Open Access Article
Theo M.
Suter
ab,
Thomas S.
Miller
*b,
Jeremy K.
Cockcroft
a,
Abil E.
Aliev
a,
Martin C.
Wilding
ac,
Andrea
Sella
a,
Furio
Corà
a,
Christopher A.
Howard
*d and
Paul F.
McMillan
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University College London, Christopher Ingold Building, 20 Gordon Street, WC1H 0AJ, London, UK. E-mail: p.f.mcmillan@ucl.ac.uk
bElectrochemical Innovation Lab, Department of Chemical Engineering, University College London, Torrington Place, London WC1E 7JE, UK. E-mail: t.miller@ucl.ac.uk
cMaterials and Engineering Research Institute, Sheffield Hallam University, City Campus, Howard Street, Sheffield, S1 1WB, UK
dDepartment of Physics & Astronomy and London Centre for Nanotechnology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK. E-mail: c.howard@ucl.ac.uk
First published on 21st December 2018
The development of processes to tune the properties of materials is essential for the progression of next-generation technologies for catalysis, optoelectronics and sustainability including energy harvesting and conversion. Layered carbon nitrides have also been identified as of significant interest within these fields of application. However, most carbon nitride materials studied to date have poor crystallinity and therefore their properties cannot be readily controlled or easily related to their molecular level or nanoscale structures. Here we report a process for forming a range of crystalline layered carbon nitrides with polytriazine imide (PTI) structures that can be interconverted by simple ion exchange processes, permitting the tunability of their optoelectronic and chemical properties. Notable outcomes of our work are (a) the creation of a crystalline, guest-ion-free PTI compound that (b) can be re-intercalated with ions or molecules using “soft chemistry” approaches. This includes the intercalation of HCl, demonstrating a new ambient pressure route to the layered PTI·xHCl material that was previously only available by a high-pressure-high-temperature route (c). Our work also shows (d) that the intercalant-free (IF-) PTI material spontaneously absorbs up to 10 weight% H2O from the ambient atmosphere and that this process is reversible, leading to potential applications for membranes and water capture in dry environments.
Within layered materials the intralayer bonding is significantly stronger than that between the layers, giving rise to highly anisotropic properties. Such a bonding arrangement facilitates the intercalation process as the interlayer (out-of-plane) spacing expands or contracts readily as a function of the insertion or removal of intercalant species. Intercalation events can therefore be detected by monitoring changes in the unit cell dimensions, particularly the lattice parameter normal to the layers, using X-ray diffraction (XRD).3 The lattice expansion typically occurs without breaking covalent bonds within the layers and thus does not damage the host framework.15,16 Intercalation processes in layered materials can either occur spontaneously or be driven externally, as a function of chemical potential or electrochemical driving forces, in solid–gas or solid–liquid systems.16,17
Carbon nitrides, with N
:
C ratios > 1, form an important class of wide-gap semiconductors that are attracting increasing interest, most notably for their visible light absorption and photocatalytic properties.13,18–20 Polytriazine imide (PTI) carbon nitride structures are constructed from triazine (C3N3) rings, bridged by sp2 N–H groups. They form layers with C6N9H3 stoichiometry that resemble graphitic sheets, but contain regular structural voids (Fig. 1a and b). The crystalline sheets are typically stacked either in an AA′ fashion, with the triazine rings lying directly above and below each other (Fig. 1b), or as an AB motif where the void lies directly below and above the triazine rings of adjacent layers. The first of these crystalline PTI layered materials to be characterized was formed by a reaction between melamine and cyanuric chloride under high pressure (0.5–3 GPa) and high temperature (500 °C) conditions.21,22 The resulting compound was found to contain an additional HCl component incorporated within its structure, with Cl− ions located approximately in the centre of the C12N12 voids within the carbon nitride plane, and the extra H+ protonating one of the surrounding triazine ring units.21,22 This material is referred to here as PTI·HCl.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Diagram showing the structure of PTI·LiBr. (a) A charge balanced structure of PTI·LiBr showing the position of the Br− anions located between the layers and the (assumed) positions of Li+ cations, that either partially replace H+ bound to the bridging imide units or between two adjacent triazine rings.26 In the present study the Br site occupancy was found to be approximately 50%. (b) A diagram of PTI·LiBr showing the layer stacking arrangement, with Br− ions intercalated between the layers. The layers are arranged such that the triazine rings in successive layers are directly aligned above each other, but with bridging amine groups on alternating sides of the triazine ring in adjacent layers. This is termed the AA′ stacking motif. | ||
An alternative synthesis route to related crystalline PTI materials was presented by M. Bojdys et al.23 who carried out a condensation reaction from dicyandiamide (DCDA, C2N4H4) in a molten eutectic LiCl/KCl or LiBr/KBr salt mixture at 600 °C. Although this original study suggested that the layers contained polyheptazine structural units, later work by Wirnhier et al. and others showed that the carbon nitride sheets were based on the same polytriazine imide motif as found for the PTI·HCl compound.23–26 The molten salt synthesis process produced PTI·LiCl or PTI·LiBr structures containing Cl− or Br− ions intercalated between the PTI layers (Fig. 1), along with Li+ ions either partly replacing H+ attached to the carbon nitride planes, or located between the layers (Fig. 1a).23–26 Chong et al. discussed the effect of anion size on the interlayer separation that determines the gallery height,24 and also noted that the Br content was lower than the fully intercalated theoretical stoichiometry of C12N18H4Li4Br2.24
Recent attention has focused especially on the photocatalytic activity of layered carbon nitride materials, leading to water splitting as well as other photocatalytic processes important for energy and sustainability applications.27–32 These compounds typically exhibit colours in the yellow-brown range, indicating visible as well as UV light absorption, with bandgaps stated to occur in the 2.4–2.7 eV range. It has been shown by McDermott et al. that tuning the Li+, H+ and other intercalated ion site occupancies can be used to alter the optical bandgap and thus influence the photocatalytic activity.10
Here we describe a method to fully remove the intercalated ions from PTI materials to create an ‘intercalant-free’ (IF-) PTI compound, and then replace them using ‘soft chemistry’ techniques with different ionic species. This points the way to the creation of a new family of crystalline layered PTI materials with tunable optoelectronic and chemical properties. Our IF-PTI phase constitutes the first substantiated example of a crystalline layered PTI-structured ion-free carbon nitride compound, with stoichiometry C2N3H. We also observe that this material spontaneously and reversibly absorbs H2O from the ambient atmosphere.
The gallery height, defined as the distance between two adjacent carbon nitride layers, is readily extracted from the 2θ or dhkl value of the (002) reflection.36 This peak changes from 26.5° 2θ (3.36 Å) for PTI·LiCl to 25.2° 2θ (3.52 Å) in PTI·LiBr, representing the 0.16 Å change in interlayer spacing expected for intercalation of the larger halide ion (ionic radii: 1.81 Å for Cl−, 1.96 Å for Br−).24,37 We note that the nature and degree of occupancy of the halide ion site has a significant effect on the PXRD patterns of PTI materials, because the high-Z intercalant species (Cl− and Br−) dominate the X-ray scattering intensity over the lighter elements (C, N, H) that determine the layered structures.19 We also note that some broadening occurs for reflections with a non-zero “l” Miller index component compared with hk0 reflections in the PTI·LiCl and PTI·LiBr diffraction patterns. Such differences in peak broadening between in-plane and between-plane reflections is commonly observed among layered materials that can exhibit different degrees of structural order within and between the planes.36,38
:
N ratio remained constant, and that there was no observable change in the O impurity content of the materials (Fig. 3a and b). Comparing the fitted XPS C 1s and N 1s peaks from each structure (Fig. S5–S7†) demonstrated that the chemical environments of these elements within the carbon nitride layers remained unchanged. These data substantiate that Soxhlet extraction involving continuous washing of the PTI·LiCl and PTI·LiBr starting materials in water results in the production of a new intercalant-free (IF-) form of crystalline layered PTI, with layer composition C6N9H3 (C2N3H). The stoichiometry established from elemental analysis of PTI·LiBr and IF-PTI obtained via two different methods (XPS and combustion analysis) is provided in Table 1. These analyses show that the C to N ratio is not affected by the washing procedure. However, the H content is slightly higher in the IF-PTI material due to replacement of Li+ ions in the structure by H+ ions derived from the aqueous extraction medium. This is borne out by pH measurements that showed the water reservoir in the Soxhlet reactor to have changed from a starting value of ∼7 to close to 10. This increase in pH can be attributed to the exchange of Li+ from the PTI·LiCl or PTI·LiBr materials with H+ derived from the water, resulting in an increase in OH− concentration within the aqueous phase.39
| XPS | Combustion analysis | 7Li content from NMR | |
|---|---|---|---|
| PTI·LiBr | C12N16.8Br1.0 | C12N16.6H10.2Br1.3 | C12N16.6H10.2Li1.9Br1.3 |
| IF-PTI | C12N18.8Br0.0 | C12N16.2H13.3Br0.05 | C12N16.2H13.3Li0.015Br0.05 |
The PXRD pattern of IF-PTI (Fig. 3c) could be analysed using the same in-plane lattice parameters as those established for PTI·LiBr, indicating that the internal structure and bonding within the PTI layers were not affected by the washing and de-intercalation process (Fig. 2c). However, all peaks with an out-of-plane hkl component shifted to higher 2θ values as a result of the substantially reduced interlayer spacing from 3.52 Å to 3.23 Å (Fig. 3c). These results show that the base gallery height of crystalline IF-PTI is even smaller than that of graphite (3.35 Å),40 perhaps because the localized partial charges between carbon and nitrogen result in interlayer attraction.32 In all the PTI materials investigated in this study we found that reflections with a non-zero (l) component were broadened compared with (hk0) reflections (Fig. 2a and c). This anisotropic peak broadening was more evident in the PXRD pattern for IF-PTI. The de-intercalation process results in large changes in the relative intensities of different reflections in the PXRD patterns, because of the removal of the high-Z elements with their large contribution to the X-ray structure factor and diffraction intensities. For example, this results in the significantly stronger (100) reflection observed in the IF-PTI PXRD pattern (Fig. 3c) compared with that for PTI·LiBr (Fig. 2c). The combination of broadening and shifts in peak position for reflections with an (l) component, along with the change in relative peak intensity, causes some of the characteristic peaks from the starting PTI·LiBr phase (such the (102) and (111) reflections) to be reduced in intensity so that they fall below the detection sensitivity of the instrument. We also observed an additional reflection for IF-PTI at ∼18° 2θ, that can be explained by the appearance of the (101) reflection for the hexagonal unit cell, which is not observed for PTI·LiBr or PTI·LiCl. This peak appears because of the change of symmetry that occurs as the layer stacking pattern changes from AA′ in which the voids ‘line up’ along the c axis, to AB with a triazine ring located directly above and below each void. This change in layer stacking motif is clearly seen for the PTI·HCl material (Fig. 5c), and it can be explained by the loss of anchoring between layers by the intercalated ions, as well as by the different relative sizes of the LiBr/LiCl vs. HCl intercalants that have been removed or exchanged.
The hexagonal crystallites observed in TEM images of IF-PTI are identical to those reported for PTI·LiBr and PTI·LiCl materials prepared by similar synthesis routes (Fig. 3d).23,26 Our TEM studies did not reveal any detectable increase in defect density of the crystallites following the Soxhlet extraction procedure. The in-plane characteristic distances measured from Fourier transforms of our TEM images remained unchanged following washing, confirming that in-plane ordering within the carbon nitride layers was not affected by the de-intercalation process. The TEM images combined with the PXRD, elemental analysis and XPS data show that the de-intercalation procedure removed the Li+ and halide intercalant species without any structural damage to the covalently bonded PTI framework. The resulting solids containing only carbon, nitrogen and hydrogen with a layer composition C6N9H3 (C2N3H) represent a new intercalant-free (IF-) PTI phase, containing layers of triazine rings bridged by secondary imido (–NH–) groups.
:
KBr) mix in a sealed ampoule under reduced pressure (see ESI† for details).1 This reaction was designed to study re-intercalation of the Li+ containing salt back into the IF-PTI framework, to re-form the initial PTI·LiBr intercalated compound and thus demonstrate that the de-intercalation/re-intercalation process could occur without damaging the carbon nitride backbone. Similar approaches have been applied to create a wide range of graphite intercalated compounds (GICs).1,43 PXRD results show that the re-intercalated (RI-PTI·LiBr) is structurally identical with the starting PTI·LiBr compounds (Fig. 5a). We further investigated the procedure by exposing IF-PTI to a LiCl
:
KCl molten salt mixture, and found that the resulting PXRD pattern corresponded exactly with that of crystalline PTI·LiCl, obtained using molten salt synthesis (Fig. 5b). These results demonstrate that the intercalation processes are entirely reversible, leading to the possibility of creating new PTI phases depending on choice of molten salt used for re-intercalation.
After refluxing IF-PTI with 5 M HCl for 4 days we observed formation of a PTI·HCl phase. Lin et al. have attempted to create this material at atmospheric pressure, but this resulted in a material that is inconsistent with the original PTI·HCl created using high-P,T reactions from molecular precursors.21,22,44 PTI·HCl has been predicted to exhibit improved photocatalytic hydrogen evolution properties due to its optimized band gap, so that our potentially scalable method of producing it at ambient conditions via re-intercalation of IF-PTI should prove useful.10 Our XPS data demonstrated a substantial increase in the Cl content, without any changes occurring in the C/N ratio (or O content) (Fig. 5c and d). The XPS data indicated a Cl− site occupancy near 65%. The PXRD pattern for the RI-PTI·HCl phase is almost identical to data reported previously for materials formed by high-P,T synthesis, but with minor differences in the relative intensities of the (100), (110) and (210) reflections and a slight change in the position of the (002) interlayer reflection from 27.7° 2θ to 27.5°, associated with the lowered Cl site occupancy.21,22,24 The appearance of the (101) reflection at ∼18° 2θ demonstrates the change in layer stacking from AA′ to AB analogous to that observed for IF-PTI (Fig. 3c).
The features at longer wavelength, beginning near 650 nm and culminating in a broad peak at ∼420 nm, have been attributed to n to π* transitions associated with lone pairs on N atoms in the triazine rings becoming excited into the π* orbitals.31,46 These transitions are forbidden for highly symmetrical planar layers, but become allowed as loss of symmetry and layer buckling occurs.31,46 The UV/Vis spectra of previously de-intercalated and then re-intercalated RI-PTI·LiCl and RI-PTI·LiBr samples (Fig. 6a and b) show the same π to π* transition bands, but both exhibit more pronounced n to π* absorption features, most likely due to minor structural distortions and layer asymmetries occurring as the Li+ and Cl−, Br− ions were introduced during the re-intercalation process.
Unlike PTI·LiCl and PTI·LiBr samples, the spectrum of PTI·HCl shows two distinct maxima at 300 and 340 nm in its π–π* transition region, and the rise in absorption coefficient attributed to the bandgap onset is much less marked (Fig. 6c). However, the broad n–π* absorption occurs over a similar range. McDermott et al.10 suggested that partial replacement of H+ with Li+ at the imide positions should cause splitting to occur in the N valence band states at highest energy.10 This likely contributes to the complexity and broadening of the π–π* region for the PTI·LiCl and PTI·LiBr samples, which partially retain NH groups at the bridging imide sites. PTI·HCl contains no intercalated Li+ so there is no splitting of the N valence band states and less hybridization with Cl orbitals, hence the sharpness of the observed peaks. If the bandgap is taken as the onset of the first π–π* peak near 360 nm, then there is a slight increase in bandgap energy compared with ∼375–380 nm values observed for PTI·LiCl and PTI·LiBr (Fig. 6). The PTI·H2O sample shows a further evolution of the spectrum, with a weaker feature at 290 nm, a main broad π–π* peak occurring at ∼340 nm with its onset near 360 nm, and a broad n–π* absorption similar to the other materials (Fig. 6d). The observed strength of the n–π* absorption for this sample could be associated with incorporation of intercalated H2O molecules, resulting in loss of local symmetry, and enhanced intensity of the normally forbidden transition.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8sc05232h |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |