Rahul Ghosh
Dastidar
a,
Takuya
Okamoto
*ab,
Kiyonori
Takahashi
ab,
Yuta
Takano
ab,
Chakkooth
Vijayakumar
cd,
Challapalli
Subrahmanyam
e and
Vasudevanpillai
Biju
*abe
aGraduate School of Environmental Science, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Hokkaido 060-0810, Japan. E-mail: okamotot@es.hokudai.ac.jp; biju@es.hokudai.ac.jp
bResearch Institute for Electronic Science, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Hokkaido, 001-0020 Japan
cChemical Sciences and Technology Division, CSIR-National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology (NIIST), Thiruvananthapuram 695 019, India
dAcademy of Scientific and Innovative Research (AcSIR), Ghaziabad 201 002, India
eIndian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Kandi, Telangana 502285, India
First published on 16th January 2024
Zero-dimensional hybrid copper(I) halides (HCHs) are attractive due to their interesting photoluminescence (PL) properties and the high abundance and low toxicity of copper. In this study, we report green–red dual emission from rhombic 1-butyl-1-methyl piperidinium copper bromide [(Bmpip)2Cu2Br4] microcrystals (MCs) prepared on borosilicate glass. The structure and elemental composition of the MCs are characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis, scanning electron microscopy, and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. Interestingly, MCs prepared on an ITO-coated glass plate show an intense green emission compared to the dual emission on a bare glass or plastic substrate. Furthermore, the intensity of the green emission from the MC is enormously increased by powdering using a conductive material, suggesting the deactivation of the red-emitting state by a charge transfer interaction with the conductor. These findings open a new strategy to suppress the self-trapping of excitons by longitudinal optical phonons and control the dual emitting states in HCHs.
Due to the d10 configuration of the Cu(I) ion, HCHs form various structures and comprise different compositions.20 The PL properties of HCHs are controlled by their dimensionality related to the connectivity between the inorganic motifs rather than the crystal morphology or particle size. Several HCH materials have been investigated to correlate the structure, chemical composition, and dimension with optical properties.8–10,13–18,21–31 For instance, Xu et al. synthesized zero-dimensional HCHs, namely 1-butyl-1-methyl piperidinium copper bromide [(Bmpip)2Cu2Br4], showing a broad orange emission with a large Stokes shift.17 Peng et al. reported three different zero-dimensional HCHs, (C4H9)4NCuCl2 (508 nm),21 (CH3NH3)4Cu2Br6 (524 nm),22 and (Gua)3Cu2I5 (481 nm),23 showing broadband emissions with large Stokes shifts. These optical properties result from self-tapped exciton (STE) states. Also, a few examples of one- and two-dimensional HCHs have been reported.8,9,11 Several HCHs show dual emission from two different excited states.24–28 Fu et al. reported two hybrid Cu(I) iodides showing broadband emission attributed to triplet and STE states.24 Lian et al. reported dual emission of C16H36NCuI2 single crystals and correlated the temperature-dependent STE state populations with the thermal activation energy of the STEs.25 The STE states of tetrabutylammonium (TBA) copper iodides [(TBA)2Cu2I4] are discussed with the electron–phonon coupling and multi-phonon modes.26,27 Recently, Wang et al. demonstrated temperature-dependent dual emission from (C4H12N2)Cu2Br4 single crystals.28 These single crystals show bright blue emission at high temperatures whereas at low temperatures (<100 K) they show two different STE state emissions (460 nm and 605 nm) due to increased lattice distortion. The mechanical modulation of the STE states is also reported.29,30 Bentio et al. found a mechanochromic luminescence of phosphine-based [Cu4I4] cluster polymorphic crystals.29 Wu et al. demonstrated multi-stimuli responsive luminescence of (CN3H6)3Cu2I5 crystals.30 Although modulating the STE emission from HCHs is important for PL band broadening and optical switching, the methods to control it are still limited to those using heat and mechanical force.
Here, we report the modulation of dual-color emission from solution-processed (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 microcrystals (MCs) interacting with an insulating or conducting surface under blue light excitation (ca. 400 nm). The optical microscopy images show rhombic MCs with edge lengths of ca. 200 μm. Single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) results suggest that the MCs exhibit an orthorhombic phase.17 The MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate show green (ca. 540 nm)–red (ca. 620 nm) dual emission under blue light excitation (404–405 nm). Interestingly, the MCs prepared on an ITO-coated glass plate show an intense green emission compared to red emission. Both MCs show similar PL excitation (PLE) spectra and homogeneous distribution of Cu and Br with a stoichiometric ratio of Br/Cu = 2. When broken using a stainless-steel spatula, the MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate also showed an intense green emission. Such dual emission and changes to the emission color point towards modification of the electronic structure of the band edge. We discuss the origin of the enhanced green emission from the viewpoint of changes to the STE states and exciton recombination rates on insulating and conductive materials.
PL images and spectra of the MCs were obtained by exciting the samples at 404 nm (3.07 eV), which is comparable with the experimental bandgap based on the Tauc plot reported by Xu et al.17Fig. 2a and b shows the optical transmission image and PL image of (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate. The rhombic MCs show green–red dual emission (Fig. 2c) under 404 nm CW laser excitation. The dual emission of the MCs shows two distinct components at ca. 541 nm and ca. 619 nm. The intensity ratio of these emission peaks depends on the MCs. Some MCs show an intense red emission with a faint yellow emission on the edges (Fig. S2†). The yellow color overlays the green and red PL, which are clearly resolved in the PL spectra. Interestingly, the MCs prepared on an ITO-coated glass plate (MCsITO) show an intense green emission under 404 nm excitation, as shown in Fig. 2e. The size and shape of MCsITO are comparable with those of the MCs prepared on the borosilicate glass plate. Inside the MCsITO shows weak yellow emission. The PL spectrum of the MCsITO is shown in Fig. 2f, indicating that the red PL contributes to the faint yellow emission inside the crystals. Both MCs and MCsITO show similar PLE spectra for the green (540 nm) and red emission (600 nm) (Fig. S3†). We prepared MCs on a borosilicate glass plate with a small amount of water (MCswater) in the precursor solution to confirm whether humidity affects the PL of MCs.31 We added 10 μL of water to 2 mL of the (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 precursor solution before placing the solution on a borosilicate glass plate for crystallization. However, the MCswater show similar dual emission to the MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate rather than MCsITO (Fig. S4†). The SEM images and EDX elemental mappings of an MCsITO and an MC prepared on a borosilicate glass are shown in Fig. 2g–l and Fig. S5,† respectively. Both MCs show homogeneous atom distribution of copper (Fig. 2h and S5b†), bromide (Fig. 2i and S5c†), and carbon (Fig. 2j and S5d†). Also, the stoichiometry ratio Br/Cu = 2 is calculated for both MCs from EDX profiles. This indicates the purity of the MCs and the Cu(I) state of copper. Moreover, oxygen atom distributions in both samples (Fig. 2l and S5f†) suggest that the oxidation of Cu is unrelated to the green emission.
We consider different possible origins of the dual and enhanced green emission bands of the MCs: (i) mechanical force-induced PL emission state modification, and (ii) semiconductor–conductive material interaction-induced PL emission state modification. To investigate the origin of the intense green emission of the (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 MCs prepared on an ITO-coated glass plate, we investigated the PL properties of MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate after cracking and powdering using a plastic (ABS resin, insulator) or metal spatula (stainless-steel, conductor). Although we transferred the MCs prepared on borosilicate glass and those cracked or powdered using a plastic spatula to an ITO-coated glass plate, the MCs still showed dual emission without intense green emission. Fig. 3 shows PL images and PL spectra of two MCs during the crystal powdering processes. Initially, both MCs show overlaid green (ca. 540 nm) and red (ca. 620 nm) dual emission. The PL spectra of the samples were normalized at 620 nm to compare the PL intensity ratios of green/red emission. As shown in Fig. 3a and c, the PL intensity ratio (green/red) and the spectral shape were essentially not affected by breaking using a plastic spatula. We also crushed MCs sandwiched between two borosilicate glass plates by applying mechanical stress. However, the green/red PL intensity ratio did not change. In contrast, as shown in Fig. 3b and d, the PL intensity ratio of the green/red emission increased enormously (ca. 7.5 times) by cracking and powdering using a stainless-steel spatula as the corresponding spectral shape changed. With increased MC powdering time, the PL intensity ratio (green/red) also increased (Fig. S6†). The green emission peak of the powdered crystals was similar to that of MCsITO (ca. 541 nm). Although powdering MCs with an insulating material such as a borosilicate glass plate or a plastic spatula does not affect the PL color, spectral shape, or intensity, we do not rule out the effect of mechanical force on the lattice structure and the energy state of (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4. For example, the mechanical grinding of HCH crystals with a Cu4I429 or Cu2I530 core shortens the distance between Cu atoms in those copper cluster cores, lowering the energy of the emitting state. Such a mechanical pressure-induced structural deformation can modify the PL of the MCs. To understand the crystal structure of the samples powdered using a stainless-steel spatula, we measured the PXRD pattern of a powdered sample (Fig. S7†). The PXRD of the powdered sample is well matched with the XRD pattern from SCXRD analysis for the as-prepared MC on a borosilicate glass plate, indicating no phase transition after powdering using a stainless-steel spatula. Slight changes in the diffraction peak intensities and widths of the powder samples are due to the lower crystallinity of powdered crystals than the single crystal. Therefore, the mechanical force negligibly contributes to the modulation of the dual emission states without any phase transition. However, color and PL spectral changes due to the interaction with conductive materials remain an interesting but unsolved issue.
Time-resolved PL measurements help understand the exciton recombination process modulation in (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate during powdering using a plastic or stainless-steel spatula. The samples were excited by fs laser pulses (405 nm, 150 fs, 200 kHz). Fig. 4a shows the PL decay curves of a (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 MC during the powdering process using a plastic spatula (Fig. 4b–d) and a stainless-steel spatula (Fig. 4e). The as-prepared MC (Fig. 4b) shows delayed emission. Fig. 4f shows the exciton recombination process of the MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate, showing dual emission. krG and krR are radiative recombination rates for the green emission and red emission, respectively, and knrG and knrR are the corresponding non-radiative recombination rates. We attribute the delayed emission to the STE recombination process.1,17,19 Generally, the STE emission shows a broad spectral width and large Stokes shift.32 STEs are generated from the lattice distortion induced by exciton (electron) phonon coupling in HCHs. Under photoexcitation, the weakly bound exciton in the highly dielectric MC is quickly self-trapped to the STE state because of the strong electron–phonon interaction. The STEs are easily de-trapped to higher STE states.19 The strong polaronic effect in the MC retards the electron and phonon. As a result, it can be trapped in a low-lying STE state in high dielectric semiconductors such as (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4. Inter-band relaxation from such an STE state can be further delayed due to repeated trapping–de-trapping processes. The origin of the dual STE states of HCHs is discussed from the viewpoint of exciton–phonon coupling. Peng et al. discussed the dual STE states of (TBA)2Cu2I4 single crystals based on the multi-phonon mode.26 A shallow STE state (polaronic state) is formed by the strong electron–phonon coupling (a TBA+ cation and an I–Cu–I). Two TBA+ cations and [Cu2I4]2− clusters form a deeper STE state. Although such a model fits with the delayed and red-shifted emission, it cannot explain the dual emission modulation of the MCs induced by mechanical force or the interaction with a conductive material.
We assume that the energy difference between the red and green emission originates due to relaxations from the shallow STE state dominated by the surface phonons and the deeper STE state dominated by the highly polaronic inner lattice phonons. Conversely, the red emission and the green emission of the MCs are assigned to the lattice phonon–exciton-coupled STE state (STEL) and the surface–phonon exciton-coupled STE (STES) state, respectively. Based on the surface-to-volume ratio, the density of the lattice phonon is expected to be larger than the surface phonon density in the MCs. Therefore, red emission is dominantly observed in the as-prepared MCs. Here, the STES to STEL trapping rate kt is greater than the radiative recombination rate from the green emitting STES state (kt > krG). Also, the trapping rate kt is greater than the de-trapping rate (kt > kdt). Therefore, red emission is dominant for the MCs prepared on borosilicate glass plates. To verify those phonon effects on the PL emission color, we conducted temperature-dependent PL measurements for MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate or an MCITO (Fig. 4h–l). The MC prepared on the borosilicate glass shows intense green emission at a lower temperature (18 °C) than room temperature (23 °C). The PL emission of the MC changed from green emission to dual emission with increasing temperature (Fig. 4h). The PL spectra of the MC show resolved dual emission bands as the abovementioned green–red dual emission peak wavelengths (Fig. 4j). Above the room temperature, the PL peak intensity ratio is constant for the temperature. The MCITO also shows a similar PL emission color change from green emission to dual emission with increasing temperature (Fig. 4i). The PL spectra of the MCITO show a decrease in the PL peak intensity at 543 nm (green emission) with increasing temperature (Fig. 4k). This heat-induced PL color change suggests lattice phonon–exciton-coupling (red emission enhancement). Moreover, the PL emission color differences between MCs prepared on a borosilicate glass plate and an MCITO are due to the temperature threshold differences (Fig. 4l).
After cracking (Fig. 4c) and powdering (Fig. 4d) the MCs with a plastic spatula, the changing trend of peak PL intensity ratio is similar to the result in Fig. 3c (Fig. S8a and b†). The PL decays of these samples show a slight increase in the fast decay component. The fast decay component is associated with the green emission band. Fig. S8d–f† summarizes the fast decay components corresponding to green emission. The narrower bandwidth and faster decay of the green emission compared to the red emission suggest that the green emission state corresponds to the STES state because of the fewer surface phonon–exciton coupling states and lower coupling stability compared to those of lattice phonons. After powdering the MCs, the surface-to-volume ratio is increased but still smaller than the lattice phonon effect due to the micrometer scale crystal size. Therefore, the red and delayed emission is dominant for a sample powdered using an insulating surface. Conversely, the intense green emission after powdering using a conductive surface for the crystal prepared on an ITO-coated glass plate suggests three possible origins of the green emission or deactivation of the red emission: (i) the de-trapping rate from the STEL to the STES states exceeds the trapping rates, (ii) the energy of the STEL state exceeds the STES state, and (iii) the STEL state is deactivated by heat or charge transfer from MCs to ITO or the stainless-steel spatula (Fig. 4f and g). Although an increase in the energy of the lattice–phonon trapped state is unlikely to happen, we do not rule out the other two possibilities, leaving the ultimate solution an open challenge.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Table S1 and Fig. S1–S8. Sample preparation schemes, PL images, PL spectra, SEM image, EDX elemental maps, PXRD pattern, photocount maps (PDF), and crystallographic data for (Bmpip)2Cu2Br4 (CIF). See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3nr05503e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |