Shear-induced criticality in glasses shares qualitative similarities with the Gardner phase

Abstract

Although glass phases are ubiquitously found in various soft matter systems, we are still far from a complete understanding of them. The concept of marginal stability predicted by infinite-dimensional mean-field theories is drawing attention as a candidate for a universal and distinguishing unique feature of glasses. While among theoretical predictions, the non-Debye scaling has indeed been observed universally over various classes of glasses, the Gardner phase is found only in a limited portion of them. In this work, we numerically demonstrate that plastic events observed in two-dimensional Lennard-Jones glasses under quasistatic shear exhibit statistical properties that are qualitatively consistent with the picture of an infinitely hierarchical energy landscape associated with the Gardner phase.