N. Tan
Luong
,
Hanna
Oderstad
,
Michael
Holmboe
and
Jean-François
Boily
*
Department of Chemistry, Umeå University, Umeå SE-901 87, Sweden. E-mail: jean-francois.boily@umu.se
First published on 22nd May 2023
Water films captured in the interlayer region of birnessite (MnO2) nanosheets can play important roles in biogeochemical cycling, catalysis, energy storage, and even atmospheric water harvesting. Understanding the temperature-dependent loadings and properties of these interlayer films is crucial to comprehend birnessite reactivity when exposed to moist air and temperature gradients. Using vibrational spectroscopy we show that birnessite intercalates one water (1W) monolayer at up to ∼40 °C, but that loadings decrease by half at up to 85 °C. Our results also show that the vibrational properties of intercalated water are unaffected by temperature, implying that the hydrogen bonding network of water remains intact. Using molecular simulations, we found that the lowered water storage capacity at high temperatures cannot be explained by variations in hydrogen bond numbers or in the solvation environments of interlayer K+ ions initially present in the interlayer region. It can instead be explained by the compounded effects of larger evolved heat, as inferred from immersion energies, and by the larger temperature-driven mobility of water over that of K+ ions, which are electrostatically bound to birnessite basal oxygens. By shedding new light on the temperature-driven intercalation of water in a nanolayered mineral, this study can guide future efforts to understand the (geo)chemical reactivity of related materials in natural and technological settings.
Intercalated films greatly control birnessite stability5,6 and water-driven processes, including electron transfer and ion exchange. Works on molecular orientations,7 cation–water interactions,5,6,8 thermal stability,5,6,9 and populations4 of this internal hydration environment advanced the knowledge needed for understanding reactions of importance to nature and technology. Examples of these applications include mass transport reactivity in (bio)geochemistry,10–14 water desalination15 and purification,16 removal of air-bone organic contaminants,17,18 catalysis,19 water oxidation,20 batteries,21,22 nuclear waste management,23 and atmospheric water harvesting.24
Birnessite formed in aqueous solutions usually intercalate one (1W; 7 Å birnessite) to two (2W; 10 Å birnessite, or buserite) water monolayers.4 Interlayer ordering is typically controlled by MnO6 basal sheet crystallinity.25 At high levels of crystallinity, water molecules have minimal water–water interactions and establish only one hydrogen bond with OB sites exposed on MnO6 basal sheets (Fig. 1). They also serve as the first hydration shell to intercalate cations (e.g. K+ in K+-birnessite).4,6,7 Interlayer identity can, at the same time, influence the thermal stability of the hydration layer. For example, monovalent cations promote dehydration at lower temperatures than divalent cations.6 Removing water from the interlayer promotes, in turn, structural disordered birnessite at a temperature of 200 °C in Li+-birnessite or even a cryptomelane-like (KMn8O16) structure in K+-birnessite at 400–600 °C.5 Birnessite that underwent dehydration, yet that retained its crystallographic structure, can only be rehydrated up to a single monolayer (1W = 1.33 H2O per unit cell) when exposed to moist air under ambient conditions.4 Previous studies4–6,25,26 revealed the structure, stability and reactivity of intercalated water films. However, some studies were conducted under extreme conditions of temperature and pressure,5,6 which may have a compromised birnessite structure.
This study focuses on investigating the thermal behaviours of intercalated water in birnessite,4,27 and is built upon a previous study by our group on these reactions at 25 °C.4 In this work, we focused on K+-birnessite because it dehydrates at low temperature while its structure remains unchanged at temperatures as high as 400 °C.5,6 We used vibrational spectroscopy to monitor the ability of K+-birnessite to trap and release water vapour across a range of temperatures. Molecular simulations provided new insights into the temperature-resolved properties of intercalated water. As temperature is a critical factor in controlling the reaction kinetics, this work serves as a basis for further studies on the behaviour of birnessite in hot and moist air.
A portion of the sample was oven-dried at 60 °C for particle characterization, and a detailed account of which was already presented in our previous study.4 Briefly, the solid phase was a low crystalline birnessite phase with a Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (B.E.T.)29 specific surface area of 59.2 m2 g−1. From X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), the particles had a surface Mn:
O
:
K composition of 1.00
:
1.49
:
0.20. We note that the O/Mn ratio was lower than the expected stoichiometric value of 2 because XPS probes the topmost 10 nm region of the samples, and because of the loss of chemisorbed water under ultra-vacuum conditions. XPS also revealed that the surface of birnessite had a Mn atomic oxidation state (AOS) of 3.69. Using the method of Ilton et al.30 this AOS arises from a mixture of 72% MnIV, 25% MnIII, and 3% MnII.
Centrifuged wet pastes of birnessite were deposited on the diamond window of an attenuated total reflectance (ATR) cell (Golden Gate N29328 by Specac). This ATR cell was equipped with a heating unit enabling measurements at a temperature of 80 °C. The wet birnessite film was then covered with a modified Golden Gate cryo-chamber equipped with a gas inlet and an outlet, enabling a flow of 500 mL min−1 N2(g) over the sample. Prior to each experiment, wet pastes were first dried and then equilibrated under a steam dry N2(g) at pre-selected temperatures in the range of 30–80 °C (30, 40, 50, 60, 70, and 80 °C). FTIR spectra were thereafter collected to monitor the loss of water using the absorbances of the O–H stretching and bending bands of water.
Water vapour adsorption/desorption isotherms were then collected at each temperature by exposing birnessite to a 500 mL min−1 flow of 10 pre-selected partial pressures of H2O in the range of 0–3.11 kPa (i.e. 0.4–95% relative humidity at 25 °C) with 98.2–101.3 kPa N2 (g). A 1 h equilibration period was allowed between each change in H2O content. These gases were prepared at 25 °C by mixing pre-determined proportions of humid N2 (g) produced from a humidity generator module (proUmid MHG32) with dry N2 (g). Water vapour pressures were continuously monitored using both a sensor equipped with the module and a nondispersive InfraRed device (LI-7000, Licor Inc).
To study the temperature-resolved changes in the birnessite-bound water, we analysed the O–H stretching and bending vibrational regions by spectral deconvolution. Following preliminary efforts testing various distribution functions, we found that absorbances of the O–H stretching region (AO–H) were best modelled by a linear combination of Gaussian components:
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
All simulations were carried out using GROMACS,32 using a 1.0 nm cutoff for the direct van der Waals and Coulombic interactions. Long-range Coulombic interactions were treated using the particle-mesh Ewald (PME) method. The birnessite lattice was, just as in our recent study,4 modelled with Mn3.75+ as in the study of Cygan et al..33 However, using the recently reported Lennard–Jones forcefield parameters of Newton and Kwon,34 water was simulated using the SPC/E model,35 and K+ ions were simulated with SPC/E compatible ion-pair potentials from the study of Joung and Cheatham.36
Simulation results were thereafter analysed for d001, hydrogen bonding, K+–O coordination, and K+ and water diffusion coefficients. Diffusion coefficients were calculated with the Gromacs utility gmx msd from 3 ns production runs over individual 250 ps segments, omitting the first 50 ps in each. Comparison of diffusion coefficients obtained in the canonical (NVT) ensemble confirmed that the short simulations and large box sizes did not introduce deviations in values that could otherwise be expected37 from the simulation run in the NPT ensemble (Fig. S2, ESI†).
Finally, energetics of stable hydration states were determined using the following equation:38,39
Q(N) = U(N) − U(N°) − Ubulk(N − N°) | (3) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a)–(d) FTIR spectra of birnessite exposed to a 500 mL min−1 flow of 0–3.11 kPa H2O in N2(g) (a total pressure of 101 kPa) during the adsorption leg. See Fig. S3 (ESI†) for the complete data set for both adsorption and desorption legs at all temperatures. All absorbances were normalised for the quantity of MnO2 based on the absorbance of the Mn–O stretching band at 600 cm−1 (Fig. S1, ESI†). (e) and (f) Integrated band areas of all normalised spectra of Fig. S3 (ESI†) (ADS = adsorption; DES = desorption) in the (e) O–H stretching and (f) water bending regions. (g) Microgravimetric and model predictions from our previous work4 showing the relative concentrations of intercalated, adsorbed and condensed water at 25 °C. |
Vapour pressure- and temperature-dependent water loadings were more clearly captured using the integrated normalised absorbances of both O–H stretching (Fig. 2e) and water bending (Fig. 2f) regions. First, the shape of these spectroscopically derived adsorption isotherms was consistent with our previous4 microgravimetric data (Fig. 2g). Both revealed a type II adsorption/desorption40 isotherm, with comparable hysteresis in the desorption leg. Our previous modelling efforts4 expressed water uptake chiefly in terms of intercalated water, reaching a maximum coverage of a single water monolayer (1W) at a high humidity (∼1.33 H2O per unit cell (UC)). Adsorbed and condensed water accounted for a smaller fraction of water, with the latter accounting for the larger loadings at high humidity only. From the absorbances of the vibrational spectra, we also found that water loadings were lowered by ∼50% at temperatures exceeding ∼40 °C (Fig. 2e and f). These temperature-adjusted isotherms also showed that even atmospherically relevant partial pressures of water (e.g. up to 3.11 kPa H2O) at high temperatures could not saturate the interlayer region of birnessite with water. Saturation at temperatures exceeding 40 °C can, as such, only be achieved in pressurised environments or in liquid water.
To deepen our understanding of the humidity dependence of intercalated water, the O–H stretching (ν1) and water bending (ν2) regions were resolved by spectral deconvolution (Fig. 3 and 4, and Fig. S4, ESI†). The O–H stretching region was modelled at all temperatures in terms of (Gaussian-shaped; eqn (1)) bands at (i) 3574 ± 15 cm−1 from free (isolated) O–H bonds of water bonded to basal oxygens (OB; Fig. 1) of the interlayer region, (ii) 3470 ± 9 cm−1 from hydrogen-bonded water (weak intermolecular coupling41,42), (iii) 3276 ± 30 cm−1 from hydrogen-bonded water (strong intermolecular coupling41,42) and Fermi resonance (2 ν2) of the water bending mode (ν2 = 1622 cm−1), and (iv) 3189 ± 2 cm−1 likely representing a distinct sub-population of intercalated hydrogen-bonded water molecules. Band positions were not greatly affected by temperature (Fig. S4, ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Band deconvolution of the O–H stretching (a)–(c) and water bending (d)–(f) regions for samples reacted at 30 °C. Examples of fitting are shown for three water partial pressures only. (g)–(l) Gaussian component absorbances (An,O-H,max in eqn (1)) for the O–H stretching region and (m)–(r) Lorentzian component absorbances (An,O-H,max in eqn (2)) are shown for all temperatures over the range of 0–3.11 kPa H2O. Corresponding component wavenumbers (νn in eqn (1) and (2)) are shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Temperature dependence of water binding to birnessite, using the adsorption data from Fig. 2. (a) Numerically integrated band area of the O–H stretching (ν1) and water bending (ν2) regions. Absorbances of the (b) Gaussian band components (An,O-H,max in eqn (1)) of the O–H stretching region and (c) Lorentzian band components (An,O-H,max in eqn (2)) of the water bending region. Each value was normalised for the (a) band area or (b) and (c) component absorbance for respective values at each water partial pressure at 30 °C. |
These assignments were supported by the following water vapour pressure dependence on component absorbances (Fig. 3g–l). O–H groups from intercalated water (3574 and 3189 cm−1) followed a type II adsorption isotherm akin to our modelling of the microgravimetry data, plateauing at ∼0.6 kPa H2O (Fig. 2g). The number of hydrogen-bonded water molecules increased throughout the range of 0–3.11 kPa, first through a steep increase with humidity akin to that of intercalated water, and through a lower response to humidity from externally bound (adsorbed and condensed) water (Fig. 2g).
Modelling of the water bending region revealed (Lorentzian-shaped; eqn (2)) bands at (i) ∼1592 ± 10 cm−1 from intercalated water and (ii) ∼1622 ± 8 cm−1 from liquid-like water. Again, band positions were not systematically affected by temperature (Fig. S4, ESI†). The water vapour pressure dependence of the 1592 cm−1 band chiefly aligned with that of O–H stretching bands of intercalated water (3574 and 3189 cm−1). The lower bending frequencies of the intercalated water also aligned with the expectation of a strong hydrogen bond with the basal oxygen sites of the interlayer region of birnessite. The ∼1622 cm−1 term, on the other hand, continued to increase in absorbance as a result of the increased water loadings. This can be taken as evidence that liquid water-like films appeared at birnessite nanoparticle surfaces.
Finally, the temperature-dependence of component absorbances (Fig. 4) reflected the exothermic nature of the water binding reactions, as expected from calorimetric studies.43 Total absorbances suggest a loss of water of at least ∼40% when birnessite was heated from 30 °C up to at least 50 °C. This loss in absorbance can be explained by the removal of all types of water from birnessite (Fig. 4b and c). In particular, the loss of bands from water molecules that were hydrogen-bonded to basal oxygens (3574, 3189 and 1592 cm−1) suggested that interlayer water films were preferentially removed within the 40–50 °C range.
The temperature dependence of the band components (Fig. 4b) also revealed no preferential loss in water molecules that were hydrogen-bonded to basal oxygens (3574 and 3189 cm−1) over those that were more weakly hydrogen-bonded to water (3470 cm−1). The loss of the 3276 cm−1 band (Fig. 4b) however indicated that water–water interactions were preferentially disrupted with temperature.44 This can also be seen in the water bending region by temperature-programmed desorption in Fig. S5 (ESI†).
Simulations (Fig. 5–7 and Fig. S6, S7, ESI†) showed that the interlayer spacings for one (1W) and two water monolayers (2W) were practically independent of temperature (Fig. 5a). The 2W state, known as buserite, can however only be attained by submerging birnessite in liquid water.1,45,46 Additionally, immersion energies in the 1W state were larger at higher temperatures, a result consistent with the concept for more exothermic reactions at high temperatures (Fig. 5b).43
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Predicted immersion energy profiles versus water loadings (H2O/UC; UC = unit cell) showing the 1W state at 1.33 H2O/UC (5.33 H2O/K+; d001-spacing = 0.685 nm) and the 2W state at 3.33 H2O/UC (13.33 H2O/K+; d001-spacing = 1.00 nm). (b) Temperature dependence of immersion energy at 1W over the range of 0–85 °C. See Fig. S6 (ESI†) for immersion energies against d001-spacing and Fig. S7 (ESI†) against water H2O/UC for comparison. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 MD-simulated diffusion coefficients of (a) water and (b) K+ as a function of interlayer water numbers (nW). Dashed vertical lines indicate ideal 1W and 2W hydration states. (c) Temperature dependence of diffusion coefficients of water and K+ as 1W and 2W. Note that the ordinate axis of Fig. 8c from the study of Cheng et al.,4 also reporting water diffusion coefficients, should read as ‘D × 10−9′ and not ‘D × 10−10′. |
In previous studies,47,48 our 1W hydration state was nearly-monoclinic, with cell dimensions that were nearly independent of temperature (a = 0.511, b = 0.295, and c = 0.706 nm; d001 = 0.685 nm because UC β = 104.0°; Fig. 1). Additionally, K+ and water oxygens (OW) were consistently at the centre of the interlayer region between oxygens of the basal face (Ob) of birnessite, a result aligning with previous MD work.33 Total K+ coordination numbers (∼9.7 O/K+) were consistently from ∼5.2 Ow on the same plane of the 1W water layer, and ∼4.5 Ob from both the basal faces of MnO2 per K+ ion. These numbers were also independent of temperature for 1W.
The most relevant piece of information that links back to our FTIR results relates to hydrogen bond numbers, as these directly affect spectral shapes and positions. These were dominated by interactions with basal oxygens (1.83 Ob/H2O) and a minute portion involved in water–water interactions (0.13 bond/H2O). These results consequently align with our previous finding that the increase in vibrational bands of ‘liquid water-like’ components (1592, 3189 and 3574 cm−1 in Fig. 2 and 3) was not from intercalated water but adsorbed and condensed water at birnessite particle surfaces (Fig. 2g).
From these results, we conclude that variations in water loadings with temperature can only be explained in terms of the dynamics of the 1W layer, as the structure and molecular interactions remained unchanged (Fig. 6). This aligns with the large temperature-driven increases in water and K+ diffusion coefficients (Fig. 7). While the 1W state had the lowest diffusion coefficients for any nW state (Fig. 7a), these values increased by nearly one order of magnitude at 85 °C (Fig. 7c). Those of K+ remained, on the other hand, relatively unchanged with temperature. Because K+ (0.266 nm) and H2O (0.275 nm) have similar sizes, the chief factor influencing the smaller temperature-dependent diffusivity of K+ is its charge. As such, while increasing temperatures effectively enhanced water mobility along the 1W layer, the K+ ion mobility was systematically lower due to electrostatic interactions with Ob sites (4.5 Ob/K+ in 1W). K+ diffusivity in the 2W state, in contrast, increased on par with water with temperature because the first shell K+–Ob interactions (≪1 Ob/K+) were replaced by K+–Ow interactions (Fig. 6b). We therefore attribute the diminished capability of the interlayer region of birnessite to store water in the 1W state at high temperatures to the compounded effects of (i) increased evolved heat (i.e. exothermicity), and (ii) the larger mobility of water over that of K+ with temperature.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3cp01209c |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2023 |