Yunfeng
Zhao
a,
Xiaorong
Ma
a,
Pengli
Li
a,
Yang
Lv
a,
Jianfeng
Huang
b,
Haixia
Zhang
a,
Yongli
Shen
a,
Qibo
Deng
a,
Xizheng
Liu
*a,
Yi
Ding
a and
Yu
Han
*c
aTianjin Key Laboratory of Advanced Functional Porous Materials, Institute for New Energy Materials & Low-Carbon Technologies, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China. E-mail: xzliu@tjut.edu.cn
bMulti-scale Porous Materials Center, Institute of Advanced Interdisciplinary Studies, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Chongqing University, Chongqing 400044, P. R. China
cAdvanced Membranes and Porous Materials Center, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, Thuwal 23955-6900, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. E-mail: yu.han@kaust.edu.sa
First published on 29th January 2020
Polymeric membranes with high ionic conductivity and solvent molecule blocking capability are attracting considerable attention as separators for new-generation batteries adopting hybrid electrolytes. The performances of the membranes are closely dependent on their microstructures and functional groups. Here, we report the design and fabrication of a carboxyl-functionalized polymer-of-intrinsic-microporosity (PIM) membrane, which has optimal surface properties and microporous channels (∼0.8 nm) to permit cation (Li+ or Na+) transportation, while preventing solvent molecule penetration. Using a droplet-templating strategy, we create large pores on both surfaces of the PIM-membrane to improve its interfacial contact with electrolytes. The obtained membrane integrates good mechanical strength with high thermal and electrochemical stability, demonstrating a great potential for battery applications as a flexible separator. When intercalated with Li+, the membrane (PIM-1-COOLi) exhibits a remarkable Li+ conductivity in both aqueous (6.5 × 10−3 S cm−1) and organic (7.3 × 10−4 S cm−1) solutions, as well as a good solvent permeation resistance (19 μmol cm−2 min−1 at 10 Pa for H2O). Taking these advantages of the PIM-membrane, we are able to fabricate challenging batteries with hybrid electrolytes, such as Li–H2O2 and Na–H2O2 batteries (Li/Na anode with organic electrolyte and H2O2 cathode with aqueous electrolyte), into a flexible laminated form. The as-fabricated battery shows an excellent discharge performance, comparable to a model battery constructed with the commercial ceramic Li super-ionic conductor, but is more tolerant to mechanical treatment and harsh environment. Our study demonstrates that PIM represents a promising platform for developing flexible secondary batteries with hybrid electrolytes, which are particularly desirable for wearable and portable electronic devices.
In comparison with ceramic membranes, polymeric membranes have advantages including lower production cost, higher stability, and better processability. Most importantly, polymeric membranes are flexible, which is crucially important for foldable and wearable devices. Unfortunately, despite the high ionic conductivities, commonly used polymeric ion-conductive membranes, e.g., Nafion, are unable to block solvent molecules,17 and thus unsuitable for new-concept batteries with hybrid electrolytes. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop a new type of polymeric membrane that combines a high ionic conductivity with an ability to block the shuttling of water and other solvent molecules, while preserving the intrinsic excellent properties of polymers (flexibility, stability, and processability).
Polymers of intrinsic microporosity (PIMs) are a class of polymer that is constructed from stiff monomers (e.g. spiro- or binaphthyl compounds) and featured by rigid, contorted skeleton, large free volume, and uniform ultra-micropores.18,19 Due to these unique properties, PIMs have primarily been used to fabricate highly permeable and selective membranes for gas separation.20,21 Several recent studies reported the use of PIM-based separator membranes for rechargeable batteries: a pristine PIM-1 membrane was used to block shuttling of polysulfur ions in Li–S battery;22 Tröger's base23 and N-spirocyclic quaternary ammonium24 polymer membranes showed the ability to conduct hydroxide (OH−) or proton (H+); an amidoxime-functionalized PIM membrane was used to construct solvent crossover-free Zn-based redox flow batteries.25 It is worth noting that these works mainly focused on the ionic conductivity of the membranes, whereas how to incorporate the “solvent molecule blocking” ability in a polymeric membrane has not been explored and remains a challenge, which requires rational design at the molecule level to achieve precise control of microstructure and functionality of the membrane.
Herein, we report the first polymeric membrane that fulfils the dual function of “cation conduction” and “solvent molecule blocking” for batteries adopting the hybrid electrolytes configuration. This polymer is prepared by modifying a well-established PIM polymer (PIM-1) with carboxyl groups. The modification not only introduces cation conductivity into PIM-1, but also reduces the effective pore size down to an optimal value (∼0.8 nm) to exclude solvent molecules passing through. The membrane fabricated from carboxyl-modified PIM-1 exhibits excellent solvent molecule blocking capability, high ionic conductivity, and good stability. We develop a droplet-templating method to produce large pores on both sides of the membrane, which increase the contact area of the membrane with electrolytes to facilitate ion transportation. As a proof-of-concept, we use this membrane to construct Li/Na–H2O2 batteries, in which reactive alkali metals (Li or Na) serve as anodes in an organic electrolyte and the strong oxidizer (H2O2) in an aqueous electrolyte acts as the active material on the cathode. Any permeation of H2O or H2O2 from the cathode side to anode side would lead to the Li metal corrosion and battery failure. The ability to block solvent molecules and high ionic conductivity of the PIM-1 membranes guarantee the operation of flexible batteries with organic/aqueous hybrid electrolytes.
J = ΔG/A × t, |
Our designed membrane was fabricated in a similar way as the pristine PIM-1 membrane, except two extra steps: (1) LiTFSI was used as an additive to mix with PIM-1 polymer in the CHCl3 solution before membrane casting; (2) the formed membrane was immersed in a 10 wt% NaOH solution to undergo a hydrolysis process. The aim of the first step is to generate macropores on the surfaces of the membrane by a droplet-templating strategy, in order to enhance its interfacial contact with the electrolytes and thus promote ion transportation (Fig. 1b–d). The polymer to Li salt ratio was optimized according to the mechanical strength, and an optimal ratio of 1:1 (PIM:LiTFSI) in weight was determined (Fig. S2†). Note that our droplet-templating strategy is based on the reported “breath figure” mechanism,31 where water droplets (in this work, the water droplets are produced by Li salts through adsorbing the vapour from the air) serve as templates for creating pores on the surface of an evaporating polymer solution. The aim of the second step is to convert a portion of the cyano (–CN) groups in PIM-1 into carboxyl (–COOH) groups (Fig. 1a), which can be visualized by the gradually darkened colour of the membrane during the hydrolysis process (Fig. S3†). The hydrolysis conditions have been optimized to achieve a combination of high ionic conductivity with good mechanical strength. The hydrolysis of –CN into –COOH was optimized to yield an ideal membrane with excellent ionic conductivity and mechanical strength, and the weakening of stretching vibration of the –CN group (at ∼2235 cm−1) in Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR, Fig. S4†) was employed as an indicator. As evidenced by the FTIR, the hydrolysis was trivial at room temperature (25 °C). Despite that higher temperatures could accelerate the hydrolysis (Fig. S4†), the membrane hydrolysed at 80 °C or above cracks easily. The optimized membrane was achieved by the hydrolysis in 10% NaOH solution (H2O/ethanol = 3:7) at 60 °C for 6 h. The corresponding hydrolysis percentage of the –CN group is approximately 50%, as determined by the elemental analysis.32 A higher degree of hydrolysis would lead to a fragile membrane.
After the hydrolysis process, we further converted the membrane to its Li-form or Na-form by an ion-exchange process (see the Experimental section) for further characterization and battery applications. The resulting membrane (denoted as PIM-1-COOLi or PIM-1-COONa) exhibited excellent flexibility, and retained good integrity even after repeated folding and unfolding (Fig. 1e–h). Unlike the pristine PIM-1 membrane that has flat surfaces, PIM-1-COOLi has both sides of the surface full of highly open macropores (∼1.7 μm in diameter) with a high density, as revealed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) (Fig. 2a and b). The cross-section of PIM-1-COOLi has a sandwich structure, consisting of two macroporous skin layers of thickness ∼10 μm and a dense internal layer with a thickness of ∼23 μm (Fig. 2c). The macropores observed at the cross-section are 10–30 μm in diameter (highlighted by red circles in Fig. 2c), which are interconnected with smaller channels, as indicated by arrows in Fig. 2c. The SEM characterization confirms the successful fabrication of the designed membrane morphology. In addition to the macroscopic membrane morphology, PIM-1-COOLi also differs from the pristine PIM-1 membrane in microporosity. As determined from the CO2 adsorption isotherms collected at 273 K, PIM-1-COOLi has a markedly smaller micropore size compared to pristine PIM-1 membrane (0.8 nm vs. 1.3 nm) (Fig. S5 & S6†). The narrowing of micropores is the consequence of the generation of carboxyl groups, and it is expected to favour the blocking of solvent molecules.
Fig. 2 (a) SEM image (b) and the corresponding statistical pore-size analysis of the surface of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane. (c) SEM image of the cross-section of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane. |
We use the Polymatic simulated polymerization algorithm33 to model the ionic transportation channel of PIM-1-COOLi, based on polymer chains containing 15 repeating units (Fig. 3a). The results show that the stereoscopic-structure Spiro centre causes a loose packing of the polymer chains, generating intrinsic microporosity (Fig. 3b). Through van der Waals surface analysis of the micropores, we found that the carboxyl groups are mainly distributed inside the pore channel, leaving sufficient space and ion-bonding sites to ensure the guest-ion conduction (Fig. 3c). To study the solvent-permeation resistance of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane, we measured the permeation rate of water under different pressures using a home-made apparatus (Fig. S7†). The results showed that water molecules could not pass through the membrane under ambient-pressure; under near-vacuum conditions (10 Pa), the permeability was measured to be 19 μmol cm−2 min−1, according to the pervaporation data (Fig. S8†), which is almost 50-fold smaller than the value measured for the Nafion 117 membrane (930 μmol cm−2 min−1).34 Due to the limited availability of the organic solvent used in our battery (i.e., EC/DEC), we did not measure its permeability on the PIM-1-COOLi membrane directly. However, it is conceivable that the membrane is much less permeable for ethylene carbonate/diethyl carbonate than for water, as we found the permeability on PIM-1-COOLi decreases as the molecular size increases (e.g., 0.38 μmol cm−2 min−1 for methanol and 0.15 μmol cm−2 min−1 for ethanol) (Fig. S8†), which confirms a size-exclusion effect.
Fig. 3 (a) Structural model of a segment of the PIM-1-COOLi chain. (b and c) channel structure (b) and van der Waals surface (ED = 0.001 a.u.) (c) of PIM-1-COOLi. |
Because metallic Li anode often forms Li dendrites during battery cycling that can propagate through separators to cause an internal short-circuit between the two electrodes, the separator membranes need mechanical strength to resist the punch of Li dendrites. The mechanical strength of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane was characterized by stretching and punching in a mechanical testing machine (Fig. S9†). To perform the tensile strength test, the membranes were cut into rectangular pieces (5.0 mm × 25.0 mm) and then were applied with a tensile force at a quasi-static speed of 1 mm min−1 at room temperature. As shown in Fig. 4a, the utmost tensile stress the PIM-1-COOLi membrane (thickness: 40 μm) could tolerate before failure was 6 MPa, under which the strain reached 7.8%. Moreover, the fracture curve shows that the stress decreased slowly with the increase of the strain, which suggests that PIM-1-COOLi has certain ductility, consistent with its good flexibility demonstrated in Fig. 1. The result of a puncture test shows that the PIM-1-COOLi membranes could withstand a high punching force of up to 0.15 N at a large elastic deformation of 1.2 mm (Fig. 4b). We also evaluated the thermal stability of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane based on a thermal degradation analysis within the temperature range of 30–800 °C in both N2 and air atmosphere. The results show that the membrane remained undecomposed at up to 320 °C, a temperature much higher than the conventional operating temperature of batteries (Fig. 4c). In addition, linear scanning cyclic voltammetry revealed an unaltered electrochemical behaviour of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane at <4.0 V, indicating its promise as a separator for rechargeable batteries (Fig. 4d).
To measure the ionic conductivity, the PIM-1-COOLi membrane was assembled into coin-type cells containing an either aqueous (i.e., 0.1 M LiOH in H2O) or organic (i.e., 0.1 M LiClO4 in EC/DEC) electrolyte in each test (Fig. S10†). Fig. 4e presents the Nyquist plots of the PIM-1-COOLi membrane at room temperature, from which the Li+ conductivity was calculated to be 6.5 × 10−3 S cm−1 in the aqueous electrolyte or 7.3 × 10−4 S cm−1 in the organic electrolyte. The PIM-1-COONa membrane was examined in the same way except that 0.1 M NaOH aqueous solution was used. The determined Na+ conductivity of the PIM-COONa membrane is 2.2 × 10−3 and 8.7 × 10−5 S cm−1 in the aqueous and organic solution, respectively (Fig. 4f). In comparison with various reported ion-conductive membranes, PIM-1-COOLi/Na membranes are among the state-of-the-art membranes in terms of ion conductivity (Table S1†).35–38 By contrast, the pristine PIM-1 does not show detectable ion conductivity, due to the absence of ionic conducting groups, and inadequately-hydrolysed PIM membranes display intermediate ion conductivities (see Fig. S11 and S12†). These results confirm a strong correlation between the carboxyl group and the ion transportation. It is interesting to note that the PIM-1-COOLi membrane exhibited good wetting with both EC/DEC solvent (contact angle: 90°) and water (contact angle: 99°) (Fig. S13†). This amphiphilicity is likely due to the coexistence of –CN and –COOH groups which are of hydrophilic and lipophilic property, respectively, as well as the designed macroporous membrane surface structure. Such amphiphilic behaviour certainly promotes the interfacial infiltration of electrolytes to reduce the charge-transfer resistance. On the basis of these excellent properties, we assembled Li/Na–H2O2 batteries using organic/aqueous hybrid electrolytes and PIM-1-COOLi/Na as separator membranes (Fig. S14†). In these batteries, the very reactive alkali metal (i.e., Li or Na) in the organic electrolyte (i.e., EC/DEC) and the strong oxidizer H2O2 in the aqueous electrolyte serves as the anode and the cathode, respectively (Fig. 5a). The battery reactions are as follows:
Cathode: H2O2 + 2e → 2OH− |
Anode: Li (Na) → Li (Na)+ + e |
Overall reaction: Li (Na) + H2O2 → Li (Na)OH |
The results of galvanostatic discharge testing showed that the Li–H2O2 battery delivered a constant output voltage of 3.2 V at a current density of 0.1 mA cm−2 during discharge, while it only slightly decreased to 3.0 V, as the current density increased to 0.3 mA cm−2 (Fig. 5b). For comparison purpose, another battery was assembled in exactly the same configuration except that a LISICON membrane was used as the separator. The comparison results indicate that in terms of the discharge voltage, PIM-1-COOLi is even slightly superior to LISICON at high current densities (i.e., 0.3 mA cm−2) (Fig. 5b). It is worth noting that although LISICON has combined properties of Li+ transport and solvent blocking, its instability in strong bases or acids and the poor mechanical flexibility hinder practical applications. When a LISICON film is bent or crushed, the resultant cracks reduce the resistance against H2O permeation and consequently incur safety problems. In contrast, the PIMs maintain robust flexibility even after extreme folding (Fig. 1h) and more stable under harsh conditions (e.g., the hydrolysis process in 10 wt% NaOH under 60 °C for 6 h). The galvanostatic discharge testing was also performed for a Na–H2O2 battery that was assembled using the PIM-1-COONa membrane, which yielded a high discharge voltage of 2.75 and 2.50 V at a current density of 0.1 and 0.3 mA cm−2, respectively (Fig. 5c).
Finally, we integrated the PIM-1-based membrane into a flexible Li–H2O2 battery with organic/aqueous hybrid electrolytes, and evaluated the battery performance in different bending states. As illustrated in Fig. 6a, the flexible battery is fabricated in a laminated manner, in which a carbon black (CB)-coated Ti foil and a metallic Li foil served as the cathode and anode, respectively. The PIM-1-COOLi membrane separated the cathodic and anodic compartment, which was filled with an aqueous H2O2 solution and an organic EC/DEC solvent, respectively. A piece of aluminium-plastic film was used as the cover on each side of the battery, and the battery was assembled on a thermocompressor. As evidenced by the consistent illumination of a commercial blue-light-emitting diode powered by the flexible battery under different bending conditions (Fig. 6b–e and ESI Video†), the battery is able to deliver a stable discharge voltage regardless of its bending degree (Fig. 6f). Also, the fabricated cathode displays robust stability during the cycling process in Li–H2O2 cell as the morphology of composite electrode are barely changed after discharging (Fig. S15†). Although the voltage (∼3 V) is slightly lower than that of the model cell due to the different battery configurations, the results here unambiguously demonstrate the good performance of this PIM-incorporated Li–H2O2 cell, and further confirm that the membrane possesses excellent ionic conductivity and solvent penetration resistance, high flexibility, and stable mechanical/electrochemical properties. These characteristics are favourable for not only flexible Li/Na–H2O2 batteries, but also other advanced batteries featuring hybrid electrolytes.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ta13210d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |