Kevin J.
Glennon
*,
Hector F.
Valdovinos
,
Tashi
Parsons-Davis
,
Jennifer A.
Shusterman
,
Anna G.
Servis‡
,
Kenton J.
Moody
and
Narek
Gharibyan
Nuclear and Chemical Sciences Division, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA 94550, USA. E-mail: glennon5@llnl.gov
First published on 15th September 2022
A compact field-deployable microfluidic system has been developed to improve timelines for the rapid analysis of debris in post-detonation nuclear forensics. We used a high-resolution 3D printer to miniaturize typical laboratory-based procedures into a fieldable platform. Microfluidic half-modules were produced for the purification of Pu from excess U, along with a portable alpha chamber for the following isotopic analysis of the Pu stream. A porous PTFE membrane is soaked with a hydrophobic tributyl phosphate (TBP) solution and is placed between two half-modules; separation is performed as a liquid–liquid extraction in an extraction channel across this membrane, where the forward and back-extractions occur within one complete module. Following separation, a 100 μL sampling of the Pu-bearing stream is injected into a small-footprint 3D printed alpha chamber for isotopic assay via alpha spectrometry as part of an online process. In this first demonstration of microfluidic separation coupled with online alpha spectrometry, high extraction yields have been obtained for Pu (98.9 ± 4.0)% and U (97.5 ± 2.5)%. The process uses less than 800 μL of solution with separation chemistry complete within 45 minutes and subsequent alpha spectrometry initiating 25 minutes after separation.
Liquid–liquid extraction systems utilizing tributyl phosphate (TBP) in n-dodecane have been used extensively to separate Pu and U from these reaction products in the context of nuclear fuel cycle and Pu production processes.10 To improve the rapid analysis of the primary fuel elements (Pu and U) in post-detonation debris, a suitable TBP-based chemistry system could be miniaturized for field deployment. An appropriate chemistry system for this application should be compact and lightweight and be able to perform chemical separations rapidly with a minimum volume of acids and solvents. A microfluidic chemistry system presents itself as an ideal solution to each of these criteria. Such microsystems have been used to perform chemical separations with high yields and decontamination factors (DFs) for many different applications.11–18 Flat-sheet supported-liquid membrane (FS-SLM) modules are microfluidic systems in which a semi-permeable membrane is placed between two open-faced microfluidic channels, allowing selected species in solution to extract over the membrane from one channel to the other.19–21 Forward and backward extractions can be performed in a single module without the use of a phase separating system. Thus, FS-SLM modules provide a platform which is appropriately compact and lightweight for field deployable applications. When produced with shallow microfluidic channels, these modules can have total volumes less than 40 μL, which minimizes the amount of acid to be safely transported in the field.
Recently, a microfluidic system which utilizes 3D-printed FS-SLM modules was shown to quantitatively extract UO2(NO3)2 using a porous polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) membrane coated with a TBP in n-dodecane solvent.19 In this work, we use the FS-SLM modules to develop a fieldable radiochemistry platform capable of measuring accurate 238Pu/(239,240Pu) activity ratios following separation from 104 mass-excess U for the first time. We accomplish this in two parts; first, we introduce a method to use the FS-SLM platform to separate Pu from excess U. Second, we couple the Pu product stream to a novel field deployable alpha chamber to perform an online isotopic assay of the Pu-bearing stream. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first published deployable system capable of performing a Pu isotopic measurement following separation. Traditionally, the separation technologies and radiation detection instrumentation required for these procedures are too large and contain too many steps to be considered suitable for field operations;2,3 the fieldability of the process described here is enabled specifically by the miniaturization of these two laboratory technologies coupled as a deployable online process which uses less than a milliliter of solution per sample.
The Pu product stream from this procedure is isotopically assayed using alpha spectrometry; this is a radiation detection technique that produces a spectrum of alpha particle energies which are emitted from a radioactive source. These alpha particle energies are characteristic of the radionuclide which emits them, enabling identification and quantification of different radioactive isotopes in the sample, which is a key deliverable in nuclear forensic operations.2,3 Typically, alpha spectrometers are benchtop instruments which utilize heavy stainless steel alpha chambers and often require extensive sample preparation procedures to create fixed solid sources. This work uses a novel 3D printed alpha chamber design which is cheap, disposable, lightweight, and utilizes a rapid, automated sample preparation procedure directly from the solution state. The FS-SLM separation platform is coupled to this alpha chamber to enable an online isotopic assay of a small volume of the Pu product stream (≤100 μL) following separation in the microfluidic platform. The separation of Pu from U in the FS-SLM prior to alpha spectrometry would be necessary in a real sample to reduce the total radioactivity of the sample and allow for the unambiguous identification and quantification of Pu.
Isotope | Atom fraction (%) | Half-life (year)22–26 |
---|---|---|
238Pu | 0.010 ± 0.001 | 87.7 ± 0.1 |
239Pu | 91.805 ± 0.010 | 24![]() |
240Pu | 7.925 ± 0.010 | 6561 ± 7 |
241Pu | 0.227 ± 0.001 | 14.290 ± 0.006 |
242Pu | 0.0330 ± 0.0003 | (3.73 ± 0.03) × 105 |
Similarly, the legacy 233U also required purification to remove its immediate decay product, 229Th. The U was evaporated to dryness in conc. HCl and reconstituted in 1 mL 9 M HCl prior to loading onto a Poly Prep column containing 2 mL of AG 1-X8 anion exchange resin prewashed with 10 mL H2O and 10 mL 9 M HCl. The Th was eluted from the column with 10 mL of 9 M HCl, and the U was then eluted with 20 mL of 0.1 HCl. This solution was evaporated to dryness, reconstituted and dried in conc. HNO3 once, and finally reconstituted in 1 mL 3 M HNO3 for use in the FS-SLM System. The recently purified 238Pu solution18 was dried in conc. HNO3 and reconstituted in 1 mL 3 M HNO3.
The FS-SLM modules were printed 3 at a time over 18 hours with a Formlabs 3 printer using a resolution of 25–25–50 μm (x–y–z) followed by UV-curing for 60 minutes at 60 °C with the Formlabs Form Cure. The fully enclosed channels were thoroughly flushed with isopropyl alcohol prior to curing to prevent the enclosed channels from clogging during the cure process. Optical profilometry was performed with a Zygo ZeGage 3D Profiler on six of the finished stripping half-modules. Series 1 contained half-modules 1A, 1B, and 1C and were printed at the same time; series 2 (2A, 2B, and 2C) were printed together two weeks later. The profiles of the two series are shown in Fig. S2 and S3.† Generally, the 3D printed pieces were consistent with each other and with their intended geometry per CAD design. The peak-to-valley distances were measured as 99.2 ± 2.4 μm and 99.7 ± 2.9 μm, and the average variation across the profile of an extraction channel was 1.7 and 2.1 μm for series 1 and series 2, respectively.
As shown in Fig. S1B,† the top FS-SLM half-module carries the feed stream and the bottom FS-SLM half-module carries the stripping stream, with the 80 μm thick hydrophobic PTFE semi-permeable membrane placed between them. Prior to extraction, the PTFE membrane is placed over the stripping half-module extraction channel and wet with 100 μL of 30% (v/v) TBP in n-dodecane. The half-modules are then assembled into a full FS-SLM module with counter-current flow by affixing the half-modules together with four #8 screws with locking nuts. FEP tubing (1/16′′ outer diameter (O.D.) with 0.01′′ inner diameter (I.D.)) is connected to each inlet and outlet of the constructed FS-SLM using flangeless Delrin nuts and ferrules with dash size 003 O-rings to prevent leaks.
The feed-rinse syringe was then replaced with the feed syringe, which contained Pu and/or U in 3 M HNO3. Typical activity concentrations used were 0.1–7.2 Bq μL−1. 10 μL aliquot of 42% (w/w) iron(II) sulfamate solution was added to each feed solution and hand shaken for 2 minutes at room temperature prior to loading them in the syringe. Iron(II) sulfamate is a well-known reducing agent used to stabilize Pu as Pu(III) in HNO3 solutions.10 The feed and stripping solutions were pumped through the FS-SLM module at a rate of 5 μL min−1 for 10 min, corresponding to approximately 0.6 Vhm min−1 and 6 Vhm, respectively. This allowed the system to reach a steady-state operation where the activity concentration of Pu and/or U in the feed and stripping outlets remained constant.19
Finally, the feed and stripping solutions were pumped through the FS-SLM module at 5 μL min−1 for 22 min (0.6 Vhm min−1 for 13 Vhm) to collect enough of the feed and stripping streams for assay. In some extractions (denoted as online), the feed product stream was pumped directly into the bottom of the 3D printed alpha chamber for isotopic analysis by alpha spectrometry. In all other extractions (denoted as offline), the feed and stripping product streams were eluted into clean microcentrifuge tubes and an aliquot was taken for assay by either liquid scintillation counting (LSC) or alpha spectrometry.
In the online extractions, the Pu product stream was pumped directly into the bottom of the alpha chamber through the inlet and evaporated to dryness by applying a vacuum of approximately 30 Torr on the system. A piece of Al tape was used to cover the interior sample seat of the alpha chamber to prevent small amounts of Pu or U from absorbing into the surface pores of the cured resin during deposition. In the offline extractions, alpha spectrometry was conducted by air-drying a small amount (20–100 μL) of the product stream onto an Al planchet at 80 °C and placing it in the bottom of the chamber. A schematic of the deployable radiochemistry platform as described so far is outlined in Fig. 1. This figure has not been drawn to scale to highlight some of the most important aspects of operation. The actual size of each component is described in the previous sections of the main text, and in Fig. S1 and S4.†
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 A schematic overview of the deployable radiochemistry platform, not drawn to scale. The feed solution is pumped into the top of the FS-SLM module while the strip solution is pumped counter-currently through the bottom of the FS-SLM module. U(VI) from the feed solution extracts across the membrane and exits through the strip product, while Pu(III) fails to extract and exits through the feed product. A 100 μL sampling of the feed product is then pumped into the reservoir (a) in the bottom of the 3D printed alpha chamber where a vacuum is applied to dry the sample. Alpha particles are released by the dried source and create events in the detector (b) which are characteristic of the radionuclide which emitted them. Fig. S1 and S4† include more details with accurate dimensions for each component. |
All alpha spectrometry was performed using a Canberra PIPS 600 mm2 silicon detector utilizing an Ortec 428 Bias supply, an 855 Dual Spec amplifier, and a 927 ASPEC multi-channel analyzer (MCA) powered by an Ortec 4006 Minibin power supply. These electronics are all contained within the 24 × 32 × 35 cm benchtop power supply; if further miniaturization is required, products such as the nanoMCA from Yantel (9.2 × 3.8 × 2.5 cm) may be utilized with a separate bias supply instead. The chamber was evacuated to an ultimate pressure of 20–30 Torr using a 17 W Ametek ALPHA-MINI-PPS vacuum pump (18 × 10.6 × 9.95 cm). All LSC was performed by aliquoting 100 μL of a product stream into 10 mL of Ultima Gold scintillation cocktail and assaying with a Perkin Elmer Tri-Carb 3110TR.
Triplicate extractions were performed separately for Pu and U to investigate the effect of the stripping acid concentration on extraction yield from 0–0.3 M HNO3 (Fig. 2). Because U and Pu were investigated individually, these extractions were quantified via LSC. Extraction yields for each stream were determined by comparing the activity concentrations in the feed product stream and strip product stream to the activity concentrations in the initial feed stream. No statistically significant difference was observed between any acid concentration within the given range, indicating that the FS-SLM modules can provide consistent results for both Pu and U over a range of stripping acid concentrations with these low-mass tracer solutions. To avoid hydrolyzing conditions for Pu, 0.3 M HNO3 was selected as the stripping solution for subsequent studies. When using a 0.3 M HNO3 stripping solution, the extraction yield of Pu(III) and U(VI) in the feed stream was (98.9 ± 4.0)% and (0.301 ± 0.082)%, respectively; the extraction yield of Pu(III) and U(VI) in the stripping stream was (4.59 ± 0.56)% and (97.5 ± 2.5)%, respectively. The total activity balance was (103.4 ± 4.0)% and (97.8 ± 2.5)% for Pu and U, respectively. The reported uncertainties represent the square root of the external variance in the weighted average of triplicate measurements. For the removal of bulk U from Pu, these extraction yields would predict a decontamination factor (DF) of 330 ± 170 if both elements were introduced into the extraction system together, providing sufficient decontamination of U from Pu for a subsequent isotopic analysis of the Pu stream by alpha spectrometry. Fieldable operations may present with temperatures above or below the typical room temperature of a laboratory; Pu(III) does not form an extraction complex with TBP, so it is not expected to extract at any temperature, while the distribution coefficient of U(VI) into TBP changes slightly from approximately 20–15 within the range of 15–40 °C.28 For these reasons, typical temperature variations aren't expected to impact extraction performance with liquid systems.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Effect of stripping acid concentration on extraction yields. Fraction of Pu and U in (A) the stripping product stream and (B) the feed product stream. |
The spectrum of the feed stock (Fig. 3A) shows a clear peak for both 233U and 238Pu in the sample. The stripping product (Fig. 3B) shows that 233U(VI) was quantitatively extracted across the membrane and transported out of the stripping stream; the feed product (Fig. 3C) indicates that approximately 96% of the Pu(III) was eluted through the feed, and no detectable amount of U(VI) followed it. The detection limit for 233U in the feed product, set at 3 standard deviations above the 238Pu tail, is 0.015 counts per second (cps), which corresponds to <2% of the 233U signal in the feed stock (<1.2 Bq). Using this detection limit, the DF observed here was ≥52. These results are consistent with the individual element assays via LSC (Fig. 2). Based on the Pu/U DF, the efficacy of the FS-SLM module for the purification of small amounts of Pu from relatively large amounts of U, even at a low mass ratio of 1 × 10−4, was demonstrated. The most common traditional laboratory technique to separate Pu from excess quantities of U is column chromatography.2,3 This processes may use hundreds of milliliters of acid per sample, require a fume hood, involve significant work-up between each step, and generate large quantities of waste. These requirements present significant challenges for deployable chemistry. Our FS-SLM platform miniaturizes the separation process and allows us to perform a Pu/U separation with less than a milliliter of solution per sample in under one hour while minimizing material resources. The 3D printed FS-SLM platform costs less than 5 USD (ref. 19) and up to four units can be printed and prepared within 24 hours on a single printer. These properties allow the platform to be disposable which helps prevent cross-contamination between multiple samples in the field.
Field-deployable applications require simplified and streamlined source preparation, such as direct injection of the product stream from the FS-SLM modules into the bottom of the alpha chamber and immediate evaporation to dryness prior to an online data acquisition. This is readily achievable with this system as a small volume of the product stream (100 μL) is collected and evaporated using the applied vacuum to the chamber. The rate of evaporation was tested in the chamber by aliquoting 100 μL of 0.3 M HNO3 containing 65 Bq of 238Pu directly onto the Al tape covering the bottom of the chamber, evacuating the chamber to approximately 30 Torr, and acquiring data in two-minute intervals. The resolution and count rate in alpha spectrometry are sensitive to the thickness of the radioactive source; therefore, both are expected to increase as the source approaches dryness, reducing degradation within the sample.
Alpha spectra were collected in two-minute intervals over a total of 38 minutes, where t0 represents the time when the vacuum pump was turned on. The fraction of total counts within the 238Pu region of interest (ROI) plotted as a function of time (Fig. 4) indicates that a significant change occurs in the physical source properties around the 16-minute mark. The moment when the sample reaches dryness is unclear, but the ROI fraction approaches and begins to vary around the mean of its final value by the 24-minute mark. This indicates that the source is sufficiently dry to begin an online Pu isotopic assay within 24 minutes after extraction chemistry is complete. The actual data acquisition time can then range from minutes to hours, depending on the Pu concentration in the sample. Traditional laboratory source preparation methods require affixing a solution to a solid surface to create an essentially massless deposit using microprecipitation, evaporation, or electrodeposition. Ideal sources can take up to an hour to complete from beginning to end. The source preparation method described here is relatively fast and requires little input from the operator. The data acquisition time for a given sample is dependent on the total Pu present within the sample, which is characteristic of the sample. Therefore, total acquisition time would be similar when using either this deployable technique or a traditional laboratory technique.
During an assay of post-detonation nuclear debris, a wide range of Pu isotopic distributions may be observed.2,3,29 The principal alpha energies of 239Pu and 240Pu (5156 and 5168 keV, respectively) are not distinguishable with a typical alpha spectrometer. However, a forensic-relevant Pu ratio that can be readily measured by alpha spectrometry is the 238Pu/239,240Pu activity ratio, where the 239,240Pu sum peak is used instead. A 100 μL aliquot of CRM 138 containing approximately 722 Bq of Pu was evaporated onto an Al planchet and measured via offline alpha spectrometry. The CRM 138 isotope standard was used within one month of the purification procedure previously described. The 238Pu/239,240Pu activity ratio was measured as 0.0181 ± 0.0002 on November 3rd, 2021, consistent with the decay-corrected certified 238Pu/239,240Pu activity ratio of 0.0174 ± 0.0017. The Pu isotopic standard NBL CRM 138 was then used to demonstrate the online alpha spectrometric Pu measurement following SLM purification from bulk U.
A 1000 μL feed stock was prepared using CRM 138 Pu and the 1000 ppm U ICP-MS standard in 3 M HNO3 at a Pu/U mass ratio of 1 × 10−4 (approximately 3.15 × 10−7 g Pu and 3.15 × 10−3 g U). 10 μL of the iron(II) sulfamate stock was added and an online extraction was performed by injecting the feed product stream directly into the bottom of the alpha chamber. The extraction was terminated after 100 μL of the feed product stream was pumped into the alpha chamber (approximately 45 min total); following extraction, the alpha chamber was sealed off from the rest of the microfluidic line using a shut-off valve. The vacuum pump was turned on for 25 minutes to allow the feed product to dry and an alpha spectrum was acquired over 5 hours. Fig. 5 shows the resulting alpha spectrum of the feed product stream with a measured 238Pu/239,240Pu activity ratio of 0.0181 ± 0.0003 on November 5th, 2021, consistent with both the certified value and the previously measured value of the purified CRM 138 Pu. An accurate measure of the 238Pu/239,240Pu activity ratio in a sample with a low Pu/U mass ratio was obtained using the fieldable system in just over 6 hours, with 5 hours devoted to alpha spectrometry. This provides us with the first fieldable radiochemistry platform capable of separating Pu from excess U followed by a forensic evaluation of the Pu-bearing stream. Bringing these traditionally laboratory-based techniques into the field accelerates the pace of nuclear forensics in post-detonation scenarios. The development of this fieldable platform was made possible by the miniaturization of typical laboratory-based techniques into custom 3D printed modules capable of performing microfluidic chemistry coupled directly to alpha spectrometry.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2lc00391k |
‡ Present address: Argonne National Laboratory, Lemont, IL 60439, USA. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |