Open Access Article
Phuc T. T.
Nguyen‡
ab,
Gökalp
Gözaydın‡
a,
Jieran
Ma
a,
Bingqing
Yao
c,
Qian
He
c and
Ning
Yan
*ab
aDepartment of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, National University of Singapore, 4 Engineering Drive 4, 117585, Singapore. E-mail: ning.yan@nus.edu.sg
bJoint School of National University of Singapore and Tianjin University, Fuzhou 350207, Fujian, China
cDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, National University of Singapore, Singapore 117575, Singapore
First published on 30th January 2024
Chemical upcycling of plastic waste offers a promising opportunity for synthesizing value-added products. Despite its potential, transforming poly(phenylene oxide) (PPO) into nitrogen-based chemicals remains underexplored. To that end, we report the direct conversion of PPO to dimethylanilines over bimetallic Pd–Ru/CNT in a mixture of octane and aqueous ammonia. In a one-pot manner, PPO is initially converted into substituted phenols, and then is aminated, yielding 30% dimethylanilines over Pd7Ru3/CNT under optimum conditions. The bimetallic catalyst outperforms its monometallic equivalents. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM), powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) unveiled the features of well dispersed and small-sized metallic nanoparticles. Control experiments using deuterium indicated a high reliance of hydrogen and water for the amination step and the hydrogenolysis step, respectively. Furthermore, we demonstrated product isolation through a straightforward acid–base treatment and extraction. This work introduces a viable route for upcycling PPO into valuable nitrogen-containing compounds.
Organonitrogen chemicals, constituting over 80% of the top 200 pharmaceuticals among others, are pivotal in the chemical sector.27 To foster green chemistry, there's a push to derive these chemicals from non-fossil resources like waste polymers.28 Ammonolysis and aminolysis techniques have been explored to convert polyethylene terephthalate29–35 and certain polyamides36–38 to amines and amides. Additionally, alanine was efficiently produced from biodegradable polylactic acid using ammonia and Ru/TiO2, with impressive purity and selectivity obtained over multiple cycles.39 More recently, lignin as an aromatic polymer has been converted into phenolic amines using Ru catalyst,40 emphasizing the potential of making amines from aromatic polymers.
Poly(p-phenylene oxide) (PPO) is a versatile engineering plastic exhibiting high heat resistance and stability. It is made via the oxidative condensation of 2,6-dimethylphenol, and it is broadly used spanning from electronics to automotive production. Despite its USD 1.67 billion market size in 2019, the catalytic conversion of PPO into other valuable chemicals has not been thoroughly studied.41 Notably, Ru/Nb2O5 has been identified for its ability to cleave PPO's C–O bonds. By adjusting the metal particle size, distinct products like m-xylene or 3,5-dimethylphenol have been selectively obtained.42,43 Small-sized metal particles are responsible for preserving the phenolic hydroxyl group while Brønsted acid sites facilitate the cleavage of C(o)–O bonds rather than C(m)–O bonds.
Dimethylanilines are essential for producing dyes and pharmaceuticals.44 They are commercially produced by the amination of substituted phenols in the presence of aluminum oxide-containing catalysts, aluminum salt as well as hydrogen transfer catalyst with cyclohexanone co-catalyst.45–48 The market size of 2,6-dimethylaniline and 3,5-dimethylaniline reached USD 50 million49 and USD 33 million50 in 2022, respectively. Considering the structural similarity between PPO unit and dimethylanilines, and the established methods for the catalytic conversion of phenolic compounds to anilines,51–55 one-pot catalytic system for the transformation PPO to dimethylanilines using metal catalyst was explored in this study. Transforming PPO to dimethylanilines involves two primary steps: PPO's hydrogenolysis to dimethylphenols (either 3,5 or 2,6 substitution) and the subsequent amination of dimethylphenols to dimethylanilines. The latter step requires the partial hydrogenation of dimethylphenols into dimethylcyclohexanones, followed by imination and a series of hydrogenation/dehydrogenation reactions to produce dimethylanilines. Given the known dehydrogenation properties of the Pd-based catalyst for the cyclohexane ring,56,57 Pd was chosen as an active component. Meanwhile, Ru on carbon nanotubes (CNT) is recognized for its efficiency in amination reactions,58,59 due to its enhancement of alcohol dehydrogenation in the presence of NH3, its ability to hydrogenolyze Schiff bases to primary amines, and the stability of CNT as the catalyst support under highly basic conditions.60 This knowledge led us to consider a nanoalloy Pd–Ru/CNT catalyst for the one-pot PPO to dimethylanilines transformation (Scheme 1).
000–50
000) was purchased from BLDpharm. Pd(NO3)2·2H2O (40% Pd basis), RuCl3·xH2O (40.00–49.00% Ru basic), 2,6-dimethylphenol (99%), 3,5-dimethylphenol (99%), 2,6-dimethylaniline (99%), 3,5-dimethylaniline (98%), octane (98%), toluene (anhydrous, 99.8%), 2-methyltetrahydrofuran (2-MeTHF, 99.5%), tert-amyl alcohol (TAA, 99%) were purchased from Sigma Aldrich. Aqueous ammonia solution (25%) and ethyl acetate (≥99.5%) were purchased from VWR. CNT (multiwalled carbon nanotube) was purchased from ANR Technologies.
:
y (denoted as PdxRuy/CNT) were synthesized by incipient wetness impregnation using Pd(NO3)2·2H2O and RuCl3·xH2O as the precursors. Under this terminology, 2% Pd7Ru3/CNT refers to bimetallic PdRu catalyst, with a total metal loading of 2 weight percentage, and a Pd
:
Ru weight ratio of 7
:
3. Typically, CNT was washed with a 5 M HCl aqueous solution (30 mL g−1) for 4 h, filtrated, rinsed with water (3 L g−1) to remove metal impurities and dried at 100 °C for 12 h before use. Pd(NO3)2·2H2O and RuCl3·xH2O were dissolved in 2 mL water by sonicating for 30 min and mixed with 0.5 g CNT. After being dried at 100 °C for 12 h, the catalyst was reduced at 400 °C under 5% H2/N2 for 2 h. Pd–Ru loaded on other supports (ZrO2, TiO2, CeO2, and MgO) catalysts were prepared with the same incipient wetness impregnation method.
For the recycling test, the catalyst was separated from the reaction mixture by centrifugation. The liquid phase underwent quantitative analysis using GC, while the solid catalyst was sonicated with 6 mL of toluene for 1 hour to dissolve any unreacted PPO. Following this, the catalyst was washed with 15 mL of ethanol and was subsequently dried in an oven at 60 °C for 12 hours before either direct use in the subsequent run or being sent for characterization. Starting from the second cycle, due to some catalyst loss after treatment, the amount of PPO was adjusted based on the remaining catalyst to maintain a consistent PPO
:
catalyst mass ratio.
:
Ru weight ratios (0
:
1, 3
:
7, 5
:
5, 7
:
3, 1
:
0) were synthesized and evaluated for PPO conversion to dimethylanilines at 5 bar H2, 280 °C for 4 h. Pd/CNT achieved a 3% dimethylanilines yield, while Ru/CNT was inactive for amination. The Pd7Ru3/CNT bimetallic catalyst significantly improved the dimethylanilines yield to 21.1% in an octane and aqueous ammonia mixture solvent (Fig. 2a). As temperatures increased, dimethylanilines yield followed a volcano trend, while dimethylphenols yield consistently increased to 36.3% (Fig. 2b). At 260 °C, hydrogenated products prevailed due to the exothermic hydrogenation of aromatic rings (low temperature favoured).55,63 H2 pressure also exhibited a volcano type of trend (Fig. 2c): at 1 bar H2 atmosphere, hydrogenolysis and amination did not occur, while 10 bar H2 led to benzene ring hydrogenation, producing nearly 90% reduced products. Previous studies indicate that aromatic compound formation from plastic and biomass depends on catalyst nanoparticle size, with smaller sizes preferred to prevent benzene ring hydrogenation and adsorption.42,43,64 Thus, we assessed how the metal loading of Pd7Ru3/CNT impacts PPO amination (Fig. 2d). The yields of dimethylanilines and dimethylphenols tended to rise as metal loading decreased from 10% (3.2 nm, Fig. S3†) to 2% (2.4 nm, Fig. S3†), reaching a 30.4% amine yield. Conversely, m-xylene yield fell from 33.6% to 10.1%. At a further reduced metal loading of 0.5%, 6% phenolic monomers emerged due to limited metal sites for hydrogenolysis. Recognizing that a 2% metal loading is optimal, we evaluated the performance of 2% Pd7Ru3 on various supports (Fig. S4†). Besides Pd7Ru3/CNT, only the MgO-supported catalyst exhibited moderate activity, yielding 19.3% of dimethylanilines. In contrast, Pd7Ru3 supported on ZrO2, TiO2, and CeO2 was found to be inactive.58
Interestingly, the catalyst was active only with an octane-ammonia mixture (Fig. 2e). While toluene and TAA were effective for lignin amination,65 they yielded minimal monomers from PPO. The distinctive impact of octane can be explained by its capacity to facilitate PPO dispersion even at room temperature42 (Table S1†), as well as its inert nature to the Pd7Ru3/CNT under the hydrogenation condition. While toluene has the capability to dissolve PPO, its poor performance is attributed to the undesired hydrogenation of toluene to methylcyclohexane, which occupies the catalytic sites and consumes hydrogen (Fig. S5†). Moreover, aromatic amine production from PPO was sensitive to the octane-NH3 ratio (Fig. 2f). Change in ammonia amount dramatically affected the dimethylaniline yield, with the best ratio between octane to ammonia at 4
:
1 being identified. A lower ratio resulted in the aggregation of PPO and the catalyst (Fig. S6†), hindering the depolymerization of PPO.
We assessed the effect of D2 in PPO amination using 2% Pd7Ru3/CNT by substituting H2 with D2. Three trials were performed: direct PPO conversion to amines (one-pot), PPO hydrogenolysis without NH3 (step 1), and substituted dimethylphenol amination (step 2), with results shown in Fig. 3. Switching to D2 (Fig. 3a) led to reduced dimethylamines yields in the one-pot reaction (13.9%) and step 2 (12.5%) but left dimethylphenols yields in step 1 slightly increased, suggesting amination is more hydrogen-reliant than hydrogenolysis. In contrast, replacing H2O by D2O resulted in a significant drop of dimethylphenols yield in step 1 to 10.0% (Fig. S7†). This highlighted D2O is involved in the rate-limiting step in hydrogenolysis, likely occur via a previously reported route of water participated C–O bond breakage.66,67 Nonetheless, the D2-H2 exchange catalyzed by Pd might mitigate the isotope effect.68,69
Additionally, the liquid products were analyzed by GC-MS to determine deuterium atom distribution within desired compounds. Utilizing mass fragmentation patterns, we established the isotopologue distribution (Fig. 3b) by fitting the mass spectra data70 with peak areas from extracted ion chromatograms. Deuterated products always account for over 50% of total product, with mono-deuterium (d1) being more abundant than di-deuterium (d2) and tri-deuterium (d3) products. Unusual adjacent fragmentations at specific m/z value of 77 (C6H5+), 91 (C7H7+), 106–107 (molecular ion losing a methyl group), and 121–122 (molecular ion) in the MS spectra (Fig. S8†) highlight deuterium substitution on the benzene ring. Generally, dimethylanilines and dimethylphenols exhibited consistent isotopologue patterns, but 3,5-dimethylaniline was exceptional with roughly 27% heavier isotopologues. One explanation is that 3,5-dimethylaniline has higher reactivity in dehydrogenation and hydrogenation, leading to multiple cycles that swap original hydrogen with deuterium.
To gain further insights into the reaction pathway of the PPO-to-dimethylanilines conversion process, a kinetic study was undertaken (Fig. 4a). The yield of dimethylphenols reached its highest value (35.7%) at 2 h and was considerably reduced with prolonged reaction time, suggesting its roles as intermediates. Meanwhile, the yield of dimethylanilines exhibited a gradual increase and reached a plateau after 4 h. Interestingly, m-xylene yield steadily grew, reaching 32.0% after 16 h; but the yield of 3,5-dimethylphenol displayed a reversed trend after 4 h. This prompted us to assess dimethylphenols and dimethylanilines’ activities under the reaction condition (Fig. 4b). Regardless of -OH or -NH2 functional groups, the 3,5-isomer, due to less steric hindrance, was less stable than the 2,6-isomer, resulting in a greater conversion. In line with the PPO amination kinetic trend, 3,5-dimethylaniline primarily became m-xylene (35.7%) within 4 h. Importantly, no isomerization was seen when using 2,6- and 3,5-isomers: 2,6-dimethylphenol didn't transform into 3,5-dimethylaniline but only produced the corresponding aniline isomers.
Based on the experimental observations, plausible reaction pathways for PPO conversion were proposed in Fig. 4c. Four main steps are involved, namely hydrogenolysis, hydrogenation, imination, and dehydrogenation. It is worth noting that although dimethylcyclohexanones are considered undesired products, they are key intermediates for the amination step. Previous research proposed that the amino group can only be incorporated into the products through the attack of ammonia on the ketone group of dimethylcyclohexanones and the resulting imines subsequently transfer hydrogen to phenol, leading to the formation of the desired anilines and the regeneration of the dimethylcyclohexanone.71 The generation of dimethylphenols and m-xylene from dimethylanilines under the reaction condition suggested that this hydrogenation – imination – dehydrogenation reaction sequence is reversible. This is aligned with the proposed pathway of phenol amination over Pd/C.72
The by-product, m-xylene, is formed either through the C–O bond scissoring of dimethylphenols, or through the aromatization and hydrodeoxygenation of the reduced products.72 It should be noted that dimer products, such as bis(3,5-dimethylphenyl)amine and 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethyl-1,1′-biphenyl, were also detected in the reaction mixture through MS analysis (Fig. S9†), indicating the occurrence of coupling reactions as side pathways.
To understand the roles of individual metal sites (Ru/Pd) and their combined effect, we examined the transformation of PPO to dimethylanilines, PPO to dimethylphenols (step 1), and 2,6-dimethylphenol to 2,6-dimethylaniline (step 2) using monometallic, bimetallic, and physically mixed catalysts (Fig. 5b–d). The GC-FID chromatograms for each route over Pd7Ru3/CNT are shown in Fig. 5a. In the one-pot transformation, the bimetallic catalyst surpassed both physically mixed and monometallic variants in dimethylaniline yield, following the order: Pd7Ru3/CNT (30.4%) > Pd/CNT (20.6%) > mixed catalyst (18.4%). This demonstrates the importance of well-dispersed and cohered active metal sites (Fig. 5b).
For step 1 (Fig. 5c), Ru/CNT demonstrated decent hydrogenolysis activity, producing 13.5% dimethylphenol yield, in line with prior studies highlighting Ru's efficacy in aromatic C–O bond cleavage in lignin.65,73 The bimetallic catalyst showed even higher C–O linkage cleavage activity, yielding 27.4% dimethylphenols. On the other hand, step 2 (Fig. 5d) witnessed Pd/CNT outperforming Pd7Ru3/CNT in amination of 2,6-dimethylphenol, yielding 30.3% of 2,6-dimethylaniline. The physically mixed Ru and Pd catalysts resulted in a moderate 2,6-dimethylaniline yield (13.7%), but Ru/CNT showed no activity. Pd/C's effectiveness in phenol's liquid-phase amination to aniline, in contrast with Ru/C's inertness in the step, demonstrates Pd's selectivity in the hydrogenation/dehydrogenation of aromatic rings.52,72 Combined, these control experiments demonstrate a synergistic effect in the bimetallic catalyst in PPO amination, especially in step 1, while step 2 is predominantly Pd-dependent. Pd7Ru3/CNT resulted in the production of more 3,5-dimethylphenol compared to Pd/CNT and Ru/CNT, and 3,5-dimethylphenol possessed a higher activity compared to 2,6-dimethylphenol in the amination reaction (Fig. 4b). We believe that these factors induce the improved formation of dimethylanilines with Pd7Ru3/CNT.
Considering that dimethylanilines are generated via dimethylphenols amination, it might be expected that the total dimethylanilines and dimethylphenols yield in the one-pot reaction would be equal to or lower than the dimethylphenols yield in step 1. However, the results showed the opposite trend, where step 1 only generated 27.4% of dimethylphenols compared to 49.5% of the total dimethylanilines and dimethylphenols yield in the one-pot reaction. Given that the only difference between the one-pot reaction and step 1 is the presence of NH3, it is clear that NH3 has enhanced the hydrogenolysis of PPO.
We conducted a recycling test to assess the reusability of the 2% Pd7Ru3/CNT. The yield of dimethylanilines decreased after each run, reaching 7% at the third run (Fig. S10a†). Elemental analysis of the reaction mixture using ICP-OES indicated that the leaching of Pd and Ru from the catalyst was minimal, accounting for less than 0.2% (Fig. S10b†). Hence, metal leaching is unlikely to be the primary pathway for deactivation. Raman spectroscopy revealed no significant alteration in the ID/IG ratios of the catalysts after each run, implying the stability of the CNT support (Fig. S10c†). TEM analysis on the used catalyst revealed the aggregation of metal particles (Fig. S10d†), suggesting that metal aggregation may be the primary pathway for catalyst deactivation. These findings align with our observations regarding the impact of catalyst loading on product yields, where a smaller particle size was found to be more beneficial in terms of dimethylaniline yields (Fig. 2d and Fig. S3†).
Finally, we conducted a demonstration of isolating dimethylanilines from the product mixture. Successful separation was achieved through a straightforward procedure involving treatment with HCl and NaOH, followed by extraction with ethyl acetate (Fig. S11†). This eliminates the necessity for column chromatography or distillation in isolating dimethylanilines.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: TEM images, particle size distribution, STEM image, elemental maps, product yield and gas phase analysis of PPO hydrogenolysis to dimethylphenols using deuterium, MS spectra. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3gc03757f |
| ‡ Both authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |