Open Access Article
Mengmeng
Zheng
,
Fredrik
Haeffner
and
Jianmin
Gao
*
Department of Chemistry, Merkert Chemistry Center, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467, USA. E-mail: Jianmin.Gao@bc.edu
First published on 30th June 2022
Phage display, an ingenious invention for evaluating peptide libraries, has been limited to natural peptides that are ribosomally assembled with proteinogenic amino acids. Recently, there has been growing interest in chemically modifying phage libraries to create nonnatural cyclic and multicyclic peptides, which are appealing for use as inhibitors of protein–protein interactions. While earlier reports largely focused on side-chain side-chain cyclization, we report herein a novel strategy for creating backbone-side chain cyclized peptide libraries on phage. Our strategy capitalizes on the unique reactivity of an N-terminal cysteine (NCys) with 2-cyanobenzothiazole (CBT) which, in conjugation with another thiol-reactive group, can elicit rapid cyclization between an NCys and an internal cysteine. The resulting library was screened against two model proteins, namely Keap1 and Sortase A. The screening readily revealed potent inhibitors for both proteins with certain Keap1 ligands reaching low nanomolar potency. The backbone-side chain cyclization strategy described herein presents a significant addition to the toolkit of creating nonnatural macrocyclic peptide libraries for phage display.
Screening of this library readily revealed potent peptide ligands for two proteins, namely Keap1 and Sortase A, which are chosen as examples for those involved in protein–protein interactions and difficult-to-inhibit enzymes.
NCys is known to conjugate with CBT (Fig. S1†) under physiologic conditions with fast reaction kinetics (k2: ∼10 M−1 s−1).13 To achieve backbone-side chain cyclization, we derivatized CBT with a reversible thiol-reactive group, namely α-cyanoacrylamide (M-a-23, Fig. 1C),17 to induce facile NCys–Cys crosslinking of CXnC peptides (n randomized residues flanked by a pair of cysteines). CXnC peptide libraries can be readily constructed on M13 phage. We chose a reversible thiol-reactive group for the design of M-a-23 to ensure exclusive NCys modification by CBT. Importantly, α-cyanoacrylamide exhibits fast thiol conjugation kinetics to elicit rapid peptide cyclization, which is desirable for phage library construction.17,18 For comparison, we evaluated a non-cyano-substituted analogue of M-a-23 for peptide cyclization, which was only observed after several days (Fig. S2†).
Synthetic details of M-a-23 can be found in the ESI.† With the compound in hand, we first tested it against several model peptides, which underwent complete conjugation within 2 h (Fig. 2A, S4, and S5†). Two peaks were recorded with the same molecule weight (17
:
3 in ratio), presumably due to the diastereomeric peptides generated from the Michael addition (Fig. 2B). We did notice a small degree of double CBT modification in which the internal cysteine also conjugated with CBT to give a thioimidate (Fig. 2A and S3†).19,20 Fortunately, we found that the internal cysteine modification could be readily reversed by the addition of free cysteine, which competitively cleaved the thioimidate to recyclize the peptide (Fig. 2A). It is important to note that the cysteine treatment caused no effect to the M-a-23 cyclized peptides, despite the potential reversibility of the α-cyanoacrylamide–thiol addition. Furthermore, the cyclized peptide was found to be stable in a redox buffer containing 1 mM glutathione (GSH
:
GSSG, 9
:
1). Finally and importantly, we found that M-a-23 modified peptides resisted iodoacetamide labelling (see later discussion and Fig. S14† for details), lending strong support to the efficient and stable peptide cyclization elicited by M-a-23.
To construct M-a-23 cyclized libraries, we prepared a CX9C phage library (sequence diversity: 4.5 × 108), which installs a Factor Xa cleavage site preceding the CX9C peptides (Fig. 2B). Subjecting this library to Factor Xa cleavage followed by TCEP reduction readily exposed a free NCys on the displayed peptides (Fig. S6 and S7†). The M-a-23 induced peptide cyclization on phage was validated using a streptavidin-mediated ELISA assay as well as a phage pulldown assay. These assays measure the extent of phage biotinylation after treatment with various combinations of reagents (Fig. 2D). As expected, treating a TCEP reduced CX9C phage library with B-IA elicited near quantitative phage pulldown (90%, Fig. S7†). Hence, the B-IA treated phage was used as a positive control in the ELISA assay. Treating the reduced CX9C library with B-CBT resulted in a high level of phage biotinylation (Fig. 2C and S7†). Specifically, B-CBT treated CX9C phage resulted in ∼80% pulldown, indicating efficient NCys modification by B-CBT. As expected, treating the reduced CX9C library with M-a-23 first and then by B-CBT resulted in little biotinylation and pulldown (Fig. 2C and S7†), confirming efficient phage modification by M-a-23. Importantly, a low level of biotinylation was observed when M-a-23 modified CX9C phage library was treated with B-IA (Fig. 2C). In contrast, treating the CX9C library with CBT first and then B-IA afforded a high level of phage biotinylation. These contrasting results indicate that the M-a-23 modified peptides on phage exist in cyclic forms. It is worth noting that, although efficient, M-a-23 did not elicit 100% phage modification, which would inevitably leave some unmodified phage in the library. However, we envision this is of little concern because our phage display protocol presents multiple copies of each unique phage variant (>1010 input phage vs. 4.5 × 108 sequence diversity). Considering the M-a-23 labelling efficiency of ∼80%, most copies for any unique phage variant will be converted into the M-a-23 cyclized form. In other words, despite the non-perfect labelling efficiency, each unique peptide sequence of the library will be well represented in its M-a-23 cyclized form for phage selection.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Phage panning reveals potent binders of Keap1. (A) Crystal structure of Keap1 Kelch domain in complex with the Nrf2 domain (75QLDEETGEFL84, pdb 2FLU). (B) Enriched peptide sequences after two rounds of panning against Keap1. The corresponding Kd values for Keap1 binding are listed to the right. #Kd value cited from ref. 22. (C) Chemical structure of K5 derivatives. (D) Fluorescence polarization assay results of various K5 derivatives binding the target protein Keap1. *: FAM labelled peptide. (E) Competition assay of K5 derivatives binding to Keap1 recorded through competition with a Nrf2-derived peptide (Fam-βAla-DEETGEF). Each data point in (D) and (E) represents the mean value of three independent measurements. | ||
As shown by the tabulated Kd values (Fig. 3B and S11†), all peptide hits yielded from phage panning proved to be potent Keap1 binders. In particular, K4_M-a-23* and K5_M-a-23* were found to exhibit low nanomolar affinity, yielding a Kd value of 0.14 and 0.06 μM respectively. To evaluate the potential significance of the luciferin linker, we analysed the disulphide cyclized peptides for Keap1 binding as negative controls. Gratifyingly, the M-a-23 cyclized peptides were found to display greater potency than the disulphide controls. For example, the M-a-23 cyclized K6 gave a Kd of 1.0 μM for Keap1 binding, six times lower than that of the disulphide control (Kd: 5.9 μM) (Fig. S12†). Similarly, the M-a-23 cyclized K5 exhibited eight times higher affinity than the disulphide control as well (Kd: 0.06 vs. 0.48 μM) (Fig. 3C and D). The binding affinity differences determined by Keap1 titration were further confirmed using a competition assay, in which the non-fluorophore labelled K5_SS and K5_M-a-23 were titrated into a preformed Keap1-fluorescence substrate complex. The competition assay revealed four times greater potency for the M-a-23 cyclized K5 (Fig. 3E). We further compared the M-a-23 cyclized K5 to a linear control, for which the NCys of K5* was capped with CBT (Fig. 3C and D). This linear control peptide showed eight times lower affinity for Keap1 as well, indicating the importance of the M-a-23 induced cyclization for the peptide's binding to Keap1.
To gain structural insight into the peptide-Keap1 binding, we performed computational docking studies of using a structural analogue of K5_M-a-23, namely K5_M-a-23-2, in which the cyano group is omitted (Fig. 4A, see below for more details of this analogue). The docking poses showed that this luciferin-cyclized peptide adopts a binding geometry very similar to that of Nrf2 peptide (Fig. 4C), which is perhaps not surprising given the high structural similarity between these two peptides (Fig. 3B). Importantly, the docked structure revealed a direct contact between the protein and the phenyl group of the thiol-acrylamide adduct, which may explain the higher potency of K5_M-a-23 for Keap1 binding in comparison to the disulphide or linear controls.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Irreversible peptide cyclization with M-a-23-2. (A) Chemical structure of peptides K5_M-a-23 and K5_M-a-23-2. (B) Results of the competition assay showing identical Keap1 binding affinity for K5_M-a-23 and K5_M-a-23-2. (C) Overlay of a docking pose of K5_M-a-23-2 with the natural peptide substrate of Keap1. The Keap1–Nrf2 complex structure is rendered using PDB file 5WFV. Details protocols for docking and superposition can be found in the ESI.† Colour scheme: Keap1, white; peptide ligand N: blue; O: red; Nrf2 C: yellow; K5_M-a-23-2 C: magenta; M-a-23-2 derived crosslinker: pink. | ||
:
GSSG (9
:
1). Nearly identical binding curves were obtained in the presence and absence of glutathione (Fig. S13†). To quantitatively assess the kinetic stability of the M-a-23 cyclized peptides, we used iodoacetamide (IA), an irreversible cystine alkylation agent to capture the free internal cysteine in order to estimate the cyclic peptide ring-opening rate. Specifically, K5_M-a-23* was incubated with 500 μM IA in PBS buffer at room temperature, and the sample was monitored by LC-MS at different time point (Fig. S14†). The data showed that, after 2 h incubation, only 15% of the peptide was alkylated with IA. In contrast, a CBT modified linear control peptide was fully alkylated under the same experimental condition (Fig. S15†). Fitting the kinetic data of K5_M-a-23* disappearance over time yielded a pseudo-first order rate constant (kobs) with a value of 1.38 × 10−5 s−1, which corresponds to a half-life of 20 hours for the M-a-23 cyclized peptides. It is interesting to note that the dissociation rate (k−1) for a bimolecular α-cyanoacrylamide–cysteine conjugate is 1.5 × 10−2 s−1 (Fig. S16†). In comparison, the cyclic peptide ring opening is ∼1000 times slower than the bimolecular conjugate, owing to the intramolecular nature of the M-a-23 mediated peptide cyclization.
We further envisioned that removing the CN group in M-a-23 would completely eliminate the reversibility issue of the cysteine–α-cyanoacrylamide linkage. Towards this end, we evaluated M-a-23-2 cyclized peptides (Fig. 4A). Without the CN group, M-a-23-2 elicited much slowed peptide cyclization (Fig. S2†), which is unsuitable for phage library construction, however may be acceptable for the synthesis of cyclic peptides during hit optimization. Indeed, although much slower, M-a-23-2 did elicit complete cyclization of K5 after four days. Using the competition assay, we assessed the Keap1 binding of K5_M-a-23-2 in comparison to K5_M-a-23 in parallel. The results showed essentially identical binding curves and IC50 values (Fig. 4B). The tight binding of K5_M-a-23-2 is supported by a docking structure (Fig. 4C), in which the cyclic peptide displays a overlapping structures as the Nrf2 peptide. Overall these results suggest that the combined use of M-a-23 and M-a-23-2 for library screening and peptide hit synthesis respectively may be a powerful strategy to develop potent and stable macrocyclic peptide inhibitors.
Similar to what we observed with Keap1, panning of the M-a-23 cyclized CX9C library against SrtA led to the convergence of peptide sequences after four rounds of panning: multiple recurring sequences were found to harbour either an LPP or LGN signature (Fig. 5B and S18†). We note that LPP-containing sequences were also observed in previously reported cyclic peptide ligands of SrtA.26 These peptide hits were synthesized in pure form and characterized for SrtA binding. Interestingly, the peptides S1_M-a-23* and S2_M-a-23* showed low micromolar binding affinity to SrtA, which shared the LPPYXS motif (Fig. 5B). The remaining peptide sequences (S3–S5) did not show significant SrtA binding up to 50 μM and are deemed as false positive hits (Fig. S19†). In addition, the M-a-23 cyclized peptides were found to bind SrtA with either comparable or just slightly higher affinity in comparison to the disulphide cyclized peptides. For example, M-a-23 cyclized S2 gives a Kd value of 18 μM in contrast to 25 μM for the corresponding disulphide peptide (Fig. S19†). In other words, SrtA inhibition appears to benefit to a smaller degree by having a M-a-23 derived crosslinker compared to the Keap1 binding peptides. The underlying chemical basis for this observation needs to be further explored as molecular docking studies did not reveal compelling hypotheses (Fig. S20 and S21†). Nevertheless, the peptide cyclization was found to be critical for the peptide's binding to SrtA whereas a CBT capped control peptide showed a much reduced SrtA binding propensity under the same experimental conditions (Fig. 5C).
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detailed protocols for synthesis and biochemical assays, and additional characterization of the peptide hits. See https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc03241d |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |