Xinliang
Li
a,
Mian
Li
*b,
Zhaodong
Huang
a,
Guojin
Liang
a,
Ze
Chen
a,
Qi
Yang
a,
Qing
Huang
b and
Chunyi
Zhi
*acd
aDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, 83 Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong 999077, China. E-mail: cy.zhi@cityu.edu.hk
bEngineering Laboratory of Advanced Energy Materials, Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology & Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo, Zhejiang 315201, China. E-mail: limian@nimte.ac.cn
cCentre for Functional Photonics, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon, Hong Kong 999077, China
dCenter for Advanced Nuclear Safety and Sustainable Development, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon, Hong Kong 999077, China
First published on 8th December 2020
Rechargeable iodine conversion batteries possess promising prospects for portable energy storage with complete electron transfer and rich valence supply. However, the reaction is limited to the single I−/I0 redox at a potential of only 0.54 V vs. the standard hydrogen electrode (SHE), leading to a low voltage plateau at 1.30 V when Zn is employed as the anode. Herein, we show how to activate the desired reversible I0/I+ redox behavior at a potential of 0.99 V vs. SHE by electrolyte tailoring via F− and Cl− ion-containing salts. The electronegative F− and Cl− ions can stabilize the I+ during charging. In an aqueous Zn ion battery based on an optimized ZnCl2 + KCl electrolyte with abundant Cl−, the I-terminated halogenated Ti3C2I2 MXene cathode delivered two well-defined discharge plateaus at 1.65 V and 1.30 V, superior to all reported aqueous I2–metal (Zn, Fe, Cu) counterparts. Together with the 108% capacity enhancement, the high voltage output resulted in a significant 231% energy density enhancement. Metallic Ti3C2I2 benefits the redox kinetics and confines the interior I species, leading to exceptional cyclic durability and rate capability. In situ Raman and ex situ multiple spectral characterizations clarify the efficient activation and stabilization effects of Cl− (F−) ions on reversible I0/I+ redox. Our work is believed to provide new insight into designing advanced I2–metal batteries based on the newly discovered I−/I0/I+ chemistry to achieve both high voltage and enhanced capacity.
Broader contextAqueous conversion-type I2–Zn battery has been intensely studied and is regarded as a promising inherent safe energy storage device. To date, the electrochemical activity of reported I2–Zn batteries stops at the reversible I−/I0 conversion, corresponding to two electron transfer or lower. Limited by the unstable nature of positive I+ ions in the electrolytes, reversible multivalent transitions for I species, with high capacity and output voltage, is constrained. Thus, the reported aqueous Zn–I2 batteries can only achieve a low output voltage plateau at ∼1.30 V. In this work, we proposed an efficient inter-halogen strategy for non-negative halogen fixation to fully activate and stabilize the unrealized high I0/I+ redox at 0.99 V vs. SHE via a facile electrolyte tailoring method. With the support of F− or Cl− additives, the resultant multivalent conversion of I−/I0/I+ led to a significantly improved electrochemical performance, including capacity, output voltage and energy density. This discovery is an exemplary effort to bring new insight to the aqueous I2–Zn batteries, and the developed brand-new I0/I+ chemistry can be extended to design other advanced I2–metal batteries such as Li, Mg and Al. |
On the other hand, the redox chemistry of positive I0/I+ located at a potential of 0.99 V vs. SHE was more attractive than the I−/I0 couple.15,16 For example, once the I0/I+ redox reaction can be activated in the aqueous Zn battery, the expected output plateau will exceed the vast majority of reported cathodes of Zn batteries, and an enhanced capacity can also be expected.17,18 In general, the electrochemical performance of a battery depends on the indispensable conductive carrier, whose electron conduction efficiency and affinity to the active substance directly determine the reaction kinetics and cycle durability. However, these factors are not applicable to redox systems.2,19 Unlike the I− ions, positive I+ ions are difficult to stabilize in conventional electrolytes. Previous attempts focusing on positive valence redox of iodine have never been successful due to poor reversibility and toleration.13–15 In principle, the identified effective mutual containment between inter-halogen offers a new viable strategy for non-negative halogen fixation, which is expected to stabilize positive I+ and hence, activate the I0/I+ redox chemistry. Unfortunately, this area has not been explored yet.13,19
Herein, we demonstrated multivalent redox chemistry of iodine (I−/I0/I+) in an aqueous Zn ion battery by F− or Cl−-rich electrolytes, employing I terminated halogenated Ti3C2I2 MXene cathode and Zn foil anode. The resultant Ti3C2I2//Zn battery with an optimized electrolyte of 2 M ZnCl2 + 1 M KCl was equipped with a two-step reaction: in addition to the conventional I−1/I0 conversion at 1.30 V, an unprecedented I0/I+ redox reaction occurred at 1.65 V, resulting in a significantly improved electrochemical performance. As expected, the emerging high voltage plateau strengthened the capacity and energy density to 205% and 330%, respectively. Also, benefiting from the efficient electron conduction and the confinement effect of the Ti3C2I2 MXene interlayer, the reaction kinetics was remarkably enhanced, and the shuttle effect was effectively suppressed. Accordingly, a decent cyclic lifespan of over 2800 with 80% capacity retention and excellent rate capability with 207 mA h g−1 Ti3C2I2 at 0.5 A g−1 and 126 mA h g−1 Ti3C2I2 at 5 A g−1 was achieved. In situ Raman characterization revealed that the strong interaction of free Cl− ions in the electrolyte with I+ ions at high voltage was the decisive factor to activate and stabilize the reversible redox reaction of the I0/I+ couple.
Ti3AlC2 + 5CuI → Ti3C2I2 + 5Cu + AlI3↑ |
The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image shows the as-produced MXene particles exhibiting the representative accordion-like morphology with a lateral size of around 6 μm (Fig. 1a).20 Also, the laminated feature of Ti3C2I2 sublayers was revealed by the section-view of the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image (Fig. 1b). The energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) analysis indicates the internal elemental composition that contains Ti, C and I elements with an atomic ratio of approximately 3:2:2 (Fig. S2, ESI†), which was different from typical Ti3C2 MXene with electrochemically inert –O/OH/F/Cl surficial groups produced using conventional wet chemical etching methods (Fig. 1c).21–23 The departure of Al-layers and formation of I terminations led to the uniform interlayer galleries of about 1.25 nm, as evidenced by the high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) image in Fig. 1d. Further quantitative analysis confirms that the atomic ratio of Ti and I elemental compositions were about 3:2, with negligible Al and O contents. Hence, the obtained MXene was conventionally referred to as Ti3C2I2.24–26 The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns in Fig. 1e reveal that the emerging diffraction peak at 7.15° was indexed to the (002) crystal plane of Ti3C2I2 MXene after etching, indicating an expanded interlayer spacing of about 12.5 Å (8.9 Å of Ti3AlC2), matching the HRTEM result well. The other peaks at 14.5°, 21.4°, and 28.8° were indexed to (004), (006), and (008) planes.22,27–29 The smaller strength ratio between (002) and (004) planes can be attributed to the capability difference in scattering X-ray caused by I terminations compared to traditional Ti3C2TX MXene. Besides, the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectrum in Fig. 1f shows the distinct I3d signal at 620–630 eV and the absence of the Al2p signal, in addition to the peaks of Ti2p and C1s.
To perform the electrochemical analysis, we assembled the Ti3C2I2 cathode (Fig. S3, ESI†), Zn metal anode, and aqueous electrolytes containing 2 M ZnSO4 electrolyte with/without various F− or Cl− ion additives. KF, NaF, NH4F, or KCl, NaCl, NH4Cl salts were used to provide the F− or Cl− ions in the designed electrolytes. The Ti3C2I2 MXene cathode terminated with I was endowed with natural electrochemical activity, which was different from the conventional pseudocapacitive Ti3C2TX (–O/OH/F/Cl).30–33Fig. 1g depicts a comparison of cyclic voltammogram (CV) profiles at 10 mV s−1 of the full batteries tested in the three aqueous electrolytes with different F−containing additives. Clearly, for all curves, two obvious redox peak pairs located at around 1.32/1.23 V and 1.84/1.66 V vs. Zn2+/Zn were recognized within 0.8–1.9 V. It should be noted that only the redox peak pairs at 1.32/1.23 V were detected in the pure ZnSO4 electrolyte under the same conditions. In addition to the I−/I0 redox (theoretical value: 1.30 V), another I0/I+ conversion peak was activated with the support of F− ions (further evidence will be provided later). It should be noted that different cations will not affect the function of F− ions. A side effect was that the reversibility of the I0/I+ conversion was inferior to that of the I−/I0 redox, manifested by a lower peak current response in the anodic scanning. Furthermore, for all Cl− counterparts, similar electrochemical features with two pairs of redox peaks during cycling were identified (1.42/1.32 V and 1.74/1.66 V), as evidenced in Fig. 1h. Remarkably, the reversibility of the high-potential I0/I+ reaction was significantly enhanced in comparison to that of the F− ion containing electrolytes.34,35 Upon cathodic scanning, the peak potential referred to the conversion from I0 to I+ was blue-shifted in the three electrolytes, indicating the enhanced reaction kinetics. Then, in the subsequent anodic scanning, the matching reduction peak was seen with a higher current response and a narrow half-width, representing the excellent redox efficiency of the I0/I+ couple.2 Moreover, the introduction of K+ cations at this time has been recognized to raise the redox potential of the I−/I0 transition, that is, lower the conversion energy barrier, superior to Na+ and NH4+ ions. Besides, as evidenced by the galvanostatic charge–discharge (GCD) curves of Ti3C2I2//ZnSO4 + KF//Zn and Ti3C2I2//ZnSO4 + KCl//Zn batteries, two discharge plateaus located around 1.62 and 1.30 V were detected, which performed better in the ZnSO4 + KCl electrolyte (Fig. S4, ESI†). The above results demonstrate that both free electronegative F− and Cl− anions are capable of strongly activating and stabilizing the desired I0/I+ redox reaction, with the Cl− ions being much more effective.
Moreover, to better reveal the internal redox kinetics evolution, CV curves scanned at different current rates were collected. As shown in Fig. 2c, in the high sweep range of 4–40 mV s−1, the two pairs of identified redox peaks always remain stable, while the current response of the I0/I+ couple increases more significantly than that of I−/I0 as the rate accelerates. Such efficient kinetics has never been achieved in carbon-support I2 batteries, which undoubtedly benefits from the superior electron conduction of metallic Ti3C2.8,36,37 Moreover, the b values were then calculated to elucidate the charge storage process of the cathode according to the law as follows:8
i = avb |
i(V) = k1v + k2v1/2 |
A comprehensive electrochemical evaluation including rate capability and cycling stability of the Ti3C2I2//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn full cell vs. Zn anode was further conducted. Meanwhile, the stable and reversible Zn anode chemistry in the ZnCl2 + KCl electrolyte was clarified by testing the symmetric Zn//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn and asymmetric Cu//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn batteries (Fig. S7–S9, ESI†).39,40Fig. 3a shows the rate performance, in which a capacity of up to 207 mA h g−1 Ti3C2I2 was delivered at 0.5 A g−1 with two well-defined plateaus of 1.65 and 1.30 V.28 When compared with the widely reported aqueous I2–Zn batteries with only redox of the I−/I0 couple, the value was unprecedented even though the heavy Ti3C2 MXene was employed.2 Over 61% of the capacity could be retained when the current density was sharply increased by 10 times to 5 A g−1. Once the current density dropped to 0.5 A g−1, the capacity could be recovered immediately, suggesting an excellent rate capability. On the contrary, with the ZnSO4 electrolyte, the capacity was below 105 mA h g−1 Ti3C2I2 (Fig. S10, ESI†). As shown in the corresponding GCD curves in Fig. 3b, two well-defined discharge voltage plateaus were always detected for all rates, and a small voltage hysteresis (0.08–0.11 V) was believed to benefit from the highly conductive MXene skeleton.37
Fig. 3 (a) Rate capability of Ti3C2I2//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn battery cycled at various rates of 0.5–5.0 A g−1. (b) The corresponding GCD curves of 0.5, 2.0, and 4.0 A g−1. (c) The long-term cyclability of Ti3C2I2//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn battery at 3.0 A g−1. (d) Comparison of discharge voltage plateaus of this work to reported aqueous I2–metal (Cu, Fe, Zn) systems.2,3,10–12,16,42,43 (e) Comparison of the energy density of this work to reported aqueous I2–metal, Br//Zn, MXene-based systems.3,7,10,11,43–48 |
The long-term cyclic capability of the battery was further investigated by GCD mode at 3 A g−1, as depicted in Fig. 3c. The Ti3C2I2//ZnCl2 + KCl//Zn battery delivered excellent cyclic durability of over 2800 cycles with a decent CE of over 98%. The capacity retention of about 80% was finally achieved. In addition to stable anode chemistry, the effective binding of the Ti3C2I2 cathode to active iodine species (I−/I0/I+) was reasonably indispensable.36 Owing to the confinement effect, which originated from the nano-sized interlayer galleries, the shuttle effect was impressively suppressed, resulting in the reversible redox of the interior I− ions without undesirable leakage.41 The emerging high plateau contributed to capacity enhancement and improved energy density. The resultant energy density calculated based on the Ti3C2I2 mass reached 280 W h kg−1 Ti3C2I2 (467 W h kg−1 I2 based on only I mass). Quantitative analysis showed that the extended plateau region (above 1.4 V) occupied 52% of the capacity and 69.8% of the energy density (Fig. S11, ESI†). With Cl− ions in the electrolyte, I0/I+ redox chemistry at 1.65 V was fully activated besides I−/I0 conversion at 1.30 V, which was much higher than that achieved in other aqueous I2–metal batteries reported, including I2–Zn, Fe, and Cu systems, as summarized in Fig. 3d.2,3,10–12,16,42,43 Accordingly, the resultant energy density of this work was significantly superior to the reported aqueous I2–Zn, Fe, Al, Cu, Br2//Zn and Ti3C2TX MXene based counterparts, as depicted in Fig. 3e.3,7,10,11,43–48
Also, in terms of the conversion reaction within 1.4 V, UV-vis spectra confirm a single and direct redox of the I−/I0 couple with no intermediate present, such as the polyiodides (I3−, 290 cm−1) (Fig. S15, ESI†).2,51 Besides, SEM images of Ti3C2I2 cathode after 1000 cycles at different charged states (0.8 V, 1.3 V and 1.85 V) showed microstructure evolution (Fig. 4d–f). All observed Ti3C2I2 MXene particles were still intact, and the representative layered morphology remained distinct. No visible collapse trace could be noted benefiting from the rigid ceramic nature of Ti3C2I2 MXene.28 As expected, both signals of Cl and I were simultaneously detected in Ti3C2I2 particles with a consistent distribution pattern in the EDX mapping data (Fig. 4g).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ee03086d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |