Open Access Article
Sara
La Manna
a,
Valentina
Roviello
b,
Vittoria
Monaco
cd,
James A.
Platts
e,
Maria
Monti
cd,
Elisabetta
Gabano
f,
Mauro
Ravera
g and
Daniela
Marasco
*a
aDepartment of Pharmacy, University of Naples Federico II, 80131, Naples, Italy. E-mail: daniela.marasco@unina.it; Tel: +39-081-2532043
bDepartment of Chemical, Materials, and Industrial Production Engineering (DICMaPI), University of Naples Federico II, 80125 Naples, Italy
cDepartment of Chemical Sciences, University of Naples Federico II, 80126, Naples, Italy
dCEINGE Biotecnologie Avanzate “Franco Salvatore” S.c.a r.l., 80131, Naples, Italy
eSchool of Chemistry, Cardiff University, Park Place, Cardiff, CF10 3AT, UK
fDipartimento per lo Sviluppo Sostenibile e la Transizione Ecologica, University of Piemonte Orientale, Piazza S. Eusebio 5, 13100, Vercelli, Italy
gDepartment of Sciences and Technological Innovation, University of Piemonte Orientale, Viale Michel 11, 15121 Alessandria, Italy
First published on 25th August 2023
Platinum (Pt)(II) square planar complexes are well-known anticancer drugs whose Mechanism of Action (MOA) are finely tuned by the polar, hydrophobic and aromatic features of the ligands. In the attempt to translate this tunability to the identification of potential neurodrugs, herein, four Pt(II) complexes were investigated in their ability to modulate the self-aggregation processes of two amyloidogenic models: Sup35p7–13 and NPM1264–277 peptides. In particular, phenanthriplatin revealed the most efficient agent in the modulation of amyloid aggregation: through several biophysical assays, as Thioflavin T (ThT), electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) absorption spectroscopy, this complex revealed able to markedly suppress aggregation and to disassemble small soluble aggregates. This effect was due to a direct coordination of phenanthriplatin to the amyloid, with the loss of several ligands and different stoichiometries, by the formation of π–π and π–cation interactions as indicated from molecular dynamic simulations. Presented data support a growing and recent approach concerning the repurposing of metallodrugs as potential novel neurotherapeutics.
The self- or hetero-assembly of amyloidogenic systems, as the Aβ-amyloid (Amyloid beta (Aβ or Abeta)), α-synuclein, huntingtin, tau and islet amyloid polypeptides, to form oligomers and fibrils is directly linked to NDDs as Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, and Huntington's diseases, frontotemporal dementia and type II diabetes.5 Often the structural details of the oligomers/fibers formed by full-length proteins are elusive and very difficult to study, while, the investigations of the self-assemblies of protein fragments, as model, allow to deepen structural, biophysical and biological properties of in vivo amyloids.5
In the context of drug discovery processes in early steps of amyloid aggregation, metallodrugs can be employed. After the pioneering study of Barnham et al.6 many Pt complexes were investigated for their inhibitory properties of amyloid aggregation:7 examples can be traced back to complexes containing heteroaromatic ligands such as pyridine or its derivatives,8 imidazole,9 thiazole, pyrazoles, quinoline and isoquinoline, tetrazoles and triazoles.10 In detail, phenanthroline(phen)-Pt(II) complexes with two monodentate ligands exhibited inhibitory effects toward the aggregation of Aβ1–4011 and prion protein (PrP) fragments.12 The inhibition mechanism depends on multiple factors as the coordination of the metal center, the 1st and 2nd electrostatic spheres around the ion, hydrogen bond networks and van der Waals interactions. Examples of multifactorial amyloid inhibition are several Co-13 and Pt-compounds14 bearing polyaromatic ligands: they demonstrated reduction of Aβ aggregation through a coordinative mechanisms aided by the formation of π–π stacking interactions with aromatic side chains.15 Two glycoconjugate pentacoordinate Pt-complexes were analyzed in their capacity to affect the self-aggregation processes of two fragments of the C-terminal region of Aβ-peptide, Aβ21–40 and Aβ25–35. The water-soluble complex, named 1Ptdep, inhibited the aggregates through the direct binding to Aβ-peptides, drastically reducing the morphological amyloid features of fibers.16
On the basis of these promising results, herein we investigated the ability of four Pt(II) complexes to modulate the aggregation of two amyloid models, NPM1264–277 and Sup35p7–13, whose sequences are reported in Table 1. In the screening of agents able to modulate amyloid aggregation, often protein/peptide, even if not directly involved in neurodegeneration, are employed as models of amyloids. This is the case of Nucleophosmin 1 (NPM1), which is not an amyloid protein strictly speaking, but presents an amyloid-prone fragment, including 264–277 residues.17 In the recent past, we tested the ability of several metal-based CORM (carbon monoxide releasing molecules) to modulate the amyloid aggregation NPM1264–277.18,19 Conversely, the heptapetide GNNQQNY, spanning residues 7–13 of the Yeast Prion Protein Sup35p (Sup35p7–13), is directly involved in the aggregation of Sup35p since it is located in the prion-determining N-terminal domain (PrD),20 which demonstrated able to form amyloid fibrils.21,22
| Peptide | Sequence |
|---|---|
| NPM1264–277 | Ac-VEAKFINYVKNCFR-NH2 |
| Sup35p7–13 | Ac-GNNQQNY-NH2 |
In a recent study, we have investigated the ability of a series of square planar Pt(II)-complexes to inhibit the aggregation of amyloid peptides. The pyridine-based cationic, [PtCl(tpy)]+, called Pt-terpy, exhibited good inhibitory effects and the ability to reduce the cytotoxicity of amyloid in human SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells.23 To deepen the MOAs of similar compounds, in the present study we investigated the effects of square planar Pt(II) complexes differing in their charge: positive for two complexes and neutral for other two compounds. In detail, we analyzed the (SP-4-3)-diamminechlorido (quinoline)platinum(II) nitrate (quinoplatin, 1) and (SP-4-3)-diamminechlorido(phenanthridine)platinum(II) nitrate (phenanthriplatin, 2)24 and the enantiomeric (SP-4-2)-dichlorido(1,1′-binaphthalene-2,2′-diamine)platinum(II), 3R and 3S, respectively (Fig. 1). These complexes contain a chiral ligand (i.e., 1,1′-binaphthalene-2,2′-diamine, DABN) and the R isomer demonstrated to interact with the G-quadruplex structure AG3(TTAGGG)3 less efficiently than its S counterpart.25–27
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Structure of the Pt(II) complexes investigated in the present work; DABN = 1,1′-binaphthalene-2,2′-diamine. | ||
The ability of Pt(II) complexes to interfere with the aggregation of amyloid models was investigated via a range of spectroscopic and biophysical techniques as wells as by molecular dynamic (MD) studies.
:
1 molar ratio and the reaction was stirred for 16 h at 55 °C. The following purification steps gave 1 and 2 as white solids (yield: 70% and 59% for 1 and 2, respectively).26 Complexes 3R and 3S were synthesized directly by reacting equimolar quantities of K2PtCl4 and the R- or S-isomers of 1,1′-binaphthalene-2,2′-diamine (DABN) in DMF at 40 °C in the dark overnight. The following purification steps gave 3R and 3S as yellow solids (yield: 78% and 72% for the R and S-isomers counterparts, respectively).26 The stabilities of Pt complexes were already reported in ref. 25–27
:
2.5 complex
:
NPM1264–277. Spectra were registered in the 250–500 nm range, upon each addition. For 2, EC50 value was derived from non-linear regression of the data employing log [inhibitor] vs. response and “dose–response stimulation equation” of GraphPad program.
:
1 molar ratio with metal complexes, were registered on a Jasco J-815 spectropolarimeter (JASCO, Tokyo, Japan), at 25 °C using a 0.1 cm path-length quartz cuvette. Deconvolutions of CD spectra were obtained by BESTSEL software (https://bestsel.elte.hu/).
:
5 ratios with 2 compound and the obtained mixtures were analyzed by native ESI-MS on a Q-ToF Premier (Waters, Milliford, MA, USA) mass spectrometer. The analyses were carried out by direct injection at 10 μL min−1, setting the source parameters at 3 kV for capillary voltage and 42 kV for cone voltage. The acquisition range was scanned from 100 to 2000 m/z in 1 s and the raw data were processed with MassLynx 4.1 software (Waters, Milliford, MA, USA). Fosforic acid solution at 50% (v/v) in acetonitrile was used for the instrument calibration.
:
5 ratio, at two different times of aggregation (t 2 h for 3S and 4 h for 1 and 2), were dropped on stubs and introduced into chamber of field emission scanning (Nova NanoSem 450 FEI/ThermoFisher Scientific), to obtain SEM micrographs at 3.00 and 5.00 kV in high vacuum mode, with an Everhart Thornley Detector (ETD) and the Through the Lens Detector (TLD).
28 using the tleap utility, assigning parameters for the ff14SB29 forcefield in GBSA implicit model of aqueous solvation. For Pt-bound peptide, parameters for metal, ligands and bound Cys were obtained using the MCPB.py30 approach, in which bonded parameters were extracted from DFT calculations using the Seminario method,31 while non-bonded parameters were taken from RESP calculations. These were combined with ff14SB for proper comparison with metal-free simulations, and key data are reported in the Table S2.† All systems were minimised with 1000 steps of steepest descent. Three independent MD trajectories were then generated, first by heating to 300 K over 1 ns with a further 1 ns equilibration, both with positional restraints on all atoms, then with 100 ns of unrestrained MD. RMSD data (ESI Fig. S1†) indicate that stable trajectories were established within a few ns. Analysis of all 300 ns of trajectory data was performed using cpptraj,25 concentrating on secondary structure and clustering: the latter using a k-means approach with 10 clusters.
:
Pt-complex molar ratios were analyzed, 1
:
1 and 1
:
5. For NPM1264–277, in the absence of complexes, the starting value of fluorescence was different from 0 for an immediate partial oligomerization during sample preparation17 (Fig. 2A and B) and the time intervals required to reach saturated ThT signal appeared fast, ∼10 min, while a slight delay is observed, ∼1.5 h, for the presence of DMSO (Fig. 2C and D) that is the control condition required for compounds 3R and 3S. From the comparison of time-course profiles, all complexes were able to inhibit the aggregation of NPM1264–277 even if to different extents: between the charged complexes, the most effective inhibitor was found to be complex 2, since it inhibited NPM1264–277 aggregation of ∼50% at 1
:
1 and ∼70% at 1
:
5 ratio (Fig. 2B), whereas the inhibitory effect of 1 was significantly less at both ratios (Fig. 2A). Unlike 1 and 2, no difference in the inhibition effects of 3R and 3S was detected that was of ∼50%; for both compounds in both ratios (Fig. 2C and D).
By comparing aggregation times of NPM1264–277 and Sup35p7–13 peptides alone, great differences are observable: indeed in the case of Sup35p7–13, the time of the half reduction of the signal in the amyloid growth phase, named t½, was evaluated of ∼2.5 h (Fig. 2E and F). Noticeably the sudden decrease of folded fraction after ∼2.5 h is likely due formation of less soluble species. Thus, differently from NPM1264–277, these features hamper performance of inhibitory assays with 3R and 3S complexes which are stable for only two hours.26 Consequently, the effects of only complexes 1 and 2 preincubated with Sup35p7–13 were evaluated. Compound 1 appeared almost ineffective while 2 showed an inhibition of ∼75% (Fig. 2E and F), at both molar ratios. No interference signals with ThT were observed for all complexes for the entire durations of the analyses.
Having assessed the different abilities of metal complexes to suppress amyloid aggregation, we evaluated if they are also able to disaggregate soluble pre-formed oligomers,33 monitoring the ThT signals after the addition of metal compounds to NPM1264–277 and Sup35p7–13 aggregates at 1
:
5 ratio (Fig. 3). On the basis of different aggregation kinetics (see above), Sup35p7–13 was pre-aggregated in the absence of the complexes for 3 hours, while NPM1264–277, which is partially aggregated at t = 0, was allowed to further aggregate for 10 min before starting experiments. Upon the addition of Pt-complexes to both amyloids, a decrease in ThT fluorescence intensity was observed with a greater effect of 2 with respect to 1. Indeed, while the addition of 1 caused a disaggregating effect on NPM1264–277 and Sup35p7–13 of 30% and 60%, respectively, 2 showed a stronger effect by inducing a reduction of 40% and 70%, respectively. Also the neutral complexes 3R and 3S showed a strong disaggregating capacity that led to a reduction of ThT signal of ∼60% for NPM1264–277 and 45% for Sup35p7–13.
On the basis of similar effects of Pt-complexes observed on NPM1264–277 and Sup35p7–13, we focused only on NPM1264–277, since its longer sequence with respect to the heptapeptide Sup35p7–13, makes it more sensitive in subsequent conformational studies. ThT results indicated similar inhibitory effects provided similar inhibitory effects, hence we continued with compounds 1 and 2 which demonstrated more stable during time.26
To assess whether observed inhibitory effects of Pt-complexes could be accompanied by variations of ligands’ field around metal center, changes in the UV-vis absorption spectra34–37 were evaluated, upon the addition of NPM1264–277 to aqueous solutions of 1 and 2 at a fixed concentration. These experiments, reported in Fig. 4, confirmed different behaviors for 1 and 2. In fact, the titration with NPM1264–277 of 2 (Fig. 4B) exhibited marked variations of intensity of several absorption bands. In detail the LMCT band at 311 nm (ref. 37) provided saturated values of absorbance at 1
:
2.5 complex
:
peptide ratio and an estimation of EC50 (half-maximal effective concentration) of 26 ± 3 μM (inset of Fig. 4B). On the contrary, the same experiments carried out for 1 did not show significant variations of absorbances at 309 nm (Fig. 4A).
:
1 ratio, recorded over a period of 12 h, are reported in Fig. 5. For NPM1264–277 alone, a clear transition from a mixed α-helix and β-structure (Fig. 5A) toward a prevalent β-conformation is observable, as well as a decrease of Cotton effect due to aggregation, as previously reported.38 The presence of 2 complex, already at t = 0 h, stabilized β-conformation leading to the highest β content at 3 h of analysis (Fig. 5C), as confirmed by deconvolution percentages of spectra reported in Table S1.† On the contrary, the sample of NPM1264–277 + 1 exhibited a time-evolution of CD profile more similar to that of the peptide alone (Fig. 5B).
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Overlay of CD spectra of NPM1264–277 (A) alone and incubated with 1 (B) and 2 (C), at 1 : 1 peptide: Pt(II) compound molar ratio. | ||
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Effects of Pt-complexes on amyloid fibers. SEM micrographs of (A–A′′) NPM1264–277 + 2, (B–B′′) NPM1264–277 + 3S at 1 : 5 ratio, at (A and B) 1 mm, (A′ and B′) 50 μm and (A′′ and B′′) 5 μm. | ||
:
1 stoichiometry, in which the Pt-complex lost one Cl− and one NH3 ligand. Instead, peaks #2 and #3 are attributed to adducts with a 1
:
2 stoichiometry, peptide: 2: #2 is related to the adduct among one peptide chain and two 2 moieties lacking 3 × NH3, while #3 corresponds to the #2 carrying one additional acetate ion, which is present in the buffer. As already reported,19 the presence of Cys275, allow the formation of dimeric forms of the amyloid peptide, already at t = 0.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 2 compound interacts with NPM1264–277. ESI-MS spectra of NPM1264–277 peptide incubated with 2 compound at (A) t = 0 h, and (B) t = 4 h. | ||
| Experimental conditions | Experimental m/z | Charge | Theoretical m/z | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NPM1264–277 + 2, 0 h | 1080.483 | 2 | 1081.63 | NPM1264–277 + 2–1Cl−–1 NH3 | #1 |
| 1305.039 | 2 | 1305.26 | NPM1264–277 + 2 2–3 NH3 | #2 | |
| 1335.087 | 2 | 1335.773 | #2 + acetate | #3 | |
| 1180.955 | 3 | 1180.931 | NPM1264–277 covalent dimer | ||
| NPM1264–277 + 2, 4 h | 1080.483 | 2 | 1081.63 | NPM1264–277 + 2–1Cl−–1 NH3 | #1 |
| 1305.039 | 2 | 1305.26 | NPM1264–277 + 2 2–3 NH3 | #2 | |
| 1335.087 | 2 | 1335.773 | #2 + acetate | #3 | |
| 1180.955 | 3 | 1180.931 | NPM1264–277 covalent dimer | ||
The presence of 2 bound to Cys275 drastically changes the conformational preferences of both monomer and dimer. The Pt-bound monomer (Fig. 8C) exhibits almost no helical character indeed the dictionary of protein secondary structure (DSSP) algorithm identifying only turn and bend elements42 suggesting that the presence of the large Pt complex disrupts the helical organization of the isolated peptide. Similarly, the anti-parallel dimer appears strongly inhibited by the binding of 2 (Fig. 8D). In this case, some recorded frames contain β-strands, but these are smaller and shorter-lived than in the metal-free case. The maximum strand content is 22% of all recorded frames and is found for Phe268 of chain A and Phe276 of chain B. Closer analysis indicates the occurrence of several non-covalent interactions between 2 and the peptide chain in addition to the coordination bond to Cys275. These connections include C–H⋯π interactions between Lys and the aromatic ligand of 2, as well as hydrogen bonds from ammine ligands to backbone nitrogens of Val, Glu and Arg. The lack of a precise agreement between the ESI† data and the MD data is due to different phases, gas and aqueous buffer, and ratios of peptide to 2 complex.
In conclusion this research provides critical information on the inhibition and disaggregation of amyloid fibrillation by phenanthroline-based metal complexes with impact on the biomedical value of clinical platinum drugs against amyloid diseases.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: SEM micrographs of NPM1264–277 + 1, at 1 : 5 ratio, at 1 mm, and 300 μm; time evolution of RMSD relative to initial extended structure; time evolution of secondary structure in metal-free monomer and dimer MD simulation; deconvolution of CD spectra; bonded parameters from MCPB.py for 2 bound to Cys12. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3dt02187d |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |