C. Munashe
Mazodze
and
Wade F.
Petersen
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch, Cape Town, 7700, South Africa. E-mail: wade.petersen@uct.ac.za
First published on 11th April 2022
An atom-efficient silver-catalysed double carboxylative strategy for the one-step synthesis of quinolin-2-ones via an addition–cyclisation–elimination cascade sequence of oxamic acids to acrylic acids, mediated either thermally or photochemically, is reported. The reaction was applicable to the synthesis of a broad range of quinolin-2-ones and featured a double-disconnection approach that constructed the quinolin-2-one core via the formal and direct addition of a C(sp2)–H/C(sp2)–H olefin moiety to a phenylformamide precursor.
In broad terms, the construction of quinolin-2-ones are largely envisaged via two main disconnections; either between the aryl group and the double bond (Fig. 2A-left)—via arylation processes (of the type I)6 or between the carbonyl group and the double bond (Fig. 2A-right)—via insertion into double/triple bonds (of the type II).7 Other approaches include oxidation of quinoline salts,8a ring expansion of isatins,8b,c and aldol-type ring closures.8d By contrast, we were intrigued by the notion of simultaneously disconnecting at both ends of the double bond for a more modular synthesis—formally enabling the direct installation of a C(sp2)–H/C(sp2)–H olefin moiety into a phenylformamide precursor (Fig. 2B; of the type III).9
To the best of our knowledge, only two reports of this type of approach toward the synthesis of quinolin-2-ones have been described in the literature (Fig. 2B).10 Donald and co-workers reported a photoredox catalysed addition–cyclisation sequence to produce 3,4-dihydroquinolin-2-ones, that spontaneously eliminated HCl to afford quinolin-2-ones when using chloroacrylate derived Michael acceptors.10a This however featured only 3 examples (with modest yields), and the use of the N-phthalimido esters is somewhat of a disadvantage in terms of the overall atom efficiency. Additionally, substituted chloroacrylates and chloroacrylonitriles are not easily obtained. The second report is by Feng and co-workers who instead described the use of oxamic acids and vinyl sulfones in a related transformation.10b While the use of oxamic acids is more atom efficient, the method was limited to producing only unsubstituted quinolin-2-ones at C3 and C4. In context, the work by Jiao must be highlighted.7a Here, they reported an impressive rhodium catalysed three-component reaction involving an aniline, carbon monoxide, and an internal alkyne, that could additionally assemble the amide moiety of the quinolin-2-one. Some drawbacks however involved the use of toxic CO gas, a stoichiometric amount of a transition-metal oxidant, and the need for high reaction temperatures—with minor limitations on the internal alkyne used. Inspired by these reports, we herein describe a silver-catalysed addition–cyclisation–elimination cascade sequence for the synthesis of quinolin-2-ones utilising readily available oxamic and acrylic acids via a double radical decarboxylation mediated either thermally or photochemically (Fig. 2C).
In search of a suitable set of oxidative conditions for our envisaged cascade, our optimisation studies began using oxamic 7a and acrylic acid 8a as model substrates (Table 1, see the ESI† for full data). In accordance with our prior work,11 we first investigated the use of stoichiometric of Mn(OAc)3 as the oxidant for the reaction—the use of 3 equiv. accounting for each of the 3 independent oxidation steps (Table 1, entry 1). Gratifyingly, the desired quinolin-2-one 10a was produced in 52% yield. Although pleasing, we were acutely aware of the significant drawbacks associated with the use of super stoichiometric transition-metal metals in the context of sustainability. To this end, we opted for 50 mol% Mn(OAc)3·2H2O (∼17 mol% effective loading over the 3 steps) in the presence of K2S2O8—a low-cost and readily available oxidant14—which produced 10a in a poor 16% yield (Table 1, entry 2). The use of AgNO3/K2S2O8 is a well-known system for net oxidative transformations, particularly in the context of decarboxylation chemistry.6a,14 Pleasingly, an improved 34% yield was obtained in the presence of 20 mol% AgNO3 (Table 1, entry 3), while 50 mol% AgNO3 produced the best set of conditions; affording 10a in 58% yield (Table 1, entry 4). It is worth noting that 50 mol% AgNO3 (17 mol% effective loading per oxidation step) was found to be optimum as higher loadings (such as 80 and 100 mol%) did not affect the yield and 30 mol% afforded 10a in 40% yield (see ESI†). Carrying out the reaction at room temperature was ineffective for the reaction (Table 1, entry 5, while performing the reaction in the absence of a metal salt afforded 10a in 35% yield (Table 1, entry 6). Various other metal salts, solvent systems, and persulfates where also investigated, but these were all found to produce inferior results (see the ESI†).
Entry | Metal salt (mol%) | Oxidant (equiv.) | Solvent | Yielda (%) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Determined by 1H NMR (1,3,5-trimethoxybenzene standard). b As the dihydrate. c Reaction carried out at room temperature. d Starting material recovered. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 | — | Mn(OAc)3b (3) | PhMe | 52 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
2 | Mn(OAc)3b (50) | K2S2O8 (3) | ACN/H2O | 16 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
3 | AgNO3 (20) | K2S2O8 (3) | ACN/H2O | 34 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
4 | AgNO 3 (50) | K 2 S 2 O 8 (3) | ACN/H 2 O | 58 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
5c,d | AgNO3 (50) | K2S2O8 (3) | ACN/H2O | Trace | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
6 | None | K2S2O8 (3) | ACN/H2O | 35 |
Reactions that require significant heating are very energy intensive and therefore raises sustainability concerns in the context of global energy security. Furthermore, accessing these chemistries are particularly challenging in regions with fragile or severely constrained national energy grids—especially when extended heating periods are required.15 Indeed, high temperatures preclude thermally sensitive starting materials and products. For this reason, there is notable value in developing room temperature alternatives for these processes. In this light, and with the chemistry of the cascade sequence established, we set out to develop a comparable photoredox-mediated room temperature alternative. As mentioned, the room temperature reaction as per Table 1, entry 5 was found to be ineffective and this is due to the high activation barrier associated with disproportionation of K2S2O8 to afford its highly oxidising SO4˙− radical anion.16 On the other hand, photoexcited ruthenium complexes are known to efficiently reduce persulfate anions (S2O82−) to their corresponding sulfate radical anions (SO4˙−) at room temperature,14c,17 and we therefore envisaged that employing this strategy would enable our cascade sequence to proceed efficiently at room temperature. In the event, modifying our reaction conditions accordingly produced 10a in a comparable 54% yield when using [Ru(Bpz)3](PF6)2 in the presence of visible-light (Table 2, entry 1). Switching to the organic photocatalyst 4-CzIPN18 provided the optimum photoredox conditions; affording 10a in 58% yield (Table 2, entry 2), while acridium and iridium photocatalysts produced 10a, in 43% and 38% yields, respectively (Table 2, entries 3 and 4). In the absence of a photocatalyst, 10a was obtained in 22% yield, indicating that light activated homolysis of S2O82− is facilitated to some extent. (Table 2, entry 5). Full data is available in the ESI.† With the optimised conditions at hand, the substrate scope of the addition–cyclisation–elimination cascade sequence was investigated, paying attention to any differences between the thermal and photochemical strategies in a randomised sample set (Scheme 1). Indeed, reaction time is an obvious advantage for the thermal reaction (18 h vs. 48 h).
Repeating the reaction with the model system afforded 10a in 60% and 58% isolated yields for the thermal and photochemical reactions, respectively, while the mono-halogenated oxamic acids afforded 10b–10d in 55–82% yields. The 4-methoxy-substituted product 10e was produced in comparable isolated yields of 76% and 75% for the thermal and photochemical reactions, respectively. On the other hand, 10f, the 3-substituted variant was obtained in only 16% isolated yield, which improved to 57% yield under photoredox catalysis. Electron-withdrawing substituents were well tolerated, affording 10g–10i in 60–84% isolated yields. The difluorinated oxamic acid analogue 10j was obtained in 45% yield, while the dichlorinated variant 10k was produced in 42% yield, that could be improved to 53% when performed under photochemical conditions. Trisubstituted oxamic acids were also suitable, affording 10l in 43% yield, and improved to 54% yield using photoredox catalysis. As mentioned, 4-trifluoromethylated quinolin-2-ones have particularly utility in chemical biology. Pleasingly in context, 10m was produced in 54% yield using 2-(trifluoromethyl)acrylic acid, which was improved to an excellent 84% under the room temperature photochemical conditions. Modification of the nitrogen protecting group was also well tolerated affording 10n–10r in up to 82% yield, with notable increases in yield when performed under photoredox conditions (i.e.10p and 10r). Variation of the acrylic acid was also possible producing the 3-substituted quinolin-2-one 10s in 22% yield that could be significantly improved to 52% yield photochemically. Disubstituted acyclic and cyclic acrylic acids were also suitable; producing 3,4-disubstituted quinolin-2-ones 10t–10v in 52–59% isolated yields, with no obvious advantage photochemically (as per 10v). It is worth noting that compounds 10m and 10r were produced using recycled 4-CzIPN obtained in sequence during the substrate scope explorations. Specifically, 10m was obtained using the photocatalyst recovered during the synthesis of 10l, and then 10r was obtained using the photocatalyst recovered from 10l. Clear limitations to the cascade sequence, though, were apparent; both thermally and photochemically. For example, aryl substituted products (such as 10ua and 10ub) could not be produced, while 2-substituted oxamic acids were also found to be incompatible (producing 10uc). Unprotected oxamic acids were not suitable (producing 10ud) however this, in principle, could be overcome by debenzylation of 10n. Across the sample set, the photoredox-mediated reaction was either found to be comparable to the thermal reaction, or significantly outperform it. All things considered, we would deem the photoredox-mediated cascade sequence a superior strategy, particularly in the context of sustainable and energy efficient synthesis. The proposed mechanism of the reaction, using the model system as a representative example is shown in Scheme 2. Following visible-light excitation, and in accordance with previous literature,14c,17 the excited state catalyst (3PC*) reduces the persulfate anion (S2O82−) to the sulfate radical anion (SO4˙−), generating its PC+1 state. The highly oxidising SO4˙−19 then oxidises Ag+ to the active Ag2+ species16 that subsequently generates carbamoyl radical I1via radical decarboxylation of 7a, with concomitant return to its Ag+ state. It should be noted that stoichiometric AgNO3 on its own did not promote the reaction (see the ESI†), supporting Ag2+ as the active oxidizing species.16 Then, an addition–cyclisation sequence produces cyclohexadienyl radical anion I2, which is transformed into dihydroquinolin-2-one 9a following SET oxidation by PC+1 and the loss of a proton, while returning the catalyst to its ground state (PC). This overall transformation affording 9a is consistent with related literature reports.10,20 Elimination toward product 10a is envisaged to follow a similar pathway. Namely, radical decarboxylation of 9a by Ag2+ to afford methine radical I3, oxidation by PC+1 to the benzylic tertiary carbocation and finally the loss of a proton. As for the thermal reaction, SO4˙− (×2) is instead generated via thermolysis, following which the reaction mechanism proceeds as described. But, rather than SET oxidation by PC+1 and loss of a proton to afford 9a and 10a, H-abstraction by the second SO4˙− generated during thermolysis is proposed. Mechanistic studies supported the existence of carbamoyl radical I1 as well as carboxylic acid 9a as transient intermediates (Scheme 3).
Carrying out the reaction in the presence of TEMPO but without the acrylic acid (8a), produced TEMPO-carbamate 12a in 64% yield; supporting the formation of carbamoyl radical I1 (Scheme 3A). It should be noted that in the presence of the acrylic acid (8a), TEMPO adduct 12a was obtained as the major product in 83% yield, together with a 16% yield of the quinolin-2-one product 10a. Committing the independently synthesised quaternary 3,4-dihydroquinolin-2-one 9a to the reaction conditions using 1.2 equiv. K2S2O8 (accounting for only one decarboxylation) successfully afforded 10a in 41% yield; demonstrating that 9a is a likely intermediate in the reaction (Scheme 3B), while quaternary TEMPO intermediate—in support of methine radical I3—could not be detected in the corresponding TEMPO trapping experiment. Instead, similar conversion to 10a was observed.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, optimisation data, and compound characterisation. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2ob00521b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |