Open Access Article
Neha
Thakur
*a,
Roland
Bliem
a,
Iacopo
Mochi
b,
Michaela
Vockenhuber
b,
Yasin
Ekinci
b and
Sonia
Castellanos
*a
aAdvanced Research Center for Nanolithography, Science Park 106, Amsterdam 1098XG, The Netherlands. E-mail: n.thakur@arcnl.nl; s.castellanos@arcnl.nl
bPaul Scherrer Institute, Forschungstrasse 111, Villigen 5232, Switzerland
First published on 6th October 2020
Extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) is the current technology used in the semiconductor industry for the fabrication of integrated circuits (ICs), since it enables the further miniaturization of their components. For its optimal operation, photoresist materials that can efficiently use EUV photons (92 eV) to yield sub-10 nm patterns are required. However, there is a lack of understanding of the complex mechanisms induced by EUV radiation. In this work, we investigate the ability of a new Zn-based oxocluster to fulfil the state-of-the-art requirements for EUVL. This molecular material was conceived to provide high EUV absorptivity, owing to its contents of Zn, F, and O atoms, and high resolution, given its small molecular size. High sensitivity/reactivity towards EUV is achieved through its mixed-ligand organic shell composed of methacrylate and trifluoroacetate ligands. This new resist shows outstanding lithography performance yielding down to 22 nm half pitch line/space patterns at ∼20 mJ cm−2. Spectroscopy studies on EUV exposed samples revealed an unexpected reaction pathway where fluoride ions are formed. This is an unprecedented way of efficiently inducing a solubility switch in an inorganic resist upon EUV irradiation.
EUV photons exceed the ionization energy of any resist material so that EUV irradiation leads to complex mechanisms that involve the generation of photoelectrons and secondary electrons, together with the associated holes (electron vacancies).7–9 The understanding of this complex EUV-induced chemistry is currently rather limited.10,11 Yet, without the proper EUV-chemistry knowledge, it is a challenge to custom-design materials for EUVL that can meet the industrial targets of sensitivity (<20 mJ cm−2), low line width/line edge roughness (LWR/LER < 20%), and resolution (<20 nm).4,11–13
A prerequisite for EUV resist materials is high absorbance at 13.5 nm.14,15 A straightforward approach to attain this is to incorporate elements into the resist layer that have high EUV absorption cross-section, typically metals. Such materials are commonly called inorganic resists and have emerged as promising candidates for EUVL applications.15–17 In addition to the enhancement of EUV photon absorption, inorganic resists are also known to overcome the low tolerance of traditional organic polymers towards the etching conditions.18 In most cases, inorganic resists comprise a core of one or more metal cations surrounded by organic ligands.8,15,16 Exposure to the EUV photons (and the electron cascade that derive from them) induce chemical reactions on the organic ligands that result in the change of solubility properties of the resist material in the exposed areas, which ultimately leads to the pattern formation on resist layers.19–25
Metal-oxoclusters (MOCs) stand out among EUV inorganic resists since they are molecularly defined (small and homogeneous in size) and therefore, are anticipated to prevent variations in the nanopatterns, i.e. low LWR/LER values in the printed features.26–29 In addition, MOCs provide great synthetic flexibility, since virtually any desired organic terminal functionality can be incorporated in their organic shell, allowing for an easy way of tuning the processability and chemical reactivity of the material.25,30,31
In the present work, we investigate the lithographic capabilities of a Zn-based MOC and study the EUV-induced chemistry that enables nanopatterning on this material. This MOC consists of a tetranuclear Zn-compound that belongs to the group of basic zinc carboxylates32–34 and is found in the nodes of a prototypical metal–organic framework, MOF-5.35–37 Previously, dinuclear Zn-complexes proved to work as EUV resists.26 Here, we aimed at enhancing the EUV absorbance thanks to the more condensed Zn-based oxo core and to the integration of fluorine atoms38 as part of trifluoroacetate ligands (TFA) in the organic shell. Moreover, we incorporated methacrylate ligands (MA), which can undergo cross-linking upon EUV irradiation.24,30
This reaction is in fact common in MA-based clusters when irradiated with lower energy (UV) light sources,39–42 and we anticipated that it would contribute to the solubility switch in this new Zn-based material. These considerations gave rise to a Zn-oxocluster shown in Fig. 1a and labelled as Zn(MA)(TFA). This molecular material is a mixture of clusters with an average composition of Zn4O(MA)5(TFA). This compound has previously shown to have a high linear absorption coefficient at 13.5 nm (12.4 μm−1) and high sensitivity.43 Here, we used EUV interference lithography (EUV-IL)44,45 to achieve dense line/space (L/S) patterns of half-pitch (HP) down to 22 nm at low doses (∼20 mJ cm−2) on this material, a response that is close to commercial EUV resists.12,13,17 The lithography experiments were also combined with several ex situ spectroscopic techniques, which allowed to elucidate a novel mechanism behind the nanopattern formation involving C–F bond cleavage in the TFA ligands and cross-linking of the double bond of MA ligands initiated by different radical species (Scheme 1).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Photolithography process and sample fabrication for ex situ spectroscopic analysis performed on Zn(MA)(TFA). | ||
:
1 v/v followed by sonication (4 min) and filtration using a 0.22 μm PTFE filter. Spin-coating of the resist solution was done at 2100 rpm spinning speed (acceleration 3000 rpm s−1) for 30 s. Post application baking was applied for 30 s at 90 °C to remove the excess of the residual solvent. Samples for UV-vis absorption spectroscopy were spin-coated on quartz substrates (500 μm thick) and for FTIR spectroscopy on double-side polished Si substrates (200 μm thick). Samples for X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis were spin coated on Cr/Au (3 nm/19 nm) sputter-coated on Si substrate. The thickness of the thin films spin coated for spectroscopic analysis was in the range of 25–30 nm and was measured by using AFM.
:
3 for HP 50 nm, 30 nm, and 22 nm, and ∼1
:
2 for HP 40 nm. The unbiased LWRs (shown in Fig. 2) of dense L/S features were calculated for the doses of HPs nearest to the printed dose-to-size values (as shown above in Fig. 1b). As a result of line wiggles seen in SEM image of HP 22 nm the results of unbiased LWR are relatively higher. However, the LWR values of the other HP fulfil the industry requirement (LWR < 20% of CD).12 It should be noticed that a good control in the Zn(MA)(TFA) composition is crucial for reproducibility in the sensitivity of this resist.43Table 1 below summarises the performance of some inorganic and hybrid inorganic–organic EUV photoresist when exposed using the EUVL-IL tool at PSI.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 LWR (unbiased) results obtained from PSD of respective SEM (operated at 2 kV) images of line/space features. | ||
| Resist | CD [HP] (nm) | Dose (mJ cm−2) | LWR/LER (nm) | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Inpria YA-BA | 14.9 [16] | 48 | 1.8 | 50 |
| 10 [11] | — | 1.7 | ||
| [(PhSn)12O14(OH)6]Cl2 | [18] | 350 | — | 51 |
| [(BuSn)12O14(OH)6](OH)2 | [50] | 131 | — | 52 |
| [(BuSn)12O14(OH)6](AcO)2 | [40] | 74 | — | 52 |
| HSQ | [22] | 40–90 | ∼2–3 | 53 |
| Zr6O4(OH)4Mc12 | [50] | 57 | — | 30 |
| Zn2(CO2R)4 Zn-mTA | [16] | 45 | — | 26 |
| [13] | 35 | — | ||
| Zn(MA)(TFA) | 30 | 22 | 2.8–2.6 | |
| 22 | 20 | 5.7–7.2 |
The promising outstanding performance of this new material prompted us to investigate the underlying mechanism in the pattern formation. In particular, we wanted to gain insight in the role of each type of ligand in the solubility switch that it undergoes after EUV irradiation. For that purpose, the chemical changes after EUV exposure were investigated with different ex situ spectroscopic techniques. FTIR and UV-vis absorption spectroscopy were employed to identify modifications in the organic ligands, whereas XPS allowed to detect changes in both inorganic and organic components, as it gives information on elemental ratio and on the chemical environment of all elements.
Thin films were exposed to four doses of EUV light from a dose above the threshold necessary to render a fully insoluble thin film (>20 mJ cm−2)43 up to a high dose where a full conversion of the pristine materials is expected, thus allowing the identification of the spectral features from the EUV irradiation product in Zn(MA)(TFA) resist.
A thin film of Zn(MA)(TFA) on Si was exposed to increasing EUV doses on different areas (Fig. 3b) of the same sample and the FTIR of each area was collected (Fig. 3a). The peaks were assigned according to the literature of Zn-based tetranuclear clusters.36,43,54 A decrease in the area of the peaks (Fig. 3c) assigned to the carboxylate groups of both ligands, TFA (νas 1676 cm−1) and MA (νas 1544 cm−1), was detected with increasing dose. The same trend was observed for the peaks assigned to C–F stretching (1205 and 1155 cm−1). However, a relative increase of the peaks in the aliphatic C–H stretching region (2929–2885 cm−1) was observed. This indicates that EUV photons promote the decarboxylation of both TFA and MA. In addition, the simultaneous decrease of the νas(COO) and ν(C–F) peaks suggests that TFA ligands are partially lost, either as complete units or as a result of the ligand fragmentation arising from a decarboxylation process. However, in the case of the MA ligands, the preservation and increase of aliphatic C–H stretching peaks is in line with cross-linking reactions between terminal double bonds.
To further investigate the reactivity of the MA ligands upon EUV exposure we monitored the changes in the UV-vis absorption spectrum of the material after irradiation with different doses of EUV light (Fig. 4). The unexposed material displays an absorption band at 198 nm, which arises from electronic п→п* transition localized in the MA ligands of Zn(MA)(TFA) (Fig. 4a). The bleaching of this band as the EUV dose increases clearly indicates the loss of double bonds with EUV exposure (Fig. 4b). Taking into account that the FTIR experiments confirmed the presence and slight increase of C–H bonds in aliphatic carbons, this result is in line with the promotion of cross-linking reactions between terminal double bonds, which yields saturated carbon chains.24,30
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 (a) UV-vis absorption spectra of the resist film and (b) change in the UV-vis absorbance maximum relative to the reference as a function of EUV dose. | ||
As vibrational modes and electronic transitions arising from the inorganic core fall out of the spectroscopic windows in both FTIR and UV-vis experiments, XPS was used to investigate other processes that might occur in the Zn(MA)(TFA) molecule after EUV irradiation. We focused on the detection and tracking of different C, O, F, and Zn-species as the EUV exposure dose increased. To do so, we fitted the C 1s, O 1s, F 1s, and Zn 2p3/2 high resolution spectra for the unexposed material and tracked the species of interest as a function of dose (Fig. 5a and Fig. S5 in ESI†).
Although the C 1s spectra could be fitted with 4 components, here we will only consider the components with higher oxidation states, assigned to C atoms in the O–C
O groups (289.1 eV) and C atoms bonded to F, C–F (292.8 eV). O 1s spectra were fitted using 2 components, which we attribute to O atoms participating in Zn–O bonds (oxo and hydroxo groups, 532.1 eV) and O atoms in O–C
O groups (530.4 eV). A peak assigned to F atoms in the TFA ligands was found in the F 1s accompanied by a small peak with smaller chemical shift (see explanations below). The Zn 2p3/2 peak was fitted using only one component indicating no major chemical differences between the Zn atoms in the inorganic core (see ESI†).
The evolution of the C 1s and O 1s high resolution spectra signified the loss of O–C
O species upon EUV exposure (Fig. S5, ESI†), in line with the FTIR results. Yet the most prominent changes were observed in the high-resolution spectra of the F 1s (Fig. 5a). In the latter, it was noticed that the peak at 684.5 eV increases as a function of EUV dose. This peak is assigned to fluoride ions, likely bonded to Zn metal (Zn–F) in the thin film after EUV exposure.55–57 The formation of such metal–fluoride bond has been observed in metal complexes after exposure to focused electron beam and was explained by C–F bond cleavage and appearance of F− species.58 The presence of this peak in low intensity in the unexposed sample is attributed to the chemical changes induced by X-ray photons used for the XPS measurement, as a rise of this peak was observed as a result of prolonged irradiation with X-ray after consecutive measurements on the same spot (Fig. S5, ESI†).
Since our X-ray photoelectron spectrometer does not have spatial resolution, for this experiment each dose required the preparation and exposure of a different sample. Therefore, to track the effect of EUV, we calculated the ratio of each species relative to Zn for each sample and the ratio found at each dose was compared to the initial ratio of each species in the unexposed sample. The ratios relative to Zn 2p3/2 of selected components in C 1s (O–C
O), O 1s (O–C
O and Zn–O) and F 1s (C–F and Zn–F) spectra were plotted as a function of dose (Fig. 5b). Loss of carboxylate (O–C
O, C 1s and O 1s) was detected, yet the contribution of TFA and MA to it cannot be distinguished with this technique, as both carboxylate peaks have the same chemical shift. An increase in Zn–O component as a function of dose was also observed, which can be attributed to the formation of ZnOx species after the EUV exposure. That is, after decarboxylation/ligand loss during exposure, the Zn atoms left in the film can react with water and oxygen in the atmosphere after the samples are taken out of the exposure chamber in the air. As the Zn–F species increase with EUV dose, a decrease in the C–F components is observed, simultaneously. The total concentration of fluorine (grey asterisks in Fig. 5b), decreased by 10% at high EUV doses. Overall, the changes detected in XPS in the fractional ratio with EUV exposure are fairly comparable to the results obtained from FTIR regarding decarboxylation and C–F bond loss.
From the combination of all spectroscopic results, we propose the reactions in Scheme 2 as important contributions to the solubility switch in the Zn(MA)(TFA) resist upon EUV exposure. Ionization of the oxoclusters after absorption of EUV radiation results in the emission of a photoelectron and formation of a radical cation that can further yield the decarboxylation of any of the two types of ligands (reaction (i) in Scheme 2). This process can also be initiated by an electron with kinetic energy higher than the ionization potential of the molecule.59–61 The resulting fragments would be an allyl or a trifluoromethyl radical and an outgassing neutral CO2 molecule. These sites are likely to react with water or oxygen when the film is exposed to ambient atmosphere after EUV exposure and can further lead to aggregation with neighbouring clusters.62–64 Meanwhile, the radicals formed in path (i) can initiate cross-linking reactions of the terminal double bonds in the MA ligands (process (iii) in Scheme 2).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Proposed reaction paths that contribute to the solubility switch in Zn(MA)(TFA) EUV resist. | ||
In addition to dissociative ionization processes, electrons with lower energy than the ionization potential can react with Zn(MA)(TFA) oxocluster and induce the C–F cleavage. This process, known as dissociative electron attachment (DEA), has been reported for halogen-containing molecules and in particular for trifluoroacetic acid.65–69 The resultant fragments would be F− and a difluoroacetyl radical (process (ii) in Scheme 2). Although a detailed structure of the final product cannot be inferred, XPS studies have clearly shown the presence of new F− species in the thin film after EUV exposure. We assume that they are stabilized by the Zn2+ metal cations, as explained above. In turn, the difluoroacetyl radical is expected to react with the neighboring ligands, such as methacrylate ones. Reoxidation of Zn-sites after ligand loss could occur after the exposed sample is exposed to air, as indicated by the XPS studies.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0tc03597a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |