Solenne
Ritaine
ab,
Valentin
Ternel
a,
Patrice
Woisel
a,
Jerome P.
Claverie
*b and
Jonathan
Potier
*a
aUniv. Lille, CNRS, INRAE, Centrale Lille, UMR 8207 – UMET – Unité de Matériaux et Transformations, Lille F-59000, France. E-mail: jonathan.potier@univ-lille.fr
bChaire de Recherche du Canada en Chimie des Matériaux Organiques Avancés Université de Sherbrooke, 2500 Bd. de l’Université, Sherbrooke, QC J1K2R1, Canada. E-mail: Jerome.Claverie@USherbrooke.ca
First published on 28th June 2023
Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) continue to be one of the biggest problems for air quality and it is becoming increasingly urgent to find new systems capable of limiting their concentration in the atmosphere. Thanks to their capacity to recognize halogenated derivatives, Pillar[5]arenes were used to form high performance thermosets able to absorb chlorine and bromide-based VOCs. Initially, poly(2-vinyl-4,4-dimethylazlactone) featuring different chain length were synthetized and modified by ring opening reaction by mono-amino substituted P[5]A. The high-Tg polymers obtained were then crooslinked by isophore diamine to form high performance materials featuring Tg up to 150 °C and storac modulus G′ up to 85 MPa. The ability of P[5]A cavities to capt VOCs was investigated by vapor sorption tests in presence of dichloromethane, 1,2-dibromoethane, dibromochloromethane and 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane. The P[5]A-based thermosets shown to be efficient to absord these carcenogenic VOCs and, this efficiency depends on the affinity of cavities for the studied VOCs, proving that these new generation of thermosets seems to be selective towards certain VOCs.
Nowadays, a plethora of absorbents have been described in the literature, such as metal-organic frameworks,14 deep eutectic solvents,15 activated carbons,16 various functionalized polymers17,18 or fibers.12,19 All these technologies are clearly focused one their VOC absorption capacity but only a few of them have actually been integrated into an inexpensive material that can be easily handled, transported, stored and recycled. In this vein, proposing absorbent materials based on common plastics having high glass-transition temperature (Tg) and/or high storage modulus would certainly constitute an interesting strategy. Currently, only hypercrosslinked polymers (HCP) feature these characteristics.20 Mostly synthetized by Friedel–Crafts alkylation reaction, the extensive crosslinks give them a permanent porosity with high specific area (up to 1000 m2 g−1) allowing to absorb efficiently different groups of VOCs such as aromatic hydrocarbons or ketones.21,22 Although this strategy is remarkably successful, the pore size distribution in HCP cannot easily be controlled, resulting in absorbents which usually lack of selectivity.23 Thus, in this work, we examine whether a controlled microporosity can be controlled by installing rigid cavities of a given size within thermosetting polymers? Our attention turned to macrocycles-based systems which have been described in the literature as absorbents of pollutants.24–26 Among those, modified pillar[5]arenes, supramolecular receptors composed of hydroquinone units,27 have demonstrated high efficiency to recognize pollutants or herbicides.28–31 Pillar[5]arene (P[5]A) are very rigid and the aromatic constituents in their structure leads to the formation of strong complexes by π–H or π–π stacking with electron-poor guests such as paraquat, pyridinium and halogenated derivatives.32,33 Therefore, we propose to create a crosslinked material featuring high Tg and containing grafted P[5]A. In the past, copolymerization of P[5]A-based monomers was reported,34,35 here we propose an alternative approach based on the post-functionalization of poly(2-vinyl-4,4-dimethylazlactone) (PVDMA). PVDMA was chosen due to its capacity to be easily modified by ring-opening reaction using alcohol or amine functions.36,37 This strategy allowed us to obtain polymers with 50% of P[5]A as pendant groups via a simple reaction devoid of by-products. After neutralization and crosslinking with isophorone diamine (IPD), high-Tg thermosets were obtained which capture halogenated derivatives, leading to a mass increase as high as 33 wt%. Thus, we believe that thus strategy we have devised constitutes an interesting proof of principle that materials with controlled microporosity can be employed as efficient VOC absorbents.
Polymer or material | DPn (SEC) | % P[5]A | % Butylamine | % IPD | T g (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
PVDMA 1 | 89 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 124 |
PVDMA 2 | 261 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 182 |
1–0 | 89 | 0 | 90 | 10 | 132 |
1–30 | 89 | 30 | 60 | 10 | 144 |
1–50 | 89 | 50 | 40 | 10 | 135 |
2–0 | 261 | 0 | 90 | 10 | 134 |
2–30 | 261 | 30 | 60 | 10 | 152 |
2–50 | 261 | 50 | 40 | 10 | 147 |
Then different percentages of P[5]A-NH2 were grafted onto PVDMA as pendant group. As aforementioned, the azlactone rings are known to be easily opened by amine functions, forming stable amide functions (Fig. 1). These amides are more difficult to hydrolyze than ester functions we could have obtained if we had decided to use mono-hydroxyl P[5]A.
A DOSY NMR analysis was used to identify the extent of grafting. Indeed, for a PVDMA post-functionalized by 50% of P[5]A-NH2, an identical diffusion coefficient was observed for both polymer chains and P[5]A-NH2 confirming the presence of a single compound (Fig. S18, ESI†). On the other hand, for a PDVMA containing 60% of P[5]A-NH2, two different diffusion coefficients were observed for the P[5]A-NH2 peaks, proving that a low percentage was not graft onto the polymer chain (Fig. S19, ESI†). The failed attempt to reach P[5]A-grafting higher than one out of two VDMA units is probably due to the steric hindrance resulting from bulky P[5]A structure.41 Beyond DOSY NMR, a SEC chromatography was performed to prove the modification of the polymer and an increase of its number molecular weight average. As an example, Fig. 2 shows a polymer post-functionalized with 50% of P[5]A-NH2 and the PVDMA from which it was derived.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 SEC results obtained for PVDMA DPn = 89 (blue) and after functionalization by 50% P[5]A-NH2 (green). |
Once the grafting of P[5]A-NH2 was completed, it was necessary to neutralize the rest of the azlactone rings unreacted in the chain. For this neutralization, butylamine was selected among other candidates such as dodecylamine. Indeed, it is a good compromise allowing to reduce the possibility to create complex between the alkyl chain and the P[5]A cavity, compared to dodecylamine.42 After reaction with butylamine, only 10 mol% of azlactone rings were left unreacted, which could be used for crosslinking (Fig. 3). Therefore, the crosslinking step consisted in the addition of 10 mol% of isophorone diamine (IPD). IPD was chosen as crosslinker for its low toxicity regarding human health and the environment.43 At the end, four thermosets were finally obtained from the two initial PVDMA. Indeed, two different percentages of P[5]A-NH2 (30% and 50%) were grafted onto the two different chain lengths PVDMA and so, 60% or 40% of butylamine were added to neutralize the other azlactone cycles finishing by the crosslinking process.
All these thermosets were characterized by DSC like their intermediates (Table 1 and Fig. S15, S16, ESI†). Regardless of the chain length of the precursor polymer or the percentage of P[5]A, relatively close Tg were determined (between 135 and 152 °C). By adding pendant groups like P[5]A and butylamine, an expected decrease of Tg was observed (Fig. S15, ESI†) and a light increase was logically obtained after the crosslinking.
A simple calculation allowed us to determine the theoretical absorption percentage that the P[5]A can allow (eqn (1)). Note that we use the word “absorption” because VOCs are capture in the bulk of the material, but the word “adsorption” is equally used in literature to refer to the same phenomenon. Eqn (1) works if we take into consideration that, according to the literature, only one VOC molecule can be recognized by one P[5]A cavity (1:
1 host/guest complex).
![]() | (1) |
As the chain length is not relevant to this calculation, we obtained the same results for materials 1–30 and 2–30 or for 1–50 and 2–50. Indeed, for materials containing 30% of P[5]A, theoretical absorption percentages of 6%, 13%, 14.5% and 12% were determined for VOC A, B, C and D respectively while 7.5%, 16.5%, 18% and 15% were calculated in case of 1–50 and 2–50, However, the theoretical absorption percentage of the materials is not fully taken into account in eqn (1) as PVDMA alone (i.e. devoid of P[5]A) can absorb VOC vapors. This absorption was determined experimentally by testing materials 1–0 and 2–0 under VOCs (A, B, C and D) atmosphere. After 1 days of vapor sorption, plateaus were observed for each VOCs (Fig. S24–S29 and Table S1, ESI†) and no significant difference was observed with the increase of the chain length. Finally, the maximum theoretical absorption percentage of the materials could be predicted (eqn (2)) by adding the amount absorbed in the polymer to the amount calculated from eqn (1) (Table 2):
![]() | (2) |
Experimentally, vapor sorption was performed for each VOC. For this, each material was previously dried under vacuum for one night to avoid possible presence of other solvents in the material before the analysis. The dried thermosets were then suspended in a vial containing 1 mL of VOC. The materials were then weighed every day to determine the weight change and extrapolate the experimental absorption percentage of VOC.
First of all, the impact of the chain length was investigated. Vapor sorption of A and D was performed by using 1–30 and 2–30. At most, 2% deviation was observed between both materials (Fig. S24 and S25, ESI†). Whether in terms of thermal or sorption properties, the chain length has no impact.
Then, the impact of the P[5]A cavities was verified (Fig. 4): for all VOCs, the amount of absorbed VOC increases with the amount of P[5]A contained in the material. For the case of VOC A by the material 2–50 (red points on Fig. 4(a)), it takes 4 days to saturate the material with VOC: at this point, the mass increase is of 8.5%, which compares well with the 7.5% predicted by eqn (2) (shown by the dotted line in Fig. 4a). The same observation can be made for the material 2–30 and for the VOCs C and D. However, in the case of VOC B, the plateau occurs after 7 days and an absorption percentage of 53% was observed instead of the predicted 31.5%. As P[5]A and B (1,2-dibromoethane) forms a 1:
1 complex (Fig. S22 and S23, ESI†), this result can be justified by the formation of sandwiches within the system.46,47 Indeed, B can form a complex with P[5]A featuring a high Ka up to 2 900 M−1 while A forms a much weaker complex (Ka = 120 M−1), as determined in literature.48 This strong affinity between the cavities and B can lead to the formation of a super structures where a molecule of B is trapped between two filled cavities, like a sandwich. This self-assembly can occur when the cavities are sufficiently close to each other like in the 2–50. But, in the case of 2–30, the cavities are too far away, the sandwich cannot be formed and therefore, the measured absorption percentage is in good agreement with the one predicted by eqn (2).
All these results confirm that these thermosets have the capacity to capture VOCs, in amounts which depends both on the percentage of grafted P[5]A and on the affinity between the P[5]A and the VOC.
More interestingly, the selectivity factors observed with these thermosets are higher than other systems described in the literature. Indeed, factors up to 6 between VOC B and VOC A (Fig. S34, ESI†) were observed while pillared clay-based systems proposed by Pires et al. showed factors lower than 1.5 between two halogenated hydrocarbons.49 Another essential study, to correlate the thermosets to future applications, is to determine if the captured VOCs remain within the material or if they are released over time.
To realize this study, 10 mg of VOCs were first captured by 2–30 and 2–50. After 7 days in open air, the mass of the remaining mass of the materials were determined (Fig. 5). As a control sample, 10 mg of VOCs were disposed in a tared vial and weighed after 7 days.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Remaining mass of VOCs A, B, C and D in materials 2–30 (green) and 2–50 (red) and without material (blue) after 7 days in open air. |
Without materials, all VOCs were evaporated. All the dichloromethane (A) was released from the different materials. This can be explained by the low association constants found in the literature between A and P[5]A compared to bromine derivatives50 and by the low boiling point of A. By contrast, the three other VOCs remained trapped in the materials, since more than 80% of mass were retained after 7 days.
It should be noted that in the case of VOC B, the 2–50 material retained less VOC than 2–30. This may be assigned again to the presence of sandwich-type structures. Indeed, the VOCs trapped between two different cavities are not as strongly retained as those contained in the cavities and are therefore released faster.
Moreover, the reusability of the materials for capturing VOCs was investigated using VOC A as the model as its removing under vacuum was more efficient than the other VOC.
For this, the materials were placed in a vacuum oven overnight and they were placed for 7 days under A atmosphere. It can be seen that, after five absorption cycles, the capture ability of the three materials 2–0, 2–30 and 2–50 for A vapor shoved no obvious change (Fig. 6), demonstrating their good reusability for capturing VOCs.
In addition, an analysis allowing to observe the impact of the VOC on the thermal properties of the material was carried out. For this purpose, the material 2–50 placed in a B atmosphere was chosen. Indeed, being the material capturing the most quantity of VOCs, it is then likely to see its thermal properties the most impacted. By comparing the DSC of the material before (Tg = 147 °C) and after (Tg = 144 °C) absorption, no change of the thermal properties was observed since the Tg remains identical (Fig. S17, ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Storage modulus G′ versus temperature of materials 2–0 (![]() ![]() ![]() |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3nj02422a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique 2023 |