Artur
Kasprzak
*a,
Agata
Kowalczyk
b,
Agata
Jagielska
c,
Barbara
Wagner
c,
Anna M.
Nowicka
b and
Hidehiro
Sakurai
d
aFaculty of Chemistry, Warsaw University of Technology, Noakowskiego Str. 3, 00-664 Warsaw, Poland. E-mail: akasprzak@ch.pw.edu.pl
bFaculty of Chemistry, University of Warsaw, Pasteura Str. 1, 02-093 Warsaw, Poland
cBiological and Chemical Research Centre, Faculty of Chemistry, University of Warsaw, Zwirki i Wigury Str. 101, PL-02-093 Warsaw, Poland
dDivision of Applied Chemistry Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka University, 2-1 Yamadaoka, Suita, Osaka 565-0871, Japan
First published on 15th June 2020
The synthesis of a sumanene derivative bearing three ferrocenyl substituents is presented. This conjugated compound is solution-processable, shows red-light emission with high fluorescence quantum yield and can be used for the construction of the first buckybowl-based sensor for the selective and effective recognition of caesium cations (Cs+) in aqueous solution.
Sumanene (1), a fullerene fragment, belongs to the class of the so-called buckybowls featuring a bowl-shaped motif (Fig. 1a).6 This molecule is a promising candidate for the design of functional organic materials. The unique properties of sumanene result from the presence of a curvature in its structure giving rise to unusual assembling properties or dynamic behaviours, e.g., bowl-to-bowl inversion. Recently, we have reported the synthesis of various sumanene-tethered ferrocenes7 and the applications of selected conjugates7b for caesium cation (Cs+) recognition in organic solvents. The driving force responsible for this recognition was the site-selective cation-π-interaction with the inclusion of sumanene's concave site.6d,8 Sumanene was found to act as a Cs+ recognition material in its neutral state. It is worth noting that the detection of Cs+ is of the highest environmental importance. Significant concentrations of Cs+ were found in nuclear plant waste and in post-disaster areas, especially in the case of the nuclear plant accident in Fukushima in 2011.9 Importantly, from the viewpoint of public health and environmental monitoring, special attention should be paid to Cs+ detection in water.
Herein, we report the synthesis of tris(ferrocenylmethidene)sumanene (3) and its photophysical and electrochemical properties. To our delight, this compound is readily soluble in many organic solvents together with very efficient red-light emission properties. What is more, electrochemical studies revealed the promising redox properties of this derivative. Encouraged by this finding, 3 was employed to construct a sensor that showed remarkably effective and selective Cs+ detection in water. This is the first example of using a buckybowl compound for the construction of a sensor and its application towards the recognition of an analyte in aqueous solution.
The synthesis of 3 was carried out starting from sumanene (1) and ferrocenecarboxaldehyde (Fc-CHO; 2) according to the reported procedure10 which gave excellent yield (88%; Fig. 1b).11 The combination of NMR spectroscopy, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) and high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) confirmed the formation of 3.12 As expected,10 the 1H NMR analysis revealed the presence of diastereomers (C3 symmetrical and unsymmetrical).
Compound 3 was found to be air-stable both in solution and in the solid state at a significant time interval.13 In addition, 3 is solution-processable, because of its excellent solubility in many commonly used organic solvents, both polar and non-polar, including dichloromethane, chloroform, hexane, benzene, toluene, tetrahydrofuran, acetonitrile and acetone. The colour of 3 in each solvent was deep purple-red (Fig. 1c). It is noteworthy that the solutions of pristine sumanene, Fc and Fc-CHO did not exhibit such optical properties. On the other hand, the colour of 3 in solution was comparable to those of fullerenes (C70 or C60). We anticipate that these features of 3 resulted from the π-conjugation. UV-Vis spectroscopy analysis revealed the absorption maxima of 3 at 345 and 530 nm (Fig. 1d). A red-shift was observed in comparison with similar sumanenes substituted with benzene derivatives.14 A Strong red-light emission (λmax = 620 nm; excitation wavelength 530 nm) was observed for 3 (Fig. 1d).15 The fluorescence quantum yield (ΦF) was estimated by a relative method to be 0.81, a very high value.16 It is worth noting that such a satisfactory ΦF value was not reported for pristine sumanene (ca. 0.03)17 or many buckybowl-based compounds (commonly lower than 0.57).18ΦF for 3 is comparable with the respective values for highly conjugated pyrenylsumanene (0.82)17b and some corannulenes bearing a push–pull architecture (0.76, 0.93 or 0.98).18g
Next, the cyclic voltammograms (CV) of 3 were recorded in two solvents with different dielectric constants: dichloromethane (DCM) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) at various scan rates (Fig. 2). In both solvents 3 exhibited one well-defined oxidation peak and two- or three reduction peaks. The presence of a linker between Fc and the benzene core resulted in more independent electrochemical properties and electron transfers. The lack of peak separation suggested a lack of electronic communication between the redox units. The Fc moieties are electrochemically equivalent, and, thus, were oxidized at the some potential. The oxidation process of the Fc units leads to the formation of a positively charged product in the solution, which can interact with the solution components. DCM belongs to the solvents with a very low dielectric constant (∼8.9). It is well known that the lower the dielectric constant of a solution, the greater the tendency to form ionic pairs with different stoichiometries. Thus, the presence of two cathodic peaks is most likely the result of the existence of ion pairs in the solution. In addition, the shape of the reduction peak (a drastic decrease in the current value, see Fig. 2a) indicates the accumulation of the oxidation product of 3 on the electrode surface. To examine if the above hypotheses were correct, we conducted additional experiments with a solvent (DMSO) characterized by a dielectric constant 5 times greater than that for DCM. The issue of product accumulation on the electrode surface has been eliminated; however, ion pairs are still formed, as evidenced by the cathodic signals of 3 (see Fig. 2b). The calculations of the diffusion coefficients of 3 were performed on the basis of the linear relationship of anodic peak current (Ip) versus square root of the scan rate (v0.5), because the shape of this signal indicated the clear diffusion character of the electrode process.19a The calculated diffusion coefficients for 3 equal to (3.96 ± 0.36) × 10−5 and (1.91 ± 0.14) × 10−5 cm2 s−1 in DCM and DMSO, respectively.19b For comparison, we obtained the coefficient diffusion of native Fc in DCM which is 7.72 × 10−5 cm2 s−1.20 The diffusion coefficient describes the diffusional transport and is an important parameter of the species that are involved in the electrochemical process. The comparable diffusion coefficient values for 3 and native Fc testify to the lack of a significant effect of sumanene on the mobility of its derivative with Fc.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Cyclic voltammograms of 3 recorded in DCM (a) and DMSO (b) at various scan rates. Experimental conditions: C3 = 0.77 mM; CTBAHFP = 100 mM; T = 21 °C. |
We envisioned that 3 can be used for the selective recognition of Cs+. This hypothesis was based on the literature examples reporting highly specific interactions between sumanene-based molecules and Cs+.6d,7b However, the detection of Cs+ in water by buckybowl-based molecules was never studied before, despite the fact that the detection of Cs+ in aqueous solutions is crucial in terms of public health and environmental monitoring. Thus, our ultimate goal in the light of this work was to design a novel probe for Cs+ detection in water samples. The 3-based sensor specific versus Cs+ was successfully constructed. The procedure was very simple. A droplet containing 0.77 mM of 3 and 100 mM of TBAHFP in DMSO was placed on the electrode surface and let to dry. After the construction step and after the interaction with Cs+, the recognition layer was also inspected using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The obtained SEM images are presented in Fig. 3. The SEM image showed that the rather homogeneous surface experienced a significant increase of the porosity after the interaction with Cs+.
The analytical characteristics of this sensor bearing the 3-based receptor (GC/3-TBAHFP/Nafion®) were determined on the basis of the changes in the oxidation current signal of 3. For the preparation of the GC/3-TBAHFP/Nafion® sensor, see Section S1.5, ESI† and for the analytical characteristics of the sensor formed from the DCM solvent, see Section S8 in the ESI†.
Before the experiments with Cs+ recognition the sensor was cycled between −0.5 and 1 V in water with tetrabutylammonium bromide (TBAB) until a stable voltammogram was obtained and voltammetrically characterised. The cyclic voltammograms of the recognition surface (Fig. 4), recorded at scan rates from 5 to 500 mV s−1, show well-defined oxidation and reduction peaks corresponding to the Fc/Fc+ redox couple. The CV redox peak currents scale linearly with the square root of the scan rate (Fig. 4, inset), indicating the semi-infinite diffusional charge transport within the redox film at these scan rates.21a,b
The representative differential pulse voltammograms (DPV) plotted as a function of the concentration of Cs+ are presented in Fig. 5a. Along with an increase in the concentration of Cs+ in aqueous solution, an increase in the current signal of the Fc unit electrooxidation was observed, see Fig. 5b. In addition, this increase in the concentration range of 1–50 μM was linear.21c At the concentrations of Cs+ higher than 50 μM, the changes in the intensity of the peak current were negligible. In addition, some changes in the position of the current signal were observed; the signal successfully shifted towards less positive values with increasing concentrations of Cs+ in solution.
Shifting the signal towards less positive potential values indicated a simpler exchange of electrons between the electrode surface and Fc units. However, an increase in the signal intensity may point to a greater number of Fc units involved in the electrode process. Most likely, the formation of sandwich complexes between 3 and Cs+ led to a rearrangement of the Fc units; the Fc units were closer to each other and closer to the electrode surface, making the electron exchange easier (Fig. 5c). It is known from the literature that Nafion® (fluorocarbon polymer) does not significantly limit the mobility of electrically neutral compounds; only the existence of some attractive interactions between the SO3− functional groups of Nafion® and specific cations might lead to the mobility restriction.23 It is worth emphasizing that the receptor layer was constructed from a mixture consisting of compound 3 and TBAHFP in a ratio of 1:
130. Hexafluorophosphate ions (PF6−) belong to the group of strongly coordinating anions. They are therefore strongly bonded to ferrocenium cations. It is known that the ion-pairing strength of such anions with ferrocenium cations or other cations shields their positive charge, thus lowering the E1/2 values of multiply charged cations.22
Compound 3 is electrically neutral; therefore, the formation of a sandwich complex with Cs+ within the Nafion® polymer network is possible. The driving force for the formation of such a unique sandwich complex (Fig. 5c) shows a perfect match of Cs+ with the sumanene concave cavity. The sumanene moiety remains neutral throughout the complexation; therefore, the driving force for wrapping was the site-selective cation–π interaction between the concave face of sumanene and Cs+. The calculated limit of detection (LOD) equalled to 0.02 μM.24 This LOD value is remarkably satisfactory and is better than the respective values for the previously reported Cs+ receptors (Table 1). In addition, the herein presented sensor may be potentially useful in the analyses of real samples from post-disaster areas; for example, the contamination of Mano River in Japan (north-west from the Fukishima-Daiichi plant) with active cesium (Cs137) was reported to be ca. 0.06 mM.9c,26
It is also worth emphasizing that the regeneration of the herein presented sensor is very easy; it can be achieved by just dipping it into water for 10 minutes and the sensor is then ready to work, see Fig. 5a. Furthermore, to prove the Cs+ selectivity, control experiments with other cations, namely Na+, K+ and Ba2+ (100 μM), were performed. No changes in the Fc oxidation signal, and its position were observed (see Fig. 6). This means that Na+, K+ and Ba2+ neither form complexes with 3 nor obstruct the Cs+ complexation, and that the constructed GC/3-TBAHFP/Nafion® sensor is highly selective towards the Cs+ recognition. High stability is a very important parameter defining the sensor's functionality. The stability of the proposed sensor was examined by measuring the changes in the value of oxidation current of the Fc units in water with 100 mM TBAB as a function of time elapsed since the formation of the recognition layer (GC/3-TBAHFP/Nafion®). After the preparation step, the sensor was kept under the cover at room temperature for 2 months. The proposed sensor was characterized by very good stability for the first 5 weeks. The difference in the intensities of the Fc oxidation current signal was smaller than 5%. For the longer storage time (>5 weeks) the current decreases by 10% compared to the initial value (the sensor used just after the formation of the recognition layer).
To further support the selective interaction between 3 and Cs+, UV-Vis analyses and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry measurements with laser ablation (LA-ICP-MS) were performed.27 The UV-Vis spectrum of 3 showed an increase in the absorbance intensity after the addition of further portions of Cs+. This feature was ascribed to the non-covalent, site-selective interaction between 3 and Cs+.7b In contrast, no changes were observed in the UV-Vis spectra of 3 measured in the presence of Na+, K+ and Ba2+. These trends clearly elucidate the selective binding of Cs+ with 3. Job's plot analysis revealed the 2:
1 stoichiometry of the 3:Cs+ system.27 This analysis indicates the formation of anticipated sandwich-type complexes.7b The interactions between 3 and the selected ions: Cs+, Na+, K+, and Ba2+ were also analysed with LA-ICP-MS. In the experiments a gold substrate modified with the layer 3-TBAHFP/Nafion® was immersed in a water solution containing an appropriate anion at the 100 μM level. After 3 hours, the substrate with the 3-TBAHFP/Nafion® layer was gently washed with water and analysed. The multiline laser ablation (n = 4 lines per each map; ca. 0.75 mm2) was performed on the surface of the samples with a constant speed (25 μm s−1) followed by ICP-MS measurements. Transient signals were registered for the selected isotopes during each measurement cycle. The intensities of blank signals were registered for carrier gas (Ar) only and averaged for each isotope individually from the signals registered during 20 s before the start of ablation. The blank values were subtracted from the transient signals registered during the ablation of the samples. Spikes, defined as single raw intensity data higher than the mean of two neighboring data, were removed and replaced by the mean of the neighbouring values. The results obtained for the isotopes were recalculated to the equivalent of 1% abundance for each element and averaged from the 5 subsequent data. The registered signal intensities were independently recalculated for each monitored isotope with respect to the highest signal intensity (normalization to 100%). The relative distribution patterns of Fe and Cs were evaluated for the electrodes before and after rinsing with mili-Q water (Fig. 7).
The correlation coefficient values were calculated and are given below the images of a particular element distribution to support the information about the co-presence of Fe and Cs relative to the other observed species (Na, P, K, and Ba). It should be noted that the presence of P is a consequence of using a supporting electrolyte, tetrabutylammonium hexafluorophosphate (TBAHFP), during the formation of the layer. It is clearly visible that although it is influenced by the heterogeneity of the electrode, still the correlation between the Fe and Cs distribution is much higher (R ca. equal to 0.7) than that between the other elements. The averaged signal intensities are equivalent to 1%. The abundance of each element was calculated to estimate the ratio between Fe and Cs which resulted in an approximated value of 10 ± 4. No exact quantification has been carried out, but based on this approach, a rough conclusion can be drawn about an order of magnitude greater content of Fe than that of Cs.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental section, compound characterization data, and electrochemical data. See DOI: 10.1039/D0DT01506G |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |