of the cycloalkyne nature for intracellular biovisualisation, irrespective of a lipophilic dye core. BCN-BDP FL was synthesised using commercially available BCN-NH2 and BDP FL NHS ester (ESI, section 2.2‡). The DBCO-BDP FL conjugate was obtained from Lumiprobe, a commercial supplier.
Using four different cycloalkyne reagents (BT9N-BDP FL, BT9N-Tr, BCN-BDP FL and DBCO-BDP FL), we performed biological studies to demonstrate the importance of the cycloalkyne core in the intracellular visualisation of metabolically labelled azido glycans. Before the studies, the cytotoxicity of all compounds was evaluated using HeLa and HEK293 cell lines (ESI, Fig. S1‡). All reagents were nontoxic under concentration of 1 μM, which was used for all further bioimaging assays.
Three different azidosugars were studied: Ac4ManNAz (tetraacetylated N-azidoacetyl-mannosamine) was used as a sugar known to be the component of sialic acid found on the cell surface, Ac4GalNAz (tetraacetylated N-azidoacetyl-galactosamine) was used a source of mucin O-linked glycosylation for both cell surface and intracellular glycans and Ac4GlcNAz (tetraacetylated N-azidoacetyl-glucosamine) was used for mostly intracellular labelling.13,27,49
HeLa cells were treated with the corresponding acylated N3-sugar for 72 hours. Subsequently, they were stained with the corresponding cycloalkyne-dye conjugate for 4 hours (Fig. 2A). To control the distribution of each azidosugar on the cell surface, two DBCO reagents were used: one conjugated with fluorescein dye (DBCO-F) and the other with Sulfocyanine 5 dye (DBCO-SCy5) (Fig. 2B and C).
The data obtained revealed that both BT9N-dye conjugates, BT9N-BDP FL and BT9N-Tr, demonstrate significantly higher specificity in N3-dependent intracellular labelling of Ac4GalNAz and Ac4GlcNAz treated cells compared to BCN-BDP FL and DBCO-BDP FL. These two latter conjugates displayed serious nonspecific labelling in non-treated control cells (for a quantitative comparison of the fluorescent response, refer to the ESI, Fig. S2‡). Furthermore, only weak fluorescence was observed in Ac4ManNAz metabolically labelled cells for both BT9N conjugates, which confirms the known cell-surface localisation of the deacylated mannosamine. The significantly stronger intracellular fluorescence observed in Ac4ManNAz treated cells for BCN-BDP FL and DBCO-BDP FL is likely due to the nonspecific binding of alkyne-dye conjugates with the intracellular environment.
It is interesting to note that DBCO-BDP FL exhibited greater nonspecific intracellular labelling compared to BCN-BDP FL, which is consistent with the general reactivity of DBCO.37,50
The nonspecific behaviour of DBCO and BCN reagents in cells is more likely due to their high reactivity not only in SPAAC but also with other “alkynophiles” present in the biological environment, such as the –SH and –SOH groups of proteins.
Thus it has been shown, that BCN and DBCO can react with peptidylcysteines, which is the reason of azide-independent labeling and that it can be diminished by iodoacetamide alkylation of thioles.39 Moreover the reactivity of BCN and DBCO towards sulfenic acids has been also proved.40–42
We have recently reported that the prototype of BT9N-based dyes, a cycloalkyne BT9NTs, does not react with t-BuSH in CD3CN even at 37 °C for 24 h.43 To demonstrate that cycloalkyne-dye reagents BT9N-BDP FL and BT9N-Tr are less reactive than DBCO and BCN dyes towards SH-containing biospecies, we conducted a study investigating the behavior of all four compounds towards glutathione (GSH) and human globin using MALDI TOF mass spectrometry (for details see ESI, section 5‡).51 It was estimated that DBCO and BCN dyes form adducts with human globin (alpha and beta subunits) after 3 hours of incubation at 37 °C (pH = 7.2), while BT9N-dyes do not react with the protein. Furthermore, we identified mono- and bis-adducts of DBCO and a monoadduct of BCN with GSH using 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid (DHB) and α-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid (CHCA) as a matrix for MALDI spectra. In the case of BT9N-BDP FL, only a monoadduct was identified using the DHB matrix, whereas no adducts were observed for BT9N-Tr in both matrices. Therefore, our findings indicate that less SPAAC reactive cycloalkyne-dye conjugates, based on BT9N, display increased tolerance towards endogenous thiol species in comparison with more active DBCO and BCN derivatives.
To demonstrate the pivotal role of selecting of the optimal cycloalkyne as a component of a cycloalkyne-dye reagent in achieving the desired outcomes of a study, we conducted double labelling experiments (Fig. 3).
In order to label intracellular and cell surface glycans in a single metabolic labelling experiment, either Ac4GalNAz or both Ac4ManNAz and Ac4GlcNAz were employed in the metabolic labelling of HeLa (Fig. 3A) and HEK293 (Fig. 3B) cell lines. BT9N-BDP FL and DBCO-SCy5 were used in order to simultaneously visualise intracellular and surface N3-glycans in green and red channels, respectively. The merged images for both cell lines in every case demonstrated that BT9N-BDP FL is an effective reagent for visualising intracellular azidoglycans (N3-glucose and intracellular N3-galactose), while DBCO-SCy5 is a reagent of choice for visualising cell surface glycans (N3-mannose and cell surface N3-galactose). It is of paramount importance that both reagents act orthogonally and can be employed for the labelling of corresponding glycans during a single double-labelling experiment.
Footnotes |
† Dedicated to the 300th anniversary of the Saint Petersburg University foundation. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: All synthetic and biological details, copies of NMR spectra. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ob01032a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |