Aurélie
Rensonnet
ab,
William J.
Tipping
a,
Cedric
Malherbe
b,
Karen
Faulds
a,
Gauthier
Eppe
b and
Duncan
Graham
*a
aCentre for Molecular Nanometrology, WestCHEM, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, Technology and Innovation Centre, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, G1 1RD, UK. E-mail: duncan.graham@strath.ac.uk
bMass Spectrometry Laboratory, MolSys Research Unit, University of Liège, Allée du 6 Août, 4000 Liège, Belgium
First published on 7th December 2023
Hyperspectral stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) microscopy is a powerful method for direct visualisation and compositional analysis of cellular lipid droplets. Here we report the application of spectral phasor analysis as a convenient method for the segmentation of lipid droplets using the hyperspectral SRS spectrum in the high wavenumber and fingerprint region of the spectrum. Spectral phasor analysis was shown to discriminate six fatty acids based on vibrational spectroscopic features in solution. The methodology was then applied to studying fatty acid metabolism and storage in a mammalian cancer cell model and during drug-induced steatosis in a hepatocellular carcinoma cell model. The accumulation of fatty acids into cellular lipid droplets was shown to vary as a function of the degree of unsaturation, whilst in a model of drug-induced steatosis, the detection of increased saturated fatty acid esters was observed. Taking advantage of the fingerprint and high wavenumber regions of the SRS spectrum has yielded a greater insight into lipid droplet composition in a cellular context. This approach will find application in the label-free profiling of intracellular lipids in complex disease models.
Conventional methods for the analysis of lipid composition include mass spectrometry9 and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy,10 however, these techniques lack subcellular spatial information. Whereas fluorescence imaging can permit super-resolution spatial visualisation, the use of hydrophobic dyes as contrast agents fundamentally lacks compositional information. Taken together, these techniques are unable to achieve the required spatial resolution or molecular specificity to elucidate how LDs are formed and metabolised, or to decipher intracellular function of LDs in disease onset and progression.
Advances in stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) microscopy have driven performance limits for Raman imaging in all aspects including speed, sensitivity, and spatial and lateral resolution for biological characterisation.11–13 Raman imaging is a powerful method for studying intracellular lipids, membrane phase behaviour and lipid organisation.14 For example, a recent report demonstrated quantitative chemical imaging of FAs based on chain length using C–C gauche modes in the region 1050–1140 cm−1 of the SRS spectrum.15 With a spectral resolution <10 cm−1, hyperspectral analysis was capable of discriminating mixtures of FAs in neat form using multivariate curve resolution, although the use of a femtosecond laser source for imaging is known to be cell damaging, which can limit some live cell applications.16 Despite numerous studies demonstrating the power of SRS imaging for visualising LDs in mammalian cells,17–19 tissues20 and organisms,21 the technique has rarely been used to study FA storage without the use of bioorthogonal tagging based on deuterium22–25 or alkyne modifications.26–28 The use of chemometric analysis techniques including k-means cluster analysis29–31 and spectral phasor analysis32–38 have been applied to extricate the underlying biological features contained within hyperspectral SRS imaging datasets in a label-free way. As such, we proposed that chemometric analysis of hyperspectral SRS datasets could enable imaging of FA uptake and storage without exogenous tagging.
Here, we demonstrate that hyperspectral SRS imaging coupled to spectral phasor analysis is a powerful method for the label-free discrimination of fatty acids in pure form, and for compositional analysis of intracellular lipid droplets in a cancer cell model as well as under conditions of cellular steatosis in a hepatocellular carcinoma cell model. We demonstrate the first use of spectral phasor analysis using the high wavenumber and fingerprint regions of the Raman spectrum for a greater insight into lipid droplet characterisation.
HeLa or HepG2 cells were plated at 2.5 × 105 cells per well in 6-well plates (Fisher Scientific) containing a glass coverslip (22 × 22 mm, #1.5H, Thorlabs) in DMEM (2 mL). The cells were incubated for 24 hours at 37 °C with 5% CO2 prior to treatment. After 24 hours, the medium was removed, and the cells were treated as follows:
The SRS and Raman spectra from the neat samples are provided in Fig. 1 and Table 1. The high wavenumber region of the SRS spectrum corresponds to the C–H stretching normal modes which are assigned‡ at 2847–2883 cm−1 (ν(CH2)), 2900–2970 cm−1 (ν(CH3)), and 2996–3014 cm−1 (ν(C–H)) (Fig. 1).41 Due to the numerous chemically inequivalent C–H bonds in C18 FAs, the spectra in the high wavenumber region are broad, reflecting the overlapping nature of the Raman modes in this region. As the unsaturation degree increases from stearic acid (C18:0) to stearidonic acid (C18:4), a clear increase in the (ν(
C–H)) Raman band was detected, which showed a blue shifting with increasing unsaturation (Fig. 1b). Across the unsaturated FAs, the intensity of the 2851 cm−1 symmetric ν(CH2) vibration relative to the other peaks in this region appears to decrease with increasing conjugated unsaturation (Fig. 1a). This result demonstrated that the intensity ratio of CH2/CH3 stretches decreases with an increasing degree of unsaturation. The symmetric ν(CH3) band ∼2935 cm−1 is clearly visible for linolenic acid (C18:3) and stearidonic acid (C18:4). When comparing the SRS spectra of elaidic acid (C18:1, trans unsaturation) with oleic acid (C18:1, cis unsaturation), several differences are apparent. Firstly, the relative intensity of the (ν(
C–H)) Raman mode is reduced in elaidic acid compared to oleic acid, whilst the ratio of the bands at ∼2850 cm−1 to ∼2880 cm−1 is reduced for elaidic acid when compared to oleic acid (Fig. 1b). Generally, the SRS spectrum of elaidic acid more closely resembles that of the saturated stearic acid. Altogether, the SRS spectra of the six FAs closely resemble the peak profile of the Raman spectra (Fig. 1c and d) albeit with a slight offset in the x-axis calibration in the SRS spectra (which is likely due to the reduced spectral resolution of SRS imaging compared to spontaneous Raman spectroscopy).42
ν(![]() |
ν s(CH3) | ν as(CH2) | ν s(CH2) |
ν(C![]() |
β(CH2/CH3) | α(CH2/CH3) | β(CH2) | τ(CH2) |
δ(![]() |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stearic acid | 2927 (2935) | 2881 (2884) | 2847 (2851) | 1462 (1470) | 1440 (1449) | 1414 (1425) | 1295 (1302) | |||
Oleic acid | 3005 (3004) | 2925 (2935) | 2851 (2858) | 1654 (1658) | 1438 (1449) | 1301 (1302) | 1263 (1267) | |||
Elaidic acid | 2996 (2996) | 2924 (2935) | 2883 (2884) | 2847 (2851) | 1671 (1672) | 1465 (1470) | 1439 (1449) | 1415 (1425) | 1301 (1302) | |
Linoleic acid | 3010 (3009) | 2930 (2935) | 2851 (2858) | 1657 (1658) | 1440 (1449) | 1300 (1302) | 1264 (1267) | |||
Linolenic acid | 3012 (3011) | 2932 (2935) | 2852 (2858) | 1657 (1658) | 1300 (1302) | 1265 (1267) | ||||
Stearidonic acid | 3014 (3011) | 2931 (2935) | 1656 (1658) | 1265 (1267) |
In the fingerprint region of the SRS spectrum (Fig. 1e), the unsaturated FAs displayed a prominent peak at ∼1658 cm−1 corresponding to the ν(CC) vibration, which is notably absent in stearic acid (C18:0) and is blue shifted in elaidic acid to 1672 cm−1, reflecting the trans unsaturated nature of this FA. Between 1400–1500 cm−1, several Raman bands in the SRS spectrum of stearic acid corresponding to the β(CH2/CH3), α(CH2/CH3) and β(CH2) modes were detected at 1470 cm−1, 1449 cm−1 and 1425 cm−1 respectively (Fig. 1e).41 With increasing unsaturation, the resolution and intensity of these modes decreases, with the exception of elaidic acid which has an SRS spectrum that more closely resembles that of stearic acid than the cis unsaturated FAs. Finally, the spectra displayed two bands at 1302 cm−1 (τ(CH2), stearic acid) and 1267 cm−1 (δ(
C–H), unsaturated FAs), from which the intensity ratio could be used to determine the unsaturation degree of a lipid sample (Fig. 1e).41 Across the fingerprint region, the SRS spectra (Fig. 1e) closely resemble the Raman spectra (Fig. 1f).
Across the series of C18 FAs investigated in this work, several Raman bands were shown to vary in Raman shift and intensity. For example, the degree of unsaturation for FAs could be calculated using the following ratiometric intensity analysis: ν(C–H)/ν(CH2), ν(C
C)/α(CH2/CH3) and δ(
C–H)/τ(CH2). Fig. 2 presents the ratiometric analysis of these key bands in the SRS and Raman spectra acquired in Fig. 1. The ratio ν(
C–H)/ν(CH2) at ∼3010/∼2850 cm−1 shows a positive trend across the C18 FAs analysed reflecting the increasing degree of unsaturation from stearic acid to stearidonic acid. Similarly, a positive trend was observed for the Raman bands ν(C
C)/α(CH2/CH3) at ∼1660/1440 cm−1 and δ(
C–H)/τ(CH2) at 1267/1302 cm−1, respectively. Across these three ratios, the SRS and Raman results are broadly similar, apart for the result of stearidonic acid (C18:4) (Fig. 2b and c) where a reduced ratio was detected in the SRS spectra compared to the Raman spectra. We attributed this discrepancy to sample degradation during the SRS spectral acquisition. The delay in retuning the optical parametric oscillator (OPO) in between image frames to construct the SRS spectrum (∼10 min) compared to the Raman spectral acquisition (1 min) accounted for the degradation of stearidonic acid, which is light sensitive and typically stored at −20 °C. In conclusion, the SRS spectra showed a high degree of spectral similarity to the spontaneous Raman spectra, albeit with a slight offset in the x-axis due to the lower spectral resolution of the SRS imaging system.
Having demonstrated the suitability of hyperspectral SRS imaging for the analysis of FAs in neat form, we investigated the potential of spectral phasor analysis for the automated compositional analysis of cellular lipid droplets based on the SRS spectrum. Spectral phasor analysis is a Fourier transform-based technique that projects every pixel within a 3D hyperspectral SRS image stack (x, y, λ) as a point (or phasor) on the 2D phasor plane to provide an overview of the ensemble of pixels.32 We created a hyperstack of the SRS spectra from the six FAs investigated in this study from which we performed spectral phasor analysis. The spectral phasor plot showed clear separation between the different FAs (Fig. 2d). Stearic acid and elaidic acid were located furthest from the origin and showed the greatest spectral similarity, whilst across the series of cis-unsaturated FAs, the phasors clustered in a pattern towards the origin of the plot. This study is the first to demonstrate the segmentation of FAs based on hyperspectral SRS data using spectral phasor analysis and, when combined with ratiometric analysis of the SRS spectrum, it resulted in a powerful methodology for compositional lipid analysis.
Having validated the use of hyperspectral SRS imaging combined with spectral phasor analysis, we sought to investigate lipid composition in a cellular model of cancer and DIS. Firstly, HeLa cells were treated with DMSO (control) or FA (400 μM conjugated to 5% BSA in a 1:
4 v/v ratio) prior to fixation with paraformaldehyde. Hyperspectral SRS imaging was performed across the high wavenumber region (2800–3050 cm−1) and fingerprint region (1200–1780 cm−1) of the Raman spectrum. From the image stacks, an average intensity projection was created, which provided a label-free overview of the cellular locations, together with a ratiometric image of the CH2/CH3 (2851/2930 cm−1) content (Fig. 3a). The ratiometric analysis highlighted the nuclear region (weak CH2/CH3 signal, blue), the cytoplasm (intermediate CH2/CH3 ratio, green) and the cellular LDs (high CH2/CH3 ratio, red). We next performed spectral phasor analysis on the hyperspectral SRS images, to improve the segmentation of the LDs based on the known location of lipids in the phasor domain. Spectral phasor analysis revealed that the treatment with FAs resulted in the detection of larger lipid droplets compared to the control cells (Fig. 3b) and a larger % area of LDs per cell (Fig. 3c) compared to the control cells. In addition, treatment with the monounsaturated FAs, elaidic acid and oleic acid, resulted in more lipid droplets compared to the other FAs, reflecting the impact of unsaturation and lipid conformation upon intracellular uptake.
The use of spectral phasor analysis enabled a direct comparison of the LD composition in each case. In the high wavenumber region, the mean LD spectra showed an increasing intensity of the ν(C–H) band at ∼3010 cm−1 as the degree of unsaturation of incubated FA increases (Fig. 4a and b). Interestingly, in the LD spectrum of cells treated with stearic acid and elaidic acid, the intensity of the ν(
C–H) band is lower than in the control cells. Together these results suggested that the FAs had become incorporated into the cellular LD pool. In the linolenic acid treated cells, the Raman band at ∼2850 cm−1 (ν(CH2)) was at a reduced intensity relative to the ν(CH3) at ∼2930 cm−1, which is in agreement with the SRS spectra of the neat FA (Fig. 1a). In the fingerprint region, the intensity of the ν(C
C) increased relative to the α(CH2/CH3) with increasing unsaturation, further supporting the observation that the FAs have become incorporated into the cellular LDs. From the SRS spectra, it was again possible to perform ratiometric analysis as previously, which identified that the lipid droplets in the control HeLa cells contained a high degree of unsaturated lipids (dashed markers, Fig. 4d–f). In addition, we investigated the impact of varying the treatment concentration of oleic acid. HeLa cells were treated with oleic acid (0–400 μM, 24 h) and analysed by hyperspectral SRS microscopy (Fig. S1†). As indicated by the ratiometric analysis, at all oleic acid treatment concentrations tested, a lower ratio for the lipid unsaturation was observed when compared to the untreated control samples, which were acquired concomitantly and the results of which agreed with our observations in Fig. 4. Moreover, for each ratio tested, the results did not vary significantly between the treated cells, indicating that the LDs spectra and the resulting ratios are not dependent on the concentration or uptake in FAs, but only on the nature and unsaturation degree of the lipids. The SRS imaging presented here has a higher spatial resolution (∼400 nm) compared to conventional Raman imaging systems (typically ∼ 1 μm) which means that the detection of smaller LDs is more accurate and reproducible. When coupled to hyperspectral imaging with spectral phasor analysis, the improved spatial resolution minimises the potential contribution of the surrounding cytoplasm in cases where LDs are smaller than the laser spot size. Altogether, these data indicate that hyperspectral SRS imaging coupled to spectral phasor analysis is a powerful method for lipid characterisation in a cancer cell model.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Hyperspectral SRS imaging of HeLa cells treated with FAs. Spectral phasor analysis was used to segment the cellular LDs in the hyperspectral SRS image stacks from Fig. 3 and the corresponding average SRS spectra presented in the region (a) 2800–3050 cm−1, (b) expansion of the region corresponding to ν(![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Lastly, we investigated cellular steatosis in a hepatocarcinoma cell model. Hepatic steatosis, also called fatty liver disease (FLD), is characterised by an excess accumulation of fat in the liver and can be divided into two types: non-alcoholic FLD (NAFLD) or alcoholic liver disease. HepG2 cells were treated with cyclosporin A, an immunosuppressant drug known to induce lipid accumulation and steatosis in hepatocytes.43 The cells were treated with 30 μM of cyclosporin A for 48 hours to mimic DIS, or with DMSO as a control. Thereafter, the fixed HepG2 cells were imaged by hyperspectral SRS imaging between 2800–3050 cm−1 and 1200–1780 cm−1 as in the previous experiments. Spectral phasor analysis was used to segment the lipid droplet pool in the cyclosporin A and control treated cells (Fig. 5a). The treatment of the cells with cyclosporin A did induce steatosis in the cells, which is illustrated by an increase in the LDs size (Fig. 5b), with the number of phasors related to the LDs (yellow marker) increasing in the treated cells. The results were confirmed by the calculation of the mean number of the LDs in the treated cells compared to the controls (Fig. 5c). The number of LDs per cell in the control HepG2 cells is higher than in the treated samples, indicating that steatosis induces the gathering of several LDs into larger structures. Together, these results confirmed that cyclosporin A treatment results in macrovesicular steatosis,44 through the presence of fewer, but larger, LDs per cell compared to the control cells. In addition, the SRS spectra indicated that the degree of unsaturation decreased in the larger lipid droplets associated with cyclosporin A treatment: the intensity of the α(CH2/CH3) and τ(CH2) modes are much greater in the cyclosporin A spectra compared to the control cells. In addition, the detection of an intense ν(CO) at ∼1740 cm−1 indicated the esterification of fatty acids, likely into triacylglycerols (TAGs) or the presence of cholesterol esters.41 Our results have demonstrated the potential of hyperspectral SRS imaging combined with spectral phasor analysis for studying lipid composition in the high wavenumber and fingerprint region with molecular specificity. Our method has demonstrated the benefit of spectral phasor analysis, to enable the discrimination of 6 FAs in neat form, and to enable the intracellular visualisation of FAs into cellular samples. As such, this system has enabled access to imaging across a greater rage of the SRS spectrum for lipid profiling compared to two previous reports using the fingerprint region (1070–1120 cm−1)15 and the high wavenumber region (2800–3050 cm−1).34
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Fig. S1. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3an01684f |
‡ The following assignments have been applied in this manuscript: ν = stretching vibration; δ = deformation; β = bending; α = scissoring; τ = twisting. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |