Diluted CO2 feeding was recently reported to efficiently generate CH4 at the theoretical Pt electrode potential, however, the reaction was easily deactivated. To solve this problem, we investigated the reaction/deactivation mechanism to produce CH4 from CO2 electroreduction. Using a polymer electrolyte single cell containing a Pt/C catalyst, CO2 was reduced to CH4 without overpotential by simply controlling the CO2 feed concentration. The CH4 synthesis proceeded if the Pt–CO/Pt–H ratio formed on the Pt-catalyst surface was 1 : 11 or higher. The deactivation of the CH4 generating reaction also depends on the Pt–CO/Pt–H ratio (the ratio does not satisfy 1 : 11 or higher). The optimum Pt–CO/Pt–H ratio to produce CH4 was 1 : 18. Furthermore, we achieved 86% recovery of CH4 activity by sweeping the deactivated Pt surface on the cathode up to 0.3 V where the CO2/Pt–CO redox reaction occurred simultaneously. As a result, an efficient less energy-intensive reactivation reaction that we defined as a poisoning-elimination method was established. Overall, this work demonstrated that the application of a polymer electrolyte cell together with a low concentration of CO2 is effective to minimize Pt-electrocatalyst deactivation.