Aleksandra
Mrzygłód
ab,
Rafał
Januszewski
ab,
Julia
Duszczak
ab,
Michał
Dutkiewicz
c,
Maciej
Kubicki
a and
Beata
Dudziec
*ab
aFaculty of Chemistry, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan, Uniwersytetu Pozańskiego 8, 61-614 Poznan, Poland. E-mail: beata.dudziec@gmail.com
bCentre for Advanced Technologies, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan, Uniwersytetu Poznańskiego 10, 61-614 Poznan, Poland
cAdam Mickiewicz University Foundation, Poznan Science and Technology Park, Rubież 46, 61-612 Poznan, Poland
First published on 10th July 2023
Dendrimers are a wide group of chemical compounds that are still being studied extensively. New dendrimer cores are sought to improve their physicochemical properties. We present the syntheses of silsesquioxane dendrimers with different cores, from mono-T8, octa-T8 silsesquioxane to di- and tetrafunctional double-decker silsesquioxanes. These compounds were obtained by a sequence of hydrosilylation and reduction reactions in a one-pot protocol. As part of the research, the location of reactive Si–H and Si–Vi bonds on the selectivity of the hydrosilylation process was verified, as well as two reducing agents LiAlH4 and Red-Al®, on the reduction process. In addition, the reactivity of the obtained new hydrogen derivatives of these SQs was tested in the process of hydrosilylation with selected olefins and in a repetitive one-pot route to increase the generation of these dendritic systems.
With regards to carbosilane dendrimers, two synthetic paths to their formation can be distinguished. The first method applies hydrosilylation reactions, e.g. tetravinylsilane hydrosilylated with dichloromethylsilane to obtain Si–Cl bonds. The Grignard reaction follows, which usually forms a compound possessing unsaturated carbon–carbon – silicon bonds, e.g. Si–vinyl, Si–allyl.5–9 The second protocol is based on the reduction of the Si–Cl bond to introduce Si–H.10 The compounds resulting from both these methods contain reactive Si–Vi or Si–H, susceptible to further transformation, increasing dendrimer's generation with more branching units. For carbosilanes, the procedure employing Grignards reagents is more popular.
The properties that determine dendrimers’ subsequent application depend on, i.e. their size and type of surface/end groups. There are reports on the investigation of pure carbosilane dendrimers series (G3–G8 generations) vs. their hybrid carbosilane–siloxane analogues (G4, G6, G7 generations).11,12 Interestingly, there is a correlation between the Tg and the type of functional groups in the surface layer but not in terms of dendrimer generation. On the contrary, the high molecular weight of dendrimers is responsive to specific interactions between molecules with the increasing generation and it is manifested by increases in melt viscosity and an effective liquid–solid transition. As for the surface groups, in addition to standard silane groups, the hydroxyl, imidazole, sulfonate, and carboxylate phosphonium groups enabling anchoring metal atoms are interesting.13–17 Considering organosilicon-based dendrimers, carbosilanes are one of particularly important systems due to their properties that influence further application. They have been used in diverse areas of chemistry or medicine, e.g. in catalysis, anticancer therapy, immunotherapy and drug/gene delivery.18–22 The cores of such systems can be constructed of silanes, cyclosiloxanes, 1,3,5-trisilacyclohexane, as well as more extensive structures, such as silsesquioxanes.3,23,24
The latter, i.e. silsesquioxanes (SQs), are hybrid compounds characterized by the presence of a rigid, inorganic Si–O–Si core and organic substituents attached to silicon atoms of this core. Their general formula, i.e. (RSiO1.5)n, where R stands for organic functional group and n reflects the number of repetitions of this unit from 6 to 18,25 does not give insight into the spatial architecture of these systems. They may constitute random resins or more defined ladder, open- or closed cage, and recently also double-decker silsesquioxanes (DDSQ).26–28 In the literature, there is limited information on the use of T8-type SQ dendrimer cores with a particular emphasis on octa-functionalized SQs due to theirs spherical architecture.24 The advantage of the surface area of octa-T8 SQs with diverse organic functionalities is the possibility of increasing their compatibility with organic materials. The use of this system makes it possible to obtain a large number of functional groups with a small number of synthetic steps.29,30 It should also be mentioned that SQs are present in dendrimers not only cores but also as repeat units (known as hyperbranched polymers based on SQs)31 or SQs as surface functionalities.32 However, the reports on the use of monofunctional T8-type SQ as the core of specific dendrons are limited.30,33,34 The research on the use of DDSQ as cores of dendrimers is even less explored.35 In general, the formation of SQ-based dendrimers is based on a classical approach concerning divergent and convergent methodology.24 The advantage of divergent protocols for SQs containing dendrimers is due to the multiplicity of reactive groups at SQs, their diversity which enables a wide range of chemistry tools and also on 3D SQ structure that diminish potential steric crowding of the end moieties. However, there are also few reports of the use of convergent routes.36 Due to diversity in the functional groups at SQs inorganic core, their modification is tunably varying from amidation, Michael addition, and thiol–ene reaction to metathesis or hydrosilylation, often employing reaction sequences.24 In the case of carbosilane arms at SQ cores, they may be classically modified via hydrosilylation of the followed by Grignard reaction.37 Reports on the use subsequent Si–Cl reduction to Si–H are very scarce.38 Resulting products may possess phosphine, ferrocene surface groups, which made them possible to be applied as potential catalysts, i.e. in hydroformylation, hydrocarbonylation and methoxy-carbonylation reactions, as platinum electrode modifiers, respectively.37,39–44 In general, the application of silsesquioxane dendrimer hybrid systems is comprehensive, ranging from catalysis, liquid crystals to photoactive hybrid systems used as probes, e.g. in MRI, photodynamic therapy or drug delivery.24
Here, we present studies on the elaboration of a synthetic protocol leading to the formation of silsesquioxane dendritic systems with different types of cores ranging from T8 to closed- and open-cage DDSQ systems. These compounds possess a various number of carbosilane functionalities, varying from one, two, four and eight, respectively. The synthetic protocol is based on the hydrosilylation reaction and the subsequent reduction performed in a one-pot repetitive reaction sequence. Within the scope of the studies, two reducing agents, i.e. LiAlH4 and Red-Al®, were verified. They turned out to be efficient with the respective type of silsesquioxane core. As a result, a series of SQs-based dendrimers of G2 generation possessing from 4 to 32 reactive Si–H end groups was effectively obtained. The presence of end Si–H groups opens possibilities for further functionalization/modification via i.e. consecutive hydrosilylation with, e.g. olefins (tests with allyl glycidyl ether, 1-octene), as well as the possibility to further increase of dendrimers generation (Scheme 1). This is the first comprehensive synthetic report describing the evaluation of the nature of SQ core and the type of chlorosilane on the efficiency of reactions and regioselectivity in the synthesis of silsesquioxane-based dendrimers.
In general, for olefin hydrosilylation β-regioselectivity is preferred especially in terms of dendrimer formation. It is favoured, e.g. due to steric hindrance of the surface groups and their further availability. The reaction selectivity may be influenced by various factors, e.g. a suitable catalyst, and reaction temperature, but also by the location of Si–H and olefin (Si–Vi) reactive bonds in reactants. Therefore, it was decided to verify the location of the Si–H moiety, whether in the silsesquioxane structure or in the olefin, i.e. unsaturated chloroorganosilicon component, susceptible to further modification.
A model reaction was selected with the hydrogen derivative iBu7T8-OSiH, (synthesized according to the literature data)48 and dichloromethylvinylsilane (Cl2MeSiVi) to be tested in Pt-mediated hydrosilylation (Scheme 2, PATH A). In this way, the reaction could be monitored easily by FT-IR via analysis of changes in the area of the bands at ca. = 2100 and 900 cm−1 corresponding to the stretching vibrations of Si–H bond, located in the SQs reagent. The reaction was carried out in the presence of Karstedt's catalyst ([Pt2(dvds)3]) for 24 h at 95 °C.49 After reaction completion, which was manifested by complete disappearance of the Si–H band in the FT-IR spectrum, the solvent and unreacted chlorosilane were evaporated. The crude product containing two Si–Cl moieties was subjected to consecutive reduction to form Si–H groups testing lithium aluminium hydride (LiAlH4) as a convenient reducing agent (Scheme 2).
However, after the isolation of the product resulting from PATH A, the 29Si NMR analysis showed the presence of doubled peaks in the area of all types of silicon atoms present in the postulated compound containing two Si–H moieties. These resonance lines, e.g. 11.69, 11.44 (M-unit Si), −29.08, −30.21 (Si–H), −66.89, −67.03, −67.07, −67.10, −67.74, −67.87, −67.90 (T-unit Si), and −109.64 and −109.93 (Q-unit Si) ppm indicated the presence of a mixture of two products, i.e. β and α obtained in a 80:
20 ratio, abbreviated as G1-1iBuOSi-2H-β and G1-1iBuOSi-2H-α, respectively (Fig. 1a). 13C NMR spectra revealed the presence of resonance lines at 2.37 and 11.80 ppm corresponding to –CH2– moieties of the β isomer (G1-1iBuOSi-2H-β) and 4.53 and 9.83 ppm correlating to
CH and –CH3 units in α isomer (G1-1iBuOSi-2H-α). Also verified by DEPT-135 (see ESI, Fig. S50†).
As the hydrosilylation reaction resulted in formation β and α addition products some literature discusses the impact of the location of Si–H moiety (at the SQs core or olefin) on reaction selectivity, we decided to verify this.50,51 For this reason, an analogous hydrosilylation and reduction protocols were designed (PATH B) but varying in the structure of reagents, i.e.iBu7T8-OSiVi and dichloromethylsilane (Cl2MeSiH) were used as substrates. Interestingly, preservation of almost all reaction conditions, with the sole change in the location of the Si–H group, from silsesquioxane to chlorosilane, enabled the regioselective formation of G1-1iBuOSi-2H-β system, confirmed by NMR analyses. It may be seen, especially in the 29Si NMR spectrum the presence of peaks corresponding to respective silicon atoms, e.g. 11.44 (M-unit Si), −29.08 (Si–H), −67.07, −67.10, −67.87, −67.90 (T-unit Si), and −109.64 (Q-unit Si) ppm (Fig. 1b). The selectivity of this reaction may be a derivative of two factors, i.e. steric bulkiness of SQs core but also the electronic effect of substituents (i.e. Cl vs. O) in reactive Si–H and Si–HCCH2 groups. It affects the type of olefin insertion into the Pt–H bond of active catalyst occurring as either 1,2- or 2,1-insertion that results in the formation of β or α isomer respectively. Also, it was reported that the presence of electron-withdrawing atom(s) increases the reactivity of Si–H moiety.51 This is in accordance with the Chalk–Harrod's mechanism.47,63
The obtained results facilitated the selection of the optimal location of the Si–H and Si–Vi bonds in applied reactants. This also helped to develop an efficient protocol for the synthesis of dendritic systems using different types of silsesquioxane cores, i.e. di- and tetra-DDSQ as well as octa-T8. As the usage of silsesquioxanes possessing reactive Si–Vi moieties affects the final regioselectivity of the β-addition product, it was decided to apply two compounds direct linked to the vinyl group to T8 core, without the –OSi(Me2)– unit between them. For this purpose, we omitted the β symbol in the abbreviations of products (unless needed) in further parts of the manuscript. Additionally, the iBu7T8-Vi is obtained in fewer steps of the synthetic path.52 For the proper exploration of the sequence of hydrosilylation (1.) and reduction reactions (2.), the iBu7T8-Vi was used as a model reagent to react with dichloromethylsilane (Cl2MeSiH) in order to optimize reaction conditions and enable the formation of G1-1iBu-2H. The first of the reaction sequence was hydrosilylation, which was carried out using Karstedt's catalyst ([Pt2(dvds)3]) at 95 °C for 24 h with stoichiometry [iBu7T8-Vi]:
[Cl2MeSiH]
:
([Pt2(dvds)3]) = 1
:
2
:
1 × 10−4. Two-fold excess of Cl2MeSiH enabled >99% conversion of iBu7T8-Vi. After completion of the reaction, the solvent and unreacted chlorosilane were evaporated under reduced pressure and crude dichloro product as an intermediate product (G1-1iBu-2Cl) was dried and the subsequent step of the PATH B was maintained. The reduction was performed in toluene, and 1.2 equiv. of reducing agent per one reactive Si–Cl group was added and the reaction was conducted at room temperature for 20 h. In this case, LiAlH4 was used. When the reaction was finished, the by-products, such as lithium chloride and aluminium chloride, were removed by a syringe filter (0.2 μm). The product (G1-1iBu-2H) was obtained in 89% isolate yield. An analogue synthetic approach was applied for other monosubstituted T8 derivatives with iBu groups (G0-1iBu-1H, G2-2iBu-4H). The comparison of FT-IR spectra of iBu7T8-Vi and G1-1iBu-2H showed apparent proof of the differences in their structure. The disappearance of stretching vibration bands deriving from
C–H and C
C bonds at ca.
= 3050 and
= 1600 cm−1, was noted respectively, with the simultaneous presence of Si–H stretching vibration bands in the range of ca.
= 2100 and 900 cm−1 (Fig. S53 in ESI†).
The double-decker silsesquioxane is specific construction of cage silsesquioxanes. It is characterized by two decks of cyclosiloxane rings that are stacked one above the another and connected by two oxygen bridges with phenyl groups at Si core atoms. They may occur in the form of di- and tetrafunctional analogues.53,54 As octafunctional T8 SQs are applied as cores for dendrimers and the reports on DDSQ-based systems resembling dumbbell-shaped dendrimers are very rare in the literature.35
For this, we applied the developed sequence of hydrosilylation reaction (1.) with subsequent reduction (2.) using LiAlH4 that was verified in terms of di- and tetrafunctional DDSQ, e.g. to obtain G0-2D-2H. The 1H NMR spectrum of crude product pointed to the disappearance of resonance lines from vinyl groups at ca. 5.90–6.20 ppm. However, as there was no resonance line deriving from Si–H bond which supposed to be present at ca. 3.50–3.70 ppm, there was no evidence on the successful completion of Si–Cl to Si–H reduction. The solution for this was to replace the reducing agent from LiAlH4 to sodium bis(2-methoxyethoxy) aluminum hydride (Red-Al®). Red-Al® possesses two active reactive hydrogen atoms in its structure and is considered a milder reducing agent.55 In the procedure elaborated to yield G0-2D-2H the step Si–Cl to Si–H reduction (2.) was performed using 0.6 fold excess of Red-Al® per one reactive Si–Cl group in the DDSQ.
Despite the fact that reduction of Si–Cl to Si–H is a well-known reaction, it has never been verified in situ, so we decided to study this process using real-time FT-IR spectroscopy. The conducted experiment using G1-4D-8Cl (to gain G1-4D-8H), revealed that the consumption of Si–Cl with simultaneous formation of Si–H bonds proceeded extremely fast (Scheme 3). Specifically, it occurred immediately after the addition of Red-Al® which was evident from the appearance of a new band in the range of 880–970 cm−1 (Fig. 2a). We also observed a notable increase in the process temperature, from approximately 23 °C to 26 °C (Fig. 2b). However, the reaction was performed on a small scale, indicating that, for larger-scale synthesis, the addition of the reducing agent to the reaction mixture along with reaction time should be carefully controlled due to the exothermic nature of the process and possible diffusion issues.
Another problem to be solved was the isolation of the pure G0-2D-2H product with good yield. In general, the purification of SQ-based compounds can be performed using various techniques such as column chromatography, precipitation, extraction or their combination. Herein, at first, the crude G0-2D-2H product was precipitated in acetonitrile (MeCN). This is a good solvent in which Red-Al® is soluble, so could be easily decantated. G0-2D-2H was properly separated from the impurities by washing with DCM to dissolve the G0-2D-2H. After decantation and evaporation of DCM, pure G0-2D-2H product was obtained in 64% yield. This isolation procedure was described as Method I and is depicted in Fig. 3 and in Table 1. Interestingly, we found that using a higher excess of reducing agent (i.e. 1.5 equiv. of Red-Al®) did not improve the product yield, despite being tested for its impact.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Method I for isolating products from a reaction mixture from a reaction in which the reducing agent was Red-Al® for phenyl derivatives of DDSQ and T8. |
G0-2D-2H | G1-2D-4H | G0-4D-4H | G1-4D-8H | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Method I | 64% | 23% | 58% | 19% |
Method II | 90% | 85% | 94% | 91% |
The procedure developed for the effective formation of G0-2D-2H was transferred to other DDSQ compounds, e.g. to obtain G1-2D-4H (0.6 equiv. Red-Al® on the reactive group). Unfortunately, the isolation yield was unsatisfactory, i.e. only 23%. In this case, a different method of isolation was developed which includes a combination of different techniques. One of the procedures was a dropwise addition of the reaction mixture to cold isopropanol (iPrOH) to decompose Red-Al® followed by solvent evaporation. The crude product was filtered on a chromatography column with DCM as eluent. Another method was based also on iPrOH used for Red-Al® decomposition and washing of resulting precipitate with DCM to extract G1-2D-4H. However, none of the presented protocols provided a positive result in the increase of G1-2D-4H yield. Finally, as the crucial aspect is decomposition of Red-Al® and the fact that DDSQ compounds are not soluble in water, the extraction was performed using toluene and 10% acetic acid water solution. Surprisingly, this procedure enabled the isolation of G1-2D-4H in 85% yield and was described as Method II, shown in Fig. 4. All DDSQ-based dendrimers were isolated using both methods to compare their impact on the isolation yield, which was presented in Table 1. As a result, Method II based on the extraction using toluene and 10% acetic acid water solution significantly affected the isolation yields of verified compounds when compared to Method I.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Method II for isolating products from a reaction mixture from a reaction in which the reducing agent was Red-Al® for phenyl derivatives of DDSQ and T8. |
After optimizing the conditions for various SQ derivatives, we decided to apply the developed methodology for the functionalization of more challenging structures, namely spherosilicates bearing a significantly greater number of reactive Si–H species. The Pt-catalyzed hydrosilylation of trichlorovinylsilane with octakis(dimethyl-siloxy)silsesquioxane (octaT8-OSiH) followed by subsequent reduction of the Si–Cl intermediate in the presence of Red-Al® gave a mixture of isomers (β:
α = 64
:
36). This phenomenon was expected and also observed for other classes of SQs. However, the opposite approach based on the application of octakis(dimethylvinylsiloxy)silsesquioxane (octaT8-OSiVi) and trichlorosilane resulted in the regioselective formation of β isomer. The same behaviour was observed when the dichloromethylsilane and octaT8-OSiVi were used, which was corroborated by 1H, 13C and 29Si NMR analyses (Fig. S35–S37†). The outcomes of these experiments clearly indicated that the application of the chlorohydrosilanes and vinyl-SQ derivatives always leads to the anti-Markovnikov addition products (β isomer), regardless of the type of SQ structure and the number of reactive groups bonded to the SQ cage. Surprisingly, this observation has not been reported so far. The isolation procedure for octa-T8 derivatives relied on the decomposition of Red-Al® in 2-propanol followed by evaporation of the volatiles and subsequent product extraction by n-hexane. This simple methodology allowed us to isolate products with satisfactory yields i.e. >80% The synthesized novel derivative (G1-8T-16H), due to the easily accessible hydrosilyl units, opens possibilities for the synthesis of functionalized dendritic SQ-derivatives bearing sixteen organic groups around the cage, as well as the formation of a higher generation through the above-described one-pot protocol.
While searching for the most effective purification methodology enabling efficient product isolation, two methods were developed (Fig. 3 and 4) depending on the type of the SQ core. Method 1 involves the use of MeCN, a good precipitating solvent for silsesquioxanes. During the isolation of respective SQ derivatives, some crystal material of the following systems were obtained: G0-4D-4H and G1-2D-4H, which were amenable to XRD analysis. These two systems were found to be more susceptible to crystallization in MeCN when compared to other compounds. Perspective views of the molecules G0-4D-4H and G1-2D-4H are shown in Fig. 5a and b. The molecule G1-2D-4H is Ci-symmetrical, lying across the inversion center in the space group Pbca. As observed in similar structures, the geometry around Si atom is quite stable, as shown by the mean values and their esd's (Table 2). On the other hand, the range of Si–O–Si angles is quite extensive. In principle, the overall geometries and shapes of both open and closed structures are similar to those shown by us earlier.56,57
G0-4D-4H | G1-2D-4H | |
---|---|---|
〈Si–O〉 | 1.620(12) | 1.615(9) |
〈Si–C〉 | 1.858(23) | 1.845(8) |
〈Si–O–Si〉 | 147(7) | 155(7) |
Max (Si–O–Si) | 162.2(2) | 162.8(2) |
Min (Si–O–Si) | 138.5(2) | 141.7(2) |
〈O–Si–O〉 | 109.3(12) | 109.2(14) |
〈O–Si–C〉 | 109.2(18) | 109.4(14) |
〈C–Si–C〉 | 111(3) | 114.9(4) |
In the elaboration of the synthetic protocol for the DDSQ-based dendrimers based on Red-Al® instead of LiAlH4, some tests were performed to obtain mono-T8 systems with Ph inert groups, which exhibited some failures in the formation. It was decided to verify the methods using LiAlH4 and Red-Al® for these derivatives. In the beginning, a similar procedure to gain G0-1Ph-1H was conducted using LiAlH4 by analogy to the G0-1iBu-1H system. Unfortunately, similar lack of Si–H bond was observed on 1H NMR spectra. Analogous reduction protocol based on Red-Al® was applied and the desired products (G0-1Ph-1H and G1-1Ph-2H) were obtained with good yields. Both methods were validated to obtain G1-1Ph-2H. Interestingly, for this system, the use of LiAlH4 and Red-Al® made it possible to obtain a product with a yield of 45% and 60%, respectively, showing improvement for Red-Al®. The G1-1Ph-2H is again a good example of the fact that silsesquioxanes, due to their differences in architectures and presence of diverse inert groups should be approached individually. This concerns the synthetic protocol conditions for their formation as well as their isolation and purification.35,58
Although the product of double β-addition is the preferred substitution position in the synthesis of dendrimers during the hydrosilylation reaction, all of the products in this mixture have the G2 generation. For the β, β-product, a longer flexible, ethylene bridge reduces steric hindrance in subsequent generations. On the other hand, for the α, β- or α, α – systems, the reactive groups are available for further modification, though the steric hindrance may be an obstacle to further modification which may not proceed easily. Moreover, the same result was obtained when G1-8T-16H was used as a starting material in the synthesis of the SQ-based second dendrimer generation (G2-16T-32H) which was depicted in Scheme 5. This in turn confirms the previously emphasized conclusion describing the crucial role of the Si–H and Si–Vi location in reagents on the reaction regioselectivity. Nevertheless, the presence of α-regioisomers does not exclude their susceptibility to further functionalization through catalytic reactions.47,63,64
The GPC analysis may enable the determination of the dispersity of dendritic systems. The obtained chromatograms confirmed the monodispersity of all the obtained systems. It should be also emphasized that no increase in the value of the polydispersity index (PDI) was observed in any of the example. Its value is in the range of 1.08–1.24, which proves the high selectivity of the process without the formation of any duplex systems (see ESI†). Such relationships were observed for silsesquioxane-based dendritic systems.65–68
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, analytical data of isolated compounds. CCDC 2184824 and 2184825. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3qi00500c |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |