Open Access Article
Zhengwei Xionga,
Qian Liua,
Jinlong Tanga,
Leiming Fangb,
Xiaoqiang Zhangc,
Jun Lid,
Yajun Fua,
Jin Wanga,
Zhipeng Gao
ad and
Deli Shi
*a
aJoint Laboratory for Extreme Conditions Matter Properties, Southwest University of Science and Technology, Mianyang, 621010, China. E-mail: deli.s@foxmail.com; 2801465754@qq.com
bInstitute of Physics Nuclear and Chemistry, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang, 621900, China
cInstitute of Electronic Engineering, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang, 621900, China
dInstitute of Fluid Physics, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang, 621900, China
First published on 19th April 2021
Fe nanocrystals (NCs) were embedded into the epitaxial BaTiO3 (BTO) matrix. According to optimized growth processes, a novel nanocomposite system was constructed, which consisted a well epitaxial BTO layer and three-dimensional Fe NCs. Based on this, the different dielectric response in the regions of low temperature-high frequency and low frequency-high temperature were revealed by the contribution of hopping and interfacial polarizations, respectively. With the increased amount of Fe NCs, the obvious enhancement in the low-frequency conductivity, middle frequency capacitance, and high-frequency inductive effect was found. The embedded metal NCs play an important role in tuning the dielectric behaviors and AC conductivity of oxide dielectrics. This significant rectification effect in wide-frequency ranges opens up a new direction for designing embedded nano-capacitors.
Actually, in the classical percolation model, metal particles were isolated by dielectric layers (ceramic phase) and regarded as capacitor electrodes. In this case, the three-dimensional (3D) geometry of metal particles, such as the size and spacing, are essential to the dielectric behavior of CMCs system. However, in the past reported CMC systems, contained metal particles had random and uncontrollable distribution.13–19 Although the volume fraction of metal particles in the dielectric matrix has been found to be an important factor in the high permittivity, according to the percolation model,22–24 the effect of the spacing or size has been rarely studied. In addition, all CMC systems in previous works possess a polycrystalline microstructure,11–22 leading to the existence of uncontrollable grains and grain boundaries. Consequently, the effect of the ceramic grains and the grain boundaries on the dielectric response in the CMCs is difficult to clarify in detail. Therefore, the dielectric behaviors of CMCs at varied frequencies explained by the percolation theory are still controversial.
In this work, we embedded the Fe NCs into the BTO dielectric matrix, and achieved a co-existence system of the NCs and the epitaxial dielectric matrix. Compared with other typical polycrystalline ceramics in CMCs, the highly epitaxial BTO matrix almost exhibited no grains and grain boundaries,26 providing an ideal model to disclose and analyze the electric mechanism induced by the metal NCs in wide frequency regions. The dielectric properties and AC conductivity in the Fe NCs–BTO composites were investigated in wide frequency ranges from 10−1 to 107 Hz. Based on this, the influence of the capacitor, resistor, and inductance in the CMCs has been clearly explained.
The growth progresses of the films were measured in situ using a reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED) system. The typical energy of the electrons was 25 keV and a CCD camera was used to observe the diffraction pattern. The results were analyzed with a commercial software. Atomic force microscopy (AFM, Veeco Instruments, Nanoscope IIIA) was utilized to observe the morphologies of the Fe NCs–BTO nanocomposites and the spacing (R) between the Fe NCs and the diameters (D) of Fe NCs were estimated by statistics. All the AFM results were captured in 512 × 512 pixels by a standard Si3N4 probe (Model NP), typically with a cantilever of 100 μm in length and tens of nm in diameter at the apex. TEM examinations were conducted using a JEOL 4000EX high resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM) equipped with a Gatan imaging filter (GIF). The microscope was operated at 400 kV, which provides a point-to-point resolution of 0.17 nm. Chemical analysis was done by electron energy-loss spectroscopy (EELS). For cross-section TEM characterization, samples were prepared using cutting and mechanical polishing, followed by dimpling to create thin areas with total thicknesses of about 10 μm. Final thinning was done using low energy (3 keV) argon-ion milling, giving thin electron-transparent areas of about 200 nm in thickness. The final thinning of the specimens was carried out on a Gatan precision ion polishing system (PIPS™, Model 691) using an accelerating voltage of 5.0 kV and an incident angle of 3°–5°. The dielectric properties of the films were measured using an impedance analyzer (HP 4294A, Agilent) in the frequency range from 10−1 to 107 Hz. The Au top electrode was formed on fabricated composite films by the L-MBE. The 0.5 wt% Nb:SrTiO3 (001) substrate was used as the bottom electrode.
The cross-sectional TEM image in Fig. 2a displays a multilayer structure, consisting of BTO separating layers with a uniform thickness of ∼40 nm and the Fe NCs layers. Along the growth direction, namely, the epitaxial (00l) orientation, the HRTEM image (Fig. 2b) shows that the Fe NCs are embedded in the BTO matrix. The dark area corresponds to the Fe phase due to the relatively heavy elements. Around the edge of the interfaces between the Fe NCs and BTO, some misfit dislocations exist such as missing atom planes or other defects. On getting far from the interfaces, highly organized lattices of BTO are observed, indicating the (001) plane. We further measured the lattice spacing of Fe (1.982 Å) and BTO (4.015 Å), corresponding to the planes of (110) and (100), respectively. Despite the introduction of local dislocations, the lattices of hetero-epitaxial BTO films are almost not disturbed by the Fe NCs. The lattice relaxation has been revealed in the Ni NCs/BTO composite films.24 The strain derived from the large lattice mismatch plays a part of the source of the driving force for the embedded NCs. In order to reduce the interfacial stress, the NCs (110) with minimum strain energy are presented so as to provide a flat fresh surface to the next BTO atomic layers. This greatly reduces the effect of strained distortions caused by the large lattice mismatch between the different interfaces. From the HRTEM observation (Fig. 3b), the sufficient lattice relaxation between the Fe NCs and BTO interfaces demonstrates the absence of boundary layers. We further provided the EELS of Fe–L3,2 in the composite films (Fig. S1, ESI†). It can be seen that the position of the L3 and L2 edge from the area of Fe is 707.2 and 721.3 eV, respectively. It proves that the Fe element presents a metallic state in the composite films instead of iron oxides.27,28 Thus, combined with the RHEED, HRTEM, and EELS results, it can be concluded that the metal Fe NCs were successfully embedded in the single crystal BTO matrix.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) Cross-sectional TEM image of the films with the separate BaTiO3 layer (the thickness of 40 nm) and the embedded Fe NCs, (b) the HRTEM image. | ||
As the AFM results of the BTO grown structure in Fig. 3 shows, the small NCs are sparsely distributed on the epitaxial BTO matrix, corresponding to the diffraction spots of the REHHD patterns (Fig. 1b–e). With the increase in deposition time, denser Fe NCs are presented on the BTO surface, suggesting the obviously decreased R between the Fe NCs. To analyze the D and R of the Fe NCs clearly, the average values of D and R are given in Fig. 3, corresponding to D = 4.9, 5.0, and 5.2 nm and R = 32.5, 15.6, and 7.8 nm for the P1, P2, and P3 samples, respectively. Thus, the spacing between the Fe NCs is gradually decreased while the NC diameters are almost unchanged with increased amount of Fe NCs. This result means that the number of equivalent grains (the BTO films between NCs) and grain boundaries (contact interfaces between the NCs and BTO) both increase.
The ε′ and tan
δ values of pure BTO films were measured as a function of temperature (293–593 K) at different frequencies (10−1 to 107 Hz), and the results are shown in Fig. 4. The ε′ plots of the pure BTO films deliver a peak at about 400 K (Fig. 4a), which suggests the Curie temperature point (Tc) of the BTO, agreeing well the previous works.22–24 With the increase in the frequencies, the peaks of ε′ and the corresponding tan
δ plots (Fig. 4b) of the BTO shift, showing an obvious dielectric relaxation phenomenon. In fact, the dielectric response of the perfect BTO single crystal should not display any relaxation below 10 MHz. However, the strain gradients caused by the partial coherence of the film with the substrates in the epitaxial films are unavoidable and would further form a network of dislocations to partially relax the thin films.29–31 Hence, dielectric relaxation was also found in the experimentally epitaxial BTO films.29–31
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) Dielectric constant and (b) dielectric loss tan δ of the pure BTO sample at varied frequencies. | ||
Compared with the ε′ and tan
δ of pure BTO films in Fig. 4, the Fe NCs–BTO samples possess high dielectric constant at low frequencies and higher dielectric loss (see Fig. 5). Besides, the ε′ plots of the Fe NCs–BTO thin films possess the following features (Fig. 5a–c): (1) with the increase in temperature from 293 to 593 K, the ε′ rises rapidly and a strong dispersion is also observed at low frequency (<100 Hz), which can be attributed to the increased macroscopically interfacial electron charge density activated by increasing the temperatures;1,6,12,13,18 (2) with decreased R, the values of ε′ are also increased; (3) frequency dependent ε′ in the low and high frequency regions can be observed while a frequency independent plateau is presented in the midfrequency regions. The abnormal ε′ at low and high frequencies could be explained by the MW function and the Debye law, respectively.12,13,18,20 Generally, the resultant low-frequency ε′ of dielectric materials is due to different types of polarization (dipolar, ionic, electronic, and interfacial).21 Electronic and ionic relaxations are related to very rapid oscillations of weak dipoles and are only measurable at higher frequencies (>1010 Hz).21 Dipolar and interfacial polarization usually contribute to colossal permittivity at low frequencies.18,21 Many researchers have reported that the origin of colossal ε′ in BTO-based ceramics is the result of hopping polarization within the grains and the interfacial polarization at the grain boundaries.6,18,21 In this work, increasing the embedded amount of Fe NCs and the resultant decreasing spacing R between the NCs can correspond to the changes in the equivalent grains and the grain boundaries, which should also contribute to the abnormal dielectric response. To further clarify the effect of the grains and the grain boundaries on the dielectric property for different samples, the contributions of hopping polarization and interfacial polarization to the ε′ will be quantitatively analyzed later.
For the P1 sample, an obvious tan
δ peak occurs at low frequencies, accompanied by a weaker peak in the midfrequency region (Fig. 5d). With the increased amount of Fe NCs for the P2 sample (Fig. 5e), a low-frequency peak for P1 is quenched and only one tan
δ peak prominently emerges at the midfrequency region. Further increasing the amount of Fe NCs induces the disappearance of the midfrequency peak in P2 and produces a weak peak at a high frequency in the P3 sample (Fig. 5f). These resonant frequency (f) peaks would move to high frequency with the increase in temperature for all the samples. The shifting of dielectric loss peaks is well correlated with the variation in the dielectric constants. Combined with ε′ and tan
δ, the dielectric relaxation is gradually weakened and moved from the low frequency to the high frequency region with an increase in the Fe NCs amount.
As we all know, the relaxation frequency can be represented by
f = f0 exp(−Ea/kBT)
| (1) |
To further prove this assumption clearly, ε′ in the universal dielectric response model can be written as follows.
| fε′ = A(T)fs | (2) |
f plot in Fig. 7a and b at a given temperature represents the value of s. The fitted straight line is deviated from the slope as the frequency increases due to relaxation, subsequently decreasing in a step-like behavior and displaying another straight line at the high temperature region. Two different slopes are observed in all the samples, which are located at low temperatures-high frequencies and high temperatures-lower frequencies, suggesting two different dominant polarizations.6,18 One of s = 0.95 and 0.98 occurs at 293 K and higher frequencies, while the other s = 0.90 and 0.93 are obtained at 593 K and lower frequencies for the P1 and P3 samples, respectively. Actually, as the value of s is closer to 1, the polarization charges are more strictly localized.6,18,22 Compared to the high temperature-low frequency region, the larger s at low temperature-high frequency reveals more localized charge carriers of polarization. It is obvious that more amounts of Fe NCs with stronger local field enhancement induce larger values of s. Due to a certain energy to overcome the relatively small energy barrier for polarization, hopping polarization is becoming active at high frequencies and low temperatures. Nevertheless, the sufficient energy to overcome the large energy barrier at low frequencies and high temperatures is the interfacial polarization, which is associated with mobile electrons in the NCs and holes in the BTO, which are activated.18,22 Therefore, hopping polarization plays a primary role in the low temperature-higher frequency region, while interfacial polarization is dominant at high temperatures-lower frequencies.
The high value of ε′ has been attributed to the MW-type contributions of the grains and the insulating grain boundaries in the IBLCs model.32 On assuming the IBLCs model, the periodic Fe NCs–BTO nanostructure can be equivalent to a series connection of conductive Fe NCs and insulating BTO, where the NCs and the contact interfaces between the Fe NCs and BTO plays the role of grains and grain boundaries, respectively. Based on the analysis, this structure is much similar to that of the IBLCs model. Thus, the contribution of interfacial polarization to the colossal permittivity at 593 K and 0.1 Hz can be calculated using the IBLCs model,32 which can be presented by
| εeff = ε′D/R | (3) |
410 at 0.1 Hz and 593 K. The measured D of the varied samples are both ∼5 nm and the R is 32.5 nm for P1. Thus, the effective permittivity of 125
104 is calculated, which is equivalent to 15.4% of the huge experimental permittivity. Therefore, the huge permittivity at high temperatures and low frequencies can be attributed to the 15.4% interfacial polarization and 84.6% hopping polarization in the P1. Based on this estimation, the relative contribution of interfacial and hopping polarizations is calculated for each sample. The proportion of interfacial polarization is 15.4%, 32.1%, and 64.1%, while the hopping polarization is 84.6%, 67.9%, and 35.9% for the P1, P2, and P3 samples, respectively. With the decreased R of the Fe NCs, interfacial polarization gradually plays a dominate role in the high dielectric response at high temperatures-low frequencies. Consequently, the interfacial and hopping polarization can be tuned quantitatively by adjusting the R between the Fe NCs in this nano-CMCs system.
Fig. 7c and d display the σ–f curves of the samples at different temperature. By contrast, the P1 and P3 samples possess the following difference: (1) at low frequency, both P1 and P3 have a frequency independence plateau, also named DC conductivity σ0, while the plateau values of σ for P3 are higher than that of P1 due to the increased concentration of Fe NCs; (2) in the midfrequency region, P1 has a narrow plateau in this frequency range, while the σ of the P3 is linearly correlated with the frequencies; (3) at high frequencies, the σ of P1 at varied temperatures is dependent on the frequencies, while P3 owns a narrow plateau. In the conventional jump relaxation model (σ = σ0 + A1ωn1 + A2ωn2),8 the lg
σ–lg
f curves increase linearly with different slopes in the mid-frequency and high frequency regions, differing from our results.
To clarify the variation, the typical RLC electric model was utilized in this system. As the schematic diagram shows in Fig. 7e, the embedded Fe NCs and the BTO between the Fe NCs can be regarded as the electrodes and the dielectrics between the electrodes in a capacitor, respectively. In addition, the metal NCs have an intrinsic resistance and parasitic inductance.25 Therefore, the Fe NCs–BTO system can be simplified as a typical RLC electric model, as shown in the inset of Fig. 7e. Furthermore, the Zt in the RLC electric system is equal to Rt + jωLt − 1/jωCt, where ω is the angular frequency (ω = 2πf). In combination with the frequency dependence Zt of the classical RLC model in Fig. 7f, it is clear that the resonant frequency (fR) would move to high frequencies with decreased Ct.25
Fig. S2† shows the temperature dependence conductivity (σ) of 0.5 wt% Nb:SrTiO3 substrates and the epitaxial BTO films. With the increase in temperature, the σ of the Nb:SrTiO3 substrate is almost linearly decreased (Fig. S2a†), which may be because Nb:SrTiO3 behaves as a doped semiconductor with the electrons being thermally activated. On the contrary, the σ–T curves of the BTO films present insulating properties. Thus, we can exclude the influence of 0.5 wt% Nb:SrTiO3 substrates on the films. By comparison, the conductivities of the Fe NCs–BTO composites (Fig. 6c and d) are higher than that of the BTO films (Fig. S2b†), proving that the embedded Fe NCs could really increase the σ of the BTO matrix. The increased leakage conductance further brings an increase in the tan
δ (Fig. 4b). To sum up, it can be concluded that the embedded Fe NCs could indeed change the dielectric properties of the epitaxial BTO films. Besides, there might exist a small amount of Fe ions in their valence states (e.g. Fe3+), which could possibly be located at the interfaces between the BTO and the Fe NCs although the elemental metallic state of the Fe NCs has been demonstrated by the EELS measurement (Fig. S1†). Several investigations have found that tiny cationic dopants (such as Fe3+ and Bi3+) could urge the transformation of BTO from a ferroelectric to a relaxor material.33,34 Thus, the possible existence of Fe ions could influence the dielectric performance of the composite films, which will be carried out in the future.
Here, the narrow σ plateaus of P1 in the mid-frequency region can be assigned to the relaxation of the dielectric constants (Fig. 4a). With the decreased R of the Fe NCs, Ct increases (Ct = ε′S/R, where S and R represents the area and spacing between the Fe NC electrodes, respectively), indicating the enhanced capacitance effect (blocking DC current and flowing AC current). As a result, the ability of blocking the DC current and flowing an AC current is increased, leading to the linear dependence of σ–f in the midfrequency region for the P3. Furthermore, at high frequencies, the narrow σ plateaus of the P3 can be attributed to the NCs inductance effect (blocking the high-frequency AC current and flowing the high-frequency DC current). With the increased amount of Fe NCs, Lt is increasing,25 implying the enhanced inductance effect. Thus, the ability of blocking the AC current and flowing the AC current is increased, resulting in the plateaus of P3 in the high frequency region relative to the linear dependence of σ–f in the P1. Increasing the amount of Fe NCs induces an obvious enhancement in the low-frequency conductivity, mid-frequency capacitance effect, and high-frequency inductive effect. Therefore, NC embedding plays an important role in adjusting the AC conductivity in the CMC systems. The obvious rectification effect offers a great nano-CMC system for application in dielectric capacitors and other electrical devices.
000), Adv. Mater., 2001, 13, 1541 CrossRef CAS.Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Electron energy loss spectroscopy of Fe–L3,2 in the composite films. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ra09854j |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |