Guiju
Liu
*abc,
Margherita
Zavelani-Rossi
d,
Guangting
Han
a,
Haiguang
Zhao
*a and
Alberto
Vomiero
*ce
aCollege of Textiles & Clothing, State Key Laboratory of Bio-Fibers and Eco-Textiles, Qingdao University, No. 308 Ningxia Road, Qingdao 266071, P. R. China. E-mail: hgzhao@qdu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Physics, Yantai University, Yantai 264005, P. R. China. E-mail: gjliu@ytu.edu.cn
cDepartment of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics, Division of Materials Science, Luleå University of Technology, 971 87 Luleå, Sweden. E-mail: alberto.vomiero@ltu.se
dDipartimento di Energia, Politecnico di Milano, via G. Ponzio 34/3 and IFN-CNR, piazza L. da Vinci 32, 20133 Milano, Italy
eDepartment of Molecular Sciences and Nano Systems, Ca’ Foscari University of Venice, Via Torino 155, 30172 Venezia Mestre, Italy
First published on 30th March 2023
Luminescent solar concentrators (LSCs) are large-area sunlight collectors for efficient solar-to-electricity conversion. The key point for highly efficient LSCs is the choice of fluorophores, which need to have broad absorption, high quantum yield and large Stokes shift. Among various fluorophores, carbon quantum dots (C-dots) hold great promise as eco-friendly alternatives to heavy-metal-containing quantum dots (QDs) due to their adjustable absorption and emission spectra, non-toxicity, low cost and eco-friendly synthetic methods. However, due to the limited absorption band and relatively low quantum yield in the red region, it is a challenge to obtain efficient LSCs based on C-dots. Here, we demonstrated highly efficient LSCs based on red-emissive C-dots. The as-synthesized C-dots have a cubic structure, broad absorption covering 300–600 nm, and red emission (peak located at 595 nm), with a high quantum yield of ∼65% and a large Stokes shift of 0.45 eV. Transient absorption experiments of the C-dots revealed the ultrafast formation of the broad emissive state (1 ps). Based on the excellent optical properties of the C-dots, the as-prepared large-area LSC (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) exhibited an optimized external optical efficiency of 4.81% and a power conversion efficiency of 2.41% under natural sun irradiation (70 mW cm−2). Furthermore, a tandem LSC using green-emissive C-dots (top layer) and red-emissive C-dots (bottom layer) as fluorophores exhibited an external optical efficiency as high as 6.78%. These findings demonstrate the possibility of using eco-friendly carbon-based nanomaterials for highly efficient large-area LSCs.
The external optical efficiency of LSCs is defined as the total number of photons emitted from the edges over the total number of photons radiated from the top of the LSCs.9,16 To obtain high-efficiency LSCs, the key factor is to select high quality fluorophores, which need to have broad absorption well matched with Sun's spectrum, high quantum yield (QY), large Stokes shift with a small overlap between the absorption and emission spectra, and long-term stability.16 The broad absorption means the fluorophores can absorb more solar energy, the high QY means the fluorophores can re-emit more photons to transmit to the edges for solar cell absorption, and the large Stokes shift can decrease the reabsorption probability of the re-emitted photons and reduce the energy loss during photon transmission. In recent years, various types of fluorophores have been used for fabricating high performance LSCs.17–21 Among these fluorophores, colloidal quantum dots (QDs) have attracted a lot of attention due to their size and composition tunable absorption/emission spectra, high QY and excellent stability.20–23 However, the most efficient QD based LSCs contain toxic elements (Pb or Cd), such as in CdSe/CdS, PbS/CdS or CsPbClxBr3−x QDs.9,17,24,25 Considering the large-scale preparation and practical application, environmental pollution may be a major issue for these heavy-metal-containing QD based LSCs. Recently, a series of eco-friendly heavy-metal-free QDs were synthesized and employed as fluorophores in LSCs, for example AgInS2/ZnS, CuInS2/ZnS, Si QDs and carbon QDs (C-dots).4,20,26–30 Among them, C-dots have a wide absorption band and tunable emission spectra, an absorption coefficient comparable to inorganic QDs, low cost and good stability, which make them promising candidate fluorophores for LSCs.30–33 For example, Zhao et al.30 used C-dots with a high QY and large Stokes shift to prepare LSCs and obtained an external optical efficiency of 2.2% (15 × 15 cm2). Zhou et al.34 reported a laminated LSC based on C-dots with an external optical efficiency of 1.1% (10 × 10 cm2). However, these C-dots suffer from (i) limited spectral coverage of the solar spectrum (usually working mainly in the ultraviolet-blue region, with typically a 300–500 nm absorption band) and (ii) low QYs because of the existence of abundant structural and surface defects, which lead to external optical efficiency lower than that of inorganic heavy-metal-containing QD based LSCs (2–4% with dimensions of 10 × 10 cm2).9,34–37 Moreover, the photo/thermal stability of LSCs is still an open issue that prevents their practical applications.
In this work, we demonstrated a highly efficient large-scale LSC using red-emissive C-dots. The red-emissive C-dots exhibit a broad ultraviolet-visible spectrum absorption (300–600 nm), long-wavelength emission (550–700 nm), high QY (∼65%) and large Stokes shift (∼ 0.45 eV). Transient absorption measurements performed with high temporal resolution (∼150 fs) revealed the ultrafast formation of the broad emissive state, which takes place in about 1 ps. The LSC was prepared by embedded C-dots in polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) on a glass substrate. The large-area LSC (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) exhibits an optimal external optical efficiency of 4.81% and a PCE of 2.41% under natural sun irradiation (70 mW cm−2) after coupling to silicon solar cells. Moreover, a tandem LSC using green-emissive C-dots and red-emissive C-dots (top and bottom layers correspondingly) as fluorophores exhibited an external optical efficiency as high as 6.78%.
Green-emissive C-dots were prepared using a space-confined vacuum-heating approach.31 Typically, 1 g citric acid, 2 g urea and 1 g CaCl2 were mixed with 2 mL water under stirring until the aqueous solution was clear. Then the mixture was heated to 120 °C under vacuum for 30 min to pump away the water and then gradually heated to 180 °C for 30 min and then to 250 °C for 1 h. Finally, the product was dispersed in methanol and centrifuged at 8000 rpm for 10 min. The supernatant was transferred into dialysis bags with a molecular weight of 300 Da for 12 h and then the C-dots/methanol solution inside the dialysis bag was collected and dried. The C-dots were redispersed in methanol for further application in LSCs.
Excitation-distance dependence PL spectra were collected by fixing the position of one LSC edge facing the detector and exciting the LSC with a movable laser (λex = 365 nm) perpendicular to the top surface of the LSC. The spot size of the exciting light was ∼0.75 mm2. The external optical efficiency of the LSCs was measured under standard solar illumination using a solar simulator (Newport) at AM 1.5G (100 mW cm−2) or under natural sunlight illumination. In order to irradiate the full area of the LSCs, for the LSC with a size of 5 × 5 × 0.52 cm3, the measurement was performed under a solar simulator; meanwhile for the LSC with a size of 10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3, the measurement was carried out under natural sunlight illumination. During measurements, the solar cell was directly coupled on one side of LSC edges. The application of anti-reflection coatings and plasmonic and back-reflector design strategies to overcome the photon energy loss in solar cells have been reported in previous reports.39,40 In the LSC-PV system, to avoid the inevitable loss of energy caused by coupling the solar cell to the LSC, we used a transparent epoxy to connect the solar cell with the LSC, which can decrease the reflections caused by the different refractive index between the solar cell surface and air. In the calculation of the efficiency, we estimated the total power produced by the LSC as the power produced from one side multiplied by four (for a square LSC). To validate this procedure, we measured the produced power under the same irradiation conditions at different sides of the LSC and we found no discrepancy, within the measurement uncertainty, in the measured power values from different LSC sides. To avoid any reflection from the three sides, where no PV cell is placed, we masked them with black tape, able to completely absorb the radiation from the LSC. This way, we minimize possible overestimation of PCE coming from either reflected light or light entering the lateral sides of the LSC, where no PV cell is placed. The current–voltage (J–V) characteristics were measured by using a Keithley 2400 Source Meter. Through measuring the changes of solar cell current after direct solar irradiation and LSC irradiation, the external optical efficiency (ηopt) can be defined as:36
(1) |
For the stability study of the LSCs under different wavelength irradiation, we selected three kinds of filters (350 ± 5 nm, 450 ± 5 nm, and 550 ± 5 nm) to filter the sunlight irradiated on the LSCs, and compared them with the LSC without filters and the LSC in a dark environment to study the efficiency variation of the LSCs (5 × 5 × 0.52 cm3) under different wavelengths of sunlight irradiation as a function of irradiation time. The optical efficiency measurements were carried out under solar simulator illumination. For the long-time stability study of the LSCs, we used a large-area LSC (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) as an example, and put it in a natural room for 2 months (ambient atmosphere, humidity of 40–60%, day and night, and without any light filter). Then the J–V curve of the LSC-solar cell system under outdoor natural sunlight illumination was obtained and eqn (1) was used to calculate the external optical efficiency of the LSC.
Fig. 1 (a) TEM image and (b) size distribution of red-emissive C-dots. (c) HRTEM image of one red-emissive C-dot. |
Fig. 2a shows the ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) absorption and normalized PL spectra of the C-dots dispersed in toluene. It shows that the C-dots have a broad absorption spectrum (from the ultraviolet to visible range, with onset at 600 nm and the first-excitonic absorption peak at 490 nm) and red emission ranging from 550 nm to 700 nm with a peak located at ∼595 nm, which means that they have a large Stokes shift of 0.45 eV. The PL decay curve of the C-dots in toluene is shown in Fig. 2b, which can be fitted by a single-exponential decay curve with a PL lifetime of 8.6 ns. The QY of the C-dots was obtained by means of an integrating sphere (λex = 500 nm) coupled to a PL spectrometer. For the absolute QY measurement, the excitation and emission of both the QD sample and reference (background without QDs, see the black line in Fig. 2c) were measured to compare. By comparing the differences in the sample and reference data, the excitation (494.0–506.5 nm) and emission (527.0–732.0 nm) spectra can be divided, and thus the number of photons absorbed and emitted can be derived (Fig. 2c), which shows that the C-dots have a high QY of ∼66% in toluene, mainly driven by the development of highly brilliant luminophores. Using the QY and PL lifetime, we can calculate the radiative and nonradiative decay rates of the C-dots. The QY can be expressed as:
(2) |
The lifetime can be calculated as:
(3) |
To further explore the exciton dynamics of the red-emissive C-dots, fs-TA spectroscopy measurements were carried out by the pump-probe technique, under excitation at 365 nm and using a broad visible probe, with a temporal resolution of about 150 fs. The collected data are shown in Fig. 3. Fig. 3a displays the contour plot, for the 430–720 nm probe spectral range, and time delays up to 1000 ps. The two positive bands, peaked at around 490 nm and 700 nm, represent photo-induced absorption processes and can be assigned to excited state absorption (ESA); its evolution describes the excited state population. The broad negative signal, peaked at ∼594 nm and extending roughly from 570 and 670 nm, spectrally coincides with PL and thus accounts for stimulated emission (SE). Fig. 3b and c display TA spectra at different time delays and TA kinetics at selected wavelengths, respectively. It can be noted that the excited state is populated in about 600 fs and reach its maximum population in ∼1 ps (see Fig. 3c). ESA has a very broad band, which covers all the probed region, from 430 nm to 720 nm, as can be seen in the plot of Fig. 3b (light pink line in Fig. 3b, at 0.5 ps time delay). In the spectral region around 594 nm we observe a competition between ESA and SE. Initially ESA is stronger than SE, but in ∼1 ps SE overcomes ESA, and, correspondingly, the TA signal changes sign: from positive to negative (see the green line in Fig. 3c). This shows the evolution of the emissive state: the formation of the broad emissive state is ultrafast, it is stronger than any other absorption mechanism and its fast formation outcompetes any other form of relaxation. This is consistent with the hypothesis of a single, well-defined de-excitation channel.
On longer time delays, we observed some rearrangements in the first 4–5 ps, and similar evolution for all bands on longer time scales (up to 1 ns at least). In particular, two bands of ESA (around 490 and 700 nm) show the same decay (Fig. 3c), and this confirms the assignment of both ESA to the same starting state. The SE band, at 594, shows a very slow decay, with a lifetime exceeding 1 ns, which is consistent with PL evolution. In Fig. 3d we depicted a scheme of the band structure and of the population evolution of the red-emissive C-dots.
The above excellent optical properties, especially the wide absorption, fast and stable PL emission and high QY, make the red-emissive C-dots a potential fluorescent material for efficient LSCs. The LSCs were obtained by mixing the C-dots (synthesized by a solvothermal reaction) with PMMA polymer/toluene and by drop-casting on glass substrates (details in the Experimental section). We further detached the QDs/PMMA from the glass and measured the thickness of the as-prepared film using a CHY-C2A thickness system for selecting 100 points in the film (Fig. S3a†). Fig. S3b† shows that the thickness of the film ranges from 143 to 222 μm, with the main thickness distribution range of ∼150–190 μm, indicating the uniformity of the film. Fig. 4a shows a typical LSC with the dimensions of 10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3 (G = 4.84) under simulated solar irradiation. It clearly shows that the as-prepared LSC was semi-transparent and a clear concentrated red light could be propagated to the edges of the LSC. There was no significant difference in the absorption and emission spectra for the C-dots dispersed in toluene and in the PMMA polymer film (Fig. 4b and c). A slight peak position variation of the C-dots in the LSC was most probably due to the change in the refractive index of the matrix (toluene solution vs. PMMA polymer). As shown in Fig. S4,† the C-dots dispersed in toluene, hexane and water exhibit different emission colors due to the different refractive index. The PL lifetime of the C-dots in the PMMA film was ∼8.2 ns, showing a very slight difference compared with the C-dots dispersed in toluene (Fig. 4d). The QY of the C-dots in the LSC also shows a slight decrease compared with that in toluene due to the effect of the medium (for example the defects in the polymer lead to fluorescence quenching), but it still maintained ∼50% under 500 nm excitation (Fig. 4e), indicating potential for BIPVs.
Following a method reported in the literature,30 we performed distance-dependent PL measurements to evaluate the distance dependence of the efficiency, as shown in Fig. 5a. Fig. 5b shows the change of total PL intensity with increasing the distance of the irradiation from the side edge. The inset in Fig. 5b illustrates the measurement process of the distance-dependent PL. For the LSC with the dimensions of 10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3, the PL intensity of the C-dots decreased with the increase of the distance between the beam spot and edge of the LSC. When the beam spot irradiated in the central region of the LSC (5–7 cm away from the edge of the LSC), the PL intensity of the device maintains a nearly stable value. This means that the optical efficiency of the LSC decreased with the increase of the light propagation distance due to the reabsorption and G. This phenomenon has been widely reported and used to evaluate the reabsorption loss in LSCs.27,30,44 In our case, the reabsorption is very low, as verified by Fig. 5a, where the shape of PL is almost unaffected, meaning that very weak resorption is present. In generally, in addition to the reabsorption loss due to the re-absorption and re-emission, the energy loss in an LSC is also affected by the following aspects: transmitted light (non-absorption of incident photons), partial light loss due to non-unity of the QY (<100%), surface reflection and the escaped light below the critical angle. To further understand the distance-dependent efficiency of the LSCs, the external optical efficiency (ηopt) of the LSCs was calculated. The theoretical optical efficiency of the LSCs is defined as the edge emitted photons over the total incident photons. It can be calculated as:45
ηopt = ηabs × ηinternal | (4) |
(5) |
(6) |
The calculated external optical efficiency of the LSCs is shown in Fig. S5.† In the simulation, the sunlight absorbed by the LSC was ∼15.3% of the total solar spectral energy (Fig. S5a†) and the QY of the C-dots was set to 65%. As shown in Fig. S5b,† the optical efficiency shows a decrease with the increasing length of the LSC. We further measured the optical efficiency of the LSC by coupling a solar cell at the edge of the LSC (details in the Experimental section). In the case of large-area LSCs (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3), the power intensity was 70–80 mW cm−2, which was determined by the natural sunlight irradiation (Qingdao, China). In the case of the small-area LSCs (5 × 5 × 0.52 cm3), the power intensity was set at 100 mW cm−2 (AM 1.5G standard) using a calibrated solar simulator. The measured optical efficiency of the LSCs was 4.5 ± 0.3% (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) and 4.8 ± 0.2% (5 × 5 × 0.52 cm3). Although the experimental result is systematically lower than the calculated optical efficiency due to the scattering of the surface or lower absorption, the variation trend of efficiency with size is consistent with the theoretical results (Fig. S5b†). As shown in Fig. 5c, the optimal optical efficiency of the LSCs (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) was measured to be 4.81% under natural sunlight illumination (70 mW cm−2). This is the highest efficiency of LSCs based on C-dots,34,35,46–49 compatible with the 75% trap efficiency,50 thanks to their large absorption range, high QY and large Stokes shift. To understand the actual contribution of the C-dots to the optical efficiency, we further tested the J–V curve of the PMMA film/glass-solar cell system without luminophores, as shown in Fig. S6.† The result indicates that 98% of the optical efficiency of the LSC is contributed by the C-dots. A comparative analysis of the performance of LSCs based on different types of C-dots is also reported in Table S1 in the ESI.† The LSC-Si solar cell configuration exhibits a PCE of 2.41% under natural sunlight (70 mW cm−2), which is larger than most of the reported C-dot based LSCs30,38,46,51 and comparable to doped-C-dot based LSCs.52
LSCs are supposed to be used outdoors under various conditions, and the thermal stability plays an important role in the LSC system. Furthermore, the temperature dependence of the efficiency was measured, as shown in Fig. 5d. It can be seen that when the temperature increased from room temperature to 60 °C, the ηopt gradually decreased. When the temperature further decreased to room temperature, the efficiency increased. The thermal stability of the as-fabricated LSCs maintained 89% of its original value even at a high temperature of 60 °C, which is comparable to previous reports (Table S2†). We used negative temperatures to characterize the efficiencies over a wide temperature range (Fig. S7†). The results show that the integrated PL intensity can maintain 77% of its highest value at −50 °C. Considering that the PL intensity determines the optical efficiency of the LSC, we used the variation of PL spectra to evaluate the change of the efficiency in the negative temperature range. It can be seen that the PL peak position shows no obvious changes while the PL intensity increased and then decreased when the temperature increased from −30 °C to 50 °C. This means that the efficiency also increases first and then decreases as the temperature rises from −30 °C to 50 °C. When the temperature is set at 0 °C, the PL intensity is the highest, which indicates that LSCs have the highest efficiency when the temperature is 0 °C. All the results demonstrate the outstanding thermal stability of the C-dot based LSCs.
To further improve the optical efficiency of the LSC, a tandem structure was designed based on C-dots as fluorescent materials. In this structure, green-emissive fluorescent C-dots were embedded in PVP to prepare a green-emissive LSC film (details in the Experimental section). Fig. S8† shows that this kind of C-dots in methanol have an absorption spectrum covering the 300–460 nm range. After excitation at 365 nm, the C-dots exhibit a broad PL emission in the 450–650 nm range with a peak located at ∼520 nm. Their lifetime is 16.2 ns longer than that of the above red-emissive C-dots (8.6 ns). Similar to red-emissive C-dots, after the green-emissive C-dots are embedded into the PVP polymer, the absorption, PL emission spectra and PL decay curves also show a slight difference due to the change of the refractive index of the surrounding (Fig. S8†). Furthermore, following the same measurement method, we performed distance-dependent PL measurements as shown in Fig. S9.† For the green-emissive LSC (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3), the PL intensity of the C-dots decreased with the increase of the distance between the irradiation beam spot and edge of the LSC, which is similar to the red-emissive LSCs due to the reabsorption energy loss and G.
The optical efficiency of the green-emissive C-dot based LSC is 3.00% under the irradiation of natural sunlight (78 mW cm−2), as shown in Fig. 6a. Under the same operation conditions, the red-emissive C-dot based LSC exhibits an external optical efficiency of 4.37% (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) (Fig. 6b). For the tandem structure, the green-emissive C-dot based LSC was placed at the top of the red-emissive C-dot based LSC, as shown in Fig. 6c. In this structure, the optical efficiency of the green LSC is still maintained at 3.00%, while the efficiency of the red LSC is decreased from 4.37% to 3.78% (Fig. 6d), due to the absorption of the top layer. Thus, the total optical efficiency of the tandem structure is 6.78%, which is the highest ever reported efficiency among all the different configurations and types of C-dot based LSCs.34,35,46–49
To investigate the long-term stability of the C-dot based LSCs, we measured the external optical efficiency variation of the LSCs (5 × 5 × 0.52 cm3) upon different sunlight illumination (350 ± 5 nm, 450 ± 5 nm, 550 ± 5 nm, full solar spectrum and dark) under natural conditions (Fig. S10†). The results show that the UV and visible light in the absorption range of the C-dots can both lead to the decrease of the optical efficiency. Under the same conditions, when there is no light irradiation, the efficiency of the LSCs also decreases, especially when the air humidity is high (>80%). This means that both sunlight and moisture can influence the properties of the LSCs. When the LSC (10 × 10 × 0.52 cm3) was placed in a natural room for 2 months, the efficiency decreased to 3.46% (Fig. S11†), keeping 72% of its initial value, indicating a good stability of the device. Further to improve the stability, encapsulating the device with epoxy glue or a laminated structure can be used to isolate the C-dots from the external environments (air, moisture or other chemicals).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2ta09972a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |