Guang
Tian
ab,
Yi-Chi
Zhang
b,
Chuanguang
Qin
*a and
Jie
Wang
*bc
aDepartment of Chemistry, Shanxi Key Laboratory of Polymer Science & Technology, MOE Key Laboratory of Supernomal Material Physics & Chemistry, School of Chemical & Chemical Engineering, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi'an 710129, China. E-mail: qinchg@nwpu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Medicinal Chemistry, Shanghai Institute of Materia Medica, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 201203, China. E-mail: jiewang@simm.ac.cn
cUniversity of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
First published on 8th November 2022
Herein we report a unified strategy for the divergent total synthesis of six Elaeocarpus alkaloids in 6–10 steps from commercially available materials. This modular approach relied on the rapid construction of the tetrahydrobenzopyran-4-one framework through an aldol/dehydration/oxa-Michael process to set all carbons and functional groups ready for the core construction. A key NbCl5-mediated intramolecular Mannich reaction was used to build the C ring and secure both stereoisomers existing in these natural products. Finally, a diversification was achieved through the intermediacy of thioamide, with the side chain of elaeocarfoline A/B installed by an Eschenmoser sulfide contraction/reduction sequence.
Due to their structural diversity and unique biological activities, Elaeocarpus alkaloids have attracted considerable attention from the synthetic community. In 1970, Tanaka and co-workers accomplished the total synthesis of elaeocarpine (1) and isoelaeocarpine (2) for the first time utilizing copper catalyzed diazoketone-pyrrol insertion and the Dieckmann condensation as key steps.8 Thereafter, Onaka reported a very short synthesis of 1/2 through reductive condensation of dehydroindolizidine and salicylaldehyde, albeit with low yields.9 Tufariello and co-workers disclosed an elegant synthesis of 1/2 in 1979 employing a nitrone-olefin cycloaddition reaction as the key strategy.10 From 2007, the synthetic interest was revived due to Carroll's discovery of the unique biological activities, leading to the successful total synthesis of grandisines A (5), B, D and F by Danishefsky,11 Tamura,12 Taylor13 and their co-workers. The Tamura group also prepared elaeocarpenine and its analogs to evaluate the opioid receptor binding affinity.14
We became interested in Elaeocarpus alkaloids particularly due to the apparent correlation between the DOR binding potency and the dihedral orientation of B/D rings of these natural products, reflected by their relative stereochemistry in C7/8/9 conjunction (Scheme 1a). With the B ring being directed in an orthogonal orientation to the D ring, compounds 5 (cis–cis in C7/8/9) and 2 (cis–trans) exhibit a higher binding affinity than 1 (2.7 and 13.6 μM vs. 86.4 μM), whose B ring is located almost in the same plane as the D ring (trans–trans). Recognizing that basic nitrogen and extended aromatic substituents are important features for selective DOR binders,15 the ideal scaffolds from this class would be molecules possessing both cis–cis configuration and an aromatic A ring, e.g., 8-epi-1, which is unnatural and not easy to construct according to Danishefsky's studies.11,16 In addition, some newly isolated natural products, such as 3, 4, 6 and 7, have not been synthesized yet. Many of the Elaeocarpus alkaloids are also extremely scarcely available from their natural sources, with 3, 6 and 7 all being isolated in less than 1 ppm from the corresponding dried plants, which hampers the detailed biological evaluations of these natural products. In this regard, we intended to devise a stereodivergent approach to synthesize natural Elaeocarpus alkaloids and create novel analogs in a modular fashion17 and explore their potential as analgesic agents.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 (a) Correlation of the DOR binding affinity with the stereochemistry and (b) retrosynthetic analysis. |
Our retrosynthetic analysis is shown in Scheme 1b. The C7/8/9 relative stereochemistry is the same for 1, 3 and 6 as trans/trans, while in 2, 4 and 7 it is cis–trans. Therefore, 3/4 were designated as the gateway compounds in our synthetic plan, which would connect to 1/6 and 2/7 by late-stage selective modification of the amide carbonyl group. Considering that both C7/8/9 trans/trans and cis–trans stereochemistry are desired for the target natural products and that the cis–cis isomer is also of interest for biological evaluations, the C ring was strategically disconnected at C8–C9 by an intramolecular Mannich reaction18 through the intermediacy of an N-acyliminium ion. The precursor 8 could be in turn broken into three commercially available fragments 9, 10, and 11. Although not necessarily representing the biosynthetic pathway,5c,7a,9 the current retrosynthesis was inspired by the hypothesized biosynthetic intermediates proposed by Onaka.9
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 Total synthesis of elaeocarpine (1), oxoelaeocarpine (3), oxoisoelaeocarpine (4) and elaeocarfoline A (6). |
First, a modified procedure (methyl enol ether was obtained with catalytic p-TsOH in MeOH/CH(OMe)3, the imide group was reduced with LiBH4 in THF and then worked up with HCl) was carried out in one-pot to produce 14a in 78% overall yield on gram-scale. Unfortunately, with 1 mol% of Sn(NTf2)4 as the catalyst, no cyclization product was observed on our substrate 14a (entry 1, Table 1). We then tested several other Lewis and Brønsted acids in different solvents. While Sc(OTf)3, NbCl5 and HNTf2 in CH3CN proved to be unsuccessful (entries 2–4), catalytic p-TsOH in MeOH under refluxing conditions furnished the cyclized product in 55% yield (entry 5). After careful characterization, the product was determined to be a 1:
1.2 mixture of the natural product (±)-oxoisoelaeocarpine (4) and its cis–cis isomer 18 whose structure was confirmed unambiguously by X-ray crystallographic analysis. The observed solvent preference inspired us to assume that the hemiaminal O-methyl ether might be formed in situ and it is important for the cyclization reaction to take place, with the diastereoselectivity possibly being tuned by the solvent and catalyst to obtain the trans/trans isomer required in other natural products. To this end, hemiaminal 14a was converted into its corresponding O-methyl ether 14b in 94% yield with p-TsOH in In(OTf)3 and no or a trace amount of product was obtained (entries 6–10).
Entry | Substrate | Lewis or Brønsted acid | Solvent | Temperature | Yield (3/4/18, %)b |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: a solution of 14a or 14b (0.1 mmol) and catalyst in the indicated solvent (1.0 mL) was stirred for 24 hours. b Yield determined by crude 1H NMR using 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane as the internal standard. c Isolated yield. ND = not detected. | |||||
1 | 14a | Sn(NTf2)4 (1 mol%) | CH3CN | 60 °C | ND |
2 | 14a | Sc(OTf)3 (1 mol%) | CH3CN | 60 °C | ND |
3 | 14a | NbCl5 (60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | ND |
4 | 14a | HNTf2 (5 mol%) | CH3CN | 60 °C | ND |
5 | 14a | TsOH (10 mol%) | MeOH | Reflux | 0/25(23c)/30(30c) |
6 | 14b | I2 (10 mol%) | CCl4, or MeOH | r.t. | ND |
7 | 14b | Cu(OTf)2 (10 or 60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | <5% |
8 | 14b | In(OTf)3 (10 or 60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | <5% |
9 | 14b | FeCl3 (10 or 60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | ND |
10 | 14b | Sc(OTf)3 (10 or 60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | <5% |
11 | 14b | NbCl5 (60 mol%) | MeOH | 60 °C | 0/65/26 |
12 | 14b | NbCl5 (60 mol%) | DMF or DMSO or CH3CN | 60 °C | ND |
13 | 14b | NbCl5 (60 mol%) | Acetone | 60 °C | 29/28/27 |
14 | 14b | NbCl5 (60 mol%) | CH2Cl2 | r.t. | 41(39c)/36(36c)/0 |
![]() |
NbCl5 turned out to be an efficient mediator, a substoichiometric amount (0.6 equivalent) of which in MeOH produced 4 and 18 in a 2.5:
1 ratio and 91% yield (entry 11).27 The diastereoselectivity was found to alter in different solvents. In acetone, the natural product (±)-oxoelaeocarpine (3) could be produced along with 4 and 18 in a 1
:
1
:
1 ratio (entry 13). Finally, the cis–cis isomer could be completely avoided by switching the solvent to CH2Cl2 (entry 14) and the desired natural products 3 and 4 were obtained in 39% and 36% isolated yield respectively (separable by flash column chromatography).
Throughout the conditions of screening, three stereoisomers out of four were observed including the cis–cis isomer 18 with a rather congested conformation, but not the trans–cis isomer 19. This prompted our interest to perform a conformational analysis of the reaction transition states (TS) (Table 1b). In both trans–trans (TS1) and cis–trans (TS2) configuration that exist in natural sources, the side chain on the pyran ring occupies an equatorial position and subsequently undergoes a chair TS to form cyclized products. In the cis–cis (TS3) scenario, with the side chain switching from the equatorial to the axial position, a chair TS can also be obtained. However, in order to form the trans–cis isomer, the side chain has to occupy an equatorial position and form the subsequent boat TS (TS4), which is high in energy and kinetically unfavored. The remarkable solvent effects for the observed 3/4/18 selectivity could also be explained with these TSs by dipole interaction. Since the axial conformation might exhibit a higher dipole moment than the equatorial,28 the lowest dipole moment was generated in TS1 (starting from the e form and all three substituents being in the e,e,e form in the newly formed C ring), whereas the highest of which was generated in TS3 (starting from the a form and all the substituents being in the e,a,e form) and TS2 behaved somewhat in between (starting from the e form and all the substituents being in the a,e,e form). As the transition state with a higher dipole is expected to be more favoured in the solvent with a larger dielectric constant,28TS1 was the least favourable in MeOH and TS3 the least favourable in CH2Cl2, which agreed well with our results that 3 was not observed in MeOH, 18 was not observed in CH2Cl2, and that all the three isomers (3, 4, and 18) were obtained in the acetone solvent with a medium dielectric constant.
The Nb-mediated intramolecular Mannich reaction could be implemented on a gram-scale to produce 3 and 4 in quantities with unaltered efficiency, and the stage is now setting for the divergent synthesis of other Elaeocarpus alkaloids. To achieve this goal, oxoelaeocarpine (3) was first converted into the corresponding thioamide 15 in 75% yield using Lawessen's reagent (Scheme 2). After activation with Meerwein's salt and reduction using NaBH3CN, (±)-elaeocarpine (1) was synthesized successfully in 63% yield. To attach the side chain to C3 as required in elaeocarfoline A (6), metal-catalyzed diazocarbonyl-thioamide coupling was initially attempted. While copper29 did not provide any useful product, ruthenium catalysis30 produced the desired enaminone 17 successfully. However, the yield was very low (<20%) and could not be improved after an extensive optimization, suffering from a low conversion rate due to steric hindrance from both coupling partners. This problem was solved employing the canonical Eschenmoser sulfide contraction reaction by modifying Michael31 and Russowsky's32 protocols. By mixing 15, bromide 16 and NaI in a minimum amount of CH2Cl2 and then evaporating off CH2Cl2, the mixture was rendered in a neat form and stirred for two days to achieve a high conversion. Followed by treatment with PPh3 and Et3N in CH2Cl2, enaminone 17 was obtained as a single isomer in 74% yield. The double bond geometry was tentatively assigned to be E, based on Russowsky's studies.32 With 17 in hand, reduction of the enaminone was achieved diastereoselectively from the convex face using NaBH(OAc)3 in CH3CN providing a single isomer in 72% yield, the stereochemical outcome of which was confirmed by demethylation with BBr3 to furnish (±)-elaeocarfoline A (6) in 59% yield.
Similarly, as shown in Scheme 3, oxoisoelaeocarpine (4) was converted into the corresponding thioamide 20 and then activated and reduced under Me3OBF4/NaBH3CN conditions to furnish the natural product (±)-isoelaeocarpine (2). A three-step sequence (sulfide contraction, reduction and demethylation) was also applied on 20 to produce (±)-elaeocarfoline B (7) uneventfully in 29% overall yield. The spectroscopic data for synthetic 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 7 are all in good agreement with those reported from the isolation literature.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2169386. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2qo01460b |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |