Samantha H.
Rutherford
*a,
Gregory M.
Greetham
b,
Michael
Towrie
b,
Anthony W.
Parker
b,
Soheila
Kharratian
cd,
Thomas F.
Krauss
d,
Alison
Nordon
e,
Matthew J.
Baker
af and
Neil T.
Hunt
c
aWestCHEM, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Strathclyde, Technology and Innovation Centre, 99 George Street, Glasgow, G1 1RD, UK. E-mail: samantha.hume-rutherford@strath.ac.uk
bSTFC Central Laser Facility, Research Complex at Harwell, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Harwell Campus, Didcot, OX11 0QX, UK
cDepartment of Chemistry and York Biomedical Institute, University of York, Heslington, York, YO10 5DD, UK
dSchool of Physics, Engineering and Technology and York Biomedical Research Institute, University of York, Heslington, York, YO10 5DD, UK
eWestCHEM, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry and CPACT, University of Strathclyde, 295 Cathedral Street, Glasgow, G1 1XL, UK
fDxcover Ltd, Suite RC534, 204 George Street, Glasgow, G1 1XL, UK
First published on 14th July 2022
Binding of drugs to blood serum proteins can influence both therapeutic efficacy and toxicity. The ability to measure the concentrations of protein-bound drug molecules quickly and with limited sample preparation could therefore have considerable benefits in biomedical and pharmaceutical applications. Vibrational spectroscopies provide data quickly but are hampered by complex, overlapping protein amide I band profiles and water absorption. Here, we show that two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy can achieve rapid detection and quantification of paracetamol binding to serum albumin in blood serum at physiologically-relevant levels with no additional sample processing. By measuring changes to the amide I band of serum albumin caused by structural and dynamic impacts of paracetamol binding we show that drug concentrations as low as 7 μM can be detected and that the availability of albumin for paracetamol binding is less than 20% in serum samples, allowing identification of paracetamol levels consistent with a patient overdose.
Infrared (IR) absorption spectroscopies provide molecular-level insight into complex mixtures but have, to date, failed to detect protein–drug binding in biofluids at clinical levels. This is because water (H2O) absorptions overlap strongly with the protein amide I band, while drug binding causes only subtle changes to this band, further hampering detection of protein–drug binding.6 In contrast, two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy has proven the ability to measure the protein content of biofluids.7 The amide I band provides a 2D-spectral signature linked to protein secondary structure,8,9 while the non-linear nature of the 2D-IR experiment suppresses interference from H2O absorptions.7 2D-IR signals have also been shown to be sensitive to protein binding in solution,6,10,11 suggesting that extension to interactions with serum proteins in vivo is feasible. Furthermore, the small sample volumes (<10 μL) needed for 2D-IR along with measurement times of a few minutes per sample raise the realistic prospect of future high-throughput screening applications of 2D-IR.12,13
Here, we target 2D-IR detection of paracetamol bound to serum albumin in blood serum at clinically relevant concentrations. Paracetamol is the most common drug consumed in the UK and accounts for ∼50% of all drug related hospital admissions.14 Emergency departments in the UK see on average ∼100000 patients presenting with a paracetamol overdose annually, with around half requiring hospital admission.14–16 While it is the free drug that is thought to be primarily responsible for toxic effects, the bound portion acts as a reservoir, releasing the drug in order to maintain an equilibrium of the bound-unbound fractions making it equally important to have knowledge of the bound fraction from a clinical perspective.17
Conventional analytical methods used to determine drug concentrations in blood serum employ laboratory-based assays that are only able to target the free drug fraction or the total level via protein dissociation.18–20 Although reliable, these methods typically produce results hours or days after blood collection, leading to delays in decisions and treatments and, potentially, to poorer outcomes and elevated costs associated with longer patient stays in hospital.21,22 Quicker analytical methods would allow earlier diagnosis, thus patient treatments and discharge from hospital can be managed in a timely manner. Emerging methods using electrochemical finger-prick tests have produced promising results for measuring free paracetamol levels in whole blood, but rapid access to the protein-bound drug concentration in serum remains challenging.19
Paracetamol is known to bind to serum albumin,23 the most abundant serum protein. Serum albumin primarily functions as a carrier protein, binding a variety of substrates and so plays a critical role in the pharmacokinetics of drugs.4,17,24,25 Although the structure of albumin is known, its binding behaviour is complex. It features at least two drug-binding sites (Sudlow I & II) and seven fatty acid binding sites, occupation of which can allosterically affect binding at the Sudlow sites.26,27 By adding paracetamol to serum samples spanning the normal clinical range for paracetamol from trace amounts to levels associated with potential hepatotoxicity,19,28 we used 2D-IR to identify spectroscopic changes in the amide I band of serum albumin and compared the changes to known binding behaviours, demonstrating the ability to detect protein-bound paracetamol at clinical concentrations and introducing a generalised approach for studying drug binding to serum proteins in vivo.
To study the spectroscopy of serum samples at a range of drug concentrations, powdered paracetamol (molecular weight; 151 g mol−1) was spiked into the pooled equine serum at a concentration of 1.8 mM, creating a 4:
1 molar ratio (1.8
:
0.45 mM) of paracetamol to the serum albumin. This sample was left overnight to maximise probability of drug–protein binding. Serial dilutions were created from the 4
:
1 solution by adding additional pooled serum, maintaining a consistent albumin concentration of 0.45 mM throughout. A total of 10 samples were created (Table 1) with the lowest concentration of paracetamol at 7 μM having a 0.01
:
1 drug
:
protein molar ratio. These samples span the clinically relevant range of paracetamol after a typical oral dose,28 from trace amounts to levels associated with potential hepatotoxicity, defined as serum levels at or above 1.323 mM and 43.1 μM at 4 h and 24 h post ingestion respectively.19
Sample | mmol dm−3 (mM) | μg mL−1 |
---|---|---|
0[P] | 0 | 0 |
0.01[P] | 0.007 | 1 |
0.03[P] | 0.015 | 2 |
0.06[P] | 0.03 | 4 |
0.12[P] | 0.06 | 9 |
0.25[P] | 0.11 | 17 |
0.5[P] | 0.22 | 34 |
1[P] | 0.45 | 69 |
2[P] | 0.9 | 137 |
4[P] | 1.8 | 275 |
Additionally, a paracetamol control sample was produced by dissolved the paracetamol at a concentration of 10 mg mL−1 (66 mM) in a Tris buffer, in H2O, at a pH of 7.5, to mimic the serum pH.
To measure IR and 2D-IR spectra in water using transmission mode, the sample thickness was carefully controlled to avoid saturation of the δH–O–H mode of water at 1650 cm−1. Samples were housed between two CaF2 windows and no spacer was used. The tightness of the sample holder was adjusted to obtain a consistent absorbance of ∼0.1 for the δOH + υlibr combination mode of water located at 2130 cm−1. Based upon the measured molar extinction coefficient of water, this corresponds to a sample thickness of ∼2.75 μm.7
Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to extract features specific to paracetamol–albumin binding and to discriminate between paracetamol containing samples and neat serum. PCA is an unsupervised multivariate analytical technique that aims to maximise the variance within the dataset, while reducing the data dimensionality.33,34 The algorithm was used without the addition of built-in scaling, normalisations or mean-centring parameters. Each sample was measured in triplicate, after analysis the results were averaged and standard deviations calculated for each sample concentration.
All 2D-IR spectra were pre-processed and analysed using a custom script written using the statistical analysis software programme, R.35
Applying PCA to 2D-IR spectra has been shown to allow identification of components of mixtures.36 PCA of the spectra in Fig. 1 revealed two main sources of variance (99.8% of the total). A distinct separation between the serum only sample (Fig. 2(a), black circle) and those containing paracetamol (Fig. 2(a), coloured circles) was observed upon plotting PC1 versus PC2, indicating a significant change in the serum spectrum upon addition of paracetamol even from concentrations as low as 7 μM. It is noted that as the data was not mean-centred prior to PCA, PC1 does not centre around zero. Examining these changes in more detail shows that the PC1 score (99.1% variance) remained constant with increasing paracetamol levels (Fig. 2(b)) while there was a notable increase in the PC2 score (0.7% variance, Fig. 2(c)) at small values of [P], which flattens at higher concentrations.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Principal component analysis (PCA) results for the n[P] dataset. (a) PC1 vs. PC2 scores, yellow and blue ellipses show data separation between 0[P] and those containing [P], respectively. Averaged score results for (b) PC1 and (c) PC2 as a function of [P]. Error bars show 1σ variation. Black dashed line denotes linear fit for PC1. (d) PC1 loadings plot (e) 2D-IR spectrum of 0[P] sample, black dashed line at 1652 cm−1 indicates pump slice viewed in Fig. 3 and (f) PC2 loading plot; red and blue arrows highlight lineshapes denoting an increase and reduction in signal, respectively. Blue and purple dashed lines highlight overlap of PC1 and PC2 with 0[P], respectively. |
The PC1 loadings plot is in close agreement with that of neat serum (Fig. 2(d) and (e), respectively). The PC2 loadings plot (Fig. 2(f)) shows a dominant feature with a pump frequency of 1652 cm−1, which coincides with the albumin amide I band (Fig. 2(e), black and purple dashed traces). An increase in PC2 score with increasing [P] indicates changes in the spectrum consistent with a reduction in albumin α-helix signal (Fig. 2(f), blue arrow), in agreement with the findings of other groups.26,37 The PC2 loadings also highlight a decrease in the anharmonicity of paracetamol bound albumin (Fig. 2(f), red arrow) as [P] increases. These observations can also be visualised via slices through the 2D-IR spectra at a pump frequency of 1652 cm−1 in Fig. 3(b). In contrast to the spectrum of neat serum (black dashed line), a clear shift to lower frequencies and a decrease in the v = 1–2 mode amplitude is observed with increasing paracetamol concentration (colour traces).
To ascertain that these spectral changes are not attributable to unbound paracetamol, a 2D-IR spectrum was obtained at a concentration of 66 mM, ∼40 times greater than the highest levels used in serum experiments, in aqueous buffer (Fig. S1†). Not only was the spectrum of free paracetamol too weak to detect at the levels added to serum samples, but the bands due to paracetamol did not coincide with the changes observed in the serum spectra. We thus assign the PC1 contribution to neat serum (Fig. 2(d and e)) and PC2 to spectral changes to the albumin signal associated with the addition of paracetamol (Fig. 2(f)).
To confirm the assignment of spectral changes due to albumin–paracetamol binding, we compared the spectral changes revealed by PCA with predictions of serum–paracetamol binding based on the known binding constant.37 To quantify the spectral changes, four data points, A–D, highlighted in Fig. 3(a) were used with the equation:
The ratio of points A and B quantifies changes in the albumin v = 1–2 peak relative to that of the globulin serum fraction, which is invariant with [P] (Fig. 2(f)). A reduction in signal at point A as observed for paracetamol binding, will thus increase this ratio. A previously-determined scaling factor of 1.8 has been applied to account for differences in the molar extinction coefficients of albumin and globulin.7 Similarly, the ratio of points C and D quantify the shift of the albumin peak to lower probe wavenumbers with increasing [P] (Fig. 3(b)), arising from a change in the anharmonicity of the amide I band of albumin. Plotting the Pbound parameter, normalised to the total protein concentration to mimic the drug–protein binding curve (Fig. S2†), as a function of drug concentration (Fig. 3(c)) results in the dependence on [P] shown in Fig. 3(c).
Albumin is reported to have one or two binding sites for paracetamol,37–39 which correlates well with the fact that our data shows spectral changes saturated at a paracetamol:
albumin molar ratio close to unity (Fig. 3(c)). The association constant for paracetamol and albumin has been determined to be 1 × 104 mol L−1.37 Comparing the normalised Pbound parameter to the expected concentration of paracetamol
:
albumin complex for a given [P] based on an albumin concentration of 0.45 mM, gives poor agreement with the experimental data (blue dashed line (Fig. 3(c)). However, this analysis assumes that all of the albumin in our samples is available for binding. By contrast, studies over a range of albumin and paracetamol concentrations suggests that only a small fraction (10–20%) of the albumin is available to bind paracetamol.23,40 Changing the model to reflect this reduced protein availability (10% solid black; 20% red dotted traces, Fig. 3(c)) gives much better agreement with the paracetamol binding parameter, showing that our data is consistent with available literature.23,40
With regard to the use of 2D-IR for general DMPK applications, characterisation of the spectral impact of albumin binding for any small molecule could be achieved following this protocol. The effectiveness of the 2D-IR approach will depend upon the spectral effect of binding and the effective concentrations of the drug and the binding constant, however, the potential for further development of the method is clear. When combined with our methodologies,7,31 the application of 2D-IR to detect and understand drug–protein complexes in serum is highlighted, making significant progress and allowing rapid, non-destructive, label-free and accurate diagnostics in situ without the need for any sample preparation or isolation of compounds. The ability to measure directly within blood and its derivatives will enable more effective drug treatments to be developed and advance the understanding of drugs in the human system as well as providing an approach to studying intermolecular structural dynamics in vivo.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2an00978a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |