Kim
Steenbakkers
a,
Tom
van Boxtel
a,
Gerrit C.
Groenenboom
b,
Oskar
Asvany
c,
Britta
Redlich
a,
Stephan
Schlemmer
c and
Sandra
Brünken
*a
aRadboud University, FELIX Laboratory, Institute for Molecules and Materials, Nijmegen, The Netherlands. E-mail: sandra.bruenken@ru.nl
bRadboud University, Institute for Molecules and Materials, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
cI. Physikalisches Institut, Universität zu Köln, Köln, Germany
First published on 19th December 2023
Infrared messenger-tagging predissociation action spectroscopy (IRPD) is a well-established technique to record vibrational spectra of reactive molecular ions. One of its major drawbacks is that the spectrum of the messenger-ion complex is taken instead of that of the bare ion. In particular for small open-shell species, such as the Renner–Teller (RT) affected HCCH+ and DCCD+, the attachment of the tag may have a significant impact on the spectral features. Here we present the application of the novel leak-out spectroscopy (LOS) as a tag-free method to record the cis-bending of the HCCH+ (∼700 cm−1) and DCCD+ cations (∼520 cm−1), using a cryogenic ion trap end user station at the FELIX laboratory. We demonstrate that the obtained LOS spectrum is equivalent to a previously recorded laser-induced reactions (LIR) spectrum of HCCH+. The bending modes are the energetically lowest-lying vibrational modes targeted with LOS so far, showing its potential as a universal broadband spectroscopic technique. Furthermore, we have investigated the effect of the rare gas attachment by recording the vibrational spectra of Ne- and Ar-tagged HCCH+. We found that the Ne-attachment led to a shift in band positions and change in relative intensities, while the Ar-attachment even led to a complete quenching of the RT splitting, showing the importance of using a tag-free method for RT affected systems. The results are interpreted with the help of high-level ab initio calculations in combination with an effective Hamiltonian approach.
This interesting cation, exhibiting a 2Π3/2 electronic ground state, is also relevant from a fundamental spectroscopic point of view due to its open-shell linear nature. It is subjected to both spin–orbit and Renner–Teller (RT) coupling effects complicating the rovibrational spectra of its trans- (ν4) and cis-bending (ν5) modes of which only the latter is IR active. The HCCH+ ion was one of the first RT affected tetra-atomic species that has been experimentally13 and theoretically investigated and has since been widely used as a model system.14–19 The spectroscopic studies on the RT affected bending modes of this ion include low- and high-resolution pulsed-field induced zero electron kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy (PFI-ZEKE PES),20–22 laser induced reactions (LIR),23,24 and Ar-tagging infrared predissociation (IRPD) spectroscopy.25 Investigations into its doubly deuterated form, DCCD+, are limited to two theoretical studies by Perić and Radić-Perić26 and Jutier and Léonard16 and a low-resolution photoelectron spectroscopic study by Reutt et al.,27 revealing one feature of the RT split trans-bending, but none of the cis-bending.
This abundance of spectroscopic and theoretical data makes HCCH+ an excellent system to test the potential of the newly developed action spectroscopic technique leak-out spectroscopy (LOS).28 With this technique, the mass-selected ions, stored in a low-temperature ion trap, are vibrationally excited after which they collide with a neutral buffer gas, in turn transferring their internal energy to kinetic energy. As a result of this extra kinetic energy, the ions “leak-out” of the trap and are then detected, giving rise to a nearly background-free vibrational spectrum. The LOS method is thus very universal, in particular compared to another tag-free method, laser-induced reactions (LIR29,30), which has also been applied previously to the cis-bending of HCCH+,23,24 but requires a suitable slightly endothermic reaction to be applicable. Leak-out spectroscopy has already been applied for the high-resolution ro-vibrational spectroscopy of C3H+,28 ro-vibrational and double-resonance rotational spectroscopy of c-C3H2D+, H2CCCH+, and HCCCO+,31 and to the RT inactive antisymmetric C–H stretch (ν3) of HCCH+.32 In these studies, the infrared excitation leading to collisional energy transfer was done in the 3 micron region, using narrow-bandwidth continuous-wave, or in some cases also ns-pulsed, radiation. Our work presented here on the low-energetic bending modes of HCCH+ (∼700 cm−1) and DCCD+ (∼500 cm−1) using a μs-pulsed infrared free-electron laser may therefore act as proof-of-principle for LOS as a broadband spectroscopic technique.
Another spectroscopic technique to record broadband vibrational spectra of reactive species under isolated conditions is IRPD action spectroscopy. This technique is based on attaching a messenger atom [usually a rare gas (RG) such as He, Ne or Ar] to the target ion at cryogenic temperatures, so that a stable, but weakly bound complex is formed, which will dissociate upon resonant single-photon absorption.33–36 The binding of a RG atom to a closed-shell species typically results in only minor shifts in the corresponding vibrational spectrum, such that the recorded spectrum can be taken as a proxy for that of the bare ion.37–41 However, for small open-shell species, such as HCCH+ and DCCD+, the interaction between the RG tag and the ion may have a significant impact on the bending potential energy curve and thus its spectral features, as seen previously for Ne-tagged HC3N+.42 So far, to our knowledge, no systematic study exists on the effect of the rare-gas attachment on Renner–Teller perturbed systems.
In the present work we have recorded the spectrum of the IR active cis-bending of HCCH+ with LOS and Ne- and Ar-tagging IRPD, adding to the existing LIR work of Schlemmer et al.23 and Asvany et al.24 Not only do these measurements act as proof-of-principle for the application of LOS on low-energetic vibrational modes, but they also allow for a systematic investigation of the RG attachment to RT perturbed systems. Furthermore, we have recorded the first vibrational spectrum of the DCCD+ ion by means of LOS and Ne-tagging IRPD. Using an effective Hamiltonian approach the observed structures were analyzed and the resulting spectroscopic constants were compared to those obtained in the earlier PFI-ZEKE PES and LIR studies.
The HCCH+ ions are produced by electron impact (EI) ionization of acetylene (C2H2 ≥ 98%, Linde Gas) and the DCCD+ ions from acetylene-d2 (C2D2, 99%-d2, CDN Isotopes). Both gases were diluted with He in a 1:
3 (precursor
:
He) mixing ratio to aid ionization and the pressure in the source was kept at ∼10−5 mbar. Fig. 1 shows the EI mass spectra (30 eV electron energy) of the HCCH and DCCD precursors overlayed with the background signal from residual gas. We dominantly form the radical cations with m/z 26 (HCCH+) and m/z 28 (DCCD+), respectively, where for the latter a small admixture of CO+ and N2+ is present in the same mass channel.
The ions are extracted from the source in a ∼15–50 ms long pulse and are introduced into a quadrupole mass filter to mass select the ions of interest. After mass selection the ions are guided into the 22-pole ion trap,45 where either an IRPD or LOS spectroscopic scheme is applied.
For IRPD action spectroscopic experiments complexes of the target ions with Ne or Ar are formed inside the ion trap via three-body collisions by storing them at 6–7 K for Ne and 13–18 K for Ar and exposing them to a short (few 10 ms) He:
Ne(Ar) pulse with high number density (∼1015 cm−3) with mixing ratio 3
:
1 for He
:
Ne and 5
:
1 for He
:
Ar. Under these conditions ∼17% of m/z 26 (i.e. HCCH+) forms a weakly bound complex with Ne and ∼5% with Ar (see Fig. 2). For m/z 28 only ∼10% binds with Ne, which is likely due to the presence of both N2+ and CO+ in the m/z 28 mass channel. These ions may have lower Ne binding energies than DCCD+, resulting in an overall lower tagging efficiency. In the trap the formed complexes are then exposed to FELIX infrared light for 1-3 s, inducing predissociation upon on-resonant irradiation. Then, the content of the trap is analyzed with a second quadrupole mass selector and a single-ion counting detector, monitoring the depletion of the ion-complex signal as a function of the FELIX wavelength.
For leak-out spectroscopy the target ions are stored and collisionally cooled in the ion trap at 15–17 K by exposing them to a short (few 10 ms) He pulse at high number density (∼1015 cm−3). The trap exit electrode potential is set so that the ions are just stored and that only a small kinetic energy gain is needed for them to leak out. These settings are continuously adjusted to account for changes in the effective voltages due to condensation. While the ions are stored, neon gas is continuously flowing into the ion trap (∼1012 cm−3) to act as a collision partner, which is needed to convert the internal energy of the excited ions to kinetic energy. The number density and trap temperature were optimized for maximum LOS signal strength and avoidance of formation of Ne-complexes. In the trap, the bare ions are exposed to FELIX infrared radiation for 1–3 s and leak-out upon on-resonant irradiation. After each cycle the trap content is discarded and the process repeats. To record the vibrational spectrum one may either monitor the depletion of the bare-ion signal as a function of the FELIX wavelength after each trapping cycle, or directly monitor the ions leaking out during the trapping period. In this work the former method was used.
The 440–600 cm−1 and 650–840 cm−1 wavenumber ranges were covered in this study using the free-electron IR laser FEL-2 of the FELIX Laboratory‡ with a macropulse repetition rate of 10 Hz, maximum pulse energy in the trap region of <20 mJ (at 700 cm−1), and a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of around 0.7% of the center wavenumber. To account for varying laser pulse energy E, pulse number n, and for saturation effects, the signal is normalized prior to averaging using , giving the intensity I in units of cross-section per joule as a function of the frequency (ν), where NON (ν) gives the on- and NOFF the off-resonance ion count. The individual measurements are averaged using statistical binning with a bin size of 1 cm−1 to obtain the final spectrum. The final spectra were normalized with maximum intensity equal to one, to facilitate comparison between different methods.
|nPJM;p〉 | (1) |
|n〉 = |Λ〉|SΣ〉|v5l5〉|K〉. | (2) |
We approximate the total effective Hamiltonian by:
Ĥ = Ĥvib + ĤSO + ĤRT + Ĥrot, | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
ĤSO = ASO![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
g5 = ε5ω5. | (7) |
![]() | (8) |
![]() | (9) |
The complex normal mode operators 5,± are related to the Cartesian normal modes
5,x and
5,y by
![]() ![]() ![]() | (10) |
Finally, the rotational Hamiltonian is given by
Ĥrot = BR2 ≈ B[(Ĵ2 − Ĵz2 + Ŝ2 − Ŝz2 − Ĝz2) − (Ĵ+Ŝ− + Ĵ−Ŝ+)], | (11) |
The wave function is expanded in the basis
![]() | (12) |
Hui = Eiui, | (13) |
The line strengths for the ΔK = ±1 transitions are computed by
![]() | (14) |
![]() ![]() ![]() | (15) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Comparison of the infrared spectra of the cis-bending of HCCH+ taken with LOS (in red) and in previous work with LIR23 (in green) recorded at a nominal trap temperature of 16 and 90 K, respectively. |
ω 5 (cm−1) | ε 5 | x 5 | A SO (cm−1) | g K 5 (cm−1) | B (cm−1) | T (K) | FWHM (cm−1) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Parameters are fitted by hand. b Parameters are calculated ab initio on RCCSD(T)/aug-cc-pV5Z level of theory. | ||||||||
HCCH+ LOS | 719.39(35) | −0.02737(10) | −0.00373(18) | −31.283 (66) | 4.545 (47) | 1.1028 (11) | 38a | 5.5a |
HCCH+ LIR | 719.39(35) | −0.02737(10) | −0.00373(18) | −31.283 (66) | 4.545 (47) | 1.1028 (11) | 90a | 4.5a |
DCCD+ LOS | 528.5a | −0.02737(10) | −0.00373(18) | −31.283 (66) | 2.3a | 0.80b | 27a | 3a |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Infrared spectra simulated with the effective Hamiltonian model described in Section 2.2.2. The spectroscopic parameters were taken from Tang et al.21 and the temperature and FWHM were fitted to the spectra obtained with LOS (a) and LIR (b),23 recorded at a nominal trap temperature of 16 K and 90 K, respectively. The best fit internal temperature is 38 K for the LOS and 90 K for the LIR measurement. The corresponding spectroscopic and fit parameters are given in Table 1. The inlay in (b) shows an illustrated energy level diagram (not to scale). |
The good match of the experimental infrared spectra with the simulations using the spectroscopic parameters obtained by Tang et al.21 provides some clarification regarding the discrepancies between the Renner–Teller parameters for the cis-binding mode reported in the three experimental works: Yang and Mo20 reported ω5 = 704.05 cm−1 and ε5 = 0.0219, Tang et al.21ω5 = 719.39 cm−1 and ε5 = −0.0274 and Schlemmer et al.23ω5 = 710 cm−1 and ε5 = 0.032. Most striking is the significant difference between spectroscopic parameters obtained by Yang and Mo20 and Tang et al.,21 since both works use the same, high-resolution, experimental technique (zero-kinetic-energy photo-electron spectroscopy). The effective Hamiltonians used for the fitting were also very similar with the largest difference being the inclusion of an anharmonicity term and the Brown gK5 Renner–Teller correction by Tang et al.21 We have simulated the vibrational spectra using both Hamiltonians with their corresponding parameters and found a far better agreement with the parameters of Tang et al.,21 where the inclusion of the gK5 term turned out to be critical to fit our experimental data.
It is noteworthy that the fitted rotational temperature of the LOS spectrum (38 K) is significantly higher than the nominal trap temperature (16 K), while for the LIR spectrum this is not the case (both recorded and fitted temperatures are 90 K). This effect of the LOS technique has been previously observed by Asvany et al.,31 where they discuss that collisions of the ions with heaver species (i.e. Ne) in an RF field leads to heating of the stored ions. The line width is expected to be dominated by the resolution of the free-electron laser whose FWHM may vary between 0.6–0.8% of the center wavenumber, corresponding to Δω = 4.2–5.6 cm−1 at 700 cm−1 and Δω = 3–4 cm−1 at 500 cm−1. The fitted FWHM are in agreement with these values. The fact that the structure of both the LIR and LOS spectra can be reproduced by the simulation at different temperatures, indicates that the discrepancy between the obtained spectra is mainly a result of the temperature difference. Furthermore, the simulations show that recording a vibrational spectrum at different temperatures may be of great help in assigning the observed structure and validating the used model, especially for a relatively low-resolution technique.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Vibrational infrared spectrum of the cis-bending of DCCD+ recorded by means of LOS at a nominal trap temperature of 16 K. The experimental spectrum is overlayed with a spectrum simulated with the effective Hamiltonian model described in Section 2.2.2 using a best fit internal temperature of 27 K. Used spectroscopic parameters are given in Table 1. |
From ab initio calculations the harmonic vibrational frequency and Renner–Teller constant can be extracted for both species. Our calculations at RCCSD(T)/aug-cc-pV5Z level of theory give ωcis = 725.2/736.2 cm−1 (ω5 = 730.7 cm−1, ε5 = 0.015) for HCCH+, and ωcis = 533.4/540.7 cm−1 (ω5 = 537.0 cm−1, ε5 = 0.014) for DCCD+. For both species the calculated harmonic frequency is overestimated compared to the fitted value, but the ratio between the two matches very well: and
.
The gK5 parameter, which captures the mixing of the excited 2Σ in the ground 2Π electronic state upon the bending of the ion, decreases with deuterium substitution. This is in line with previous findings of Smith et al.56, who investigated deuterium substitution in SiCH and found that . This equation only holds when the coupling and energy gap between the excited 2Σ in the ground 2Π is isotopically invariant. From the fit we get
and
, which is in reasonable agreement considering that the DCCD+ parameters were fitted by hand. This agreement indicates that the isotope substitution of HCCH+ indeed only has a minimal impact on the electronic landscape and shows that isotope substitution can be extremely useful in understanding the complex ro-vibrational structure of Renner–Teller affected species and can aid in justifying the used model and parameter space.
Since this is the first vibrational spectrum of DCCD+ a comparison with earlier theoretical works is imperative. Table 2 shows the rotational band origins of the four vibrational bands of ν5 (μ2Σ1/2, 2Δ5/2, 2Δ3/2, and κ2Σ1/2) obtained from the fit together with the ab initio values of earlier theoretical work by Perić and Radić-Perić26 and Jutier and Léonard.16 Both works are based on a variational approach, where Perić and Radić-Perić used reduced degrees of freedom and Jutier and Léonard a full set of valence coordinates. Though both works report fairly different values, the divergence from the experimental work, here captured by the root-means-squared (RMS) of the difference between the calculated and observed values, is almost equal. The largest deviations are found for the RT affected 2Σ1/2 states, where Perić and Radić-Perić26 underestimate and Jutier and Léonard16 overestimate the Renner–Teller splitting. Furthermore, both works overestimate most of the predicted band positions.
State | Perić26![]() |
Jutier16 (o-c)b | Our work |
---|---|---|---|
a The effect of the spin–orbit coupling (ignored in ref. 26) was added to the rovibronic energies to facilitate comparison to ref. 16, where SO was included. b The values between brackets represent the difference between the observed and calculated band origins. | |||
μ2Σ1/2 | 530(−15) | 512(3) | 515 |
2Δ5/2 | 532(−7) | 530(−5) | 525 |
2Δ3/2 | 560(−4) | 559(−3) | 556 |
κ2Σ1/2 | 562(−5) | 574(−17) | 557 |
RMS | 9 | 9 |
To determine the effect of the vibrational energy on the observed leak-out intensity one needs to take the height of the trapping barrier into account. Ideally the height of the trapping barrier is set so that (almost) all ions are trapped but can still leak-out upon resonant irradiation. The setting of the trap barrier therefore affects the leak-out efficiency as shown by Bast et al.57 As a consequence, a lower gain of kinetic energy would reduce the leak-out intensity. In order to find out to what extent intensity variations within a band are influenced by this effect the intensities of the cis-bending vibrations for HCCH+ at around 700 cm−1 and DCCD+ at around 520 cm−1 should be carefully analyzed. Only then one could judge whether a significant intensity variation within one of the above-mentioned bands could be associated with a changing efficiency of the leak-out process. Since LOS is a considerably new method many such systematic studies are needed to get a better account on its limits.
Notably, the discrepancies between the measured and calculated intensities within the cis-bending vibrations of HCCH+ and DCCD+ only occur in the Sigma bands. This is an indicator that the deviation might be associated with an incomplete theoretical treatment, e.g., by ignoring couplings to other modes. Also here more systematic studies are needed to explain the current findings.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Comparison of the infrared spectra of the bare HCCH+ ion taken with LOS and of Ne–HCCH+ and Ar–HCCH+ taken with IRPD. |
Very clear differences can be observed between the three spectra: first, for both IRPD spectra no rotational substructure is observed due to the decrease of the rotational constant upon rare-gas attachment. Second, the Ne-tag induces a shift in band position together with a change in relative intensity altering the Renner–Teller pattern. The Ar-tag results in a collapse of this structure, indicating a complete quenching of the Renner–Teller splitting. To explain this behavior, we performed calculations on the geometrical structure of the two RG–HCCH+ complexes. A scan of the potential energy curve was computed at RCCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ level of theory, where the Ar or Ne atom were displaced around the center of mass of HCCH+. The counterpoise corrected binding energy was then calculated as a function of the attachment angle, which was kept frozen, while all other geometric parameters were allowed to relax. For both Ar- and Ne–HCCH+ the overall structure remained planar so that a symmetry plane can be distinguished (here xz). The label A′ corresponds to a symmetric and A′′ to an antisymmetric wavefunction with regard to this plane, corresponding to configurations (πx)1(πy)2 and (πx)2(πy)1, respectively. The resulting potential energy curves are shown in Fig. 7.
For the Ar-attachment the global minimum is found at a bent position (∼70°), where the Ar atom attaches with a binding energy of ∼1200 cm−1, which is in agreement with earlier computational work of Dopfer et al.58 and experimental work of Relph et al.25, where the ν2 C–C stretch was observed, indicating symmetry breaking effects as a result of strong Ar attachment. Furthermore, the here recorded spectrum clearly shows that the bent attachment results in a quenching of the Renner–Teller splitting, meaning that the complexation with the argon atom has lifted the degeneracy of the Π orbitals enough so that the Born–Oppenheimer approximation holds.
It is striking that the estimated binding energy (∼1200 cm−1) is much larger than the observed mode energy (∼720 cm−1). This could mean that the binding energy of the Ar is greatly overestimated by the calculations, but this seems rather unlikely due to the high level of theory used together with the Counter–Poise correction applied here. Another explanation is that the fragmentation of the Ar-complex occurs through a two-photon absorption. In order for this to happen, the difference between the v = 0–1 and v = 1–2 transitions should fall within the FELIX bandwidth. If the system would still be RT affected one would not expect this to occur, since the splitting pattern in v = 2 is different than in v = 1. However, since for the bent Ar–HCCH+ complex the RT splitting is quenched this difference is only determined by the anharmonicity and can be calculated with 2ω5x5 = 5.37 cm−1, which falls well within the FELIX bandwidth (FWHM = 5.5 cm−1).
In contrast, the Ne–HCCH+ PES reveals two minima of similar binding energy (D0 ∼ 250 cm−1) at linear and bent (∼70°) geometry with a ∼40 cm−1 barrier. However, after correcting for the zero-point energy (see Table 3) the bent geometry is clearly favored (D0 ∼ 211 cm−1) compared to the linear one (D0 ∼ 96 cm−1). Seeing that the Renner–Teller splitting remains visible one might argue that the Ne must be attached in a linear fashion. However, the Ne atom is much more weakly bound than the Ar-atom, so that the lifting of the degeneracy of the Π orbitals in the bend minimum might not be enough to fully quench the Renner–Teller effect. To test this hypothesis we have recorded the (originally IR inactive) C–C stretch region of the Ne–HCCH+ complex (see ESI:† Fig. S2), but only a very weak signal could be observed (within the noise level), indeed pointing towards a weak attachment of the Ne atom. Furthermore, with a barrier of only 40 cm−1 between the bent and linear configuration, one might expect a large amplitude motion of the Ne sampling all geometries. It is beyond the scope of this work to calculate the behavior of the Ne-tag and its impact on the vibrational landscape ab initio, since it requires a full diabatic treatment including the messenger atom. However, if we assume that the Ne-atom is bound in a linear fashion we can calculate its rotational constant ab initio, fit the Renner–Teller parameters and make a comparison with parameters of the bare ion. To verify the used model this procedure was repeated for the Ne-tagged DCCD+, which shows similar behavior upon Ne tagging as HCCH+ (ESI:† Fig. S3). To reduce the number of fitting parameters the spin–orbit constant ASO and anharmonic constant x5 were kept fixed. Furthermore, the temperature T was set to the recorded trap temperature (7 K), since no rotational substructure was visible. The resulting fits are shown in Fig. 8 and the corresponding spectroscopic parameters in Table 4.
ν1 | ν2 | ν3 | ν4 | ν5 | ν6 | ν7 | ZPE | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Linear Ne–HCCH+ | 3350 | 3241 | 1839 | 808/579 (703, 0.321) | 759/740 (750, 0.025) | 92 | 76/72 (74, 0.054) | 5779 |
Bent Ne–HCCH+ | 3356 | 3250 | 1840 | 783/558 | 737/727 | 72 | 20 | 5661 |
HCCH+ | 3354 | 3247 | 1839 | 785/558 (681, 0.329) | 738/729 (734, 0.012) | … | … | 5625 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Infrared spectra of (a) Ne–HCCH+ and (b) Ne–DCCD+ simulated with the effective Hamiltonian model described in Section 2.2.2. The corresponding spectroscopic parameters are given in Table 4. |
ω 5 (cm−1) | ε 5 | x 5 | A SO (cm−1) | g K 5 (cm−1) | B (cm−1) | T (K) | FWHM (cm−1) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Parameters are fitted by hand. b Parameters are calculated ab initio on RCCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ level of theory. c Excitation temperature was kept fixed to trap temperature. | ||||||||
HCCH+ LOS | 719.39(35) | −0.02737(10) | −0.00373(18) | −31.283(66) | 4.545(47) | 1.1028(11) | 38a | 5.5a |
Ne–HCCH+ IRPD | 723a | −0.025a | −0.00373(18) | −31.283(66) | 6a | 0.09b | 7c | 9a |
DCCD+ LOS | 528.5a | −0.02737(10) | −0.00373(18) | −31.283(66) | 2.3a | 0.80b | 27a | 3a |
Ne–DCCD+ IRPD | 531a | −0.024a | −0.00373(18) | −31.283(66) | 3.2a | 0.09b | 7c | 6.5a |
For both the Ne–HCCH+ and Ne–DCCD+ all fitted parameters seem to change in a similar manner: the harmonic frequencies (ω5) are blue-shifted, the RT constants (ε5) decrease, the Brown parameters (gK5) increase and the FWHMs increase with respect to the bare ions. The blue-shift of the harmonic frequency is in line with the ab initio calculations for the linear Ne–HCCH+ complex (see Table 3), but is much less pronounced than predicted. Furthermore, the RT parameter ε5 decreases, while an increase is predicted from the harmonic frequency calculations and the gK5 increases with about one third, which is much more than would be expected if the electronic structure would be invariant to the neon attachment (then equation would hold). These findings indicate that the Ne-attachment has a significant impact on the electronic landscape of Ne–HCCH+ and Ne–DCCD+.
Finally, the fitted FWHM are about a factor 2 larger than those of the bare-ion LOS and the linewidth of FELIX (3.3–6.6 cm−1). This cannot be fully attributed to a saturation effect, since the maximum depletion of the DCCD+ was only ∼30% and we correct for this in the data analysis. One could argue that the temperature of the Ne–HCCH+ and Ne–DCCD+ complexes might be significantly higher than the set trap temperature of 7 K, which may result in a broader rotational profile. To test this we have simulated the Ne–HCCH+ spectrum at 30 K and 50 K (see ESI:† Fig. S4). These figures clearly show that the broadness of the simulated spectra is dominated by the FWHM of the Gaussian convolution at all temperatures. The observed linewidth can therefore not be related to the rotational temperature of the complexes. Another cause of this broadening can be linked to life-time or pre-dissociation broadening effects, where a linewidth of ∼8 cm−1 would correspond to a very short lifetime of about 0.66 ps, which seems unlikely looking at the stability of the complex. Furthermore, it seems that the FWHM of the lines in the Δ band (highest intensity band) is larger than that of the Σ bands, since their contour is not well matched when using a universal FWHM for all lines. This could indicate that the vibronic angular momentum K may have an impact on the stability of the Ne-ion complex, but more likely is that the Δ band is overlayed with the rotational structure of the bent Ne–HCCH+ complex. The latter hypothesis is strengthened by the spectrum of the Ar–HCCH+ complex, which is much stronger bound than the Ne–HCCH+ (and should therefore have a longer lifetime), but is of similar linewidth. Of course higher-level calculations are needed to fully describe the effect of the Ne-attachment on the electronic structure, but these calculations and measurements are in line with a large amplitude motion of the Ne atom around the HCCH+, sampling both geometric minima.
In addition, we have recorded the vibrational spectra of HCCH+ and DCCD+ by means of the commonly used infrared predissociation (IRPD) action spectroscopic method, using Ne and Ar as messenger atoms. We found that the Ne-attachment leads to a distortion of the RT splitting and Ar to a complete quenching, which is supported by both ab initio calculations and an effective Hamiltonian analysis. The IRPD method is often used under the assumption that the spectrum of the weakly-bound complex can be taken as proxy for that of the bare ion. Seeing that this is clearly not the case for HCCH+ and DCCD+ and that similar effects were reported for HC3N+,42 where it was found that the Ne attachment affected the RT splitting, we argue that spectra obtained with the IRPD method should not be taken as a proxy for the bare ion spectra for RT affected species. In these cases LOS provides an excellent universal alternative.
In contrast to most closed-shell species, the state of ab initio calculations for the simulation of the ro-vibrational spectra of Renner–Teller perturbed molecules is relatively poor, as shown here for DCCD+. It is therefore particularly important to obtain accurate experimental spectroscopic constants that are used to simulate the radio- or infrared spectra through which these species are detected. The newly launched James–Webb Space Telescope (JWST) provides mid-resolution observational infrared data at unprecedented sensitivity, and a means of detection for low-abundance symmetric species with no rotational spectrum like HCCH+. The spectroscopic parameters now derived and confirmed for the highly characteristic cis-bendings of DCCD+ and HCCH+ may be used for follow-up high-resolution studies or may even be sufficient for direct comparison to JWST data, as has recently been demonstrated for the hydrocarbon ion CH3+.59,60 This paper also highlights the complementary nature of PFI-ZEKE PES and infrared LOS, where PFI-ZEKE may provide rotationally resolved spectra and accurate spectroscopic constants and LOS information on expected line intensities and selection rules. The demonstration of LOS as a universal broadband infrared action spectroscopic method as shown here, opens the door for future studies of other astro- and fundamentally relevant RT affected cations, such as linear HCCCH+, CCH+ and HCCN+.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3cp04989b |
‡ https://www.ru.nl/en/hfml-felix. |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2024 |