Thomas M.
McGuire
and
Antoine
Buchard
*
Centre for Sustainable and Circular Technologies, Department of Chemistry, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath BA2 7AY, UK. E-mail: a.buchard@bath.ac.uk
First published on 6th July 2021
A D-xylose anhydro sugar derivative (1) has been applied in the ring-opening copolymerisation (ROCOP) with CS2 to form a polythiocarbonate (poly(CS2-co-1)) with high head-head/tail-tail regioselectivity towards alternating thiono- and trithiocarbonate linkages (up to 95%). Through variation of the reaction parameters (e.g. temperature and CS2 stoichiometry), some control over the regioselectivity (head-head/tail-tail linkages 57–95%) and the nature of the polymer linkages is possible. Conditions can also be tailored to enable the facile isolation of a polymerisable cyclic xanthate, 2. Kinetic experiments suggest that across the range of temperatures studied, the formation of poly(CS2-co-1) proceeds at least partially by direct copolymerisation of 1 and CS2, without necessarily going through the ring-opening polymerisation (ROP) of 2. Poly(CS2-co-1) exhibits partial chemical recyclability into cyclic monomer 2 (up to 45% after 20 h at 110 °C with [poly(CS2-co-1)]0 = 1.34 mol L−L). Finally, rapid degradation (<1 h) of poly(CS2-co-1) is possible under UV radiation (λ = 365 nm) and is accelerated in the presence of tris(trimethylsilyl)silane (TTMSS).
It is known that the replacement of oxygen atoms with sulfur ones in oxygenated polymers can give the resulting polythioethers, polythiocarbonates and polythioesters enhanced physical and thermal properties,10–16 as well as additional advanced optical17 and electrical characteristics.18 Moreover, sulfur-containing polymers exhibit biocompatibility and have shown potential in metal and bacterial adhesion.19,20 The presence of sulfur atoms in the backbone of polymers may also accelerate degradation under appropriate conditions (e.g. under UV radiation).19,21
The synthesis of polythiocarbonates is possible through polycondensation,22–25 the ring-opening polymerisation (ROP) of cyclic thiocarbonates,26,27 polyalkylation of trithiocarbonates28,29 or the ring-opening copolymerisation (ROCOP) of CS215,30–33 and COS11,34–38 with cyclic ethers (epoxides and oxetane). ROCOP methods are particularly interesting given the array of synthetic possibilities provided by the pool of cyclic ethers usable, coupled with the polymerisation control brought by existing ROCOP catalysts.39,40 To date, both heterogeneous (e.g. Zn–Co(III) double-metal cyanide complexes)41 and homogeneous catalysts/initiators (e.g. metal salen/onium catalysts30,34,42 and LiOtBu31) have been reported for CS2/cyclic ether ROCOP. However, reports of ROCOP between an oxetane and CS2 remain rare.32
CS2 is manufactured by reaction of charcoal or natural gas with sulfur, and despite its known toxicity, incorporating it into polymers has some benefits in terms of waste valorisation. Indeed, sulfur is an abundant by-product of the oil and chemical industry.43–45 Our group has previously used CS2 to synthesise a series of cyclic thiocarbonates for ROP towards sugar-derived polythiocarbonates.27 However, the synthesis of these monomers was challenging, necessitating extensive purification (e.g. successive column chromatography) to be suitable for ROP techniques. For xylose-derived xanthate monomer, 2, ROP towards poly(2) formed a regioregular polymer with up to 87% head-head/tail-tail (HH/TT), trithiocarbonate/thionocarbonate linkages, although no control over the polymer microstructure was demonstrated.
It was envisioned that the ROCOP of CS2 with oxetane-functionalised xylofuranose derivative, 1, may expediate the polymer synthesis given its ease of preparation in purities suitable for ROP46 and ROCOP.47 Moreover, we hypothesised that alternative polymer sequences may be accessible through ROCOP. Lastly, through judicious choice of conditions, it was hoped that the reaction between CS2 and 1 could be tailored towards cycloaddition over copolymerisation, to access 2 with fewer purification steps.
We have previously used 1,2-cyclohexanediamino-N,N′-bis(3,5-di-t-butylsalicyilidene)-chromium(III), CrSalen and bis(triphenylphosphine)iminium chloride (PPNCl) to catalyse the ROCOP of cyclic anhydrides and 1 for the preparation of polyesters.47 CrSalen/onium salts (PPNN3) binary catalytic system has also been applied in the ROCOP of oxetane with CS2. Detailed study revealed the presence of multiple polymer linkages indicative of sulfur/oxygen scrambling which became more prevalent at higher temperatures.32 Werner and co-workers have reported on the ROCOP of terminal epoxides with CS2 initiated by LitOBu.31 The polythiocarbonates were found to be highly regioregular with up to 94% head-head/tail-tail alternating thionocarbonate/trithiocarbonate linkages.
Herein we describe the ROCOP of 1 with CS2 to form sugar-based sulfur-containing polymers with very high regioselectivity towards HH/TT, trithiocarbonate/thionocarbonate linkages (up to 95%), marking an improvement on the similar polymer synthesised through the ROP of 2. The head/tail configuration of poly(CS2-co-1) can be varied through modulation of the reaction temperature and CS2 stoichiometry. Mechanistic investigations show that ROCOP proceeds at least partially directly. Lastly, poly(CS2-co-1) exhibits partial chemical recyclability into 2, as well as full degradation under UV light.
Entry | T (°C) | [1]0:[CS2]0: [cat]0:[co-cat]0 | Cat. | Co-catalyst | % conv. of 1a | % 2b | % poly(CS2-co-1) b | Polymer linkages ratio n:m:lc | M n,SEC [ĐM] (g mol−1)d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reactions carried out in σ-dichlorobenzene at [1]0 = 1.34 mol L−1 over 20 h unless stated otherwise.a Conversion of 1 determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 using relative integration of anomeric protons in 1 (δ = 6.26 ppm (d, J = 3.7 Hz, 1H)), poly(CS2-co-1) (δ = 5.88–5.99 ppm (1H)),and 2 (CDCl3, δ = 6.03 ppm (d, J = 3.7 Hz, 1H)).b Calculated by 1H NMR spectroscopy using relative integration of anomeric protons in poly(CS2-co-1) and 2.c Calculated by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 using relative integration of e environments (CH2) assigned to HH/TT trithiocarbonate linkages n (δ = 3.68 ppm (h, J = 6.9 Hz, 4H)), HT xanthate linkages m (δ = 3.51 ppm (t, J = 6.6 Hz, 2H).and thioether linkages l (δ = 3.04–2.74 ppm (m, 2H)).d Calculated by SEC relative to polystyrene standards in THF eluent; ĐM = Mw/Mn..e Time = 309 h.f Bracketed values taken at 119 h.g [1]0 = 0.67 mol L−1.h [1]0 = 0.335 mol L−1.i 0.08 mol L−1. | |||||||||
1e | 25 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 61 | 4 | 96 | 92:6:2 | 8700 [1.70] |
2f | 60 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 88 | 15 {10} | 85 {90} | 85:9:6 {59:10:31} | 12000[1.77] {5300 [2.02] } |
3 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 13 | 77 | 89:9:2 | 15000 [2.13] |
4 | 100 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 14 | 76 | 73:11:16 | 7700 [1.63] |
5 | 140 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 38 | 62 | 57:12:31 | 6300 [1.93] |
6 | 80 | 200:100:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 58 | 34 | 66 | 56:7:36 | 2700 [1.68] |
7 | 80 | 200:200:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 22 | 78 | 82:10:8 | 9100 [1.76] |
8 | 80 | 200:800:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 10 | 90 | 95:5:0 | 14000[1.78] |
9 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | CoSalen | PPNCl | 0 | — | — | — | — |
10 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | AlSalen | PPNCl | 1 | — | — | — | — |
11 | 25 | 200:400:1:1 | AlTris | PPNCl | 12 | 8 | 92 | — | — |
12 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | AlTris | PPNCl | 100 | 19 | 81 | 75:10:15 | 6300 [1.69] |
13 | 100 | 200:400:1:1 | AlTris | PPNCl | 100 | 52 | 48 | 55:7:38 | 2200 [1.53] |
14 | 80 | 200:400:1:5 | LZn 2 Ph 2 | CHD | 1 | — | — | — | — |
15 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | KOtBu | 18-Crown-6 | 2 | — | — | — | — |
16 | 80 | 200:400:1:0 | CrSalen | — | 8 | 43 | 57 | — | — |
17 | 80 | 200:400:0:1 | — | PPNCl | 0 | — | — | — | — |
18 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | NBu4Cl | 91 | 16 | 84 | 91:5:4 | 6600 [2.00] |
19 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | NBu4Br | 4 | — | — | — | — |
20 | 80 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | NBu4I | 51 | 31 | 69 | 77:11:12 | 4700 [1.77] |
21 | 110 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 35 | 65 | 66:11:23 | 4400 [1.58] |
22g | 110 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 100 | 58 | 42 | 47:8:45 | 1700 [1.33] |
23h | 110 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 93 | 65 | 35 | 39:10:51 | 1400 [1.28] |
24i | 110 | 200:400:1:1 | CrSalen | PPNCl | 33 | 52 | 48 | — | — |
Entry | T (°C) | Reagent | % a Conv | % b Polym | n:m:lc | M n,SEC [ĐM]d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reactions carried out for 20 h in σ-dichlorobenzene with [2/1monomerunit]0:[CrSalen]0:[PPNCl]0 loadings of 200:1:1, and [2/1monomerunit]0 = 1.34 mol L−1 unless otherwise stated.a Conversion of substrate determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 using relative integration of anomeric protons (1H) in substrates and products (1: δ = 6.26 ppm (d, J = 3.7 Hz)); poly(CS2-co-1): δ = 5.88–5.99 ppm; 2: δ = 6.03 ppm (d, J = 3.7 Hz).b Calculated by 1H NMR spectroscopy using relative integration of anomeric protons in poly(CS2-co-1) and 2.c Calculated by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 using relative integration of e environments (CH2) assigned to HH/TT trithiocarbonate linkages n (δ = 3.68 ppm (h, J = 6.9 Hz, 4H)), HT xanthate linkages m (δ = 3.51 ppm (t, J = 6.6 Hz, 2H).and thioether linkages l (δ = 3.04–2.74 ppm (m, 2H)).d Calculated by SEC relative to polystyrene standards in THF eluent; ĐM = Mw/Mn.e Reaction performed with [2]0:[TBD]0:[4-MeBnOH]0 loadings of 100:1:1 in DCM with [2]0 = 1.0 mol L−1, time = 15 minutes.f Substrate polymer data: n:m:l ratio = 82:6:12; Mn,SEC = 8500 g mol−1.g Insoluble black residue formed during 20 h reaction. | ||||||
1e (ref. 27) | 25 | 2 | 86 | 86 | 87:10:3 | 10600 [1.5] |
2 | 80 | 2 | 75 | 75 | 85:12:3 | 12700 [2.05] |
3f | 80 | Poly(CS2-co-1) | 0 | 100 | 76:8:16 | 8200 [1.70] |
4f | 110 | Poly(CS2-co-1) | 45 | 55 | 65:10:25 | 3600 [1.62] |
5f | 140 | Poly(CS2-co-1) | —g | — | — | — |
Minor resonances associated with the e environment were also observed between δ = 2.65–3.13 ppm and δ = 3.42–3.56 ppm, suggesting the occurrence of other polymer linkages (Fig. 2). While only resonances S1 and S2 were observed in the thiocarbonyl region of the 13C{1H} NMR spectrum of isolated poly(CS2-co-1) (Fig. 1e), a weak correlation between a xanthate-like (δ = 212.8 ppm) and an e (δ = 3.42–3.56 ppm) proton environment was detected by 1H–13C{1H} NMR HMBC spectroscopy (Fig. 2c), revealing the presence of xanthate polymer linkages (exanthate). Conversely, no 1H–13C{1H} NMR HMBC correlation was observed for the e proton environment detected at δ = 2.65–3.13 ppm. Comparison with literature data32 revealed that the 1H NMR and 13C{1H} NMR shift values of this resonance was comparable to known polythioethers (Fig. 2b),36 corroborating the absence of a nearby quaternary carbon. This resonance was therefore attributed to a thioether polymer linkage (ethioether). The complexity of the signals seen may stem from random position of the thioether linkages in the polymer sequence. Regardless of the origins of those various linkages, the e environments in the 1H NMR spectra were thus identified as an easy way to assess the selectivity of the ROCOP process.
Encouraged by this preliminary data, further catalytic ROCOP experiments were performed to study the effect of concentration, temperature, CS2 stoichiometry and nature of the catalyst and of co-catalyst on the products of the ROCOP reaction (Table 1).
Within the limits of 1H NMR spectroscopy, in all the experiments performed, all resonances seen could be assigned to poly(CS2-co-1) (as described above), cyclic xanthate 2 or oxetane monomer 1 (Fig. 1). However, varying the reaction temperature caused significant divergences in product distributions. Increasing the temperature resulted in a loss of regioselectivity (Table 1, entries 1–5 and Fig. S6†). At 25 °C, 60 °C and 80 °C, high HH/TT regioselectivity was observed (92, 85 and 89%, respectively, Table 1, entries 1–3). Conversely, for reactions performed at 100 °C and 140 °C, lower percentages of trithiocarbonates linkages were observed (73 and 57%, respectively, Table 1, entries 4 and 5) with an increase in thioether linkages detected (16% and 31%, respectively). The increased occurrence of thioether linkages at elevated temperatures likely arises from the elimination of COS from propagation intermediates, favoured by entropy (Scheme S2†) and as noted in previous studies.30,32,42 The ratio of xanthate links also increased with temperature, but to a lesser extent than for the thioethers (6% at 25 °C up to 12% at 140 °C, Table 1 entries 1–5).The formation of xanthate linkages may be a result of several mechanisms: the ‘expected’ CS2/1 ROCOP, but also various S/O rearrangements occurring during ROCOP,27 including transthiocarbonation between polymer chains, as well as the regioregular ROP of 2 (Schemes S1 and S2†).
At 80 °C, quantitative conversion of 1 was observed after 20 h, yielding the maximum molar mass of polymer achieved under the conditions tested (15000 g mol−1, ĐM = 2.13, Table 1, entry 3). More generally, obtained Mn,SEC values were far from Mn,theo, likely due to residual protic impurities (e.g. 1,2-O-isopropylidene-D-xylofuranose) in the monomer samples which may act as chain transfer agents to decrease the molar mass of the polymers. This is typical within the field of cyclic ether/CS2 ROCOP.30,32,42 Further purification of 1, including via successive or reactive distillation with NaH/MeI,52 unfortunately did not increase the polymer molar masses. While analysis of the polymer by MALDI ToF mass spectrometry proved unsuccessful, end-group titration by 31P NMR spectroscopy indicated that some of the polymer chains were linear and terminated by secondary alcohol end groups (Fig. S24 and 25†).
Increasing the temperature to 100 °C and 140 °C, also resulted in quantitative conversion of 1, although the polymer molar masses were lower (7700 g mol−1, ĐM = 1.63 and 6300, ĐM = 1.93, Table 1 entries 4 and 5, respectively). At these temperatures, several factors may be responsible for a decrease in molar mass, including the increased occurrence of thioether linkages (concurrent with loss of COS) in the polymer, and the decreased reaction selectivity towards polymer (in favour of cyclic monomer 2), in line with thermodynamics principles.
The reaction at 60 °C was monitored for up to 5 days to assess the impact of longer reaction times on the polymer linkages and molar mass (Table 1, entry 2). A decrease in molar mass and increasing thioether linkages were observed, suggesting decarbonylsulfonation of the polymer chains upon extended heating.
The effect of the co-catalyst nature was next studied (Table 1, entries 18–20). A reaction performed with NBu4Cl at 80 °C with [1]0:[CS2]:[CrSalen]0:[NBu4Cl]0 loadings of 200:400:1:1 gave 91% conversion of 1 with comparable selectivity ratios to those observed with PPNCl (Table 1, entry 18), albeit with lower molar mass polymer obtained (6600 vs. 15000 g mol−1 in entry 3). Conversely, a copolymerisation carried out with NBu4Br gave only 4% conversion, indicating the bromide salt is unsuitable for 1/CS2 ROCOP (Table 1, entry 19). Under similar conditions, NBu4I gave improved conversion of 1 although with lower activity than observed with PPNCl and NBu4Cl (Table 1, entry 20). An increased amount of 2 was also observed suggesting that iodide may promote backbiting.
Collectively, these data thus identified CrSalen/PPNCl as the optimal binary catalytic system for 1/CS2 ROCOP so far, in terms of activity, polymer molar mass, and regioselectivity of the polymer linkages.
In order to probe whether the copolymerisation of CS2/1 occurred via ROP of 2, reaction monitoring by 1H NMR spectroscopy was performed at 25 °C, 80 °C and 110 °C with [1]0:[CS2]0:[CrSalen]0:[PPNCl]0 loadings of 200:400:1:1 (Fig. 4). At 80 °C, inspection of the early stages (<1 h) of the reaction revealed that polymer and 2 formed at approximately the same rate (Fig. 4a). After 1–2 h, the concentration of 2 plateaued as the polymer concentration increased.
At 110 °C, simultaneous rapid formation of both the polymer and cyclic xanthate was also observed (Fig. 4c), whereas at 25 °C, minimal xanthate was detected across several days (Fig. 4d). An experiment to monitor the ROP of 2 was also performed at 80 °C, with [2]0:[CS2]0:[CrSalen]0:[PPNCl]0 loadings of 200:200:1:1 in the presence of a alcohol initiator, 4-MeBnOH. CS2 and 4-MeBnOH were added to the reaction mixture in attempt to simulate ROCOP conditions, in which excess CS2 and polymer growing chains are present in solution. Assuming first order kinetics in monomer, the rate of polymer formation was slower in the ROP of 2 than in the 1/CS2 ROCOP (Fig. 4b). With no build-up of 2 seen during ROCOP, this data therefore suggest that polymer is formed at least partially via direct ROCOP.
2 could also be formed via back-biting of the polymer chains (Fig. 3). A reaction performed at 80 °C with isolated polymer as substrate, at [poly(CS2-co-1)]0:[CrSalen]0:[PPNCl]0 loadings of 200:1:1, gave no formation of cyclic xanthate after 20 h (Table 2, entry 3). This suggests that at 80 °C, cycloaddition of 1 and CS2 is the dominant mechanism for formation 2. However, at 110 °C, backbiting was observed, with approximately 45% xanthate formed after 20 h. No other cyclic species were detected in solution (Table 2, entry 4). The polymer molar mass also decreased from 8500 g mol−1 to 3600 g mol−1, corroborating the loss of 2 from polymer chains. Increasing the temperature further to 140 °C led to formation of a black, insoluble residue (Table 2, entry 5). SEC analysis of the THF-soluble fraction indicated the presence of oligomers only. These data suggest that at elevated temperatures, alternative depolymerisation mechanisms are operative leading to significant, uncontrolled, polymer degradation.
Entry | n:m:la | M n,SEC [ĐM] (g mol−1)b | T d,onset (°C) | T d5 (°C) | T g (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Calculated by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 using relative integration of e environments (CH2) assigned to HH/TT trithiocarbonate linkages n (δ = 3.68 ppm (h, J = 6.9 Hz, 4H)), HT xanthate linkages m (δ = 3.51 ppm (t, J = 6.6 Hz, 2H).and thioether linkages l (δ = 3.04–2.74 ppm (m, 2H)). b Calculated by SEC relative to polystyrene standards in THF eluent; ĐM = Mw/Mn. | |||||
1 | 95:5:0 | 14000 [1.78] | 188 | 216 | 114 |
2 | 89:9:2 | 15400 [2.13] | 167 | 190 | 110 |
3 | 87:10:3 | 9100 [1.78] | 191 | 216 | 108 |
4 | 69:17:14 | 14400 [1.27] | 208 | 257 | 137 |
5 | 61:5:34 | 14000 [1.19] | 172 | 186 | 117 |
6 | 57:12:31 | 8400 [1.67] | 178 | 209 | 120 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, NMR spectra of polymers and degradation products. SEC, TGA-MS, WAXS and DSC traces. Mn plots and mechanistic considerations. See DOI: 10.1039/d1py00753j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |