Yujie
Zhang
,
Hongping
Wu
,
Zhanggui
Hu
,
Jiyang
Wang
,
Yicheng
Wu
and
Hongwei
Yu
*
Tianjin Key Laboratory of Functional Crystal Materials, Institute of Functional Crystal, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China. E-mail: hwyu15@gmail.com
First published on 19th June 2022
A new Hg-based infrared nonlinear optical (IR NLO) crystal, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10], was synthesized based on a property-oriented structural design strategy. It crystallizes in the noncentrosymmetric tetragonal space group (I) and consists of a 3D [HgGa4S10]6− anionic moiety formed by corner-sharing tetrahedral HgS4 and supertetrahedral Ga4S10 clusters, as well as a 3D [Ba4Cl2]6+ cation network. The physical property measurements show that it can exhibit well-balanced NLO performances, including a large second-harmonic generation (SHG) response (1.5 × AgGaS2), wide band gap (2.95 eV), and high laser damage threshold (∼15 × AgGaS2). First-principles calculations indicate that the large SHG response of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] mainly originates from the strong covalent HgS4 and GaS4 tetrahedra and the ionic bonding [Ba4Cl2]6+ guest network contributes to the wide band gap of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10].
Generally, an excellent IR NLO crystal should satisfy the following crucial NLO criteria: (i) a strong phase-matching SHG response (dij > 0.5 AgGaS2); (ii) a high LDT (>10 AgGaS2) and a wide band gap (Eg > 3.0 eV); (iii) a broad transmission region (3–12 μm); and (iv) good physicochemical stability. Nevertheless, it is well-known that large SHG responses mainly derive from the covalency of a compound, whereas a high laser-induced damage threshold strongly depends on its ionicity. This implies the undesired contradiction between SHG responses and the laser-induced damage threshold.11 Therefore, achieving large SHG responses and a high laser-induced damage threshold is always a significant challenge among these NLO criteria. To balance this relationship, many attempts have been made and resulted in the discovery of a series of high-performance IR NLO crystals, e.g., LiGaS2, Li2In2SiS6, Li2CdSnS4, Na2ZnGe2S6, and BaGa2GeQ6 (Q = S, Se). Most of these strategies are mainly focused on using higher electropositive alkali or alkaline-earth cations to substitute the Ag+ cations in chalcopyrite-type AgGaS2 and AgGaSe2 to widen band gaps, while introducing as many as possible NLO-active functional motifs, MQ4, (M = Ga, In, Ge, Sn etc., Q = S, Se) to optimize the SHG response.12–16 Although these attempts are effective and fruitful, they also suffer from some difficulties arising from the fact that ionic and covalent structural units are usually mixed in various assembly processes, whereas the processes favoring good NLO performances can be hardly determined.17,18
Based on the study of the structure–property relationship, it is clear that the SHG response mainly depends on NLO-active functional motifs, MQ4, possessing strong covalency. Meanwhile, the 12 group transition metal tetrahedra and 13 and 14 group element tetrahedra are usually employed as the NLO-active units to generate large SHG responses in compounds.19–21 Especially for transition metal Hg2+ cations, they have a heavy atomic mass and highly polarizable characteristics. When they are introduced into chalcogenides, the materials can produce much larger SHG coefficients and a wider IR transparency region than other 12 group transition metals, making the materials highly competitive IR NLO materials, e.g., KHg4Ga5Se12 exhibits a large phase-matching SHG response (20 AgGaS2).22 Remarkably, the narrow band gaps of Hg-based compounds, e.g., KHg4Ga5Se12 (1.61), BaHgSnSe4 (1.98 eV), SrHgSnSe4 (2.07 eV), Li4HgSn2Se7 (2.10 eV), and SrHgSnS4 (2.72 eV), are unfavorable for them to display a high laser-induced damage threshold.23,24 In addition, according to Guo's investigation on the electron localization function map,17 the introduction of strong ionic components has a positive effect on the band gap of the material. Subsequently, it is expected that introducing strongly ionic metal–halogen bonds into Hg-based chalcogenides would be able to increase the band gaps of materials and achieve a good balance between SHG responses and band gaps.25
Guided by these ideas, a new Hg-based chalcogenide, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10], has been successfully designed and synthesized by finely mixing three types of chemical bonds with different covalency and ionicity, including covalent Ga–S and Hg–S, and strong ionic Ba–Cl/S bonds. As expected, this compound can exhibit well-balanced IR NLO properties, including a large SHG response (1.5 × AgGaS2), wide band gap (2.95 eV), high laser-induced damage threshold (15 × AgGaS2), and wide transparent window (0.42–25 μm). The results demonstrate that fine mixing of covalent and ionic bonds in the structure is an effective approach for achieving the balance between the SHG response and the band gap.
Polycrystalline [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] was synthesized through a solid-state reaction in a sealed silicon-tube at 750 °C, and its purity was confirmed by powder X-ray diffraction (Fig. S1†). Then, a millimeter-sized single crystal of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] was grown with BaCl2 as the flux. By using these crystals, the structure of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] was determined by single-crystal XRD analysis, which reveals that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] crystallizes in the noncentrosymmetric tetragonal space group, I (no. 82).26 The energy-dispersive spectroscopy measurement corroborates the existence of Ba/Cl/Hg/Ga/S with an average atomic ratio of 18.49%
:
9.48%
:
4.75%
:
20.57
:
46.71, which is approximately equal to the theoretical one, 19.05%
:
9.52%
:
4.76%
:
19.05
:
47.62 (Fig. S2†).
The crystal structure of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] is shown in Fig. 1. Its asymmetric unit contains one Ga, one Hg, one Ba, three S, and two Cl atom(s). All the Ga atoms are coordinated by four S atoms to form GaS4 tetrahedra with Ga–S distances of 2.244(5)–2.290(5) Å, and every four GaS4 tetrahedra connect with each other through corner-sharing to form T2-type Ga4S10 supertetrahedra (Fig. 1a). For Hg atoms, they are also coordinated by four S atoms to form HgS4 tetrahedra with a Hg–S distance of 2.548(5) Å, and each HgS4 tetrahedron is bonded by four Ga4S10 T2-supertetrahedra through corner-sharing forming a three-dimensional (3D) 3∞[HgGa4S10]6− covalent framework (Fig. 1b). The residual charges of the 3∞[HgGa4S10]6− covalent framework are balanced by a 3D [Ba4Cl2]6+ guest network, which is composed of the highly distorted [Cl(1)Ba4] and [Cl(2)Ba4] tetrahedra via corner- and edge-sharing (Fig. 1c). For Ba–Cl and Ba–S bonds, their bond lengths range from 3.048(1) to 3.107(1) Å and 3.243(5) to 3.644(5) Å, respectively. The bond valence sum calculations resulted in values of 2.01 for Ba2+, 2.16 for Hg2+, 3.04 for Ga3+, 1.95–1.99 for S2− and 1.30–1.52 for Cl−.27 The slightly high oxidation states for Cl− result from the slightly short Ba–Cl bond lengths owing to the extreme difference of electronegativity between Ba and Cl atoms, which is comparable with those of reported chalcogenides, e.g., [CsBa2Cl][Ga4S8] and [Ba4Cl2][ZnGa4S10].28,29 Importantly, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] contains three types of chemical bonds with different covalency and ionicity, including covalent Ga–S and Hg–S, and strong ionic Ba–Cl/S bonds, which is conducive to obtaining well-balanced NLO properties.30,31
The UV-vis-NIR diffuse reflectance and absorption spectra of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] are shown in Fig. 2a. It displays a wider band gap (2.95 eV) than those of commercially used AgGaS2 (2.70 eV), AgGaSe2 (1.83 eV), and ZnGeP2 (1.75 eV). Meanwhile, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] contains alkaline-earth Ba2+ cations without unwanted d–d or f–f electron transitions, the strongly electronegative Cl atom with a blue-shift effect,6 and an ionic-bonded 3D [Ba4Cl2]6+ guest network, which contributes to the wide band gap of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10].17 The wide band gap is positively related to the large laser-induced damage threshold. Furthermore, the laser-induced damage threshold of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has also been measured based on the single-pulse powder laser-induced damage threshold method with AgGaS2 as the reference using a 1064 nm pulse laser (110 A, 1 Hz, 20 ns). The result reveals that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has a high powder laser-induced damage threshold of 310 MW cm−2, which is ∼15 × AgGaS2. Furthermore, a wide IR transmission region is also essential for the application of NLO crystals. The IR and Raman spectra of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] are shown in Fig. 2b. The IR spectrum shows that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has no obvious absorption in the region of 4000–400 cm−1 (i.e., 2.5–25 μm), indicating its potential as an IR NLO crystal.32 The Raman peaks at 353 and 379 cm−1 belong to the characteristic vibrations of the Ga–S bonds. The absorption peak at 256 cm−1 can be assigned to Hg–S bond interactions.
In addition, the low-frequency peaks below 200 cm−1 mainly originate from the Ba–S vibrations. The assignments for the Raman peaks are consistent with those of other chalcogenides, such as LiBa4Ga5S12, (Na3Rb)Hg2Ge2S8 and BaHgS2.33–35
As [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] crystallizes in the noncentrosymmetric space group of I, and contains the NLO-active [GaS4] and [HgS4] tetrahedra, a relatively large SHG response could be expected. The powder SHG measurement for [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has been carried out using the modified Kurtz-Perry method under irradiation with a 2090 nm laser with AgGaS2 as a reference. As shown in Fig. 2c, the SHG intensity of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] is around 1.5 × AgGaS2 at a particle size of 180–250 μm (Fig. 2d). The effective NLO coefficient deff was calculated using the formula
(where I2ω and
are SHG intensities for the sample and AgGaS2, respectively) with polycrystalline deff, AgGaS2 = 11.8 pm V−1 (polycrystalline deff, AgGaS2 is the angular average of single-crystal d36, AgGaS2 = 13.7 pm V−1).36 Therefore, the experimental polycrystalline deff value is estimated to be 14.7 pm V−1 for [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10]. The large SHG response of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] will be conducive to generating a high conversion efficiency in the application.
To understand the origin of the large SHG response in [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10], the electron structure of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has been calculated by first-principles calculations. It shows that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has a direct band gap of 2.53 eV (Fig. S3†), which is smaller than the experimental value attributable to the discontinuity of exchange–correlation energy.37 The electronic densities of states (DOS) of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] are shown in Fig. S4.† It is clear that the tops of the valence bands of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] are mainly composed of S 3p states with a small part of the Ga 4p and Cl 3p states, while the bottoms of the conduction bands are primarily S 3p, Ga 4s, Ga 4p, Hg 6s and Ba 5d states. These results indicate that the [HgGa4S10]6− anionic moiety has the main contribution to the band gap and SHG response of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10]. In order to further understand the contribution, an intrinsic dipole moment calculation was implemented by a simple bond valence model.38 The calculated results are listed in Table S1.† The dipole moments from GaS4 and HgS4 tetrahedra are 2.99 and zero Debye (D), respectively. Although the static dipole moment of HgS4 units in the unit cell is zero, introducing Hg2+ in [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] increases the dipole moment in Ga4S10 supertetrahedra, which is systematically larger than those in [RbBa2Cl][Ga4S8],28 [Ba4Cl2][ZnGa4S10],29 [KBa3Cl2][Ga5Se10],39 and [Ba4Cl2][MGa4Se10] (M = Zn, Cd).40 Additionally, the induced dipole moments from the MQ4 (M = Zn, Ga, Hg and Q = S, Se) units in AgGaS2, AgGaSe2, Ba3KGa5Se10Cl2, Ba2RbGa4S8Cl, Ba4ZnGa4S10Cl2, Ba4ZnGa4Se10Cl2, and [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] were also quantified based on the calculation of the empirical “flexibility index” F.28,29,39–43 As listed in Table 1, the F value of the [HgS4] unit in [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] is slightly larger than those of the MQ4 (M = Zn, Ga and Q = S, Se) units in other chalcogenides, e.g., AgGaS2, Ba2RbGa4S8Cl and Ba4ZnGa4S10Cl2. The relatively large induced dipole moment is helpful for [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] to generate an enhanced SHG response. In addition, the NLO coefficients of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] can also be calculated based on the calculated electron structure. According to Kleinman symmetry, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] has two nonzero independent SHG coefficients, d15 = d31 = 9.40 pm V−1 and d14 = d36 = 22.04 pm V−1. Obviously, the calculated d36 value is about 1.6 times that of AgGaS2 (d36, AgGaS2 = 13.70 pm V−1),18 which is also matched with the experimental result.
Compounds | Space groups | MQ4 units | d ij (× AGS, pm V−1) | F | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
AgGaS2 |
I![]() |
GaS4 | d 36 = 13.4 | 0.212 | 41 |
AgGaSe2 |
I![]() |
GaSe4 | d 36 = 33.0 | 0.211 | 42 |
Ba3KGa5Se10Cl2 |
I![]() |
GaSe4 | 3.6 × AGS | 0.258 | 39 |
Ba2RbGa4S8Cl | Pmn21 | GaS4 | 0.9 × AGS | 0.220–0.236 | 28 |
Ba4ZnGa4S10Cl2 |
I![]() |
GaS4 | 1.1 × AGS | 0.183–0.223 | 29 |
ZnS4 | |||||
Ba4ZnGa4Se10Cl2 |
I![]() |
GaSe4 | 1.6 × AGS | 0.212–0.255 | 40 |
ZnSe4 | |||||
[Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] |
I![]() |
GaS4 | 1.5 × AGS | 0.226–0.235 | |
HgS4 |
Clearly, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] can exhibit a relatively large SHG response and a wide band gap, which would be related to the covalent [HgGa4S10]6− anionic moiety and the ionic [Ba4Cl2]6+ cation network, respectively.18,29,43–45 To better show the different covalence and ionicity, we also calculated the overlap populations and electron localization function (ELF) of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] based on first-principles calculations. Given that the overlap populations can represent different electron density localization statuses, i.e., the larger values (>0.5) reflect the localized electron states and the stronger covalent characteristics; inversely, the smaller values (<0.5) represent delocalized electron states and the stronger ionic characteristics.18 As shown in Fig. 3a, it can be seen that the Ga/Hg–S bonds (0.45–0.66 e) show strong covalency and Ba–S/Cl bonds (0.1–0.13 e) exhibit strong ionicity in [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10]. Furthermore, the ELF map of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] reveals that the covalent Ga/Hg–S and strong ionic Ba–S/Cl bonds present fine mixing in the structure (Fig. 3b), which achieves the expected balance between the SHG response and the band gap in [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10].
To further understand the importance of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] with fine mixing of covalency and ionicity for exploring IR NLO crystals, a property comparison between [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] and some high-performance IR NLO crystals with Hg-based and Ga–S bonds has been performed. Compared to the recently reported Hg-based compounds (e.g., (Hg6P3)(In2Cl9) (dij = 0.5 × AgGaS2, Eg = 3.13 eV),46 (Hg2Cd2S2Br)Br (Eg = 2.41 eV),47 (Hg3Se2)(Se2O5) (Eg = 2.63 eV),48 KHg4Ga5Se12 (dij = 20 × AgGaS2, Eg = 1.61 eV),22 SrHgSnS4 (dij = 1.9 × AgGaS2, Eg = 2.72 eV)23), and chalcogenides with Ga–S bonds (e.g., Ba2Ga8GeS16 (dij = 1 × AgGaS2, Eg = 3.0 eV)49 and Ga2S3 (dij = 0.2 × AgGaS2, Eg = 2.8 eV)50), [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] constructed from the structural units with mixing of covalency (Hg–S and Ga–S bonds) and ionicity (Ba–Cl/S bond) can exhibit a good comprehensive IR NLO performance (dij = 1.5 × AgGaS2 and Eg = 2.95 eV). Additionally, compared to AgGaS2 and other chalcohalides, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] exhibits a relatively large SHG response, wide band gap, and high laser-induced damage threshold (Fig. S5 and Table S2†), which achieves the expected balance between the SHG response and the band gap. These results indicate that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] will be a promising IR NLO crystal, and the Hg-based chalcohalides with mixed covalent and ionic bonds may be a worthwhile materials class for the exploration of IR NLO crystals.
In conclusion, a new noncentrosymmetric chalcohalide, [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10], has been successfully synthesized by introducing electronegative halogens in a Hg-based chalcogenide. Its structure consists of a 3D [HgGa4S10]6− anionic moiety formed by corner-sharing tetrahedral HgS4 (T1) and supertetrahedral Ga4S10 clusters (T2), as well as a 3D [Ba4Cl2]6+ cation network. The property measurements show that it can exhibit balanced NLO properties, including a large SHG response (1.5 × AgGaS2 at 2090 nm), wide band gap (2.95 eV), high laser-induced damage threshold (15 × AgGaS2), and wide transparent window (0.42–25 μm). These results show that [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] would be a promising IR NLO crystal. Furthermore, the overlap populations and ELF map analysis results confirm that the balanced NLO properties of [Ba4Cl2][HgGa4S10] mainly originate from the fine mixing of covalency and ionicity in the structure. This work will provide a feasible way for exploring excellent IR NLO crystals through finely mixing covalency and iconicity.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2168297. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2qi00937d |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2022 |